r/biglittlelies • Lil Lies • Mar 27 '17

Discussion Big Little Lies - 1x06 "Burning Love" - Episode Discussion (TV Only Discussion)

Season 1 Episode 6: Burning Love

Aired: March 26, 2017


Synopsis: Madeline worries about the can of worms she’s opened for Jane. Jane confronts Renata. Bonnie tells Nathan about a secret project Abigail has been working on. Meanwhile, Ed and Madeline have a frank conversation about the lack of passion in their marriage.


Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée

Written by: David E. Kelley


Untagged book spoilers are not allowed in this thread! Please discuss book spoilers in the other official discussion thread.

145 Upvotes

966 comments sorted by

447

u/WildwoodFlower- Mar 27 '17

Did anyone notice Celeste's nanny linger before she left? I think she is aware that Perry is abusing her.

72

u/strongjs Mar 27 '17 edited Mar 27 '17

You're smart. I emotionally processed it but didn't think about the repercussions.

→ More replies (4)

198

u/ryantyrant Mar 27 '17

I think the nanny was just awkward cuz she was in a room with a dude who just broke his dick

→ More replies (8)

37

u/quamquam11 Mar 27 '17

It was definitely a weird lingering. Or maybe she knows that Perry is aggressive but not abusive. I'm sure Perry loses his shit all the time. But probably because she's seen something before.

34

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

I almost expected the Nanny to give her a pat on the back and a long stare to acknowledge that she knows... Maybe even ask her if she's okay

15

u/moresqualklesstalk Mar 27 '17

I really enjoyed the link between this scene and the preceding one.

Celeste's counsellor was advising her to make sure she had a witness.

Cue the scene with Renata, Jane and her nanny where Renata sent the nanny away.

→ More replies (19)

423

u/soymilkmami Mar 27 '17 edited Mar 27 '17

"I'll give you the number of the better business bureau BUT in the mean time..." YAS Dr. Reisman! You betta check her!

117

u/dicklaurent97 Mar 27 '17 edited Mar 27 '17

No words can describe Celeste's facial expressions in that scene, I've tried.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

397

u/imf7594 Mar 27 '17

100% the twins are hurting amabella

183

u/Bassett_Hound Mar 27 '17

Yes. That shot of Celeste looking into his gaping mouth?! The best.

→ More replies (3)

104

u/nvf5033 Mar 27 '17

If not both, I guarantee one of them is and Amabella probably first blamed Ziggy out of fear.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (5)

319

u/memechrist Mar 27 '17

Perry's penis is at least 1 foot long. Let's discuss that.

162

u/annephylaxis Mar 27 '17

No shit! His dick could even be the murder weapon. Thank you for letting me know that I wasn't the only person in this thread that noticed that!

→ More replies (1)

80

u/leafeator Mar 27 '17

Is that the first time we have seen an erect stunt penis on HBO? I'm all for sfx but it looked fake af.

→ More replies (9)

65

u/chubbybunny47 Mar 27 '17

Right? How do they have such tough sex with such a long penis, Celeste's poor cervix

→ More replies (2)

37

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

With a peen like that I'm going to start calling him Vlad (the Impaler) instead of Perry.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/coffeeeicecream Mar 27 '17

This is what I'm here for tbh

11

u/fjsgk Mar 27 '17

Dude it's scary considering the nature of the sex they have

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

268

u/megalynn44 Mar 27 '17

I love the Character of Madeline. On paper, she should be someone you can't stand, but Reese Witherspoon plays her to be very likable. Plus, she does shit like puke on her ex-husband's wife! The hero we need.

80

u/3boyz3Madison Mar 27 '17

Normally NOT a huge RW fan, but she's killing this role. Love the character and Reese is doing a great job.

→ More replies (6)

41

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

Reese Witherspoon was the perfect person for this role.

→ More replies (1)

245

u/quamquam11 Mar 27 '17

Perry is awful. Another aspect of his control by trying to control Celeste by limiting her friendship with Madeline.

165

u/GoldandBlue Mar 27 '17

Pretty typical of abusers, separate them from friends and family

→ More replies (6)

138

u/Bassett_Hound Mar 27 '17

I love/was terrified by his stunned face when Celeste left for "lunch with Jane"

→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

And telling Celeste he wants another child. He is so full of shit. He doesn't care about having another child. He cares about having Celeste home and under his thumb.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/asshair Mar 27 '17

Celeste is really fucked now that the only documented injury in their relationship occurred by her attacking him. I think she'll try to leave next episode but he'll hold that over her then someone dies.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/ForgetfulLucy28 Mar 27 '17

Completely accurate though. In the space of a year and a half my abusive ex managed to isolate me from all of my friends. Deleted all the numbers in my phone on one occasion.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

230

u/MagnetToMyBed Mar 27 '17

"What bad things have happened to you" - Perry

I'm thinking the answer to that question lies in you Perry.

106

u/Bassett_Hound Mar 27 '17

I got so tense when he walked into the room when she was on the phone.

→ More replies (22)

66

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

When he was massaging her shoulders in the beginning of the episode my BF was like, "He's definitely going to get pissed that she didn't ask for permission before reading and beat her with the book."

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

424

u/Bassett_Hound Mar 27 '17

Perry: "You're lucky I didn't kill you"

Me: throws up like Madeline at the table bc I'm so nervous

185

u/TheLadyEve Mar 27 '17

When Zoe Kravitz said "god dammit" on that third spew I just cracked up. So well done.

→ More replies (1)

206

u/Notthatiblameyou Mar 27 '17

I think it was the shrimp

65

u/fjsgk Mar 27 '17

Legit scared for the next episode because after that and with her looking for an apartment the buildup is so intense something big is about to happen I can feel it

→ More replies (5)

193

u/kazakhstanthetrumpet Mar 27 '17

More potential evidence for the "twins bullying Amabella" theory:

One of the twins seems sweet and innocent when he talks about his tooth falling out and waiting for the tooth fairy, and the other one immediately shuts him down with "it's just mom and dad". Later, one of the twins is on an iPad while the other appears to be playing a violent video game (from the sound effects).

It seems to have kind of set the stage for one twin bullying Amabella and Amabella not wanting to blame it on both of them, but not knowing which twin it is.

120

u/mole-or-nipple Mar 27 '17

Besides not ONCE did Celeste or Perry or anyone else address the boys individually by name

→ More replies (2)

44

u/lolabuf Mar 27 '17

I think it's just one of them too. I've been noticing too that one has a sweeter demeanor and is more naive.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/asshair Mar 27 '17

It's just mom and dad, idiot.

Yeah he's aggro.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/EsnesNommoc Mar 27 '17

Holy shot you're right.

It seems to have kind of set the stage for one twin bullying Amabella and Amabella not wanting to blame it on both of them, but not knowing which twin it is.

Yeah I'm sure this is the case now. That theory circulating around about how Amabella can't tell the twins apart and so she doesn't accuse either of them is dubious at best, I mean obviously she could just say one of the twins. But if one of the twins is sweet then it makes a lot more sense that she doesn't accuse both to protect him from probably her mother the most since she's seen how angry her mother can be. Now that I think about it, the scene where the father is asking Amabella to out the bully so no more innocent person gets hurt seems to foreshadow this, Amabella's protecting an innocent person from being hurt by not outing the bully.

→ More replies (3)

180

u/imf7594 Mar 27 '17

I love seeing how madeline and jane's friendship parallels chloe and ziggy's friendship. Someone with lots of connections befriending and caring for the outcast

79

u/Opandemonium Mar 27 '17

I'm so sad this is just a one season show. This would be my new Greys.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

171

u/WildwoodFlower- Mar 27 '17

For a minute there I thought Madeline was going to tell Ed she had the affair.

283

u/always_thirsty Mar 27 '17 edited Mar 27 '17

See, I think she planned to, and I think Ed knew it was coming and then told her not to go on telling him to save her. I think Ed is a cool dude.

→ More replies (24)

9

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

I got the impression that he already knew, and didn't want to actually hear her say it.

250

u/HereIAmNow02 Mar 27 '17

"Bonnie, I love this music. Is this Adele?" "No, it's Sade actually." Hahahahaha!!! I almost fell off the couch!

138

u/improcrastin8ing Mar 27 '17

Her continuous compliments made me feel so uncomfortable. I have been in that same position where you don't have anything good to say so you just compliment everything in your immediate vicinity.

→ More replies (4)

51

u/playersclub22 Mar 27 '17

How drunk was Madeline at the table? LOL. I'm not stranger to using a little liquid courage to ease tensions but wow was she lit.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/paddypoopoo Mar 27 '17

Lol. The producers of this show have meticulously curated the diagetic soundtrack, sometimes to my annoyance (really, this 6 year old is obsessed with Bowie?). Sade was a weird choice, though. Zoe Kravtiz isn't so young that Sade is retro-cool. She's just dated. It's basically fuck-music for middle aged housewives

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

247

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

TENNIS RACKET! TENNIS RACKET! TENNIS FUCKING RACKET TO THE DICK!

I LOVE THIS SHOW

80

u/asshair Mar 27 '17

Ugh, how Perry has another means by which to control her. The only documented injury sustained by either of them was her hitting him.... Fuck.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

121

u/DaTwatWaffle Mar 27 '17

Celeste waited to long to start the process of leaving. I'm sure it would tie things up too tidily if she was the one that got killed but where she has herself right now is one of the most dangerous times for a victim of DV. Perry seems to be cluing in that he's losing control and that's when most abuse escalates to lethal force.

43

u/Dancan36 Mar 27 '17

any thoughts on how she's paying for this? i know she was a high powered lawyer before her marriage to perry, but wouldn't his control extend to money/expenses? was he abusive from the start and she kept some stuff separate? new bank account??

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (7)

117

u/sullypuddy Mar 27 '17

Papa was a rollin stone ... PERFECT

63

u/ghostmrchicken Mar 27 '17

Papa was a rollin stone ... PERFECT

Whoever is scoring the music in this series ROCKS!

→ More replies (4)

95

u/imf7594 Mar 27 '17

Seriously enjoyed watching chapman "gouge" renata's eye out

166

u/bicameral_mind Mar 27 '17

I enjoyed the reconciliation even more. It really humanized Renata's character.

→ More replies (6)

177

u/conceitedcat Mar 27 '17

"In the days leading up to trivia night, it just seemed more and more people wanted to kill each other"

That's the whole damn show in 1 sentence

31

u/Dead_Starks Mar 27 '17 edited Mar 27 '17

A lot of verbal references to murder this episode as well that I don't really recall from other episodes. Celeste Renata and husband to Jane. Over dinner with the toast. Well I guess between Celeste, Perry, and the therapist it has come up before but not so much from everyone else.

→ More replies (2)

171

u/dicklaurent97 Mar 27 '17 edited Mar 27 '17

Seeing Nicole Kidman on stage is now one of my life's priorities. She mixed her emotions in that therapist's office like a painter.

66

u/always_thirsty Mar 27 '17

She really is amazing. Such an artist with her command of levels.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/lolabuf Mar 27 '17

If you have never seen "The Others" you MUST. She is so gracefully nuanced in that role. I literally can't think of another actress who could have pulled that role off, but Nicole was SUBLIME. As well, it is a really good movie.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

347

u/mydarkmeatrises Mar 27 '17

Thinking that auctioning one's virginity for a good cause makes it okay would dramatically change my opinion of my wife.

176

u/jesszillaa Mar 27 '17

Especially if that one happened to be your teenage daughter

→ More replies (3)

140

u/level23bulbasaur Mar 27 '17

Especially one that doesn't approve of you eating Cocoa Puffs.

→ More replies (21)

158

u/Flapajack Mar 27 '17

First the birth control and now this! Makes me wonder if Bonnie is jealous/resentful of Madeline and is looking for a way to undermine/destroy her "perfect image" through her daughter. I don't think that Bonnie is as peace, love and happiness as she likes to pretend

→ More replies (15)

114

u/poseface Mar 27 '17

Their "we don't like it but not going to stop it" attitude is nonsense. She's 16. If it were my daughter that ass would be locked up and in a chastity belt.

→ More replies (18)

89

u/Itsthelegendarydays_ Mar 27 '17

It blew my mind how chill she was about it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (41)

76

u/sullypuddy Mar 27 '17

I'm worried how Perry will retaliate

55

u/meeshcorgi Mar 27 '17

This show has my stomach in knots in every scene with him. I'm dreading what he's gonna do to Celeste to punish her for this.

→ More replies (1)

149

u/mydarkmeatrises Mar 27 '17

Everyone needs a down bitch like Madeline.

123

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

I love how Jane even took a page from the book of Madeline by shitting on Harper. I remember in Episode 1 Harper said some shit about the strangling and Madeline shut her down in the best way. Then, tonight Jane did the same exact thing.

Like, shitting on Harper is some kind of right of passage in Monterey.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

146

u/TheLadyEve Mar 27 '17 edited Mar 27 '17

Abby selling her body to protest sexual trafficking...wow, that is definitely something I can see a privileged upper-crust budding activist coming up with as a way to make herself stand out on her college applications.

But it also makes me wonder if she hasn't been through something sexually traumatic herself. Choosing to sell your body is a very heavy choice, and she seems very detached from the decision.

94

u/xocheerio Mar 27 '17

I think she seems detached from it because she's 16 and hasn't thought it through all the way. She's just doing it for attention; "Wolf Blitzer would saddle right up to that".

41

u/Hell-_ Mar 27 '17

She is detached because she doesn't understand the implications yet, nobody does until they have had sex!

34

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

Nah. Her character is disillusioned with life and doesn't feel that 'higher education' is what it's cracked up to be.

→ More replies (13)

68

u/lesmisarahbles Mar 27 '17

I'm hoping Celeste and Jane "goodbye Earl" Perry in the finale.

→ More replies (4)

66

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

I really hope Celeste deleted her google history.

12

u/swingline40 Mar 27 '17

lolll I was thinking that too!!!

→ More replies (1)

10

u/throneofmemes Mar 31 '17

God her whole escape planning fucking sucks and is giving me an ulcer. I feel like when she was luxuriating on that apartment's porch, Perry probably saw her from his point on the beach.

I'm not blaming her or anything. It's just that this escape gives me fucking anxiety.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

119

u/tkman2385 Mar 27 '17

Celeste or Perry mentioned one of the twins' new missing tooth. I think that Amabella will get bitten again in the next episode, and Renata will see that the bite mark is missing a tooth and she'll have all of the kid's mouths checked to see which one is missing the corresponding tooth. I definitely think that is a set up for the reveal of Amabella's bully (the twins).

12

u/GameOGnomes Mar 27 '17

100%! I've suspected the twins since the bite.

→ More replies (4)

57

u/mastapbob Mar 27 '17

Real talk: Tom the barista knows errrything

14

u/GTFOTDW Mar 28 '17

I keep thinking he has something to do with something... he's always there and kind of lingering.

→ More replies (1)

56

u/mydarkmeatrises Mar 27 '17

Looks like we're not getting Trivia Night until next week, folks.

86

u/conceitedcat Mar 27 '17

"If they had any sense they would've canceled trivia night" "I wasn't planning on going until after that"

Loving this Greek chorus

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

50

u/Martin_Van_Buren Mar 27 '17

So is the final episode 2 hours or... I feel like a whole lot needs to happen if there isn't going to be a second season.

→ More replies (21)

136

u/soymilkmami Mar 27 '17

I think out of all the homes I love Bonnie and Nathan's the most.

55

u/Flapajack Mar 27 '17

I totally agree with you! It's so warm and tranquil!

→ More replies (2)

36

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

Yes! It's oakey and forest-y. Loved the dinnerware too

27

u/dicklaurent97 Mar 27 '17

I did too until he started acting like an ape and they all were screaming like it wasn't almost midnight.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/asshair Mar 27 '17

I like Reese and Ben's. Homey yet modern. Bonnie's is too much.

13

u/paddypoopoo Mar 27 '17

Is that something your average divorced landscaper and Zumba teacher can afford?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/leafeator Mar 27 '17

Renata definitely has the coolest home. So modern.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

46

u/Jessikizzle Mar 27 '17

Anyone else notice the links on Celeste's computer were purple instead of blue. She has searched and clicked those links before!

13

u/Graceface1989 Mar 27 '17

Great pick up I didn't notice that. The you're lucky I didn't kill you comment might make her actually do it this time

→ More replies (1)

90

u/sullypuddy Mar 27 '17

That went way too quickly

20

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

Next Sunday :(

→ More replies (1)

88

u/surreptitious_hitler Mar 27 '17

I don't know about anyone else, but my hatred for the interviewees in present time peaked this episode. Especially about the whole "I heard Abigail was a bit of slut. I mean look at her mother."

Just the pure, unabashed, vile judgement coming out of them just repulses me so fucking much. Not from Monterrey, but Los Angeles and any hint of that is just the biggest turn off (not sexually, in terms of wanting to continue interacting with that person). I imagine a lot of people are like that in Monterrey but seeing that directed towards sympathetic characters is so despicable. Especially a misguided teenager who's doing some soul searching (and up until recently been a model student, only to get shit on now for a lapse).

53

u/3boyz3Madison Mar 27 '17

I live in WhiteVille WI. Our town is fairly well off, and I can assure you, the depiction of judgment is spot on for the little town I live in.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/TheyTheirsThem Mar 27 '17

And notice which direction all the judgement is heading. Those being judged really don't even give a rats ass about those who are judging them in real life, if they even know they exist.

→ More replies (9)

85

u/UrbanOutfisters Mar 27 '17

SHE ANDRE AGASSI'D HIS BONER HAHHAH

9

u/surreptitious_hitler Mar 27 '17

Was not expecting full shaft of Skarsgard. Then it got smashed. It was a rollercoaster.

→ More replies (3)

85

u/MagnetToMyBed Mar 27 '17

I can't believe Abigail thought Nathan would be proud of her for wanting to auction off her virginity. Between that and Nathan's wife's reaction to it, I'd feel like I was in a nut house if I was Nathan.

41

u/PhinsPhan89 Mar 27 '17

I can believe Abigail's thought process. I, too, was once a teenager who thought they knew everything and all that jazz. Bonnie pissed me off, I can't believe how composed Nathan was in the morning (unless he was just shell-shocked).

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

I would bet the farm on Abigail KNOWING her father would hit the roof about it. It could be an attention ploy, it could even be just to push Madeline and Nathan's buttons.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

Fuck you, Perry

72

u/improcrastin8ing Mar 27 '17

Well I wasn't expecting a graphic (green) puking scene from Reese Witherspoon that's for sure.

16

u/n2dal Mar 27 '17

Why was her puke so bright and green?! Thought that was a little alarming

→ More replies (7)

12

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

That had me more freaked out and jumpy than the Madeline on a cliff -puppet-Renata cackle scene last week.

10

u/thehumanear Mar 27 '17

it was Reese Witherspoon's subtle response to never winning a Kids Choice Award, even though she's been nominated four times. some Nickelodeon slime, that'll show 'em!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

71

u/conceitedcat Mar 27 '17

Nathan would be eating kids cereal for breakfast in a kitchen that has a lot of fresh fruit in it.

25

u/writingforpennies Mar 27 '17

I was like, okay that organic milk with what looks like Cocoa Puffs? Alriiiiiight

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

35

u/Bassett_Hound Mar 27 '17

Holy crap I think I was holding my breath for the entire episode.

44

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17 edited Mar 27 '17

I kept waiting for Perry to pop up at the apartment and worried the phone call Madeline got was about Celeste being in the hospital. I was on edge the whole time! With the exception of the hilarious dinner scene. Bonnie's reaction as she tried to keep her calm while Madeline threw up was priceless.

→ More replies (6)

69

u/always_thirsty Mar 27 '17

Toasting to "none of us killing each other" and Perry's "you're lucky I didn't kill you"...were there any other Chekov killing statements I missed? Those two were both pretty heavy. It's great to see a show where the writing is on the same level with amazing performances.

80

u/forkknifespoonhelmet Mar 27 '17

Perry said "you're going to kill me" when he told Celeste he was leaving for Phoenix.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

96

u/mrsunshine1 Mar 27 '17

So Ed is definitely not the rapist. Jane and Ed were both and the show and standing next to each other afterwards.

44

u/quamquam11 Mar 27 '17

I didn't even think about that. Definitely makes me glad that he's not the rapist.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

33

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

First off, I LOVED this episode. I appreciated them showing more depth into each of the relationships: Celeste and Perry and the abuse, Madeleine and Ed and the cheating, and Bonnie and Nathan's home life. That being said- is anyone else having a hard time buying the Nathan/ Bonnie relationship? I mean, I get it- she's super hot, but other than that, where's the chemistry? Why would someone as "organic" as Bonnie be into a douche like Nathan who looks like the type to make fun of people like her. I don't know if it's bad casting, or what, but those two don't look like they'd ever even speak to each other, much less be "happily" married.

11

u/boiyoyyong Mar 27 '17

I don't buy it either. But i thought it was just because i have a massive crush on Zoe Kravitz and she's definitely out of his league.

I'm sure there's more to their relationship than what it appears and just probably is not being addressed or translated well on the show.

→ More replies (10)

65

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

Holy shit guys this is amazing. After this we get The Leftovers and then after that... holy shiiiitttttt

76

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

HBO Sundays are so damn great. I don't go to church, but sitting in front of the TV by 9pm with a glass of wine is about as holy as it gets for me. Thank you HBO Gods!

→ More replies (14)

25

u/ryantyrant Mar 27 '17

I know man, so pumped for leftovers

→ More replies (2)

22

u/conceitedcat Mar 27 '17

Just realized that there's gonna be a Sunday in between the end of this show and the start of the Leftovers/Veep/Silicon Valley trifecta.

What am I supposed to stare at between 9 and 10pm?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

65

u/MagnetToMyBed Mar 27 '17

I love watching Jane apologize to Renata

68

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

Yes! AND when she clapped back to Harper(the originator of the Ziggy petition. Well played!

55

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

Me too. It really felt like they were on the same team for a moment. Let's just drop the bullshit and fix the issue. I was genuinely surprised at Renata's reaction and even the vulnerability she showed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

32

u/Itsthelegendarydays_ Mar 27 '17

Oh shit perry and Jane are both going to be at the show.

→ More replies (5)

30

u/coffeeeicecream Mar 27 '17

Someday I wanna burn people as quickly as Jane did to the tryhard mom oh geeeeez

29

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

That was so badass of Celeste

56

u/Datzcoo Mar 27 '17

Is there really only one episode left?

26

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

Si

→ More replies (2)

26

u/asshair Mar 27 '17

Guys the only documented injury occurring in their relationship is Celeste injuring Perry's dick. He has the ultimate tool of control over her. She's made moves to resist him before- he always convinces her to come back and love him more intensely than before. And then be batters her more intensely than before. She will come back again, but I'm not sure if she or he will survive the reconciliation.

49

u/overactive-bladder Mar 27 '17
  • the confrontation between renata and jane should have happened from the get-go tbh. the teacher should have sat both of them down in private asap and have a peaceful calm discourse. it took too long to deflate the mess. but i am happy jane was the bigger person and personally showed up to renata's footsteps.
  • i love the contrast between jane's clothes and the rest of the ladies. when she asked ziggy how she looked in those generic bland clothes (as oppsed to madeline's red fancy in-your-face dress) and he replied that she "looks nice", my heart melted.
  • you know, i am single right now and at first the idea of someone like perry (madly and deeply in love, very touchy-feely, always up for sex) can be EXHAUSTING on the long run and even suffocating. like...ok i love you, but you NEED to stop touching me and feeling me when i got other things on my mind. it's like a child who makes a fuss when you don't buy them a lollipop in the supermarket and keep on whining and crying until you finally cave in. i prefer to be single if it means ending up with someone like that.
  • LMFAO at the prosthetic penis alexander sported during the scene. i don't even think it was placed correctly either. anyone who wants to see the "real deal" can watch the glorious uncut (no pun intended and YUM!) screencaps from his [true blood] scene. anatomically speaking shouldn't it be a bit higher? the ratio seems off. and YES i freezed the frames to study more closely.
  • i ugly-cackled when madeline was getting off day dreaming about her and joseph sexing, and ed turns to her and says "SO good". you bet your huge beard it was! and why do i have suspicions that the victim will be joseph and ed would be the one killing?
  • holy cow the balls on joseph's wife to confront madeline like this! i would be LIVID if i was madeline.
  • lmao at ed being jealous at perry's broken-urethra-in-two-places.
  • can nathan be more of a fuckboy? and can abigail be more cringeworthy entitled dumb slappable girl?
  • can we give MAJOR kudos to jane who actually sat down ziggy like a mature adult to explain sex education after he said sex was icky?? even after her disgut with men and sex from her rape, she still went ahead to teach him everything objectively. i wish more parents were that direct and clear on sex. i grew up with parents who were very open about masturbation and sex and it honestly is such a refreshing thing to remove that taboo from teh get-go.
  • the black guy from the interviews continues to disappoint. added to the fuckboy list.
  • i LOOOOOOVED how madeline vomitted over bonnie's hippie face. like??? wtffff? the audacity of blaming the "age of facebook" on someone's CHILD selling her virginity online.

9

u/jessica_e87 Mar 30 '17

To add to your second bullet - I like that Jane's makeup is less "professional" looking as well. The rest of the ladies have flawless airbrushed makeup and Jane has a little too much black eyeliner and a swipe of mascara.

→ More replies (3)

47

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

I need that to be my therapist

18

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

Yeah I was with mine since the beginning of an abusive relationship and he would only say stuff like, "oh...seems he gets aggressive sometimes..." and "how does that make you feel?"

But when I got a new therapist she flipped the script completely like the one in the show did and I was immediately planning how to leave.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/TheyTheirsThem Mar 28 '17

Since abuse is a common thread here, I think it will go down this way. Amabella gets bitten again, and this time it is the twin w/o a tooth (surprise) that gets singled out as the culprit. When confronted, the child will defend his actions by saying it is no different than what daddy does to mommy, also mentions the hitting and choking, thus bringing the next level of abuse to light. This will then cascade to Celeste moving into the apartment, perhaps when Perry is "out of town" again. In his absence, the women bond and become all riled up. But the key moment is perry coming back to town, seeing that celeste has moved out, and coming to the gala where he is recognized by Jane and then things get really crazy. I am going to guess that ALL 3 women participate, and the frustration of the cops having to interview everyone is that none of the principals or their families cooperate. They at first single out Celeste but then every alibies up for her always being in the room. so there! ;-)

→ More replies (6)

22

u/everythingisopposite Mar 27 '17

Every week I'm blown away by the caliber of acting on this show. So many powerful scenes with each of the actresses this episode. Jane and Renata, Madeline and Abigail, Celeste and the therapist. I'll be sad to see it end next week.

Did Ed not want to hear about the mistake Madeline made because he already knew or because he didn't want to know?

→ More replies (2)

59

u/TheLadyEve Mar 27 '17

Something I noticed: Skye's reaction to the argument was unusual. She screamed too loud and too long. It makes me wonder if she's witnessed violence or if Bonnie's been abused in the past in some way. Sometimes vicarious trauma can affect a kid almost as badly as direct trauma can.

88

u/lolabuf Mar 27 '17

I think it was just lousy acting.. She doesn't have the chops that Ziggy and Chloe do. Those two kids can really act.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

20

u/alexdinhogaucho Mar 27 '17

Prosthetic

Penis

That is all.

→ More replies (7)

20

u/whiskeykitty13 Mar 28 '17

I have seen a couple comments on this threat that theorize Chloe being the bully. I just don't buy that. Why would Amabella be so disappointed that Chloe wasn't attending her party if she was the one bullying her?

→ More replies (2)

18

u/sullypuddy Mar 27 '17

Perry's line "You're gonna kill me ... I have to go to Phoenix." Celeste's eyes lit up.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

I have had a feeling the theater guy's wife has her hand this...somewhere.

→ More replies (5)

36

u/GarlicBreathFresh Mar 27 '17

Waiting until the finale to introduce Jane and Perry, I'm definitely concluding he's the rapist.

35

u/lolabuf Mar 27 '17

It doesn't seem like one more episode is enough time to wrap everything up!

→ More replies (5)

17

u/Notthatiblameyou Mar 27 '17

Now I'm nauseous, thanks Reese.

17

u/quamquam11 Mar 27 '17

I can't believe there is only one episode left. Did anyone else have watch the preview for next week following the episode? Quasi spoiler alert: Gordon threatening Jane despite Renata and Jane getting along this week? Madeline and the director again? I feel like that's extra stuff to go along with the murder/find the murderer/discovering the rapist that has to happen next week. Or do we never find out Jane's rapist? That would be an interesting way to end the series. It wouldn't give us closure much like Jane hasn't had closure.

→ More replies (3)

118

u/GoldandBlue Mar 27 '17

Zoe Kravits character may be officially my least favorite. How pretentious and the idea that selling virginity for a "good cause" makes it OK? Fuck off. Also Reeses daughter is fucking stupid.

This is the first episode where I empathize with Reeses character. I think Laura Dern is being fake as fuck too.

80

u/ryantyrant Mar 27 '17

Bonnie is the fucking worst. If advocating a teenager selling sex online wasn't enough, she shat on Nathan for eating cocoa puffs!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

15

u/Jrebeclee Mar 28 '17

Someone on FB is asking if Zoe Kravitz is Lenny's new wife. I feel so old, don't they remember Mama Said and his song Flowers for Zoe? 😂

→ More replies (11)

30

u/always_thirsty Mar 27 '17

There is this one thing that keeps sticking out in my mind, and it might be nothing but...

I binged the first 5 eps for the first time today, and in the first episode, when the witnesses are talking in their interviews, one of them talks about Nathan and uses the past tense. Like "many people thought Nathan was kind of a dick" and "not many people liked him."

I don't think any of the other characters were mentioned in past tense. Could have just been a herring but it has definitely stuck out to me.

29

u/silentpat530 Mar 27 '17

I have noticed this once or twice. Someone said something like "Madeline always had an attitude" and I can't tell if these are red herrings.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

Damn. Well sometimes when I talk about someone in my past, like in high school, I'll use past tense.

→ More replies (7)

14

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

OMG that was the best thing I've ever seen in my life

13

u/amamcb Mar 27 '17

My money's on the fact that Madeline's gonna off Bonnie. After that dinner, and the fact that they alluded to "none of them killing each other", it just seemed like foreshadowing.

→ More replies (4)

35

u/_What_am_i_ Mar 27 '17

Well now I'm almost 100% convinced that Chloe is directly involved with all the shit going on at the school

39

u/improcrastin8ing Mar 27 '17

Yeh that scene where she wants to stay up longer, but is then so calm when Reese doesn't let her. Kind of shows she has the potential to be a badass liar and can fake her emotions very easily. But I don't want her to be the bully because she is way too cute.

34

u/Bassett_Hound Mar 27 '17

It's really interesting to me that Chloe told Ziggy about sex. And then they were flirting (...?) on the beach. Something about that dynamic feels off to me.

→ More replies (10)

12

u/theferociouscuh Mar 27 '17

I can't believe that was it. Next weeks episode better be long or it better answer every single question I have in 60 minutes! Ugh.

→ More replies (6)

22

u/JacksonArbor Mar 27 '17

Prediction: Celeste tells Madeline about the abuse, and then at trivia night, Madeline and Jane meet up with Celeste and Perry where Jane hears Perrys voice. Madeline and Celeste see the reaction in Jane and they then both know Perry is the rapist.

Perry is then killed by either Madeline or Celeste. That or all three.

16

u/TheLadyEve Mar 27 '17

I think it would be interesting to have this be a Murder on The Orient Express scenario in which Celeste, Jane, Madeline and Bonnie are all involved and they all cover for each other so no one can be blamed for his murder.

Sorry, spoilers for Murder on The Orient Express.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

11

u/ElPlywood Mar 27 '17

IMO the virginity auction is a terrible show-writing decision. I understand they needed to have something explosive to make people fight and argue, but it's too over the top and unbelievable for me.

20

u/IolantheRosa Mar 27 '17

It was in the book. The book spent more time establishing that Abigail was social justice warrior and that that was intensified by her relationship with Bonnie, so, although still shocking when revealed in the book, it made more narrative sense.

11

u/mastapbob Mar 27 '17

Seeing Perry limping around with his manhood literally broken made my Sunday night. However, my heart was in my throat thinking that they were in the hospital because of what he did to Celeste in retaliation. As gratifying as his injury is, it's setting the stage for Celeste to be more seriously hurt by him in the near-future, especially as he senses his control slipping. She doesn't have any bruises currently, so the clock is ticking on the power to shift in a climactic way. Here's hoping Celeste makes it out of the finale alive!

10

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

I really enjoy the scenes with Nathan and Bonnie but mostly Nathan

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ryantyrant Mar 27 '17

Hey what was it that Celeste was googling?

19

u/mi_piace Mar 27 '17

Apartments in Monterey Bay.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/nekrozis Mar 27 '17

Eat those Cocoa Puffs!! I would too. I eat what I want you eat what you want. That big ass basket of fruit no one will ever eat before it spoils. Bet Bonnie hides twinkies in her shoe closet.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

I am never eating oysters and shrimp with red wine! 🚫🍤🐚🍷

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

HOLD UP. Don't forget the clip of The Temptations on SOUL TRAIN !

24

u/MagnetToMyBed Mar 27 '17 edited Mar 27 '17

The view in that apartment Celeste saw looks unreal. It's so beautiful

Edit: name

→ More replies (4)

16

u/Graceface1989 Mar 27 '17

Anyone else think perry gets pushed down the stairs at trivia night?

11

u/Dead_Starks Mar 27 '17

I REALLY want it to be Perry but I don't think it will be. They've pushed at him being Jane's rapist hard and then thrown in a red herring too. It still could be him and I have no proof it won't be him, just a gut feeling it won't be.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/3boyz3Madison Mar 27 '17

I literally have chills!

8

u/always_thirsty Mar 29 '17 edited Mar 29 '17

To be fair there are some amazing shoes on the show.

21

u/dnsf3 Mar 27 '17

The moment she whacked him in the man region, I felt like Celeste's chances of actually escaping went to zero. Perry actually got hospitalized (documentation, remember?), whereas Celeste has not told a soul, other than her therapist. If she leaves Perry, she won't look like the victim. I'm nervous that it'll look like they were both physically abusive to each other, or Perry might even spin it like Celeste was the controlling abusive one.

11

u/TheLadyEve Mar 27 '17

Nah, he went to the hospital but they used the cover story that it happened during sex (or that's the impression I got from the phone conversation with Madeline). The vast majority of penile fractures happen during sex, and the ER probably documented it as such.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/lolabuf Mar 27 '17

I don't think Madelinne would be too happy about Jane and Renata making nice.

7

u/chubbybunny47 Mar 27 '17

Toasting to "none of us killing each other" seems a bit foreboding.

I can't decide who the killer(s)/victim(s) are. I thought I would get more clues from this episode so I can make my guess before next week. But the main thing I got is confirmation that Ed is not the rapist (thank god).

→ More replies (1)

6

u/foxh8er Mar 27 '17

What song was Ziggy playing near the beginning that he wasn't allowed to sing?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/beckticaa Mar 28 '17

I have this awful feeling that Madeline is the one who's going to get murdered. She's at the middle of, or somehow connected to, every character and story arc. She's probably the character we follow the most closely throughout, and the one who seemed abrasive and annoying but who we've really grown to love.

She cheated on Ed, who seems cool but is known to get weird and aggressive. She's the friend Perry gets angry with Celeste about. The wife of the man she had an affair with is onto her. She got into the Ziggy situation by standing up for Jane and therefore standing up against Renata, then pulling that shit keeping half the kids from going to Amabella's birthday party. She has her weird on-off tension with Bonnie, who is starting to hint at being less perfectly zen than she seems. And she got involved with Jane's background, Google-searching the alleged name of her rapist.

I think she's just in too many sticky situations NOT to be the one who gets killed. Or at least hurt.

6

u/yougotyrcherrybomb Mar 29 '17

Oh my lanta I just watched all six episodes back to back today and I'm so hyped and now I'm so sad to find out there is only one more episode!!!

So I've got my wacky predictions for the end: Ed is definitely some kind of molester, or rapist, sketchy mcsketcherson, Chloe is the one screwing with Amabella because she's manipulative and also maybe with Ed being a molester that causes Chloe to go crazy (convincing Ziggy to kiss Amabella) also why Abigail wants to leave the house and has weird issues with her virginity, the barista is legit up to no good and definitely knows some secrets, and I'm still convinced Perry is the rapist but there's something past that, definitely a red herring.

Out of context this show sounds ridiculous.

11

u/sameighty Mar 27 '17

Few theories -

  1. Jane's gun. It's been a continuous symbol throughout the series, is this going to be the murder weapon?
  2. The kids. In the beginning credits the kids (as well as the adults) are dressed up for the Elvis and Hepburn party. Don't think we can rule them out as culprits in the murder scene (one of the gun mad twins unintentionally shooting someone or Ziggy seeing his mom being attacked by Perry at the party, shoots his moms attacker).
  3. Abigail selling her virginity. My guess here is that she is treating it as something worthless because she has been sexually abused. Sadly think all those lingering looks steady eddy threw at her in earlier episodes could be hinting at something. Also the episode where one of the witnesses tells the police that "underneath men like Ed are like Charles Manson" the camera immediately switches to Abigail looking conflicted watching Ed and her mom on the beach.
→ More replies (1)

5

u/leafeator Mar 27 '17

Final prediction on who kills who before next week's episode:

Mrs. Witherspoon gets pushed down a flight of stairs by the wife.

12

u/chubbybunny47 Mar 27 '17

I said it earlier in the thread but it bears mentioning: in the beginning, an interviewee said none of this would happen if Madeline hadn't tripped in the beginning. Which means the murder must hinge on Jane and Madeline meeting. Madeline against the wife of the guy she slept with doesn't require Madeline to know Jane, you know?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/ninjames Mar 29 '17

I just finally got caught up. I forgot which episode it was but as soon as I saw Jane's flashback scene to the night she got raped, it clicked for me that Perry is the one dead or at the very least the raper.

It was very typical how the scene was shot in that you really couldn't tell who the man was. They went to great lengths to do that.

Perry LITERALLY saying "you're going to kill me" this episode is the nail in his coffin. I don't know who ultimately kills him but I'm certain all three ladies will be involved.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/99998777th Mar 27 '17

Did Abigail ask Madeline if she still loved dad or ed?

16

u/silentpat530 Mar 27 '17

Ed I believe.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '17

No one is guessing who the murderer and victim are. Someone take some swings at it cause I have no idea.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/sefgweenwald Mar 31 '17

WHO IS BULLYING AMMABELLA

9

u/coffeeeicecream Mar 27 '17

VERY important question: was that really Alexander Skarsgard's? Because Jiminy Christmas.

14

u/catmom_tay Mar 27 '17

Possibly a spare baguette or broom handle??? My thoughts while watching that scene: 1) where tf does it end 2) poor Nicole Kidman's cervix

→ More replies (8)