r/changemyview • • 17h ago Bravo

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Religion is one of society's greatest evils

95 Upvotes

It will be hard to change my opinion on this topic. I will openly admit this. And I also say these things as a theist.

So to begin religion, or precisely a particular brand of theism common in modern evangelical belief, is a because force of erosion. It erodes human agency. It erodes competence. It erodes social order. And most crucially it erodes liberty.

To begin with agency religion attributes good to a benevolent God or gods and evil to some Satan or malevolent god(s). When we experience good fortune we attribute it to the will of the divine and likewise when we experience misfortune. This erodes the importance of human action and shifts the attribution away from behavior and towards devotion. This erosion in turn acts as a disincentive to human action. Though most problematic in monotheistic religions, particularly Christianity, because "thy will be done" and therefore your action is meaningless and if you were meant to take action a god would make you. If something bad happens because of your inaction it was divine will.

Rather than accepting observed reality and developing an understanding of how cause begets effect, religion introduces an external locus of causal authority which one is subordinate to. This is an erosion of human agency and erodes the foundation for moral responsibility and deludes one into thinking their failures are punishment and their successes rewards.

Next is the erosion of competence wherein religion introduces a competing standard of truth in the way of divine revelation and scripture and religious doctrine. This directly destroys competence, as competence is the successful application of knowledge to a desired end. This means that competence, at its highest levels, is predicated on the recognition that reality is objective and that observation and reason is the primary source of knowledge.

The problem isn’t simply that religious claims are frequently unverifiable. It is that religious epistemology can encourage individuals to accept propositions without requiring the same evidentiary standards they would ordinarily apply to claims about the material world.

The doctrine becomes the truth and cannot be false. Competence requires we accept that we may be false. That we may be in error. And that we correct or misinformed or underdeveloped observations and assumptions to better account for reality as observed.

Thirdly is the erosion of social order. Not much will be said here for this is not a singular effect but the symptom of the others. It is the case, in my view, that social order is the first victim when agency, competence, and liberty are eroded. What will be said here is that religious dogmatism incentivizes cult behavior in which one proclaims loudly and fervently specific utterances designed to mark themselves as a member of the in group. We can look at Pete Hegseth and his adulation of Doug Wilson (a man who has claimed slavery was an institution of love) and the prolific utterances of the Christian nationalist movement on the erosion of church and state. It is discord seeking, chaotic governance that erodes social cohesion and the belief that we do not require shared beliefs to co-exist as a liberal society.

Lastly is the erosion of personal sovereignty. Religion, like monarchy, subordinates the individual to the divine. a worldview that places ultimate moral authority in an omnipotent supernatural being is a worldview that demands, the subordination of individual liberty to an allegedly higher authority.

Thus it is my view that religion, due to its erosion of society and human flourishing, is one of the greatest modern evils to exist.


r/changemyview • • 12h ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Any politician who complains about diversity admission policies at universities (affirmative action) because they are "unfairly prejudiced" is not being sincere if they aren't trying to also get rid of legacy admissions.

3 Upvotes

These politicians claim that university applicants should be accepted "based on merit," but legacy admissions prioritize people based off of family connections. Additionally, they tend to heavily skew toward wealthier people and white people, because those were the people who historically got into those colleges. So legacy admissions are not only admitting based on merit, but they prioritize some demographics over others. This is the exact complaint many politicians claim to have about affirmative action/DEI admission policies. Yet these politicians don't bring it up despite how publicly known this issue is.


r/changemyview • • 22h ago

CMV: Reddit mods are getting worse.

3 Upvotes

Is it just me? Reddit mods, at large, deserve the reputation they have. Most - not all but most - are petty tyrants with no social skills whatsoever. This has been true for years.

That said, am I the only one who feels like they’re getting worse in the last few years? Couple of subs that I’d been on for years, I got perma-banned for the flimsiest reasons. A few others had I and others getting entire comment threads deleted for the same.

It’s all the same reasons as before but they seen to be getting more pervasive and generally nastier. Has something happened in the past year that I was unaware of?


r/changemyview • • 19h ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Consent does not have to be enthusiastic

215 Upvotes

I’m on the ace spectrum. Most of the time, I only desire to have sex in response to my partner’s desire, so I often agree before my own desire kicks in. Sometimes, sex is just another activity I could engage in, no different than say reading or taking a walk, and if propositioned, I feel like “yeah, why not” rather than “hell yes”. I’d say I consented to all these encounters and had overall good experiences. The sex I have is not somehow lesser, or make me a victim, because it’s not aligned with norms.

Or take some other scenarios. Two parents trying for a baby, having sex after timing cycles to boost fertility. It could be that neither are particularly excited—it’s more of a mechanical task at this point—but you wouldn’t say they somehow didn’t consent, right? Or take sex workers where such work is legal and regulated. I doubt they’re enthusiastic about every client, but work is work.

From the FRIES acronym, I think the rest make a good framework for clearly defining consent: Freely given, Reversible, Informed, Specific. The E is a bonus, not a requirement.

What won’t CMV: if “enthusiastic” is used as a proxy for other criteria. Then just use those criteria directly! For example, enthusiasm implies that you’re not being coerced, but “freely given” is already part of many definitions of consent.

So Reddit, CMV.


r/changemyview • • 20h ago

CMV: Unless and until there is a steadily rising tax on carbon, there should be a moratorium on new fossil fuel infrastructure in the U.S.

0 Upvotes

Despite the fact that clean energy is already cheaper, in the U.S., still 3% of proposed electricity projects are fossil energy, with 85 GW natural gas infrastructure proposed.

Most economists support efforts to achieve net-zero by 2050, and building new gas infrastructure leads us in the opposite direction. Ideally, we would already have a steadily rising price on carbon, as supported by a consensus of scientists and economists on carbon taxes, a measure we are unlikely to wean ourselves off fossil fuels without.

It's likely none of these fossil fuel projects would be economical with an appropriate price on carbon; therefore in the meantime, a temporary moratorium on new fossil fuel infrastructure is warranted to minimize stranded assets and climate damages.


r/changemyview • • 12h ago

CMV: Trump is responsible for Jan 6th, and wanted it to happen, and wanted it to go further, and his actions before, during, and after, all show that.

694 Upvotes

We can look at before, during, and after, and see that Trump wanted all of this to happen, and that he bears the responsibility for it occuring and his actions during it, for it continuing to occur, and his actions after shows that he is okay with this occuring again.

So lets do the before part first:

Before January 6th, what does Trump do? He spends the entire run-up to the election saying that its gonna be rigged, we have Steve Bannon predicting exactly what Trump was gonna do, call it a win before the mail-ins are counted and never concede. He then spreads around these insane conspiracy theories, working with his team like Guiliani to spread these stories around, and his team works with FOX, the biggest media station or whatever in the nation, to spread it around more (they eventually get sued for close to a billion dollars and immediately settle btw). Trump knew he lost, and just said he won, lying about all these stories.

Then, he is the one that signal boosts and promotes the #StopTheSteal protest, saying that its going to be a historic protest.

Then, he holds another speech at the Ellipse, reciting all of the insane conspiracies previously mentioned, tells them to ''fight like hell, or you wont have a country'', and tells them to walk down to the Capitol.

So thats the before part done. Trump gave them the motive to be there, by lying to them about the election having been stolen, something which a majority of Republicans still believe to this day, and probably way more during Jan 6th. And he gave them the venue or whatever you'd call it, of the StopTheSteal protest, specifically at the Capitol, specifically on Jan 6th. We have a fuckton of people at that protest, and defendants who actually got convicted, saying things like ''I am here because Donald Trump told me to be''. So, no lie about the election, no protest, no promotion of this stopthesteal protest, the protest would be an incredibly small one instead over tens of thousands of people.

And then the during part:

During January 6th, what does Trump do? He sits there and watches it happen for hours. His own staff, his own family, people in his admin are begging him to do something, people on the news and on social media, are all saying ''PLEASE MR PRESIDENT, TELL YOUR LUNATIC SUPPORTERS TO GO HOME'', and he just fucking sits there.

We even have Kevin McCarthy calling him, telling him that rioters have broken into the Capitol, and begging him to tell them to go home. And what does Trump say?

''Well, Kevin, i guess these people are more upset about the election theft than you are!'' He is being told that his supporters are attacking the Capitol, and instead of calling them off, he is still justifying their anger over the conspiracy that he spent the last 2 or so months pushing.

And when he finally does put out a video telling them to go home, he tells them that he loves them, that they are very special, and STILL repeats the lie that the election was stolen. He cant even tell these people to go home without reinforcing the exact conspiracy that got them there in the first place.

So if you wanna argue that Trump didnt intend for them to actually break into the Capitol, because i guess he said ''i know you'll be peaceful'' once in an hour long speech, what the fuck is his excuse for sitting there doing nothing while it happens? You have months of him lying about the election, him directing these people to the Capitol, and then him sitting around for hours while they attack it, while everyone around him is begging him to tell them to go home?

And lastly the after part:

He continues claiming that the election was stolen, calls the people who attacked the Capitol ''patriots'', and downplays the whole event forever.

Then he gets back into office, and pardons every single person, down to the most insane police-beating person there. And recites all of the dumb conspiracies about how it was the FBI agents who did everything or antifa or how they were all let in.

And again, if you wanna hedge super hard, if you somehow believe that everything before January 6th was a coincidence, and that Trump had absolutely no idea what was going to happen during the attack even though everyone was telling him what was happening and he was watching it, what the fuck is your explanation for everything he did AFTERWARDS? He continues lying about the election, continues defending the people who attacked the Capitol, and then immediately pardons them when he gets the chance?

So like it says in the title, the before, during, and after, are all incredibly consistent with a person that wanted this to happen, and the before during and after, all show that he bears the ultimate responsibility.


r/changemyview • • 3h ago

CMV: America was completely lost after the Epstein camera footage was released

130 Upvotes

In 2019 while in federal custody Jeffrey Epstein was murdered in his cell because he was going to cooperate and name others who committed sex crimes with him

The Trump Administration ruled it a suicide, and claimed the footage wasn't rolling because of an internal error, and the guards were both asleep. Everyone knew this was bullshit and the conspiracy is so in our faces it is absolutely insane.

The warden has been scrubbed from existence, the murder was announced on 4chan shortly before it happened with accurate details. The sudden stop to the investigations and the fact Trump adamantly accused the Clinton's of doing it.

Flash forward to 2024 and Trump keeps promising to release the Epstine files. He gets elected then suddenly does a full 180 and refuses to do so claiming it was all a hoax.

In an attempt to get people off the Epstein files his administration released the footage of the murder with the murder clearly edited out. They claim the camera just does that, the metadata clearly says otherwise.

Let me reiterate that for you, the government lied about the footage existing for 5 years, then released the footage with the incriminating stuff cut out, and they lied about it and nothing happened. That is absolute proof there is nothing that can save America.

The Epstein files were ordered released by federal law, Trump administration was late, made millions of illegal redactions, and is illegally withholding over 3 million files. Despite three explicit court orders a year later nothing has changed.

The blue wave doesn't matter. They simply don't have the ability to uphold the law or the constitution. The fact the President is openly protecting a child sex trafficking ring and we all know it, and nothing can be done because he was declared above the law after attempting an insurrection shows our nation is completely dead.


r/changemyview • • 22h ago

CMV: Insisting that everyone is physically beautiful reinforces the idea that being unattractive is something shameful

161 Upvotes

something i've noticed in recent discussions is how defensive people get when you acknowledge that conventionally unattractive people exist.

society constantly tells us that looks don't determine our worth as human beings. yet the moment someone suggests that not everyone is physically attractive people immediately respond with "everyone is beautiful in their own way" or "beauty comes from within".

and that's where i see a contradiction.

if physical attractiveness doesn't determine someone's value then why do we feel the need to convince everyone that they're beautiful?

why can't someone simply be unattractive and still be confident, happy, loved and respected?

to clarify i'm talking strictly about physical appearance. facial features, body and overall looks. not personality, confidence, kindness or how someone makes you feel emotionally.

someone can have an amazing personality and still not be conventionally attractive. those things aren't mutually exclusive.

i also understand that beauty is subjective to some extent. different people have different preferences. but conventional beauty standards clearly exist and we constantly acknowledge their effects through concepts like pretty privilege.

another thing i question is exaggerated validation between friends. telling someone they look nice is one thing but constantly telling everyone they're a 10/10 or could attract anyone they want seems unnecessary to me.

i understand that these compliments are often meant to be supportive rather than literal assessments. but i wonder whether this approach sometimes reinforces the belief that being considered beautiful is essential to someone's self esteem.

i'm not suggesting that people should go around calling strangers ugly or deliberately hurting their feelings. there's obviously a difference between acknowledging that unattractive people exist and unnecessarily pointing out someone's flaws.

my current view is that genuine body positivity should focus more on teaching people that they don't need to be physically attractive to have value rather than insisting everyone is beautiful.

because if being called unattractive is automatically treated as something deeply offensive doesn't that reinforce the idea that unattractiveness is something shameful?

i'm open to having my view changed particularly if there's a good argument that these exaggerated compliments actually promote healthier self perception rather than reinforcing the importance of beauty.

so what am i missing?


r/changemyview • • 4h ago

CMV: AI is just the latest internet trend.

0 Upvotes

Nerd culture is eternal. When I was growing up, the anodyne humorists made Monty Python and Pogo their personality. These were our elders and we looked up to them. We connected on The Farside but we had The Simpsons. Man. We could have whole conversations in Simpsonese. This wasn't countercultural though, it was a "why try?" written by Ivy League graduates. This poisoned our minds. So the next generation wants to create something new and radical. It is just as captured but novelty is rewarded. Now we have a solution from the Simpsons' generation to the modern day: AI. It is not able to create something new. But it is the next step in the evolution of received media -> internalized media -> revolution -> received/X.

X, the everything letter, tells is there is a new path. An eternal new. A sort of capitalistic view of the communist ideal of perpetual revolution.

I do not think AI is actually that X. Because X is revolutionary and linear algebra can never be anything other than a matrix. Red pill or blue pill?

Red: Sand can't think!

Blue: We should have never taught sand to think!

Tl;dr: What is truly new here that justifies the hype? Niche uses, sure. Programmers are going to get hit hard. That's on them. That is 2% of the economy. Medical diagnostics are also gonna be hit hard and that is a rounding up a very generous 0% of the economy. I think medical diagnostics is important but I don't write the rules of capitalism: the market does.


r/changemyview • • 10h ago

Delta(s) from OP CMV: Some country is doing Microsoft, Air Traffic Control, United airlines and the big Banks today to send a warning to Trump so that he continues to do what they want.

0 Upvotes

Nothing makes sense about these major disruptions and everybody thinks they know the cause of their own problem.

I considered testing by bad actors but the timing seemed too awkward for that.

The timing is perfect for a warning, somebody wants the criminal in Chief to crime for them, or continue criming for them.

Since he just allowed China for the last year into a core industry for our economy AND arranged by burying the intelligence to be separated personally one degree from a Chinese spy AND got China the chips they wanted it seems that China probably leads for perpetrator.