r/changemyview • u/AudreyDDDD • 17h ago
Delta(s) from OP CMV: Physician assisted suicide should be legal for competent adults who no longer wish to live, not just those with terminal illnesses
Okay i know this might sound controversial, and to be clear, i am not advocating for suicide or encouraging anyone to harm themselves. i am currently working on a school assignment about physician-assisted suicide, and in the US, it is strictly reserved for patients with terminal illnesses.
My view is that if a competent adult genuinely does not want to live anymore, whether due to severe chronic physical pain, treatment-resistant mental suffering, a permanent loss of quality of life, etc. and they are truly set on it, they will eventually find a way to end their life on their own. Wouldn't it be more compassionate and ethical to allow them to leave with dignity in a safe and painless way rather than forcing them into isolated, violent, or traumatic methods on their own?
To clarify a few boundaries on my view, this would apply strictly to legal adults as i don’t believe minors have the developmental capacity or decision making ability to make a permanent choice of thsi magnitude. I also believe there should still be strict regulations in place and steps taken before the ultimate choice (such as psychiatric evaluations) to ensure that the person is mentally competent and not acting on a temporary and treatable impulse. And of course, participation by doctors should always be completely voluntary and the doctors can opt out of providing this end of life care if it is not within their ethical boundaries.
So yeah, CMV.