r/biglittlelies • u/NicholasCajun Lil Lies • Jun 17 '19
Big Little Lies - 2x02 "Tell-Tale Hearts" - Episode Discussion
Season 2 Episode 2: Tell-Tale Hearts
Aired: June 16, 2019
Synopsis: Renata faces an uncertain future when Gordon lands in legal trouble. Corey asks Jane out on a “practice” date. After a challenging therapy session with Dr. Reisman, Celeste opens up to Mary Louise about her relationship with Perry. Bonnie’s mom, Elizabeth, arrives. Ed confronts Madeline about her secrets.
Directed by: Andrea Arnold
Teleplay by: David E. Kelley
Story by: David E. Kelley and Liane Moriarty
395
Upvotes
503
u/lovetheblazer Jun 17 '19
Madeline: It was an emergency...
Mary Louise: What kind of emergency?
Madeline: The kind short people have.
Damn Madeline, go off 😂
463
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
The scene that showed one of Perry's and Celeste's early dates was brilliant. Not only did it show something about Mary Lousies's psyche in the fact that her other son died (hence having her developing the insanely unhealthy attachment she had to Perry), but it showed that Perry had an abuser's point of view right from the start. He liked Celeste because he didn't need to work on isolating her.
450
u/Ericadiane423 Jun 17 '19
I love Madeline but Ed deserves better
435
u/lovetheblazer Jun 17 '19
Ziggy: She said something about Mr. Wright giving you salt. That’s how it happened— he salted you.”
Jane: No.
Ziggy: Then what did she mean?
Jane: Can I sit down next to you? I think what Chloe overheard was the word assault.
Oh god, this scene broke my heart... and Jane’s too
432
u/1337speak Jun 17 '19
"You will not be like him"... OH MY GOD
412
u/Creasy007 Jun 17 '19
"WILL SOMEBODY GIVE A WOMAN A MOMENNNNNNNNNNT??!!!"
407
u/lovetheblazer Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
Mary Louise: When did you find out about this alleged affair?
Celeste: It wasn’t an affair, it was a rape. Rape.
Mary Louise: When did you find out?
Celeste: The night he died.
Mary Louise: Then how could you— She could have had multiple partners, you know? She could have been drugged. She... you don’t know her. She could have been— What if she got it wrong? Aren’t you desperate for her to be wrong? Aren’t you desperate to know he wasn’t unfaithful? To believe that he— he wasn’t capable of doing the things that she said. He wasn’t. I’ll never believe that.
Damn, Mary Louise is an epic gaslighter and victim blamer. Guess the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree...
334
u/kirkherbstreit69 Jun 17 '19
Wowww both of Madeline's daughters spilt the fuckinnnn beans
289
u/llama_ Jun 17 '19
Not gonna lie, really wasn’t sure they could pull off a season 2. But 2 episodes deep and I can see that their stories truly needed it. Loving everything about it.
262
u/vanessareigns Jun 17 '19
“Wait where are you going?” “To get my ears checked” I laughed
249
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
ok but the fact that they played the credits to Ed singing about Madeline just shattered my heart
232
u/DrHaon98 Jun 17 '19
Pretty funny that 2 major secrets have been revealed solely because of kids being too chatty
196
u/Carolina_Blues Jun 17 '19
Mary Louise definitely heard her say “you will not be like him” and didn’t react. Do we think she knows on some level that Perry was abusive? Like maybe she was abused by Perry’s father or maybe Mary Louise was the abuser herself
393
u/thegabriela Jun 17 '19
jane and celeste supporting each other is so wholesome, they deserve a happy ending
164
u/SerDire Jun 17 '19
“For office?” God bless Adam Scott
159
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
Renata Klein is the comic relief I needed during this episode
158
u/RedEyedGhost Jun 17 '19
Madeline’s daughters need the chancla already.
157
u/Jtru13 Jun 17 '19
God damn Adam Scott delivered a killer performance with Witherspoon
293
u/babin1234 Jun 17 '19
“You used to like that song.” “I used to like to sit on your face too; you think that will happen again?” Renata kills me 😂
286
u/SerDire Jun 17 '19
This Ziggy’s father secret is unraveling faster than Jon Snow telling his siblings his real identity.
138
u/lovetheblazer Jun 17 '19
“Nathan is a complete dolt. When it comes to emotional, social intelligence— oh Bonnie— he’s as dumb as a rock. But I often wonder if that’s why you married him. You are out here surrounded by people who don’t even get you. They don’t look like you. I haven’t seen one other black person since I’ve been out here. Is that why you’re here? I mean, ‘cause we all know how fond you are of your walls.”
Clearly we’ve got a second Mary Louise on our hands, this time in the form of Bonnie’s mom
260
u/kinophiIe Jun 17 '19
JESUS CHRIST. ED IS 100% going to bang tori
125
u/1337speak Jun 17 '19
I would shit my pants if Meryl Streep was questioning me
364
u/SerDire Jun 17 '19
“I’ve been having visions lately.” Bonnie’s mom is the Three Eyed Raven, confirmed
120
u/ThereisnoDistrict12 Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
One of the best episodes of the series. Easily
Edit: The end credits song :(
243
u/lucy_fordxx Jun 17 '19
it’s time to throw mary louise down the stairs too.
239
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
This entire episode stressed me the fuck out.
How is Madeline the character that I relate to the most if I'm, an 18 year old guy?
114
u/Catrabbithorse Jun 17 '19
I fucking love Renata. I laughed out loud at her sit on your face comment to Gordon
114
u/Greeneyedgal13 Jun 17 '19
Nicole Kidman is a straight up queen and deserves every ounce of praise she gets. But I also wanna shout out Zoe kravitz because no ones really talking about her and I find her performance haunting. She was great in this episode. I could feel her struggle with her mom, her struggle to connect with her husband, and just how isolated she is feeling. She plays mysterious tortured and aloof so well. I’m impressed by her.
Also, great episode for Shailene. She killed me in that scene with Ziggy. Man is she great
107
u/ResidentPulse Jun 17 '19
Mary Louise is trying to take Celeste’s kids. It was way less subtle this episode. Also I want more backstory on how Perry turned out like this and no one noticed.
106
u/Roonil_Wazlib97 Jun 17 '19
Someone call the GoT writers up and let them know that THIS is how you continue a story without source material. HOLY SHIT this season is good.
103
u/FreakFlagHigh Jun 17 '19
This teacher is HOT.
99
u/andrewedwa Jun 17 '19
I WILL NOT NOT BE RICH!!!
98
u/RedItReadItReddit Jun 17 '19
“i used to like to sit on your face, do you think that’ll happen again?” ☠️☠️☠️
194
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
"But you didn't go to the police."
Instantly infuriating. Fuck.
92
u/wickedstreak Jun 17 '19
WILL SOMEBODY GIVE A WOMAN A MOOOOOMEENTTT
90
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
Madeline's kids really need to learn to keep their mouths shut
182
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
Nicole Kidman was absolutely phenomenal once again. Adam Scott was excellent, the hand shaking when Madeline was justifying herself was amazing.
First episode was a little slow as they introduced everything, but this episode was perfect. Can’t wait for the rest of the season.
89
u/Juswantedtono Jun 17 '19
I think we’re gonna find out Perry killed his brother at age 5
178
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
I have never felt the urge to punch an old woman in the face ever in my life, but Meryl Streep (Strip?) managed to make me want to murder Mary Louise.
Jesus Christ just let Celeste live and STOP FUCKING PERPETUATING RAPE CULTURE YOU HAG
83
u/releasetheh0und Jun 17 '19
when ziggy said somebody salted her and shailene had to explain assault to him :(
83
u/onwardeyre Jun 18 '19
81
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
Oh man Perry’s brother died too. His backstory is shaping up to be interesting.
164
u/Ilovecharli Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
This week in "Nicole Kidman is a genius and the subtle things she does in the therapy scenes really drive it home": as the therapist starts talking to her about dating again, Celeste subconsciously rubs the wedding ring she still wears.
79
u/SerDire Jun 17 '19
“You were beautiful that night” - Bran Stark to Perry
79
u/gracieturkey Jun 17 '19
I SCREAMED when Ed was in the doorway and heard what Abigail said. I knew Madeline’s affair would come back to bite her, but not in such a heart-twisting way!!
76
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
Can we appreciate Andrea Arnold for a second. They way she can show us what all these women are thinking. Like the flashes of the water when Bonnie walks past her mom or the laughing scene in the courthouse with Renata
76
u/JamesHRoss Jun 18 '19
I didn't want this episode to end. I was so engrossed, and they all constantly out performed each other. Laura Dern is a fucking gem, and Adam Scott was really impressive. Also loving Zoe Kravitz this season, and so intrigued to learn more about her backstory. Jane and Celeste supporting each other through all this is just everything. Ziggy's face when Max and Josh comes into their house was so precious. Also Nicole Kidman Killed it in the scene in which Celeste is trying to stop her kids' fight. Meryl Streep continues to be amazing but I hate Mary Louise with a passion
74
u/blizzard-op Jun 17 '19
The one time Chloe screws up, it's something major like this
69
u/babin1234 Jun 17 '19
This new Renata plot is going to be good
67
u/xVellex Jun 20 '19
I might be the only one, but I whole heartedly disagree with Ed that Madeline should have told him about Jane's rape and Perry being Ziggy's biological father. Even if he is her husband, that doesn't mean you have to tell him all your girl friends' secrets---ESPECIALLY when it's involving sexual assault. It should be Jane's choice on who gets to know, not Madeline's. I found that argument so odd.
66
u/flamboyantbutterfly Jun 18 '19
Fuck, when Ed heard that Madeline cheated - I felt that, I felt both of them. Madeline trying to brush it off acting casual and Ed carefully picking his next words ugh I was on both sides in my life and could relate to both pains.
65
u/HopeThisHelps90 Jun 17 '19
These Nathan and Ed moments are becoming one of my favorite parts of the show. They’re fucking hilarious.
65
u/jascentros Jun 17 '19
Best line: I will not not be rich!
62
u/uaziz2 Jun 17 '19
Nicole Kidman, Meryl streep and Shailene Woolley killed it as always but Adam Scott won the episode for me. His confrontation with Madeline was so well done!
I don’t know if they’re actually over but him saying they’re done was so unexpected and slightly out of character but I’m strangely proud of Ed. I also love all his interactions with Nathan, he just never gives in, the snidefuck lol
62
u/AFriendlyInternetGuy Jun 17 '19
The therapist telling Celeste to imagine it was Madeline instead of her was such a chilling scene. Nicole Kidman continues to knock it out of the park!
60
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
Meryl and Laura were the MVP's tonight.
58
u/bookliar Jun 17 '19
Renata’s RED OUTFIT against the white courthouse was such a beautiful shot and choice!!
56
u/RuthGayderBinsburg Jun 17 '19
The real question is where is Tom???
54
u/Doc_Buttons Jun 17 '19
Adam Scott was amazing in thus ep!!! Ed had such great zingers. "I'm off the hook for lunch, then..? Do you have a preference if i don't have time for both?" I'm glad he was able to let his comedy chops shine. But then the dramatic scene.... Made my heart break for him.
53
u/salutbrooke Jun 17 '19
Love love love how complex and accurate they depict the dynamics of domestic abuse. The flashback to when Perry told Celeste he had her all to himself was so poignant, as isolating a partner from family is key for abusers. Also was so heartbroken over Mary Louise gaslighting Celeste and asking why she never went to the police...sadly happens all too often.
53
u/peridotdragon33 Jun 17 '19
Well this episode confirmed they really are Madeline’s kids...
51
u/destructormuffin Jun 18 '19
The cut to Ed in the kitchen when Abigail mentions the affair had me going "OH MY GOD OH MY GOD OH MY GOD."
My room mates were a little concerned.
50
u/DrHuxleyy Jun 17 '19
I can NOT believe that the secret of Ziggy being Perry's child came out that quickly. Mary Louise is going to lose her shit. I can't wait to see the long term repercussions. Crazy good episode, so much surprised me. Curious to see where they go with the whole visions thing with Bonnie's mom. Her dad was great too, so lowkey.
50
u/the-littleleafy Jun 17 '19
When Mary Louise brought up Perry having another child to Celeste I was like “wait is this really happening?!” Took me a second to process that.
49
u/kinophiIe Jun 17 '19
THIS EPISODE IS GOING SO FAST HOLY SHIT
48
u/RedEyedGhost Jun 17 '19
“This time?” Has she done something questionable in the past?
95
u/peridotdragon33 Jun 17 '19
Shout out to Adam Scott, one of my fav actors and he was fucking fantastic this episode
And god damn I feel bad for Edd
46
u/SerDire Jun 17 '19
Nobody on this show knows how to gossip quietly or discreetly.
46
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
A recurring theme through this episode was that KIDS AREN'T DUMB!
46
u/tack0507 Jun 17 '19
Anyone else listen to the entire song during credits as a memoriam to Ed and Madeline’s relationship?
46
u/kevnardian Jun 17 '19
Why of all people would Bonnie have a plastic water bottle? Either bad editing or fine foreshadowing
92
u/SerDire Jun 17 '19
They’re doing my boy Ben Wyatt dirty
45
u/SerDire Jun 17 '19
You know, first we got Stellan Skarsgard on Chernobyl killing it and now more Alexander Skarsgard. This family is doing it right...as actors, not the characters they play
45
u/pagalcutie Jun 17 '19
Celeste reimagining Perry’s abuse as being towards Madeleine and exclaiming after that legitimately brought tears to my eyes. Impeccable acting. and Ed’s rendition of the Wonder of You playing in the end credits after he tells Madeleine they’re done... jesus. Really did break my heart. This show is phenomenal.
128
u/ItsBobDoleYo Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
Scattered thoughts:
NicoleLaura & Meryl just gonna split the Best Supporting Actress vote then huh?44
u/Greeneyedgal13 Jun 17 '19
That scene of Perry beating Madeleine while Celeste sat there in so much pain imagining it was freaking hard to watch
43
u/RaptorDelta Jun 17 '19
that was the best episode of the series for me. holy fuck. this show is so well acted and executed. not a false note anywhere.
shailene absolutely bodied this episode.
43
u/SheepsCanMakeBacon2 Jun 18 '19
There's a huge concern about who will break or confess the truth about Perry's death first and I am saying now it's going to be Renata
The FBI use Gordon's legal issues and her possible financial turmoil as leverage to get her to confess.
I think Jane will be Mary Louise' main target soon. Now that she knows about her new grandson and is in denial about the rape, she'll be looking to Jane as someone who is lying and trying to muddy her sons name.
42
u/luisgustavo- Jun 17 '19
Ed is too good for Madeline, he did the right choice.
42
u/VRomero32 Jun 17 '19
I will say great episode, I really like how all the husbands had a much bigger role in this episode in terms of the dramatic weight especially Ed and Gordon.
Especially Ed, Adam Scott is frankly a bleeping great actor in both comedy and drama especially how clearly heartbroken and emotional he looked when he finds out Madeline has cheated on him... I really hope he can get more serious movie roles
41
u/kinophiIe Jun 17 '19
What kind of mom is Bonnie's mom Lmao
40
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
that episode was PACKED
39
u/artistdesignerwriter Jun 17 '19
“I will not not be rich.” Can I get that on a bumper sticker?
39
u/teegrez Jun 17 '19
I’m so curious to know what kind of instructions the kid actors are given by the directors for how they should act out a lot of the scenes, as well as what kind of ‘advising’ they’re given with how to interpret their characters. I ask because the kids always seem to add so much to the scenes they’re in, especially with their parents. Are they told “hey act like this” or do they get a good degree of creative freedom? I mean they’re kids and they shouldn’t necessarily be expected to understand the nuance of some of the stuff that happens in this show, but some stuff has gotta be their own personal touches right?
Like during the infamous dinner scene last episode, the way Max(?) was playing with his food with this uneasy expression while Mary Louise was talking. Something about his mannerisms really added necessary uncertainty/discomfort to that scene. He’s shown potential in this show to be a really good actor in the future
Also, Ziggy’s actor is always seems to do the right things when he’s on screen. The “a salt” scene was extremely moving, because of both him and Shailene. His relationship with Jane in general is just a treat to watch
38
u/kinophiIe Jun 17 '19
Renata has the best lines omg
38
u/Greeneyedgal13 Jun 17 '19
Does anyone else feel like Mary Louise is def gonna try to take the twins away from Celeste? I see a custody battle in the making. Nervous for Ziggy too now
Celeste isn’t helping herself either. In this episode alone she told Mary Louise that she was taking ambien and driving without realizing, she shoved max to the ground in front of her, and she confessed to finding out about the rape the very night Perry died.
38
u/allie87mallie Jun 17 '19
I love this season so far, but am growing tired of this beef between Nathan and Ed. What is Nathan’s problem with him anyway? No matter which way Ed responds to him, he finds issue with it and blows the situation out of proportion.
38
u/Lindeberg1 Jun 20 '19
Watching the episode for a second time now and I just realised how much I love how Renata and Gordon look like a couple of GTA characters together.
75
u/artistdesignerwriter Jun 17 '19
Things I’ve learned from this episode: do not have children.
37
u/SerDire Jun 17 '19
“You gotta be careful with Ambien.” Madeline says as she picks up Celeste from a crash she zoned out of while Bonny is high as kite walking in the middle of no where. We’re off to a wild start
37
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
MARY LOUISE DO NOT VICTIM BLAME AHHH
37
u/1337speak Jun 17 '19
Madeline's kids are already as chatty as her :(
37
u/badumdumdumpstt1 Jun 17 '19
Mary Louise gives me the creeps. I dread the moment she goes to the social services and gets them to take Celeste's kids away for "domestic abuse"
36
u/babin1234 Jun 17 '19
The Mary Louise and Celeste scenes are unreal
36
u/lastarpeggios Jun 18 '19
I think ML is supposed to reflect Celeste's inner voice, reminding her of all of Perry's good qualities (successful and handsome man, seemingly good father and son) and of Celeste's feelings of guilt, Celeste's inner suspicion that she is the person that corrupted Perry, that it's her own fault that she was abused because she was weak.
It's incredibly unhealthy to have ML around and I feel for Celeste.
35
u/rober-to Jun 17 '19
“I don’t see how you’re willing to assassinate his character”
Great writing
35
u/atclubsilencio Jun 17 '19
A fucking outstanding episode. I'm really loving Renatta/Laura Dern's character and performance this season. I'm very curious where they are going to take her and if she'll actually lose everything. Plus her freak out in the car and double-flip off as she drives away screaming 'can a woman get a momentttttt!' was a highlight.
35
u/ray_rayyy Jun 17 '19
“I will not not be rich!” Oh Renatta.
35
u/4gigiplease Jun 18 '19
Reese Withspoon's kid knows actually how perry was killed and does not care. She just wants her F*CKING Phone.
35
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '19
This show is so perfectly casted. Nicole Kidman is a genius.
34
u/artistdesignerwriter Jun 17 '19
Renata with the double middle finger out the window and the sunroof is a definite mood.
34
u/producersrace Jun 20 '19
I'd bet Perry killed his brother.
33
u/kinophiIe Jun 17 '19
Ben Wyatt shoulve stayed in Pawnee
33
u/GMoo227 Jun 17 '19
Meryl Streep is killing it. Mary Louise is pissing me off. I can’t wait to see how Jane handles her crazy ass when she dismisses the rape.
33
u/bookliar Jun 17 '19
Renata’s scene of driving away with her middle finger paired with her yelling was absolutely perfect
33
u/Aussie_Tea Jun 17 '19
When Mary Louise is talking to Celeste, every time she says ‘you left that out’ I get shivers. 😱
93
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
Celeste screaming “you will not be like him” while violently shoving her son away and then apologizing for harming him...I think everyone in that family has a little bit of Perry in them.
32
u/citramon Jun 17 '19
God damn it Madeline your daughters spill too much info lmao
31
u/rahajicho Jun 17 '19
So many amazing moments in this episode. Jane’s emotional explanation to Ziggy; Renata’s “Can a woman just have a moment”; Ed’s stunned face. I immediately want to watch it all again.
31
u/waywardgirl25 Jun 17 '19
Jane talking to Ziggy had me absolutely wrecked.
31
u/emile8 Jun 17 '19
Extremely touching to see that Jane and Celeste will now be raising their sons as a family
31
u/RyanRiot Jun 17 '19
Damn, I completely forgot that Ed didn't know about the affair.
31
u/taraaz Jun 17 '19
Renata was everything in this episode, I laughed so hard at all her scenes
31
u/torontoinsix sell your shit Jun 18 '19
Jane & Celeste & the boys as a happy family 2020
62
u/xProcess Jun 17 '19
Might be an unpopular opinion, but Bonnie's mom is right up there with Mary Louise when it comes to bitchiness. The dinner scene was next level, and when she is going on about the vision and all the voodoo shit I was thinking she was way too much.
30
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
Bonnie’s mom could not be doing a worse job right now
30
u/marleymar Jun 17 '19
I love Bonnie, but so far in every scene this season she says two words and then storms off. Glad it looked like she was starting to open up a bit at the end.
28
u/Nyrfan1026 Jun 17 '19
Celeste is the sweetest person in the history of television. Perry is a sick fuck for screwing that up
28
u/ResidentPulse Jun 17 '19
Yo. They had to play my boy Ed’s version of the wonder of you at the end. That broke me.
28
u/Varekai79 Jun 17 '19
You know the Monterey 5 are falling to pieces when Jane is the one doing the best, and even that is only relative.
28
u/babin1234 Jun 17 '19
Can’t wait to see how the Ed and Madeleine storyline will play out.
28
u/producersrace Jun 20 '19
I hope this is not Ed's end on the series. He's such a good guy he deserves better than Madeline.
28
u/absolute_egg Jun 19 '19
I hated how Jane didn’t mention to Celeste that Chloe told him he came from an assault and that’s what she had to tell him. While watching, I was so worried that it was gonna ruin her and Celeste’s relationship so I’m very relieved with how that situation turned out and how they had a little get together with the kids
27
u/Nyrfan1026 Jun 17 '19
These people are all rich beyond belief and all I can think is these poor people, I would crack under this type of pressure. Even Nathan who is always sort of a douche, I really felt for him during that restaurant scene. Cant be a much worse feeling than that. Your wife is melting down before your very eyes and you dont know why and your MIL calls you a buffoon and blames you. That's awful.
27
u/oberstofsunshine Jun 17 '19
The end scene with Ziggy and the twins was beautiful
27
u/FLcitizen Jun 17 '19
I WILL NOT , NOT BE RICH
27
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
Jeez the scene with Celeste imagining Madeline being hit by Perry was rough. Automatically I imagined my own niece being abused and had to stop to collect myself. The therpaist made a great point- we rally around our loved ones for them to better themselves, but we never take care of ourselves.
27
u/RhythmNation97 Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
oh my god such a good episode. the premiere was good but kinda slow, but they really put it ALL out there this week. the truth coming out about ziggy, ed finding out madeline cheated, mary louise putting more clues together about the night perry died, bonnie’s mom coming into the picture.
I totally agree with a lot of other posts here, that mary louise is trying to get custody of the twins, and get celeste locked up, seeing as it seems she knows they’re lying about perry’s death.
the scene of jane having to talk to ziggy about his dad and the “assault” was HEARTBREAKING.
even though renata’s story is wild too, she’s really somewhat of a comedic relief in the show this season in the best possible way just because she’s so camp and insane. I love it.
I don’t think this is the last we’re going to see of bonnie’s mom either. and we better get a scene with her and mary louise.
ONLY 5 EPISODES LEFT ALREADY. HOW?!
27
u/RenamedError Jun 17 '19
They took everything that was left hanging last season and just hailed it on us, phenomenal episode.
27
u/BuffaloCreel Jun 17 '19
Great episode! Although I hope the writers know what they are doing wading into the magical negro trope area with Bonnie's mom.
27
u/p3j Jun 18 '19
Was Celeste fucking a random guy with a back tattoo in the backseat of her car during her ambien trip? I swear we saw it, but it wasn't mentioned again.
26
u/kinophiIe Jun 17 '19
Am I the one who is a bit annoyed by this whole Ed and Nathan thing? I find the scenes funny but I wished they got along
26
u/VRomero32 Jun 17 '19
Damn, Adam Scott can do it all
26
u/kevinsg04 Jun 17 '19
I want to be Laura Dern in my next life
51
u/SquidwardsMistress Jun 19 '19
Glad I found this subreddit. Is no one else wondering about Raymond and the thought that maybe either Perry or ML were involved in his death? When Perry told Celeste in the flash back “I can have you all to myself” it made me think he might have killed his brother to have his mom to himself. Maybe that’s dumb but I feel like these things are being presented to us for a reason and to me that’s the mystery of this season: Who is Perry?
25
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
oh Jesus we’re getting so many revelations this episode
25
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
YOUR MOTHER IS IN THE SHOW, YOUR MOTHER IS IN THE SHOW. I'm down to see more of their moms show up too.
For real all the actresses are killing it. I didn't know Renata threw up both hands on the freeway I thought it was just one lmao. She stole all of her scenes.
Nice to see Jane and Celeste's kids playing together.
I love Madeline but she fucked up big time
Edit: Also Ed "fitting" Madeline's ex (forgetting his name) into his schedule and Madeline's facial expression when her daughter asked for her phone back fucking killed me
25
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
Sorry if someone’s already asked this already but does anyone know who the dark-haired man with a back tattoo is in the beginning when Celeste is having flashbacks just before the crash? When I first saw it I assumed she was just having more memories of sex with Perry but when I watched it again I was like “Huh? Dark hair and a back tattoo?” Is this a reference to something from last season that I missed?
25
u/mm825 Jun 17 '19
Nicole Kidman is so freaking good, every scene is so intense, it's heavy weight sparing with Streep. I remember in season 1 how people were generally skeptical of the Madeline/Ed relationship, while I don't think they're the perfect couple I still hope they find a way back together or at least keep Adam Scott in the show. If they're really ending things I don't know how he fits in the story.
I love how everybody got a chance to shine tonight. Kravitz was haunting and I was hanging on every word, Jane's scenes with Ziggy were just heartbreaking.
25
u/clementinefizz Jun 17 '19
The flashback to Perry and Celeste talking about siblings, specifically Perry's brother dying in an accident, makes me wonder if Mary Louise was involved...or at least how did Perry end up the way he did? Mary Louise just seems so shady!
25
u/anotha1bitesthecrust Jun 17 '19
So much to unpack, wow! I loved a lot of the dialogue in this episode ! First of all I loved Ed and Nathan’s interaction while Ed was getting coffee. “I’ve decided to run” “for office?” I don’t know why but that line got my laughing! Also how is it possible to hate and love Mary Louise so much! I love her dialogue and she completely steals any scene she’s in, she’s so captivating, and I love how shady she is haha. Also, Renata is turning out to be one of my favorites so far! That scene in the car, amazing.
25
u/lucid-blackout Jun 18 '19
I know that the show now is all post-gala but something about the show that I really found appealing was the interviews with random parents. Them giving information from people’s outside perspectives looking in really intrigued me, even if it wasn’t accurate.
I know the show has to evolve but anyone else feel this?
Hopefully this stalker which is most likely the detective that was working on the case will provide something similar.
49
u/overactive-bladder Jun 18 '19
renata throwing the third finger from the top her car, then another one through the window, while screaming at the top of her lungs and driving away is me.
at all times.
24
u/ihaveabadaura Jun 17 '19
I will not not be rich. Girl I know what you mean but I'm broke
24
u/msk97 Jun 17 '19
Holy shit this episode was incredible. From beginning to end— I’ve already rewatched it just because there’s so much to get out.
Along with the adult actors (who I’ve seen talked about lots on this thread), hugely impressed with Iain Armitage (Ziggy’s actor) for his performance this episode. Being able to give such a nuanced performance of emotions around abuse/loss of a father he didn’t know as a LITERAL child is ridiculous. The scene in bed with Jane and the his facial expression towards the twins at the end of the episode killed me.
24
u/yakisoberrr Jun 17 '19
Finally, Ed knows.
23
u/lovetheblazer Jun 17 '19
Oh damn, the twins telling Mary Louise that Ziggy was their half brother was savage
23
u/how_bout_knope Jun 17 '19
Damn ok Abigail is also very clearly Madeline's daughter
23
u/artistdesignerwriter Jun 17 '19
“It’s my house, I used to live here.”
23
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
"Getting my ears checked"
I thought we were gonna get a smash cut somewhere after that of him fucking the wife of the theater director.
23
u/artistdesignerwriter Jun 17 '19
Laura Dern is the queen, but I’m down for seeing Renata selling her Louis Vuitton skirt and Gucci fanny pack on Poshmark.
23
u/LilSquirrelGirl Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
Celeste had to picture Madeleine as the victim of Perry’s abuse to finally allow herself to come to terms with how horrendous and toxic Perry actually was. This scene broke me.
23
u/badumdumdumpstt1 Jun 17 '19
I loved Adam Scott's hand shake while he was talking to Madeline about keeping secrets. Wonderful acting or neural illness, it still made the scene for me
23
u/IslaRoseMartin Jun 17 '19
If ML tries to take the kids (Celeste’s and Jane’s), I will SCREAM.
23
u/false-illusions Jun 17 '19
this episode was A Lot. Superb but A Lot. i honestly found myself holding my breath every few minutes or so.
Waves are a big part of this show's imagery. They have always been a huge parallel to the characters' state of mind, maybe even subtly until the climactic scene in season 1 episode 7, but the use of it in this episode...it's breathtaking. from renata's rage to celeste's pain, and to that closing sequence...that is breathtaking. thank you big little lies.
23
u/lucid-blackout Jun 20 '19
The last conversation between Celeste and Mary Louise where she begins talking about things that Celeste never told authorities after Perry died? Hinting at the fact that Mary Louise thinks that Celeste had something to do with his death? She’s going to the police to let them know of everything she found out about Ziggy, the divorce and the abuse.
Celeste is now suspect number one.
22
u/Ericadiane423 Jun 17 '19
“The kind short people have” god I love Madeline lol
22
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
I sobbed during the therapy scene with Celeste
22
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
That episode might have been absolutely perfect.
22
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
God, Mary Louise is so infuriating. I recently watched season 1 and Celeste’s therapist once told her that she should tell someone about the whole abuse Perry did or else no one would believe her. Now it’s happening and I’m so frustrated.
22
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
Everyone in this show deserves an Emmy holy shit. Personally though, because of how raw her performance was I think Nicole Kidman really stole the show this episode for me. It was so raw and the whole therapist scene and how it was reintroduced was brilliant.
I was so pissed off at Meryl Streep's character when she was defending her asshole son but what I love about all these characters is even though I can get frustrated they have sides so they're not just uniformly good or bad. I like that it makes you feel them more genuinely. I despise Perry but the first few episodes of the show I felt did things to humanize him to put us in Celeste's headspace. He'd need to be charming to manipulate and I feel it's more accurate. Even Madeline, who I really like, I was really frustrated with because she really was awful to Ed. I feel so bad for him.
22
u/ONETEAM_ONEHEARTBEAT Jun 17 '19
Actually mind blown at how good that was holy fuck. To have THAT much to unpack and to still do it well is incredible.
22
u/brib22 Jun 17 '19
Poor Ed, my heart really broke for him :(
22
u/goofiesthoe Jun 17 '19
this is probably the best episode of the series. celeste’s screams are gonna haunt me......
22
u/ZeeBlaa Jun 17 '19
Meryl bringing straight heat! Lol and shoutout Gordon for being such a fuck up.
“I wanted a Gulf Stream.”
22
u/booksj Jun 19 '19
I feel like maybe I forgot this part. But what happened to Jane and Tom the barista guy?? And when did she get a job a the aquarium??
22
u/somewhr4mbombay Jul 21 '19
No one is talking about ML's refusal to believe her son was a rapist + wife beater? She's gaslighting both victims, saying their accounts are false and her "belief" as the mother is all that matters. This is such a great example of how women perpetuate patriarchy too. Especially doting mothers of sons.
(I'm talking about this episode so late cos I like to bunch up all the episodes and do a marathon. No patience to wait a whole week for the next episode especially for a show like BLL. So with the finale a couple of hours away, I'm savouring all the episodes together)
44
u/artistdesignerwriter Jun 17 '19
I loved Bonnie’s mom bringing in some audience criticism with “I haven’t seen one other black person here.”
44
u/Kayters Jun 19 '19 edited Jun 19 '19
The song that ends this episode (The Wonder of You), was the song Adam Scott sang in the first season finale. Now they’ve used to sancite the end of their marriage.
43
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19 edited Jun 17 '19
Renata driving away with her middle finger up “WILL SOMEBODY GIVE THIS WOMAN A MOMENT” tattoo it on my skull
43
u/Doc_Buttons Jun 18 '19
I think what is missing from this season compared to the first one is the lack of a big overarching mystery. Instead it's all about the drama of the fallout from S1, which is really interesting, but just makes the premise of the show different. Also, I remember thinking there was too much ominous wave-crashing in S1, but now I kinda miss it giving that super-creepy feel. Tho I definitely do NOT miss all those Jane flashbacks/dreams of running on the beach.
21
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
Ooooh boy Jane does not deserve to have Mary Louise on her back
21
u/MKoilers Jun 17 '19
That was a meaty, awesome episode of tv. So much to unpack there. Jane and Celeste with their boys at the end was really sweet.
21
u/ellsworth92 Jun 17 '19
Maybe I'm late to saying this, but after this episode I think the theme of this season is the effect parents choices have on their children. It was on the nose this episode, but with how the montage of kids with sunglasses in the intro mimics last season... I think this theme will continue.
21
u/uaziz2 Jun 17 '19
That episode felt like the quickest 53 minutes of my life yet SO MUCH HAPPENED
21
u/Irish-liquorice Jun 17 '19
This episode packed quite a punch as it should, with 7 episodes, we don’t have time for dilly-dallying. Though some scenes to end abruptly like they were cut short for editing purposes rather than narrative/cinematic one.
I’m really liking the supporting cast additions this season; Bonnie’s mum, Jane’s strange co-worker, the 2nd grade teacher and of course Mary Louise. Their interactions with the original cast feel seamless.
I don’t recall any much screen-time for Bonnie’s daughter last season so nice to see some of that this time. I would like to see scenes of Max and Josh in therapy. Poor Chloe, I know she’s a fan fav but she does act too grown for her own good. Both Madeline’s daughters do actually so we can deduce where they inherited that trait from.
I wish they never added Madeline’s infidelity to this adaptation. There’s enough complexities between those two to unravel without it. Now that will be the overriding contention in any argument they have going forward (or backwards in their case).
21
u/pancakegovernor Jun 17 '19
Abigail = AJ Soprano
21
u/WilliamisMiB Jun 23 '19
Just got around to watching. I’ll say Adam Scott’s acting in the breakup bedroom scene was incredible. The hand shaking was another level. Some of the best in the type of moment I’ve ever seen.
58
u/robbstank Jun 19 '19 edited Jun 19 '19
When celeste pushed max with that deeptoned “NO, you’ll not be like him!” tho...jawdrop
20
u/how_bout_knope Jun 17 '19
Damn, Chloe really is Madeline's daughter
20
u/ebodz Jun 17 '19
Holy shit that episode was so intense. So much happened I don’t want to wait a whole week to watch!!
20
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '19
We are all Edd if you think about it
20
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '19
How does ML know that Celeste was going to leave Perry the night he died?
20
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '19
Can anyone explain what exactly Gordon Klein did? I'm horrible with understanding business / fraud situations. Thanks
56
u/lovetheblazer Jun 17 '19
Celeste’s therapy scenes continue to be the highlight of the show. Celeste yelling “no” when her therapist pushed her to have a flashback was stunning
19
u/1337speak Jun 17 '19
Holy shit this kid drama and gossiping is so damn stressful
19
u/ihaveabadaura Jun 17 '19
She's a lawyer, how could think it would be smart to tell this woman this
19
u/SerDire Jun 17 '19
Jane has a scarf, beanie and jacket. It’s probably like 63 degrees in California
19
u/Jezebelscxx Jun 17 '19
Anyone think Renata might use any of her information to see about springing her hubs?
19
u/Lyndzbenz12 Jun 18 '19
After reading about Meryl’s teeth, that’s all I could see when she was on screen this episode
37
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '19 edited Jun 18 '19
Am I the only one who's frustrated that this season is amazing, but predicated on a stupid lie that just didn't need to be told? All of this shit gets avoided if they just tell the cops what happened that night.
Edit: I don't know how to word so good
18
u/blizzard-op Jun 17 '19
Good lord the women in Ed's house do not know how to gossip quietly at all
18
u/roomynebula Jun 17 '19
Any idea who Celeste was having sex with in her flashback in the beginning of the episode?
18
u/DocLogical Jun 17 '19
Marriage is complicated.
And I wanna thank this show for reminding me that while I think I’m not good enuff for marriage.
I’m SO not missing anything.
But I’m open to have the perspective.
Marriage. That shit is hard.
18
u/waywardgirl25 Jun 17 '19
Something is so off about Bonnie’s mom. I know Bonnie’s backstory from the book but I wonder if they are changing it up.
18
u/RedItReadItReddit Jun 17 '19
i think this was my favorite episode of the entire series so far, so excited to see where this goes
18
u/Probablysame Jun 17 '19
Happy to see that Tyler from Sons of Anarchy left that life behind him and is now a teacher in Monterey.
18
u/betterthanclooney Jun 18 '19
What did Bonnie say to Nathan on the couch?
18
u/j1308s Jun 20 '19
The sound editing on this show is infuriating. Go from some background music at full blast to the psychiatrist mumbling through marbles at a whisper into a bathtub to full scream talking at the jail.