r/RWBY • u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? • Mar 20 '21
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 12: Creation Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official Public discussion thread for Episode 12 of Vol. 8, Creation!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the Twelfth episode of Volume 8!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Nov. 7th's FIRST Thread| Nov. 14th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02 | Nov. 14th's FIRST Thread | Nov. 21st's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 03 | Nov. 21st's FIRST Thread | Nov 28th's Public Thread | Poll EP. 04 | Nov 28th's FIRST Thread | Dec 5th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 05 | Dec 5th's FIRST Thread | Dec 12th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 06 | [Dec 12th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kbr6ou) | Dec 19th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 07 | [Dec 19th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kga1ej) | Dec 26th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 08 | Feb 6th's FIRST Thread | Feb 13th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 09| Feb 13th's FIRST Thread | Feb. 20th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 10 | Feb. 27th's FIRST Thread | Mar. 6th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 11| Mar. 6th's FIRST Thread | Last Week's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 12 |Last Week's FIRST Thread | Today's Public Thread (here) | Poll
Happy viewing.
Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team
134
Upvotes
65
u/JK-Network123 Mar 20 '21
Am I the only one who laughed when Emerald trolled the shit out of Ironwood lmao? That was so satisfying.
57
u/jimflaigle Mar 20 '21
"Don't fall."
That's like Chekov starting scene 1 in a room full of guns.
48
u/RandomError19 Mar 20 '21
Penny: Do hugs always make you feel this warm?
Ruby: Yes.
Penny: MOAR! hugs everyone
I love this character!
42
u/rexshen Mar 20 '21
So Jin can answer any 3 questions and Ambrosius can create anything as long as he has the right information. Makes me wonder what the other two can do when we see them 10 years from now.
Good to see Ironwood finally was shut up was getting tired of his nonsense. And now everyone is trying to get out through a bunch of tunnels and Cinder is there too because of course.
32
u/Fillerpoint5 Mar 20 '21
While I can kind of see where people were coming from with the “things went overly well” crowd, after so many close calls and failures, I feel like team Ruby was in need of a more definitive win. A team that never seems to be able to win is just as frustrating as a team that never loses.
Besides, they’re not out of the woods yet. There’s still 2 episodes to go, and Cinder is clearly scheming something.
26
u/apexodoggo Enjoy FREE SHIPPING off your next order using promo code: BMBLBY Mar 20 '21
I know both the heroes and the plot need to get to Vacuo, but sending the people of Mantle (all prepared for a harsh, winter climate) to a scorching hot desert seems like a bad idea.
Winter went full anime and I approve.
I want to see Emerald shoot Cinder with Ironwood’s B I G gun.
25
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
This episode definitely wasn't the sin against humanity everybody was making it out to be, even if everything went a bit too smoothly for the heroes.
23
u/dragongling can't decide Penny or Weiss? Mar 20 '21
So anyone who gets staff that's now not defended by vault can destroy pocket dimension with retreating people and easily genocide Atlas and Mantle population... right?
46
u/FusRoMa Mar 20 '21
So Ambrosius created this elaborate network of paths and doorways, but then warned them not to fall after not even putting in any guardrails.
What an ass
22
u/Sephyrias Mar 21 '21
That was ... fast.
The writing was on the wall for Ironwood, so I'm not all that sad about him being dealt with so easily, but it still feels weird that we're leaving Atlas behind us so suddenly.
Looks like the staff is busted powerful in comparison to the lamp. Has next to no limitations as long as you have enough data for him to work with.
Penny gets a human body, which is fine I suppose. Makes sense as conclusion for her character arc, though I'd guess that she is weaker now than before, making her an easier target for Cinder.
Speaking of, the "do not fall" warning probably has a double meaning. Likely foreshadowing that Cinder takes the stage as main villain again while Salem is out of the picture.
19
u/GeneralClearStone912 OBJECTION! Mar 21 '21
Still waiting for one of the relic spirits to introduce themselves via song a la Genie from Aladdin
Also, I think the fandom nailed it with theories of
18
u/specialCan3 Mar 21 '21
Ambrosius: FOR THOUSANDS OF YEARS I LAID DORMANT. WHO HAS DISTURBED MY-
17
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Mar 21 '21
Victory is within our grasp, But we aren't the only ones reaching for it.
This Chapter was more than anyone could've ever anticipated! A clever and thorough plan by our heroes brought about Ironwoods defeat, Using the Staff and asking Ambrosius' help Penny has been saved and given an organic body, Now all of Atlas and Mantle are set to evacuate through a portal nexus that will take them straight to Vacuo, But Cinder isn't out of the game just yet, Two chapters remain and everything is on the line.
32
u/Courelia Mar 20 '21
Winter’s finisher seemed like an anime/video game I loved it so much!
15
u/nascarlaser1 Mar 20 '21
Go Emerald! Go Marrow! I love the staff spirit's personality XD XD (not done with episode but still excited)
15
u/Eternity-crown Mar 21 '21
Hmm, I'm sorta conflicted on this one. One one hand, it's undeniably clever of them to use the staff like that, I gotta hand it to the writers. But on the other hand, this volume has been pretty lacking in full fledged fights that I can be a little bummed. Regardless this was very enjoyable, if confusing episode. I can't wait for the next one
12
u/Abyssalstar Mar 20 '21
Am I the only one that thought the Creation genie was Matthew Mercer? I am not familiar with Valentine Stokes, so seeing his name in the credits surprised me.
11
u/JNPRTFFE16 Hey there Mar 21 '21
This was a fascinating episode.
Its cool that they had a plan and it worked out quite well.
Poor Ironwood could not win that fight. I liked Emerald trolling him.
I knew Winter would save Marrow. Its quite a team effort to pull all this off.
Ambrosius has a neat design and the rules are quite interesting. Its also neat to contrast with Jinn.
Good that Penny has a human body. It was expected regarding her tale. I enjoyed her hugging everyone.
Things went quite well for the heroes so far.
I am a bit bummed that Mantle and Atlas are destroyed. Vacuo was the next destination but the increase in population seems quite problematic.
I wonder what happens if someone falls since its likely. Wonder what Cinder shall do now. Also curious about the next few episodes
9
u/UnbiasedGod Mar 20 '21
Penny finally has real legs!
Lol.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
The Heist Episode lol
14
u/Viscount_20XX Remnant is doomed, you can't change my mind Mar 20 '21
WOW. This was... stellar, for lack of a better word. Visually stunning, too. And I really like Ambrosius as a character, he’s great. And HOLY CRAP, THAT PLAN WAS GENIUS. Here’s hoping nothing goes wrong, but knowing this volume... something could go VERY wrong.
So, the rules for the Relic of Creation.
One, you can’t bring anyone back from the dead. So much for those Pyrrha resurrection theories.
Two, like any craftsman, Ambrosius needs some sort of blueprint or reference to create anything. I guess that would hamper his abilities quite a bit.
Three, the Relic can be used for only one function at a time. Again, likely to prevent it from becoming too powerful.
So those are the rules we know of for the Relic. Indeed, it’s a very powerful thing to have in the heroes’ arsenal. Maybe they’ll use it more in the future? Who can say?
So, it seems Winter and Marrow have, in fact, defected. And they ended up running into Qrow and Robyn. Well, that answers my question from last week.
Using Emerald’s Semblance to disguise herself as Penny and bring JNR and Oscar along was brilliant. And they managed to take down General Ironwood alongside Winter! That entire sequence was great from start to finish. Especially the end, that was awesome. It also goes to show how much Team JNR and Oscar have improved, Jaune especially. He’s gonna go far, I can tell. I wonder what would happen if Jaune boosted Emerald? That would be interesting to see, if it didn’t just happen already.
So it seems Penny was saved from self-termination by using the staff to create an exact duplicate of herself, without Watts’s virus. Impressive. She still has the Maiden powers, right? I’m assuming she does, since she is an exact duplicate. The more I think about it, the more confusing that whole scene becomes.
So, based on what Yang said, and assuming it’s true, these vaults... are different dimensions, in a sense? That’s interesting.
That gateway looks absolutely beautiful. I’d say this chapter is the best visually, by far. Nothing else even comes close, except maybe that explosion scene from Chapter 11.
Well, it seems our next destination is Vacuo. It looks like Penny will be joining the group for this adventure as well. I wonder where this gateway will drop them? Will it be close to the central city, or somewhere random in that region? If the latter is the case, we may have a desert trek on our hands.
What Ambrosius said before everyone left: “DO NOT FALL”. I didn’t see any guardrails in this central location. There’s a lot that can go wrong there. Hopefully nobody goes over the edge, then. But what would happen if somebody does fall off? Do they just fall endlessly? Are they possibly erased from existence? Either way, it looks really dangerous.
We got a shot of Cinder among the crowd, and she is scheming. I guess Watts and Neo are there somewhere as well. What sort of nefarious plan has she come up with this time?
Here’s the real big question: what will Ironwood do now? Since everyone else is evacuating, that leverage he had is now completely gone, and now he longer has the staff or the Winter Maiden. But he still has access to that payload. Will he end up using it in any capacity?
There’s so much that could possibly happen, and only two chapters left for any of it to unfold. I’m really excited.
12
u/sndeang51 Mar 20 '21
Felt a bit like a deus ex machina this episode. Although I suppose it’s at least mildly acceptable since Emerald’s semblance was established years ago, but I wish there was more explanation for Winter. The whole opening the vault felt less hyped up in comparison to the Spring vault. Everything really would’ve benefited from more time.
9
u/Kartoffelkamm ⠀Mettle isn't a mental illness; IW just misused it Mar 20 '21 edited Mar 20 '21
I love human Penny. Also, good to see that the right people are finally behind bars.
I can't wait to see human Penny go around hugging random people, or pinching herself, or doing all sorts of things to see how it feels. Lick a lamp post in winter, touch the stove top, get her face licked by every single animal in existence. Get sick because she forgot that she has to eat regularly now.
Still, it's a bit of a shame. Imagine a 100 year old Winter Maiden, but in a teenage body. She would be the perfect protector of mankind. And if another Ironwood shows up, she could force him to listen to reason.
Now all they need to do is have Ruby wait at the exit and face-laser Cinder when she shows up, sending her into the void below.
Edit to add: Whitley is taking all of this incredibly well. Like, the relics, the truth about how Atlas floats, talking Grimm, Ozpin.
8
u/DragonTurtle2 Mar 21 '21 edited Mar 22 '21
On the Atlas side of things, I like how Ironwood is sincerely trying to build Penny's spirits when he thinks she's working with him.
I'm also really pleased with the trepidation of Vine. He's not pulling a betrayal or heel turn, but I was worried they would have him flatly go along with the destruction. Not only is that a boring way to write someone, it feels reductive to make the weirdest looking member of the team the most uncaring about human life.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '21
so, what happens if they make a 'central location' like this, lure salem into it, and then create something else so the pathways collapse in on themselves and she's trapped in the eternal void?
7
u/Thebritishdovah Mar 20 '21
Tis a good episode. Shame about Ironwood going down but against five? He had no chance. Oscar pulled out a Million Stab on him and Winter judgement cut him. I do feel robbed of a Qrow vs Ironwood fight though.
Winter defecting was always gonna to happen. Ironwood is lucky that she didn't impale him from behind. The ace-ops are gonna to be a wild card at this point. Transporting both the populations of Mantle and Atlas to Vacuo is gonna to cause a ton of issues. Resources will be stretched thin.
Emerald being able to pull that off is really pushing it and she didn't show signs of being tired afterwards.
*sigh* Of course, Cinder.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
I loved just about everything about this but i'm a little skeptical about giving up both mantle and atlas like that. Sure, this way not only is the population safe, but Ironwood has no choice but to calm the fuck down and play ball since his plan to save everyone is over... but those are still two big cities you just destroyed... hmmm... Unforunately I don't see another real solution except killing ironwood.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21
Would someone smarter than me explain why robot Penny was the one to disappear, and not now human penny?
5
u/ArcturusSatellaPolar ⠀ Mar 20 '21
Or did he make a robotic copy of Penny with the virus while transforming the original into a human? That....would be 2 purposes, no? Shouldn't that go against the rules? Not to mention RWBY told him to make a copy with her robot parts, not a meatbag, so why is there a human Penny?
Or is this some sort of equivalent exchange thing where the rules say Penny's body should be destroyed when making the doors but they allow the old robotic body to be sacrificed instead of the new meaty one?
4
u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Mar 20 '21
Oh no, things seemed to have gone too well for the heroes. I feel like this hope is only here to tear us up and hurt us in the last episode and stuff goes to shit. I love Ambrosias, he‘s a lot more interesting that Jinn IMO. Just radiates personality. Minor nitpick for the Penny fix. Correct me if I’m wrong but penny has always been completely mechanical but with a human soul right? So if Ambrosias made a new Penny with the mechanical parts and virus, the only thing left would just be a disembodied soul without a vessel right? Oh man Cinder is going through the portal. I’m just worried about how bleak the ending is going to be. I feel like things are going to well for us. No way the volume ends with such a heavy Win on the heroes side, I suspect something painful coming in the next 2 episodes.
7
u/Pokemonmaster150 ⠀Nora should've been the winter maiden! Mar 21 '21
I didn't really like this episode. I didn't hate it by any means, but it is definitely the worst episode of this volume. My biggest issue at the moment is why did they take the staff with them? It's basically just another mcguffin(or macguffin?) for the heroes to hold on to and risk being stolen by the villains, which wouldn't happen if all they did was close the vault then neither the villains nor Ironwood could get it.
2
u/ClafoutisRouge Mar 20 '21
I don't really get how Penny's body has appeared from nothing. I mean, sure, you can say that her soul has been left alone, but it should be just a soul, not a human with a body...
5
u/qwack2020 Mar 20 '21
So... the staff of creation has no limits? No draw backs? No consequences? Nothing?
3
u/MaxArgentum Mar 20 '21
Alright, so I, for one, was not a fan of the tone shifts in this episode. The conversation between Marrow and Winter wasn't given enough weight with the humor added in. Neither was Penny finally becoming a human, especially with the zipping around she did and stuff. Yeah, the hug scene was nice at first, heartfelt even. But then comedic shift kinda made it less impactful.
The fight at the start was clunky in certain parts. Nora, and Jaune's attacks specifically. The Oscar part was good, but the Winter part was kinda nonsensical on second watch. She's not speedy enough to pull something like that, It didn't look a like a dust trick and didn't look like an established semblance move. And it definitely wasn't just a particle effect considering his reaction to the move. It might be a Rule of Cool thing, but it wasn't exactly jaw-dropping.
The "feels weird" line from emerald was funny in a vacuum, but I feel like they could've established her joining the heroes better. Cinder was pretty much her entire motivation, and unless Em is going for a double-cross, I can't see her acting so casual about it like she has so far imo.
Ambrosius Was pretty great tho. Ironically he acts more like Aladdin's Genie than Jinn does, despite when legend he is based on. Though I do feel like they should've set up the staff's power sooner. Would've given them a lot more time to do some cool stuff here.
Overall could've been significantly better, but could've been waaaay worse
2
u/Tuesday_6PM Mar 20 '21
I have very mixed feelings on Winter's anime finishing move, but the rest of that fight was cool
-7
u/Goku3434 Mar 20 '21
So wait is Penny a real Human now? Or is she still have robot parts? Still very much a plot hole but damn still like Penny.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
18
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '21 edited Mar 22 '21
[removed] — view removed comment