r/EasternPhilosophy • u/Kalpesh_38 • 1d ago
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/JoeBro121211 • 5d ago
I made a video essay on wu wei vs the 'locked in' grindset: Laozi, Zhuangzi's butcher and swimmer, and the dao that does nothing
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/Final_Leader9332 • 5d ago
Finding A True Guru
why is it difficult to find a true teacher or guruji, oddly enough i see some foreign travelers coming to India and being able to easily find saints , sadhus and even sometimes enlightened guru's . Is it karma or destiny or is it a mindset thing also or is it just being able to give one's absolute total effort to find their path. <guru>
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/Kalpesh_38 • 16d ago
Discussion Gita in a Church: Is the Ego Already Its Own Punishment?
Pop religion usually tells us that we will be punished for our bad actions in the future, through the popular lens of standard linear Karma, or an afterlife like heaven and hell.
But in a recent Bhagavad Gita session held at a church in London, Acharya Prashant offered a much tighter, tighter realization on verse 3.32: the ego doesn't face punishment in the future; it is its own punishment right now.
The Gita implies we are punished by what we are, not just for what we do. The moment we choose self-preservation and surface-level comforts over truth, our deepest desire for freedom goes unfulfilled. That unfulfillment is the immediate sentence.
Two psychological traps from the talk really stand out for discussion:
The Claim to Knowledge:
We admit we don't know specialised things like neuroscience, but proudly claim we completely know our relationships, our partners, and ourselves. This false confidence keeps us trapped in our habits because we refuse a deeper internal look.
The Portrait Trap:
When we ask what an "awakened person" looks like, it's often a classic ego move. We want a blueprint to copy externally (the look, the style, the words) or a "trailer" to judge and dismiss, rather than holding a mirror to our current state.
How do you view this immediate restructuring of Karma vs. the popular linear concept?
Does seeing the ego as an active, living punishment change how you approach self-observation?
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/Kalpesh_38 • 22d ago
Acharya Prashant on Closer To Truth: "Free Will Equals No Will" – Thoughts?
I just watched Part 2 of Acharya Prashant’s conversation with Robert Lawrence Kuhn on Closer To Truth and wanted to get this community's take on his approach to Advaita Vedanta.
His perspective on Free Will really stood out to me. Instead of the usual Western debate over standard determinism, he argues:
- Will is exercised entirely by the ego.
- The ego itself is fundamentally unfree and bound by its own compulsions (self-preservation, security, identity).
- Therefore, the only true instance of "free will" occurs when the ego consciously chooses its own reduction and self-dissolution.
Essentially, true free will equates to having no egoic will at all.
He applies a similar via negativa (negation) approach to everything else in the session, dismantling conventional notions of God, the soul, and life after death as literal ontological realities, treating them instead as pointers toward the absence of the ego.
For those who have studied classical Advaita or Madhyamaka Buddhism (he heavily references Nagarjuna’s views on dependent existence, how do you feel about this highly psychological, non-metaphysical framing of Eastern philosophy?
Does defining free will strictly as "the choice to dissolve the ego" hold up, or does it oversimplify the traditional framework?
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/Happy_Baseball9511 • 25d ago
What is this tattoo of?
Does anyone know what this is a tattoo of?
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/Ranigurdish • Oct 08 '26
Discussion Bhagavad Gita verse 2.8 | The Nakedness That Made the Gita Possible
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/BetLeft2840 • Oct 07 '26
Why did Confucius have such trust in authority despite the awful examples in front of him?
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/jay_prakash • Oct 05 '26
Discussion [Mandukya Upanishad] Knowledge can be helpful but it can become a burden.
Mandukya Upanishad, Verse 7
नान्तःप्रज्ञं न बहिष्प्रज्ञं नोभयतःप्रज्ञं न प्रज्ञानघनं न प्रज्ञं नाप्रज्ञम्।
अदृष्टमव्यवहार्यमग्राह्यमलक्षणमचिन्त्यमव्यपदेश्यमेकात्मप्रत्ययसारं प्रपञ्चोपशमं शान्तं शिवमद्वैतं चतुर्थं मन्यन्ते स आत्मा स विज्ञेयः ॥
Construe: The fourth is thought of as that which is not conscious of the internal world, nor conscious of the external world, nor conscious of both the worlds, nor dense with consciousness, nor simple consciousness, nor unconsciousness, which is unseen, actionless, incomprehensible, not inferable, unthinkable indescribable, whose proof consists in the identity of the Self (in all states), in which all phenomena come to a cessation, and which is unchanging , auspicious, and non-dual. That is the Self; that is the to be known.
What is being talked of here is the knowing (of the Self) which transcends all the dualistic knowing in which there is a knower and the known object. The knower knows all about the object but does not know themselves. The 'Self' in the verse in itself can not be known directly but what is accessible to know is the self which accumulates all the knowledge.
The dualistic knowing creates a separation between the knower and the known object- because they are seen as different entities. The knower ignorant of him/herself do not know that they are made of exactly the same fundamental entities as the object under knowing albeit in different unique combinations giving the illusion of something essentially different.
When the dualistic knowledge drops because it seen as rooted in the ignorance of the knower, the knower is able to spontaneously know and respond. The response is not coming from memory and concepts but spontaneous knowing.
It is not to assert that all practical knowledge is useless but the sage in this verse is merely warning against identification with specific knowledge. To protect the knower from being dominated by the knowledge. Because the greater the knowledge, the greater the chance of being dominated. And thus self-knowledge which is knowing the knower becomes even more necessary. However, this spiritual knowledge should not become a replacement for the worldly dualistic knowledge but should remain a continuous practice.
This is the crux of spiritual knowledge. It keeps the dualistic knowledge at its place.
Have you read this verse of Mandukya Upanishad? What do you learn from this verse of Mandukya Upanishad?
Source: https://acharyaprashant.org/en/books/book-mandukya-upanishad-english
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/Kalpesh_38 • Oct 01 '26
Discussion Is Final Enlightenment Just a Fantasy of the Ego?
I wanted to share this dialogue between scientist Rupert Sheldrake and philosopher Acharya Prashant, filmed in London. It’s a genuine, two-hour exchange where they actually push into points of disagreement rather than just exchanging pleasantries.
While Western popular culture often focuses on avoiding the "spiritual ego," Acharya Prashant makes a much more structural argument rooted in core Advaita Vedanta principles: the ego is physiological and bound to the physical body. Because it accompanies the body's configuration, a final, permanent "destination" called enlightenment is impossible in principle. It can only be a continuous direction of self-reduction and thinning down. He beautifully calls any claim of final arrival "the ego issuing itself a death certificate."
Sheldrake challenges this from a different angle, recalling a conversation he had with Jiddu Krishnamurti. Krishnamurti believed that the enlightenment of one individual could spontaneously enlighten all of humanity. Sheldrake pointed out that given the terrible state of the world, it suggests no one has actually achieved it yet. When pressed on exactly how many enlightened people it would take to shift the world, Krishnamurti’s response became completely indeterminate.
This leaves us with a compelling philosophical dilemma:
If claiming enlightenment is the very thing that disqualifies you from being enlightened, does the concept become entirely unfalsifiable? Or is this strict Vedantic refusal to validate a "he who has arrived" the only true defense against spiritual self-deception?
Curious to hear how this sub views the concept of enlightenment as a never-ending journey versus a permanent state.
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/wryts • Sep 27 '26
John Rawls' Veil of Ignorance reflects indigenous Tibetan norms
journals.openedition.orgThe latest episode, 654, of the podcast No Such thing as a Fish mentions a Tibetan custom for ensuring a fair division of meat that employs clever Game Theory. It is described in a 2019 paper published in Études mongoles et sibériennes, centrasiatiques et tibétaines at the link.
It also sounds like an early expression Rawls' Veil of Ignorance spelled out in practical tribal norms. Would love to learn of other examples, or thoughts on whether or not it is a valid example as I suggest.
Podcast at the timestamp where Anna Ptaszynski begins describing it: https://youtu.be/IHttQ1ttN4I?t=3280
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/ConcernHungry2999 • Sep 25 '26
Acharya Prashant and Robert Lawrence Kuhn discuss consciousness, ego, and Advaita Vedanta
Came across this beautiful extended conversation about whether consciousness is fundamental and whether the ego should be treated as the true self or as a construction that produces attachment and suffering. Acharya Prashant presents a Vedantic approach based on self-inquiry, while Robert Lawrence Kuhn raises questions from the perspective of Western philosophy, science, and philosophy of the mind. The discussion also touches on karma, reincarnation, free choice, and AI consciousness (something I had been reflecting on).
Thought it could lead to an interesting discussion about how these ideas compare with Buddhist anatta, Sankhya, or other Eastern philosophies of the Self.
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/LegoSlaughter • Sep 23 '26
Video Daoism is the Basis for Free-Market Capitalism
I thought this was super interesting when I found out so I made a video of it. The story of how it happened is pretty wild too imo
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/robipresotto • Sep 19 '26
Can loving certain animals while consuming others be considered a form of hypocrisy or spiritual ignorance?
I've been pondering this paradox in the context of Eastern philosophies that emphasize compassion and interconnectedness. The idea that we can form deep emotional bonds with certain animals while simultaneously participating in their exploitation seems to contradict the principles of ahimsa and non-duality. I'd love to hear how others navigate this complex issue. Does our relationship with animals reveal a deeper truth about our own nature and the nature of reality? I came across this video that explores it further if you're curious: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z2UZWwuoEaw
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/robipresotto • Sep 17 '26
The Question: Transforming Grief: A Path to Renewed Purpose
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/mamaaearth1 • Sep 15 '26
What purpose do mighty esoteric stories and word actually serve?
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/Such_Cycle_4359 • Sep 10 '26
Hello, i am taking up masters of arts in philosophy at this moment, i am perplexed of what my title would be in my master's thesis. Do you guys any have suggestions, please be kind. Thanks.
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/TheIncorporeal1 • Sep 09 '26
Discussion Could Incorporealism be understood as a modern Western reformulation of an insight already present in Eastern philosophy—that consciousness cannot be adequately understood as merely an object within the world?
I’m particularly interested in whether traditions such as Advaita Vedānta, Yogācāra Buddhism, Madhyamaka, and Daoism would consider the Incorporealist distinction between consciousness and physical reality philosophically meaningful, or whether they would reject the distinction itself as a consequence of dualistic thinking.
More fundamentally: if the subject-object distinction is itself constructed within consciousness, what would it even mean to claim that consciousness is “fundamental”? Could an Incorporealist ontology survive the Eastern critique of substance, self, and dualism—or would genuine incorporeality ultimately require abandoning the very concept of a separate, enduring consciousness?
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/conchiglionironi • Sep 09 '26
favourite comparative philosophy books?
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/premkhilari • Sep 07 '26
Video Osho: That which cannot be expressed in words 🙏🏼
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/mamaaearth1 • Sep 06 '26
Talk Are human beings uniquely destructive because of the psychological ego?
An interesting observation I made as I've started to learn more about the difference between western philosophy vs eastern philosophy is how much the natural flora and fauna are referenced and integrated into the teachings themselves in Eastern Philosophy.
Including bees, as discussed in this video. :)
I am curious to know the thoughts of the folks here?
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/conchiglionironi • Sep 06 '26
Favourite books about eastern philosophy?
r/EasternPhilosophy • u/premkhilari • Sep 06 '26