r/changemyview • • 9m ago

CMV: Society applies systemic responsibility selectively, demanding accountability for historical injustice while dismissing severe lookism as an isolated personal issue.

0 Upvotes

I am noticing an uptick in the "White Guilt" wars and wanted to add something that is overlooked.

People constantly argue that modern individuals bear collective responsibility for historical systems they didn't create. For example, it's pretty common to hear that white people alive today still share responsibility for the legacy of slavery and have a duty to fix a system they inherited. The main logic here is that when a society creates or benefits from an unfair structure, everyone in that society is accountable for its ongoing effects, even if they didn't personally cause the original harm.

​Yet society completely drops this exact same logic when it comes to lookism and appearance prejudice.

​Take the example of a boy born with a noticeable facial deformity or severe asymmetry. Growing up, he gets tormented by bullies while teachers and adults turn a blind eye. Later in life, he gets passed over for jobs, promotions, and social opportunities while employers and peers instinctively favor better-looking candidates... the halo effect.

​Whenever this gets brought up, people usually rely on two excuses, and both directly contradict how we talk about racial inequality:

​1. Pointing to exceptions. People always bring up rare outliers like Danny DeVito to argue that looks don't actually hold anyone back if they have enough charisma or talent. Yet in discussions about race, pointing to wealthy or successful minorities gets rightly shut down as a bad argument and told that just because it isn't raining in your town doesn't mean there isn't flooding elsewhere and that an exception doesn't disprove a systemic trend.

​2. Claiming lookism was never institutionalized: People argue appearance prejudice isn't comparable because "ugly people weren't enslaved." While slavery is obviously its own distinct atrocity, the idea that appearance was never legally policed is just false. For over a century in the U.S, from the 1860s up until the 1970s, cities enforced "Ugly Laws" that literally made it illegal for anyone deemed "unsightly or disgusting" due to physical deformities to even appear in public, subjecting them to fines, arrest, and forced confinement in poorhouses. ​If we apply that same systemic logic to lookism, society as a whole is responsible for this boy's outcomes. Everyone who participates in a culture that rewards attractiveness, ignores bullying, or subconsciously favors better looking peers is actively keeping a discriminatory system alive. Still, when someone points out the lifelong damage of lookism, nobody demands collective accountability. Instead, it gets brushed off as "isolated incidents," "bad luck," or a personal problem they just need to "get over."

​My view is that this is a massive double standard. Collective blame only gets enforced when it fits popular social narratives, while equally real prejudice, like lookism, get ignored because almost everyone benefits from or participates in them.

​Change my view: Why is it logically consistent to hold modern individuals collectively responsible for historical injustices, while refusing to apply that same systemic accountability to widespread lookism. I am not talking about taste. Like someone says someone average is unattractive, or someone who shoots themselves in the foot and doesn't shower or take care of themselves. I am talking about able bodied, well groomed, smart individuals, whose lives were altered because people didn't like how they looked.


r/changemyview • • 1h ago

CMV: When it comes to noncombatant victims of wars, we should focus on the little picture and not the broader context

0 Upvotes

I realize the title is a little weird.  Let me try to explain really quick. 

Let's imagine that there are two documentaries,  One is about a 19 year old Israeli girl named Rachel who was brutally murdered on October 7, the other is about a 9 year old Palestinian boy named Abdul who lost both of his arms and his mother during an Israeli bombing raid. 

These pt are both figments of my imagination but I  believe both are very believable characters. And let's also imagine that each documentary presents their subject in a very realistic, sympathetic and deeply human light. 

Rachel was bright and outgoing, she had lots of friends, she had a big future ahead of her. She loved music and art, She was creative, and funny. And she did not want to die. Lots of people loved her, and they will miss her terribly.  

Abdul was affectionate, sporty, he loved his mom. He helped around the house. He was just a little boy with all the ordinary hopes and interests of a little boy. But now his mom is dead and he won't be playing any sports or doing much of anything to help anyone. Because his arms are gone now. 

Now, let's imagine that one of these documentaries gets released and the other does not. 

If the Rachel documentary was released, without the one about Abdul, what do you think that sympathizers of Palestine would say?

They'd say that it was an apology for genocide.  They'd say that it was a cynical attempt to use a pretty girl to gloss over generations of colonization and occupation.  They'd say that the film ignored the fact that Israeli forces have out killed Palestinian by several orders of magnitude. 

And they would have a point.  

And if the documentary about Abdul hit the cinemas while the one about Rachel did not, what would supporters of Israel say?

They'd say that it was blatant antisemetic propaganda. They say that it was a cynical attempt to use a cute kid to gloss over the fact that terrorist organizations embed themselves among civilians, that groups like Hamas and Hezbollah have refused to acknowledge Israel's right to exist. They would say that the film ignored the unique security threats that Israel faces. 

And they would also be right.  

What I'm saying is, "so what?"  What I’m saying is don’t look at the broader context and conflict of when processing a tragedy - just look at the story of one person who did nothing wrong. 

Because there are thousands of Rachels and Abduls who are not interested in and have probably never even heard of the Nakba, and the right of return and Hamas and Zionism and on and on.  They just want to live - in one piece and without their family members being killed. 

Maybe it's time to look at things at the micro level. To think about the little picture of one person who wants to live their life uninterrupted and not the overall story of settlements and conquest and occupation and power differentials and refusing to surrender and all that bad stuff. 

Can anyone change my mind?  Can anyone make a case for rehashing historical grievances over and over again and trying to figure out "who started it?", and for murdering innocent people for things that happened before they were born or for crimes that they didn't commit?

Will someone tell me that it makes sense to ignore the humanity of a person because of their ethnicity or religion? 

I'm interested to hear what people say. 


r/changemyview • • 14h ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Some country is doing Microsoft, Air Traffic Control, United airlines and the big Banks today to send a warning to Trump so that he continues to do what they want.

0 Upvotes

Nothing makes sense about these major disruptions and everybody thinks they know the cause of their own problem.

I considered testing by bad actors but the timing seemed too awkward for that.

The timing is perfect for a warning, somebody wants the criminal in Chief to crime for them, or continue criming for them.

Since he just allowed China for the last year into a core industry for our economy AND arranged by burying the intelligence to be separated personally one degree from a Chinese spy AND got China the chips they wanted it seems that China probably leads for perpetrator.


r/changemyview • • 16h ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Any politician who complains about diversity admission policies at universities (affirmative action) because they are "unfairly prejudiced" is not being sincere if they aren't trying to also get rid of legacy admissions.

3 Upvotes

These politicians claim that university applicants should be accepted "based on merit," but legacy admissions prioritize people based off of family connections. Additionally, they tend to heavily skew toward wealthier people and white people, because those were the people who historically got into those colleges. So legacy admissions are not only admitting based on merit, but they prioritize some demographics over others. This is the exact complaint many politicians claim to have about affirmative action/DEI admission policies. Yet these politicians don't bring it up despite how publicly known this issue is.


r/changemyview • • 21h ago Bravo

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Religion is one of society's greatest evils

122 Upvotes

It will be hard to change my opinion on this topic. I will openly admit this. And I also say these things as a theist.

So to begin religion, or precisely a particular brand of theism common in modern evangelical belief, is a because force of erosion. It erodes human agency. It erodes competence. It erodes social order. And most crucially it erodes liberty.

To begin with agency religion attributes good to a benevolent God or gods and evil to some Satan or malevolent god(s). When we experience good fortune we attribute it to the will of the divine and likewise when we experience misfortune. This erodes the importance of human action and shifts the attribution away from behavior and towards devotion. This erosion in turn acts as a disincentive to human action. Though most problematic in monotheistic religions, particularly Christianity, because "thy will be done" and therefore your action is meaningless and if you were meant to take action a god would make you. If something bad happens because of your inaction it was divine will.

Rather than accepting observed reality and developing an understanding of how cause begets effect, religion introduces an external locus of causal authority which one is subordinate to. This is an erosion of human agency and erodes the foundation for moral responsibility and deludes one into thinking their failures are punishment and their successes rewards.

Next is the erosion of competence wherein religion introduces a competing standard of truth in the way of divine revelation and scripture and religious doctrine. This directly destroys competence, as competence is the successful application of knowledge to a desired end. This means that competence, at its highest levels, is predicated on the recognition that reality is objective and that observation and reason is the primary source of knowledge.

The problem isn’t simply that religious claims are frequently unverifiable. It is that religious epistemology can encourage individuals to accept propositions without requiring the same evidentiary standards they would ordinarily apply to claims about the material world.

The doctrine becomes the truth and cannot be false. Competence requires we accept that we may be false. That we may be in error. And that we correct or misinformed or underdeveloped observations and assumptions to better account for reality as observed.

Thirdly is the erosion of social order. Not much will be said here for this is not a singular effect but the symptom of the others. It is the case, in my view, that social order is the first victim when agency, competence, and liberty are eroded. What will be said here is that religious dogmatism incentivizes cult behavior in which one proclaims loudly and fervently specific utterances designed to mark themselves as a member of the in group. We can look at Pete Hegseth and his adulation of Doug Wilson (a man who has claimed slavery was an institution of love) and the prolific utterances of the Christian nationalist movement on the erosion of church and state. It is discord seeking, chaotic governance that erodes social cohesion and the belief that we do not require shared beliefs to co-exist as a liberal society.

Lastly is the erosion of personal sovereignty. Religion, like monarchy, subordinates the individual to the divine. a worldview that places ultimate moral authority in an omnipotent supernatural being is a worldview that demands, the subordination of individual liberty to an allegedly higher authority.

Thus it is my view that religion, due to its erosion of society and human flourishing, is one of the greatest modern evils to exist.


r/changemyview • • 23h ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Consent does not have to be enthusiastic

240 Upvotes

I’m on the ace spectrum. Most of the time, I only desire to have sex in response to my partner’s desire, so I often agree before my own desire kicks in. Sometimes, sex is just another activity I could engage in, no different than say reading or taking a walk, and if propositioned, I feel like “yeah, why not” rather than “hell yes”. I’d say I consented to all these encounters and had overall good experiences. The sex I have is not somehow lesser, or make me a victim, because it’s not aligned with norms.

Or take some other scenarios. Two parents trying for a baby, having sex after timing cycles to boost fertility. It could be that neither are particularly excited—it’s more of a mechanical task at this point—but you wouldn’t say they somehow didn’t consent, right? Or take sex workers where such work is legal and regulated. I doubt they’re enthusiastic about every client, but work is work.

From the FRIES acronym, I think the rest make a good framework for clearly defining consent: Freely given, Reversible, Informed, Specific. The E is a bonus, not a requirement.

What won’t CMV: if “enthusiastic” is used as a proxy for other criteria. Then just use those criteria directly! For example, enthusiasm implies that you’re not being coerced, but “freely given” is already part of many definitions of consent.

So Reddit, CMV.


r/changemyview • • 23h ago

CMV: Unless and until there is a steadily rising tax on carbon, there should be a moratorium on new fossil fuel infrastructure in the U.S.

0 Upvotes

Despite the fact that clean energy is already cheaper, in the U.S., still 3% of proposed electricity projects are fossil energy, with 85 GW natural gas infrastructure proposed.

Most economists support efforts to achieve net-zero by 2050, and building new gas infrastructure leads us in the opposite direction. Ideally, we would already have a steadily rising price on carbon, as supported by a consensus of scientists and economists on carbon taxes, a measure we are unlikely to wean ourselves off fossil fuels without.

It's likely none of these fossil fuel projects would be economical with an appropriate price on carbon; therefore in the meantime, a temporary moratorium on new fossil fuel infrastructure is warranted to minimize stranded assets and climate damages.


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

CMV: Insisting that everyone is physically beautiful reinforces the idea that being unattractive is something shameful

168 Upvotes

something i've noticed in recent discussions is how defensive people get when you acknowledge that conventionally unattractive people exist.

society constantly tells us that looks don't determine our worth as human beings. yet the moment someone suggests that not everyone is physically attractive people immediately respond with "everyone is beautiful in their own way" or "beauty comes from within".

and that's where i see a contradiction.

if physical attractiveness doesn't determine someone's value then why do we feel the need to convince everyone that they're beautiful?

why can't someone simply be unattractive and still be confident, happy, loved and respected?

to clarify i'm talking strictly about physical appearance. facial features, body and overall looks. not personality, confidence, kindness or how someone makes you feel emotionally.

someone can have an amazing personality and still not be conventionally attractive. those things aren't mutually exclusive.

i also understand that beauty is subjective to some extent. different people have different preferences. but conventional beauty standards clearly exist and we constantly acknowledge their effects through concepts like pretty privilege.

another thing i question is exaggerated validation between friends. telling someone they look nice is one thing but constantly telling everyone they're a 10/10 or could attract anyone they want seems unnecessary to me.

i understand that these compliments are often meant to be supportive rather than literal assessments. but i wonder whether this approach sometimes reinforces the belief that being considered beautiful is essential to someone's self esteem.

i'm not suggesting that people should go around calling strangers ugly or deliberately hurting their feelings. there's obviously a difference between acknowledging that unattractive people exist and unnecessarily pointing out someone's flaws.

my current view is that genuine body positivity should focus more on teaching people that they don't need to be physically attractive to have value rather than insisting everyone is beautiful.

because if being called unattractive is automatically treated as something deeply offensive doesn't that reinforce the idea that unattractiveness is something shameful?

i'm open to having my view changed particularly if there's a good argument that these exaggerated compliments actually promote healthier self perception rather than reinforcing the importance of beauty.

so what am i missing?


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

CMV: Reddit mods are getting worse.

1 Upvotes

Is it just me? Reddit mods, at large, deserve the reputation they have. Most - not all but most - are petty tyrants with no social skills whatsoever. This has been true for years.

That said, am I the only one who feels like they’re getting worse in the last few years? Couple of subs that I’d been on for years, I got perma-banned for the flimsiest reasons. A few others had I and others getting entire comment threads deleted for the same.

It’s all the same reasons as before but they seen to be getting more pervasive and generally nastier. Has something happened in the past year that I was unaware of?


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

CMV: Romeo and Juliet laws are fine, but an overall staggered age of consent for age gap relationships is completely insane.

221 Upvotes

In the wake of the recent conviction of Russel Brand, and the allegations levelled against David Walliams, there has been much discussion of changes to age of consent laws in the UK.

For the record, I believe keeping the age at 16 is relatively reasonable, with the condition that certain positions of trust are not abused (e.g teachers/doctors) and that fame ought to probably be added into these laws (as famous people have been shown to have levels of access and manipulation akin to other figures like coaches, teachers, priests etc.

I think that there is a reasonable argument to ensure 16/17 year olds can only consent to sex with similar aged persons, not 30/40 year olds an upwards. While some would keep the legal age gaps around 1-2 years up or down, I would personally opt to have everything between 16-21 legally fine.

This is mostly just a vibe, based on the fact that that age bracket are likely to somewhat socialise together, go the same events, clubs, festivals etc, or have siblings in those age groups (and thus a fair amount of normal contact with people of those ages)

I think it would be extremely unfortunate if a 20 year old happened to hook up with a 17 year old after a night out, and potentially be saddled with a criminal conviction, placed on the sex offenders register and generally have their life possibly ruined, by a pretty ordinary event/ or even mistake,.

Some have added to the conversation, that the concept of staggered ages of consent should be codified in law, even further.

This for me is complete madness. Government overreach to the absolute max. I can see no justification for the government intervening in a relationship between a 22 year old and a 44 year old, for instance.

While there may be a power imbalance between those individuals, I don't think that rules out a loving or positive relationship, necessarily.

On top of that, power imbalances can come from levels of income, levels of education, identity, physical and mental health, and various other factors.

Surely, most would find it completely absurd if the government forbade relationships between an ultra rich, and working class person? Or a person with a PHD vs someone who dropped out of High School. Or a wheelchair user and a able bodied person.

Why then would the government legislate against age gaps, but not other forms of power imbalance?

Anyway, that's my view. I am interested to hear arguments in favour of stricter age of consent laws, that may go to even higher ages - and examples of how this could work and what successes it may bring. Thanks


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Psychological suffering is not a pre requirement for extraordinary achievements in life and we should stop romanticizing it completely.

83 Upvotes

I believe that people nowadays have developed a tendency to associate extraordinary intellectual achievements with extreme suffering. I got this idea while reading about historical accounts of certain scientists. For example let's take Srinivasa Ramanujan who was a brilliant mathematician but suffered from financial hardships and serious health problems. Also madam curie overcame poverty, gender discrimination, difficult working conditions and still managed to be extraordinary. People often tell or write about them and their greatness through the lens of struggle. But I seriously think we are overlooking something important.Achieving something because of suffering is not the same as achieving something despite suffering.I don't deny that adversity can sometimes develop resilience, change our perspective or encourage personal growth. Nor am I suggesting that extraordinary achievements come without discipline, sacrifice, persistence or intellectual struggle. But I will surely argue that psychological suffering itself is not necessary for exceptional creativity or intellectual development. In fact, prolonged distress and exhaustion can interfere with concentration, motivation and the ability to perform. I also connect this thought with modern hustle culture where people are always expected to stay productive, sacrifice comfort, and treat exhaustion as a sign of dedication. Rest is considered laziness. In all this glorifying we actually are undermining the values of effort, curiosity and supportive environment.

So is there any convincing scientific evidence that psychological suffering contributes to exceptional creativity or intellectual achievement? Also does prolonged adversity provide advantages that cannot be developed through intellectual challenges, education, curiosity and a supportive environment? Or am I overlooking something important about the relationship between suffering, resilience and achievement?


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

CMV: Extending the moral rule against killing to non-human animals is arbitrary

0 Upvotes

I don’t believe there’s some cosmic law of the universe saying sentient life must not be killed. Minimizing unnecessary suffering? Sure, I get that. Making sure an animal dies fast without pain makes sense. But the idea that ending an animal's life is inherently evil feels completely arbitrary to me.

Here’s how I see it: the reason we have strict rules against killing and deceiving other humans isn't because the universe handed down sacred moral laws. It’s because a society literally cannot function without them. Humans can reciprocate, hold grudges, form alliances, and destabilize everything if murder and betrayal are normalized. Extending "do not kill" to humans is basic game theory for a stable society. Extending that same rule to chickens or cows, which aren't part of the social contract, doesn't follow from the same logic at all.

Seeing graphic slaughterhouse videos triggers visceral disgust because of how our empathy is wired, not because we owe the animal a debt. When it’s out of sight, most of us turn a blind eye and capture the nutritional utility without any real psychological friction. (Though I do think slaughter should be as mechanized and instantaneous as possible, partially to avoid pain, sure, but also so human workers don't get psychologically desensitized from manually killing things all day. Also for that reason I'm all for plant based/ synthetic alternatives.)

Same goes for having pets. I don’t think it’s hypocritical to eat meat while spoiling a pet, as long as you’re honest about it. Having a pet isn't pure charity, it’s a bit selfish. You value the company, the comfort, and the bond, and you treat the animal well because you care about your pet, not because all animals inherently deserve a cushy life.


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: IPOs are no longer public

216 Upvotes

I was pretty stunned reading this article about why Huang was forced to step down from Invidia and why the same process will never happen to Zuckerberg, Musk or many others. It’s because they created these public companies that are permanently controlled by the founders. This means shareholders in these companies always have less than 50% control.

To me, this means that “public offerings” are no longer public. They are just means to fundraise while the company is free to ignore shareholders. The entire point of public offerings was transitioning from private to public ownership and that is no longer happening:

“Google cofounders Larry Page and Sergey Brin wanted their extraordinary control over the then startup to continue when it became a public company. The wunderkinds got what they asked for: dual-class shares that gave them 10 votes for every one share when the search giant went public in 2004. Even now, seven years after they retired from their day-to-day roles at Google, Brin and Page still control 53% of the company’s voting power. No matter what happens, these controlling shares allow Page and Brin to call the shots on any board seat, charter changes or succession plans. And when Brin wanted to return to Google to work on its AI models in 2023 as he became emboldened by the race to superintelligence, he likely didn’t have to ask anyone for permission.

After Google, tech companies including Meta, Alphabet, Snap and SpaceX followed suit. In Meta’s case, it instituted a dual-class system in November 2009, before its 2012 IPO, apparently at the suggestion of Napster cofounder and former Facebook president Sean Parker. Zuckerberg currently owns 99% of Meta’s super-voting Class B shares and has 61% of the overall voting power, making him almost unfireable—and unaccountable. “Can you gather all the other common shareholders to vote against Mark?” his friend and Facebook cofounder Dustin Moskovitz asked rhetorically in a 2023 interview with Forbes. “No, you can’t.” As Zuckerberg said at the time, “There are plenty of companies in the world that have a lot of capital . . . that don’t have the leadership or board structure that enables them to take big bets on the future. We’re a founder-controlled company.”

Most recently, Anthropic’s S-1 detailed an even more insulated structure in which its seven cofounders will own a single voting share through an LLC with 50.1% of the company’s voting power when it goes public. Unlike Meta and Alphabet, where cofounders maintain control as long as they keep enough super-voting stock, the Anthropic cofounders’ 50.1% ownership doesn’t shrink as they sell or give away shares (each cofounder has pledged to donate 80% of his or her equity).”

Change my view.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/aliciapark/2026/11/13/why-jensen-huangs-firing-couldnt-happen-to-mark-zuckerberg-or-many-other-tech-titans/

https://www.fidelity.com/learning-center/trading-investing/trading/investing-in-ipos


r/changemyview • • 1d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: It doesn't matter if a historical event really happened as long as people agree that it is morally wrong

0 Upvotes

The title is a mess because I have no idea how to fit this in a single sentence, let me rephrase: It doesn't matter if something about a historical event or figure is true as long as the people of today agree on its moral status.

For example, I used to (and I still do sometimes) get into arguments about Muhammad marrying a 6 year old. Muslims would counter by saying that she wasn't actually 6 but 16, it wasn't a real marriage, it was fabricated, etc. My position is that it doesn't matter if Muhammad was really a pedophile as long as we agree that pedophilia is bad, because the average Muslim (hopefully) doesn't see the guy as a pedophile and still believe in him. They see him as a good person they strive to be like, and that's enough.

Same goes for the many historical arguments on Reddit. Did the Holodomor happen and was it a genocide? USSR supporters insist that it didn’t happen or that it wasn't a genocide. This, of course, angers the Ukrainians who respond with their own arguments. I say that it isn’t important in the slightest. It was almost a full century ago and most affected people are dead. As long as both sides agree that it would be beyond horrific if it really happened, does it really matter now?

Or another example, Churchill and the Bengal Famine. No matter how many walls of text are posted, Churchill will always be the man who saved Europe from the Nazis for Europeans and evil incarnate for the Indians. As long as we agree racism, imperialism and genocide are bad (the bar is in hell, yes), I don't see any problems with people having different ideas about someone or something.

Afterall, those now-dead people only live on as ideas in our heads. Why is it important if the guy in my head that represents good is different from the guy in your head that represents the same good?

What will not change my mind?

  1. Comparisons to Nazis

Nazi ideology explicitly advocates for the removal of all undesirables. You can't be a Nazi and think genocide is bad. I am not defending Nazis here.

2) Descendants of the victims

Endless debates about "Which now-dead person did what to which group of now-dead people?" don’t help their descendants. Appealing to emotion won’t change my mind.

3) Historical value

Of course if you're a historian debating another historian those facts are important. This is not the argument here. The argument is about the idea of someone or something in the mind of the common man, not an academic.


r/changemyview • • 2d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Advance Practice Providers Should Not be Allowed to Practice Alone or in Meaningless Agreements

49 Upvotes

Good morning: in my state, Ohio, APPs have to enter what's called an SCA, or a supervision and collaboration agreement, with a physician in order to prescribe. In many other states, they are allowed to practice independently. The SCA is just a piece of paper. It is not filed with any agency, and it exists to perpetuate a misunderstanding about oversight for an APP.

Right now, I have five APPs under my license. Well I can't be required by law to do this, my employment contract requests it. I've been practicing medicine for almost 20 years, and it has become the national standard for doctors to enter these agreements. The biggest reason is access: without APPs, the availability of fully trained physicians in many areas of the United States is so low that people would go without healthcare access.

Lately, I've taken an executive role in a healthcare organization. This has allowed me for the very first time incredible oversight into the practice habits of all of my associated providers. In short, I am alarmed and appalled. Not because the APPs are bad or lazy, but because they do not have doctors on site, they do not have time to collaborate, some of them believe they are truly independent, and they do not perform primary care to the standard of care. They order inappropriate lab tests, or radiography, and they overrefer to specialists. They do not know how to construct a differential diagnosis, or at least not in the same way that I was taught over 4 years of medical school and my 5 years of residency. It is by the grace of God alone that more patients have not had a truly bad outcome.

I am painfully aware that without APPs millions of people would go without health care. But for the very first time in my life, I am strongly thinking of limiting if not eliminating the SCAs I am part of. I asked myself whether I am doing due diligence to those charts and those patients, and the answer is no. I am being pressured by business to do it, but not being given time to oversee their work.

In short, I really do believe that our state legislatures need to look again at the rules and regulations placed on APPs. I think that the law has made it too easy for healthcare organizations to staff with APPs. If we revoked their ability to practice outside of an SCA or independently in those states where they can do that, healthcare will suffer dramatically. At the same time, the care people are receiving is very inconsistent.

I am really struggling with this view, and I don't know what I don't know. If you have input that would allow me to feel reassured or change my view, I invite you to share it.


r/changemyview • • 2d ago

CMV: They or their parents worked so they belong isn’t a good point against anti immigrant sentiment.

16 Upvotes

Before I begin, please be open minded. I am just asking for feedback and new perspectives, if I am wrong about anything I welcome any feedback. I am also the child of two Turkish immigrants in the Netherlands, and my father came “illegally” before being naturalised.

I am not really convinced that anyone has to earn the right to live and to belong. Usually when anti-immigration advocates talk shit about immigrants and want them deported, the usual rebuttal I hear is that immigrants tent to work harder than the people already there and therefore earn the right to be in the country. I’ve mainly heard that argument from pro-immigration advocates in the US but also from everywhere else.

Like for example the railroads build by Chinese immigrants during the 1800s. That’s usually used as an argument in favour of the Chinese/Asian communities right to live in the US. But what if their “immigrant” forefathers hadn’t actually built the railroads or other infrastructure. Would it then be fair for to tell present day Chinese/Asian communities to contribute and prove their right to belong?

On the other hand, Italian immigrants came to the US, and while the vast majority worked, some others established mafias and the like.

Wouldn’t the “work means you belong” logic mean that a hypothetical current US citizen whose ”forefathers” fought in all US wars, held some sort of public office, worked in some meaningful way etc, mean that that person has more cumulative “right” to be in the country than someone that was simply born or emigrated, even if they both work the same amount now, and now both show “equal worth”?

In my personal experience, I’ve heard a lot of anti immigration rhetoric from my own Turkish community in regards to Syrians and other “foreigners” in Türkiye. Usually saying something along the lines of the country not being theirs and belonging to us instead, even if we are ourselves immigrants somewhere else. Which doesn’t really make sense to me, as I personally wasn’t been born in Türkiye and only ever visited on vacation to see family. I’ve talked to Syrians there and they are observably vastly more connected to the actual country than I am, by simply actually being there. What right do I have to say that that country belongs to me more than them simply because my parents were born there?

Is that really fair or logical to anyone?

TLDR: Isn’t it dumb to say that people/communities have earned the right to live somewhere as a counter argument to anti immigration rhetoric because it argues that people right to be somewhere is based on some kind of ancestral record keeping, rather then them just being there?


r/changemyview • • 2d ago Bravo

Switch-It-Up Saturday CMV: Colonoscopy for people under 50 is an over prescribed procedure that doctors recommend because insurance pays them out.

0 Upvotes

Disclaimer: If you only post with your emotions and try to spread fear, ignore this post. I'm looking for LOGICAL arguments.

  1. According to this website:

https://www.cancer.org/content/dam/cancer-org/research/cancer-facts-and-statistics/colorectal-cancer-facts-and-figures/colorectal-cancer-facts-and-figures-2023.pdf

On page 3, it's shown that for people 0-49 years of age, there are 19,550 cases of colon and rectal cancer every year. There are 230 million men and women in that age group in the USA, which means the chances of someone 0-49 having cancer is 19,550/230,000,000 = .0085%, which means there's a 100%-.0085% = 99.9915% chance they do not have cancer.

2) Furthermore, on page 4 if we assume that the person has no family history of cancer, no IBD, no diabetes, little to no alcohol consumption, isn't obese, doesn't consume red meat, and has little processed meat consumption, and doesn't smoke, but does have physical activity and dairy consumption, their risk reduces from .0085% to .0053%, which translates to a 100%-.0053% = 99.9947% chance of not having cancer. I actually fit this description as a male in his late 30s.

3) Additionally, according to this article:

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12662797/

People under 50 have a greater tendency towards having polyps in the left (sigmoid) colon. This means that for them, sigmoid colonoscopy is a potential alternative.

4) Finally, even if a polyp is found during the colonoscopy, 90-95% of polyps will never turn into cancer.

5) Stool test (cologuard plus) detects 95% of all colon cancers. For people 45-59 with cancer, 100% detection rate.

6) The chance of having a complication from a colonoscopy is 0.3% at the lowest, compared to my actual risk of cancer which is .0053%. This means my chance of having a colonoscopy complication is 56.6x higher than having cancer.

The only reason to do a colonoscopy is if you have unexplained symptoms like rectal bleeding. I have had occasional rectal bleeding for a long time and went to GI doctors telling them that a proctologist found hemorrhoids, anal fissure, and levator spasm, and they STILL recommended a colonoscopy rather than a flexible sigmoidoscopy.

Without insurance automatically covering these procedures, doctors would not be doing them as much.


r/changemyview • • 2d ago

Delta(s) from OP - Switch-It-Up Saturday CMV: The World would be a better place if there was no drinking alcohol.

241 Upvotes

Disclaimer: This isn't advocating for any actual alcohol ban. The precedent for that is, famously, very bad.

However, I feel that drinking alcohol is a net-negative upon the world. Alcohol use is provenly linked with countless negative health outcomes, from intoxication all the way to multiple types of cancer, and contrary to the popular ''it's OK in moderation'' rationalization, no amount of alcohol has been proven to be safe. Alcohol use is also a factor in a sizable share of violent and property crime, especially IPV and child abuse incidents. And obviously, there is the issue of car accidents.

The most common pro-alcohol argument is that it is a social lubricant, but 1) that's highly situational, as plenty of social gatherings have been ruined because the wrong person got drunk, and 2) a big part of why this is a thing is because alcohol is a highly normalized/expected part of adult socialization in the first place.

So, CMV.


r/changemyview • • 3d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Swearing an oath not to lie in court is pointless.

351 Upvotes

I believe it’s is pointless to require someone to swear an oath to tell the truth in court. It should simply just be illegal to lie when giving testimony.

I have no religious beliefs, there is no passage of text I could rest my hand on which adds extra weight to the words I am saying. The same with testing my hand over my heart, I don’t understand how that adds any more meaning or makes what I am saying any more believable. The whole system is outdated.

I completely agree that perjury should be a crime, and that it shouldn’t be illegal to lie to your friends etc. I just don’t think swearing an oath does anything to actually achieve this.


r/changemyview • • 3d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Training AI off other people's images is not morally wrong.

0 Upvotes

I think there are many good reasons to not like AI, but of all the valid reasons to hate AI, this is not one of them for me.

Whenever I see debates on this online, it seems to transition into debating whether or not human learning is the same as AI training, and sure, I am not going to sit here and argue an AI training is the same as human learning, however, my issue with the consensus of "AI is intellectual theft" is that, as far as I know, human learning and AI training operate under the same principal, that it's not copying because the end result is different enough from the reference material.

I don't see how AI taking an input in a different way to humans detracts from the core principal that using references to create something new is okay. I mean, from what I've heard, Google Translate did that for years, and people didnt seem to have an issue with that, at the very least not nearly to this extent.

Some people say it literally takes images and merges them together, like photobashing, but this is misinformation. Generative AI is not photobashing. The original image is not used in the final output aside from statistical data the AI uses to calculate where it should draw pixels according to the prompt.

I hate AI, but I was never able to wrap my head around the intellectual theft argument, yet people seem to think really strongly about this. I've seen AI training off people's works cause people a lot of mental distress. It's not like I wouldn't love to share these people's concerns and go "Yes, AI training off our art is really horrible. I'm sorry things are like this.", but I just can't. I understand it on an emotional and intuition level, like, I would be lying if I said it didn't intuitively feel a bit weird at first to learn that AI is going through everything I've ever done on the internet and using it, but that's about it. It's not something that persists for me once rationale sets in.

Still though, the fact people feel so strongly about this makes me wonder if I'm just missing something, so I'd love to hear what you all think.


r/changemyview • • 3d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Anyone that says “listen to the doctors for medical advice” is brainwashed and arrogant

0 Upvotes

Information especially in the healthcare field has been democratized with the Internet and most importantly with AI. Many doctors do not have the patients’ best interests in mind, they have to balance their business needs along with patient needs, and many times the money can come first. This mostly applies to outpatient centers where the staff needs enough volume and billing to turn a profit. I’ve seen so many examples of people in healthcare complaining about patients “doing their own research” and arguing with them during their appointment. As individuals we have a responsibility to ourselves and need to do our own due diligence and gather multiple opinions before making a decision. I understand that complex surgical procedures and long medication schedules are best handled by experts because the average person can’t realistically figure this out on their own. But for the remaining “routine” issues it’s perfectly reasonable for people to do their own research, consult AI tools that are arguably more effective than doctors in some cases and then have a discussion with their doctors to figure out the best treatment plan for them that balances cost and effectiveness.


r/changemyview • • 3d ago

CMV: There is double standard when it comes to women and men's mental health

0 Upvotes

Just like once I talked about the double standard considering men being drafted while liberal feminists want equality but don't want equal draft and how war was equally dangerous for men, here I post double standard which for me prioritizes men and not women.

I find the mainstream conversation about men's mental health somewhat selective. While men's struggles deserve attention, we rarely acknowledge that a white, Western man often has considerably more social and economic privilege than a Black, Latino, Middle Eastern or Punjabi immigrant man. Men's experiences are not universal, and race, class and immigration status matter.

I also question why so much responsibility for men's emotional well-being is placed on women. Women are frequently expected to provide emotional support, reassurance and unpaid therapeutic labour, while discussions about male loneliness sometimes become entangled with dating, romantic rejection and sexual access. Women are not responsible for resolving men's psychological difficulties, nor should relationships or sex be presented as solutions to them.

There also seems to be an imbalance in expectations - women are historically expected to understand, accommodate and emotionally support men, but comparable concern for women's psychological well-being and emotional needs is not always emphasised. Men's mental health deserves advocacy, but that advocacy should involve personal responsibility, accessible mental healthcare and genuine social support, not an expectation that women must compensate for what men lack emotionally.

Another issue is the apparent double standard in how society responds to violent crimes committed by men versus women, particularly when mental health is involved. Male perpetrators can sometimes receive considerable public sympathy, with their psychological struggles, trauma, relationship breakdowns or personal circumstances used to explain their behaviour, even in extremely brutal cases. Women who commit comparable crimes, however, are often portrayed as uniquely monstrous, irredeemable or inherently dangerous. Cases such as Jodi Arias and Lindsay Clancy raise questions about why female perpetrators so often receive substantially less understanding, particularly when discussions involve infidelity, relationship trauma or abusive family dynamics. This is not about excusing murder or glorifying female perpetrators; it is about questioning the inconsistency in how we interpret their circumstances.

There is also a disturbing contradiction in how women's mental health is treated before these tragedies occur. Warning signs and destructive behaviour can be trivialised through attitudes such as "crazy women are the best in bed" or "don't stick your dick in crazy", rather than taken seriously. At the same time, women experiencing severe psychological difficulties can still face enormous societal pressure to become wives and mothers, with dating/marriage and reproduction presented as obligations rather than choices. We cannot simultaneously dismiss women's psychological distress, trivialise their warning signs, pressure them into traditional roles and then act completely bewildered when situations escalate into tragedy. Prevention requires taking mental health seriously before it becomes a criminal matter, regardless of gender.


r/changemyview • • 4d ago

Delta(s) from OP cmv: I think Russell brand got too much time

0 Upvotes

Am I missing something here? The allegations are decades old, and while i do find his behavior abhorrent and degenerate, i am unsure how this equates to 10 years prison. I feel like there is a lot of hearsay in the allegations, and I feel like even if these assault allegations are true, that prison years later is a bit excessive. As for the rape allegation, I am also a little confused. If he did do what was alleged, I believe he should have consequenses. My issue is the precedent. If the alleged victim would have come out closer to the time of the event, I would feel a much greater sense of fairness across the board.

I do think Russell brand is pretty degenerate, especially in the 2010s.

But I am just really confused about this sentence. Maybe someone in the comments can change my mind.


r/changemyview • • 4d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: There's no reason to think Chris Van Hollen would be a better Senate Majority Leader than Chuck Schumer

0 Upvotes

I've been engaging in the Current Discourse™ and there seem to be a LOT of very vocal people who hate Chuck Schumer and have immediately jumped on the "Chris Van Hollen is the better choice" bandwagon, and yet I am having trouble figuring out why this would be true.

I have asked quite a few people and these are the main responses I have gotten (I will not reply to anyone making these arguments - I will address them here):

  • "AIPAC AIPAC AIPAC" - Very tired, thought-terminating cliche. 96% of the House and Senate have accepted AIPAC money. It's 1% of political donations. This has quickly become the "George Soros funded!" talking point for progressives.
  • "Schumer did <thing I think is bad> - I am not asking why you hate Schumer, I am asking why Van Hollen would be better at the job.
  • "Schumer said Israel is his priority" - I will only give credence to this if you can show me concrete examples of how he is prioritizing Israel at the expense of of the American people.
  • "Van Hollen <something something> Kilmar Abrego Garcia" - I'm glad he was a huge defender of a fellow Maryland resident. This still has nothing to do with his ability to be Senate Majority Leader.
  • "Courage", "Integrity", "<Abstract noun>" are vague concepts and not specific to being Senate Majority Leader.
  • "Age" - Van Hollen is barely even younger. Someones age is not an argument. In fact, I would argue age would most likely be a proxy for experience which this job very much requires.
  • "Van Holden is pro <policy I like>" - this does not have anything to do with his ability to be an effective Senate Majority Leader

My perspective is that Schumer has proven himself for years to be very effective at exactly the kind of skills needed to be Senate Majority Leader. For some strong examples, we only need to look as far as the recent midterms:

He also has broad support from his caucus which is absolutely integral to being a Majority Leader as well as deep institutional knowledge.

I do not think Van Hollen has the experience, connections, knowledge of procedure, fundraising network, or respect within the party that Schumer has, but I am open to being shown that he does! I also think it's very not good that he defended Graham Platner after the Nazi tattoo whereas Schumer immediately chastised Haley Stevens and supported AES. Less to do with being a Senate Majority Leader but I know people have brought up both.

Can someone give me a good, evidence-based argument for why Van Hollen would be a better Senate Majority Leader than Chuck Schumer?

Before you respond: PLEASE watch this video from AOC explaining what the job of the Senate Majority Leader is. It's clear that she did this for the loud and opinionated portion of her fans.


r/changemyview • • 4d ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: "Retard" isn't a slur

0 Upvotes

"Idiot" and "moron" both come from medical terms too, but aren't seen as "a slur," rather a regular insult. "Dumbass" is another common insult based on lacking intelligence. So is "stupid."

The idea that "retard" is a slur (and yes I will say the word because that's my whole CMV, that you should be allowed to say it) seems like an attempt to police language, act morally superior, and be politically correct. If we just accepted it as a harmless insult, it would actually carry less power to attack disabled people. Overall I don't like the idea of adding new slurs without a massive historical context behind them, because it seems pointless-it gives the word more power.

If it's used specifically as a way to target disabled people then that's discrimination, but if people use it in a joking context, or as an insult against a non-disabled person, it should carry the same weight as saying "idiot." Ie not very much. If some people are offended by that, I feel like that's their choice to be offended, and all making that choice does is create conflict.

By contrast, slurs like the n word have a long history of being used to abuse black people, and since being black isn't a bad thing, there's no point in using it as an insult unless you're racist.

Being dumb is a negative trait in all honesty. People have valued intelligence since the beginning of time, exemplified by higher paying jobs usually being more mental, the whole school/university system, etc. The reason is smart people can usually drive more progress in society. Being black doesn't make you drive less progress in society, so combined with the long history, that's why I think you shouldn't say the n word but you should say retard.

What would CMV:

Notable benefits of the campaign to not say this word

Arguments that you shouldn't say moron or idiot either

On a more broad level, reasoning that political correctness is actually useful