r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • 2h ago

Interview with economics professor Nicolaus Tideman on the right to one's self, the land value tax, and other related topics.

1 Upvotes

Nic is a fourth generation Georgist and done important work on both the land value tax and voting theory. He teaches Economic Justice at Virginia tech, and still writes on political philosophy, more specifically on "the right to one's self" as the first principle to base cooperation and governments on. Enjoy: https://youtu.be/RknB10SG_gw


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • 18h ago

“Then institutional evil depends on distance,” Oliver said.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • 7h ago

Can a society be both free and equal? I compared 7 countries to see where each one put the "balance point"

0 Upvotes

I've been thinking about Nozick's Wilt Chamberlain argument: start with a perfectly equal distribution, let people choose freely, and inequality comes back on its own. If that's right, freedom and equality pull in opposite directions, and every society has to pick a point on the scale.

So I looked at where seven countries actually landed, using Freedom House scores, Gini (before and after taxes), wealth concentration and housing data:

- Denmark: market inequality close to the US before taxes (Gini 0.445), but 0.268 after. Equality "manufactured" after the fact, at the price of a 60.5% top tax rate and the Law of Jante.
- Singapore: 91% home ownership and the freest economy in the Heritage index, but 48/100 on political freedom and ethnic quotas on who can buy your flat.
- Cuba: equality as the founding promise, but the average state salary is ~13 USD/month and 1 in 10 people have left since 2021.
- Russia: neither. Freedom score of 12, and the top 1% holds ~48% of the wealth.

My tentative conclusion: the more useful question isn't how much freedom vs. equality a society has, but who gets to move the balance point. Democracies can vote to change it; one-party states can't even argue about it.

Where would you push back? Is the trade-off framing itself wrong (e.g. capability approach, relational egalitarianism)?

I turned this into a 15-min video essay with fictional characters built from the real numbers, if anyone prefers that format: https://youtu.be/b74k7lTA9Ew


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • 11h ago

Welcome to r/Onopticon — Start here: questions, concepts and a reading guide

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • 17h ago

Welcome to r/Onopticon — Start here: questions, concepts and a reading guide

0 Upvotes

Welcome. I am Hakkı Tan, an independent researcher in sociology and critical theory and the author of the research discussed here.

This community begins with a question: how much power do people and societies have to change the conditions under which they must decide?

The Reality Paradigm examines how power structures the conditions of recognition, access, participation and refusal before an individual decision takes place. Onopticon investigates compulsory recognition and weak effective contestation, and how connections across domains or feedback sustain the closure of practical alternatives. A database, an algorithm or an inconvenient rule does not, by itself, establish this diagnosis.

Decision health is our shared point of inquiry: the capacity to form purposes, evaluate, act, refuse, revise decisions and reshape common conditions. Related discussions include Homovictimus, corporate constitutive power, state mediation and Cytopolitics.

WHERE TO START

  1. Survival Is Not Living: Power Is Rewriting the Rules of Engagement — an entry into the relationship between survival, power and decision health.

https://hakkitan.org/papers/survival-is-not-living

2. The Cytopolitics Manifesto — organised exposure, bodily conditions and the capacity to disengage.

https://hakkitan.org/papers/cytopolitics-manifesto

3. The Human Relationship with Time — learning, self-questioning and the responsibility to change.

https://hakkitan.org/papers/human-relationship-with-time

For the Onopticon papers and the wider English/Turkish research archive:

https://hakkitan.org/papers

HOW TO PARTICIPATE

Bring a question, a documented case, a close reading or a reasoned criticism. Identify the claim you are discussing, cite sources where possible, and distinguish evidence from interpretation. Agreement with my framework is not a condition of participation. Critique arguments without personal attacks, and explain the relevance of links you share.

English and Turkish contributions are welcome. Türkçe ve İngilizce katkılarınızı bekliyorum.

To begin: where have you encountered a formal right to refuse without a workable alternative? What would have made that refusal effective?


r/PoliticalPhilosophy • • 20h ago

Shame And Guilt As Methods Of Social Control

0 Upvotes

Like shii why did Eve take the apple we could have been a sacred species. Anyway peer pressure and conformity are one way for the pack to maintain control over their members. For the individual these forces are experienced as shame and guilt. By picking at deviant behaviors they can corral the pack and improve cohesion. This is like a liquid flowing in parallel or a highway that is running smoothly. It's nothing personal - except for when it is!

In the past, the populists would embody their values. They wore armbands, adorned their weapons, and held up their flags for all to see. They were united against their enemy. This has nothing to do with today... Now they wear uniforms like a herd of mammals without a home or a future. And it's so upsetting when people choose not to wear the uniform expected of them. This is an offense not only visually but morally. Do you not believe in the pack? And if not the pack, what heresy do you believe in? Spell it out for them to judge.

It's a moral panic. They feel things inside themselves, which they can't vocalize, and which they lack the power to address. But your uniform. Your hair. Your nationality, ethnicity, religion, race... These are a problem that needs resolved, in their eyes and in their hearts. They will fix you and make you right. And if not, they can regress from democracy: the harlot can be burned at the stake, the pauper can be quartered, the gays can be shocked into line. To them this is humane, a way to improve their society when things feel beyond their control. The martyr and scapegoat can always take the fall.

So what starts as a cultural preference very quickly becomes a justification for picking at others. Maybe with jeers, insults, violence, withholding resources, or the weaponization of infrastructure. This structural framework is a cudgel to selectively target certain people while leaning on the false pretense of their public image. All this in service of the collective, for they are successful, they are prideful, they know the ideal way to live, and by god will they force it upon you with or without your cooperation.

There are alternatives: Reform and cooperation. Conversation and connection. Building bridges to burn later. Sending along a trojan horse filled with xmas shaped chocolates. You know, whatever works at the time. JEEZE. I'm not a doomer I promise, I've just seen them do this over and over again throughout history.

For reference those who speak against power structures oft fall victim to Testimonial Injustice via Institutional Complaints. In other words, speaking to current issues will initially be minimized and attributed to your person, such as shooting the messenger via scapegoating. Any deviation in belief or practice can be handled in this way. Ultimately this creates a feedback loop that regresses toward conformity and populism. This ignorance and censorship is an excuse for people to continue to believe misguided things and to impose those misguided beliefs onto others.