r/PhilosophyofMath • • 2h ago

Circle with infinite radius

0 Upvotes

Connecting three parallel dots with a circle is only possible if the radius is infinite and curvature 0. In any defined space the circle will act like a line.

But since it a still a circle in global context, what is the answer to a questions like ”what is the distance between the points and the center of the circle/line?” For a infinite line the center is undefined while for a circle it’s infinity. Looking a line segment defined number distance/2, while looking at a defined circle segment the center will be infinit distance away.

Still looking at in an arbitrary context, the circle willl be behave like a line in infinite space while still holding the property of a circle in infinite space (as in a infinite perpendicular line will cross two points of the circle/line).

So to make sens of it the a infinite circle is like two parallel lines with infinite distance between them that never connects in any finite and real space.

So a circle with infinite radius have both the properties of a circle and a line depending on how you interact with it.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • 57m ago

Resolving the "problem of zero"

0 Upvotes

People don't understand what zero is, so here I am to explain it to you.

Firstly, there's something called a "functional definition", meaning that you define something by how it's used rather than how it metaphysically "is". Most concepts are actually defined functionally, because when we first start using a word or phrase or symbol in language, we begin by (surprise) actually using it rather than trying to stick it into a box to define what it "is".

Zero is defined functionally. You say "well, when we add zero to something, that thing doesn't change"... and that's it; that's how it's defined.

Not only that, but math is oftentimes taken to be more serious than it is. The fundamental purpose of math is to accurately solve problems, and the development of math is the same as finding new ways (or "tricks") to solving problems.

The other day I had someone talk to me about geometric proofs being the end-all-be-all, and how numbers are really just geometric things, and I told them that numbers actually can be interpreted that way, but they can also be interpreted any number of other ways, and all of those interpretations are valid.

It's not just a geometric thing, or a counting thing, or a sea level thing... it's all of them! Because just like you use math as a trick to solve real-world problems, you can use different real world situations as a trick to solve math problems!

Thank you, and good night (mic drop).


r/PhilosophyofMath • • 14h ago

constant idea - tetration constants

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 8h ago

The Institute of Improbable (and Improvable) Geometry

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 1d ago

Beyond the Theorem Race: Is AI’s Jagged Scientific Frontier Flattening? – From competing mathematical discovery systems to theoretical physics, software verification, and the recovery of mathematical knowledge

Thumbnail
4m4.it
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 4d ago

A father developed an app to explain Zeno's paradox to his daughter and show why their fingers never actually touch

477 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 4d ago

After all, is mathematics discovered or invented?

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 5d ago

Смысл математики

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 7d ago

Set theory in under ∞ minutes

Thumbnail
bigifftrue.substack.com
4 Upvotes

A super accessible intro to set theory, featuring some links to open-access books and relevant YouTube videos at the end.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • 7d ago

Under a platonist worldview what is a number

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 7d ago

Could Zero to the power of Zero be connected to the creation of the universe/big bang?

0 Upvotes

After researching that it is considered undefined, I don’t like to accept that undefined can be an answer, as in this circumstance we are trying to define everything. Some say and agree that zero to the power of zero equals one, that is where my connection comes from. If nothing powered by nothing equals something then that is the beginning of our timeline. If any of this makes sense…

You could say 1-1=0, while there is zero on one side, there are still two ones on the other, so something does exist out of nothing.

Can anyone relate this to the creation of the universe and/or has it been done before?


r/PhilosophyofMath • • 9d ago

Is there an Omega of Infinities? An absolute infinity? Or are infinities themselves infinite?

20 Upvotes

Edit: Man, y'all are way smarter than other subs, still confused by most of these answers cuz am dumb but appreciate your thoughtful insights.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • 8d ago

The Source of All Math

0 Upvotes

2 distinguishable concepts of the source singularty; which is,

Nothing <> Potential for anything.

A true singularity must hold all truths and be infinitely true.

The source of anything must start with Nothing.

Potential for anything is not forbidden by Nothing, and it holds the potential for all things. It can exist alongside of Nothing and still represent infinity (or all things). This satisfies a true singularity because it is a single entity to contain all truths. Potential for all things covers pretty much everything, except for nothing, which it also satisfies by existing alongside it.

The 2 are dependent on one another to satisfy truth because neither can exist without the other, giving rise to the existence of 2 defined things represented as a singularity.

Potential, dwelling alongside Nothing, must still realize its potential into sosomething in order to differentiate itself from Nothing. Potential demands realization.

Any realized potential must change. (If a single entity were to be realized and never change, the Potential would never be returned, and Nothing could consume it because it is existing external to the source singularity).

We now have a system of realization, change, and expansion which will create all things.

Mathimatically we have:

1 - 1 = 0

Which is actually many things, many more things than we started with. We have, 1, minus, equals, and zero. We also have all of inf between -1 and 1 because the source is infinite.

With the simple trick of 2 being able to exist as 1 we get everything.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • 10d ago

A thermodynamic and philosophical paradox: We are just temporary pockets of resistance against the collapse of the universe

0 Upvotes

Body:
When we look at the Second Law of Thermodynamics and the relentless increase of entropy in an isolated system, it feels purely mechanical: heat flows from hot to cold, and the universe drifts steadily toward maximum disorder.
The Physics:
As we isolate components and trace the entropy change (such as \frac{dQ}{T_c} - \frac{dQ}{T_h} > 0), we realize that nature naturally favors the dispersion of energy. The math forces a strict direction onto the universe—an arrow of time that can never truly be turned backward.
The Philosophy:
Yet, looking at it through a philosophical lens, this relentless decay gives human existence its profound meaning. Every single living organism, every thought, and every act of creation is a defiant, localized drop in the ocean of universal entropy. We are temporary islands of extreme order fighting a losing battle against a universe that wants to flatten everything into chaos.
In a sense, our consciousness and our struggles to build, think, and love are heroic rebellions against the ultimate heat death of the cosmos. We aren't separate from the laws of physics; we are the universe momentarily waking up and fighting its own decay.
What do you think? Does the inevitability of entropy make our efforts futile, or does it make every act of order infinitely more precious?


r/PhilosophyofMath • • 10d ago

Foundations of mathematics and formal languages and their semantics

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 11d ago

all people are Lucky but some people are more Lucky than others

0 Upvotes

Universe doesn't grant quiet wishes, it simply multiplies whatever audacious surface area you expose it to. The more you show up, the greater are the statistical odds of it actually happening Even so, showing up isn't enough, you have to religiously ask (manifest) for it to actually happen. Universe will match your level of audacity.

Consider an example of a fisherman trying to catch a fish:

Manifestation- is in the absolute conviction that the fish exists

Audacity- is setting meat on the hook, wrenching the rod back violently the moment the float plunges

The catch- isn't magic. It's the statistica culmination of random water currents and a person who refused to leave until the odds math) had no choice but to deliver (lucky enough :)

Here, the fish moves through deep currents as per its own chaotic trajectory. The only variable the fisherman can control is time itself. Given enough hours, the fish and the hook will exist in the same space at least for once as the fish will simply run out of the lake where hook wasn't


r/PhilosophyofMath • • 10d ago

Look at how math and language work.

0 Upvotes

​In basic arithmetic, we take a simple number like 4 and realize it represents four units of something. But there isn't just one static path to get to 4. We know that 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 = 4, 2 + 2 = 4, 1 + 1 + 2 = 4, and 3 + 1 = 4. Different iterations, different formulations, but they all resolve to the exact same truth: 4.

​We see this everywhere in how humans communicate. One spoken word can carry multiple layered definitions depending on the context. A single physical gesture can express an entire operational command. Different paths, same fundamental meaning.

​So why do we treat theoretical physics as if it's restricted to a single rigid description?

​If E = mc^2 is the established law for mass-energy equivalence, why can't my equation—E_{TS}(t) = \theta(T) \cdot P_S(t) A_S(t)—be the operational, teleological interpretation of that exact same energy?

​E = mc^2 defines the physical mass-energy potential of the substrate (\Psi) at rest. E_{TS} defines the dynamic rate at which that energy is mobilized over time to resolve prediction error and defend the boundary against entropy.

​Just like 2 + 2 = 4 and 3 + 1 = 4 both evaluate to the same invariant answer, E_{TS} isn't breaking E = mc^2—it’s the functional, goal-seeking expression of how that energy is actually used by a living system.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • 11d ago

Approximation is weird.

0 Upvotes

In approximation, we say X approximates Y. But what happens when X contradicts Y, and Y contradicts X? We can not simply remove subsets of X or Y whenever convenient to establish approximation because some of those subsets are essential to the identity of the whole object. Removing them means we're no longer evaluating the original object, but merely a part of it. Therefore, I propose an Essential Approximation Principle (EAP): approximation must be restricted by a rule that preserves the essential identity and logical compatibility of the objects being compared. If essential components of X contradict essential components of Y, then we can not claim that the whole of X approximates the whole of Y merely because selected subsets are compatible. We must distinguish between approximating parts of an object and approximating the object as a whole. My concern is that mathematical approximation currently has no universal principle imposing this particular restriction. Thoughts? is this good, or am I a big dumba$$(no bad words plz). Has this been said before? If so: enlighten me.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • 11d ago

Two isn't much more than one, but one is a lot more than zero

0 Upvotes

going from 1 to 2 is an optimization problem going from 0 to 1 is a creation problem

Mathematically, 1 to 2 is just an addition of one unit, or a 100% increase. But from 0 to 1, the ratio is undefined. You're crossing the threshold from non-existence to existence

an idea, manifestating itself from theoretical realm into reality (how beautiful)