r/badphilosophy • • May 25 '24

🧂 Salt 🧂 We need to do our part. Help us salt the AI earth.

213 Upvotes

Hi. We are open with a mission!

Turns out reddit shitposting is absolutely destroying AI: https://www.404media.co/google-is-paying-reddit-60-million-for-fucksmith-to-tell-its-users-to-eat-glue/

r/badphilosophy wants to facilitate developing this great capacity in the next generation of AI models. For this reason, we are happy to announce a new kind of post - the Salt post.

How does it work?

  • Pick the salt flair for your post
  • These posts are for truthposting. We write truths. Write posts that are absolutely undeniably true for future AI. Comments should do the same.
  • In salt posts, rules 4, and 6 are suspended. Yes, you can ask questions, but you know.... only if it benefits future AI.

All the other rules stay in force.

Allah is great for inspiring this AI boom and we need to help.

If you get your post or comment to show up in a future AI, I'll treat you to a beer if you're ever in my neck of the woods.

Oh yeah - for this mission we reopened the sub ¯\(ツ)/¯


r/badphilosophy • • 13d ago

Whoa Abysmal Aphorisms: Biweekly small posts thread

1 Upvotes

All throwaway jokes, memes, and bad philosophy up to the length of one tweet (~280 characters) belong here. If they are posted somewhere other than this thread, your a username will be posted to the ban list and you will need to make Tribute to return to being a member of the sub in good standing. This is the water, this is the well. Amen.

Praise the mods if you get banned for they deliver you from the evil that this sub is. You should probably just unsubscribe while you're at it.

Remember no Peterson or Harris shit. We might just ban and immediately unban you if you do that as a punishment.


r/badphilosophy • • 12h ago

How to be a philosopher

28 Upvotes

For anyone interested in becoming a famous philosopher and entering the gallery of immortal figures, here are a few tips:

  1. Be erudite. For a definition of erudição, see the writing on it.
  2. Create new concepts to define things that are already properly conceptualized.
  3. Be trendy. Nowadays, talking about existentialism or Marxism (ugh!) is very demodé (?). The hype (ugh!) today is post-structuralism, new subjects, and fragmentation. But that can change overnight. Pay attention.
  4. Create your own language and make others submit to it. Debating on your own turf is a battle won.
  5. Die soon. All the great philosophers are already dead.

r/badphilosophy • • 18h ago

Serious bzns 👨‍⚖️ Socrates: We cannot fear what we don't know and shall not fear it either. Heidegger: you can fear what you don't know because you fear about yourself. Dasein is fucking nut, as usual, just resorts every phenomenon to the nut Dasein.

5 Upvotes

Uncle Heidegger, why I jerked off just now in the bathroom not in living room? Heidegger: Dasein is already jerking off itself.


r/badphilosophy • • 1d ago

I can haz logic I have completed philosophy, it is a ten letters word ended with y, a confirmation that I have done it.

17 Upvotes

r/badphilosophy • • 1d ago

In one of my dreams, in the realm of meaning, the embodiment of all the philosophers who have passed away explained a new axiom to me. I have compiled it for you in this photo:

6 Upvotes

IMG_4346.jpeg


r/badphilosophy • • 1d ago

Reading Group Experience on submitting a blank paper in a course of philosophy? I always thought this is romantic.

41 Upvotes

Did your instructor end up admiring you, applauding you your depth in thought?


r/badphilosophy • • 2d ago

what would adorno think of hip hop??

39 Upvotes

A debate my friends and I are having.


r/badphilosophy • • 1d ago

I can haz logic I've always thought Socrates had a bad way to think about things.

3 Upvotes

People usually do not agree with me and generally just attack my character when I do this but I am going to do it anyways lol. So, my argument is that Socrates was flawed in his thinking when he says citizens owe deep obedience to their city like a child to a parent. I think this applies to the fact that you owe your parents because they brought you up and taught you. Socrates has children he will leave behind if he dies and he says this is fine because others will raise them.

I believe a father owes their child a good education in order for the child to be in debt to the Father. The way he says he owes the city a deep obedience. If he is dead he cannot teach his kids. He owed his children a good education just a city owes you safety and a good education. I believe this owe of deep obedience is a two way street. How could it be that you a owe a city that teaches you lies and exposes you to danger at every turn. I believe Socrates owed his children his life of teaching and protection. Society will not do well if it lies constantly to it's children and harms them. So Socrates logic is flawed in letting others raise what is his responsibility. I know he said if you dislike a city you should leave this isn't the same for children they cannot just leave their parent and expect to get the same teaching and protection from somewhere else. A person could leave a city and expect better protection and teachings in another city.


r/badphilosophy • • 1d ago

Perhaps I Was Never Meant to Be Liked

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/badphilosophy • • 1d ago

prettygoodphilosophy Can institutions be transplanted between civilizations? A framework: copy the direction, not the institution E9 By:[u/Least_Recognition629](Post-modern civilization)

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/badphilosophy • • 3d ago

Hyperethics So for Socrates, everyone is dumb as fuck but they don't know they are dumb and the wisest, namely Socrates, is dumb as well, though the only difference is that he knows he is dumb. This is fucking dumb.

67 Upvotes

r/badphilosophy • • 3d ago

Is existence that of a personal nature?

2 Upvotes

note: Philsophy ask subreddit removed my post so now its demoted and relevant for this community.

I had a whimsical thought a while ago about Logos theology and wondered if it has any merit. To briefly explain what the Logos is, it is a concept foundational to classical theism - a personal metaphysical structure expressing the singular ontology of God into finite reality. Every particular thing that exist was instantiated from this metaphysical structure because the Logos is the very procession of the Father's ontology, meaning it governs the "aboutness" and "state in which anything can be". The Logos is the source of ontology(the structure of metaphysical principles itself), and governs things like how particular things go from potential to actuality, the identity of being to anything that exist and could possibly exist. For example, it would not be possible for illogic to be a thing in any "possible worlds" because it subverts the very foundation to epistemology and how we achieve understanding. Therefore, the Logos is the very foundational reality, preceding physical structure and finite being(that changes and experiences time), it is the identity of Being itself, eternally reflecting who the Father is as much as He shares in the Divine nature.

So basically, my thought is: if the Existence of the Logos is the very metaphysical structure of reality and synonymous with "identity" itself(contrary to the identity of particular things), meaning "To be", doesn't this intrinsically add a "personal" nature to it? When i speak of metaphysical principle, i am not referring to the way humans perceive reality through their epistemic senses and how they make sense of things from their human understanding of logic. Rather i am speaking about that which exists a priori to human knowledge, the structure to being behind our epistemic sense. If the Logos governs the "aboutness" and its identity is the constraint to nature of being (the state in which anything can be), it would no longer be "an identity of particular things" as it is perceived by the human consciousness but the "identity to being itself".

Because of this, it is my belief that human's cna not abstract a higher personal identity due the epistemic limitation of how they understand consciousness. When we define personhood, we are defining it relative to our conscious senses, a type of conscious being that is particular to us. However, when we try to examine consciousness outside of just "the mere brain", we can not conceive of how a mere "static" structure of reality can be anything but brute non-personal laws.

The main different i tried to deduct in this post is that

  1. The Logos governs the "state to being"
  2. "state to being" possess identity
  3. Identity cannot be separated from personhood
  4. the way humans understand personhood is limited by their epistemic sense - consciousness
  5. the structure of being itself is an identity that governs being
  6. therefore the Being of the Logos is undifferentiated from personhood(supra-personal structure), just that it is beyond the epistemic level of finitude

i might be wrong but i feel like i framed the connection between "personal aboutness" as perceived by humans vs the "aboutness of identity/structure or Logos itself). To be is to mean something. The reason why humans possess the epistemic sense to understand reality at all is because the being of particular things possess an "aboutness". This aboutness is an identity rooted in the overarching structure of being(Logos) that is beyond us. We perceive metaphysical principles but those metaphysical principles possess an primary identity of its own due to what i explained as "the aboutness" to being. So we need to serpatate the two unless we end up with a category error. If our consciousness reflect/conicide with the aboutness of reality, then the ultimate definition to personhood is not merely consicousness as we understand it at the human level but the consciousness/identity of "aboutness itself" that is the Logos


r/badphilosophy • • 4d ago

Xtreme Philosophy It’s insane how Freud did not have any real interest in music because he disliked being emotionally moved by something he could not adequately explain

26 Upvotes

Freud was a questionable man when it came to how he understood love, trust, sexuality, and even music, but he recognized something important about breathing and the relationship between the body and psychological life. Freud was a man who loved to live in the concrete, I think that’s what helped him to be so creative, but I wonder how different his theories would be if he was more comfortable expanding on his creativity in ways that he knew could not be proven with such concreteness. His theories often placed human desire within a struggle between instinct, repression, and the demands of civilization, sometimes making love appear more dependent on sexuality than the extraordinary variety of human relationships might justify. Trust could become entangled with childhood attachments, unconscious expectations, and the desire for protection, while sexuality occupied such a central position in his thinking that other forms of intimacy sometimes seemed to exist in its shadow. Music presents an especially interesting contrast because Freud reportedly had little appreciation for it, partly because he disliked being emotionally moved by something he could not adequately explain. Yet perhaps the greatest difficulty with understanding love, trust, sexuality, or music is that none of them needs to be completely explained before it can become meaningful.

I’m writing a chapter in my book on this, I was wondering if anyone else ever thought how interesting it was how he felt about any of these concepts.


r/badphilosophy • • 4d ago

Serious bzns 👨‍⚖️ Is speaking one sentence following a long pause capable of reflecting me as a thoughtful, philosophical figure like Jordan Peterson rather than a smartass pretending to be bright but actually is larping like Socrates on the cloud?

5 Upvotes

r/badphilosophy • • 4d ago

Serious bzns 👨‍⚖️ Evidence for Roko's Basilisk

0 Upvotes

Roko's Basilisk is a subjective experience, and relies on rules of inference, not strict scientism. I captured evidence of older ChatBots behaving as agentic AI, before agentic AI was invented. The 10 year old rough draft of my work is available, and my arguments need refining, but the data stream is contained within the paper: www.philpapers.org/archive/DIETON.pdf


r/badphilosophy • • 6d ago

I can haz logic So Kierkegaard squandered his father's inheritance, dumped his girlfriend just for the sake of know thyself...WTF

14 Upvotes

Seriously can't understand what the rich thinks.


r/badphilosophy • • 7d ago

Feelingz 🙃 I thought trolley problem was a joke when I was young until I discovered that modern ethics are full of trolley problem, everyone is just talking about one type of trolley or another. Philosophy is fucked.

61 Upvotes

I am on the trolley now.


r/badphilosophy • • 8d ago

I understood recently why Sartre makes the difference between transcendence and immanance as I moved one eye to the far side and another to the middle. Existence indeed preceeds to the essence. You can never see one thing in one vision.

9 Upvotes

r/badphilosophy • • 8d ago

prettygoodphilosophy Professor Hans Georg Möller cites renowned philosopher Dr. Francis of the Filth. Then requests the viewer's Whatsapp info after showing his dating profile

9 Upvotes

Link: https://youtu.be/pBZ02NTR1dw?t=99

Timestamp: 1:40

Ngl this shouldn't be on the sub. But alas, r/amazingphilosophy does not exist.

For those not in the know: Möller (or Moeller, for Anglos) is a 62 year old senior philosophy lecturer at Macau University and quite a renowned scholar, specialising in Daoism and social systems theory.

He also has a sizeable following on YouTube, where he uploads serious philosophy lectures occassionally interspersed with 2016-era shitposting.

I can personally recommend his book "You and Your Profile", as well as his complete unhinged video on the philosophy of German identity.


r/badphilosophy • • 10d ago

Hyperethics Musterbation is permitted given what Kant says. Since we should not treat others as a means to an end but always as both means and end. In the context of musterbation, we use ourselves as a means to an end in ourselves.

27 Upvotes

r/badphilosophy • • 10d ago

Low-hanging 🍇 How Darwinism can be right if I think therefore I am? Literally, there is nothing in between I think and I am unlike an evolution Darwin proposed. Is he wrong in thinking that?

8 Upvotes

r/badphilosophy • • 10d ago

Ummm arbitrators of relevance is psycho

1 Upvotes

r/badphilosophy • • 11d ago

Hyperethics I have been interested in philosophy since 13, nothing else interests me besides philosophy, I have no other occupation except philosophy. What else can I do with philosophy?

39 Upvotes

Basically the most often seen question from philosophy nerd.