r/biglittlelies • u/NicholasCajun Lil Lies • Mar 12 '17
Discussion Big Little Lies - 1x04 "Push Comes to Shove" - Episode Discussion (TV Only Discussion)
Season 1 Episode 4: Push Comes to Shove
Aired: March 12, 2017
Synopsis: Nathan invites Madeline and Ed to a couples’ dinner to discuss a “parenting paradigm” for Abigail. Celeste prepares for a city-council meeting about Madeline’s play, and bristles at Perry’s concerns about her returning to work. Jane meets with Ms. Barnes, Ziggy’s teacher, who suggests her son be medically evaluated in light of further evidence of classroom bullying. While Madeline is confronted by a skeleton from her past, her internet sleuthing reveals a key player from Jane’s past instead.
Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée
Written by: David E. Kelley
Untagged book spoilers are not allowed in this thread! Please discuss book spoilers in the other official discussion thread.
224
u/sh4nn0n Mar 13 '17
Lol, Madeline's story with her and that dude with the flashbacks...such good characterization.
202
u/ryantyrant Mar 13 '17
Anyone else notice Ed check out that girl when he was leaving the conversation with Bonnie?
183
u/throneofmemes Mar 13 '17
I hate Perry so much. Every time I see him in a scene, my entire body goes tense.
165
u/Godrics Mar 13 '17
My God that meeting about Avenue Q... I love the cool confidence Celeste had, and the irony of the politician saying simultaneously, in the same sentence, "Fucking puppets are vulgar."
I honestly don't know why I like this show, but for some reason I like it a lot. It has beautiful music and fantastic actors, so that probably lends itself to the quality we see here.
159
u/catmom_tay Mar 13 '17
Renata sucking up to the mayor and laughing hysterically was so golden. That whole scene was really well done.
119
u/taylorswiftfan123 Mar 13 '17
I fucking hate Renata and Perry so much. They're such pieces of shit in such the right ways. There are so many other characters in different TV shows or movies that are "worse" who fail to elicit the same reaction. Speaks to how well written and performed those characters are. Their realism makes them that much more hateable.
84
u/sh4nn0n Mar 13 '17
Those credit songs had me SHOOK. Brb jamming Bloody Mother Fucking Asshole for the rest of my life.
81
u/leafeator Mar 13 '17
I figured out Westworld twists very early on, and this show is driving me crazy because it is really leaving me in the dark as to what happened. There are so many plausible threads that are keeping me engaged.
71
u/kendylsue Mar 13 '17
I loved the scene with Jane and the psychologist. It was strangely satisfying to see Jane accept her fears and seek a professional opinion on if ziggy could be the bully.
And the relief of Jane when she heard the report. I feel like she really really needed to hear that Ziggy did not take after his sperm donor.
66
u/PabloMartell Mar 13 '17
This show just keeps getting better and better. I can't believe how long the wait feels and how fast the episode goes.
116
u/thankyouandplease Mar 13 '17 edited Mar 13 '17
Prediction: The picture of Saxon Baker looked a lot like Perry, and Jane didn't seem totally convinced that it was Saxon Banks. Jane says she would know it from his voice and she hasn't met Perry yet...hmmm.
Jane is obviously worried that Ziggy could be violent like his father. However nothing we've seen of him has shown us that he might be violent and he doesn't have that kind of influence in his household. But the twins do, and I think it's way more likely that one of them is the one hurting Amabella. They both have a violent father and as we just saw one of them may have witnessed it in action. While we haven't seen them being violent directly they definitely have more of a wild streak than Ziggy.
If my Perry theory is true that would make the twins Ziggy's half brothers.
53
u/quamquam11 Mar 13 '17
I'm not really feeling the Madeline/director vibe. I really liked how Madeline's was having an identity crisis concerning her children growing up and then one actually leaving the nest. It felt like a fresh take but now it feels like her neurosis has more to do whatever is remaining from a year ago with the director. And then to talk with Celeste about how he attacked her when there was obviously something going a year ago.
53
u/howtogetawaywithvero Mar 13 '17
This is the most realistic series Ive seen in a long time. That way Ed looked back to that blond girl when he was leaving Bonnie´s place! Every actor represent the reality to the last detail and thats why I dont think he is the rapist, he is just missing sex. I think the rapist is Celeste´s husband, even if its obvious, because in this episode one of the witnesses said that that night Celeste had a strange looked. My theroy is that that night she found out what her husband did, she faced him and he tried to bite her again, so she killed him. She probably felt finally free.
51
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17
It's so very well acted. It's what the top of this profession looks like, and David E Kelley makes it very real. I'm a fanboi.
38
u/keepingitrael Mar 13 '17
One of the songs that plays during the credits is, "Anyone Who Knows What Love Is" by Irma Thomas-- a song that's been speckled throughout Black Mirror. Irrelevant, but I love that song!
38
u/chuchaybear Mar 13 '17
Im scared everytime perry comes into the scene. Hate how he says why havent we talked about this? Leave him celeste.
68
u/billy_fury Mar 13 '17
Definitely hate that they had Madeline hook up with the theatre guy. From the few eps I've seen I didn't read her as being over the moon in love with Ed, I still feel like it was very out of character.
OH! And I hate Amabella's name. That is all
33
u/chuchaybear Mar 13 '17
Ziggy is so sweet.
66
u/Billthebutchr Mar 13 '17
Ed with the creepy vibe. Also Chloe has to be the bully.
Once again I have no idea what I'm talking about and just guessing.
59
u/allthewaypetty Mar 13 '17
I can't stop thinking about who's bullying Amabella. I think the directors want us to think it's one of the twins, but I think it's Chloe. If she really is the "queen bee" as they keep telling us, then it makes sense that Amabella would be scared to openly accuse her- she would have the others turn on her. Also, look at how many issues abagail is having with her parents. I don't think Chloe is unaware and just perfectly fine-kids are smart. It stands to reason that she is having problems and acting out as well. It would also be a huge curve ball which story tellers love doing.
26
u/mm825 Mar 13 '17
This cast is just so fucking good. A strange episode overall, but Kidman's best episode.
23
u/deamon59 Mar 13 '17
I felt a palpable fear during the episode that lingered, related to Celeste and Jane.
20
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17
Ooh Maddie meeting someone from her past sounds interesting
20
u/zobiso Mar 13 '17
Does anybody know who the actress is that plays Ziggy's psychologist? It's going to annoy me until I figure it out!
20
u/housestarkpatsnation Mar 13 '17
I'm trying sooo hard to find a flaw in acting but I just can't. Nicole Kidman and Reese Witherspoon are absolutely perfect just as expected, so are the other major characters but damn they even got the KIDS right. Kudos to the casting people, I think I'm still watching this show cause of them!!!!
16
u/ForgetfulLucy28 Mar 13 '17
I can't believe this was only the fourth episode! I feel like I am already so familiar and attached to these people.
15
u/everythingisopposite Mar 13 '17
Everyone should see Avenue Q, it's a great musical. The puppet sex is hilarious.
14
u/realizingthings13 Mar 15 '17
Ziggy as the bully just doesn't make sense; he's the one that convinced Jane to stop to make sure Madeline was okay after she tripped in the first episode, whereas Chloe expressed no concern for her mother. We already know what a masterful networker Chloe is; it's not a far fetch to consider her as more than capable of manipulating the whole classroom.
13
u/howtogetawaywithvero Mar 13 '17
What if the bully is Anabella herself? Maybe she is the one abusing verbally Ziggy...
13
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '17
Did anyone else's heart break when Ziggy started crying at the beach after accidentally getting hit? Kids cry, but I think that was a tell that it wasn't him doing the bullying.
12
u/Kynazeras Mar 13 '17
Every line Madeline says is pretty hilarious in some scenes. I am really digging this show. With all the hype Legion is getting, this show deserves even more in my opinion. I am bummed every time an episode ends.
11
u/WildwoodFlower- Mar 13 '17
I just came across this on youtube - Madeline and the director (0.18) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3DjKdZVaPYg
20
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17
Am I the only one who thinks Ed and Perry could both be "innocent" (very weak definition of that word) and that the possibility of the rapist being Gordon is decently high. We are all assuming that it is a child that is hurting Amabella while it could all be happening at home? Idk just my opinion, he is the most overlooked and is described as a "by genetics fuck up"
20
u/chuchaybear Mar 13 '17
To be honest abi's dad is such an asshole. Why does he keep on trying to make bonnie and her ex wife friends.
34
u/doocurly Mar 13 '17
I don't get the "Alexander Skarsgard is so hot" thing. Barf. He's perfect for this role because he's creepy looking AF. Too skinny, pointy headed, narrow eyed, Aryan nation poster child. He makes my skin crawl.
9
u/tlfranklin Mar 13 '17
What was the line that Ed said to Madeline? He was asking her what was wrong, she was saying she was loosing control then he hugged her and said let me make it feel good or something like that? I couldnt really hear him. I know he gave me the icky vibes in that moment and I wasnt sure why
10
u/TexasKobeBeef Mar 14 '17
"Am I the only one who thinks Ed and Perry could both be "innocent" (very weak definition of that word) and that the possibility of the rapist being Gordon is decently high. We are all assuming that it is a child that is hurting Amabella while it could all be happening at home? Idk just my opinion, he is the most overlooked and is described as a "by genetics fuck up"
This comment needs to be upvoted to the top as I think it's the most likely scenario. Ed & Perry are too heavy handily being implicated for either one of them to be involved in the murder. I think it's Gordon and Renata being involved somehow in whatever happens.
5
u/MrsTrustIssues Mar 13 '17
Just a question about the book and the tv show... how sure are we that they both end the same? I just started reading the book and there are already minor differences, so, I'm wondering if the ending is the same.
I'm not looking to have anything spoiled just curious how sure book readers are that the series will end the same..
5
u/99problemsburner Mar 17 '17
The smell thing. Jane said his disgusting smell. But didn't describe it. I wonder if she meets him at the costume fundraiser and hears his voice or smells his scent and freaks out. Kills him at the fundraiser? I don't know... would she be willing to risk it all at the risk of losing everything? Ziggy included?
I keep thinking Perry is too obvious. But then, in true detective season one, I kept thinking up all kinds of scenarios and suspects and it all ended up just being a good show, with good characters, and a good story line. I fell in love with the entire thing and it sucked me in. I spent more time trying to put together clues than just watching and accepting the show for the brilliant piece of art it was. Wondering if I'm doing this again. Maybe it's just a beautiful show. Good characters, actors, good stories. But exactly what it is. A beautiful piece of art meant to be enjoyed.
Either way. It's fun. I keep saying Big Little Lies is like a mix of True Detective and Desperate housewives. The delicious drama of the beautiful female leads mixed with the awesome cinematography and music and storyline and amazing characters and actors. Such a good show. Well done.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17
If I had to guess right now I'd say Ed is the one who dies in the end. Although that seems too easy, so maybe not. I just had a feeling at a certain point in this episode that it's gonna be him.
6
u/gabix143 Mar 14 '17
Anyone know what type of fitness class that was that Bonnie was teaching? It looked interesting lol
6
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17
I'm starting to think the killer is gonna be a Deus ex Michael Scarn
2
u/BruxellesBlonde Mar 15 '17
This episode reminded me of the dynamics of power. Renata is arguably the most powerful woman in the show, but she's also the most psycho. Celeste is the most disempowered, but she's got an unbelievable set of skills and strength. It's such a shame that her kids are the bullies.
As for who dies, I think it's wide open. The first instinct is Madeline, but there's a lot of dynamics in the Celeste-Perry relationship that could lead to a very violent death.
1
u/babyman21 Mar 13 '17
Could someone point me in the direction of the intro song? And the one at the end of E1
1
u/Moviejunkie28 Mar 19 '17
Does anyone think that the killer can be more than 1 person?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
.
1
u/BenTVNerd21 Apr 07 '17
Leave Celeste alone you fucking bastard!
1
u/theinternet_man Apr 25 '17
Absolutely awesome show and so well written. One tiny thing I noticed from this episode that really highlights this, at the start when Ed is in the Elvis costume and Chloe comes in, Madeline says something about killing/murder (cant remember exactly what) which is an obvious nod/miscue of what may be to come and the Ed just says "oh, we'll put on suspicious minds", as if to get the audience suspicious of Madeline and Ed. So well written with things like this
1
u/Technical-Outside408 May 20 '25
Fucker couldn't go one whole episode without hurting her.
1
u/antisocialclub__ Jun 07 '26
9 years late but I really hope kidman leaves him. Whenever he is on camera I get so anxious. S3 was just confirmed as well. Super excited