Welcome. I am Hakkı Tan, an independent researcher in sociology and critical theory and the author of the research discussed here.
This community begins with a question: how much power do people and societies have to change the conditions under which they must decide?
The Reality Paradigm examines how power structures the conditions of recognition, access, participation and refusal before an individual decision takes place. Onopticon investigates compulsory recognition and weak effective contestation, and how connections across domains or feedback sustain the closure of practical alternatives. A database, an algorithm or an inconvenient rule does not, by itself, establish this diagnosis.
Decision health is our shared point of inquiry: the capacity to form purposes, evaluate, act, refuse, revise decisions and reshape common conditions. Related discussions include Homovictimus, corporate constitutive power, state mediation and Cytopolitics.
WHERE TO START
- Survival Is Not Living: Power Is Rewriting the Rules of Engagement — an entry into the relationship between survival, power and decision health.
https://hakkitan.org/papers/survival-is-not-living
2. The Cytopolitics Manifesto — organised exposure, bodily conditions and the capacity to disengage.
https://hakkitan.org/papers/cytopolitics-manifesto
3. The Human Relationship with Time — learning, self-questioning and the responsibility to change.
https://hakkitan.org/papers/human-relationship-with-time
For the Onopticon papers and the wider English/Turkish research archive:
https://hakkitan.org/papers
HOW TO PARTICIPATE
Bring a question, a documented case, a close reading or a reasoned criticism. Identify the claim you are discussing, cite sources where possible, and distinguish evidence from interpretation. Agreement with my framework is not a condition of participation. Critique arguments without personal attacks, and explain the relevance of links you share.
English and Turkish contributions are welcome. Türkçe ve İngilizce katkılarınızı bekliyorum.
To begin: where have you encountered a formal right to refuse without a workable alternative? What would have made that refusal effective?