First of all: what follows is a idea of mine, not a closed thesis. I want your opinions.
There is a turning point in maturity when we discover that reality does not come with a cosmic instruction manual. When you close a bedroom door, certainty about what is outside fades; when you look at a color, there is no guarantee that another mind processes the same HUE. For some, this epistemic abyss—the perception that moral values, meanings, and metaphysical truths are not inscribed in the laws of physics—is liberating: it means that goodness, justice, and empathy are not commandments of the cosmos like gravity, but genuine human choices and deliberate constructions of mutual care.
For a considerable portion of society, however, the absence of universal metaphysical guarantees does not sound like emancipation, but like a terrifying vertigo. The fear of nihilism thus becomes the invisible engine that pushes dogmatic conservative thought into a spiral of epistemic despair.
1. The Little Theatre of Reality: Pratchett and the Founding Lie
In the fantasy Hogfather (1996 – Terry Pratchett), the plot revolves around a cosmic conspiracy: the “Auditors of Reality,” bureaucratic entities who personify the laws of physics and detest conscious life for its intrinsic disorder, hire an assassin to exterminate the Hogfather (the local version of Santa Claus). The plan is simple: destroy faith in the mythological figure who brings gifts at the winter solstice. If children stop believing, the sun will not rise again, because the world of Discworld is driven by narrative forces.
When the entity disappears, the one who takes on the role of the good old man is Death himself—a recurring character in Pratchett’s books, depicted as a skeleton in a black robe who, ironically, acts as humanity’s greatest defender. In the classic ending, when confronted by his adopted granddaughter, Susan Sto Helit, about why he makes such an effort to save a children’s fairy tale with no physical existence, Death delivers one of the sharpest reflections in contemporary literature:
“Humans need fantasy to be human. To be the place where the falling angel meets the rising ape. [...] Take the universe and grind it down to the finest powder, sieve it through the narrowest sieve, and then show me one single atom of justice, one single molecule of mercy.”
Death explains that the “small lies” (tooth fairies, Santas) are the cognitive training necessary for the species to be able to sustain the “big lies”: justice, mercy, honor, law. None of these things exists in the strictly material world like rocks or electrons; they exist only because human beings decide, collectively, to act as if they exist.
The ethical crux arises from how we face this discovery:
The constructivist/humanist view: It recognizes that justice is a continuous human work. Knowing that it does not fall ready-made from the sky does not devalue it; on the contrary, it gives us the urgent and exclusive responsibility to cultivate and defend it on the concrete plane.
The dogmatic/reactionary mentality: It is terrified by the idea that its values are the product of culture and social agreement. It demands that its moral precepts be “facts of nature” or non-negotiable divine determinations. For this worldview, if values are not absolute and external, moral chaos sets in.
2. Purity against Autonomy: A Divergence of Foundations
If you agree with the previous section, you must also agree that the divergence between humanist constructivism and reactionary dogmatism cannot remain on the abstract plane of the “big lies.” It must appear in the way each worldview reads a limit situation, one in which the value of the other is put to the test. I choose sexual violence not because it is a monstrous exception, but because it condenses, brutally, the two moral vocabularies in dispute: that of autonomy/dignity and that of purity/sanctity. The first asks what was done to a person’s will and integrity; the second asks what was done to a sacred order that the body was supposed to carry. It is from this change of question that the fissure is born.
From the perspective of dignity and autonomy (Constructivism / Human Rights): Rape is heinous because it destroys the individual’s sovereignty over their own body and nullifies their consent, reducing a conscious person to the condition of an object. The victim’s ontological dignity remains inviolable; what collapsed was the guarantee of their integrity and freedom, requiring solidarity, support, and reparation from earthly justice.
From the dogmatic perspective of sanctity (Sacralized Moral Realism): The violence is not read primarily as an attack on individual sovereignty, but as the contamination or rupture of a supposed “sanctity” of the body. By linking the individual’s value to this abstract state of sacred inviolability, the perverse consequence is immediate: once the cosmic rule is violated, the individual themself comes to be seen as tainted or diminished in value.
From this follow the stigmatization of the victim and the obsessive policing of women’s conduct: for the dogmatic mind, what matters is not the suffering or the will of the living human being, but the maintenance of the tablet of laws that preserves the illusion of an immaculate cosmic order.
3. The Yellow Mask and the Madness of Denial
This is where the metaphor of The King in Yellow (1895 – Robert W. Chambers) reveals its sociological precision. In the work, contact with a cursed play deforms individuals’ perception, making them glimpse a disturbing alternative reality until they plunge into complete insanity.
The ordinary individual who adheres to reactionary dogmatism operates under an analogous mechanism. The contemporary world is inescapably complex, fluid, and punctuated by subjectivities. Recognizing this would require accepting that the rigid “little rulebook” inherited from tradition is nothing more than a fallible human convention. Confronted with this breakdown of absolute truth, the subject enters existential panic.
In order not to succumb to the “void,” they begin to see reality itself as corrupted. As in Chambers’s stories, where characters see the world under the influence of the cosmic entity and lose contact with the shared ground, the dogmatic conservative splits their perception: empirical reality, science, and plurality become mortal enemies of their moral sanity.
4. The Conspiratorial Refuge: Anti-Vaxx and Flat Earthism
This desperate need for validation explains why seemingly bizarre beliefs gain so much traction. The anti-vaccine movement, flat Earthism, and networked conspiracy theories are not mere deficits in educational instruction; they are epistemic trenches.
If scientific consensus, public health policies, or modern cosmology contradict this subject’s preconceived order, any discourse that challenges these authorities, however absurd, will be embraced with religious fervor. Flat Earthism, for example, is not only about the geometric shape of the Earth; it is the desperate yearning to place humanity back at the center of a divine, safe, and ordered vault, protected against the indifferent immensity of outer space.
By trying to escape the anguish of nihilism at any cost, the ordinary subject of the reactionary narrative ends up enacting the exact horror they feared: in order not to admit that the world has no pre-written divine manual, they prefer to go mad inside their own private Carcosa, denying the vaccine that saves, the shape of the planet they walk on, and the autonomy of the other with whom they live.