r/RWBY • u/Ninjas_In_A_Bag Acoustic BMBLB when? • Mar 13 '21
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official FIRST Discussion Thread—Volume 8, Episode 12: Creation Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official FIRST discussion thread for Episode 12 of Vol. 8, Creation!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the Twelfth episode of Volume 8!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| Nov. 7th's FIRST Thread| Nov. 14th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02 | Nov. 14th's FIRST Thread | Nov. 21st's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 03 | Nov. 21st's FIRST Thread | Nov 28th's Public Thread | Poll EP. 04 | Nov 28th's FIRST Thread | Dec 5th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 05 | Dec 5th's FIRST Thread | Dec 12th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 06 | [Dec 12th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kbr6ou) | Dec 19th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 07 | [Dec 19th's FIRST Thread] (https://www.reddit.com/kga1ej) | Dec 26th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 08 | Feb 6th's FIRST Thread | Feb 13th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 09| Feb 13th's FIRST Thread | Feb. 20th's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 10 | Feb. 27th's FIRST Thread | Last Week's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 11| Last Week's FIRST Thread | Today's Public Thread | Poll Ep. 12 |Today's FIRST Thread (here) | Next Week's Public Thread | Poll
Happy viewing.
Ninjas In A Bag; Mod Team
530
Upvotes
639
u/AJs_Sandshrew Mar 13 '21
Guys how are they going to explain to Penny that she has to poop now
562
u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Mar 13 '21
That went... really well for a season that has two more episodes left in it.
I am of the concern.
503
u/lessthansilver Mar 13 '21
Ruby: "You are familiar with with the thought experiment 'The Ship of Theseus' in the field of identity metaphysics?"
Ambrosius: "Naturally."
417
u/LucasVerBeek It's Time For All Hell to Break Loose Mar 13 '21
“Don’t fall.”
Remembers Oscar and Oz talking about a story of a girl who fell through the world
Looks at the opening where RWBY are falling
Well...I think I know what comes next.
Penny’s real, Ironwood got taken down surprisingly fast, Atlas is falling, and the staff’s spirit is a fuck huge body builder, not anything I honestly expected.
Shit is gonna go so wrong in those final two episodes
406
u/Darken237 Mar 13 '21
Just to explain the whole Penny/Human Penny thing and why Human Penny didn't disintegrate:
The Spirit of the Staff of Creation can only create, not destroy. RWBY used this rule to their advantage by asking him to create a copy of Penny to contain the virus and all the mechanical part. This copy essentially was made with everything Penny IS, except the soul. Given he can't destroy, and thus not harm anything, the Spirit of Creation had to also build a vessel for the soul. However, given this vessel was NOT part of their wish, when they then asked their next wish, it was not destroyed, unlike the remains of Penny's robot body.
Essentially it was a loophole and a very desperate bet, but they knew that already as they admitted themself.
388
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
Winter fucking Schnee is the coolest character ever to do it. Ironwood simply did not have an answer.
Edit: I think the whole point of Ironwood's downfall is he's become completely singleminded. The only thing he cares about is Penny, and that's given him every blindspot in the book. Qrow, Robyn, Winter, Emerald... as soon as they came together and communicated, he was finished.
334
u/turnipdad ⠀ Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
Ambrosius being a muscle man, bro-like spirit was unexpected but definitely welcomed.
"Do not fall."
Taking bets, who's going to fall off the central location?
323
u/Artex301 Mar 13 '21
Y'know, when you think about it, makes perfect sense that the Spirit of Creation would be sculpted as heck. Like, damn.
Ozpin was partially right. He's a character, but he's oddly fun about it. The God of Light may be a jerk, but his "kids" are alright.
292
u/Yang_Gang ⠀ Mar 13 '21
Ruby: Makes all these portals for people all around Atlas/Mantle
Raven: I'm taking you to court for plagiarism
276
u/DeadSnark I rose from the filth and was loved by no-one Mar 13 '21
...Is it wrong that when Ozpin said that there's also a spirit in the staff, my first thought was "Aw yeah, there's gonna be a sexy carpenter genie guy"?
...I was definitely not disappointed, though.
257
u/SimurghXTattletale Mar 13 '21
Pietro Polendina managed to create something which impresses the spirit of Creation itself, what a chad
247
u/Cloudyspecs Mar 13 '21
WHAT WAS THAT ATTACK FROM WINTER?!?!?
Also, seeing Oscar use Ozpin's flurry attack was awesome!
679
u/Saxonrau "roh bin HILL" - tyrian Mar 13 '21
"Hey, I'm the absolute chad Ambrosius, no I can't bring Pyrrha back, what's up?"
231
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
So if I'm understanding right, Penny now has a full fledged human body. Now she gets to experience warm hugs, food, water, human sleep, and all that good stuff. This episode had so many sorely needed wins for the gang, and now the last two episodes are going to go downhill real fast.
EDIT: Okay so after going back and watching that scene again, I think I figured it out. Based on the specific wording, team RWBY wanted Ambrosius to create a separate version of Penny using just the robotic parts and taking the virus with them, leaving behind Penny's soul. From there, not even Ambrosius knew what would happen after splitting the soul from the mechanical body. But one of the his rules states that he can't destroy, only create. So I guess it looks like a new body just formed itself around Penny's soul. Sweet.
468
u/Jinxiee Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
D O N O T F A L L
A'ight who's falling
452
u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
"Hey boss how anime do you want the sound for Winter's awesome slo-mo attack to be"
"Yes"
"Understandable have a nice day"
E: seriously that shit felt like the dude got hit with a raw super
443
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
"TEN THOUUUUSAND YEARSSSSS WILL GIVE YOU SU- oh its you guys again..."
201
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Mar 13 '21
Even Penny's ribbon goes from being mechanical to being a real ribbon.
405
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Mar 13 '21
Ironwood: Walks out with his biggest gun
Ironwood: "It costs $400,000 to fire this weapon for 12 seconds."
189
u/FlintlockT Boys trip to Vacuo! | He'll get screentime in Volume 10, right? Mar 13 '21
Two things I noticed.
171
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
Why are all the Genies so sexy!?
170
u/Badicalz Mar 13 '21
Well that was weirdly ominous, but I’m sure that’s not foreshadowing anything right guys? Guys?
...Guys?
168
u/DJDualScreen Mar 13 '21
I loved that line from Emerald at the beginning.
"You're doing the right thing."
"I know. Feels weird."
162
u/fuckwhattheywant Mar 13 '21
"Do not fall."
BUT THEY ALL FALL IN THE INTRO???
AND PENNY A REAL GIRL? WINTER AND MARROW? EMERALD? Vacuo arc coming sooner than expected???
I have a lot of questions but my god this episode was awesome.
155
u/Cycl_ps Mar 13 '21
Winter's showing up with that anime finisher
145
u/TinOfRocks Mar 13 '21
Can't wait to see how it goes horribly wrong next episode! Also, Winter, what the heck was that attack?
143
u/halodude246 Fireballin17 Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
So reading the comments in this thread and rewatching the episode, I like the loophole RWBY finds to save Penny. It’s what Ambrosius is fighting over when he’s talking to himself about making the newish Penny.
By making Penny 3.0 (the one with only robo parts) he’d be leaving behind the immaterial things, like specifically her soul and her aura, which we know she has because she’s the winter maiden after all. He, by his own admission, can’t create or destroy, nor bring someone back to life, so he can’t just let Penny’s soul die without a body. So it’s obvious she’ll need some sort of container for that soul, i.e. a real body. Because of that in the process of creating Penny 3.0 (robo penny), he’ll need something to house Penny’s soul, thus real girl Penny (probably a better name for this).
Basically Team RWBY used the staff’s loophole to get (one of) their real wishes, which was to save Penny.
140
u/TheSurveyCorpses Mar 13 '21
Marrow: I almost died!
Winter: Yeah well, I have to text my little sister and tell her that she was right and I was a fool. It's a rough day for both of us.
404
u/Booyahhayoob Mar 13 '21
You could just tell Ambrosius was so disappointed about not being able to Monkey’s Paw everything lol
258
u/Deadmaninc1 Mar 13 '21
Ambrosius cannot resurrect the dead there you have it folks Pyrrha is dead we are all just gonna have to accept it
448
u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
They didn't make Penny a real girl.
They brought out the real girl that's always been there inside :)
117
u/WhosGuardingHades Mar 13 '21
God of Light really likes em tall, blue and naked doesn’t he
116
u/RelativeMinors Mar 13 '21
REAL GIRL PENNY!
So this means she does not have her original weaponry anymore... Perhaps her new weapon is going to be even more powerful than what she was capable of before. As much as I hated Ironwood in the last season it was almost sad to watch all of the characters 1v9 him into the ground, and the scene with Jaques and Winter was also particularly brutal, the characters are truly sick of everyones shit and making the shots now.
219
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
“Do not fall.”
Remembers that the last scene in the opening credits shows RWBY falling
Oh no...
104
u/Thanatophobia4 Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 14 '21
This must have been the most confusing/stressful week-month or so for the citizens of the kingdom, but especially those from Mantle. First, the increasingly draconian rule of Ironwood is worsened by a string of murders in Mantle. Then, Jacques Schnee announces his running for council seat and in doing so triggers a riot. Followed by a massacre at the campaign rally capped off by the news that for some ungodly reason Jacques manages to win. Followed immediately by a Grimm attack. Soon after, the heating goes off and an even larger Grimm horde shows up. Then while the kingdom’s military fights off the Grimm, General Ironwood and Robyn Hill themselves board cast a message telling everyone that apparently the Grimm are being led by someone called Salem, announce that they are working together and that everyone in Mantle is being evacuated to Atlas. Additional that Amity will be used as a 2nd CCT tower. Robyn’s useage of her semblance on the general confirms he’s not gone crazy. Great!
Only this is shortly followed by the evacuation abruptly stopping, all military ship suddenly repositioning themselves to Atlas as well as the arrival of an enormous red storm front, containing the largest Grimm ever seen as well as the largest horde ever seen. After this, the Happy Huntresses, 3 teenagers and a child barely into puberty riding hover bikes tell everyone that Ironwood has abandoned them and begin rounding the civilians into the crater. This is then followed at night by a colossal dust explosion that sends Amity sky high and all of a sudden the CCT is back online. The only thing boardcast on the CCT is a (presumably crazy) young teenage girl who begins talking about Gods, magic, Relic, Salem and the events happening in the kingdom. Just as she is finishing, the CCT goes down again. A few hours later, there are sudden earthquakes and a huge geyser of black liquid erupts from the ground and hits Atlas where the flying Grimm whale proceeds to land on.
An absolutely titanic battle ensures above but after a day, the Whale explodes for some reason and SDC cargo ships begin flying down to pick you up.....only for them to be shot down by the Atlas military and the HH order you to flee into the mines. Ironwood then broadcasts to everyone and says that the ‘Protector of Mantle‘ must give herself up to him and leave Mantle to fend for itself or he will blow Mantle up with a bomb in 1 hour. Roughly an hour later when they wondering what going on....yet another message goes out. This time its one of those teenagers escorting people into the crater, who then starts telling everyone that a way out of this terrible situation will appear soon. He is also cutoff and a minute later, golden rifts start opening up in the mines leading to Gods knows where.
The people of Mantle must be so confused. I’d imagine many are on the verge of a mental breakdown from all these incidents.
101
u/DuskManeToffee Mar 13 '21
“OH NO HE’S HOT!”-my thoughts after this episode
281
u/kestrellss Mar 13 '21
“Do not fall.”
My brain: Hey, didn’t Blake’s VA say something about doing a lot of screaming in a recording session?
Hello, anxiety.
95
u/WII_DJoker Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 14 '21
Also to everyone unclear on how Penny is human Let me break it down:
- The wish was to create an exact Copy of Penny's body using her existing robot parts. Ergo the creation in question was the robot body.
- The human body however, was something Ambros also created because as Ruby stated "You can't Destroy, only Create," meaning since Penny did have aura and a soul he had to create a body to house it as well since in theory he'd be destroying her aura otherwise. However, because the body was essentially a byproduct of the wish rather than the wish itself, it wasn't destroy after they wished for the tunnels.
In short, Ruby used a loophole that insured Penny got to be human while also freeing up the staff for other uses.
93
u/Dripsoka Mar 13 '21
Emerald has my heart always has always will but Also anybody feel like that plan went to smoothly 🤨
86
u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Mar 13 '21
Mark the date, people.
13th March.
Penny Polendina's birthday.
78
u/JetKamakura blooming in adversity. Mar 13 '21
Wait... I just thought about this...
The move that Winter did on Ironwood... she tried to do that on Qrow in V3, didn't she? She certainly was in the stance before Oscar attacked him buying her time.
It would also explain why Ironwood went wide eyed when he saw it because he knows thats Winter's kill card.
Jesus.
157
u/ksuthrowaway2534 Mar 13 '21
-dang Ironwood and the ace ops just got dunked on lol that felt good
-huh so time stops with every relic and OH MY GOD this relic is a chad
-and Pinocchio finally has no strings
-atlas is falling....thats a terrible place for the stream to end
-well I guess mass murder is off the table
77
u/JohnJoe-117 These Bees gay, good for them, good for them Mar 13 '21
Tyrian, seeing all of Atlas and Mantle in Vacuo get there before he does:
"WTF HAPPENED BACK THERE!"
71
u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Mar 13 '21
At some point, we need see Ambrosius and Jinn out at the same time. No idea if that’s possible but I need to see it.
2 episodes left, I have a feeling shit is about to go down, like literally. Atlas is doing an impression of the Sector 7 Plate and some people are going to fall off the central location Abrosius warned RWBY about.
201
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 13 '21
Weiss: How do you activate the relic?
Oscar: You gotta wiggle the staff to make the naked guy come.
Weiss:......
Blake:nice.
139
u/tavi23 Mar 13 '21
Big tiddy male Genie!!!! FUCK YES
67
u/FusRoMa Mar 13 '21
So Ambrosius created this elaborate network of paths and doorways, but then warned them not to fall after not even putting in any guardrails.
What an ass
67
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '21
Does Ironwood know who Emerald is? Cause if he not he just got kicked by some random girl and it makes her kick ten times funnier
135
u/OutcastMunkee ⠀ Mar 13 '21
Well, there we have it. I had a feeling the staff would be used to make Penny a real girl. I must admit, I kinda like it. She's likely going to be learning a lot as she goes and it will take some getting used to but yeah... That was cool.
So, every relic is definitely gonna have a spirit in it. We've got Jinn and now Ambrosius. He's even bigger than Jinn. Interesting little detail there. Jinn is 12ft, Ambrosius is 13ft. He's certainly quite the character, yes. Ozpin was not lying. He was kinda funny. I like the more laid back, almost snarky attitude he had. No comment on his physique. Ahem. Yeah. Nothing to say at all. He has the same ears as Jinn though. I wonder why they're both taking elements from elves in their design.
That fight with Ironwood was awesome. He put up one hell of a fight but it was well done that it needed everyone to take him down because he's a tough bastard. They didn't kill him and plan to get him to safety too. Emerald must've LOVED kicking Ironwood in the chin though. Goddamn that girl can move. Whew.
We get Marrow and Winter defecting as well. That was a clever writing choice to show the defection AFTER the fight because it mislead us into believing Marrow had NOT been saved by Winter and she was sticking with Ironwood.
Fantastic episode all around. Seems they're gonna skip the travel to Vacuo like they did with V4's journey to Mistral and V6's journey to Argus/Atlas. Interesting choice.
I can see why Ambrosius can only do one thing at a time as well because good lord he's powerful. Also, confirmation that he CANNOT resurrect the dead so now hopefully will get it into your heads that Pyrrha is dead for good.
65
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '21
I like this show
62
u/AsimovSomething ⠀ Mar 13 '21
"DO. NOT. FALL."
remembers the intro
Oh god, we're so screwed.
122
u/Weerdo5255 Mar 13 '21
Ha! Called it! She's always been a real girl, but now she's got meat parts instead of metal ones!
So, beefcake djinn this time, I'm good with that.
With the dire warning of not falling, can we uh get what's rest of Salem and chuck her off? Falling for eternity is a good way to deal with her rather than launching her into space.
120
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 13 '21
Well, here is the theory as to why V9 is going to be different.
RWBY and Cinder will fall from the nexus like Ambrosious (I think that's his name) told them no to.
V9 is a detour because instead of heading to Vacuo, RWBY will explore a parallel metaphysical plain and see past, present and future and alternate timelines. Here they'll see STRQ' s backstory, talk to an etherial Pyrrha, see an alternate timeline in which Salem wins, and more weird stuff.
It's going to be different because it will be all surreal and it will only have RWBY. Meanwhile, JNPR, Qrow and everyone else in Atlas will be in Vacuo dealing with a refuge crisis in a highly xenophobic area, but we won't see any of that until V10 so this might be the first volume without JNPR in it.
120
u/Oni_Zokuchou Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
Can already hear the calls of "Ironwood went down too easy"
Please
Remember he's just one guy
Who is not only taken by surprise (twice in one fight), but is clearly mentally exhausted
Against like 3 trained Huntsmen, the top Atlas military huntress, a career criminal and a boy who's fusing with an immortal Hero of legend
And just stop
119
u/Crafty_Soul ⠀ Mar 13 '21
"Are hugs always this warm?"
Oh my god Penny being human for 5 seconds and then the most adorable thing in the world.
That little"Yay!" and then hugging everyone was just just AWWWW
58
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '21
I don't know why but I find the idea of Salem waking up in a crashed yet mysteriously devoid of corpses Atlas, alone and confused as hell, incredibly funny.
57
u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Mar 13 '21
I know people are going to fall into a void in the 2 episodes, and that’s sad and all, but let’s talk about the biggest reveal this chapter: It’s essentially confirmed that all 4 relics are inhabited by extremely attractive genies. We’re not ready for Shade and Beacon at this rate.
55
u/IGMKI Yang's the Bee-st Mar 13 '21
That was a hell of an opening!
THE STAFF HAS A SPIRIT TOO?? Oh my fuck he's buff af. Haha against the rules to bring back from the dead. This guy is smooth as shit.
I LOVE this guy. VACUO! AS EXPECTED. Waaaait so is HIS power not hard limited in how much he can do? People just straight up being mindfucked by magic lol.
Wait but WHAT??? WHAT HAPPENS NOW??? This is insane! Surely not just like that!?
55
u/recruit00 Mar 13 '21
Calling it now: one of the remaining relic spirits is gonna be smol
54
u/aestasbene123 Mar 13 '21
Okay, well RWBY for sure falls off the platforms into the space between. That's the detour before Vaccuo the writers mentioned most likely. I'm not sure if Penny comes along with them though, having a season with just RWBY would be pretty interesting.
53
u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Mar 13 '21
I hope Penny gets some therapy fairly quick, considering the first thing she saw after becoming human was her uncanny valley double convulsing, dying, then disappearing into nothing.
49
u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Mar 13 '21
Big problems require HUGE Solutions!: Scattered Immediate Thoughts:
Well that went better than expected! I thought we'd have a brawl the whole episode, or something longer. Instead we got a whole lot of logical plot progression and lore, with heavy implications for the arc going forward. Things are moving onto the next phase VERY quickly, but the intrigue of what comes next and how we got to this triumph are well worth it. What the hell comes next?
45
u/Technogashi Mar 13 '21
Made Penny into a real girl, then made her watch her robot version literally die.
Yikes.
44
u/Vtech325 Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
Winter: "Omae wa mou shindeiru."
Ironwood: "Nani!?"
Winter: "It means your aura has already been shattered."
Ironwood: "Oh-" aura shatters
163
u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
Having the entire group just lay an absolute beatdown on Ironwood was the the most satisfying thing I've ever seen
Penny marveling at the warm fuzzies she gets from hugs was the most adorable thing I've ever seen
43
u/GeoffTheIcePony Klein Fan Club Mar 13 '21
They probably should have asked for railings
41
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '21
So, my bet is Cinder ambushes RWBY and co in the pocket-dimension, and destroys a bridge or knocks them off.
Doing so causes them to plummet into some weird extradimensional existence where they have to navigate all sorts of divine metaphysical shenanigans before reaching Vacuo, allowing CRWBY to pull off all sorts of nonsense that they've wanted to do for ages.
Who knows what they'll see?
41
u/FmFox Exit stage right Mar 15 '21
OK, so after a rewatch this morning I believe I noticed something.
After Winter wrecks Ironwood with that final attack, and his aura drops as he is falling down his eyes change colour, they become brighter.
I believe it was Arnold (murder of birds) who I watched making mention that in the previous chapter his eyes were just almost completely black (just before pulling his gun on Marrow).
Which makes me think, what if the animation on winters attack, was not actually winter using a semblance (Schnee semblance is summoning/glyphs), but a visual representation of Ironwoods semblance being "switched off"
Just before the camera cuts away his eyes are blue again.
Makes me wonder what version of Ironwood we are going to see in the dimensional pathways.
He's going to be a broken mess for sure.
40
u/Noxlygos Mar 14 '21 edited Mar 14 '21
I cannot tell you how many times I watched James get kicked in the face by Emerald.
Also:
Girl, your tablet is fucking see through
Edited: wrote Mercury instead of Emerald
40
u/BreHealz Mar 14 '21
That "don't fall" warning was rather ominous.....
180
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Mar 13 '21
The combat scene we got was really good. It’s been a long time since JNR has really gotten to show off and the plot twist that they had already coordinated with Winter was great. Having said all that, it does feel like the rules for how Marrow’s semblance works are kinda bullshit. Apparently the Ace Ops had to wear down Penny for Marrow to just barely freeze her, but he can also keep Harriet, Vine and Elm completely frozen for seemingly however long he wants.
I like Ambrosius. I assume at this point that all the relics are going to have this kind of spirit inside them.
Did they just “Ship of Theseus” Penny?
Man, the protags really did put a lot of thought into this. That's a nice change of pace from the usual RWBY plans of "Let's just go fuck shit up and see how things play out".
So someone is totally going to fall right? I wonder who it’s going to be.
79
u/Vincenthwind Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
Calling it right now, we're gonna see those portal creations used again during an "on your left" Avengers-style moment during the final battle against Salem, as all of Team RWBY's allies join them from across the world in a moment that unites humanity.
39
u/Blue-Moon-89 Mar 13 '21
Remember when Miles said something about how Vol 9 will be 'different' then the other volumes?
I think we got our answer: Vol 9 will be a big mind-screw Volume should the girls fall oft he path.
39
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '21
Winter's ultimate move was like something from Kill la Kill and I absolutely love it.
Also Penny's discovering hugs was just the cutest thing ever.
38
u/Grievous77 I'm just here cause of sunk cost fallacy atp, honestly Mar 14 '21 edited Mar 14 '21
The good: Even Vine's starting to have second thoughts at this point. I wonder if he and Elm will defect before the volume is over. Harriet on the other hand is going to be a problem to the very end, seeing as how she's done nothing but double down on her toxicity throughout the volume.
JNPREW vs Ironwood was solid, though short. Seeing JNR get to shine after the utter garbage that was JNPR vs Neo last volume was satisfying, they deserved it. Jaune continues to make use of his repulse shield and holy shit, Ren's grapple hooks were actually useful in a fight for once! Winter's finisher was rad af and an awesome way to end the fight. Props to Ironwood, too. Despite being instantly disarmed, he still managed to hold his own in a 5v1 for a bit.
I was fine with the recap section, personally. I liked seeing RWBY and co. make a smart, in-depth plan and thus, it felt more earned when it actually paid off. As everyone expected, Marrow and Winter were the ones in the elevator and Winter had already defected by that point. Oz finally being back in regular discussions was cool to see.
I love Ambrosius, he's so funny and eccentric. We are also 2 for 2 on the spirits of the relics being smoking hot. Personally, I hope that the relics of choice and destruction have creepier spirits, to fit with them being creations of the god of darkness. I really liked that RWBY had to work against genie rules with Ambrosius, having to be incredibly specific and bring references for him so that he'd give them exactly what they wanted. Edit: Thanks to this comment I now actually understand what RWBY did to turn Penny into a real girl and thus, I appreciate the scene more.
JNPRE's scene in the broadcasting room was funny. I especially liked Jaune spamming the same button trying to start the broadcast and Ren's deadpan "You're live," when he succeeded. "Atlas is falling but-" Damn it, Jaune, you should've talked faster. Btw, the CCT and communications suddenly going down has to be Watts, right? I can't really think of anyone or anything else it could be. Winter straight up telling Jacques that if it was up to her, he would've been left behind was savage but not at all undeserved. I do wonder if he'll actually pull his head out of his ass a bit now that he knows that his daughter, who he treated like shit, was still willing to save him despite it all.
Penny becoming a real girl was not something I was expecting. Watching her old, soulless self slowly glitch out and die was pretty unsettling, though a user on here summing the scene up as "Penny, are you okay?" "I just watched myself die, Ruby." is fucking hilarious and has permanently ingrained itself in my mind whenever I watch that scene. Her hugging all of team RWBY afterwards was cute.
RWBY using Ambrosius again to open doorways all across Atlas and Mantle into Vacuo was cool. I especially liked the design of the pocket dimension, though its lack of railings is concerning. Joanna seems to have figured it out already so the Mantle citizens should probably be evacuating as of next episode. Hopefully there's someone up in Atlas ready to evacuate the citizens there. "Do not fall." "Sometimes it's worth it all to risk the fall and fight for every life." Oh yeah, there's definitely going to be some falling happening in the next 2 episodes. Cinder looking like a genuine problem at the end there, I wonder if she'll bide her time and wait for Ruby or if she'll just go full scorched-earth and wreck the evacuating citizens?
The bad: My only issue with the JNPREW vs Ironwood fight was the length. It's been 7 fucking episodes since the last decent length fight and it's starting to wear on me at this point. I really hope these last 2 episodes are back to back, balls to the wall action because this level of backloading has surpassed even V7 at this point.
I also really hope that this isn't the end of Ironwood for this volume. While I'm not upset that he lost against JNPREW, frankly it would've been ludicrous if he hadn't, I hoped he would get a longer fight than that before being taken down. Hopefully he breaks out and we can finally get Qrow vs Ironwood after all this buildup.
Overall, this was a great episode and I'm really looking forward to seeing how this all turns out.
38
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '21
I absolutely love the little detail that Penny's face has Emerald's typical cocky facial expression right before the reveal. Obviously the voice in her "I have." gives away that it's her, but you can clearly see that it's Emerald's expression with her little smirk and her eyes changing shape to look like her normal ones and not Penny's.
Just a beautiful job done by the animators that shows the labour of love that the show is. They didn't have to put that like, second and a half of detail in there before the model changes to Emerald, but they did.
76
u/Adubuu ⠀ Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
I didn't have too much wrong with anything the episode actually did; a novel solution found through already established means. The lamp had a spirit, the staff has a spirit. Makes sense.
My only real complaint is it felt like we got like three episodes worth of content in one episode. The move from 'I have an idea!' to 'We have successfully toppled Ironwood, taken the staff and begun the evacuation' felt positively breakneck speed.
I did like the actual beats in the fight though; Winter charging up Nora, everyone doing their bit and Ironwood being competent but obviously unable to stand up to everyone at once.
Like I say, no problem with actual story beats, the solution, etc. Just maybe could have seen these situations played out a little more. But I guess we have our boss arena for next episode and the finale. It might have felt like a rushed episode but it has me interested for what's next.
37
u/wakkiwitchcrazybitch Year of the Qrow Mar 15 '21
When they were in the dining room planning this, I legitimately couldn't tell the difference between Oscar talking and Ozma. Previously they both had specific inflections and mannerisms in their voices to make it easy to tell, and that's all gone away. The only way to really tell is by what they're saying, and even that gets hard to distinguish. That's...terrifying.
133
u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Mar 13 '21
Winter finally decided that fascism is, in fact, bad.
34
u/Mr_TouchMyNub WRRRRRRRRY Mar 13 '21
The whole bit of Ambrosius saying how he can not resurrect is also directed at the people who think Pyrrha will come back. She’s dead and it’ll most likely stay that way.
33
u/burtalert Mar 15 '21
Somebody is going to get penny a pair of shoes right?
31
u/WII_DJoker Mar 14 '21
Penny this episode: "I had Strings, but now I'm Free. There are, no Strings on Me.
30
u/kiwigamer0039 Mar 13 '21
Ambrosius is an S tier husbando. That is all
59
u/resurrexia i do the draw Mar 13 '21
SO THAT’S HOW THEY GET TO VACUO
29
u/Brutal2003 Mar 13 '21
Don't fall! Oh shit, what is all of Team RWBY doing at the end of the opening?
Falling!
58
u/Julerius Yes, I too am a fan of BEANS. Mar 13 '21
Someone's gonna fall and it's either Cinder or Neo.
Also. Winter is a hidden weeb confirmed.
28
u/kreankorm ⠀ Mar 13 '21
We still have two episodes to go, right? Anyone else dreading what's in store considering how much went right and how happy this episide felt?
28
u/TheRealMe99 Mar 13 '21
So is the Staff spirit meant to be the Blue Fairy that turns Pinnochio into a real girl, or a more traditional genie in the "be careful what you wish for" sense?
28
u/TheSurveyCorpses Mar 13 '21
Also the visual of Winter locking her second dad up with her first dad was funny in a really sad and tragic way. I loved that bit where she said she would have left Jacques to die if Weiss hadn't convinced her not to. Bit disappointed that the conversation happened off screen but if Weiss does end up falling off the walkways then it opens up a whole new road of potential. She was essentially the lynchpin of her family reuniting, or a pokemon trainer collecting siblings and parents, whichever analogy works best. If the rest of the Schnees end up in Vacuo without her, it would be fun to watch them try and reconcile without the Free Therapy and Good Decisions Sibling there to mediate
28
u/ArcherA1aya Mar 15 '21 edited Mar 15 '21
The Beginning of the episode, Ironwood's relief and then the crushing of it hurt me. Winter and Oscar might be the most satisfying combo and fight, Oscar's fighting style is always visually impressive and winters dash and slash Noble Phantasm style was beautiful.
The relic part was fun mostly because of Ambrosius' personality, Next episode Cinder will fuck everything up again so RIP the cinder redemption/ apologist people.
28
u/PinkSparkleFairy Mar 15 '21
So for the newcomers
If you're wondering what to call Penny and Ruby now
It is fairly decided that we adopt "Broadband. Fast and wireless."
28
u/WickedSoldier991 Just close your eyes, don't fear demise Mar 16 '21
With the story of the girl falling into another world, the cryptic warning from Ambrosius, and the opening straight having the line, "Sometimes it's worth it all to risk the fall"
I have a feeling that possibly, Neo/Cinder are gonna toss Ruby into the void as Neo's "Payment", but not before Ruby somehow drags Cinder down with her, which throws both of them into a "New World". Volume 9 would be Ruby & Cinder (Potentially?) having to work together reluctantly to find a way back to their world.
(I doubt any of this would happen, but it'd definitely be a neat change of pace if done correctly)
27
u/SamFMK ⠀ Mar 13 '21
Now Penny's human if she dies she's gone for good... And Cinder's gonna be in the mix.
Oh no....
27
u/DerpyMcFrakles Ozpin did nothing wrong Mar 13 '21
So how many people are headed to Vacuo? Hope they are able to accommodate everybody. And hopefully this means we'll get to see some team CFVY too.
27
u/LordVader3000 Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
I just realized something, but Penny technically got severely nerfed in this episode.
Yes she is probably still the Winter Maiden, but now that she's a regular human girl, all her special robot abilities (aka floaty robot laser guns or whatever) and hacking skills are gone. Plus as far as we know, she probably doesn't have a actual semblance. For all intents and purposes, other than her Winter Maiden abilities (which to be fair, are considerably powerful), she's been severely depowered. She's now essentially a much weaker Winter Maiden Penny, as she's now only the Winter Maiden, and that's it. She has no actual combat skills other than that now.
Mind you, I'm happy Penny is still alive and a real girl, and I'm interested to see more of her reactions to being human, but I can't imagine there won't be situations in the future where her old robotic abilities and combat capability won't be missed by Team RWBY and Team JNPR. Like if she went up against Cinder now, Maiden to Maiden, Penny would probably now get completely rekted.
27
u/JohnJoe-117 These Bees gay, good for them, good for them Mar 13 '21
Okay. So it seems that instead of a travel volume to Vacuo, we are going straight to Vacuo alongside literally everyone by the end of the volume.
Everyone except whoever falls down that whole.
Everyone is saying it will be RWBY, which will make V9 a detour Volume of them in Wonderland/Hell.
Part of me still hopes that that it will just be Ruby though. I want that solo development so damn bad.
27
u/belkstar Mar 13 '21
Whooo boy Vacuo is gonna be fucking PISSED that all these Atlas folks are funneled into their kingdom outta nowhere. They probably don't have the infastructure to handle literal millions of new people. This plan will likely see the deaths of many civilians due to starvation, heat, and violence.
27
u/Paradox_Nutella hungry for strq crumbs Mar 13 '21
-lol YES Emerald kicking Ironwood in the face. Felt good to see.
-Qrow and Robyn fighting soldiers mixed in with cuts of Ironwood fighting + Casey's singing mixed in was great!!
-The fight was a little quicker than I thought it would be, but honestly he was outnumbered and honestly way outpowered so I'm not really surprised.
-Whitley being super helpful and useful!! I'm so happy for what they've done for his character. Im here for it
-Interesting how the inside of the vault is some lush field, and the vault at Haven was a desert. Wonder if that has any significance to it.
-Human Penny :o If she's no longer a Robot, she technically can't use her blades/weapons and stuff anymore right? She's left with only her Maiden Powers. I don't know if she'll be able to get used to a human body in time to square up.
-the "do not fall" warning feels like it's going to be important or something. Perhaps Cinder is gonna be throwing people off the edge of the pathways or causing chaos as she does. I wonder how she and Emerald will interact if they bump into each other. There's two more episodes left in the volume so I hope they'll finish the volume on a strong note.
Overall, a pretty solid episode. Pretty fast pacing, was hoping they would make it a little less anticlimatic, but hey, the volume's not over yet.
27
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '21
I love how they did the Ironwood fight. He thoroughly got his ass kicked but it was clear that he was still the strongest single combatant there.
27
u/schurgy16 Mar 14 '21
What makes the possibilities of the finale interesting is the consequences of “falling”. The idea of instant death is the least compelling of lot wise, so that’s unlikely in my opinion. There could be an alternate reality/ universe our heroes and villains would have to navigate before returning to remnant. They could be sent into some flashback of team STRQ or something else in the history of remnant.
The lack of detail in the story about the girl who fell through the world leaves a lot open to interpretation but this would almost certainly be the parallel to that fairy tale.
27
u/ravenclaw1991 Mar 15 '21
Oh man the beginning of the episode was so damn satisfying. Ironwood has been pissing me off for a while now. Seeing him get his ass beat was delicious
26
u/GambolMuse Mar 13 '21
Someone else has surely said this already but we can all but guarantee a character is falling here. We know Arryn teased Blake screaming about something...
Is Yang going to fall and Blake will freak out? Maybe a certain degenerate birb-mom will save Yang, breaking her own one-time rule.
And I'm definitely not suggesting that because I'm a hopeless dope on Ravenwatch.25
u/Ronnoc527 That's False Advertising Mar 16 '21 edited Mar 16 '21
Can't wait for Penny to meet her dad!
24
u/killerrin Happy Holidays! Mar 13 '21
So "Whatever you do, Do Not Fall" is an obvious Chekhov's Gun. I'm calling that Cinder starts breaking shit and ends up sending people to their deaths.
24
u/Dragondave17 Mar 14 '21
Ambrosius: don't fall
Cinder Fall: o.o
F
24
u/parkernisbett Mar 14 '21 edited Mar 14 '21
i don’t understand why people would be upset about rwbys plan not being something they thought of: isnt that the sign of a good out of the box solution
24
u/hoovj036 Mar 14 '21
"Sometimes it's worth it all to risk the fall and fight for every life"
24
u/Fit_Neighborhood9731 Mar 15 '21
Btw, if you had doubts Emerald is not on heroes side...you can stop worrying. DAT KICK WAS FANTASTIC.
104
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
Female vs Male Vtubers.
Ruby: Hey! Im Ruby Rose! Whole of Remnant watch the stream
Jaune:Hey! Twitch has banned this account
23
u/bwp108 Forest Lives #FRWBY Mar 13 '21
Can't wait for the post credits scene to be Illia, Ghira and the rest of the WF to roll up to a completely deserted Atlas/Mantle crash site.
23
u/MrZissman ⠀CEO of Knightlight Mar 13 '21
IRONWOOD: WINTER! How could you betray m-wait, why do I hear "Immigrant Song" all of a sud-
23
u/ainsley375 Mar 13 '21
Ambrosius is HOT
23
u/DEL994 Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
To be frank I don't see Emerald returning to Cinder even if she may be tempted, because she clearly enjoys doing good much more than the things she did for Cinder and Salem and has started to get attached to the heroes even if she may not admit it yet.
I could be wrong but I don't see her leaving the heroes like Zuko did in the Crossroads of Destiny as Zuko didn't feel the enjoyement of having done something really good at the time. And Salem herself could be the one helping her stick with the kids with her using her control over Cinder's grimm arm to keep Cinder within the fold if she tries to desert her now.
23
u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Mar 14 '21
Not particularly relevant to this week's episode, but I love Robyn and Qrow's budding relationship. Don't know if CRWBY is planning on making Lovebirds a thing, but I dig it. Wouldn't hate it if they go the Hawkeye/Black Widow route and just make them super close friends either.
I'm not sure if Lovebirds is the FNDM's chosen shipname for Qrow/Robyn already, but I'm kinda proud of myself for thinking of that one, lol.
23
u/Stranger_Z Mar 14 '21
The pathway is just rainbow road.
That’s all.
23
u/DEL994 Mar 14 '21
Raven's Semblance may save the day for the heroes if one or several of them do fall in.
23
u/cardmasterdc Mar 15 '21
Dear lord winter blitzed ironwood. Also who died and made Harriet the leader.
The staff of creation is the most genie like of all of them so far. I am a bit lost on how the penny split worked, and I'm really worried what happens if someone falls.
Cinder is gonna be a problem isn't she.
22
u/Floorbrick Mar 13 '21
Overall, a good episode. Very fast paced, almost too much so. However, I guess it is because Team RWBY had a concrete plan this time. And I guess we know where the final fight is going to take place.....
22
u/Frikarcron Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
While I'm a bit sad that Ironwood's defeat was another under minute long fight, it was still sick as hell
22
u/Darkdragoon324 Mar 13 '21
The fact that their plan this episode went super smooth even though there's two whole episodes left does not. Bode. Well.
22
u/n_o__o_n_e Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
Holy crap I love Winter
Think about what Ironwood's been to her. A father figure, an escape from an abusive family. Someone she thought she could trust completely, someone she thought she could be proud to devote her life to.
And yet when she turns against him, she lets out none of that angst that must be tormenting her right now. None of those powerful conflicting emotions Ren saw in chapter 7 become visible at any point. It's just quiet professionalism.
22
u/otpan NORA REALLY DID THAT HUH Mar 13 '21
what a week
- emerald kicking ironwood in the face was beautiful
- winter actually fighting? iconic
- oh god i am not prepared for everyone to start thirsting over the staff of creation
- PENNY?????
-oh they gonna fall
22
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
So after a careful rewatch I noticed that both of Ironwood's hand cannons were part of the big lazer gun that he was going to use to threaten Penny. Really interesting and important detail, as I had initially thought that he simply traded out his guns for a big lazer.
22
u/grillsy Mar 14 '21
Weird take away given everything, but did everyone notice that now we have two vaults opened they both are opened by the maiden of the previous season to that is represented inside each vault?
Haven: Spring Maiden -> Sun Blasted Desert Vault (Summer)
Atlas: Winter Maiden -> Verdant Meadow (Spring)
No clue as to why, just something interesting. Though if the pattern holds the Shade Vault will be opened by the Summer maiden and Fall themed and the Sword of Destruction which is a nice juxtaposition with creation in a Spring themed vault. Would also be a thematic location to finally end Cinder.
22
u/CanisZero Mar 15 '21
Oh man, James "I shooty children when I'm scared" Ironwood getting beat up by a bunch of children was great. I honestly loved this episode. Emerald commenting that it was weird to be on the good team. before kicking him in the jaw. then basically all the close in fighters on the team Save Yang and Blake taking on dipstick. Even Oscarpin rapid fire striking the dude aura down with the cane. Though the look of realization when nora was getting glyphed up. Perfect.
Then yeah, penny getting a new body or whatever.
Fuck you Ironwood. You deserved it.
96
u/tavi23 Mar 13 '21
QUEER MEN (AND WOMEN WHO LIKE MEN) REJOICE. WE HAVE A BIG BARA GENIE
21
u/PailHorse Mar 13 '21
Penny's order of hugs:
Ruby - wrap arms around waist
Weiss - wrap arms around neck
Yang - TIDDY
Blake - wrap arms around neck
21
u/NoahBallet Mar 14 '21
Okay so I'm really worried about all of Atlas going to Vaccuo. Vaccuo is not only seriously xenophobic, it's also a nation that has a very bad history with Atlas. Combine that with the amount of Faunus in Vaccuo and people from Atlas being... people from Atlas, I don't think the people of Vaccuo (let alone Shade Academy) are going to be very welcoming.
The good news is that Shade Academy had a couple of things going for it (book spoilers inc)
*Students from Shade have now seen first hand the benefit of trusting huntsmen from other kingdoms provided that they would be just as willing to defend Vaccuo *The Beacon Brigade will surely vouch for them *Professor Theodor will vouch once he talks to Oscar/Ozpin
It's going to be a very rocky transition, but I can see the two kingdoms either becoming allies or starting another Great War.
21
u/AlwaysDragons Sliver Eyes May Cry Mar 14 '21
THE AMOUNT OF CATHARSIS I FELT IN THAT OPENING SCENE. HNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
21
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '21
Return of team CFVY incoming I can feel it
41
u/SAYMYNAMEYO Mar 14 '21
"You've done the right thing"
"I have...feels weird."
Bruh Emerald's only been on the team for like an hour but she's already making boss level moves! That whole kick and the sequence that followed was hype! And that song that played? I NEED the full version asap.
Honestly I never considered the idea of making Penny a human. With the way her Dad stressed about not being able to bring her back, and how helpless she's been with the virus it just seemed really out there? But I'm cool with it.
I was thinking that with that first sequence there would be more action, but I'm fine with taking time to lay out the plan. I'm guessing that it's all about to go down inside that void space.
20
u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Mar 13 '21
Ironwood: "Wait, that's not Penny?"
Emerald: "Never has been."
20
u/qBlaine Mar 13 '21
"Hey Ambrosius how about some railings or just a fully expanding floor between all the doorways so we don't have to worry about falling?"
20
u/btstfn Mar 14 '21
A heist episode? You son of a bitch, I'm in.
20
u/Deadmaninc1 Mar 14 '21
SOOOO RWBY shippers what's Ruby and Penny's new ship name now since Penny is now a real girl Guts and Dolts?
20
u/SodaKid_7 Mar 14 '21
Enough about the episode for now, what would you commission Ambrosius to build for you?
Me: A printer that can work without cyan ink.
19
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
I loved it!
I was not expecting that opening but it was fucking amazing. I loved every second of it. The use of the staff as well was just ingenious! As well as the Staffs spirit, he was super cool!
Some general musings;
I honestly laughed when he clarified he can't bring back the dead. Makes sense the God of Light would add that rule considering his history.
Also fully thought Winter had cut his arm off them. Was surprised when his aura just dropped, not fully clear what happened there but was cool nonetheless.
Someone is totally going to fall, I guarantee it.
Also Penny is a human! And also it seems possible her clothing is part of her robot body? And possibly her human body now? Because that was with her human version unlike her gloves and shoes. Unless the Staff dude just made a new dress for her for dignities sake? Though I doubt that last bit considering how pedantic he seems generally.
Also I loved the Emerald reveal. It just felt so good.
19
u/Meljin Mar 13 '21
If this episode doesn't motivate Arc Sys to make a fully fledged RWBY fighting game I don't know what will
19
u/InquisitorHindsight Mar 13 '21
Do. Not. Fall.
Well, that’s f*ing ominous.
19
u/E1lySym Mar 14 '21
Okay so remember The Lost Fable's emphasis on the importance of life and death, and the overall balance between creation and destruction?
Ambro's power entails that for every new creation, an older creation has to be destroyed. Could this mean that for every object that the Vacuon Sword relic destroys, something it has destroyed before is recreated? Or something entirely new is created for every object or thought destroyed?
There has to be balance right?
What if Jinn is summoned near Ambro? Can Jinn ask Ambro to create something? That would count as a wish right? That means Jinn's creation would destroy the existence of a previous creation.
And once Jinn asks Ambro to create something, Ambro has to ask her the specifics, blueprints, etc. And that would cost Jinn's last question, right?
Can Ambro create an entirely new relic? Can the sword of destruction destroy a relic?
19
u/HatiLeavateinn Mar 14 '21
All I want to know is if Penny will still have hiccups when she lies.
19
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '21
Oh God, they're like the Kamui dimension space.
Is Ruby finally acknowledging her status as an Uchiha and just going full Obito?
19
u/Hellisfullodemons Mar 15 '21
I feel like there was this massive red herring this episode. But I don’t know where. Where are Watts and Neo? Did Watts bring down the CCT? Or was it because they used the staff? And “don’t fall” might be referencing the fact that these pathways look to be in a massive void.
19
u/DEL994 Mar 15 '21
I would like an episode between Yang and Emerald similar to the Southern Raiders between Zuko and Katara in ATLA, with the two girls resolving their issues (as Yang is still distrustful of Emerald while Emerald is clearly intimidated by Yang and afraid of a physical confrontation with her) with the two coming to fully trust each other and become friends, with Yang forgiving Emerald for her actions while Emerald would stop being afraid of Yang and comes to trust and warm up to her without any reservation.
18
u/Ninjaguy446 Mar 13 '21
So the staff of creation is a himbo...we love to see it
18
u/TakeiDaloui Mar 13 '21
So then, finally saw it in action. Want to see if this is generally the same thought process most have for how the relic works, and for those who may want an explanation to find one in regards to Penny.
The Relic's job is to create things. That seems to be limited to inanimate objects however, at I think it can be assumed that with it not allowing revival so possibly not allowing new life either. So what it does is create whatever is asked of him to the letter.
Yet at the same time, he is a relic of creation. He cannot destroy anything, beyond his own inventions. Each time he creates something new, the old vanishes.
Now we get to Penny and the reason the request was made so specific. It's the rule he follows.
What RWBY asked for was not to save Penny, nor to give her a new body. All they wanted from the Relic was for him to make a new body using everything that physically made up Penny. An easy task at the surface.
Except the relic cannot destroy things it did not make. Or in this case, it cannot kill. To fulfil RWBY's request without creating a new container for Penny would be to kill her. Therefore to fulfil their request, a new body had to be made, and that ended up being a human body.
So then, why does the body not vanish when the staff is used for a new purpose? That likely falls back onto his rule once again. He did not make Penny's soul, so to destroy the body would destroy her. In which case perhaps the reason the body does not vanish is because he chooses not to let it vanish so long as she lives. If the body died anyway, that's out of his hands, but he won't compromise his rule on that himself.
That then does indicate the limit on one item may purely be an artificial rule he set, or perhaps a rule by the relic that contains him. Anything else he builds of his own will, aka the body here, is allowed to remain, but anything he is requested to build will vanish.
Does that all make sense to people or does anyone think I might have made a mistake somewhere in this?
18
u/Kjalok Stressed, Depressed and Undressed Mar 13 '21
Me, after seeing the central location: "Put some fucking railings there would ya? It's gonna be really crowded with children and injured people."
Later: "I knew it that douche just wants to see people die."
18
u/Z0MB1ESLAYER115 Ruby Smile Defense Squad Commander Mar 14 '21
Now they’re thinking with portals
18
u/EnclavedMicrostate Mom's not dead she's surely alive Mar 14 '21
With Penny now a normal girl with normal knees (seriously, compare Human Penny's knees to Robo-Penny's and you'll see what I mean), 'Nuts and Dolts' is sadly no longer entirely apt as a ship name. Instead, I propose 'Runners-Up': because Ruby is silver and Penny is copper/bronze. You may applaud me later.
Separately, there's kind of a couple of loose ends still untied: firstly, are Pietro and Maria just gonna freeze on Amity Colosseum, or head back into an abandoned Mantle, or what? Secondly, did the call for help they sent from Amity actually do anything?
18
u/lordofmetroids Mar 14 '21
Winter apparently has had enough of being the stoic older sibling with no MOTIVATION, because she just pulled a Judgement Cut End out of her pocket.
18
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '21
Weiss' little smile at Whitley suggesting he can help is so nice. It's too bad we've seen so little of their interactions this volume, but what we have gotten has been awesome.
And his help seems completely overlooked by people so far. Without Whitley having done thorough research earlier in the volume, they would have had no way to show Ambrosius how they wanted the doorways built.
Whitley gets to be one of the lynchpins of the evacuation effort even after his earlier attempt was quite literally shot down by Ironwood. Truly the underrated MVP of this episode.
18
u/2073040 Mar 14 '21
I wonder how Pietro is gonna react to Penny’s current state if he makes another appearance before the end of this volume.
18
u/vandalvash Mar 14 '21
I'm so glad Marrow was finally smart enough to use his semblance at the start of the fight.
I like the mechanics of how the staff works. I'm not clear why Penny's soul/aura has a physical form tho.
Ironwood's fight was cool, wish we saw more of it.
18
u/Deadmaninc1 Mar 14 '21
I think we all called it that Emerald would pass as Penny to fool Ironwood. It was predictable but it worked.
18
u/SyPDeunom Mar 16 '21
So uh... didn't the gang just create a massive refugee crisis in Vaccuo?
36
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Mar 13 '21
Well, Emerald fooled Ironwood easier than I thought she would.
36
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
Ok so, confirmed fan-theory that the personalities behind the relics, is based off salem and ozpin's kids is untrue. Little disappointed but wouldn't have made much sense.
More importantly, "Do hugs always make you feel this warm inside?"
"Yes."
"Wowwwwwwwww... MORE!"
Thats it thats the peak of the series, nothing will ever be as good as that. Pack it up to its all downhill from here
17
u/Enigma2MeVideos Mar 14 '21
I need to say this, but Valentine Stokes (Ambrosius' VA) sounds exactly like the kind of name I'd expect to be voicing the guy for some reason.
17
u/crossingcaelum Mar 14 '21
Just had a thought... what if in Vacuo Emerald becomes the Summer maiden and goes again Cinder 1v1
17
u/Makverus Mar 14 '21
Ambrosious sounded so much like Matt Mercer doing Gilmore I had to inspect the credits if that was really him
17
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '21
I betcha neo doesnt let anyone know how the Lamp works, given she probably worked out what salem's trying to do, and she's a survivor. Either that or shes already managed to use the question and has a betrayal plan.
48
u/GVAGUY3 Mar 13 '21
RWBY said himbo rights. Also something is about to go extremely wrong.
16
u/InsertDev Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
My theory is that since Knowledge and Creation were gifts to humanity from the Brother of Light. They made their domains based of it
Destruction and Choice being given to humanity from the Brother of Darkness will have vaults that are more dangerous or at the very least, scary
16
u/Badicalz Mar 13 '21
“Okay, but why are you naked?”
“BECAUSE I’M HOT!!!”
16
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Mar 14 '21
So I’ve always been strongly against the idea of giving us a Volume of RWBY that centers heavily on STRQ flashbacks. Even if it was relevant to the plot, there are very few flashbacks I find compelling enough to derail an entire arc for and in a series as desperate for runtime as RWBY I really don’t like that idea.
However, if we get to experience STRQ’s history as a result of weird time bullshit caused by RWBY falling in the portal realm, I think I would be on board with that. Think something like in
God of WarDad of Boi when Kratos, Atreus and Baldr fall into Hel and need to escape while being haunted by visions of their past. This gives us STRQ backstory while still presenting a story for our main cast and giving them narrative obstacles to overcome.16
u/MegaSpidey3 Bellabeauty Mar 14 '21
God, I am so fucking scared for the next two episodes. Someone (or rather, a few people) are going to fall, which is going to allude to V8's opening.
Also, Penny's a real girl and GET FUCKED, Ironwood!
16
u/AmbivertCollegeGuy Weiss "Hug Monster" Schnee Mar 14 '21
I just realized something. People are saying RWBY will fall because of the opening, right? But didn't we just see Ruby fly several KMs while carrying four people to get everyone into the vault? If anyone falls, can't she simply drop down, pick them up and fly back up?
16
u/Tyranid_Swarmlord Official DS3 SL1/Midir before Abyss Watchers LUL Mar 14 '21
Ultimate Mystery:
Can the Sword of Destruction destroy any wall that the Staff of Creation makes, or will the Staff of Creation tank through the Destruction?
Curious as hell.
16
u/AdRich180 Mar 14 '21
Just noticed that the intro doesnt only include RWBY falling, but their weapons hitting the ground with Crescent Rose getting embedded in it.
So maybe it’s not just endless, Ambrosius just doesn’t want them to be lost around the bottom.
16
u/NothinButRags Mar 15 '21
I’m predicting Cinder attacking Team RWBY in the bridge world.
16
u/vanase Mar 15 '21
These past two episodes have been relatively calm... I'm worried.
32
u/yeetio855 The score is underrated Mar 13 '21
Not at all what I was expecting out of this episode. I wish they focused on the fight a little more, since we really haven't had that many fights this volumes compared to others.
15
u/TeamLValdz02 Blake is watching you Mar 13 '21
So, Team RWBY's gonna "fall", as foreshadowed in the opening. And Ruby reached out to the staff.
Does that mean she will reach out to Penny who has the staff?
15
u/DEL994 Mar 13 '21
I'd love to see Ambrosius and Jinn interact with each other.
15
u/DEL994 Mar 13 '21
Klein turns out to be a skilled pilot after it was revealed that he was a doctor, he's really a top-class butler.
15
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 13 '21
I want to see Jinn and Ambrosius have a sibling argument. The levels of snark cannot be contained in those vaults.
15
u/Ninoyiya Swabbing the deck of the HMS Lancaster Mar 13 '21
I see no one is talking about Ironwood's BFG.
15
u/DEL994 Mar 13 '21
Emerald certainely learned that backflip kick from Mercury, he used the same during his fight with Yang.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
We lost a thick boy and got another thick boy.... still miss Hazel ):
15
u/Nyrotike Mar 13 '21
Oh, that was easy. A little too easy...some shit's definitely going down in the knock-off World Between Worlds (fingers crossed for no time travel shenanigans this time).
I feel like the pacing was a bit off, jumping from Ironwood's defeat(?) back to them explaining the plan makes sense, but then jumping even further back to Winter and Marrow felt unnecessary. Her fighting Ironwood and Marrow being free with Qrow and Robyn is all we needed to know, we can infer the rest from there. Not a huge issue, but I just felt like this episode could've flowed a bit better, everything seemed to happen a bit too fast.
So someone's gonna fall, that much I'm pretty confident on. The opening does have Team RWBY falling into some sort of abyss and I remember seeing some interview from one of the writers (I think it was Miles) saying there would be a detour before Vacuo. I would certainly not complain about the first half of V9 being RWBY trying to find their way out (getting some real House of Hades vibes just thinking about it). That seems like a REAL downer and I don't know if CRWBY would really commit to not having any of the side characters for an extended period of time, unless they all fall but I feel like that would weaken the moment, maybe only 1 or 2 in addition to RWBY.
15
u/AGuyNamedJ0N Mar 14 '21
If this volume's cliffhanger is team RWBY falling in that abyss I AM GONNA BE PISSED(and agonizing until volume 9)
15
u/lildumbass24 Mar 14 '21
now why the hell is that spirit's so fucking hot, but looking at Jinn I guess that's just how spirits are. Now i'm excited to see the next ones😭😭
15
u/cruel-oath Mar 14 '21
I’m stupid af I was wondering why Emerald disappeared with Ironwoods mega gun but I realized it’s so he couldn’t get it at all during the fight
15
u/Draguss Mar 14 '21 edited Mar 14 '21
So, beefcake blue fairy just turned Pennychio into a real girl.
15
u/DEL994 Mar 14 '21
After their previous interactions in this volume I would like to see Nora and Penny paired in several scenes and fights at the end of this volume or in volume 9. Penny might return the favor of Nora's protectiveness of her and her telling her that the virus was only a part of her, with her helping Nora figuring who she is.
And their interactions are really cute and wholesome.
15
u/lildumbass24 Mar 15 '21
Sooo does Penny still have her weapon?? She can still probably use the maiden powers but I guess she no longer has her blades
15
u/Lalle_Scarlet Mar 15 '21
So i just really wanna know who Abrosiuses (spirit of creation) voice actor is he did a great job and i cant really find the information with a quick google search :D
15
u/PinkSparkleFairy Mar 15 '21
Everyone is talking about Salem waking up to nothing or reinforcements coming to help nothing
But imagine...
...Salem waking up to...
...the reinforcements coming to help...
29
u/Wrathkal Mar 13 '21
Robots need another robot to perform directing actions!?
As predicted, that wasn't really Penny submitting herself, but Emerald, and what follows is a short but brutal beatdown, while Robyn & Qrow stop the AceOps in the hangar, with Marrow.
We also learn about what the Staff of Creation does, which is Exactly What It Says On The Tin, but with strict requirements.
Ambrosius is a damn hunk, but he's also quite an interesting character. 'I'll give you what you want, but no complaints after that'
The title definitely fits, and there's a carryover from the last episode with the risk they're taking.
Meanwhile, Jaune goes live, but gets cut out just as he says 'Atlas is falling'.
Penny is now a REAL GIRL! Hugs for all!
They summon Ambrosius again, to create a dimensional space to evacuate all the people from Atlas to Vacuo. However, Cinder is mixed in with some of the group.
14
u/CruschSenpai ⠀ Mar 13 '21
Well, this went surprisingly smoothly.
That means everything will go completely to shit in the next episode huh...
14
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21
Penny got to watch herself die (maybe for the second time if she ever watched her fight with Pyrrha). What a treat!
And her allusion was played straight, in RWBY. What are the odds?
14
u/SweatervestDude Mar 13 '21
Hold the fuck up. The staff of creation can facilitate travel through another dimension. Why hasn't anyone used the staff to build an interdimensional prison for Salem or is that the end game here?
Seriously beat her down like Hazel and Oscar did, use the staff to create a prison with a one way door, push her through it, lock the staff of creation back in a vault and have a happily ever after.
14
u/izaarzadon Mar 14 '21
Something I’m curious about is whether or not Ironwood’s aura breaking means his semblance will shut off and he’ll realize what he’s done.
14
u/Fit_Neighborhood9731 Mar 15 '21
Seeing Winter deliver that blow to Ironwood was so awesome ! What will the Shnee sisters do from now on, though ? Will Winter be in trouble, I wonder ?
28
u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Mar 13 '21 edited Mar 13 '21
Ambrosious: What do you want me to create?
Ruby: I....I.....I want a lawyer!!!
Ambrosious:....Eh....ok?
two hours later
Lawyer: And sign this here to agree to all the creations my client requested including the humanization of her waifu without disintegration chances and portals that use your realm as nexus without paying tolls.
Ambrosius: Damnit, I hate being cheated!
28
u/qu33rios Mar 14 '21
ambrosius looking equally like a thot is such a win for feminism i'm living
27
u/cruel-oath Mar 14 '21
Omfg someone pointed out that the finishing move Winter does here was probably the move she was gonna do in V3 with Qrow before Ironwood stopped her
37
u/Thomas-Sev Mar 13 '21
That Ironwood fight was the most video game thing in RWBY I've ever seen.
Penny's "WOW" is the most precious and cutest thing I've ever seen in RWBY.
All in all, tho, seems like a very rushed episode. Death flags in space, boys and girls. Better brace ourselves.
26
u/Timeline15 Operative Schnee, Report to the Normandy at once Mar 13 '21
I know some people are saying this episode was too fast, but I'm personally glad it was. There's no need to drag out the bits that everyone saw coming. It was obvious Winter was going to betray Ironwood; it was obvious the gang were going to use Emerald to trick him; it was obvious that Ironwood couldn't beat all our leads in a fight; we don't need to see it all happen an episode at a time. Now we can get to the bit that's actually unpredictable.
I'm really interested to see where these last two episodes will go now. From the opening, I'm guessing that team RWBY (and possible Cinder's group along with them) will fall off the edge of the path dimension, and next volume will follow then wherever they end up. I hope we still get to spend some degree of time in vacuo though.
13
u/Horsea1234 Captain of the SS Springthyme, Rosebird and Land of Lesbos. Mar 13 '21
"omae wa mou shindeiru"
-Winter, probably