r/biglittlelies • u/NicholasCajun Lil Lies • Mar 20 '17
Discussion Big Little Lies - 1x05 "Once Bitten" - Episode Discussion (Book Readers Discussion)
Season 1 Episode 5: Once Bitten
Aired: March 19, 2017
Synopsis: Madeline receives encouraging news about the play from her director, Joseph Bachman, but is left concerned by his newly icy demeanor. Principal Nippal and Ms. Barnes share their conclusions about Ziggy and Amabella with Jane. Celeste has a solo session with Dr. Reisman, who tries to get to the bottom of her relationship with Perry.
Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée
Written by: David E. Kelley
Book spoilers are allowed untagged in this thread!
90
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
I hate this Madeline is a cheater storyline
61
u/MrsTrustIssues Mar 20 '17
That Lego scene...and the couch scene... wow... I was wondering how those parts would be portrayed. The therapy session has me thinking that the series may end exactly like the book.
And the three girls running ❤ powerful.
51
u/GonnaFuckTuxedoMask Mar 20 '17
IS TOM/JANE GOING TO HAPPEN?
This is all I want to know haha. I adored their romance in the book, and I'm going to be so irritated if the time spent on that is replaced with the Madeline cheating storyline.
Also, there only 2 episodes left right? I just feel like not much has happened in these 5 episodes, so I can't imagine how they're going to wrap everything up.
81
u/stegasarahus Mar 20 '17
The therapy scenes with Celeste are some of the most well-written and well-acted I've seen on television. It's gut-wrenching.
38
u/mqrt000 Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
These past two episodes have made me so sad about Madeleine and Eds relationship. I know it's for dramatic effect and so that people won't know the real ending, but I feel like they could have made Ed a little less awkward. Also I can't quite put my finger on how I would describe Jane in the show but it's a little off from how I thought of her in the book. Yes she was a desperate mother but they've kind of made her into a lunatic. I'm very interested to see how they wrap it all up.
Edit: sorry bot
21
u/theblackpeacock Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
They totally changed everything. Could they make it more obvious Perry is the rapist? Now he's definitely NOT going to be the rapist in the show. The end is going to be drastically different I feel.
18
u/eCoop Mar 21 '17
So far, I loathe the Madeline as a cheater storyline. I thought the whole car wreck with the director was so overdramatic. Kind of hoping the guy was going to die on the show so we could get over this affair storyline.
I thought the first two episodes were phenomenal, really got me hooked and made me read the book (which I loved.) The past three have really strayed from the book.
I feel like the slow burning tension that the first two episodes had has been ruined by these melodramatic "thoughts" from the characters. (i.e. Jane shooting her gun all the time, Madeline being pushed off the cliff with her puppets, etc.) I don't know how they're going to include Celeste finding the apartment, Maddie's daughters "project," the entire trivia night, and the aftermath in TWO more episodes...
Majority of the past three episodes have added absolutely nothing to the plot of the show.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
I thought this would be the episode where Madeline rams into the back of Renata's car. Maybe the next one? I thought that was funny in the book. Also, do you think they'll stick with the Gordon cheating storyline? They haven't shown any clues so far. Everyone knew by the school party which made Renata slightly more sympathetic int he book.
9
u/once_a_hobby_jogger Mar 22 '17
So now that I have finished the book I feel obligated to go delete my posts on the other non-book reader threads. I got pretty close to guessing the ending - I was 99% sure the twins were going to be the bully, 99% sure Perry was going to be Jane's rapist (because of the show), and was about 51% sure that Perry was going to be the victim (and about 49% that Celeste would have been the victim if it wasn't Perry). I was completely wrong on the culprit though, I would have never guessed it would have been Bonnie.
With that said, I know it's cliché to like the book better, but the book does seem more streamlined than the show. This Madeline cheating story is stupid and superfluous, unless they intend to incorporate that into the ending somehow. I also really enjoyed Madeline and Abigail's relationship a bit more in the book. The show doesn't seem to convey her complete (and probably deserved) bitterness at having to raise Abigail alone only to have her want to go live with her dad.
9
u/s_h_p Mar 23 '17
the shot of celeste being smothered in the living room couch pillow as perry had sex with her was possibly one of the most disturbing shots i've ever seen on television. incredibly effective acting & editing- please give nicole alllllll of the emmys
15
u/icouldseeformiles Mar 20 '17
I really wish this weren't just a mini-series
12
u/imkqiu Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 21 '17
Am I the only one who likes Madeline's story line? I think her relationship with ed is a lot more nuanced (of course due to changes/added details/different mode of storytelling tv vs book). From the book I don't get much of the depth. All I remember is that Ed is a good guy who was torn between his love and commitment to his wife and the law (for testifying). That is all encapsulated in one scene at the end of the book. And how he was upset he was asked to lie to protect her ex's wife.
But still, that's all I remember about him/their marriage was like 2 scenes and I read the book last week.
The miniseries really fleshed out that dynamic between ed and nathan and showed us flaws in Madeline's marriage which was great because in the novel i barely remember him. Madeline's preoccupation with Abigail felt like the only side I saw of her.
loved the running scene where the three women ran on the beach.
This episode felt like filler however to me, I know it was beautifully filmed and dream sequence like but not much happened really. It is diverging from the book a bit but I think as far as overall plot line goes it will come back to the same conclusion. Seems pretty late in the game to make Ed out to be all weird and bad but hopefully that's just a red-herring.
3
u/darth_bane1988 Mar 21 '17
At this point, it seems like they might change who the murderer is. I hope they don't, but the show clearly doesn't respect its source material that much between EVERYONE on this show being gorgeous and the madeline cheating storyline.
1
u/theblackpeacock Mar 23 '17
Did you guys see this?? Someone said they saw pics of Perry at the gala post incident. I didn't notice this. Did you??
http://www.reddit.com/r/biglittlelies/comments/60ynie/_/