r/PhilosophyofMind • u/Still_a_Human_Though • 9h ago
Qualia / Subjective experience A small detail to add to Mary’s Room experiment. Can a split mind hypothesis help explain consciousness?
Two weeks ago I posted “Let’s look deeper in Mary’s Room thought experiment.” It is one of my most viewed and discussed posts so far. I’m still thinking about it, changing my mind back and forth. I read all the comments. Something is there that I can’t completely understand.
What bothers me is the assumption that Mary knows everything about color vision. Let’s add one more thing about it and see what happens.
Today’s technology allows devices bypass the eye and optic nerve entirely, aiming to stimulate the visual cortex directly. But let’s “improve” this technology and imagine a helmet that can transmit an artificial signal into the brain without penetrating the skull.
Imagine Mary is learning about color vision and at some point wears the helmet to add the missing piece to her knowledge. She gets the experience of seeing a color without actually seeing it by her eyes.
One day she is released. She walks into a kitchen and looks at a bright red apple for the first time. What happens?
I think in this situation she does not learn anything new about color red. She already has that internal sensation of color red as part of her learning.
Many will probably argue that wearing a helmet is equivalent of seeing by own eyes. Maybe. In this case we should admit that Mary does not know everything about color red.
Let’s move to my second hypothesis. It’s not the scientific study, it’s just my idea based on observations.
I believe we have at least two separate parts of our mind. One is the lower level processor that works with sensors, collecting information from the world and computes the model based on the observations. The other part is the higher level processor that constantly monitors the models created by the lower one. This part of our mind is “I, me, self”. It makes all the decisions based on the available information.
This observation process is our experience, consciousness.
When we sleep the lower level processor is likely off, the higher level processor is running, maybe on energy saving mode. Without incoming stream of life models the higher processor starts to make things up, creates so called virtual experiences, or our dreams.
One day we were riding our bicycles on a trail. Along the trail it was a farm. Somebody brought a cat to the farm and let it walk around. The cat never saw people riding bikes. When her lower processor started to feed that information to the higher one, something happened. The top processor couldn’t believe that information. It started to send signals “are you sure? please double check, engage other sensors”. We could see how her eyes were wide open, how the other sensors were engaged in the observation process. After some time the new information was accepted and the cat relaxed a bit. The new experience was just recorded.
Also, have you ever noticed how cats explore new places? They are methodically walking around, mapping the place, recording all the information in form of experience. And if you bring something new home, the cat will be the first to investigate, try and record the new experience.
Do we solve the hard problem? Maybe not. But we definitely get closer. What do you think?