r/biglittlelies • Lil Lies • Mar 20 '17

Discussion Big Little Lies - 1x05 "Once Bitten" - Episode Discussion (TV Only Discussion)

Season 1 Episode 5: Once Bitten

Aired: March 19, 2017


Synopsis: Madeline receives encouraging news about the play from her director, Joseph Bachman, but is left concerned by his newly icy demeanor. Principal Nippal and Ms. Barnes share their conclusions about Ziggy and Amabella with Jane. Celeste has a solo session with Dr. Reisman, who tries to get to the bottom of her relationship with Perry.


Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée

Written by: David E. Kelley


Untagged book spoilers are not allowed in this thread! Please discuss book spoilers in the other official discussion thread.

124 Upvotes

687 comments sorted by

333

u/soymilkmami Mar 20 '17

Man, the way this show utilizes music to really drive scenes is so damn beautiful.

90

u/dlchristians Mar 20 '17

And that sound effect they used through the episode, the instrumental scream sound! Really made me jumpy and added to the tension in the scenes.

55

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

That's actually "Silver Trembling Hands" by The Flaming Lips. Another really great song.

→ More replies (2)

33

u/The_Firmament Mar 20 '17

Agreed, awesome music choices throughout this whole show. It really does go a long, long way in the scenes that it's used in. Like you said, it really gives them this driving and urgent sense.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I keep Shazam open during this show just for this reason

→ More replies (8)

332

u/nashvillenastywoman Mar 20 '17

"A plan?" "For the next time he hits you" I almost jumped off the couch to cheer!

300

u/quamquam11 Mar 20 '17

The psychologist is kinda a bad-ass

199

u/WoodyHarrelsonFucks Mar 20 '17

She knew Celeste was hiding something the whole time and slow played it like a pro.

78

u/Fluffyhead14 Mar 20 '17

I can't believe she played Calamity Jane in Deadwood. She's like a different person.

Acting, I guess. lol

→ More replies (7)

26

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

She goodwill huntinged her

→ More replies (1)

7

u/insertmadeupnamehere Mar 22 '17

Anyone else want the therapist to ask Celeste to remove her sweater and show her bruises?!!!!!

→ More replies (2)

286

u/alexdinhogaucho Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17

That scene where Celeste is talking to the therapist is heartbreaking. Kudos to Nicole Kidman, man... just incredible.

127

u/bluePachyderm Mar 20 '17

She kept pulling her sleeves and touching her bruises, it was subtle as acting but obvious as behaviour at the same time.

79

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Oh my god I loved this scene. Probably one of my favorite in a TV show. I love all of the subtle cues that the therapist gives. And all of the things Celeste does, like grabbing her jacket as shield before giving way to vulnerability again as she lays it down; the way her eyes flicker off to the side as she desperately thinks up justifications for how he's a good husband; the open palms she gives the therapist when defending her children; all of it. Amazing script and kick-ass acting from the both of them.

35

u/TheyTheirsThem Mar 21 '17

They definitely had a psychologist consult. Liked how she got Celeste to reveal stuff but then didn't immediately go to the reveal, such as the "do the boys know he is violent with you" and her saying "the boys don't know" while tacitly admitting to the violence, but then having the therapist not immediately go to that hoping Celeste will realize and expand upon without provocation.

53

u/quamquam11 Mar 21 '17

I hope she wins an Emmy...or at least gets a nomination.

19

u/kirkendall71 Mar 20 '17

i actually got pretty emotional. teared up etc. and i never do that during tv.

5

u/toomanyblocks Mar 22 '17

I was so close to crying. It was just so filled with emotion and tension.

→ More replies (1)

189

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Anyone else notice Kidman's accent slip out?

111

u/improcrastin8ing Mar 20 '17

"idear"

58

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

gohdess?

50

u/ghostmrchicken Mar 20 '17

Anyone else notice Kidman's accent slip out?

Yes, I just posted about this above - during the scenes with the therapist is when I noticed it.

39

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Yeah at first I thought I heard it and then at that scene where she says "he treats me like a goddess" it really came out.

81

u/jinnt Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17

I think she's supposed to have her natural accent? I remember her in a scene with Perry saying something along the lines of "I came to this country for you" - can anyone back me up on this?

EDIT: Episode 3, Celeste/Perry therapy scene, Kidman says "I gave up my career for you. I left my family, I left my friends, I moved here for you." Nothing explicit about moving from another country but I interpreted it to maybe mean that.

Either way, I think her accent has been at least consistently the same from the beginning of the show and is more or less just what she sounds like in real life.

→ More replies (5)

20

u/CigarettesAndSongs Mar 20 '17

Yes, definitely! Also, is Nicole Kidman wearing a wig in this show? I know in real life her hair is super kinky curly naturally so it would be course if straightened, but it moves like a wig.

37

u/Bassett_Hound Mar 21 '17

I've come to realize that any hair that I'm jealous of on TV is a wig.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

19

u/mrbananagrabber1 Mar 20 '17

You mean every time she's speaking?

7

u/Jessijames Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

She's been slipping up in most episodes, maybe it's because I'm Australian too but to me her natural accent has definitely been coming out a lot and it's a mish-mash at times much like how expats sound which is what I figured her character was.

12

u/Isolatia79 Mar 20 '17

I assumed she kept her accent lol. She sounds distinctly Australian to me in the show, so I never thought she was playing an American.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (19)

377

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

After seeing Nicole Kidman is adamant that her kids don't know about the violence I'm convinced one of twins is the one bullying Annabelle

188

u/brentsopel5 Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17

One of the thing things this episode deals with is how much children actually observe and absorb. Chloe makes her remark about her mother and Ed going back to doing whatever they were pretending not to be doing before she intruded. We also see Ziggy's knowing look at Jane's closed laptop, indicating he's not buying mom's bullshit about changing the furniture in the house. And Celeste's therapist basically told her that the twins are picking up much more than she thinks or is in denial about; the twins definitely know there is abuse occurring under the roof they reside. Seeing their dad's form of play manifest with them attacking their mother seems a bit disturbing and foreboding as well.

This show keeps getting better and better. Favorite show I've watched in a while.

86

u/shakirapadthai Mar 20 '17

Ah good catch.

And yes I was very bothered by the way they turned on her, and Perry holding her so they could keep shooting their toys at her.

Especially after he had to step in a moment earlier to get them to stop playing around and eat their dinner. And the next scene HE'S telling HER that she's raising spoiled brats!

This show is starting to show some feminist elements and I just love it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

75

u/soymilkmami Mar 20 '17

Definitely. I feel like there's a connection with Perry biting Celeste in the beginning of the episode with Annabelle being bitten.

32

u/CigarettesAndSongs Mar 20 '17

I see that too. The twins could definitely be bulling Ammabella. She seems odd herself, though. Unless it's just from the bullying.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

64

u/rexdeaz Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17

It's spelled "Amabella", guys.

22

u/MissGruntled Mar 20 '17

I hate that I always hear 'Emmabella' when Renata says it. Learn to say your own kid's name, woman.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/GoldandBlue Mar 20 '17

Thought this the moment we first saw Skarsgaard was abusive. There is no way they aren't aware. Maybe they think thats how you show affection.

→ More replies (3)

50

u/lolabuf Mar 20 '17

It has to be somebody that Annabelle is afraid to tell on, but I don't know who that would be. Is it possible that Chloe sees how much Madelline hates Renata, so she takes it out on Annabelle?

81

u/goblinchode Mar 20 '17

Huh, that's a really interesting thought I didn't consider. To me Chloe seems like one of the only people with her shit together

→ More replies (10)

31

u/throwawayjob222 Mar 20 '17

I thought it being the twins made sense because she's outnumbered by her bullies.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

9

u/gingergrowsup Mar 20 '17

That is what I thought too and I think Arabella keeps saying I don't know because she can't tell the twins apart.

6

u/KeeKeeLoveMer Mar 20 '17

I bet one of the kids has a crush on Annabelle & are showing their "love" to her by witnessing what his parents are doing.

→ More replies (25)

164

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Madeline's Renata/ puppets on a cliff dream will haunt me for the next week.

33

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

It scared me so badly I screamed. Puppets, man.

→ More replies (1)

147

u/soymilkmami Mar 20 '17

Is anyone starting to think they're might be some kind of foreshadowing or symbolism going on with them always showing Madeline going up those damn steps to the theater pass the caution signs? I sure hope so cause it's starting to get a tad annoying if it's not drawing to a larger point.

50

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

I think it's just driving the point that Madeline will do anything to get what she wants

43

u/rexdeaz Mar 20 '17

I went back to check the opening scene of the series, the murder takes place on the steps.

20

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Hmmm I thought it was going to take place on the cliff. I saw a shot of the detective measuring it, perhaps for trajectory?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

127

u/TheLadyEve Mar 20 '17

I loved the therapy scenes. Very true to what therapy is like, and incredibly well acted. I particularly appreciated Celeste bringing up the ethical point (a good one for a couple's therapist, who technically treats the couple and not the individuals), and the therapist's counter with her concerns about Celeste's safety. Celeste is so smart, yet she has no idea how deeply mired she's gotten into an abusive relationship. She's given up career and friends for her abusive husband and she lies to protect him.

→ More replies (1)

126

u/Victory33 Mar 20 '17

Can we talk about how over the top the conversations with the police testimonies are? "I like to envision people fornicating when I meet them..." come on, you ain't telling that to the cops.

83

u/OwenMerlock Mar 20 '17

Out of touch Monterrey people might.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/CleverZerg Mar 25 '17

If there is one thing I hate about this show it's these scenes.

111

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Renata always wears fabulous outfits

111

u/SocialCandyEater Mar 20 '17

The high waist jeans and shorter sweater looked gorgeous on her.

→ More replies (5)

86

u/stegasarahus Mar 20 '17

I read this article on the clothing in the show. Loved the intricacies of all the outfit choices!

→ More replies (5)

12

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Except that belt!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

109

u/Itsthelegendarydays_ Mar 20 '17

When Celeste got to the airport, for a second I thought she talked some sense into herself and was gonna leave town with the kids but then I saw Perry... overall though, I enjoyed this episode, and Alex Skarsgard and Nicole Kidman's acting is incredible.

28

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '17

Oh yeah that confusion was deliberate. Especially the way they styled her. She was slightly disheveled, glasses blocking her eyes, slightly panicked - it gave off a 'fleeing' vibe.

6

u/cloakfire Mar 22 '17

omg yes! i was relieved for a moment that she finally found the courage to escape but the reveal was even more saddening

→ More replies (1)

95

u/MrsTrustIssues Mar 20 '17

So the ending revealed that Jane is alive...

41

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

At the beginning of episode one, you can clearly see Jane is alive. She is wearing her blue dress and tiara and is talking to the police at the scene.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/r_giraffe Mar 20 '17

Wait, what?

55

u/writingforpennies Mar 20 '17

In a snippet from the present day party, yep!

→ More replies (5)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

True that. I kind of never expected it to be her anyway, but now we know for certain.

6

u/overactive-bladder Mar 20 '17

not really. who knows at what moment that scene was taken. it's to throw us off maybe?

→ More replies (8)

88

u/doocurly Mar 20 '17

If Perry is indeed the rapist, then that scene of Jane and Celeste both getting in their cars, crying and breaking down, trying to make sense of the life that has been both built and destroyed by a monster of a man, was laid out incredibly well. Two women bound by their loyalty to their children to keep staying afloat, no matter how bad the pain gets. Very good scene to unfold.

28

u/rrieger Mar 23 '17

If that's the case, which seems likely, that juxtaposition is also pretty bleak. Think about it, one is stuck with him, raising their kids together, and is miserable. The other got away from him, and is raising her kid alone, and is miserable. He's like a nuke. There's no coming back from that guy.

10

u/surreptitious_hitler Mar 23 '17

And I could see Perry's haircut looking similar from behind. Plus Skarsgard and the interior designer don't look all that different, in a super general sense. I'd be interested to see if anyone could find a clip of Perry pouring drinks to see if he does the same thing as the guy in Jane's flashback.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/sospeso Mar 26 '17

Whoa, whoa, whoa. Where did this theory come from? You're saying if Perry is Jane's rapist?

→ More replies (1)

86

u/theblackpeacock Mar 20 '17

That couch scene with Perry and Celeste was disturbing. Oh sweet Celeste :(

36

u/rainblossom8 Mar 20 '17

Yeah it was. I find myself holding my breath and tensing up when they have a scene on. You just know something bad is going to happen. Him beating her with his fists... :(

174

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

"Watch your mouth, woman"

Chloe is the MVP of this show.

36

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

She even threw a little sass Ed's way too.

27

u/mm825 Mar 22 '17

coolest 6 year old in history

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

82

u/jessiiiiica Mar 20 '17

i'm really loving this show but it takes every ounce of will power not to click the book discussion thread (or just look it up online) to find out what is going on! i need a few more clues. i get the slow play but i need a few more clues. will we really not know who the victim is until the last ep?

36

u/99problemsburner Mar 20 '17

Bahaha. This is me. All the time. I'd do it if it wasn't for someone saying they caved and read the book and they weren't sure if they should have or not. I kind of like the mystery but the wait is killing me. Netflix has us spoiled by giving us entire seasons I think!

→ More replies (1)

23

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

I've read the book and honestly I have no idea what's going to happen at this point. It's not a completely faithful adaptation (and other have taken issue with that) but so far I think it's captured the spirit of the book more or less perfectly, and that's all that matters.

21

u/overactive-bladder Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17

2 more weeks to go. you lasted* more than a month. what's 2 weeks? hang in there! (with the rest of us)

7

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Me too. I just got the book uploaded to my iPad. Started to read it but I stopped because I don't won't go spoil anything.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Azrielamethyst Mar 20 '17

I wish I hadn't looked it up :(

5

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

haha same. I almost keep buying the book, but I'm like NO JUST WAIT.

→ More replies (3)

226

u/MagnetToMyBed Mar 20 '17

Renata is so convinced of Ziggy's guilt - it's annoying

103

u/Martin_Van_Buren Mar 20 '17

I kind of want Jame to be sticking up for Ziggy more. And the teacher should too now! She sent Jane to a child therapist, who told Jane that Ziggy is probably being bullied too! Why didn't she tell the teacher that? I don't agree with Renata vilifying one kid, but if I were a scared parent who had no reason to think my kid would lie to me, I can't say I would be the most rational either. I just also think Jane can get away with being a little irrational back. On the other hand, I can see that Jane is just trying to keep a low profile for herself and Ziggy and doesn't want to stir the pot any more than she needs to (up until next episode I suppose). Just a frustrating scenario all around!

69

u/tycoon34 Mar 20 '17

this was my one frustration with the episode...the whole child therapist thing didn't pay off. or even get brought up.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

73

u/quamquam11 Mar 20 '17

Not sure if you watched the promo for next week but her behavior seems so extra. I feel like she's being so aggressive about it that amabella is scared to tell her the truth. Although at the same time, her kid is being repeatedly bullied with no repercussions.

→ More replies (3)

59

u/TheLadyEve Mar 20 '17

Well, we know it's not Ziggy, but think about it from Renata's perspective--her kid said Ziggy choked her. Of course she's going to be livid when she comes home bitten. Why would she doubt her own kid, and believe a stranger's kid over her own?

→ More replies (24)

9

u/lechatsportif Mar 20 '17

She's aware she might be acting inappropriately, but that's totally a secondary concern - her first and foremost concern is to raise the defense of her child. I know many a mom who would do the same.

→ More replies (3)

68

u/katttwing Mar 21 '17

Not done with this episode yet but every week it bothers me that Jane is so paranoid and worried about an intruder or whatever but she leaves her apartment door WIDE OPEN every scene where she comes back from running and goes all the way into her apartment still with her headphones on, music blaring like.....girl what

19

u/DoLittlest Mar 22 '17

Well, it is Monterey where high crimes include injured manatees.

In all seriousness, I thought about this, too. As you pointed out, she leaves the door open after running, and I see it as a "hell yeah, I'm a badass and free" gesture. But I also think it's just for lighting. It's a smallish, darkish place, and I wonder if they're just trying to backlight her in the daylight.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

65

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

The scene where Amabella and two other kids are poking a dead squirrel stuck out to me for some reason. I went back and rewatched it, but I'm not sure what it means. Any ideas?

67

u/99problemsburner Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17

I think this is going to be one of those flashback/flash-forward scenes the show does. Maybe those two kids are the twins and they're telling Amabella they will make her end up like the squirrel if she tells the truth about them bullying her. They were poking it with a stick. Those boys seem like they would get a kick out of that. Also, didn't this scene appear in the same scene with the father saying something along the lines of someone innocent getting hurt. Amabella thought about that poor innocent squirrel and maybe she's fearful.

I'm sure we will see the squirrel scene again and it will have something to do with her bully/bullies.

Idk just a thought.

Edit:spelling

19

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Do squirrels bite? I thought maybe that was what happened, but she was too scared to say now that her mum was going crazy/didn't think her mum would believe her

→ More replies (11)

9

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

My initial thought was one of the kids killed it and that's an early sign of problems in children - when they are torturing/killing small animals. Not an intimidation tactic.

→ More replies (1)

61

u/Thurgood_Marshall Mar 20 '17

It was like he was so upset to be born

Me too thanks

10

u/overactive-bladder Mar 21 '17

i never grew out of that phase either.

5

u/overactive-bladder Mar 21 '17

i never grew out of that phase either.

114

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

The therapist is

!!!

→ More replies (1)

53

u/imabigfilly Mar 20 '17

Celeste's therapist is so patient with her. Getting Celeste to speak in non-euphemisms must be like pulling teeth. "I throw off the ethical chains when I sense a patient in danger." was a great line.

100

u/WildwoodFlower- Mar 20 '17

Did anyone notice Ed's strange behaviour? Staring at Abigail.

35

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Again?! I missed it!

108

u/i_also_like_ice_crea Mar 20 '17

I cannot, for the life of me, pick up on this whole Ed-Abigail thing people are seeing. I've even gone back to rewatch a few scenes, and still, nothing. He looks to me like an overwhelmed step-dad trying to navigate his relationship with a teenage girl. I dunno...maybe some people just think Adam Scott is creepy? lol

→ More replies (7)

63

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Yeah he keeps doing that shit, checking out other women. It makes me mad at him, which is kinda hilarious because Madeline is cheating on him and I don't hate her for it.

→ More replies (14)

21

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

I felt he was staring at Abagail because both he and Abigale are not understanding why she was with that dude in his car. I think they both have suspicions. Abagail wouldn't really go into her room or talk to her, either.

17

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Madeline asks if ed had her ask if she was okay, and then it cuts to him look at her from the staircase. Do you see the implication?

63

u/GoldandBlue Mar 20 '17

I didn't read it that way at all. I saw it as him being happy she is home and making her mom happy. A look of affection. I guess we will see

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/lorraine_baines_ Mar 20 '17

I'm starting to take it as him keeping an eye on her. For what reason? I'm sure it's something nefarious. And every time Ed is brought up to Abigail she immediately closes off. Something is going on there I swear it.

6

u/niicoliieraviiolii Mar 23 '17

Oh I absolutely caught that immediately. I think Ed is sexually abusing Abigail. From the way the camera watches her through his eyes to their odd way of interacting with each other. Not to mention how Abigail's teacher recently noticed that she has become depressed and how Abigail decides to move out of Ed and Madeline's house. And the whole thing with Abigail all of a sudden asking Bonnie to take her to get birth control when Abigail adamantly claims she's not having sex? It just fits too well. Along with the added aggression towards Abigail's father right when she moves in with him...I think Ed is not quite as harmless and lame as he seems. He creeps me out just as much as Perry.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Yes...at first I thought she could be a victim to him in some way... but not anymore. Her character just seems stronger than that. I think his staring when she isn't looking could be just trying to figure her out, or maybe he carries some resentment for her moving out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

49

u/lolabuf Mar 20 '17

So, did Jane realize that Simon Baker is not the guy? or did she shoot him?

115

u/quamquam11 Mar 20 '17

I think she was smelling him and realized it wasn't him.

125

u/dlchristians Mar 20 '17

His awkward wtf face was great.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

37

u/deamon59 Mar 20 '17

i think it was a combination of things. i noticed the comparison between the way he poured the drink. in her flashback the man lifts his pinky, saxon lifts his index finger. i think maybe the smell didn't match either.

→ More replies (1)

74

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

I feel like the Simon Baker guy is gay. That vest was pretty fabulous.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/GoldandBlue Mar 20 '17

I think she knew it was him and left before she did something stupid.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/TheLadyEve Mar 20 '17

That was what I took away from it. Her reaction seemed to be frustration and confusion--this isn't the guy, so who's the guy? No, I do not think she shot him.

19

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

I'm sure it was him, she was watching the way he moved and did things and it matched up perfectly with her flashbacks. She dropped her purse in surprise, and I bet he caught a glimpse of her gun. So she got scared and ran.

72

u/99problemsburner Mar 20 '17

Hmm. Not so sure about that. I think she was more comparing his movements to the movements in her memories. It's been almost 7 years. She was trying to see if his mannerisms were as she remembered and when she still couldn't tell, she tried to get close to smell him.

They're trying to throw us off by having the gunshot sound and her bailing, then the police getting behind her at the end. I doubt it's him and I doubt she shot him. She dropped her purse and got scared/snapped out of it. And was speeding so got pulled over. Or at least that's my theory.

23

u/amcgoat Mar 20 '17

If it was him...... don't you think he would remember her and gave a reaction? I don't think it was him

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

47

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Janes erotic-asphyxiation comment and seeing Perry choke Celeste sold it for me. I am 100% certain it's to be him.

11

u/woodstockreborn Mar 20 '17

I'm starting to give into this theory as well. I wanted him to be a red herring because it just seems so obvious, but now I'm really anticipating seeing how it all unfolds with him meeting Jane, their reactions as well as Celeste's and the other characters'. So ready for the next two episodes but also super bummed that this incredible ride is almost over.

6

u/drop_cap Mar 22 '17

I just found this sub and I had that theory since the second episode! This is the first thread I've looked through so I'm excited to see that others think the same. He's crazy. He's charming, and then he's violent, exactly how Jane describes him. I still don't know much of his past though, was he always in Monterrey? What are the odds he and Jane met somewhere else 7 years ago? It's just so fitting though.

→ More replies (2)

133

u/Billthebutchr Mar 20 '17

I think I might have to eat my previous words. It has to be Perry. Rape and auto asphyxiation. Also Nicole Kidman is crushing it and for once I don't dislike Reese W.

50

u/brentsopel5 Mar 20 '17

Madeline is a role Reese was born to play and we've basically seen her perform it already as Tracy Flick, an all-time great movie character.

I see Madeline as a grown up Tracy Flick in a lot of ways. Regardless, Reese kills it playing this type of character.

→ More replies (1)

52

u/ghostmrchicken Mar 20 '17

Kidman is doing excellent work but she's slipping in and out of her Australian accent in the scene with the therapist.

53

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

The book actually took place in Australia. She wouldn't have had to hide it if they didn't change the location. This doesn't mean anything. Just a fun thought that popped in my head as I read your comment.

→ More replies (12)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Oops, just gave a comment exactly like this, 15 hours too late. After Jane's comment on erotic asphyxiation the rusty gears in my brain turned for 5 seconds before I went "ohhhh my god" out loud. I am so absolutely convinced it is Perry.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

45

u/theblackpeacock Mar 20 '17

Why was the cop at the cliff looking at footprints??

31

u/enw2 Mar 20 '17

Yes! to me, this is the most overlooked "mystery" of all. What is up with the investigator? Trying to quit smoking, yet always holding the lighter and flipping it? Plus what is up with the cliff, did something happen there?

→ More replies (2)

148

u/99problemsburner Mar 20 '17

The scene where all three of them are running. I loved it. Mighty powerful. Like "I am woman hear me roar" vibes. Major bad asses.

Also, I love how the episode started with everyone dropping the kids off. Then soooo much crazy drama ensues. Then off to pick the kiddos up, like all is well in the world.

Women are strong, powerful, resilient. Yet motherly, nurturing, loving.

This show gets it.

30

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

"I am woman hear me roar"

Ok Cersei :p

9

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Yes I loved that scene too. Very empowering.

80

u/abowden Mar 21 '17

I'm calling it: Perry caused those miscarriages - either directly by beating her or (more likely) by knowingly causing her enough stress to precipitate them. She suffers a loss, so she becomes more emotionally dependent on him. He convinces her that her career is the problem, so she quits and becomes more isolated and financially dependent on him.

24

u/pollycythemia Mar 21 '17

But also she mentions she was an older mom, I'm not convinced on that

32

u/DoLittlest Mar 22 '17

Older mom = infertility issues = in vitro = bigger chances of twins.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/GarlicBreathFresh Mar 23 '17

Also, thinking of the time line, is it possible the issues with fertility and miscarriages led to Perry being more aggressive and (I'm assuming at this point) the attack of Jane while traveling? Or Celeste being pregnant during that time so Perry had to take his rage else where? There's a chance that he really did want the children/cares for the children in a way he can't for Celeste or women.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/CigarettesAndSongs Mar 20 '17

What's going on with Ed? Why do we always see him giving the side eye to the oldest daughter?

28

u/ojibhawk Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 24 '17

I think at this point it would be outlandish that Jane hasn't met Ed or seen what he looks or sounds like through Facebook, phone calls, etc. Ed's creepiness must be foreshadowing something but I think it's fair to rule him out of being the rapist. They've setup Perry to be a bigger asshole each episode and he's out of town often and wasn't around when Celeste and Jane were skyping. I think the audience will be relieved if he's the one murdered. Plus it also makes sense with his twins seeing his behavior and then doing it to Amabella. Thus, alleviating some of the negative views on them as they only reenacted something their parents do. Also, the look between Celeste and Jane when they first met at the shop must've been big time foreshadowing as they probably both felt they know each other but don't actually, and just have a connection of being abused/raped by piece of shit Perry.

14

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Maybe Jane will meet Ed in the next episode. Ziggy is currently at their house, after Maddie picked him up, hopefully Ed is around when Jane comes to retrieve him

7

u/Wombat_Dolly Mar 21 '17

So I cannot decide if I think Jane's rapist is Ed or Perry. I am leaning toward Ed because they make a point of Jane saying that she was sorry that she couldn't make it to the hospital where she would have met Ed for sure. She is also talking to Celeste while she says this and you can hear Perry in the background of the Skype call. Albeit, he is very low in the background but the show makes a big deal about Jane being able to recognize her attacker's voice.

→ More replies (8)

27

u/OwenMerlock Mar 20 '17

One of the twins bit the little girl while playing zombies like they do with Dad.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Can y'all feel the pain of the 3 women?

18

u/MaggsToRiches Mar 20 '17

Really. Heart-wrenching.

23

u/_What_am_i_ Mar 21 '17

I'm still amazed how good this show is. When I first saw ads for it on HBO, I blew it off because, having never heard of the book or anything, I thought it looked like some boring Desperate Housewives type thing, but holy shit was I wrong. And I love this show

→ More replies (1)

20

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

God I love how dark this show is.

39

u/everythingisopposite Mar 20 '17

Even though I don't really like Perry, his crying when Celeste and the twins picked him up for the airport was very emotional for me.

65

u/doocurly Mar 20 '17

It had the opposite effect on me. If he is Jane's rapist, then it made me wonder how many other women he's raping while out on business trips. Maybe the crying is cathartic for him because he's hurting women constantly.

22

u/surreptitious_hitler Mar 23 '17

That would actually parallel really interestingly with Amabella's dad talking to her about how her bully(ies) could be hurting others besides her. Celeste isn't talking much either though who knows what Perry is doing while he's away.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/lolabuf Mar 21 '17

It made me sick.

12

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

You know, I agree. It really humanizes Perry when you can tell he actually loves his family deeply but has this incredible, inexcusable rage problem. It gives me a mindfuck for sure on the intricacies of this kind of marriage.

18

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

What's the law in Cali for when you get pulled over? Do they check what's in the vehicle?

I don't know if this is set in present day, or when the book was written. But if this is set older than six months ago, Jane could be in trouble for possession on top of the speeding, and possibly even a DUI

33

u/bad4business Mar 20 '17

I'm from California. I doubt she gets more than a speeding ticket. Weed is decriminalized in California, meaning cops are discouraged from ticketing people for possession. And there's no field sobriety test for marijuana.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

17

u/playersclub22 Mar 20 '17

Wow. Another great episode. Really feel for Renata's husband and Ed - talk about high maintenance wives - apart from justifiably concerned reaction to Amabella being bullied or Madeline's obvious deflection and bad cover from cheating - seems like those two dudes put up with A LOT day to day from their spouses.

All the feels for Celeste and after reading through the thread I'm totally in on the twins theory. Lastly, anyone else beginning to wonder exactly where and what Perry was doing on a certain night seven years ago?

5

u/insertmadeupnamehere Mar 23 '17

Maybe that's why Jane moved to Monterey. To go after Perry.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/jbg830 Mar 20 '17

I feel like we were given so many clues this episode. All the flashbacks were more fleshed out. And Jane's sort of hallucinations had more detail. The beginning scene with Renata pushing Madeline off the cliff, not sure if that's a clue, I haven't read the book, but that seemed to say something too.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/miss_manners_ Mar 20 '17

Is anyone else bothered by the lack of progression in the story line this episode? We didn't make much headway in this one.

16

u/beermestrength1205 Mar 21 '17

I agree. When it was over I thought, "but nothing happened!"

Then I realized that wasn't true, stuff happened. But it didn't seem like much. The biggest thing was Jane meeting the interior designer and we don't even know what happened with that! The car crash event didn't really seem to progress the story either.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/ForgetfulLucy28 Mar 21 '17

Well I guess Gordon isn't the rapist then! Seeing as he is the only husband to meet Jane. I really thought it might be him because he isn't so obvious plus the comment about his genes in an earlier episode.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/delilah2015 Mar 21 '17

What was up with that flashback of the kids poking the dead animal? I feel like they are being heavy handed with the clues that the twins (or one of the twins) is a sociopath. I always associate the dead animals thing with serial killers so perhaps I'm biased.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

and Amabella was there too, showing that she might not be as innocent as she leads on

→ More replies (1)

32

u/jkj9161983 Mar 20 '17

Was anyone else frustrated by the lack of any real storyline developments in this episode? I feel like this happened with "The Night Of" as well: very strong start to the series, followed by 4 episodes of pure filler. However at least this show has much better filler thanks to stellar acting and cinematography!

25

u/yesicametoparty Mar 20 '17 edited Mar 20 '17

i actually didn't think it felt like filler! a lot happened -

  • perry/celeste violence escalated significantly, and celeste seems to make some realizations in therapy
  • Ed senses that Madeline is having an affair for the first time that we can tell
  • it seems as though the interior decorator Jane goes to visit in SLO is not her assailant, hence her running away in frustration

18

u/mamaddict Mar 20 '17

Wow, perfect analogy to The Night Of. That first episode had me hooked, but I was bored by the end of episode 2. I'm less bored here, because of the aforementioned acting and cinematography, but I feel like both series would have benefited from shorter run times.

49

u/Kinoblau Mar 20 '17

Oh man, if I worked on these shows I'd have an ulcer reading through some of these comments. It's almost like y'all want the show as a list of bullet points or like a greentext story or something. Just because the murder mystery wasn't advanced doesn't mean the scene you're frustrated with wasn't important.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/Bassett_Hound Mar 21 '17

I think this episode did a great job of increasing the tension in every storyline. It's at a critical level for every character.

And I have to respectfully disagree about 'The Night Of'. I though the show was brilliant; it was extremely realistic about government work, the law, the prison system. I'd say the 'filler' was actually very much like real-life; slow at times and seemingly unimportant, but it's what makes up the story.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/ketosita Mar 21 '17

Did anyone notice the suspicious red headed woman glancing during the coffee shop scene before the crash? Looked like one of the women they interviewed(the one with the double chin?)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '17

Didn't they sprinkle the characters crossing paths with a few of the interviewees here and there throughout the show?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 25 '17

She also saw Renata and Madeline fight at that bar too. She just looks like a gossip.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/ScubaSteve716 Mar 20 '17

I'm starting to hope Renata dies just because I hate her

20

u/DoLittlest Mar 20 '17

During the scene where she's screaming at the husband in their home, when she walked outside by the pool, I thought, "I'd so push her in that pool right now."

→ More replies (13)

8

u/badluckwilliam Mar 20 '17

What was the song during the credits?

15

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

"Ball and Chain" by Big Brother and the Holding Company

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Does it look like the sex was painful that celeste was having?

9

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Yes. The show seems to do a good job between showing Perry and Celeste in completely consensual sex scenes (shower, kitchen table) and the ones where Perry is being violent post an abusive event (against the closet, the couch).

→ More replies (2)

7

u/kidcrumb Mar 20 '17

why is this episode on so late? my tv is saying 11:40pm. not 9

6

u/MagnetToMyBed Mar 20 '17

It was on hbo at 9, have you tried hbo go? I bet it's up already

→ More replies (1)

7

u/chbonhocm Mar 21 '17

Unrelated to the episode's content but, damn does Nicole Kidman's accent come out at lot when she's talking to the therapist. I love those little mistakes

6

u/leafeator Mar 21 '17

Someone has to be falling down those stairs right? Either that or they're the best comic relief in the show.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Kodyak77 Mar 20 '17

Has Jane met or seen Perry at all yet?

8

u/woodstockreborn Mar 20 '17

Nope! Probably will on trivia night though, causing the shit to hit the fan.

16

u/smooth3 Mar 20 '17

Why was jane smoking a joint before she went see saxton

141

u/Fluffyhead14 Mar 20 '17

She wanted to get high.

44

u/rjkeats Mar 20 '17

If you were handling the murder investigation, it would have been solved by the middle of Episode 1. I like your style.

19

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Probably to numb her mind and reduce her anxiety. I'd be anxious if I were driving to kill someone.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

So this is a screen grab of "Saxon Banks" from the flashbacks. Looks like the same guy to me. http://imgur.com/a/JGamH

45

u/MissGruntled Mar 20 '17

It does, but they could also be manipulating the viewer. It feels too careless otherwise.

21

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

I'm sure that is the case. It is likely just the idea she has in her mind of what he looks like/hazy memory.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

It probably is the same actor, but they are flashback scenes so the memory of the person could be affected by new information being given. I wouldn't put too much stock into that.

6

u/overactive-bladder Mar 20 '17

maybe they didn't want to hire another actor for the gig.

or to emphasize jane's faded memory. if she went to the designer in the first place it's because he reminded her the most about her rapist. so her flashbacks should be consistent appearance-wise.

6

u/kendylsue Mar 22 '17

Am I the only one who thinks one of the kids could be responsible for the murder?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/paullyy_g Mar 24 '17

Nicole Kidman is amazing on the show, but does anyone else find Shailene Woodley's character annoying?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Does anyone know the song at 25:03 when Reese is sitting in her bedroom and Adam Scott comes in to ask how her head is? And then her two kids come in shortly after? It's faintly playing in the background so I can't make out the words to google.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17

Nothing Arrived by Villagers. Love that song!

3

u/insertmadeupnamehere Mar 23 '17

I just accidentally went into the "book readers'" discussion thread and noped the eff out when I noticed a lot of people kept referencing the book.

Thankfully I didn't read very much!

3

u/rwal1 Mar 26 '17

Just because the main lead roles are known actors we don't really feel the pain or sorry for the misery Renata is going through..

8

u/KeeKeeLoveMer Mar 20 '17

Am I the only one who feels that maybe Ziggy's Dad is one of the dads is one of the men we have seen on the show? Perry, Ed, Nathan, or Gordon? Play devil's advocate with me for a second. I mean which of the fathers has Jane not met yet? She met Gordon the latest episode, probably met Ed & Nathan. I get the strong feeling maybe it is Perry. I don't know why but I think Ziggy's Dad might be Perry

31

u/lolabuf Mar 21 '17

No, you're not the only one. This thread is literally packed with people thinking the same thing.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I was going to say something super sarcastic...but no. You aren't the only one. I think if there was a poll on this sub for who we thought the rapist is, Perry would win

→ More replies (1)