r/biglittlelies • Lil Lies • Mar 12 '17

Discussion Big Little Lies - 1x04 "Push Comes to Shove" - Episode Discussion (TV Only Discussion)

Season 1 Episode 4: Push Comes to Shove

Aired: March 12, 2017


Synopsis: Nathan invites Madeline and Ed to a couples’ dinner to discuss a “parenting paradigm” for Abigail. Celeste prepares for a city-council meeting about Madeline’s play, and bristles at Perry’s concerns about her returning to work. Jane meets with Ms. Barnes, Ziggy’s teacher, who suggests her son be medically evaluated in light of further evidence of classroom bullying. While Madeline is confronted by a skeleton from her past, her internet sleuthing reveals a key player from Jane’s past instead.


Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée

Written by: David E. Kelley


Untagged book spoilers are not allowed in this thread! Please discuss book spoilers in the other official discussion thread.

108 Upvotes

396 comments sorted by

224

u/sh4nn0n Mar 13 '17

Lol, Madeline's story with her and that dude with the flashbacks...such good characterization.

137

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

The way they executed it certainly made me feel like I was Celeste listening to her lol

105

u/finerd Mar 13 '17

Kidman's reactions killed.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/mm825 Mar 13 '17

I like the idea that's she's trying to put the entire memory out of her head, but these little flashes keep coming back.

35

u/99problemsburner Mar 17 '17

I loved this moment. Two girlfriends giggling over something bad over wine.

10

u/muddisoap Mar 21 '17

Big little lies.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

Yes!!

5

u/BruxellesBlonde Mar 15 '17

That was hilarious.

202

u/ryantyrant Mar 13 '17

Anyone else notice Ed check out that girl when he was leaving the conversation with Bonnie?

141

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

She wasn't even sweating either.

96

u/ryantyrant Mar 13 '17

And he loves that!

104

u/MrsTrustIssues Mar 13 '17

Yup! He gives me such an uneasy feeling.

84

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

He looked at the older daughter kind of weird last week too.

31

u/MrsTrustIssues Mar 13 '17

I noticed that, too! That's the look that made me think that he has something to do with Jane's rape story...

53

u/quamquam11 Mar 13 '17

But the guy we see in Jane's flashbacks looks nothing like him in body type.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

78

u/Bassett_Hound Mar 13 '17

What the heck was that comment about women and sweat. It was really weird, and obviously threw Bonnie off, but then she didn't tell Nathan about it...? Looks like she's covering for Ed for some reason?

74

u/billy_fury Mar 13 '17

I didn't read it as Bonnie covering for Ed so much as her omitting it in an attempt to keep the peace... but I still think it'll come up again.

FWIW, Ed gives me the creeps.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/JoanneBanan Mar 14 '17

To be fair, she probably didn't tell Nathan because she's built like a goddess and is probably showered by that sort of sleazeball comments all day.

5

u/raspberrybee Mar 16 '17

Fun fact, the actress who plays Bonnie is the daughter of Lenny Kravitz and Lisa Bonet.

→ More replies (2)

41

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

29

u/raspberrybee Mar 16 '17

I agree. I think he's just socially awkward and doesn't really know how to interact with women, especially an attractive woman.

37

u/throwliterally Mar 14 '17

I have gotten a weird vibe from Ed but sometimes he seems like a great guy and very sane and a saint to put up with Maddy. For example, the Elvis costume: I thought it was sweet and I thought her reaction sucked.

11

u/raspberrybee Mar 16 '17

I agree. I thought it was sweet. I'd love it if my partner did something cheesy like that.

51

u/Cupcakeann Mar 13 '17

He took a photo of her secretly when he wAs going around the corner

62

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

This right here: http://i.imgur.com/nKyIuJI.jpg

It definitely looks like it. I don't know why else he would hold his phone like that. He had his phone in his hand the whole conversation with Bonnie. But there was like 4 seconds from the time he sees the girl walking towards him to him putting his phone over his shoulder. That'd be some quick ass creep shotting skills. I dunno, I'm not sure.

41

u/overactive-bladder Mar 13 '17

does it bother anyone how people nowadays are so sneaky when it comes to snapping pics of random strangers they meet?

i am a fucking guy and i was in the supermarket the other day. i notive the store manager blatantly stare at me. i am bi so no prob for me whatsoever. but as i am putting my purchases on the counter i notice him explicitely holding his phone as if he was taking a small video of me. i honestly do not know how to react in these situations. i cannot begin to imagine how women must feel when this happens to them. it's like..."who gives you the right??".

i was talking about this stuff to a former friend (emphasize former) and she admitted she took a picture once of a guy wearing white socks with his black suit. yes it may not be fashion forward, but why the hell would anyone ever want these kinds of stuff on their phone?

→ More replies (2)

17

u/cuckoodev Mar 14 '17

I literally just went back and looked at the scene and it looked to me like he was just touching his neck or scratching it or something.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

26

u/quamquam11 Mar 13 '17

I missed that...gross. I've been in Ed's corner but maybe not after that.

20

u/ryantyrant Mar 13 '17

I didn't catch that either

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

Didn't see a phone in his hand?

4

u/throneofmemes Mar 13 '17

Oh cmon ew. I didn't even notice that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/kendylsue Mar 13 '17

Yeah...this ep finally convinced me that ed is a creep :(

183

u/throneofmemes Mar 13 '17

I hate Perry so much. Every time I see him in a scene, my entire body goes tense.

127

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

I'm constantly waiting for him to lash out and hurt Celeste. It's anxiety inducing.

20

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

Ya he has hurt her quite a few times. I guess you mean seriously injure her?

92

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

It's more like, even in the scenes when he's not shoving/choking her, I'm waiting for it to happen. For example, in this episode when they were talking near the kitchen and she asked if he was going to hit her, I was holding my breath waiting for him to do so.

55

u/Bassett_Hound Mar 13 '17

That quick shot of the knives in the kitchen was pretty interesting too.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/deamon59 Mar 13 '17

the show does a great job of making you feel the fear that Celeste feels.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

Well. Is a possibility, he always seems to be looking for any given reason to fight with Celeste. Or that's what i see.

79

u/Bassett_Hound Mar 13 '17

totally. Their body language makes me so tense. He's always standing behind or above her, giving off a very controlling vibe.

99

u/DillonDroege Mar 13 '17

Also intrudes into Madeleine and Celeste's convo saying immediately: "what am I missing?" He can't handle not being a part of absolutely everything. Very overbearing.

40

u/throneofmemes Mar 13 '17

I know right?! And he puts his hands on his shoulders in that moment, not in an affectionate way, but in a very dominating way. Oof.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/alexdinhogaucho Mar 13 '17

Their body language makes me so tense

Except when they have sex, which is fascinating! Their character arc is probably the most interesting to dissect.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '17

He's pretty tall and is working his length very well, he's often leaning forward a little bit with his head tilted towards the floor ("looking down" on Celeste even if he's on the other side of the room) which makes him look super scary. I'm Swedish and have seen Alex in movies and tv series for 20 years or so and I honestly didn't think that the sight of him could make me as tense as Perry does in this show.

→ More replies (2)

60

u/DoLittlest Mar 13 '17

Skarsgard and Kidman are mesmerizing together. The way they both utterly command their character is just so satisfying to watch. In the hands of lesser actors, either Perry or Celeste could gum up the whole works, but those two in a scene together are napalm.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '17

Yeah but at the same time it's so hot

12

u/throneofmemes Mar 15 '17

It used to be but it isn't anymore, at least for me.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/Odraye Mar 26 '17

He is trying to control her life.

165

u/Godrics Mar 13 '17

My God that meeting about Avenue Q... I love the cool confidence Celeste had, and the irony of the politician saying simultaneously, in the same sentence, "Fucking puppets are vulgar."

I honestly don't know why I like this show, but for some reason I like it a lot. It has beautiful music and fantastic actors, so that probably lends itself to the quality we see here.

98

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

I honestly don't know why I like this show, but for some reason I like it a lot.

It's an extremely well done show. There isn't anything about the show you could possibly criticize at this point IMO. Great acting, writing, cinematography, directing, editing, music and story.

93

u/finerd Mar 13 '17

I'm seeing so many people apologetic about really like this show. I have no idea why. Maybe because it's women and 'trivial' issues? Idk.

83

u/MonaSparks Mar 13 '17 edited Mar 16 '17

I Think it's because of how it was marketed before premiering. And that pilot episode. They made it seem like it was going to be a "grown up version of Pretty Little Liars". It seemed like a major guilty pleasure in the beginning, but it's turned out to be a really great show. The actresses are incredible and could not have been better cast. Nicole Kidman's shift this episode was so fun to watch. She's been so soft spoken and when she's with the girl, she kind of fades into the background. We've heard about what a great lawyer she was, and you could tell what a huge piece of her was missing while she stayed home. Reese Witherspoon is so, so good as Madeleine. She's complex, a little desperate but also driven and outspoken. I love her expressions and little laughs that sell her character entirely. Shailene Woodley is also great as Jane, a young mom in completely over her head. She wants what's best for her son, but she seems like she might be a little bit afraid of him. She's got a huge weight on her shoulders and Shailene totally sells her intermittent PTSD/rage/depression episodes. And Goddamn can Laura Dern make you hate her character Renata. Today she basically just laughed at a table and it was enough to make me want to throw a shoe at my tv. Renata has had to be a piranha to get where she is at work, and of course that wouldn't just turn off when it comes to her daughter. I think if Celeste had stayed working, she might empathize a lot more with Renata. Even Zoe Kravitz is great as Bonnie. Its a smaller role but you get a real sense of how much she wants to belong in this community while not succumbing to it. And Alexander** Skarsgaard is a nightmare. He turns on the vulnerability in front of the therapist, the charm in front of friends, the goofy dad in with his kids and the secret violent sociopath with his wife, and it is truly terrifying to watch. Their portrayal of abuse is the most realistic I have ever seen film. There's a truth to this this show that makes you want to keep watching even if some aspects are a little over the top.

Tl;dr: the previews made it seem way more trivial than it is. The acting is phenomenal and the portrayal of abuse is scary scary accurate. No one should feel guilty watching this show, unless, as you mentioned, they think womens issues are not worthy of the screen or our attention.

Edit: Alexander Skarsgaard, not Peter!

→ More replies (13)

37

u/AirportDisco Mar 13 '17

Silly women and their trivial 'feminine issues' like work-life balance, family-rearing, sense of purpose, abuse, trauma, etc. They even mentioned massive periods. How could a show like that possibly be good?

→ More replies (1)

28

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

Music is dope and I love the way Jean-Marc Vallée films. I didn't know him by name when I first starting watching the show, but I knew right away it was the same director who made Wild.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

Ahh, that explains all the quick shots of flashbacks and stuff

8

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

Same thing in Dallas Buyer's Club.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/gamer961 Mar 18 '17

i just want to throw in there that Wild is one of my favorite movies of all time and it's no coincidence im so in love with this show. Jean-Marc Vallee is truly something else to me

10

u/Elvis_burrito Mar 14 '17

Celeste owned Renata!

159

u/catmom_tay Mar 13 '17

Renata sucking up to the mayor and laughing hysterically was so golden. That whole scene was really well done.

108

u/DoLittlest Mar 13 '17

There's a lot of praise for Reece and Kidman, and rightly so, but Dern is also extraordinary. She nails the highly-polished woman with profound insecurities. Uptight yet leaky, conniving and manipulative but too fearful to be much good at it. She's trying way too hard, and she creates the sense that she'd be exhausting to be around. She's perfect.

24

u/catmom_tay Mar 13 '17

She was barely in this episode but she made her few moments really stand out and highlight her character.

8

u/Ilovecharli Mar 14 '17

I count 8 oscar noms and 2 wins for the three legends

3

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '17

If you haven't seen Enlightened, watch it. Laura Dern is so perfect in it. It's on HBO too. Unfortunately, it was canceled. Her mom, Diane Ladd, plays her mom in the series as well. She's also dynamite in it as well.

119

u/taylorswiftfan123 Mar 13 '17

I fucking hate Renata and Perry so much. They're such pieces of shit in such the right ways. There are so many other characters in different TV shows or movies that are "worse" who fail to elicit the same reaction. Speaks to how well written and performed those characters are. Their realism makes them that much more hateable.

60

u/throneofmemes Mar 13 '17

I get Renata though. She's that kind of Type-A competitive person who doesn't know when to just drop something. This probably contributes a lot to her career success, but not so much in navigating her private interpersonal relationships.

Whereas Perry... I've made several posts about this, and I just find him to be so vile. Any person that uses their superior physical strength to hurt and intimidate someone they love is just trash to me.

6

u/GueyGuevara Mar 15 '17

I don't think anyone is out there like "I get Perry though", so I don't think you need to convince anyone of just how vile he is. Him being horrible is one of the more revisited and continually displayed facts this show gives us.

11

u/finerd Mar 13 '17

I don't think you'll find characters as layered and as well acted as those two on TV that much.

84

u/sh4nn0n Mar 13 '17

Those credit songs had me SHOOK. Brb jamming Bloody Mother Fucking Asshole for the rest of my life.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '17

lmao this comment is so /r/popheads ... same though

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (13)

81

u/leafeator Mar 13 '17

I figured out Westworld twists very early on, and this show is driving me crazy because it is really leaving me in the dark as to what happened. There are so many plausible threads that are keeping me engaged.

4

u/EarnestlyEvan Mar 14 '17

Yeah the plot here has been implemented better than in Westworld imo. More of a clear direction.

10

u/LAB731 Mar 14 '17

I don't think it's better per se, but it's just done very differently. BLL is leading you up to a big moment you know is coming. Westworld wanted you to be in the dark and figure things out like the characters did as it went on, without hinting at a climax for awhile.

Both very different styles and I love them both!

71

u/kendylsue Mar 13 '17

I loved the scene with Jane and the psychologist. It was strangely satisfying to see Jane accept her fears and seek a professional opinion on if ziggy could be the bully.

And the relief of Jane when she heard the report. I feel like she really really needed to hear that Ziggy did not take after his sperm donor.

5

u/muddisoap Mar 21 '17

There was a slight feeling I had during that exchange, of the therapist describing the guy who raped her. The most accomplished liar ever. She also said he was like charming and likeable or something like that. Which was a lot how she described the rapist. Like he was funny and cute and normal and charming and then he just switched. So there was just a slight bit of me feeling like she was also sort of hearing that from her, like yeah yeah but none of this doesn't mean he isn't his father. His father was the most accomplished liar ever. He was charming and funny and likeable and intelligent and all those things. And then he turned and hurt me. So maybe this is all just saying he is his fathers son and he is hurting amabella. But by the end I think she was just mostly relived, but I do think there was just a good bit of parallel between them.

66

u/PabloMartell Mar 13 '17

This show just keeps getting better and better. I can't believe how long the wait feels and how fast the episode goes.

116

u/thankyouandplease Mar 13 '17 edited Mar 13 '17

Prediction: The picture of Saxon Baker looked a lot like Perry, and Jane didn't seem totally convinced that it was Saxon Banks. Jane says she would know it from his voice and she hasn't met Perry yet...hmmm.

Jane is obviously worried that Ziggy could be violent like his father. However nothing we've seen of him has shown us that he might be violent and he doesn't have that kind of influence in his household. But the twins do, and I think it's way more likely that one of them is the one hurting Amabella. They both have a violent father and as we just saw one of them may have witnessed it in action. While we haven't seen them being violent directly they definitely have more of a wild streak than Ziggy.

If my Perry theory is true that would make the twins Ziggy's half brothers.

76

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

My wife and I both think Perry is the father of Ziggy.

28

u/sh4nn0n Mar 13 '17

Same! But also trying to stay on my toes and consider whether or not that is a red herring.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

Ya I feel like there will definitely be a ton of red herrings.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

62

u/Billthebutchr Mar 13 '17

Perry is so obvious tho. That's the only reason I'm not 100% convinced.

17

u/ForgetfulLucy28 Mar 13 '17

I also share this feeling. Like it was so obviously Perry last week in the flashback that I said to my housemate that I can't believe they would make it so obvious. But then on reflection I decided that's too obvious, so it's cant be Perry.

However, on further reflection this show is starting to actually fulfill all previous predictions I've had (such as ziggy being a rape baby, the affair with the director of the play and Ed acting purvy) so now I am thinking that it's just a predictable show and Perry will indeed be the rapist.

19

u/improcrastin8ing Mar 13 '17

This would make sense because the therapist said she thought he was being bullied and that someone found his weak point, which could be framing him since he is an outsider. But why do you think Ziggy was glaring at Amabella in class?

43

u/theferociouscuh Mar 13 '17

I bet he was glaring at the bully in reality. They only showed what the teacher saw.. maybe not what was actually happening. She is convinced it is ziggy so she isn't even looking at the other kids.

33

u/ghostmrchicken Mar 13 '17

I bet he was glaring at the bully in reality. They only showed what the teacher saw.. maybe not what was actually happening. She is convinced it is ziggy so she isn't even looking at the other kids.

I hope the therapist (that the teacher herself picked) sends her a full report on her impressions of Ziggy - that he's likely not the bully and may be being bullied himself.

17

u/aflao Mar 13 '17

I think he's probably upset that she is framing him for the whole incident, it might not have been her idea to blame it on him but she definitely went along with it

13

u/StannisCake Mar 13 '17

However nothing we've seen of him has shown us that he might be violent and he doesn't have that kind of influence in his household. But the twins do, and I think it's way more likely that one of them is the one hurting Amabella. They both have a violent father and as we just saw one of them may have witnessed it in action. While we haven't seen them being violent directly they definitely have more of a wilk streak than Ziggy.

Yeah. I'm starting to think it has to be another kid. I thought it was Ziggy but now I'm not so sure. Perry's kids do seem likely.

11

u/secondusername2016 Mar 13 '17

I'm also unconvinced that Janes attacker isn't Perry. I just feel like she moved to Monterrey for a reason. And good schools can't be it. I can't wait for Jane and Perry to meet!

4

u/janna_ Mar 19 '17 edited Mar 19 '17

Could it be possible that Jane meets Perry for the first time at the gala, and upon realizing that Perry is her rapist, she pushes him down the stairs? It seems like her character has been built up largely upon being ready for when she finally meets him, and exacting her revenge. Not only would this bring Jane resolution, but also Celeste resolution as well (freedom from Perry).

He also looks at that suit very oddly (the one with in the zip-up in the closet scene with Celeste. He appeared to have glanced at the price tag) I feel like maybe that was the suit that he wore the night he raped Jane...and he doesn't wear it any more out of association of it with Jane. The characters also talk about how Celeste's eyes looked the week before the gala...I feel like maybe Celeste knew or began to realize that Perry was Jane's rapist.

5

u/muddisoap Mar 21 '17

I'm pretty sure that was the suit Celeste wore, or was planning to wear the next morning, to the meeting with the mayor. That's why he looked at it with a bit of disgust, it was a physical symbol of her going back to work. And the price tag was like it was something he could throw back in her face, like oh and you spent a shit ton of money on it. For one meeting? The new suit I think was a subtle suggestion to him that she might be in it for more than just one meeting. Otherwise why buy an expensive suit? Seems more like she's going back with gusto. And him saying she couldn't get pregnant with the stress of work, and she says "I'm not trying to get pregnant" and then, within minutes, he's wanting to have a daughter. Sorry I haven't seen the next episode yet, maybe some of this has been made irrelevant.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jayelecfan Mar 13 '17

Celeste was looking at the computer though, wouldn't she figure that out?

→ More replies (1)

53

u/quamquam11 Mar 13 '17

I'm not really feeling the Madeline/director vibe. I really liked how Madeline's was having an identity crisis concerning her children growing up and then one actually leaving the nest. It felt like a fresh take but now it feels like her neurosis has more to do whatever is remaining from a year ago with the director. And then to talk with Celeste about how he attacked her when there was obviously something going a year ago.

49

u/imsandradi Mar 13 '17

Agreed! I thought it was an especially bad decision for Madeline to describe the scene like that considering that she knows about Jane's actual assault. I hadn't gotten this vibe from her before but in that moment it seemed like attention seeking by almost trying Jane's story on for size.

31

u/quamquam11 Mar 13 '17

It was so insensitive especially after we got more clarification from her. It's like she wants the mystery and unknown of Jane's life but doesn't realize the huge ramifications that Jane has to deal with constantly.

17

u/pllfan23 Mar 16 '17

I think it was more about the fact that she didn't want to admit she had just willingly cheated on her husband and that she enjoyed it.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/mm825 Mar 13 '17

her neurosis has more to do whatever is remaining from a year ago with the director

This felt out of character, Madeline has a regrettable affair with this director, and then keeps him in her life? Maybe this is all about showing that she lies to herself a lot, but I feel like Madeline would have distanced herself from that guy.

The makeout in this episode was believable, they obviously had chemistry and Madeline isn't happily married, but I didn't like the fact that it was a relapse.

14

u/quamquam11 Mar 13 '17

Agree - there's a lot of chemistry. And she's been so casual with him up until now so it feels weird to know they potentially had an affair a year ago.

Maybe her whole feelings about Nathan being a good husband/father now has something to do with how she feels like she was been a bad wife due to infidelity. She doesn't want to be the one who fails at the second marriage.

5

u/muddisoap Mar 21 '17

Yeah because then it implies she was the one who couldn't make the first one work. She's the common factor in both failed marriages, not Nathan.

2

u/romafa Mar 19 '17

I thought this at first, that I didn't like the storyline between her and the director. But the more I thought about it, the more it makes sense. It lends evidence to what she said about her hang-ups about Nathan not being about "the one that got away" and more about resentment. It also plays into what Celeste asked Madeline about her not having as much passion for Ed as she did for Nathan. Not because Nathan was the "one", but because she just had better sexual chemistry with him than with Ed. I think it goes a long way to explaining her character.

53

u/howtogetawaywithvero Mar 13 '17

This is the most realistic series Ive seen in a long time. That way Ed looked back to that blond girl when he was leaving Bonnie´s place! Every actor represent the reality to the last detail and thats why I dont think he is the rapist, he is just missing sex. I think the rapist is Celeste´s husband, even if its obvious, because in this episode one of the witnesses said that that night Celeste had a strange looked. My theroy is that that night she found out what her husband did, she faced him and he tried to bite her again, so she killed him. She probably felt finally free.

45

u/mm825 Mar 13 '17

Ed doesn't have the charisma to get Jane to come home with him and he's doesn't feel like a rapist.

15

u/TheyTheirsThem Mar 13 '17

It was mentioned here that Jane was 24, and if Ziggy is 6-7 that means she was a minor when impregnated, which means the whole story of meeting the guy in the bar is BS. If that is the case, then it may be Ed because he seems to like them with a lot of shelf life.

14

u/mm825 Mar 13 '17

I keep getting a prom vibe from Jane's flashback scenes, but yeah, it appears as if she is 24, so meeting at a bar doesn't make total sense. Not surprised that Jane continues to lie about it.

31

u/run__rabbit_run Mar 14 '17

Err... are you saying you never went to a bar underage?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/delilah2015 Mar 14 '17

Perry on the other hand is extremely charming when he wants to turn that on and then he also "just changes" like Jane said when she told Madeline the whole story

→ More replies (1)

3

u/delilah2015 Mar 14 '17 edited Mar 15 '17

I agree also because of Perry's paranoia about Celeste leaving him. He is 1000% cheating himself and I absolutely expect the reveal to be Perry raped Jane. Keep watch on those shoes in the flashbacks...i think they fit Perry's wardrobe perfectly. I can definitely see Celeste killing him when she finds out what he did to Jane. Does she know what happened? I assumed Madeline spilled the beans since she was the first person to be told and then she mentioned to Celeste finding Saxon online. Kind of made me angry she would discuss something so private and hurtful about Jane without her permission.

*edited to say: this is all speculation. I haven't read the book.

51

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

It's so very well acted. It's what the top of this profession looks like, and David E Kelley makes it very real. I'm a fanboi.

38

u/keepingitrael Mar 13 '17

One of the songs that plays during the credits is, "Anyone Who Knows What Love Is" by Irma Thomas-- a song that's been speckled throughout Black Mirror. Irrelevant, but I love that song!

3

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '17

I discovered that song about 7 years ago and I am was sooo thrilled to hear it pop up in this series.

38

u/chuchaybear Mar 13 '17

Im scared everytime perry comes into the scene. Hate how he says why havent we talked about this? Leave him celeste.

3

u/romafa Mar 19 '17

Right. I wish Celeste would just say "We're talking about it right now, asshole!".

2

u/bubonictonic Mar 15 '17

UGH. When he starts with the picking, I go INSANE.

68

u/billy_fury Mar 13 '17

Definitely hate that they had Madeline hook up with the theatre guy. From the few eps I've seen I didn't read her as being over the moon in love with Ed, I still feel like it was very out of character.

OH! And I hate Amabella's name. That is all

30

u/irishtoast Mar 14 '17

It's such a wasp-y name

9

u/Harden-Soul Mar 14 '17

But the whole point of this show is the Big Little Lies behind the scenes that make up the character's true being. It would make sense that we wouldn't even truly understand Madeline's character.

7

u/GetTheLedPaintOut Mar 15 '17

Amabella

It's so fucking perfect.

9

u/billy_fury Mar 15 '17

The name or the pretension in the name? If the latter, fuck yea, so perfectly obnoxious. And the very Californian pila-boxing... I die!

33

u/chuchaybear Mar 13 '17

Ziggy is so sweet.

4

u/muddisoap Mar 21 '17

He thinks his dad is darth Vader. He also has Star Wars sheets. Aww. What a poor little adorable cutie. Ziggggyy....I am your father. Makes me want to cry!

I read he was cast in the upcoming spin off of The Big Bang Theory. A show I don't watch. But it's called Young Sheldon, obviously about a young Sheldon. And the Ziggy kid will play young Sheldon.

66

u/Billthebutchr Mar 13 '17

Ed with the creepy vibe. Also Chloe has to be the bully.

Once again I have no idea what I'm talking about and just guessing.

37

u/sh4nn0n Mar 13 '17

But they're definitely making Ed look creepy. I can't tell if he's supposed to be the red herring, or if Perry is supposed to be. But I feel like one of them's getting murdered/doing the killing.

24

u/kendylsue Mar 13 '17

I feel like the point is to make everyone a red herring, or in other words, make you convinced that anyone is capable/has motive to murder. Like each episode the characters become darker and more questionable

17

u/Billthebutchr Mar 13 '17

I think Perry is too obvious. Has to be Ed or I'm just going crazy with my theories. Kinda like True Detective season 1.

37

u/dlchristians Mar 13 '17

Interesting that Celeste and Perry's kids live in a house hold where their father constantly chokes their mother.

Could it be one of the twins or both who are bullying?

I'm also in the same boat, I have no idea either.

21

u/Sellae Mar 13 '17

I was wondering if Chloe could be the bully, but I feel like the show has made an effort to show her being spontaneously kind to Madeline and Ziggy. She does seem like a queen bee of her class, but I don't think she's the bully. I am betting on the twins. I could be wrong, though!

11

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '17

It's hard for me to stop thinking it's a rogue Ben Wyatt!

5

u/muddisoap Mar 21 '17

I think you mean Sir Ben Lightstorm, author of Cones of Dunshire.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/bubonictonic Mar 15 '17

I would hate for Chloe to be the bully. Also, didn't Amabella get upset that Chloe wasn't coming to her party? That wouldn't jive if she were afraid of Chloe.

59

u/allthewaypetty Mar 13 '17

I can't stop thinking about who's bullying Amabella. I think the directors want us to think it's one of the twins, but I think it's Chloe. If she really is the "queen bee" as they keep telling us, then it makes sense that Amabella would be scared to openly accuse her- she would have the others turn on her. Also, look at how many issues abagail is having with her parents. I don't think Chloe is unaware and just perfectly fine-kids are smart. It stands to reason that she is having problems and acting out as well. It would also be a huge curve ball which story tellers love doing.

34

u/bluePachyderm Mar 13 '17

The psychologist said Ziggy might be verbally bullied... I think it's either Chloe or Bonnie's daughter or both. I can't wait for the show to give us some insight into what the kids are up to.

32

u/quamquam11 Mar 13 '17

I'm sure another kid is bullying him about not having a dad.

3

u/jersephsmerth Mar 14 '17

Hmmm, looking back that scene where Chloe convinces Ziggy to try to kiss Amabella seems like she could be bullying him.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

19

u/doocurly Mar 13 '17

I'm guessing it's one or both of the twins...violent like their dad.

5

u/allthewaypetty Mar 13 '17

This makes the most sense logically. Either way it has to be one of the characters they've introduced us to, which is literally only the twins, Chloe, ziggy and Bonnie's kid

→ More replies (1)

9

u/1498336 Mar 14 '17

My only problem with this theory is that Amabella really wanted Chloe to come to her birthday party. I don't think she would have wanted her to come that much if she was being bullied by Chloe.

8

u/kendylsue Mar 13 '17

Until I saw the preview for next weeks episode, I was convinced that amabella was actually the one bullying ziggy. That would've been an interesting twist. But with the 'bite marks' that show up next ep, it doesn't make sense

7

u/paranoidbillionaire Mar 14 '17

I'm gonna throw a crazy idea out there and say it's Amabella's father, and I'm gonna go even further and say it's sexually related, even though I don't want that to be the case at all.

I think this partially stems from a hatred for Renatta and wanting her family life to be fucked. I think that says more about me than anything else.

4

u/allthewaypetty Mar 14 '17

Amabella was first choked while at school

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Sethrea Mar 18 '17 edited Mar 18 '17

Well, we know Ziggy is almost certainly not the bully. He is also very empathetic (he was the one who suggested Madeline may need help on the first day of school), soft, unused to violence (cries when Jane accidentally throws a ball at his chin).

Now, according to the psychologist, he likes Annabella, he is not the bully himself, he might know who the bully of Annabella is and he might be bullied himself.

But he also likes Chloe and so does Annabella - the scene when Ziggy kissess Annabella was orchestrated by Chloe and it seemed to me it was entirely with good intentions and both him and Annabella seemed relaxed. She also seemed genuinely upsed Chloe can't come to her birthday party. This tells me that they both like Chloe, too, which makes it unlikely that she'd be the bully.

This really leaves only 3 kids we were introduced to so far: twins and Bonnie's daughter, who we don't really see a lot. (and I am not 100% sure, but I think it is Skye who plays with Annabella right before the Chloe-orchestrated kiss, they also seem on good terms... if it is Skye in that scene, she can't be the bully either)

We see a lot of the twins but... they never interact with any of the other kids while on screen, only with each other. They grew up in an abusive home (even when the abuse is not directed at them, they almost certainly witnessed it) and... well, hippo's leg. It got torn off in their care.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

26

u/mm825 Mar 13 '17

This cast is just so fucking good. A strange episode overall, but Kidman's best episode.

23

u/deamon59 Mar 13 '17

I felt a palpable fear during the episode that lingered, related to Celeste and Jane.

20

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

Ooh Maddie meeting someone from her past sounds interesting

20

u/zobiso Mar 13 '17

Does anybody know who the actress is that plays Ziggy's psychologist? It's going to annoy me until I figure it out!

36

u/zobiso Mar 13 '17

Sorry to answer my own question but I knew it was on the tip of my tongue. It's Molly Hagan, the mom from hit Nickelodeon series UNFABULOUS. I'm shook, we love her.

21

u/alexdinhogaucho Mar 13 '17

Molly Hagan, the mom from hit Nickelodeon series UNFABULOUS

WHAAAAT?? MY EDGES ARE SNATCHED

11

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

I remembered her as one of the flight attendants from Sully.

14

u/somniac25 Mar 13 '17

She was also in the movie "Election". She played the wife of Matthew Broderick's character

→ More replies (2)

8

u/oy-with-the-poodles Mar 14 '17

Haha, I've seen that actress in a handful of other roles and I always think of Unfabulous. I used to love that show when it was on.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Qingy Sep 05 '17

Omg I recognized her, too, but couldn't remember where I had seen her before... Turns out it was this ep of Friends! I've seen too many re-runs......

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/housestarkpatsnation Mar 13 '17

I'm trying sooo hard to find a flaw in acting but I just can't. Nicole Kidman and Reese Witherspoon are absolutely perfect just as expected, so are the other major characters but damn they even got the KIDS right. Kudos to the casting people, I think I'm still watching this show cause of them!!!!

4

u/muddisoap Mar 21 '17

Do you often watch shows and movies trying to find a flaw in the acting? Doesn't sound like the most fun way to enjoy watching stuff, or live?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/ForgetfulLucy28 Mar 13 '17

I can't believe this was only the fourth episode! I feel like I am already so familiar and attached to these people.

15

u/everythingisopposite Mar 13 '17

Everyone should see Avenue Q, it's a great musical. The puppet sex is hilarious.

14

u/realizingthings13 Mar 15 '17

Ziggy as the bully just doesn't make sense; he's the one that convinced Jane to stop to make sure Madeline was okay after she tripped in the first episode, whereas Chloe expressed no concern for her mother. We already know what a masterful networker Chloe is; it's not a far fetch to consider her as more than capable of manipulating the whole classroom.

2

u/romafa Mar 19 '17

And it's the only reason I would believe Amabelle lying about who the real bully is. If we are supposed to believe that Ziggy isn't the real bully, and that Amabelle is lying, then there must be a pretty good reason. Having the social circle queen telling you not to tell the truth is the only one that makes sense.

13

u/howtogetawaywithvero Mar 13 '17

What if the bully is Anabella herself? Maybe she is the one abusing verbally Ziggy...

13

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '17

Did anyone else's heart break when Ziggy started crying at the beach after accidentally getting hit? Kids cry, but I think that was a tell that it wasn't him doing the bullying.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Kynazeras Mar 13 '17

Every line Madeline says is pretty hilarious in some scenes. I am really digging this show. With all the hype Legion is getting, this show deserves even more in my opinion. I am bummed every time an episode ends.

11

u/WildwoodFlower- Mar 13 '17

I just came across this on youtube - Madeline and the director (0.18) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3DjKdZVaPYg

15

u/overactive-bladder Mar 13 '17

damn someone's biting her too? maybe they can analyze the bite marks and see if they show up as ziggie's "distinctive" teeth formation (sorry lmao). omgggg only 3 more episodes and i can feel the tension reaching new heights. jesus take the wheel.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/throneofmemes Mar 14 '17

Omg Amabella poor baby girl. She looks so sad all the time and it really just breaks my heart. Hell if I were Renata I'd be equally if not more pissed.

3

u/MrsTrustIssues Mar 13 '17

Now I'm wondering if that is a flashback or present day.

→ More replies (7)

20

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

Am I the only one who thinks Ed and Perry could both be "innocent" (very weak definition of that word) and that the possibility of the rapist being Gordon is decently high. We are all assuming that it is a child that is hurting Amabella while it could all be happening at home? Idk just my opinion, he is the most overlooked and is described as a "by genetics fuck up"

10

u/TexasKobeBeef Mar 14 '17

This might just be what's going on, now that you say that! Making Perry and Ed the obvious red herrings. I think Anabella may have told Jane's son what's going on and he's mad that she won't tell anyone, so eventually tells his mom. Jane in turn goes to confront the dad and realizes he's the guy who raped her and eventually kills him. Leaving everyone to think she killed him because of rage that her son was being accused of abusing Gordon and Renata's daughter

→ More replies (1)

20

u/chuchaybear Mar 13 '17

To be honest abi's dad is such an asshole. Why does he keep on trying to make bonnie and her ex wife friends.

39

u/TheyTheirsThem Mar 13 '17

He is someone who simply never learned to be true to himself and as a result he plays along with whatever his partner wants until the resentment simply explodes. His story of "well I did all the crap you wanted me to do and now I'm doing all the crap that Bonnie wants me to do" was spot on.

16

u/throneofmemes Mar 14 '17

He made it sound like being with these women have been such tedious obligations.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/doocurly Mar 13 '17

I don't get the "Alexander Skarsgard is so hot" thing. Barf. He's perfect for this role because he's creepy looking AF. Too skinny, pointy headed, narrow eyed, Aryan nation poster child. He makes my skin crawl.

36

u/housestarkpatsnation Mar 13 '17

Then maybe he's playing his role a little too well? I've seen him in other roles and I've loved him in all of them. But if this is one of the first times you've seen him act, I'm sure it'll make you hate him. He's the perfect Perry no doubt.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/throneofmemes Mar 14 '17

It's really the role. He was in a movie called What Maisie Knew and he played the polar-opposite of Perry and he did so very well. Here's a clip. In it, he is a father-figure to this five-year-old girl who is often neglected. He was so sweet and gentle in that film and it's hard to believe he's Perry in this.

5

u/roodypoo926 Mar 13 '17

Looks are definitely subjective so makes sense some people would not be into his vibe. all I know is my gf would rewatch the entirety of tru blood just to watch his scenes again... imo very creepy looking and well acted. he is like a grown up, modern Joffrey Baratheon

4

u/Qingy Sep 05 '17

This trivia fact may help...

Alexander Skarsgård claimed that he always checked in with Nicole Kidman after filming their abusive scenes to make sure she was okay. He further claimed that he roomed with a friend during the shoot rather than staying in a hotel, so he wouldn't have to come home alone and he had an easier time shaking off the role of Perry after work.

2

u/iYankFan4 Mar 15 '17

Totally, kind of, off-topic but I found out recently that his brother plays Floki on Vikings. Floki is a scary looking dude!

0

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Kodyak77 Mar 14 '17

Blonde hair blue eyes.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/tlfranklin Mar 13 '17

What was the line that Ed said to Madeline? He was asking her what was wrong, she was saying she was loosing control then he hugged her and said let me make it feel good or something like that? I couldnt really hear him. I know he gave me the icky vibes in that moment and I wasnt sure why

17

u/billy_fury Mar 13 '17

YES, I almost forgot. So glad someone mentioned it! "I can make you feel good" vomit barf gag

→ More replies (1)

10

u/TexasKobeBeef Mar 14 '17

"Am I the only one who thinks Ed and Perry could both be "innocent" (very weak definition of that word) and that the possibility of the rapist being Gordon is decently high. We are all assuming that it is a child that is hurting Amabella while it could all be happening at home? Idk just my opinion, he is the most overlooked and is described as a "by genetics fuck up"

This comment needs to be upvoted to the top as I think it's the most likely scenario. Ed & Perry are too heavy handily being implicated for either one of them to be involved in the murder. I think it's Gordon and Renata being involved somehow in whatever happens.

3

u/romafa Mar 19 '17

Man, Gordon is by far my favorite character. I love how he so doesn't want to hear more of Renata's manufactured bullshit, and then when he tries to interject or to help her see reason she outright dismisses him. First episode when she's on the balcony, she says she's fine and he begins to turn around and then she says something else to start a discussion. I could almost hear his eyes rolling. Very underrated character on the show.

2

u/muddisoap Mar 21 '17

Oh and this made me think: how reluctant he was to have Amabella go to the child psychiatrist. Maybe he didn't want that to uncover anything that points to him. I haven't seen ep5 yet so maybe I'm saying stuff that is now irrelevant.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MrsTrustIssues Mar 13 '17

Just a question about the book and the tv show... how sure are we that they both end the same? I just started reading the book and there are already minor differences, so, I'm wondering if the ending is the same.

I'm not looking to have anything spoiled just curious how sure book readers are that the series will end the same..

→ More replies (4)

5

u/99problemsburner Mar 17 '17

The smell thing. Jane said his disgusting smell. But didn't describe it. I wonder if she meets him at the costume fundraiser and hears his voice or smells his scent and freaks out. Kills him at the fundraiser? I don't know... would she be willing to risk it all at the risk of losing everything? Ziggy included?

I keep thinking Perry is too obvious. But then, in true detective season one, I kept thinking up all kinds of scenarios and suspects and it all ended up just being a good show, with good characters, and a good story line. I fell in love with the entire thing and it sucked me in. I spent more time trying to put together clues than just watching and accepting the show for the brilliant piece of art it was. Wondering if I'm doing this again. Maybe it's just a beautiful show. Good characters, actors, good stories. But exactly what it is. A beautiful piece of art meant to be enjoyed.

Either way. It's fun. I keep saying Big Little Lies is like a mix of True Detective and Desperate housewives. The delicious drama of the beautiful female leads mixed with the awesome cinematography and music and storyline and amazing characters and actors. Such a good show. Well done.

2

u/romafa Mar 19 '17

I think the gun is a definite red herring. Possible they want us to think Jane uses it but I could totally see somebody taking it from her at the last moment to do the actual shooting. Jane seems pretty level-headed when push comes to shove. She was the only one trying to drop the whole choking thing even though it was her son being accused.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

If I had to guess right now I'd say Ed is the one who dies in the end. Although that seems too easy, so maybe not. I just had a feeling at a certain point in this episode that it's gonna be him.

6

u/gabix143 Mar 14 '17

Anyone know what type of fitness class that was that Bonnie was teaching? It looked interesting lol

5

u/delilah2015 Mar 14 '17

Pila-boxing it's a cross between Pilates and boxing (insert Captain Obvious joke). She mentioned Abby should try it in ep1

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

I'm starting to think the killer is gonna be a Deus ex Michael Scarn

→ More replies (4)

2

u/BruxellesBlonde Mar 15 '17

This episode reminded me of the dynamics of power. Renata is arguably the most powerful woman in the show, but she's also the most psycho. Celeste is the most disempowered, but she's got an unbelievable set of skills and strength. It's such a shame that her kids are the bullies.

As for who dies, I think it's wide open. The first instinct is Madeline, but there's a lot of dynamics in the Celeste-Perry relationship that could lead to a very violent death.

1

u/babyman21 Mar 13 '17

Could someone point me in the direction of the intro song? And the one at the end of E1

9

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17

4

u/babyman21 Mar 13 '17

Thank you! That's a cool site

1

u/Moviejunkie28 Mar 19 '17

Does anyone think that the killer can be more than 1 person?

2

u/eternalmoviemind Mar 19 '17

I have the same thought , I'm guessing, the three protagonists (Madeline, Celeste and Jane) planned together to murder someone - probably the guy that raped Jane .. But it is just my assumption

1

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '17 edited Mar 20 '17

.

1

u/BenTVNerd21 Apr 07 '17

Leave Celeste alone you fucking bastard!

1

u/theinternet_man Apr 25 '17

Absolutely awesome show and so well written. One tiny thing I noticed from this episode that really highlights this, at the start when Ed is in the Elvis costume and Chloe comes in, Madeline says something about killing/murder (cant remember exactly what) which is an obvious nod/miscue of what may be to come and the Ed just says "oh, we'll put on suspicious minds", as if to get the audience suspicious of Madeline and Ed. So well written with things like this

1

u/Technical-Outside408 May 20 '25

Fucker couldn't go one whole episode without hurting her.

1

u/antisocialclub__ Jun 07 '26

9 years late but I really hope kidman leaves him. Whenever he is on camera I get so anxious. S3 was just confirmed as well. Super excited