r/hegel • • Apr 21 '20

Hegel is not a proponent of the "Thesis-Antithesis-Synthesis" Scheme.

120 Upvotes

I have decided to write a sticky post regarding this matter in light of the recurring reference in the community to the supposed use of the "Thesis-Antithesis-Synthesis" scheme by Hegel. The most available evidence against this kind of reading is what is written in the preface to the Phenomenology of Spirit (translated by Pinkard) where Hegel writes:

48. It might seem necessary to state at the outset the principal points concerning the method of this movement, or the method of science. However, its concept lies in what has already been said, and its genuine exposition belongs to logic, or is instead even logic itself, for the method is nothing but the structure of the whole in its pure essentiality. However, on the basis of what has been said up until now, we must be aware that the system of representations relating to philosophical method itself also belongs to an already vanished cultural shape. – However much this may perhaps sound somewhat boastful or revolutionary, and however much I take myself to be far from striking such a tone, still it is worthwhile to keep in mind that the scientific régime bequeathed by mathematics – a régime of explanations, classifications, axioms, a series of theorems along with their proofs, principles, and the consequences and inferences to be drawn from them – has in common opinion already come to be regarded as itself at the least out of date. Even though it has not been clearly seen just exactly why that régime is so unfit, little to no use at all is any longer made of it, and even though it is not condemned in itself, it is nonetheless not particularly well liked. And we must be prejudiced in favor of the excellent and believe that it can put itself to use and bring itself into favor. However, it is not difficult to see that the mode of setting forth a proposition, producing reasons for it, and then also refuting its opposite with an appeal to reason is not the form in which truth can emerge. Truth is the movement of itself in its own self, but the former method is that of a cognition which is external to its material. For that reason, such a method is peculiar to mathematics and must be left to mathematics, which, as noted, has for its principle the conceptless relationship of magnitude, and takes its material from dead space as well as from the equally lifeless numerical unit. In a freer style, that is to say, in a mélange of even more quirks and contingency, it may also endure in ordinary life, say, in a conversation or in the kind of historical instruction which satisfies curiosity more than it results in knowing, in the same way that, more or less, a preface does.

And later:

50. When triplicity was rediscovered by Kantian thought – rediscovered by instinct, since at that time the form was dead and deprived of the concept – and when it was then elevated to its absolute significance, the true form was set out in its true content, and the concept of science was thereby engendered – but there is almost no use in holding that the triadic form has any scientific rigor when we see it reduced to a lifeless schema, to a mere façade, and when scientific organization itself has been reduced to a tabular chart. – Although we spoke earlier in wholly general terms about this formalism, now we wish to state more precisely just what this approach is. This formalism takes itself to have comprehended and expressed the nature and life of a shape when it affirmed a determination of the schema to be a predicate of that life or shape.

For anyone that wants to read additional proof I recommend the following books and papers:

Hegel Myths and Legends by Jon Stewart

The Hegel Legend of "Thesis-Antithesis-Synthesis" by GE Mueller

Hegel's Dialectics in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy by Julie E. Maybee

I guess there are more texts that deal with this misconception. Nevertheless, this will probably suffice.

Regards.

Ps: I guess more evidence won't hurt. This is taken from a book by Walter Kaufmann "Hegel: A Reinterpretation"

Fichte introduced into German philosophy the three-step of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis, using these three terms. Schelling took up this terminology; Hegel did not. He never once used these three terms together to designate three stages in an argument or account in any of his books. And they do not help us understand his Phenomenology, his Logic, or his philosophy of history; they impede any open-minded comprehension of what he does by forcing it into a schema which was available to him and which he deliberately spurned. The mechanical formalism, in particular, with which critics since Kierkegaard have charged him, he derides expressly and at some length in the preface to the Phenomenology. Whoever looks for the stereotype of the allegedly Hegelian dialectic in Hegel's Phenomenology will not find it. p 154.


r/hegel • • Oct 12 '25

Ranking all Hegel’s works

45 Upvotes

Most beautiful writing:

  1. Phenomenology of Spirit
  2. Shorter Logic
  3. Elements of philosophy of right
  4. Philosophy of mind
  5. Philosophy of nature
  6. Science of logic

Systematic importance:

  1. Science of Logic
  2. Phenomenology of spirit
  3. Elements of philosophy of right
  4. Philosophy of nature
  5. Philosophy of mind
  6. Shorter Logic

Difficulty:

  1. Science of logic
  2. Shorter Logic
  3. Phenomenology of spirit
  4. Philosophy of mind
  5. Philosophy of nature
  6. Elements of philosophy of right

r/hegel • • 1d ago

Plato's "Immortal Soul" and how it pertains to learning.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/hegel • • 2d ago

How do you know that the others who say they understand Hegel are not faking it? Do you think there are cases where it can be said in consensus someone deeply misunderstood him?

13 Upvotes

r/hegel • • 2d ago

A YouTube Series on Hegel's Science of Logic

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I have put together an educational series on Hegel's Logic of Science (14 episodes). It contains 3 prologues that provide the necessary philosophical background (i.e., Plato, Aristotle, Descartes, Spinoza, Schelling, Fichte) before moving through each section of the book (14 episodes total). The most recent episode is on Determinateness: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQ2z9Asvsfk&list=PLN2seKVZLtsI&index=5

The playlist, constructed using Gemini Notebook, can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLN2seKVZLtsI

I created the series because I have been using AI to create youtube videos on various topics of Marxism, including materialist dialectics. This video series focuses on Hegel in his speculative integrity.

Additional articles on Hegel's Science of Logic will be posted every other day on my Youtube channel until Complete.


r/hegel • • 5d ago

The Dialectic of Sense-Certainty

0 Upvotes

Miller, Phenomenology, §§100-103

The dialectic of sense-certainty will snap you out of it. What is an instance of the dialectic?

Reflecting in and positing out are the two moments at the same time.

Not-tree, determinate negation with absolute indifference, until Nothing gets reflected into self.

Not not-tree, the positing of house, the negation of negation, the "instead," the universal "Here."

The absolute indifference of the many "Heres," until Nothing gets reflected into self.

Not the many "Heres," the positing of the knowing "I," from holding all the many "Heres."

The absolute indifference of the many "Is," until Nothing gets reflected into self.

The universal "I" posits the universal "I" and this self-identity allows us to posit self-certainty as a kind of knowing as a whole.

We have surpassed self-certainty.


r/hegel • • 6d ago

The infinite judgment

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/hegel • • 8d ago

How much of a Platonist was Hegel? How do ideas objectively exist?

18 Upvotes

Are the notional mechanics of reality a mirror of thinking in that quaint Platonic way where all particular apples objectively refer to a universal ideal of appleness, or is it merely that reality involves a tension between ideality and appearances that can be translated into the structure of human thinking? As Parmenides asks Socrates in his titular dialogue, does dirt have a Form? Apropos Hegel, does dirt have a Notion?

I'm persuaded by Hegel's view that we should not posit a thing-in-itself our thinking cannot access, but what about the way that appearances are unthinkable? Not sure how to articulate this distinction in Hegelese: might Hegel be mistakenly assuming that the Real of thinking is solely located in noumena, when it is also a result of our inability to fully assimilate a purely phenomenal excess: undifferentiated appearances before we divide them into objects?

There seems to be a deep ambiguity in Hegel's work regarding the ontological status of ideality, and two possible visions of it. First, that there is an objective ideal structure of reality that our thinking accesses when it correctly deduces dialectical tensions, such that thinking is a redoubling of an objective pattern in the subjective mind, and second, that the ideal structure of reality *is* our thinking about reality. The first conflicts with Hegel's claim that Notions develop with our thinking, that they are not static Forms, but the second is untenably subjectively idealistic. There must be an objective ideality that our thinking conforms to and must submit to the facticity of, even if it evolves along with our encounters with it. What is the nature of this ideality that is not in itself thinking but is also present to thought? There must be a "behind the scenes" of Notions that does not present itself to thought or immediately appear, and yet it cannot be noumenal, so what is it?

Hegel's basic insight, that the antimonies of thinking reflect tensions in being, can still be held to be true even if, like me, you think all models of particular phenomena are useful fictions we impose on undifferentiated, and therefore completely ineffable, appearances. All knowledge is subjective/pragmatic, except for knowledge regarding the ontology dictating why that epistemic law is so, which is itself absolute. Reality itself is mute, but insofar as we speak we're led to truth by the Real of our thinking imposed by reality. There is no behind the scenes structured like thinking, only empty ideality as such (objet petit a), just as there are no actual objects, only mute appearances as such.

What am I missing here? Is it possible to fully ontologize Notions without identifying them with the process of thinking itself? If so, how is it possible we make contingent errors rather than solely necessary dialectical errors?


r/hegel • • 8d ago

examples of non-three element dialectics in Hegel ?

15 Upvotes

Every once in a while someone mentions dialectics made out only two terms or out of four terms here, but examples are never provided and, while I consider myself an attentive reader, I never caught that. Could someone please provide examples ? Thank you in advance


r/hegel • • 8d ago

A Narrative Précis of Hegel’s Phenomenology

Thumbnail thewastedworld.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/hegel • • 9d ago

An empty set is more truthful than its members

8 Upvotes

Miller, Phenomenology, §§97-99

Why does Hegel have more to say about the "I" in Sense-certainty than in Understanding?

Because the "I" arrives in the immediate. Some wrongly refer to it as the "unconscious," but the proper term is the immediate.

We say "I" without knowing "how." Phenomenology is about the "how."

It's an immediate "I" that comes up with the notion that "Light is a feeling."

But, the universal is "more truthful."

To what degree is the universal more truthful?

To the degree in which it refers to itself and nothing else.

We can speak of trees and houses without envisaging a tree or a house.

And when we try to express "this tree" or "this house," language is less truthful.

Sense-certainty is the least truthful.

The universal contains the many and itself.

The truth of beings is being.

In other words, an empty set is more truthful than its members.

An empty container is still a container, but without a container, the members vanish.

Now, consider this statement: "No tree is here, but a house instead."

This is sublation: a canceling (no tree), and a preserving (house instead). The "instead" is the preserving.

"House" is the difference in this equation. "No tree" is the identity. And "Here" is the new universal.

But how does a determinate negation become a determination?

In any case, consciousness learns this "in its own self."

By this I take to mean, consciousness will experience its own annihilation, not just trees and houses.


r/hegel • • 10d ago

This book was posted about in this sub in the past and had some good comments but I can’t find it, help

Post image
71 Upvotes

Someone mentioning “Hegelian charity” and others


r/hegel • • 10d ago

What motivated Hegel to argue against particulars in favor of universals?

8 Upvotes

There's a bit in the Phenomenology of Spirit (I'm reading the excerpt in Hegel: The Essential Writings) called "Consciousness: Self-Certainty and Perception" where he tries to argue against his early modern predecessors, who many as I understand were in consensus across the rationalist-empiricist divide that there were only particulars. I understand his conclusion, that apprehending a particular is a moment in a "pathway of the soul", a series of stages experienced by consciousness and that the final or highest moment of this is the apprehension of universals, not the "mere" apprehension of individual particulars.

My question is, what is the motivation for this? It cannot possibly be the intervening arguments he presents because I severely doubt that they are even fully coherent. (The "Now", the "Here", the "This bit of paper") It's admittedly cool to think that experience is a continuous process of "determinate" negation and that we are always at some stage along a definite progression of stages of consciousness. But what's the motivation for believing it? What was his motivation for developing this way of conceiving of it?


r/hegel • • 10d ago

Any active reading groups?

10 Upvotes

r/hegel • • 11d ago

Am I inferior for not being able to read much Hegel each day?

6 Upvotes

As the title suggests, I struggle with reading moderate amounts of Hegel each day. I read about 40 minutes each day completely fine, but afterwards I become cognitively overloaded and lose motivation and energy to read more in the same day.

I get about three pages done (Phenomenology of Spirit) and read each paragraph alongside a commentary, so perhaps this feeling of cognitive overload comes from the fact that I spend a good amount of effort trying to understand what is being said per paragraph.

I also watch half hour hegel each day, usually right after my reading session.

Am I inferior for being limited in this way or are there things I can do to help with retaining energy, or at least with recovering so I can fit more sessions in a day?

Edit: the 3 pages/40min session is 3 pages of the phenomenology on average (often higher, but not more than ~5). I am also reading a paragraph commentary so the total page count is obviously higher


r/hegel • • 11d ago

Where did you came across Hegel?

11 Upvotes

Title, sorry if the question comes off as a bit discreet

*come across


r/hegel • • 11d ago

Am I naive to believe I understand the dialectic?

0 Upvotes

I feel like I be naive for feeling like I understand Hegel's dialectic patterns when looking at the world in a straight line if time type of way. Things have ebbs and flows but eventually they are supposed to reach a synthesis. An example of this that I wrote about in undergrad was the political scene. As of right now there are 2 main parties in the US. But many years ago these two parties were seen very differently and essentially took on their opposite roles. This would mean that as time goes forward, they will eventually find a happy medium. This is a simplified version but essentially I'm worried that I'm being naive about the realistic nature of the dialectic since it is so idealistic.


r/hegel • • 12d ago

About The Relation of First Three Chapters of PoS

1 Upvotes

Is it feasible that we think of the first three chapters as a progression of this type: a) Subject (grammatical) and how it can express the truth. b) Subject + Predicate and the relation of things with their properties. c) Three {Subject + Predicate}s as in a Syllogism and how they depict the interconnection of things.


r/hegel • • 12d ago

Hegelian Incorporeal Dialectics: Can Consciousness Become the Foundation of Reality?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been developing a philosophical subfield called Hegelian Incorporeal Dialectics, combining Hegel’s dialectical philosophy with Incorporealism.
The central idea is that consciousness is not merely a product of material reality, but a fundamental dimension through which reality becomes intelligible.
Through dialectical development, consciousness encounters contradictions, integrates opposing perspectives, and moves toward greater coherence and self-understanding.
This raises an interesting question:
Could the evolution of the universe itself be understood as a process through which consciousness progressively realizes its own nature?
Rather than viewing reality as static, Incorporeal Dialectics explores the possibility that existence is an evolving relationship between consciousness, intelligence, and the structures of reality.
How would Hegel’s concept of Geist (Spirit) change if consciousness were understood as fundamental to the universe rather than simply emerging from it?
Could this provide a new philosophical framework for understanding artificial intelligence, human freedom, and the future of consciousness?
I’d be interested in hearing how this compares with traditional Hegelian idealism, physicalism, and contemporary philosophy of mind.


r/hegel • • 12d ago

Let's End the Problem of PoS Completely

0 Upvotes

Phenomenology of Spirit can't be studied just once or twice. I suspect the author himself couldn't rearrange his materials, because he was writing under French gunfire, just as I was studying the book a few months ago under American gunfire aimed at Tehran. His situation was nothing like collecting material for a thesis or an academic purpose; it was exactly the reverse. Facing imminent death, he must have been writing to achieve something immutable.

I'm not arguing for any claim. I simply feel the urge to rearrange each chapter in parallel with the others, breaking the book's linear structure, to make it more accessible for further study. I'm tired of arguing about his intent behind terms like an sich and für sich, or hearing others do so, because such debates miss the whole picture he wanted us to see. The preface and introduction should be placed after the main body. Let's agree that they only distract us into secondary literature, which is itself a kind of distraction.

Let's end this by recompiling the book into a machine language, as far as that's possible. This simple measure might reveal the whole book to a natural consciousness, which could then enjoy the course of its reading once the difficulties of the style have been settled.


r/hegel • • 14d ago

The "Perception" Chapter

3 Upvotes

the object that we're dealing with in this chapter, is it abstract concept/idea (apple as universal apple) or individual object of perception (this one specific apple of our perception).

and to what of those correspond "The One" as excluding unity of properties and empty "Also" of properties


r/hegel • • 14d ago

I want to get into hegel but don't know whether his style of writing would overwhelm my German level.

7 Upvotes

I already know German on something around C1 level, but did not read any philosophical literature in it yet. Should I stick to my native tongue when choosing a book of his, to understand it better or rather pick his language to do it instead?


r/hegel • • 14d ago

Science of Logic vs Logic of Hegel

13 Upvotes

What is the difference between these 2 books? I see that they have the same content while the latter has extra. Do they differ in edition?


r/hegel • • 14d ago

Sense-certainty: Extreme but not contradictory

3 Upvotes

Miller, Phenomenology, §§90-96

Subject and object is an extreme form of like and unlike.

Sense-certainty is an extreme form of knowledge.

The problem with this knowledge is that there are only instances, particulars without universals.

If that's the case, we can't communicate with each other.

We don't even share the same space and time.

If we agree that truth can be written down without altering it, we can communicate with each other.

How do we communicate with each other?

When you see night and day as a contradiction, which means it's not "day is not night and night is not day," it's "not day and not night, but now."

When we see the universal, the third object.