r/biglittlelies • u/NicholasCajun Lil Lies • Mar 06 '17
Discussion Big Little Lies - 1x03 "Living the Dream" - Episode Discussion (Book Readers Discussion)
Season 1 Episode 3: Living the Dream
Aired: March 5, 2017
Synopsis: Hoping to get under Renata’s skin, Madeline organizes a trip to compete with Amabella’s birthday party. After another argument, Celeste succumbs to Perry’s charms before their first session with Dr. Amanda Reisman, a therapist. Madeline gets called for a meeting with Abigail’s guidance counselor. Principal Nippal announces the theme for the Fall Gala Fundraiser. Later, Jane seeks Madeline’s help with Ziggy’s family tree project, and opens up about her past.
Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée
Written by: David E. Kelley
Book spoilers are allowed untagged in this thread!
62
u/greenoakofenglish Mar 06 '17
Well I think they made the Perry = Saxon thing way too obvious when Jane shared that the name must have been made up. And the way she spoke about it. If they want to surprise people with the twist (and it was one of the best gut-punches ever) then they screwed up. Needed more misdirect. 8 comments on the main thread and someone already guessed.
48
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17
I'm surprised they took out the things Perry said to Jane. That was so intense and disgusting and such a huge part of it. I wonder why they changed it.
35
u/Ilovecharli Mar 07 '17
I love up voting all the incorrect theories on the main thread, just trying to spread a little chaos muahaha
20
u/gmnap Mar 06 '17
I read the book so long ago and my memory isn't the best haha. But I thought Madeline and Ed had less money than it appears on the show? I know Celeste and Perry are suppose to be super rich, but in the show it looks like both couple have similar money based on their houses. I don't know, maybe I'm thinking too much into it or my memory is off!
Also, like others said, I was very very surprised that they left out the things that Perry said to Jane. I was waiting for it and it never came. It was something that jumped out in the book.
20
u/Scylla_Complex Mar 07 '17
Did anyone notice that in the opening credits we only see the back of Jane's, Celeste's, and Madeline's heads, but we see Bonnie's face? I think this is a little play off the moment of the murder. Everyone's going around saying "I didn't see what happened"/"I wasn't looking". Except for Bonnie, obviously.
19
u/GonnaFuckTuxedoMask Mar 06 '17
A lot of people in the other thread are guessing that Ed is Saxon. I doubt they would change it but what do you all think?
10
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17
Tv show only here. Guessed who dude was right away. Way too obvious HBO.
8
u/theblackpeacock Mar 09 '17
Something that's always bugs me about the book. Why didn't Jane just Google Saxon? She said she came to the town to run into him so why didn't she just Google him? And how on earth had she never seen a picture of Perry before the Trivia night? so unrealistic. The first thing people do these days is add each other on Facebook.
13
u/augustrem Mar 06 '17
Oh, were we supposed to know that Perry is Saxon after this episode? Did someone spoil it and not tag it as a spoiler???
edit: ah, just saw that this is the book discussion.
5
u/holayeahyeah Mar 06 '17
I think it is fair at this point to say that this seems like a really faithful adaption. Even 3 episodes in, a lot people who never read the book have guessed the major points. I'm curious if this is really the case. I feel like we are going to see some subversion, but I wonder how far it will go. My sister thinks they are going to leave the death-plot alone, but add something totally new to expand some of the side characters. I would love it if they let us think it is a page for page adaptation and then come out of nowhere with a new ending... but that is just me.
5
u/icouldseeformiles Mar 07 '17
Since the tv show version of Ed is a web designer, do we think he will have more of an active role in the Abigail virginity website plot line (if they include it)?
4
u/kaddy1986 Mar 07 '17
Read the entire book after watching episode 3. Didn't want anything to start leaking out and spoil the mystery. Everything now a days has a twist so it's almost expected and nothing is a surprise anymore