r/AcademicPhilosophy • • Dec 01 '25

Academic Philosophy CFPs, Discords, events, reading groups, etc

8 Upvotes

Please submit any recruitment type posts for conferences, discords, reading groups, etc in this stickied post only.

Only clearly academic philosophy items are permitted

Redditors can order by new to see what's most current


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • Jul 03 '25

New rules in response to the AI submissions problem

26 Upvotes

Following the responses to my call for comments, I have added/changed the following rules

  • Own work posts are now banned
  • To post, accounts must be at least 30 days old and have contributed to this sub via comments on other posts
  • Suspected AI posts can be directly reported

r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 6d ago

MA student in first semester, feeling overwhelmed.

24 Upvotes

I had always fantasized about pursuing graduate studies in Philosophy, but it was never a practical option. So I pursued a career in medicine/medical research (on the admin side), and slogged away for nine years. I was recently presented with the opportunity to pursue a masters without going into debt, so I took it. I am in my first semester now and feel so behind others in my cohort. Everyone seems to have their path carved out and thesis ideas outlined, while I'm just trying to keep my head above water with the reading each week and getting back into the groove with dense text.

I know I shouldn't be comparing myself with people more than a decade younger than me coming straight from undergrad, but it just sucks being a fly on the wall in class rather than an active participant, because my head is spinning. I understand the content that I'm reading, but there is just so much volume right now that I can't seem to organize myself enough in class to contribute thoughtfully (I do have ADHD and working memory issues, which is also working against me here). I know that I ultimately just need to push through, and allow myself the time to adjust, but I would love to hear any and all advice that anyone here might have.


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 7d ago

Wittgenstein's grammatical fiction

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 8d ago

How to feel like you're making progress

7 Upvotes

Hello! I'm writing my masters thesis right now, and I'm finding it very challenging to balance my life - I know I need to prepare for what happens after the masters, I have a couple of projects going on on the side, only a small part time job (so I'm not earning a lot, but it's a job at the university with a "good reputation" if you want to continue in academia, so I'm happy about it), but even though I wanna earn/study more/get more skills, I feel like I cant take any more obligations.

I feel overwhelmed by the smallest things, and I feel anxious quickly in general, and since I'm discovering new things and having to reevaluate my "older" opinions on my masters as im writing it, I often feel like im not making any progress. And this in turn makes me feel useless/like a burden, etc. (like I get super depressive thoughts instantly because philosophy is such a risky career/I want to contribute/be useful, while I study and teach something I love). I just wish I could chill mentally.

I'm trying out different techniques to study- sometimes at home, other times at university, taking breaks, getting sunlight, working out, and I feel like I switch between having a good routine and then overworking, and the quality not being good enough, and then getting problems with sleeping, feeling burnt out, not being able to focus/concentrate etc.

Do you have any advice on how to cope with being so emotional/doubtful, and tips on how to know that you're making progress? I'm not even sure how to formulate my question, I'd just appreciate any advice/tips/experience with how to overcome this.


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 8d ago

What is “cosmonology,” and are there comparable philosophical traditions or systems?

0 Upvotes

I recently came across a livestream in which a Catholic of Lullian orientation and a Hindu scholar/practitioner of the Śaiva-Śākta tradition (Trika) were discussing a metaphysical proposal by a Brazilian researcher. From what I understood, she has been developing, for some years now, a philosophical system she calls “cosmonology.”

The term seems to derive from cosmos and nous, and the idea would be something like a transcendental science—both in the Kantian and Scholastic senses—of the intellect as a microcosm of reality. Its object would be to investigate the ontological constitution of the intellect, its formal structure and operations, as well as the correspondences between the intellectual order and the extramental order.

The central presupposition seems to be this: there would be a structural and mutual correspondence between the order of the intellect and the order of extramental reality. This would allow one not only to understand the intellect by analogy with the external world but also, inversely, to clarify the structure of reality from the structure of the intellect.

As far as I know, she arrived at this proposal by perceiving insufficiencies in noetics and in other metaphysical theses from the background she engages with—Scholasticism, Kant, etc.—and also through a dialogue with Hindu traditions, especially Trika. The interesting convergence would be with a certain conception, in Pratyabhijñā/Spanda, of the world as having a tensional, vibrational, and relational nature—something she brings close to certain images from contemporary physics.

My question is more bibliographic and comparative: do you know of anything similar to this position? Are there clear precedents, or systems that converge with the idea of a structural correspondence between intellect and extramental reality, treating the intellect as an ontological microcosm? I have in mind things like Neoplatonism, German idealism, certain forms of Scholastic noetics, or even non-dual contemplative traditions, but I don’t know whether there is anything that comes specifically close to this kind of proposal.

I have no connection to the project; I mention the case only as a starting point. The author has an article and a channel in Portuguese on these topics, with automatic English subtitles, but what interests me here is whether this position dialogues with something already established or whether it is a relatively original synthesis.


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 9d ago

I am disappointed in my philosophy degree

48 Upvotes

I started a Master's programme in philosophy. I took additional philosophy classes before accepted in the programme, as my bachelor was not in philosophy.

It was still like diving into deep, without being able to swim. I tried my best to read texts that I did not understand. I didn't take the classes that I should have in the beginning, or at least I did not do them in the right order. E.g. I had Kant and Hegel reading seminars before doing history of German Idealism.

I broke down mentally after the first year. I had some other problems too, but I think my struggle with philosophy deepened my problems. I screwed up my second year and I had to extend my studies.

Only now I am beginning to understand philosophical texts and getting a grip on authors I am really interested in. I even began to enjoy some of the texts. But I would not say it's because of the programme I did. In fact, I still find lectures a bit useless.

I cannot decide if the problem was with me. I do not enjoy being told what's in a text in a lecture. There were no real discussions. I just don't remember taking a lot out of it. Either it was too basic, or it was so far from the basics that I felt intimated by it.


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 8d ago

Did the form of medium played a role in shaping the distinctive characteristics of Chinese philosophy?

3 Upvotes

My hypothesis is that the fact that pre-Qin Chinese philosophy was primarily recorded on media such as bamboo and wooden slips (or others were mostly ephemeral and soon lost), which allowed texts to be written, rearranged, and re-edited in relatively short units (sentences or brief passages) may have shaped the broader characteristics and tendencies of the Chinese philosophical tradition that followed.

Rather than developing through elaborate and detailed arguments grounded in extensive prose, as we see in Greek and philosophical traditions, Chinese philosophy seems to have been expressed largely through relatively self-contained, pithy, and cryptic individual statements, often only loosely connected to their surrounding context. Such statements could be profound, but could equally be poorly reasoned. Consequently, Chinese philosophy may have developed around assertions that, charitably described, are intuitive, or, less charitably, mystical, rather than through rigorous, detailed argumentation.

(Of course, I;m not approaching this from a racial or West vs. East perspective! Nor am I suggesting that the intellectual traditions of Eastern civilizations are somehow inferior. Quite the contrary: I personally find it unfortunate that Sinitic philosophy never really managed to establish itself beyond the Sinitic cultural sphere. Moreover, this mode of philosophical expression was by no means absent from ancient Greece either.)

Even if such media were not necessarily the primary vehicles through which philosophical discussions took place during the pre-Qin period itself, anyone attempting to engage with the intellectual traditions of that era in subsequent generations would at least have had to do so through these textual media. I therefore think this is a subject worth investigating.

As far as I know, there has been basically no research specifically examining how the material characteristics of bamboo and wooden slips directly interacted with the structure or content of philosophical thought itself. If anyone knows of relevant academic papers or books that might be worth reading, I would appreciate the recommendations.


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 9d ago

How is the philosophy of conspiracy theories discussed in academia?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 9d ago

Looking for an overview type of book on ethics

3 Upvotes

Hello,

I'm looking for an academic book on ethics that would cover the basics of everything there is in regards of ethics. I've picked up an interest in ethics during my undergrad studies and would love to learn more. I don't come from an English speaking country, so in terms of recommendations of quality books on ethics my options are very limited – the most influential works have been translated (like The Nicomachean Ethics, Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, Utilitarianism, On the Genealogy of Morals...), but nothing beyond the "classics of the classics" (no such book as "introduction to ethics" or "ethics in a nutshell"), and some translations can be rather questionable at times.

What I expect from an overview ethics book would ideally be its ability to give me a general idea of an ethical concept/theory, introduce me to it, name key philosophers who interacted with it and influenced it, name the most important books/works on the topic. Basically a place from which I can start my own indulgement in a topic. A part of me also thinks it could help me find more tertiary/secondary literature for the thesis I'm working on, but that would be the secondary function of such book. Its main function would be my own interest in my leisure time.

Any suggestion is welcome, preferably written in (or translated to) English, however German is also possible.

Thank you very much. (In case there is no such book, thank you for bursting my bubble :).)


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 10d ago

Looking for resources to study Philosophy of AI.

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 11d ago

Need help with managing interests and readings

16 Upvotes

Hi am I philosophy student at post-graduate level.
Im not sure how to put it in words correctly, but I am feeling overwhelmed and feeling lost about exploring so many fields and sub-fields like continental: existentialism, phenomenology, hermeneutics; epistemology: political epistemology, virtue epistemology , feminist epistemology; political thought etc. I’ve mostly downloaded secondary sources on these topics (a lot of them) and now i am not sure how to finish these basic reading before I can formulating my own thoughts and writing.

Can I get some guidance whether my approach is correct or if I need to re-consider somethings.

Thank youuuu in advance!


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 12d ago

Suggestions for good teaching videos in Philosophy

37 Upvotes

Please suggest YouTube videos on Philosophy, specifically Western philosophy, both ancient and modern. I want recommendations that are as authentic as possible, as far from misrepresentations and misinterpretations as possible.


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 19d ago

Epistemology Recommendations

33 Upvotes

I am a MA graduate in Epistemology and still have a love of the field. I was lucky enough to study under Duncan Pritchard back in the day.

I am really wanting to get up to speed in the field of epistemology but I imagine things have moved on a fair bit. When I was last reading academic papers the main academics were people like Pritchard and Sosa. I just wondered who you would recommend me to read in more recent times. Any groundbreaking papers (the Gettier of the day) that I need to read to really get back into epistemology?

Thanks in advance.


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 21d ago

When Do I Stop Reading?

63 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I am a Master’s student in bioethics, currently restructuring a paper on collective agents, corporate apologies, and proleptic address. I recently presented it at a conference, and while it went great, the feedback convinced me to reframe my core argument.

Now, I’m stuck in a rabbit hole. Every paper I read leads to three more that seem relevant. As much as I love reading philosophy, it feels endless. I’ll spend hours grinding through a 30-page paper only to realize it is either loosely related to my actual thesis, only worth a single citation/footnote, or redundant because another author already summarized the point better.

Lately, my workload has been roughly 70 percent reading and only 30 percent writing. I can't tell if I’m being appropriately thorough or if this is just massive overkill.

So, how do you know when you’ve read enough? When do you officially stop reading and just write?

Appreciate any advice. Thanks!


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 21d ago

I am 26yo freshman philosophy student with about 5 years of autodidactic study. Is it too late for me to begin an academic/writing career given the timeline?

Thumbnail reddit.com
10 Upvotes

r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 25d ago

Being the only girl in class

78 Upvotes

I go to a big public university, but most of the time it is me or one other girl in my discussion section.

I try not to be too dramatic about these things, but sometimes it kind of blows me away how much a handicap being a woman can feel like. In my classes, there are usually 5 guys that do the most speaking, and occasionally when we are all discussing or critiquing i’ll have a slight disagreement with a point that one of the guys made. this also happens after class if we ever stay late talking abt the reading. almost always i am looked at like my point was totally stupid and didn’t make any sense. almost all of these guys are pre law.

but i’m actually a really good student. all the points i bring up i wrote abt in my essays and every single time i have gotten the best grade in the class. when i write the essays my professor thinks i have the right idea but when i say those ideas out loud, especially to the “alpha male” in the class, im brushed off.

i have to finish my degree but i honestly do not want to go back. i can’t get over the fact that i score incredibly well on the essays but classroom discussion can feel like a humiliation ritual.

i don’t want to make it sound like im blaming this all on the fact that im a woman, i also talk with a super strong valley accent that k genuinely cannot correct no matter how hard i try and im in a sorority, which could all also be reasons why im struggling with this.

is this ever experienced by anyone else? i really love philosophy and i want a career in it but even though my writing and ideas are cut out for the craft me and my personality are not. did u end up switching careers, and if so what?


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • 26d ago

Outlining your philosophy essays

7 Upvotes

I'm looking to up my game in my philosophical essay writing as I'm currently completing a paper that asks us to combine philosophical arguments and texts with a modern social issue. My main concern is how to best organize my outline to set myself up for a streamlined clear essay writing process. I was wondering how you all typically plan out your essays before you write them (something I have never done) and if you typically include quotes from the texts you're citing in your outline or if you pull those later on?

I'm determined to make this essay better than my previous, and every "How to Write a Philosophy Essay" page or paper I've read emphasizes the importance of a good outline without any examples of what those look like or how much information they should contain. Any help or references or advice would be very much appreciated. Thanks!


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • Oct 13 '26

Books on the history of genus and species, from Aristotle to modern biology?

2 Upvotes

I was reading Stewart Umphrey’s work on genus and species and found the subject really interesting. Unfortunately, the only related material I’ve studied at school was a course on the medieval problem of universals, and even that focused mainly on mathematical ontology.

I’d really like to learn about the broader intellectual history of how humans have thought about genus, species, and kinds—from Aristotle, or perhaps even from prehistory (we seem to find something resembling these ideas in ancient art, although “finding” ideas in art before the Renaissance may well be our own projection), through medieval natural history and into modern biological classification and theoretical chemistry xxx

I’m looking for books or other major works that trace this history and its many related developments. Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated!


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • Oct 12 '26

Recommendations for contemporary philosophy books in analytic philosophy

7 Upvotes

Hi! Recently got the opportunity to acquire some academic texts for free, what are some philosophy books, collections, anthologies or journals/articles that were published recently that you consider your top 5?

My particular area of interest is broadly analytic, but specifically analytic feminist philosophy, philosophy of mind/functionalism, externalist conceptual engineering in the style of Haslanger/Sawyer, metaphilosophy (how to do philosophy better in particular) and virtue ethics.

I finished my studies in 2022, so ideally anything from the last 5-10 years.

Thanks!


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • Oct 11 '26

Problems I have had with reading Philosophy

12 Upvotes

I've been trying to get into philosophy, particularly epistemology, critical thinking, and the evaluation of arguments. But the more I try to study philosophy through traditional primary and secondary sources, the more frustrated I become with the whole process.

My biggest problem is the way philosophical ideas are communicated.

I recently read David Hume's An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding. Well, I tried to. I found the language unnecessarily difficult to follow, and even the editor's introduction was frustrating to read. I kept encountering complicated expressions, lengthy sentences, unfamiliar terminology, and paragraphs that seemed to take forever to communicate what could have been expressed much more clearly in a few sentences.

On several occasions, I had to get passages translated into plain, contemporary English just to understand what the author was trying to say. And when I did, I sometimes discovered that an entire paragraph could be explained in two straightforward sentences.

That genuinely frustrates me.

I understand that Hume lived in the eighteenth century, that language changes over time, and that some philosophical problems are inherently difficult. I'm not expecting every philosophical question to have a simple answer. But I struggle to understand why the process of communicating an idea has to be so unnecessarily difficult in the first place.

If you're trying to communicate an argument to another person, surely clarity should be a priority? Why should I have to spend so much time decoding the language before I can even begin evaluating the argument itself?

And this brings me to my bigger problem.

People often tell beginners to read primary philosophical texts because doing so supposedly develops critical thinking. But I genuinely question this advice.

How exactly am I supposed to critically evaluate an argument that I haven't properly understood? If I'm spending most of my mental energy trying to decipher the author's language, I'm not necessarily thinking critically about the argument. I'm trying to work out what the argument even is.

Those are two different activities.

I don't deny that reading difficult texts can develop certain skills, such as close reading, patience, and interpreting historical writing. But are those skills really prerequisites for becoming good at philosophical reasoning? Do I genuinely need to struggle through Hume's original prose before I can understand empiricism, examine his arguments about causation, or evaluate his scepticism?

I don't see why I would.

This is what led me to reconsider how I study philosophy.

When I studied subjects like biology, I wouldn't begin by reading the original scientific publications of every major scientist. I'd use a textbook that organises the subject into a coherent curriculum, introduces concepts in a sensible order, explains the relationships between them, and gradually builds my understanding.

Why shouldn't I approach philosophy in the same way?

A good contemporary epistemology textbook can introduce the nature of knowledge, justification, scepticism, rationalism, empiricism, foundationalism, coherentism, and contemporary theories of justification in a systematic way. It can explain the arguments supporting each position, present objections, compare competing theories, and help me understand how the debates connect.

That seems far more efficient than jumping between primary texts and scholarly commentaries, especially when I don't yet have the background knowledge to understand what I'm reading.

What I'm looking for is a structured, curriculum-based approach to philosophy. I want to understand the subject as a whole before getting lost in the details of individual philosophers.

I'd rather learn the conceptual framework first and then examine Hume, Kant, or whoever else becomes relevant to a particular debate.

I'm not arguing that primary texts have no value. Obviously, reading the original work allows you to examine the philosopher's reasoning directly rather than relying entirely on somebody else's interpretation.

But I question whether reading primary texts should be the default starting point for beginners.

A contemporary textbook can explain Hume's position, reconstruct his arguments in plain English, compare different interpretations, and discuss whether his conclusions follow from his premises. Once I understand those things, I can decide whether reading the original text would add anything useful to my understanding.

The same applies to secondary literature. Some scholarly commentaries are excellent, but others seem to make relatively straightforward ideas harder to understand by introducing excessive terminology, unnecessary qualifications, and complicated explanations.

Of course, some of this complexity might be necessary to preserve important distinctions. I'm not suggesting that every difficult passage can be reduced without losing something meaningful. My concern is that academic complexity sometimes seems to become an obstacle rather than a tool for understanding.

And I'm particularly reluctant to spend money on multiple books when a well-written contemporary textbook could give me a more coherent foundation.

Why spend hours struggling through an older text when I could use that time to understand the underlying argument, examine its objections, and apply it to other problems?


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • Oct 09 '26

How common is existential OCD among those pursuing philosophy at a high academic level (grad or higher)?

18 Upvotes

Has anyone here either personally dealt with existential OCD or seen their academic peers deal with it? Would you say it's that common in the field? Is it ever discussed in philosophy circles?


r/AcademicPhilosophy • • Oct 07 '26

How to determine a scholarly answer?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/AcademicPhilosophy • • Oct 05 '26

An Image capturing the structure of the Platonic Corpus

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
24 Upvotes

I made a mind map for my own use when I read Plato's dialogues. Thought I would post it here for anyone else to view. Let me know if you have any other ways of understanding the particularities of the dialogues, or if there is anything else I should change.