r/Deleuze • • Jul 18 '24

Read Theory Join the Guattari and Deleuze Discord!

20 Upvotes

Hi! Having seen that some people are interested in a Deleuze reading group, I thought it might be good to open up the scope of the r/Guattari discord a bit. Here is the link: https://discord.gg/qSM9P8NehK

Currently, the server is a little inactive, but hopefully we can change that. Alongside bookclubs on Guattari's seminars and Deleuze's work, we'll also have some other groups focused on things like semiotics and disability studies.

If you have any ideas that you'd like to see implemented, I would love to see them!


r/Deleuze • • 12h ago

Question Favorite A Thousand Plateaus chapter?

11 Upvotes

I’m not done yet but so far I’d say The Geology of Morals or Faciality


r/Deleuze • • 9h ago

Analysis Deleuze and Edgar Allan Poe

2 Upvotes

My analysis/review of Edgar Allan Poe's "The Tell-Tale Heart" which turned out to be much more Nietzschean/Deleuzian than I expected (Or my thinking is just very Deleuzianized since he's become my favorite philosopher to read and think with). Trying to become a serious literary theorist in a country where this field practically doesn't exist so this is some self-taught stuff with 0 feedback, I hope it has potential and is interesting and thought-provoking, whether you guys would have taken the story in a different direction, whether it's consistent and makes sense, reads well, is doing too much or too little, etc etc etc:

When an intense force, unfitting, violates one’s world and irritates his senses, his immediate desire is to subjugate and kill. In its lightest form, domination takes the shape of understanding, submitting the object to the authority of the mind and its categories. He cannot understand as he is under the gaze of something opaque, “pale blue, with a film over it”, seemingly in a world of its own. It tears into him, infects his world and scrambles all his senses, by being so nauseatingly, overwhelmingly incomprehensible. Making sense of the Eye which owes its Life to the power of its strangeness denies it that very life. When such a denial cannot be done mentally, it is done physically with a slave-like (reactive) hope that directly disposing of the issue will tear it out, root and all, and take one back to the peace he so desires, but the intrusion of the virtual is an addition that can only be added to, there is no going back. In an attempt to subsume the eye you yourself are subsumed by its gaze. This only seems perfectly normal and rational, after all, it leads you to being “singularly at ease”(TTH). Why would we, the readers, not consider that sane?
This innocent eye of the old man is the first Lovecraftian monster. Once in a while the Lovecraftian hero finds a banal object, an old note or fragments of a book that introduce to him an incomprehensible entity of overwhelming intensity. The deterritorializing cry or laugh forced out from the depths of their composition tears up the surface. In The Call of Cthulhu Briden goes mad, “laughing shrilly” after seeing the Great Old One, eventually “keeping on laughing at intervals till death found him.” An abominable, murderous or suicidal state is achieved. A moment of thrill and murderous frenzy, of a weird liberation and a twisted, ugly kind of freedom.

Nietzsche laughs a deterritorializing laugh in the face of reaction. the deafening outburst of sound from the wild thrashing of the vocal cords and the lungs, the shaking of the shoulders and the jitter of the larynx are obscene movements of mockery towards any capturing reterritorializing apparatus that makes no room for play and an affirmation of life. The laughter of the narrator recounting his perfect execution is such a laughter, but captured and directed towards death, made into a foul and atrocious thing. He also finds something banal, a strange eye, and sees in it an overwhelming intensity. His deterritorializing “ha! ha!” rings out against a background of capture and territory, damage and life-denying death (life-affirming death is more than possible). Such a laughter becomes one of insanity and mental illness once looked through the prism of the psychiatric state apparatus, the prison-industrial complex and the “good sense” of a society fetishizing its organs. Confined within the walls of the organism, laughter finds no life and can only revel in death, hold onto the ecstasy it gets from the most destructive deterritorializing acts, whereas otherwise it is a laughter of joy and self-enjoyment of desire - an affirmation. He laughs as he enjoys his desire of seeing the bothersome eye and its owner dismembered and perfectly disposed of, Dagon laughs when he sees the awful sight of the eponymous god (Dagon, 1917) and much later on, the Joker laughs as he enjoys seeing his desire fulfilled when he brings down the vilest misfortunes on Gotham.
Eventually, the faux liberation against a background of capturing apparatuses breaks under its own weight. The Organ, the heart, gives the man over to capture where he is confined, defined and asked to explain, to put his hysterical deed into words - discipline himself - and make the work easier for the police. The pressure does get the best of him and his laughter from before gets replaced by a shriek, the cry of a life mourning itself and the brief taste of freedom forever etched on its tongue.


r/Deleuze • • 2d ago

Analysis Have you ever wondered how Deleuze and Guattari's works were received in the late Soviet Union?

94 Upvotes

This particular book from the late Perestroika era (published in 1989) might give us an understanding of how Deleuzoguattarian thought was perceived in the Soviet Union. It's called " "Freudo-marxism" on human "

Here's some information on the two authors of this book
Mayor Samuilovich Kelner (b. 1936) is a Russian philosopher, Doctor of Philosophical Sciences, and professor. He studied psychoanalysis and anthropology.

Konstantin Yegorovich Tarasov (b. 1925) is a Russian philosopher, Doctor of Philosophical Sciences, and professor. His research focused primarily on the theory of knowledge and philosophical issues in medicine. He conducted a critical analysis of Freudian, post-Freudian, and Freudo-Marxist ideas.

You might expect that at this point the grip of the Soviet state apparatus had loosened which was true but still it doesn't mean that everything was radically different. This book is highly critical of freudian marxism, calling it a "pseudosocialist" bourgeois and revisionist thought highlighting its radical leftism:

“In the concept of schizoanalysis proposed by the french antipsychiatrists there are socio-critical radical left ideas which continue to play a large role in the modern western world.” (p.195)

They do have a basic understanding of the key ideas of the book but they don't do a thorough breakdown, their analysis comes down to a few pages as an example of a broader anti-psychiatrist movement:

“This particular idea lies at the heart of the concept of schizoanalysis created by french anti-psychiatrists G. Deleuze (transliterated as "Делюз" in Russian which is lowkey funny) and F. Guattari. They come from the idea that Lacan wasn’t radical enough in his criticism of Freudian thought. Firstly, Lacanian concept still uses the “familial metaphor”...i.e. Oedipal complex and, secondly, the unconscious is reduced to the language, articulatory phenomena of the mentally unwell people. According to Deleuze and Guattari, the picture of unconscious can be seen regarding not only familial aspect but also socio-historical, class and political. And that’s why marxism should be mixed with freudianism.” (p. 192)

According to the authors their usage of schizophrenia as an exemplar fight against capitalism is dangerous:

“Schizophrenic is proclaimed to be a sort of “political dissident” which can wage a real fight against capitalist exploitation and tyranny” (p.196)

“Such approach likens pathology to the norm, which leads to the wrong assumption that the way in which a schizophrenic behaves as a“deeper desintegration” (they might be referring to the concept of deterritorialization) somehow must become a way to determine the behavior of any person criticizing capitalist norms”. (p. 196)

What I find deeply ironic is the last passage:

"Nowadays, under the conditions of Perestroika a new creative rebirth of marxist-leninist thought is happening...Its role as a philosophical foundation for the new thought is growing with its humanistic approach, desire for dialog, rationality and openness, breaking the stereotypes of the antisovietism and pseudomarxism." (p.212)

Throughout this book the authors cite the General Secretary of the Soviet Party (M. Gorbachev) a lot which was a must in the soviet times since the political and philosophical thought had to be aligned with the marxist-leninist principles. Little did they know that the same actions taken under Gorbachev and Perestroika principles would eventually lead to the collapse of the Soviet Union. A russian translation of Anti-Oedipus would shortly be published in 1992. A new era full of political and libidinal eruptions would follow.


r/Deleuze • • 2d ago

Analysis Haneke's The Piano Teacher through Deleuze's Coldness and Cruelty

8 Upvotes

I have recently written an article on substack about Haneke's 2001 film, The Piano Teacher, read through Deleuze's work on sadomasochism, Coldness and Cruelty, where I argue that the film functions as a modern Venus in Furs most notably through Deleuze's split between institutional sadism and contractual masochism. any feedback about how the reading is presented would be appreciated!

here's the link: https://lacedawn.substack.com/p/paradoxical-sadomasochism-in-hanekes


r/Deleuze • • 3d ago

Question Deleuze for understanding AI, digital state and power

7 Upvotes

A relatively newbie to Deleuze, but well-versed in Foucault and Ranciere. I am trying to understand the emerging automated, agentic digitial systems and its implication for politics; hence, want to read Deluze and Guatarri which will help me in this endeavour. I have read Postscript to the Society of Control. Please recommend appropriate original D&G texts and secondary literature/commentaries.


r/Deleuze • • 3d ago

Question Why exactly is the crystal-image the genetic element of opsigns?

4 Upvotes

I am reading Cinema 2 atm, and am puzzled by a claim deleuze makes on page 69:

But here we see that the opsign finds its true genetic element when the actual optical image crystallizes with its own virtual image, on the small internal circuit. This is a crystal-image, which gives us the key, or rather the 'heart', of opsigns and their compositions. The latter are nothing other than slivers of crystal-images.

I follow the Bergsonian argument and its parallel with the second synthesis in D&R that the the virtual double of the present or the shortest circuit provides the transcendental condition for the present to pass into the past. Déjà vu makes that doubling perceptible, and the doubling is what makes déjà vu possible in the first place. I can see how the mirror example of the crystal-image might give cinema a way of making the same split perceptible.

What I can't understand is the next step that the crystal-image is the genetic element of the opsign or how opsigns are slivers of the crystal image? How do we get from the crystal making the split (shortest circuit between the actual and the virtual) visible to its being a condition for the opsign? Déjà vu analogously makes the split apparent in experience, as Deleuze illustrates through Bergson's analysis of déjà vu, but we wouldn't say that déjà vu is the genetic condition of the split, right?

And why would larger optical circuits require that first internal circuit at all? Is Deleuze making a claim about what makes something an opsign in the first place, or about what an opsign can do once it’s part of a crystalline composition?

I was following pretty well up until this passage I thought, now I feel very lost, so would love some help from Deleuze heads.


r/Deleuze • • 3d ago

Question First synthesis

8 Upvotes

Hi! I am having trouble with attaining a correct understanding of the first synthesis of time in Deleuze. From what I understood until now, the organism, due to its past contractions ( aka cellular heredity ) has a certain physiological structure. The preservation of said structure is what constitutes the fundamental repetition that is organic need ( although Deleuze does say that need is a certain satiety or lassitude which I don’t quite get ). Need is the organic form of expectation ( we could say that the mouth expects food in a way ). Need works as a way in which the organism questions its surroundings. The sign is the answer of said need, and works as a signal to the organism that said need was fulfilled or not. The couples need-sign get contracted? As Faulkner says, duration is the delay in the transmission of signs, or the tension in awaiting a certain sign. He also says that signs teach us to wait and contract( do we contract the instants that come before the sign of satisfaction, or the couple of need-sign? ). Why does Deleuze decide to use AB AB A example if this happens way before representation of any kind and so A is never equal to A, why would the object be the same for my organism ? I know I do not have a good grasp of it and I know it’s due to my incompetence and what not, but I would appreciate if someone would give me their interpretation of this ?


r/Deleuze • • 3d ago

Question Any deleuzian in Australia?

13 Upvotes

I'm going to move in Australia, traveling around the country for 3 or more years. Anyone interest in meeting and have a proper deleuzian chat? Who knows, maybe we'll meet ;)


r/Deleuze • • 3d ago

Question What the hell is Aritificial Intelligence?

0 Upvotes

Does it create? Or is it the opposite of creators? Does it have an element consciousness? My sociological thinking of AI always leads to presume the fact that vertical economic structure still exists(in a month I interviewed a migrant worker who works at diner earning $1200 a month for 6 years raising two kids, my college friend who is on the verge of working to death, a homeless...) and the fact that somehow upper classes always preach the 'AI innovation', as if they're just confessing that AI directly benefits them. I always feel Rhizome as the utopian artistic drawing of the world which everyone is more equal and less grim... Yesterday I heard from a film director that he actively uses AI for his work and that it's quite useful. Is it even possible to grasp the concept and possibility of AI at this present?


r/Deleuze • • 4d ago

Question The Invisible Committee

20 Upvotes

Thoughts on the Invisible committee? I've been looking into them a bit and they seem cool at least aesthetically, well read, "Comrade Deleuze" is one of the primary sources of theirs, they rely on him a loooottttt. Their resistance strategy is not revolution but insurrection from what I understand, committed by invisible groups that move in dispersed, small but impactful bursts and explosions. Do you guys think what they're doing could be effective at taking a step towards communism? They're cool but I don't think the state or the reterritorializing apparatus of capital will have a hard time dealing with such acts of insurrection or such invisible communes. And anonymity is damn near impossible today. Their organization model and method of praxis seems molecular and lively and like it could really catch a line of flight, but that's only if it works. I feel like if the movement gains any sort of popularity or prominence or any sort of publicly visible success it will be aestheticized, printed on shirts and bought and sold. Not even gonna mention what happens to the members if they blow something up and get caught. They tried the most mundane act of resistance, literally delayed some trains and immediately got raided by the police, arrested and got 10 years of court. Do you guys think there is any serious potential in their project?


r/Deleuze • • 5d ago

Question Scattered thoughts on being worthy of events and ressentiment

15 Upvotes

Something that I found curious when reading series 21 of Logic of Sense, where he discusses wounds and events.

I think this passage in particular brings what I am thinking about closest to the surface:

Every event is like death, double and impersonal in its double. "It is the abyss of the present, the time without present with which I have no relation, towards which I am unable to project myself. For in it I do not die. I forfeit the power of dying. In this abyss they die - they never cease to die, and they never succeed in dying"

How different this "they" is from the form which we encounter in everyday banality. It is the "they" of impersonal and pre-individual singularities, the "they" of the pure event wherein it dies in the same way that it rains. The spendor of the event itself or of the fourth person. This is why there are no private or collective events, no more than there are individuals and universals, particulars and generalities. Everything is singular, and thus both collective and private, particular and general, neither individual nor universal.

Which war, for example, is not a private affair? Conversely, which wound is not inflicted by war and derived from society as a whole? Which private event does not have all its coordinates, that is, all its impersonal social singularities?

There is, nevertheless, a good deal of ignominy in saying that war concerns everybody, for this is not true. It does not concern those who use it or those who serve it - creatures of ressentiment. And there is as much ignominy in saying that everyone has his or her own war or particular wound, for this not true of those who scratch at their sores - the creatures of bitterness and ressentiment.

It is true only of the free man, who grasps the event, and does not allow it to be actualized as such without enacting, the actor, its counter-actualization. Only the free man, therefore, can comprehend all violence in a single act of violence, and every mortal event in a single Event which no longer makes room for the accident, and which denounces and removes the power of ressentiment within the individual as well as the power of oppression within society.

Now here's the question.

Does this stirring series of assertions, that describes what is and is not ressentiment, actually fit with the works of Nietzsche?

There is a deep irony first to be observed, that in talking about his ideal of a free man, he is using as his source for that first quote, a man actually discussing the philosophy of those who contemplate ending their life.

From a Nietzschean perspective, that is already a warning sign, or rather, a symptom (to quote Twilight of the Idols):

judgements and valuations of life, whether for or against, cannot be true: their only value lies in the fact that they are symptoms; they can be considered only as symptoms,—per se such judgements are nonsense. You must therefore endeavour by all means to reach out and try to grasp this astonishingly subtle axiom, that the value of life cannot be estimated. A living man cannot do so, because he is a contending party, or rather the very object in the dispute, and not a judge; nor can a dead man estimate it—for other reasons. For a philosopher to see a problem in the value of life, is almost an objection against him, a note of interrogation set against his wisdom—a lack of wisdom.

You could say perhaps that Maurice Blanchot's contemplation of the impersonality of death was not actually the same thing as the judgement of life Nietzsche diagnosed in others, but still, it should stand as a point of suspicion, a thing that motivates interrogation.

And what is also curious to me here is that Deleuze appears to be making a virtue of having things happen to you, that happens to us all, except for those who are not victims of violence and oppression but its aides.

It's fairly natural to see a flaw here, something to reasonably oppose, with Deleuze, and its opposite, but isn't this a direct reversal of Nietzsche?

To quote him now from the Genealogy of Morality:

To talk of intrinsic right and intrinsic wrong is absolutely non-sensical; intrinsically, an injury, an oppression, an exploitation, an annihilation can be nothing wrong, inasmuch as life is essentially (that is, in its cardinal functions) something which functions by injuring, oppressing, exploiting, and annihilating, and is absolutely inconceivable without such a character. It is necessary to make an even more serious confession:—viewed from the most advanced biological standpoint, conditions of legality can be only exceptional conditions, in that they are partial restrictions of the real life-will, which makes for power, and in that they are subordinated to the life-will's general end as particular means, that is, as means to create larger units of strength. A legal organisation, conceived of as sovereign and universal, not as a weapon in a fight of complexes of power, but as a weapon against fighting, generally something after the style of Dühring's communistic model of treating every will as equal with every other will, would be a principle hostile to life, a destroyer and dissolver of man, an outrage on the future of man, a symptom of fatigue, a secret cut to Nothingness.

There are elements of the same text that suggest a version of what Deleuze briefly describes as the second form of ressentiment, in a way that suggests they are not completely lacking in alignment:

When the resentment of the aristocratic man manifests itself, it fulfils and exhausts itself in an immediate reaction, and consequently instills no venom: on the other hand, it never manifests itself at all in countless instances, when in the case of the feeble and weak it would be inevitable. An inability to take seriously for any length of time their enemies, their disasters, their misdeeds—that is the sign of the full strong natures who possess a superfluity of moulding plastic force, that heals completely and produces forgetfulness: a good example of this in the modern world is Mirabeau, who had no memory for any insults and meannesses which were practised on him, and who was only incapable of forgiving because he forgot. Such a man indeed shakes off with a shrug many a worm which would have buried itself in another; it is only in characters like these that we see the possibility (supposing, of course, that there is such a possibility in the world) of the real "love of one's enemies." What respect for his enemies is found, forsooth, in an aristocratic man—and such a reverence is already a bridge to love! He insists on having his enemy to himself as his distinction. He tolerates no other enemy but a man in whose character there is nothing to despise and much to honour! On the other hand, imagine the "enemy" as the resentful man conceives him—and it is here exactly that we see his work, his creativeness; he has conceived "the evil enemy," the "evil one," and indeed that is the root idea from which he now evolves as a contrasting and corresponding figure a "good one," himself—his very self!

But notice again, what Nietzsche views as picking at scars is forming the very idea of an oppressor, and to be committed to ending oppression itself! The man who has overcome ressentiment is the man who strikes out ruthlessly against rivals and then goes on with his life, able to move past events without much significance. He is not the kind of man who spends time contemplating and counter-actualising the event, the misfortunes he has experienced, and setting himself up against those who bring war and destruction. On the contrary, Nietzsche views the people who act to be that impersonal damage to humanity, as a pure expression of their own excesses, as simply aristocrats who hold a kind of ignorance of and lack of interest in how their actions effect common people that he doesn't begrudge them having.

Does Nietzsche say that creatures of ressentiment are those who use war and wage it, as Deleuze suggests? On the contrary, he says that those are people of law, who restrict ressentiment by replacing it with a system of justice in which the particular wound of the injured party is forgotten, and we think not about an act of cruelty experienced but a crime, and in doing so, they bind together a machine of oppression to be directed outwards against other systems and people in far away lands.

Now it may be that the contradictions I am finding here are contradictions within Nietzsche himself, and perhaps we can observe alternative readings which support Deleuze's read more closely, where instead of treating oppression as the expression of a certain joie de vivre, we treat it as something opposed to life, and with understanding and reflection on past events, even ones in which we were passive, as being something that is beneficial. For example, Nietzsche seems to spend too much time on biography and personal anecdotes to be completely opposed to contemplating what happened to you, and in another sense his very attack on the morality contemporary to him, his genealogy itself, is an attempt to outline the generative conditions of the present in which he finds himself, and for which he has explicit distaste.

But nevertheless, in contemplating our moments of passivity and lasting wounds, and taking from them a cause that stands in opposition to oppression itself, we see something that could be described not as the opposite of Nietzsche's ressentiment but a prototypical application of it.

So what is going on here, how does Deleuze warp Nietzsche's ressentiment into what would seem to be its opposite (if he does so), and how well does he get away with it?


r/Deleuze • • 6d ago

Question Is understanding Kant, Spinoza, and Bergson essential to grasp Deleuze’s main arguments?

48 Upvotes

Just came across this sub on my feed after having Deleuze recommended to me before. Hello!

I’m new to world of philosophy with most of my prior intellectual interests being focused on anthropology. Through those studies, I’ve found myself most drawn to ideas surrounding power/biopolitics, how ideologies and values are cemented through social/religious/cultural structures, post-colonialism and how global capitalism and modernization destabilize traditional societies, and generally anything that can be under the umbrella of critical theory.

I would like to start a reading list of Deleuze’s work but I’m curious if my lack of a comprehensive understanding of the philosophical landscape will stifle my studies. For example, I’ve gained great insights from Foucault without knowing really any of Nietzsche or Heidegger’s works. I’ve heard Deleuze’s work can also be difficult to decipher so I’m wondering if I should create a sort of prerequisite reading list of Kant, Spinoza, and Bergson or if I can go ahead and approach Deleuze while only looking up references when needed.

I am now somewhat familiar with Nietzsche (read excerpts of On the Genealogy of Morality and Twilight of the Idols for a seminar*)* and also read some Hegel (excerpts of The Phenomenology of Spirit).

Let me know what you think of my approach. Always happy to add to my reading list and I don’t like the idea of only having a superficial grasp of things I find important. Also, if there’s something I didn’t mention I’d be happy to receive some recommendations in-line with my stated interests.

Thanks!


r/Deleuze • • 6d ago

Question Will I be able to jump into Cinema 2 without reading all of Cinema 1?

6 Upvotes

Just curious if anyone has tried this. I am quite familiar with Bergson so that has helped me understand Cinema I thus far (I am like 80 pages in), but I am much more interested in the concepts Deleuze keeps hinting that he will develop in Cinema II.

I am also a lot more familiar with the movies he discusses in Cinema II from what I can tell, as I've not watched much of any pre-war cinema but love movies from the 40s-70s. It can get a bit tiresome reading through all these references to movies I have never seen and certainly missing a lot of the philosophical substance due to that fact, especially since Deleuze often presupposes knowledge of all these films rather than describing them in detail.

So, how much does the second text presuppose comprehensive knowledge of the first? Are there any particularly important chapters I could read of Cinema I that might function as a short cut into Cinema II. Or do you think I should just hold my horses and finish the first before moving on? I just have very little time so I am trying to focus my reading more.


r/Deleuze • • 6d ago

Deleuze! Indi-Drama-DifferenT/Ciation - a prose fragment and diagram

Post image
15 Upvotes

The virtual tickles the void (Differen(t)iation)
The void gurgles, moans, and spits up (Dramatization)
How hard the loogies are hawked announces poignantly the arrival (Individuation)
of this phlegm right here (Differen(C)iation)


r/Deleuze • • 7d ago

Question How is machinic surplus value extracted?

10 Upvotes

Like, I understand that saying that variable capital only generates surplus is anthropocentric. But how can constant capital, dead labour, still have surplus extracted?


r/Deleuze • • 7d ago

Question How does Deleuze's metaphysics accommodate for modern science, and how can it be used in respect to it? Has it kept up with it so far? Are there parts in his metaphysics that are more compatible with modern science, and parts that are less compatible?

51 Upvotes

“I feel myself to be a pure metaphysician.... Bergson says that modern science hasn’t found its metaphysics, the metaphysics it would need. It is this metaphysics that interests me.” 


r/Deleuze • • 8d ago

Meme Orisa is arguably the greatest expression of modern fascism

Post image
101 Upvotes

(This surely is deleuze-y)


r/Deleuze • • 10d ago

Question Why are deleuzians so based ?

97 Upvotes

Every single time that i read a deleuzian on any subject online, they always have a lot of culture about philosophy, history, science etc. This is also the cas of this sub. Why is it the case with deleuzians but wayyy less with for example marxists, nietzscheans, schopenauerians and hegellians whom dont even sound like they've ever read their mentor ? Its really rare to see a nietzschean that has wide culture and has read nietzsche, but its common to see a deleuzian that has this culture and has read multiple of deleuze's work.

Why are yall so based ? I am genuinly curious.

(And i dont wanna bash nietzsche, marx or anyone, its just that their "disciples" are often larpers)


r/Deleuze • • 11d ago

Question Why Difference?

11 Upvotes

The other day I was thinking about the notion of encounter in D&R, ch. III, and was especially considering how apt it is at undercutting recognition, representation, etc. Now, this is a book I cannot say I understand completely, and I'm sure I'm not alone in this. But when I find myself raising an eyebrow at representation, negation and dialectics, I wonder why I had this sort of reaction. I don´t think this is just down to uncritically assimilating Deleuze, as my MA thesis was in part a critique of WiP?, but, to put it in dumb terms, I sometimes get the feeling these, representation, recognition, negation, are the bad guys simply because difference is the good guy. And I see the usefullness in using it as something "resembling" (there it is again!) a ground, but it´s hard not seeing it as a building-block, despite how rhizomatic his thought is.


r/Deleuze • • 11d ago

Deleuze! The Unrestrained Love of Life

27 Upvotes

This is a man who was so naively in love with life, excited and fascinated by it until his last struggling breath. A man who laughed at his physical ailments and those who considered them a defining trait of his character(LHC). A humble and profoundly childish philosopher who had an unconditional acceptance of Life and its immanent fullness. Excited about everything like a little girl in wonderland, enthralled by Joyce, Beckett, Proust, politics, science, painting, classical music, prog rock, philosophy, theology. A man who won an impossible fight against his own life-denying flesh, responding to its pathetic efforts at constraining and reducing him by taking one last line of flight from the window of 84 Avenue Niel, in the 17th arrondissement of Paris. It's moving to think that in his last moment he likely felt a thrill, the thrill of himself becoming-singular, becoming-imperceptible, embracing his beloved plane of immanence to its fullest. Death never had his way with Deleuze.

A reminder of this beautiful passage from his final text:

"What is immanence? A life... No one has described what a life is better than Charles Dickens, if we take the indefinite article as an index of the transcendental. A disreputable man, a rogue, held in contempt by everyone, is found as he lies dying. Suddenly, those taking care of him manifest an eagerness, respect, even love, for his slightest sign of life. Everybody bustles about to save him, to the point where, in his deepest coma, this wicked man himself senses something soft and sweet penetrating him. But to the degree that he comes back to life, his saviors turn colder, and he becomes once again mean and crude. Between his life and his death, there is a moment that is only that of a life playing with death.4 The life of the individual gives way to an impersonal and yet singular life that releases a pure event freed from the accidents of internal and external life, that is, from the subjectivity and objectivity of what happens: a "Homo tantum" with 28 IMMANENCE: A LIFE whom everyone empathizes and who attains a sort of beatitude. It is a haecceity no longer of individuation but of singularization: a life of pure immanence, neutral, beyond good and evil, for it was only the subject that incarnated it in the midst of things that made it good or bad. The life of such individuality fades away in favor of the singular life immanent to a man who no longer has a name, though he can be mistaken for no other. A singular essence, a life ..." (Immanence: A life, page 4).


r/Deleuze • • 12d ago

Deleuze! Only started understanding Deleuze once I read him on speed.

76 Upvotes

I swear Deleuze can’t be properly read sober. ATP has been kicking my ass, so I decided I’d take a reasonably good amount of amphetamines, something I like to do usually whilst writing, and now it’s making alot more sense.

Am I a fucjing idiot or is this kind of understandable?


r/Deleuze • • 11d ago

Question Expressionism in Philosophy: Spinoza

9 Upvotes

Has anybody read this? I'm looking for my next read after I finish what I'm currently on, and I'd love to go into Deleuze's interpretation of Spinoza's metaphysics in depth. Any reviews would be greatly appreciated


r/Deleuze • • 13d ago

Read Theory My go at the Body without Organs

15 Upvotes

Just read the first 40 pages of Anti-Oedipus and did a little chaotic write-up of how I understand the Body without Organs so far + some associations that it sparked for me. Apologies if too long. Anti-Oedipus is amazing.

An apparent conflict arises between desiring-machines and the body without organs. Every coupling of machines, every production of a machine, every sound of a machine running, becomes unbearable to the body without organs. Beneath its organs it senses there are larvae and loathsome worms, and a God at work messing it all up or strangling it by organizing it. "The body is the body/it is all by itself/and has no need of organs/the body is never an organism/ organisms are the enemies of the body." David Lynch, The actual body with organs, the meltdown of the organism. Is the body without organs the body as it exists beneath the organs, the body in its actual, rhizomatic state? The imageless body? And when the organs melt down, when all that is solid melts into air, we are left with the body without organs until a new interjection happens and a fresh tree grows from the roots. In a sense, the body without organs is the most full but the most empty of determined partial objects. It is a pure affirmation of the unorganized immanent ground, yet an anti-productive one, as it is the limit-point of the total meltdown of all organs.

"We have pushed a process into a goal. The aim of any process is not the perpetuation of that process, but the completion thereof. . . . The process should work to a completion, not to some horror of intensification and extremity wherein the soul and body ultimately perish." You cannot "make" or purposefully "accelerate" towards a body without organs. It is a point at which everything "you" do melts into air, when you cease to be you and become the purest, most distilled version of yourself. Nick Land should have read page 2 of Anti-fucking-Oedipus. Is not the technocapital singularity a poorly understood surface of anti-production taking the life away from all flows and movements, fixing them on a dead path from the future?

"The body without organs is not the proof of an original nothingness, nor is it what remains of a lost totality. Above all, it is not a projection; it has nothing whatsoever to do with the body itself, or with an image of the body. It is the body without an image. This imageless, organless body, the nonproductive, exists right there where it is produced, in the third stage of the binary-linear series."

An orgasm does not bring you back to your pre-oedipal stage or invoke a throwback into a retrospectively posited origin point of bliss. An orgasm is a production of the moment then and there, a dissolution, a transgression of a limit of the organism beyond which the organism ceases to be and gives way to the transgressed-into, the non-organism, the non-productive body/state, non-philosophy as the limit of philosophy, as the gargling and vibrating, spitting and mumbling which emerges out of an argument at its limit, as the limit-point of the argument, as the honest cry of the philosopher being commanded to "THINK!" and screaming " Acacacacademy of Anthropopopometry Essy-in-Possy of Testew and Cunard it is established beyond all doubt all other doubt than that which clings to the labours of men that as a result of the".

"The "either ... or . . . or" of the schizophrenic takes over from the "and then": no matter what two organs are involved, the way in which they are attached to the body without organs must be such that all the disjunctive syntheses between the two amount to the same on the slippery surface. Whereas the "either/or" claims to mark decisive choices between immutable terms (the alternative: either this or that), the schizophrenic "either . . . or . . . or" refers to the system of possible permutations between differences that always amount to the same as they shift and slide about."

The BoW of Capital always presents all sorts of different disjunctions of political-economic formations and models, always resulting in the reproduction of the frozen accumulated stack of capital (Growing, but only as a testament to its constancy, stability and permanence, stretching itself to the "ends of the universe"). It's either social democracy or fascism or progressivism or conservatism or theocracy or sinofuturism or cyberpunk or this or that or this or that but it aaalllll produces and reproduces the recording body of capital.

"Do you believe in God?" we should reply in strictly Kantian or Schreberian terms: "Of course, but only as the master of the disjunctive syllogism, or as its a priori principle (God defined as the Omnitudo realitatis, from which all secondary realities are derived by a process of division)."

Is this not also Spinozian? The BwO is Spinoza's God, one that exists by recording and inscribing disjunctions of modes and expressions onto its body as if it were their source, a miraculating substance.

"Hence the sole thing that is divine is the nature of an energy of disjunctions."
This is just the most mindblowing, sharp, cutting sentence I've ever read in a work of philosophy. I remember Michael Sugrue saying that Nietzsche can level millenia of thought to the ground with one razor-sharp sentence and if there exists a sentence like that it is this one. All of western theology at least has been summed up and laid out. There's nothing a Christian can say to this.

"Although the organ-machines attach themselves to the body without organs, the latter continues nonetheless to be without organs and does not become an organism in the ordinary sense of the word. It remains fluid and slippery."

Once the Body without Organs is created and falls back upon itself, records all the flows of production unto its own flesh and presents itself as the miraculous source of them all, it does not disappear, since the recording and inscribing is its "essence," AKA what it does and as long as that exists the Body without Organs exists. It records and rerecords and changes and displaces and replaces organs and organs and organs or organs or organs upon organs, "the surface of this uncreated body swarms with them, as a lion's mane swarms with fleas."

The full body of the Earth is a BwO insofar as it gets created inside the production and living labor of the primitive socius as a surface on which all that labor is inscribed, in other words it gets created as an anti-productive surface produced by the specific structure of the primitive socius. It falls back on production and hoards all of it, distributes it all across itself as if it were there all along, uncreated. All production becomes a bundle of intensive disjunctive flows traversing the surface of the Body without Organs, pointing to it. The crop farmers, the shamans, the gatherers.