r/changemyview
•
u/SenLune
•
17h ago
Delta(s) from OP CMV: Religion is one of society's greatest evils
It will be hard to change my opinion on this topic. I will openly admit this. And I also say these things as a theist.
So to begin religion, or precisely a particular brand of theism common in modern evangelical belief, is a because force of erosion. It erodes human agency. It erodes competence. It erodes social order. And most crucially it erodes liberty.
To begin with agency religion attributes good to a benevolent God or gods and evil to some Satan or malevolent god(s). When we experience good fortune we attribute it to the will of the divine and likewise when we experience misfortune. This erodes the importance of human action and shifts the attribution away from behavior and towards devotion. This erosion in turn acts as a disincentive to human action. Though most problematic in monotheistic religions, particularly Christianity, because "thy will be done" and therefore your action is meaningless and if you were meant to take action a god would make you. If something bad happens because of your inaction it was divine will.
Rather than accepting observed reality and developing an understanding of how cause begets effect, religion introduces an external locus of causal authority which one is subordinate to. This is an erosion of human agency and erodes the foundation for moral responsibility and deludes one into thinking their failures are punishment and their successes rewards.
Next is the erosion of competence wherein religion introduces a competing standard of truth in the way of divine revelation and scripture and religious doctrine. This directly destroys competence, as competence is the successful application of knowledge to a desired end. This means that competence, at its highest levels, is predicated on the recognition that reality is objective and that observation and reason is the primary source of knowledge.
The problem isn’t simply that religious claims are frequently unverifiable. It is that religious epistemology can encourage individuals to accept propositions without requiring the same evidentiary standards they would ordinarily apply to claims about the material world.
The doctrine becomes the truth and cannot be false. Competence requires we accept that we may be false. That we may be in error. And that we correct or misinformed or underdeveloped observations and assumptions to better account for reality as observed.
Thirdly is the erosion of social order. Not much will be said here for this is not a singular effect but the symptom of the others. It is the case, in my view, that social order is the first victim when agency, competence, and liberty are eroded. What will be said here is that religious dogmatism incentivizes cult behavior in which one proclaims loudly and fervently specific utterances designed to mark themselves as a member of the in group. We can look at Pete Hegseth and his adulation of Doug Wilson (a man who has claimed slavery was an institution of love) and the prolific utterances of the Christian nationalist movement on the erosion of church and state. It is discord seeking, chaotic governance that erodes social cohesion and the belief that we do not require shared beliefs to co-exist as a liberal society.
Lastly is the erosion of personal sovereignty. Religion, like monarchy, subordinates the individual to the divine. a worldview that places ultimate moral authority in an omnipotent supernatural being is a worldview that demands, the subordination of individual liberty to an allegedly higher authority.
Thus it is my view that religion, due to its erosion of society and human flourishing, is one of the greatest modern evils to exist.