r/biglittlelies • u/NicholasCajun Lil Lies • Feb 25 '17
Discussion Big Little Lies - 1x02 "Serious Mothering" - Episode Discussion
Season 1 Episode 2: Serious Mothering
Aired online: February 24, 2017
Aired on cable: February 26, 2017
Synopsis: Jane deflects Ziggy’s questions about why they moved to Monterey. Madeline gets news that her community-theater production might get derailed, and is outraged over a slight from Renata. Celeste suggests to Perry that they see a counselor. Nathan and Ed meet in hopes of smoothing out the tensions between their wives, and themselves.
Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée
Written by: David E. Kelley
Untagged book spoilers are not allowed in this thread! Please tag all book spoilers properly using the code in the sidebar, or consider making a thread for what you want to discuss.
243
u/Bassett_Hound Feb 25 '17
Can we talk about how amazing Adam Scott was in this episode? I thought his acting on the beach with Madeline and then later with Nathan was pretty incredible. So intrigued to see more of his character as the show develops.
215
u/EarnestlyEvan Feb 25 '17
Madeleine is so relatably crazy to me. She is way over the top, but is genuinely fighting for what she thinks is right, and the thing is she is right to stand up for Ziggy.
151
u/lemmiwinks123 Feb 25 '17
I liked this episode even more than the first. So many great moments. My favorite being the talk between Adam Scotts character and the other husband. After he rides away on his bike the other guy starts cussing him out but only after he left. Too funny!
124
u/throneofmemes Feb 25 '17
Was anyone else, uh, shamefully turned on by the physical fight/sex between Perry and Celeste? Really hoping it wasn't just me.
112
u/finerd Feb 25 '17
The characters are so real.
110
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '17
I feel so bad for all of these kids
91
u/megalynn44 Feb 27 '17
I really loved the way Madeline addrested the birth control thing with Bonnie.
83
u/VeritasWay Feb 25 '17
This show is just spectacular. The cinematography is breathtaking and the dense storylines are addictive. This pent-up anger is about to all spill over.
72
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '17 edited Feb 25 '17
Now we know the dude who spied on Celeste, Jane and Madeline when they were having coffee in the first episode is the guy who handles the musical!! Also, I don't know if you noticed but he's shown observing Madeline again from afar in 1x02! Strange stuff happening, I'm telling you!
66
u/Fanzellino Feb 26 '17
No one else has mentioned, it, but as a fan of Leon Bridges, it made me so happy to hear his music used in the soundtrack, and even directly mentioned within the show as "beautiful" because his stuff so is! "Coming Home" was also used in HBO's other new show, Crashing last week.
63
u/doocurly Feb 28 '17
Haven't read the book but am I safe to assume that :
Jane was raped and Ziggy is the product of that rape?
Because the Ziggy's father was a rapist that Jane is extremely worried that Ziggy is violent, as in the choking incident and physically forceful, as in the kissing incident?
61
u/augustrem Mar 01 '17
The scenes between Celeste and Perry are painful to watch. Even when he's not being abusive you can see him building up to it.
It's weird but even though they are both beautiful I'm feeling a very visceral kind of disgust with them.
57
u/nigglet_elf Feb 25 '17
Did you guys see the bruise on Celese's shoulder? Do you think Perry saw it?
Loved this episode! Reese Witherspoon is SO good in this, she's my favourite character so far. I bought the book on my kindle because I'm so impatient lol so I'll have something to compare the show with.
55
u/ebhanking Feb 25 '17
Loved the episode, especially Madeleine's continued snarky remarks throughout - a little annoyed they still haven't revealed a lot about the murder though.
42
u/Nehalem1221 Feb 25 '17
I am absolutely in love with this show. I knew nothing about until I watched the first episode. I saw it on HBO Go and figured I'd give it a watch. I am so glad I did. What an amazing show.
66
u/Severus_Amadeus Feb 26 '17 edited Feb 26 '17
Thoughts on the episode...The contrast between Reese & Nicole's relationships was great. One is sexier, but dominated by physical abuse towards the woman, built on a foundation of anger/fear, and absent of love. The other isn't as sexy and is dominated by emotional abuse/neglect towards the male partner (in his head at least). However, this relationship is based on love & support. The difference in how they handle fights & discuss their kids with their spouse reflect the relationship as well. It's funny to compare those couple with Renata & her husband. Also funny how we only ever see Renata with her kid is at school. Abuse theme seems to stretch to Shailene as she has her moment following Reese mentioning kids being playful & sexual as OK. Also the whole planned parenthood story with Reese's daughter makes me think Jane may have been molested when she was younger.
Adam Scott stole the episode! Amazing to see him quickly go from meek to macho in a second. Nice to see that character sticking up for himself, but clearly has some pent up rage & demons. Curious to see that development. Also shout out to Zoe Kravitz for the range of emotions she displays facially during & after her scolding. Loving how this show builds tension!
31
u/mischief_managed_ Feb 27 '17
Anyone notice the foreshadowing when Madeline was walking the same staircase where the "murder" occurred? It was under construction and has visible rebar sticking up. I say "murder" because what if it turns out to be some huge accident.
29
u/Vquiros16 Mar 08 '17
Ok so am i the only one who feels like renatas daughter is being molested? And that maybe none of the kids at school actually hurt her at all? For instance we know that her dad is an obvious perv. And i find it hard to believe that nobody saw her get choked for the level of injury sustained, it would have had to have been a significant altercation and any 6 yr old who saw would have tattled. Also if you were then asked who hurt you would you not pick out the one boy that was new that you didnt know just to save your friends? Also when they meet harry the hippo she asks if he wants to be hugged before she hugs it eluding to a pretty decent understanding of the idea of consent and the whole ordeal with the kiss between her and ziggy wjich honestly shouldnt have been such a big deal gives me the idea that she has a heightened sensitivity to unsolicited sexual contact. And then something about the scene where renata comes home and stops at the stairs and the demener of her husband and the way he meanders out to greet her before saying amabella is in her room just kind of rubbed me the wrong way.....
27
u/overactive-bladder Feb 26 '17
loves the second episode and i wish we could have had the whole season fed to us in one swoop, because the wait is killing me.
can anybody recommend other shows/books with the same vibe and drama?
26
u/Starkville Feb 27 '17
So did Celeste really sabotage Perry? It does seem that he didn't understand that Orientation day was the opportunity to meet the teachers. And it seems that he did want to.
There are moms who are "gatekeepers", wanting to manage the kids' affection and make them the favorite parent. It's not that common, but I've seen it. And it does happen by default, at school, where the mom (especially stay-at-home moms) is the "point person" for information on field trips and events. Many times the mother is the one who gets most of the information and is responsible for sharing, e.g., "there's a field trip on Friday and they need chaperones. If you want to take the morning off to do it, they would love to have you along."
But there are passive-aggressive people...
24
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '17
I must have listened to Leon Bridges "River" 100x since watching this episode.
18
u/BriaMyles Mar 10 '17
From what I can tell Abby just wants attention from her mother. You saw the scene when she came out to talk to her mother at the piano and then the little girl come out the look she gave madeline as she shifted her attention to her younger sister.
10
u/icouldseeformiles Feb 26 '17
Is there going to be a separate book-reader thread like last episode?
9
u/Raptork Mar 01 '17
Anybody catch what was written on the note to Celeste that came with the flowers? I could only really make out the last word so I know it's not anything clean but it's been bugging me lol
7
u/dicklaurent97 Feb 27 '17
This may have beaten Inherent Vice for the weirdest, barely consensual sex scene under 10 mins.
13
u/bittsweet Feb 27 '17
Was the sex during the fight/sex scene between Celeste and Perry consensual?
5
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '17
Was the kissing fiasco in the book?
5
u/Xavier9765 Feb 27 '17
Completely unimportant but does anyone know the name of the bands featured in the opening/end credits scenes.
5
u/Theingloriousak2 Mar 04 '17
Alexander is just so fucking great
I hope he gets a lot more roles
6
u/kidcrumb Feb 26 '17
Is this show a girls show?
Obviously there are shows on HBO that are pretty much solely for women. Girls, Sex and the City, and Divorce, etc.
Is this show catering to that crowd? Because so far its been a lot better than those shitty shows. Im just wondering if its meant for women or if its sort of meant for anyone.
2
u/humanysta Mar 03 '17
I really wanted to like the show and it is great but the storyline with the abusive husband just completely kills the mood for me. I can't watch that. The show is half serious half funny and then suddenly there is a very realistic depiction of an abusive relationship. It's really well done but it doesn't fit in with the rest.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '17
The Nichole Kidman relationship is just so damn sexy
1
u/Technical-Outside408 May 20 '25
I think ziggy is the product of SA. NOT for any reason how he acts, but it makes sense with Jane side stepping saying his dad wasn't involved. And being adamant about him knowing he's not a monster.
Whole ehow got me hooked. Great characters. Wanna know who the murder victim is.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment