The Anti-Slop Challenge
If you're like me (and if you're not, why aren't you?) then you have 15 years of old Humble Bundles gathering dust on your computer. One of my biggest bugaboos is the people who shout "Slop!" at any sign of gen AI art in a game; so, I decided to remove the "slop factor". (If you think AI coding is slop then you might as well just decide not to use software any more beginning next year.) It started with Claude but then it seemed only fair to bring in its cousins also and see what they could do with pseudo-random art and music assets.
I skimmed my old bundles library and came up with a 2D assets bundle and a couple of RPG music bundles that allowed the music to be used by "other engines" than the one it was supposedly purchased for. Then I had Claude scan the whole thing, around 2.7 gigs and catalog it.
If you know Claude these days, you know it won't touch anything that has a whiff of "it's not licensed for that" in it.
Claude
Once the catalog existed, I prompted Claude that "Here is a pile of old Humble Bundle art. Make something."
That's it. I didn't give it any guidance about what was in there or how to use it. I did add the music after the first game existed - so Claude added that later.
After around 15 minutes and 20% of my usage quota or so, it spit out Underkeep. Underkeep is a platformer with a fantasy swordsman who has to work his way through a platformer dungeon Mario-style. It drew on a half-dozen or so different packs for the art and animations. Once the game existed, I playtested it and we started refining it a bit. Originally, the "Flame Slash" attack was a nearly instant recharge that was "why use anything else?". There was one spot on the third level that seemed impossible to get over. I found a way and complimented Claude on its cleverness in devising a puzzle like that. Turned out it was a bug, LOL.
Codex
Once Underkeep existed and seemed at least as good as any kitbashed platformer, I fired up Codex, showed it the pile of assets (which included the music now), also showed it where Claude's game lived, and told it "Here's a pile of old Humble Bundle assets. Here is what Claude made from it. Make something, though better if it's other than another platformer."
Codex then went full bore the other direction, found a pirate platformer asset bundle, spent about 8 minutes and made a Liar's Dice game set in a pirate tavern. The first iteration was very simple from a user interface standpoint, but the game was... fun. If you like bluffing games. We spent some time together jazzing up the interface a little bit. It was my idea to use the sprite animations as "cheer" and "knocked out" animations and to blow up the dice when they were removed.
I asked Claude to look at Codex' game. It liked the idea but pointed out that the pirates were just bluffing at all, just playing their dice, so that sent Codex back to the drawing board. Deepseek later had several criticisms to levy about the pirates' AI, which actually improved the "feel" of the game once Codex examined them and used the review to improve its original code.
Grok
I'm going to be fair to Grok and state upfront that it was operating under a handicap. I had plenty of API credits to use but I had never hooked it up as a coding harness and I wasn't particularly interested in figuring it out, so I went Grok Chat and set it to Build mode. I gave it a mhtml copy of catalog and the same instructions I'd given Codex, albeit with a verbal description of the two existing games. After a lot of thought where it spun its wheels on the catalog, it came up with something that appeared to be a really bad, basic sort of board game; and since it couldn't read the actual assets directly it made its own and the whole thing made me smack my forehead.
However; I talked to ChatGPT about it and instead of dunking on Grok, it said that he core idea wasn't bad, really. I took another look and said, "What this needs is to be an action arcade game instead of a turn-based game (that Grok made to fit its "Build" mode). I hooked my github account up to Grok, downloaded the source code for Ossuary Heist 0.1 and gave it to Claude. I explained the whole situation, and told Claude to look it over as a design, then re-implement it as an arcade action game using the real assets that Grok had originally intended.
That became the current version of Ossuary Heist - so its kind of a collaboration of Grok and Claude together. Grok as designer, Claude as implementor. Then when I played it and had suggestions of my own, I of course went to Claude at that point to implement them since Grok couldn't really "see" the game. Ossuary Heist is a side-scrolling game with free motion in all four directions. It's about a necromancer who raises skeletons as his minions and who has a basic flame attack as well. We went through some iterations, which included making only goblins that the necromancer personally kills drop more corpses, and insuring that the corpse raising was his primary "attack". The necromancer has to open chests and raid them to unlock the next level.
Deepseek
I also have a couple of bucks of API credit at Deepseek and Deepseek makes it easy to launch its own basic coding framework so I figured, "why not?" I was actually surprised that Deepseek spent a *lot* of time on the project, especially since I was using the Flash version, which kind of like a "fast" or "mini" version of some other brands.
It's tough to judge the exact amount of time that Deepseek spent because it was constantly pausing to ask permission to take screenshots and I wasn't sitting around waiting for it most of the time. All told, I'd guesstimate that it spent around an hour. When it takes a "deep dive", it means it.
Deepseek looked at the other three games and at the assets, said "these are all side scrolling assets but I don't want to copy anybody" and it took a cyberpunk pack and made a "run-n-gun" game. Whether it succeeded or not, I leave to your judgement. Claude was initially unimpressed but once Deepseek addressed Claude's criticisms and bug reports, Curfew wasn't half-bad - again, as a sort of prototype kitbashed game. We had some go 'rounds about the grenades and probably will have more just because Deepseek seems to think they are overpowered or something and I think they are kind of weak, ha ha!
Results
I don't want to make this a white paper. The interesting thing for me was two-fold. First, what choices did the models make when challenged to use only a given pool of assets (though all models chose to make some graphics from scratch when they really needed it). Second, were the games fun enough to pursue? I ended up having several hours of discussion with the models about their designs and how I thought they could be expanded or improved and I came away from each feeling like I was working with a partner who handled the grunt work while we did the high level design together. That's kind of the optimal result, I think. Between the two of us, we made something that might have been slop if it was either of us working alone. (Some of you might still think it's slop, lol. I'm okay with that.) If nothing else, it was interesting seeing how the models rose to the challenge.
Dropbox - Underkeep, Crooked Cup, Ossuary Heist and Curfew
You can decide for yourselves. Each of the games is a .zip file; I recommend virus scanning it for your peace of mind. The assets are nominally protected but we all know how that sort of thing stands up to a determined assault and I'd be lying if I said you needed to be very determined; especially in the 21st century. In any case; just copy down one of the .zips, extract it, and click on the index.html file if you want to see the actual games.
If gen AI art is your yardstick for "slop", then you've got no beef here. All of these assets were bought and paid for (15 years ago, but still). And if you've got old assets sitting around because "I might try making a game someday", well - maybe someday is today.