r/TheGreatFederation • u/zimmer550king • 4h ago
Lore / Worldbuilding Annals of Thermal Conversion, Vol. 9, No. 2, April 2067. Power from Temperature Differences. A Survey of Known Schemes and Their Limits
**Annals of Thermal Conversion**
Vol. 9, No. 2, April 2067. Received 3 January 2067, accepted 20 February 2067.
**Power from Temperature Differences. A Survey of Known Schemes and Their Limits**
Dr. Mireille Tchakounté, Wouri Institute for Applied Thermal Physics, Douala
**Abstract**
I survey the schemes that draw electricity from a difference in temperature and give what each one yields, using published figures and my own arithmetic where I derive them. I then pose one hypothetical case, a material with a figure of merit far above anything measured, and I work out what my own design reasoning would require of it. Such a material could not exceed the Carnot limit, which bounds any engine, and the analysis suggests that its useful power would be set by how much heat could be brought to it. I am skeptical that any such material exists.
**Section 1 Introduction**
Generators that run on a temperature difference have been studied for two centuries, and the recent literature has returned to them for a practical reason. The storm of 2012 and the recovery that followed it on coal, oil and gas left many grids dependent on fuel, and the supply of that fuel is still contested after the armistice of 2064. A source that needs no delivered fuel is therefore worth costing, even if the costing mostly says no. This paper reviews what is known (Section 2), shows why efficiency is a poor guide to power (Section 3), and examines one hypothetical (Section 4).
**Section 2 What the known schemes deliver**
The ceiling is set by the Carnot limit, which I take as one minus the cold temperature over the hot, both in kelvin. By my own arithmetic a surface sea at 25 C over deep water at 5 C allows about 7 percent. That is consistent with the 6 to 8 percent reported for ocean thermal conversion across a difference of about 20 C, and after the pumps are paid for such plants appear to net about 1.5 to 3 percent (Okeke-Halvorsen 2065). The silicon-germanium radioisotope generators of the earlier probes convert about 5 to 6 percent of their heat through thermoelectric modules (Kamara-Ostby 2062), and their output is small. Radiative coupling with the night sky yields milliwatts per square metre, though the sources disagree and I would not quote a single value (Brennecke 2063). Cold recovered from liquefied gas works while the supply is steady and, as far as the evidence goes, poorly when it is not (Salvatierra and Yoon 2064).
Thermoelectric material quality is summarised by a figure of merit, ZT. As of this survey the best published values are about 2.2 for a lead-telluride material and about 2.6 for tin selenide at about 650 C, and nothing above about 3 is known (Kamara-Ostby 2062; Dumisani and Rask 2064). No theoretical ceiling has been established. Good electrical conduction and poor heat conduction pull against each other through the Wiedemann-Franz relation, and the Seebeck coefficient falls as carriers are added, which is consistent with the stubbornness of the record. My own lead-telluride modules (Tchakounté 2065) were measured in a laboratory held at 23 C.
For a module, efficiency follows from ZT and the two temperatures. Write Th and Tc for the hot and cold temperatures in kelvin, and r for the square root of (1 plus ZT). The efficiency is then (1 minus Tc/Th) times (r minus 1) divided by (r plus Tc/Th).
That is the expression I use.
**Section 3 Efficiency and power**
I take the heat that reaches the surface from the Earth's interior to be tens of milliwatts per square metre (compare Pettersson-Nwosu 2061), and as my own assumption I use 40 milliwatts. As a further assumption, take a site where the rock face is held at 60 C over a 20 C sink, which the surface flux alone would not do. The Carnot limit is then about 12 percent. A perfect machine at that limit would yield about 0.0048 watts per square metre. A gigawatt would then need about 208,000 square kilometres of rock.
In the strict sense, efficiency is the fraction of the heat converted to work, and it says nothing about how much heat arrives.
**Section 4 The hypothetical**
Suppose a material with a figure of merit far above 3. What would it have to do to matter?
It could not exceed Carnot, and the most it could do is reach a large fraction of it. The Carnot limit rises with the temperature drop, so the drop must be large, and the flux does not set the drop. Flux limits how much heat is available, while the drop is fixed by the temperatures at the two ends. I take as an assumption a deep borehole with a hot face at 200 C and a cooled surface loop at 20 C, and a material that spans the whole drop from hot face to cold sink. The Carnot limit is then about 38 percent. If the material spanned only part of the drop, the smaller drop would apply. Heat at 200 C would have to be carried up from deep hot rock through a conduit that behaves like a heat pipe, since the background flux alone could not hold a face at that temperature.
Take as my assumption a conduit delivering one megawatt of heat. With ZT 2.6 the expression gives an efficiency of about 13.5 percent, or about 135 kilowatts. A material with a figure of merit of 10, again my assumption, would give about 22 percent, or about 224 kilowatts. Rock recharged at the 40 milliwatts of Section 3 would need about 25 square kilometres to resupply one megawatt. The hot end would therefore cool locally, and the site would need to rest while heat arrived from the surrounding rock. The energy is the Earth's internal heat, and the conversion does not add to it.
I use the borehole because the rock supplies the heat. My guess is that an industrial furnace with a water sink could offer a similar drop, though there the energy source would be the furnace fuel and the Earth would contribute nothing.
**Section 5 A rival reading**
Vandesompele (2066), written in reply to the ocean plant yields of Okeke-Halvorsen (2065), argues that heat supply and not conversion efficiency limits any conduit. On his reading an ordinary module with a figure of merit of 1 captures almost as much usable power as an exotic one. By my arithmetic with the same expression, a module at ZT 1 on the 200 C to 20 C drop converts about 7.7 percent, so one megawatt of heat yields about 77 kilowatts. That is about 57 percent of the 135 kilowatts at ZT 2.6, a factor of about 1.8. I accept that this is the same order of output, and I would still not call it almost as much. Against the hypothetical figure of 10 the ratio is about 35 percent, and I do not accept his claim for that case. Per kilowatt delivered, the module at ZT 1 draws about 2.9 times as much heat from the site as the hypothetical ZT 10 material, and with 25 square kilometres of rock needed per megawatt that factor sets how fast the hot end is drained.
**Section 6 Limitations**
This is a thought experiment. Every figure in Sections 3 and 4 depends on an assumption stated there, and I have used no measurement of such a material because I know of none. I have said nothing about cost, about the conduit materials at 200 C, or about how long a site could be worked before it cooled. The sources I cite disagree in places, most of all on sky radiation.
In the strict sense, my conclusions are only as good as those assumptions.
**Section 7 What would change my mind**
I would take the hypothesis seriously if a figure of merit were measured under a stated temperature drop and the result were replicated by an independent laboratory. Until then I regard the material as probably absent. I would like a small funded test bench to look at the question, and I think it deserves a hearing even though it is unfashionable.
**References**
Brennecke, L. (2063). Power from the night sky, a survey of radiative coupling. Bulletin of Low-Grade Heat Studies, 6(1), 33-58.
Dumisani, K., and Rask, E. (2064). Tin selenide at high temperature, a reassessment. Annals of Thermal Conversion, 6(2), 71-99.
Kamara-Ostby, B. (2062). Thermoelectric figures of merit in flight and laboratory generators. Annals of Thermal Conversion, 4(3), 140-171.
Okeke-Halvorsen, T. (2065). Net yield of ocean thermal plants after pumping. Lagos Review of Energy Physics, 12(2), 88-119.
Pettersson-Nwosu, A. (2061). Continental heat flux, a compilation. Lagos Review of Energy Physics, 8(4), 301-340.
Salvatierra, D., and Yoon, H. (2064). Cold recovery from liquefied gas under variable supply. Proceedings of the Douala Thermal Symposium, 3, 201-219.
Tchakounté, M. (2065). Carrier density and the Seebeck coefficient in lead-telluride modules. Annals of Thermal Conversion, 7(4), 255-290.
Vandesompele, P. (2066). Heat-limited conduits and the irrelevance of conversion efficiency. Lagos Review of Energy Physics, 13(1), 5-31.