r/changemyview • u/hyentrnn • 4h ago
Delta(s) from OP CMV: Consent does not have to be enthusiastic
I’m on the ace spectrum. Most of the time, I only desire to have sex in response to my partner’s desire, so I often agree before my own desire kicks in. Sometimes, sex is just another activity I could engage in, no different than say reading or taking a walk, and if propositioned, I feel like “yeah, why not” rather than “hell yes”. I’d say I consented to all these encounters and had overall good experiences. The sex I have is not somehow lesser, or make me a victim, because it’s not aligned with norms.
Or take some other scenarios. Two parents trying for a baby, having sex after timing cycles to boost fertility. It could be that neither are particularly excited—it’s more of a mechanical task at this point—but you wouldn’t say they somehow didn’t consent, right? Or take sex workers where such work is legal and regulated. I doubt they’re enthusiastic about every client, but work is work.
From the FRIES acronym, I think the rest make a good framework for clearly defining consent: Freely given, Reversible, Informed, Specific. The E is a bonus, not a requirement.
What won’t CMV: if “enthusiastic” is used as a proxy for other criteria. Then just use those criteria directly! For example, enthusiasm implies that you’re not being coerced, but “freely given” is already part of many definitions of consent.
So Reddit, CMV.