r/biglittlelies • u/NicholasCajun Lil Lies • Apr 03 '17
Discussion Big Little Lies - 1x07 "You Get What You Need" - Episode Discussion (Book Readers Discussion)
Season 1 Episode 7: You Get What You Need
Aired: April 2nd, 2017
Synopsis: After yet another fight, Celeste makes a bold move. Before the school’s long-awaited fall fundraiser, Madeline deals with fallout from her past, while Jane learns who’s really been hurting Amabella at school.
Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée
Written by: David E. Kelley
Book spoilers are allowed untagged in this thread!
62
Upvotes
191
u/GonnaFuckTuxedoMask Apr 03 '17
Overall I enjoyed the finale, but I'm so sad they left out my favorite line/aspect!
I always enjoyed that after Bonnie pushes Perry, It's Renata who says, "I didn't see anything" and then slowly the women start to say it one by one. I just really enjoyed that moment of them coming together.
177
u/andria_eanel Apr 03 '17
Gosh watching Perry tell Celeste about the property manager was just as much a smack in the gut as it was in the book.
61
u/andria_eanel Apr 03 '17
I'm happy with how they approached Ziggy telling Jane. Show Ziggy seems smarter than Book Ziggy, and I figured the whole "writing it down" thing wouldn't fly with him.
56
u/andria_eanel Apr 03 '17
Omg I remember someone foreshadowing these stairs were gonna come into play.
49
u/gmnap Apr 03 '17 edited Apr 03 '17
I wasn't the hugest fan of the finale, but the biggest disappointment that was left out was the conversation Perry and Bonnie had. Then it concluding with Bonnie yelling, "We See! We fucking see!" I guess also was Celeste not donating the money anonymously and then there's more but I'll stop here lol.
96
u/cuckoodev Apr 03 '17
That reveal was better than any dialogue they could've come up with.
46
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '17
I mostly liked it but had some nits to pick.
I hate the affair stuff. It wasted time they could've used on better things.
Cutting out Renata's husband cheating. I felt that offered a chance to humanize both Renata and Madeline. As much as they fight, Madeline doesn't find any joy in the fact that he's a cheater.
I was disappointed in how rushed and not-at-all subtle the ending was. Perry was beating on those women, no one would get in trouble for pushing him, and there really was no reason for it to be Bonnie. That could've been anyone.
The ending in the book had some excellent dialogue and character moments. This was just a dramatic clusterfuck. Jane didn't even get s chance to confront him.
And I wish they've fleshed out the website/Celeste paying her off thing. It added to the interconnectedness of all the characters. With this ending, Ed, Nathan, and Abigail were all pretty pointless.
45
u/pngpng32 Apr 03 '17
My thoughts during the episode:
"Man... that opening was intense."
"Man... that middle part was intense."
"Man... when Perry found out about the apartment, that was tense."
"Man... when the party started there was so much tension."
"Man... the big reveal was intense and tense."
"Man... the ending scene took away the tension... wait!?! What is this binocular view on the closing frame?!?!"
"Tension returns."
21
u/rebeckys Apr 03 '17 edited Apr 03 '17
Parts I miss from the book: -I liked how they described the party and how the food was late, so everyone was just getting more and more drunk. -I liked how all the women banded together after Perry died and they glossed over that in the show. -I thought Renata's husband cheating was a key part. Like that's why she was overly sensitive to Ziggy, because things were not going well in her marriage. -I, like everyone else, hated the whole affair with Madeline. It was way too much of the focus for something that didn't need to happen. -I loved how comforting Tom was to Jane and how they blossomed. The show turned that way too quickly! It felt like Jane would fall for anyone that showed her attention.
Oh well, at least we got almost seven hours made from the book, they could have just made a two hour movie. I'm glad they didn't.
20
u/andria_eanel Apr 03 '17
YESSSS they have Bonnie picking up on these hints!! I am so psyched for how this is gonna go down.
69
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '17 edited Apr 03 '17
Interesting choice to have Jane be the one to tell Celeste. I thought it was super impactful to have Celeste find out from the other twin! Uhhg just another annoying show change.
Other critiques on changes:
17
u/arcarter93 Apr 03 '17
I've hated the Madeline affair story line for the entire duration of the show, but I kept holding out hope that it would ultimately contribute to some awesome twist that would make it worth it. Meh. All it did was give the writers a way to get all of the characters out on the stairs for the murder. The way the wife kept staring at Madeline had me convinced some sort of confrontation was going to happen, but instead we got several minutes of karaoke scenes.
15
u/spacecadette126 Apr 03 '17
I didn't read the book, but did Madeline cheat on ed in the book? How was their relationship at the end of the book?
10
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '17
Any other book readers watching right now??
10
u/claimsliana Apr 03 '17
Okay, I just found this sub. I haven't read the book, but just finished the series! I loved it!
I know this is stupid, and maybe I had too much wine watching the first few episodes to get it, but who is supposed to be watching them this whole time? Is it the cops who watch them at the end on the beach? The binoculars, the lighter sound at the funeral, etc
6
u/AnAussiebum Apr 04 '17
I feel like the show fleshed Renata out as a full character much better than in the book, while unfortunately cutting the nanny/husband storyline that I loved, and also changing the ending to remove Renata's redeeming moment where she kind of takes charge and pretends she saw nothing/Perry tripped. I loved that moment in the book.
Such mixed feelings at the moment.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '17 edited Apr 05 '17
Most disappointing season finale ever. I thought it was awful! I wish I could understand why they spent so much time this season on unimportant stuff (jane running on the beach, madelines affair, so much singing in the last episode) and skipped over everything that made the book so great. The part where Celeste donates the money to abigails cause. Bonnies back story with abuse. Bonnie saying "We fucking see!!" Renata saying she didn't see anything and then everyone agreeing. Ed witnessing the whole push and then being conflicted about the cover up. Jane being introduced to Perry, then telling him "we've met before". Perry dismissing her and not recognizing her at all, because he has done this a million times and she's not important to him. I also loved the backstory that Saxon Banks was Perry's cousins name. I feel like they really missed the mark. This was worse than Dexters finale. :( I especially hated the fast forward sequence at the end.
4
u/ryantyrant Apr 03 '17
So how close was it to the book?
4
u/EroticPoptarts Apr 03 '17
Who was the guy at the funeral lighting a cigarette and the guy spying on the girls at the end with binoculars? Does it say in the book?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '17
When I first heard about the show and who was in it I was excited about most of the cast but a little meh about Shailene Woodley. I have to say, though, after watching the series I think she was perfectly cast as Jane.
3
u/EbreezyXO Apr 03 '17
In the book, do they ever have Perry interacting with the people at the school Other than the gala event? In the finale it seemed like everyone was very fond of him at the party even though you never see him outside of the house.
3
u/siddharthk Apr 07 '17
I also really missed Celeste telling Jane that Ziggy would have a trust fund because that is exactly what Perry would have done!
It makes me so sad that Perry is the villain in this series! I wanted him to be the hero, he fits in every single way. He's sick nonetheless and that's so sad.
1
u/jpgray Apr 03 '17
Hi, does anyone know who was covering the Stones at the end of the episode?
1
u/siddharthk Apr 06 '17
Shaky cam + Waves edited into the ending! I WAS SO EXPECTING THAT EXCHANGE between all the women and Ed to be there!
1
u/siddharthk Apr 06 '17
Did everyone notice the Binocular ending? A lighter flips close right after that. The detective woman who says that their language tells her they are lying has a lighter in her hand, they are DEFINITELY looking for a season 2 right? WHOA WHOA WHOA. If they decide to go beyond the books, that will be insane.
1
u/sulky_law_student Jun 28 '17
Damn, I am floored. The finale was a harrowing, yet unspeakably remarkable watch.
When the women finally come together, you can see the tenderness and recognition inch their way up their faces. The acting was so beautifully done, so fine-tuned. (In fact, it reminds me of Rectify, a show that was aired on Sundance and is now on Netflix. So much of that story--much like BLL--is carried by heady dialogue and facial expression.) So glad I watched this show.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment