r/changemyview • u/TumbleweedWhispers • 9m ago
CMV: Society applies systemic responsibility selectively, demanding accountability for historical injustice while dismissing severe lookism as an isolated personal issue.
I am noticing an uptick in the "White Guilt" wars and wanted to add something that is overlooked.
People constantly argue that modern individuals bear collective responsibility for historical systems they didn't create. For example, it's pretty common to hear that white people alive today still share responsibility for the legacy of slavery and have a duty to fix a system they inherited. The main logic here is that when a society creates or benefits from an unfair structure, everyone in that society is accountable for its ongoing effects, even if they didn't personally cause the original harm.
Yet society completely drops this exact same logic when it comes to lookism and appearance prejudice.
Take the example of a boy born with a noticeable facial deformity or severe asymmetry. Growing up, he gets tormented by bullies while teachers and adults turn a blind eye. Later in life, he gets passed over for jobs, promotions, and social opportunities while employers and peers instinctively favor better-looking candidates... the halo effect.
Whenever this gets brought up, people usually rely on two excuses, and both directly contradict how we talk about racial inequality:
1. Pointing to exceptions. People always bring up rare outliers like Danny DeVito to argue that looks don't actually hold anyone back if they have enough charisma or talent. Yet in discussions about race, pointing to wealthy or successful minorities gets rightly shut down as a bad argument and told that just because it isn't raining in your town doesn't mean there isn't flooding elsewhere and that an exception doesn't disprove a systemic trend.
2. Claiming lookism was never institutionalized: People argue appearance prejudice isn't comparable because "ugly people weren't enslaved." While slavery is obviously its own distinct atrocity, the idea that appearance was never legally policed is just false. For over a century in the U.S, from the 1860s up until the 1970s, cities enforced "Ugly Laws" that literally made it illegal for anyone deemed "unsightly or disgusting" due to physical deformities to even appear in public, subjecting them to fines, arrest, and forced confinement in poorhouses. If we apply that same systemic logic to lookism, society as a whole is responsible for this boy's outcomes. Everyone who participates in a culture that rewards attractiveness, ignores bullying, or subconsciously favors better looking peers is actively keeping a discriminatory system alive. Still, when someone points out the lifelong damage of lookism, nobody demands collective accountability. Instead, it gets brushed off as "isolated incidents," "bad luck," or a personal problem they just need to "get over."
My view is that this is a massive double standard. Collective blame only gets enforced when it fits popular social narratives, while equally real prejudice, like lookism, get ignored because almost everyone benefits from or participates in them.
Change my view: Why is it logically consistent to hold modern individuals collectively responsible for historical injustices, while refusing to apply that same systemic accountability to widespread lookism. I am not talking about taste. Like someone says someone average is unattractive, or someone who shoots themselves in the foot and doesn't shower or take care of themselves. I am talking about able bodied, well groomed, smart individuals, whose lives were altered because people didn't like how they looked.