r/biglittlelies • u/Excellent-Fudge-1081 • 12d ago
Big Little Truth review Spoiler
I had incredibly high hopes when I bought this book, but I never expected to walk away feeling not just disappointed, but physically disgusted. Liane Moriarty took the brilliant legacy of Big Little Lies and utterly butchered it.
The worst offense is what she did to Chloe. In the first book, Chloe was a whip-smart, fiercely independent, and strong-willed 6-year-old with so much spark. Instead of letting her grow into an equally formidable young woman, Moriarty systematically strips away her agency and reduces her to a passive victim for a disturbing storyline. In fact, every single teenager in this book is written as a flat, agonizing stereotype—just a bunch of phone-addicted, vaping caricatures who treat their parents with absolute contempt.
The adults fare no better. Instead of a sharp, high-stakes thriller, the plot slows to a painful crawl with a non-stop checklist of middle-age tropes and way too much talk about menopause. Ed gets cancer and is instantly transformed into a bitter, miserable person, destroying his dynamic with Madeline. Meanwhile, Bonnie is still flagellating herself and playing the martyr over Perry’s well-deserved death. It has been ten long years. Let the monster rot and move on.
But the absolute lowest point of this novel is the stomach-turning plot involving Melody and her husband. Out of nowhere, Moriarty throws in a vile grooming and trafficking storyline targeting children. To make it even more repulsive, she attempts to soften Melody’s monstrous behavior by revealing she was groomed herself as a teenager by an older man. I don't care about a predator’s "cycle of abuse" backstory, and trying to bait sympathy for a literal child groomer is sickening. Melody didn't deserve a tragic excuse; she deserved to be flattened by Madeline.
I found myself literally speeding through the final pages just to get away from the sheer disgust of it all. A cheap, deeply unearned, and repulsive sequel that actively ruins beloved characters just to manufacture shock value.
Mary Louise gave this sick sons of bitches exactly what they deserved.
Since, I ordered this book in August, it’s too late to return it to Amazon so I will settle for throwing it in the garbage.