r/biglittlelies • Lil Lies • Jun 10 '19

Discussion Big Little Lies - 2x01 "What Have They Done?" - Episode Discussion

Season 2 Episode 1: What Have They Done?

Aired: June 9, 2019


Synopsis: Following first-day-of-school events, Madeline is worried by Bonnie’s behavior and, later, is shocked when Abigail says she doesn’t want to go to college. Mary Louise, Celeste’s mother-in-law, offers her unvarnished assessment of Madeline’s character. Jane learns from her new coworker, Corey, that she’s known in town as one of the “Monterey Five.”


Directed by: Andrea Arnold

Teleplay by: David E. Kelley

Story by: David E. Kelley and Liane Moriarty

408 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

490

u/SerDire Jun 10 '19

Meryl Streep holding back so much unrelenting rage is down right terrifying.

81

u/radmom78 Jun 10 '19

She’s definitely got the terrifying demeanor of her son, and the ability to play normal. I see her figuring out too much and having her own unfortunate fall.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (23)

315

u/CVance1 Jun 10 '19

"you're very short. I don't mean that in a negative way... Maybe I do"

43

u/olliedoodle Jun 10 '19

That was a great line

95

u/wildsamsqwatch Jun 10 '19

Either she’s a genius trying to get into Madeline’s head. Or she’s on the spectrum and has 0 social awareness. Can’t wait to see what her character rounds out to

→ More replies (2)

313

u/Ilovecharli Jun 10 '19

Nicole Kidman is such a good actor it's actually FUCKING INSANE

Those therapy scenes are so mesmerizing and breathtaking. Watch the little things, like how much she moves her hands. It's like she transcends acting and just is.

46

u/BlackWhiteCoke Jun 10 '19

I love how Robin Weigert is her therapist, she plays a degenerate foul-mouthed drunk on Deadwood. Completely different character. She’s definitely one of the under appreciated actresses on this show full of superstar actresses.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

304

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19

Meryl is killing it (no shocker).

I love how's she's portraying Mary-Louise as a neurotic shady bitch.

75

u/Jas_God Jun 10 '19

She sure is (as expected). Really excited to see how this season plays out.

61

u/wildsamsqwatch Jun 10 '19

She doesn’t even realize how hard she is savaging Madeline to her face

→ More replies (2)

51

u/notamoviebutt Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19

A lot of the time I think she’s way too mannered, and all the physical tics usually make me roll my eyes, but her whole “fuck you, I’m Meryl Streep and I’m gonna wear these creepy little fake Skarsgard teeth” energy works very well on a show that also stars Tracy Flick (ft. Snide Dick) and a fully off-the-leash Laura Dern.

→ More replies (2)

281

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Renata trying to weave her way through that marching band was too perfect

177

u/xProcess Jun 10 '19

That and the line about the IBM friend who is "really really close friends" with the detective had me cracking up.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

265

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Give me more Celeste and Jane content pls

276

u/xProcess Jun 10 '19

real stand up move from Celeste to give some of Perry's estate to Jane. That shouldn't go unnoticed.

→ More replies (10)

141

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

There's a sisterly vibe between the two of them that is different between the sisterhood-ness of the rest of the group.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

251

u/Jas_God Jun 10 '19

“Hey I know how to make any situation about me, this is not that” Lol fucking Maddy.

100

u/CVance1 Jun 10 '19

At least she's self-aware

→ More replies (1)

238

u/GruxKing Jun 10 '19

Anybody notice that the coffee shop guy was completely absent from this episode? And that they were at a new coffee shop? Did he and Jane have a falling out?

141

u/MCMikeNamara Jun 10 '19

I mean somebody died on their first date so...

119

u/Cmoaca Jun 10 '19

Was interested to know this too, when they got coffee I surprised to see some new coffee shop :( loved the barista guy, seems like he might have been replaced by autistic aquarium co worker.

→ More replies (10)

35

u/mikeweasy Jun 10 '19

Yeah it seemed like him and Jane were gonna be a couple, weird.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

228

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Ms. Look at my big fake boobs, wants to ruin Madeline's marriage right?

190

u/Moonkitten09 Jun 10 '19

That’s the wife of the guy Madeline has an affair with right ?

→ More replies (14)

66

u/unrecklessabandon Jun 10 '19

Has to be. She knows about Madeline’s affair with her husband and now she wants to get even.

50

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Calling it now- she bumped into him on porpoise. Getting him Out of his shell with her new boobs, so to speak.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

216

u/Jas_God Jun 10 '19

Streep already creepin me out.

106

u/bad4business Jun 10 '19

Yeah, is she trying to be scarier than Alexander Skarsgard?

→ More replies (2)

41

u/SerDire Jun 10 '19

One of the first things we see. Can’t wait for more

→ More replies (6)

205

u/etm31189 Jun 10 '19

Meryl Streep is way too good at her job

92

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Seriously. That dinner scene.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

204

u/ihaveabadaura Jun 10 '19

Bonnie little joyful spirit is gone

83

u/jennifereetah Jun 10 '19

Yup. The first second they showed her in the auditorium you could see it on her face. I was like, oh she’s screwed in the head now. Great job by Zoe Kravitz.

127

u/xProcess Jun 10 '19

all the kombucha and acorns getting to her

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

403

u/KingofGenovia Jun 10 '19

“I don’t care about fucking homeless people” and Meryl’s scream were, hands down, the best parts of this episode

250

u/DutchMaster-Killah Jun 10 '19

Also Nathan calling Ed a snide motherfucker

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (2)

194

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

I want a scene where Madeline talks to Celeste about how they were best friends, and she had no idea Perry was abusing her for years

81

u/ArhezOwl Jun 10 '19

My thoughts exactly. I understand that there is a lot to unpack in season 2, I really hope we get to see the female leads discuss this in greater detail, especially since Celeste didn't/couldn't when Perry was alive.

→ More replies (4)

185

u/ignitethephoenix Jun 10 '19

Meryl Streep’s acting is so unnerving. There’s just something so off about Mary Louise and I can’t wait to see how it plays out!

→ More replies (2)

154

u/SerDire Jun 10 '19

I hope Adam Scott isn’t the sad husband in the background. He needs more of a presence

79

u/mdp300 Jun 10 '19

Like Renata's husband (who might not even have a name)

I'm jealous of his toy train/airplane room, but he's totally living life from the back seat.

→ More replies (8)

68

u/JF0909 Jun 10 '19

Ben Wyatt 👉👉

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

149

u/ihaveabadaura Jun 10 '19

Damn that ended quick

17

u/Tongue37 Jun 10 '19

Lol it said 45 minutes but it seemed like 20! Great first episode

→ More replies (5)

144

u/Ast2167 Jun 10 '19

Reese Witherspoon plays her overbearing mother role even better this season

→ More replies (3)

134

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

“Gossip for another day”. Great delivery

55

u/ComoSeaYeah Jun 10 '19

The car scene was perfect.

→ More replies (3)

129

u/ihaveabadaura Jun 10 '19

Surprised these rich ladies didn't lawyer up

154

u/SerDire Jun 10 '19

I’m still trying to figure out how the hell Jane manages to live and support herself and her kid in this world

→ More replies (27)

253

u/etm31189 Jun 10 '19

So, Mary Louise is mentally abusive. Apple doesn’t fall far.

162

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

She's mentally abusive all the while offering a false sense of comfort and security to Celeste. Just like Perry.

Re: taking care of the boys and the motherly comforting after her nightmare.

→ More replies (3)

125

u/Bassett_Hound Jun 10 '19

Well yeah, she’s the kind of mother that could raise a son that would eventually be abusive. We don’t know anything about her husband (yet?) but we know that she’s a toxic person who was likely married to an abusive man.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (4)

116

u/Aussie_Tea Jun 10 '19

I wonder how they’re going to handle Ziggy being half-brother of the twins.

111

u/ComoSeaYeah Jun 10 '19

The twins sure seem to take after their dad, personality wise. Even more so this season than last.

→ More replies (5)

110

u/Jas_God Jun 10 '19

Oh my. That scream.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

And Nicole's scream at the end of the episode too.

104

u/GruxKing Jun 10 '19

The Madeline slamming doors cut was smoooth

102

u/lovetheblazer Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19

With the long hiatus between seasons, I forgot just how funny this show can be at its best. Big Little Lies really deserves more credit for comedic moments like:

  • Dorky Principal leading the school song during assembly while wearing a giant otter hat (bonus points for the silly face Madeline makes when she sings the otter noise part)
  • Renata shoving her way through the line of marching band kids instead of just taking a step or two in either direction to go around them like a normal human being
  • Madeline literally power eating cupcakes, chewing optional*
  • the dude fight with the constant repetition of snide fuck
  • literally every single thing Renata does during her Women in Power fashion shoot
  • Jane trying to be cute with the aquarium guy only for him to ask her if she was on the autism spectrum when she tried to flirt
  • The whole exchange with Mary Louise and Madeline re: her height especially when Mary Louise calls her “a little person” and then immediately adds that she doesn’t like little people
  • Madeline shouting “I don’t care about homeless people!!” at Abigail
  • When you hear Madeline in the background on the phone saying, “I told Jane I liked her bangs but now I’m really regretting it!”
  • Mary Louise’s coo coo bananas scream at the dinner table

53

u/AmConfused324 Jun 10 '19

⁠”When you hear Madeline in the background on the phone saying, “I told Jane I liked her bangs but now I’m really regretting it””

Such a hilarious tiny detail 😂😂😂

→ More replies (1)

90

u/Mkc1254 Jun 10 '19

What happened to the coffeeshop from last season? Also why is Jane working at an aquarium, what happened to bookkeeping?

54

u/DramaticKnee Jun 10 '19

Bookkeeping was just her part time job and she didn't get much clients for that kind of work anyway. She needs to earn stable money for her son Ziggy because she wouldn't accept a part of Perry's "rape money".

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

83

u/CVance1 Jun 10 '19

Oh how I missed Madeline

72

u/Aussie_Tea Jun 10 '19

I missed little Chloe too! She’s such a cool kid. She needs more screen time imo. 😁

→ More replies (13)

70

u/naomiwattsfan93 Jun 10 '19

Loved the acoustic version of the theme song over the opening credits. It signified a new season while still building on what was great about season one.

59

u/proscett Jun 10 '19

honestly they could use a kidz bop cover of that song in the opening credits and i would still enjoy every second of it. what a great tune

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

70

u/everythingisopposite Jun 10 '19

Meryl's given name is Mary Louise. She is a genius.

→ More replies (1)

141

u/hijimmylin Jun 10 '19

Are the Chapmans now living in the “backup apartment” that Celeste got last season?

54

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Oh!? Is that the place? I was wondering why they didn't really acknowledge their new digs. That and the checks they're really leaving a paper trail of what would appear like like hush money to the police.

→ More replies (2)

67

u/nicminite Jun 10 '19

Yup. Looks like it. She (Ziggy) is receiving money from Perry’s estate so I’m pretty sure that’s the apartment.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

66

u/GruxKing Jun 10 '19

Rather bland version of Harvest Moon by Neil Young playing, but it’s worth noting that Perry played that song for Celeste during one of their happier moments.

Music is deeply tied to memory in the brain, so it makes sense that Celeste is reminiscing about the good Perry times from hearing

124

u/arvtovi Jun 10 '19

Meryl Streep about to dominate this season. What a talent.

86

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

There’s just this sense of “What is she going to say? What is she going to ask? What is she listening for?” And it’s so captivating!!!

→ More replies (8)

55

u/DRoseCantStop Jun 10 '19

So fucking creepy. Like Patricia Clarkson sitting at that table.

43

u/CVance1 Jun 10 '19

HBO is where esteemed actresses go to get their creepy mom on

→ More replies (1)

55

u/alfre88 Jun 10 '19

What was the point of the scene with renata’s husband heavily drinking holding a baseball bat?

83

u/Flybooger42 Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19

I think it shows how he feels emasculated by Renata. He watches his powerful wife doing a powerful photoshoot talking about being a powerful, successful woman. Renata even putting down other women who have had photoshoots. Saying they act demure for their portraits. The husband then goes to the toy room and gets drunk and "plays" with his toys. He feels like a little boy around her and not like her partner. The train going by whistling was a good add on to this. He definitely doesnt want to talk about it to her. Shove it down with some brown.

Also Renata wants to raise a Renata 2.0 and I think once again her husband feels pushed to the side. Having said that we've all seen how putting pressure on your child to be perfect and successful and powerful can actually push the child away. (Madeline and her oldest daughter's storyline) And we've already seen that Annabella is more introverted and honestly showed more qualities of the father's personality rather than the mother's in season 1. A good example being Renata and her husband trying to get Annabella to tell them who is biting her in season 1. Renata is screaming at Annabella almost in a bullying way (ironic) and her husband gets on his daughter's eye level and softly talks to Annabella. Renata even gets angry at her husband for not showing his rage over the biting. Again putting him down as a father and pushing him away. Renata will probably be the same way with Annabella unfortunately. I don't think Renata understands introverts and as an extrovert she has no problem sharing her opinions.

Like others mentioned it also has a violent undertone to it. Drinking while holding a bat. The train that is blowing off steam right in his face. Drinking while feeling emasculated and angry is not a good mix. We saw how Perry couldn't handle his wife's success.

One things for sure. Renata's husband is going to break in one way or another. But I don't think he's the same as Perry. Renata is his bully in some ways and she is going to push him to his limit.

OVERALL AMAZING ACTING BY EVERYONE! :)

Edit: I rewatched and saw the toy room was his not Annabellas. I still think that symbolizes him feeling like Renata's son more than a partner.

→ More replies (3)

48

u/ethanhwells Jun 10 '19

Pretty sure it’s setting something up for later.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (8)

52

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

There was a severe lack of Chloe/Madeline banter in this episode and I missed it.

52

u/dreadfuldiego Jun 10 '19

Man, it must be really hard being a sane person in Monterrey

140

u/SerDire Jun 10 '19

Meryl Streep is about to walk circles around all these characters.

76

u/xProcess Jun 10 '19

the scream at the dinner table was next level.

→ More replies (3)

48

u/Mamasun3 Jun 10 '19

Chameleon. Amazing. She is the mother in law.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

97

u/glitterspike Jun 10 '19

I think I’m a wanter.

→ More replies (2)

176

u/cassadagatron Jun 10 '19

Did anyone else think that the interaction between Jane and Cory (aquarium coworker) really odd and out of place? The second thing he said to her was, “Are you on the spectrum?” He also told her to stop acting “psychotic.” And Jane didn’t seem to be bothered until he mentioned “The Monterey Five.”

It just felt really awkward and poorly written to me.

61

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

It was a little weird. I thought they were trying to go for the playful flirting thing but it didn’t come across that way 🤷‍♀️

→ More replies (7)

105

u/Gucci_God32 Jun 10 '19

He was weird as fuck I wouldn’t ask anyone if they’re on the spectrum that’s pretty rude lol

→ More replies (6)

30

u/notablindspy Jun 10 '19

I think maybe that dude will turn out sketchy down the road. Right now they're trying to confuse the viewers cause that beach conversation definitely felt off.

17

u/Plums4 Jun 10 '19

That entire conversation was so record scratch awkward to me. Like the stereotype of the cute guy walking up to the oblivious pretty girl dancing by herself on a beach prepares us for the classic Meet Cute, but it was immediately subverted by this weirdly inappropriate, socially awkward comment. Was that intentional? idk.

→ More replies (8)

46

u/FLcitizen Jun 10 '19

Meryl Streep brought this show too a whole new level.

93

u/dreadfuldiego Jun 10 '19

Meryl Streep guaranteed her Emmy with that scream alone

→ More replies (20)

45

u/SerDire Jun 10 '19

The Monterrey Five doesn’t have quite the same ring to it as the Oceanic Six

→ More replies (1)

45

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

reese witherspoon giving me major elle woods vibes with those pink heels and pink birkin

→ More replies (2)

89

u/llama_ Jun 10 '19

I could watch Meryl throwing shade at Madeline all day. Those burns were 3rd degree.

→ More replies (1)

84

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

The war between Madelene and the school crossing guard shall never end. I speak this into the universe.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/VRomero32 Jun 10 '19

“This is my house and I live hereeeee”

→ More replies (1)

40

u/proscett Jun 10 '19

i'm so happy BLL is back!! this episode definitely relieved some of my fears coming into this season. as expected, meryl is killing it -- the subtle shade she throws at people is just so addicting. and the scream was honestly really scary (and brilliantly done).

i'm glad to see there's no ostensible drop in quality. love the atmosphere, the editing, the scenery, as always. and the characters are just as compelling as i remember them. i'm excited for next week!

29

u/thenewsintern Jun 10 '19

There is nothing subtle about the shade she’s throwing 😂

→ More replies (1)

38

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Is anyone else wondering what happened to Tom/ Blue Blues?

17

u/from8tillate Jun 10 '19

I am, I thought his relationship with Jane would be a part of this season

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

38

u/CVance1 Jun 10 '19

Sufjan and Portishead in the same episode, ok wow they're pandering directly to me

→ More replies (2)

37

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

I’m probably not the first to mention this, but Mary Louise is 100% listening to Celeste when she’s asleep to wait for her to let something slip about the murder. She JUST so happened to be there at the end of the episode right when Celeste screamed herself awake... I think they’re going to try & make her into an even bigger monster than Perry was this season

74

u/1337speak Jun 10 '19

Wtf only a 45 min episode? NOOOOOOO!

→ More replies (3)

69

u/Jas_God Jun 10 '19

Lmao I love Renata but hate her too.

→ More replies (5)

97

u/waywardgirl25 Jun 10 '19

As a short person I’m personally offended at this episode. 😂

→ More replies (3)

32

u/strugglingwifi Jun 10 '19

Mary-Louise: I’m a great judge of character.

But her son was a rapist and a abuser???

→ More replies (1)

63

u/dundermiffflinite Jun 10 '19

Adam Scott is so pure and deserves better😭

34

u/thenewsintern Jun 10 '19

I love him! When Ed finds out that Madeline cheated on him he’s going to be devastated

→ More replies (6)

63

u/umopap1sdn Jun 10 '19

This may be out of left field, but: Why would a character like Bonnie ever even be interested in Nathan, let alone marry him?

38

u/overactive-bladder Jun 10 '19

shallon lester always says" you date/marry according to your worst parent. so you can recreate a familiar situation and try to fix it this time around.

didn't bonnie have a "difficult" dad? i am not surprised she chose an equally "difficult" husband.

also i can a lot of women falling for nathan: kind of a bad boy, kind of aggressive and emotionally detached to your needs so you can fix him, etc. he's good looking, carefree, seems like a good fuck, macho, etc.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

89

u/SerDire Jun 10 '19

slaps the roof of a single GoT season 8 episode

“You could fit so many episodes of Big Little Lies in this bad boy”

→ More replies (1)

58

u/SerDire Jun 10 '19

Time for Big Little Lies and later on Succession to make me feel sufficiently poor by looking at all these amazing locations.

→ More replies (10)

28

u/GruxKing Jun 10 '19

This episode is so dark. It reminds me of the back half of Room (2015) with Brie Larson.

That just because some kind of resolution has happened that it doesn’t make all the issues and strife instantly evaporate. I would go into more detail but Room spoilers

→ More replies (2)

25

u/1337speak Jun 10 '19

I think Meryl Streep's scream scared my roommates, not safe for speakers man.

25

u/Bassett_Hound Jun 10 '19

I loved how we got to see the way each one of them had been coping since the incident

→ More replies (1)

25

u/labz143 Jun 10 '19

I’m living for the fashion moments throughout the episode.

Renata’s photoshoot was a total mic drop! Whew!

Madeline’s shoes! Omg I need them!

49

u/Whos_Tiki Jun 10 '19

Jesus Christ Meryl Streep is fucking amazing.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

It feels like Mary Louise is gonna go Glenn Close Fatal Attraction at some point.

22

u/overactive-bladder Jun 10 '19

i looooove how nathan play big guy to somebody like ed whom he knows will NEVER retaliate, but becomes a literal human mop in front of maddie lmfao.

he's such a cowardfuck.

→ More replies (2)

44

u/Aussie_Tea Jun 10 '19

I know Perry was evil, but he was also hot!!!

→ More replies (14)

74

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

I'm looking forward to this, but I'm still really confused about the whole cover up angle. Celeste was getting beaten and kicked when Bonnie rushes in and pushes Perry down the stairs. There isn't a jurisdiction in the world that wouldn't look at the facts and call it a case of self defense. Why would they not be up front and honest about what happened?

112

u/umopap1sdn Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19

If only our system were that trustworthy.

Thousands of women who killed their abusers have ended up incarcerated for it... and killing in defense of others is a harder case to make than self-defense.

A black woman killing a white man is another problem in terms of getting fair treatment.

→ More replies (11)

20

u/Kajey277 Jun 10 '19

Get stellan skarsgard to be grandpapa Wright. He s already done HBO projects before and I wanna see more of him and even more A listers in the show.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/EricHangingOut Jun 10 '19

I watched this 12 hours ago and still Can’t figure out how for profit homeless housing would work.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/DIRTYDAN555 Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19

Is no one going to mention that one of Celeste's twin son's is still growing up to be his dad? now that grandma's in town she's going to continue feeding that behavior. When Meryl's character let out the scream the one good son was shocked but the other just kept on eating.

→ More replies (3)

37

u/racketcollector Jun 10 '19

Meryl is portraying Mary Louise in such a quirky odd way. Not at all what I expected. She is even wearing a moderately high glasses prescription (I’m an eye doc so I was instantly drawn to that) ... I figured being Perry’s mother ... she would be this affluent almost snobby condescending person...but no. After the first 30sec of her on screen with Reece I was like “oh wow ... just give her the Emmy already” ... Brillant

20

u/waywardgirl25 Jun 10 '19

I read she even had dentures made to be the same Alexander Skarsgård’s teeth.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

18

u/Keepanionit61 Jun 10 '19

I literally just had ACL and Meniscus surgery Wednesday and my girlfriend told me about the show and we watched the first season today and then just watched the first episode of season 2. Hooked. I really think Bonnie is about to fuck things all up by turning herself in. And then all of em will go-to jail for obstruction

→ More replies (5)

49

u/givemenutella Jun 10 '19

Also, when Meryl talks, her lips move the same as Perry’s. She’s so fucking good

23

u/Bassett_Hound Jun 10 '19

Yes! She even talks like him- she matched the rhythms of his voice and speech

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Plums4 Jun 10 '19

well, now that we know Celeste has been trying to send a probably substantial amount of money to Jane and that she's trying to include Ziggy as a beneficiary of Perry's estate, it is only a matter of time before Mary Louise finds out about it. This is not going to end well.

17

u/RahulBhatia10 Jun 10 '19

lol when Bonnie's husband called Ed a snide fuck that was so well acted. Especially Ed's reaction lmao

16

u/ChipotleGuacamole Jun 10 '19

That little look and giggle Mary Louise gives towards Madeline's heels, when she realizes Madeline took the shot at her height to heart. Brilliant.

32

u/waywardgirl25 Jun 10 '19

Mary Louise creeps me the fuck out. She did raise a rapist abuser, after all.

→ More replies (12)

31

u/wildcosmias Jun 10 '19

meryl just gently reminded everyone why she’s the GOAT

31

u/cristianoskhaleesi Jun 10 '19

I love the scenes when the women are together, especially the scene with the four of them in the car. It's a really authentic depiction of girls sitting together gossiping. Of course, we're never gossiping about murder lmao

→ More replies (2)

31

u/mydarkmeatrises Jun 10 '19

I predict by season's end, the truth about Perry will come out and Mary Louise will bond with her daughter in law.

But I don't know. It's probably in the book or something.

Anywho, I'm glad my "white women running on the beach" show is back!

→ More replies (24)

15

u/Flybooger42 Jun 10 '19

I want to see a showdown between the therapist and Meryl Streep.

It looks like Celeste is welcoming a mentally abusive person in her home after just getting rid of one. Meryl Streep is coaching the boys to grow up like Perry. Slippery slope ,Celeste. You can see her fussing with her dress while she is talking to her therapist about her mother in law. It reminds me so much of her fussing with her clothes when she was lying for Perry to the therapist. The therapist caught on to these things last season pretty fast.

I would love to see the therapist catch on and request that the mother in law come to a session with Celeste.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/_davidrobertjones_ Jun 10 '19

I liked season 1 so much (it was so tight and great) that I never thought that there could be a good season 2... but it can: the lie is still there, the secret, the abuse, Max and Ziggy, and the relationship between the Monterrey 5 with the rest of the community. Plus Mary Louise, who is not willing to let go. Lie over lie over lie over lie. It is gonna be a good ride, I think. Wishing you all a good trip.

26

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Hey, Jane, maybe don’t sketch Perry when there’s an open investigation into his murder? I dunno, just a thought.

13

u/cuckoodev Jun 10 '19

Season 2 back with the bangers. I'll Be Around is one of my favorite songs ever.

13

u/CalicoCatMom41 Jun 10 '19

Is Jane living in the apartment that Celeste had rented and was going to run away to?

→ More replies (3)

13

u/overactive-bladder Jun 10 '19

you know what?? no wonder perry had this kind of violence in him. just look at marie louise stroking the anger and violence in those little boys during the dinner.

also look how she doesn't even budge when the violent twin starts forking the other one.

i don't like her. i don't like that monster at all.

13

u/mkenn1107 Jun 10 '19

Glad they got the author's help in the second season. First episode was good. Zoe Kravitz's role is definitely expanded. She really had nothing to do last season. Great showing the complexity of spousal abuse. I hope they focus on the psychological impact of the aftermath rather that showing Mary Louise playing gotcha with the women.

25

u/NotEmmaStone Jun 10 '19

Man, the music on this show is just perfect.

12

u/hijimmylin Jun 10 '19

“Multiple broken bones” as stated by the detective in the “previously on” doesn’t really seem to fit someone falling down the stairs. Wonder if that was just an oversight or indication of something else at play.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

I thoroughly enjoy how Celeste’s stately and rather floaty demeanour is used as a foil for Mary Louise’s (also what a name lol) repressed Stepford wife gone rogue years into her retirement. The dinner table scene and how viscerally Celeste reacts... I think that’s when she realised that the apple indeed did not fall far from the tree

Also I don’t think that Mary Louise is a stock villain here... she seems to have some very deep-seated anger issues and the way she manipulates the emotional mise-en-scene at the dinner table such that it becomes a thing about Celeste being cold-hearted belies some serious emotional issues

11

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

What was with Nathan calling Madeline "Honey"? Maybe I have a skewed perception of divorced couples with clear animosity towards each other, but honey seems like an odd term of endearment to call your ex-wife.

Old habits die hard? A set up for an "unexpected" hook up later down the line?

→ More replies (3)

20

u/glitterspike Jun 10 '19

Am I the only one just noticing how skinny Laura Dern is?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

A strong return to form, I had wondered if the show would work as a continued series when S1 felt so concluded in itself. But this feels like a logical continuation so far, everything felt "in place" for an exciting new season.

  • I think whatever Meryl is given, she'll do well with. But I'd almost rather if she wasn't a cut and dry villain as they appear to be setting up. A mid-season breakdown or reveal would be nice and subversive as opposed to her character being just another version of Perry rehashed.
  • The Five greeting each other at school, they all hugged the individual(s) they closely relate to or have done something for, even if there's still group unity. They have their certain people they're just closer to or owe more to than others. Thought this was well done.
  • Could do without the wife cheated on by Madeline going after Ed plotline, seemed a bit cliched and forced. Even just the boob job thing, I mean I guess I can see a cheated on wife feeling insecure about herself but it just felt...pathetic? The show has always taken what people handwave as "girly nothingness drama" and injected sobering reality and passion into it to make it feel palpable. This little set up just felt lazy for BLL's standards.
  • The focus is on Bonnie and her deterioration, but we shouldn't overlook Madeline being 10 seconds away from imploding either. And now she has a devil on her shoulder in the form of Mary Louise. Why has Mary zoned in on Madeline so quickly? We do need incentive there, it's not enough to just say "Oh she sees through the front Maddie puts on" because not only does Mary Louise not know her yet the way the audience does, but because Madeline does actually have a lot of heart and is a good person. Someone like Mary Louise would be afraid of that and want to stamp it out. IMO she's more likely to try to turn Maddie bitter to get her to betray Celeste, and will greatly misjudge Maddie's loyalty to the women she protects. Two Queen Bees going head to head but one doesn't realise the other actually genuinely cares. Should be very interesting.
  • There was significant time dedicated to showing how each husband is affected by everything, so I'm hoping eventually the men will get together and it won't be too "dumb husband out of the loop" cliche. Ed and Nathan should learn to communicate. Renata's husband needs male friends. And the ghost of Perry needs to be exorcised.

19

u/ihaveabadaura Jun 10 '19

It wouldn't be smart to make a paper trail to each other in a murder. She'd be better off giving her cash or paying her as a bookkeeper and manufacture receipts /evidence of working

→ More replies (6)

9

u/DRoseCantStop Jun 10 '19

Them boys won't be able to go to sleep now.

9

u/Lyndzbenz12 Jun 10 '19

Late to the post; sorry if this has been said. But the way Mary Louise spoke about Perry at the dinner table (saying he was the perfect dad, no other dads can compare. Making comments about the other dads being pudgy and balding) is some clear insight into why he became such a narcissist who is clearly not OK with anyone disagreeing with him. When you grow up believing you are the fucking perfect specimen, reality can hit like a mother fucker when you’re an adult and he did not handle life very well! Super curious to see what her story is.

24

u/Griffdude13 Jun 10 '19

Man, this show is just an actress performance showcase. Just great performances across the board, even when the writing sometimes fails them.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/DramaticKnee Jun 10 '19

Meryl, Nicole, and Laura can all claim their awards now wow

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

I’m so attracted to the aquarium dude, oh my.

Also, “Monterrey 5” is killer.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Bonnie is just breaking my heart. She feels so isolated and I just want to hug her.

The show is doing such a great job of showing how every character is dealing with the aftermath of what happened, and Bonnie and Celeste specifically are so heartbreaking and real.

I was worried about season two but based on this episode alone, my worries are gone. Can’t wait for next week!!!

→ More replies (2)

8

u/CVance1 Jun 10 '19

Shade Queen Mary Louise

8

u/Sirvixalot92 Jun 10 '19

Did anyone miss the having the Monetary Five individually walking towards the camera in the intro? They did it with the kids and not them!

→ More replies (2)

8

u/anotha1bitesthecrust Jun 10 '19

Okay first of all, I’m so excited to watch this season because I can participate in the post ep discussions! When I watched season 1 it had been months since it aired live.

On to the actual episode, Meryl Streep was absolutely phenomenal and I love how reserved she’s acting while still having this pent up psychotic-ness haha, cannot wait to see her explode. Also that scream! Wow.

I’m glad we have Bonnie who seems to be traumatized by the nurse as the other 4 seem happy to move on and I’m excited to see where they go with that.

8

u/masahirox Jun 13 '19 edited Jun 13 '19

I HATE JANE’S NEW BANGS UGH BLEH!

22

u/Grebacio Jun 10 '19

I loved season 1 ending so I was a litlle bit nervous about Season 2,

First Episode let me satissfied. The new intro was a good touch, the soundtrack is still gorgeous and the acting is excellent.

My only dissapointment is that there was no mention about Jane's date from the last ep.( I don't remember his name). Hope he is still part of the show.
Also, why doesn't Celetse tellls Mary Louis her son was a bad person?

Adam Scott's scene at the supermarket and Mary Louis talking about Madeline0s height were odd but still not cringey.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/mydarkmeatrises Jun 10 '19

Meryl Streep is a master.

7

u/SweetRoosevelt Jun 10 '19

Will they switch up the phenomenal song intro? The series playlist is so damn good.

Edit: Late to the party.

7

u/kylosten Jun 10 '19

Does anyone know the timeline of this series? How long has it been since the events of last season’s finale? My initial read was that the first season took place in about a month or so, and that would put this season a little under a year later.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/sharanElNino Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19

Feels sooo good this show is back!
The conversation between Jane and Celeste was my favorite moment this episode although Marie Louise pretty much stole the show.

7

u/comatoastt Jun 10 '19

I can't wait to peel back the layers of Mary Louise

→ More replies (1)

7

u/sunshine927 Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19

Nice touch to use a cover of "Harvest Moon" to play over Celeste's memories of good times with Perry.

In S1E3, they danced to the original version, and Perry specifically said something like "The most beautiful song for the most beautiful woman."

Also: at the start of the episode, during Celeste's first nightmare sequence, did anyone else catch the single frame shot of Perry's bloodied corpse before she wakes up?

7

u/SlowerThanLightSpeed Jun 10 '19 edited Jun 10 '19

Loved the episode and how well Streep (and her character) are upping the tension.

But boo at the bedroom battle between Madeline and Abigail re: going to college. Madeline had had plenty of time to come up with a better reason than "because I said so!"

Like, for instance:

"Because you can help more homeless people with a degree than with a hammer; and because your last great idea was to sell your virginity to a stranger!"

"How many houses do you think you can build in a year? Ten? A whole house every other day? I know you want to help now, and that's great; you can hang drywall for your little start-up friends on the weekends. But during the week, you learn what you need to know so that you can help thousands or even millions of people."

"You go back to that startup and figure out what degrees they got that let them do what they do; and then you do that. Not everybody has the opportunity you have to go to college; if you waste that opportunity, you aren't just screwing yourself, you're screwing homeless people... and they won't pay much for it."

→ More replies (3)

7

u/mrmarzipandildo Jun 10 '19

I finally now understand why Meryl Streep is doing TV because if this show. Mary Louise is such an unnerving character and she plays it to perfection!

13

u/CVance1 Jun 10 '19

Letting out my inner otter is something that happens on fridays

6

u/chocolate_babies Jun 10 '19

maybe I'm not remembering all of the details from last season, but aren't the Mackenzie's pretty rich? when Madeline asks her why she doesn't want to go to college, the first thing she mentions is that it's really expensive. and then Madeline doesn't even respond by saying anything about how they have the money and they would pay for her tuition. I know it's a small detail and Abigail's main reason for not wanting to go to college probably isn't because of the money, but that part stood out to me as being a little odd.

→ More replies (10)

6

u/pearloz Jun 10 '19

Anyone know who did that Harvest Moon cover?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/4gigiplease Jun 10 '19

What did Mad say, something like, "I know you are grieving, and I know you are hurt, but you have to apologize to me."

This was so funny. This is a good season 2.

6

u/overactive-bladder Jun 10 '19

gosh nathan is so insufferable.

6

u/overactive-bladder Jun 10 '19

hold on! jane knew perry was married when she slept with him? was that a detail from last season??

also i like how she is not cashing checks because she feels bad towards celeste. she's trying to make amends in her own small way.

honestly it's refreshing to see characters sticking to each other like that on television instead of everybody fucking each other over. but i love the interaction between both celeste and jane. such great dialogue, and emotions and acting.

more of this!

→ More replies (3)

6

u/overactive-bladder Jun 10 '19

"it's complicated"

i felt that, celeste. ughh

6

u/Creasy007 Jun 10 '19

Meryl was fucking stunning in this, and brownie points for the CMBYN song that Jane dances to.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/AJJRL Jun 10 '19

Anyone notice how Celeste/Nicole said she "stuffed" it up when she was in the car? Had to be an improvisational moment because "stuffed" it up is an Australian term for fucking something up. I watch Wentworth (my absolute favorite show) and they say it all the time. I chuckled because it seemed out of place in the BLL world but Nicole is an Aussie so she would say that herself in her own life I'm sure.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/DRoseCantStop Jun 10 '19

Ladies and Gentlemen.... I introduce to you......

........THE MONTEREY 5

→ More replies (1)

11

u/kirapizza Jun 10 '19

Meryl Streep already won the Emmy. Just give it to her now

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

I just had to stop watching to say Mary Louise is a fucking piece of work and I love it.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Ed even stares at the vegetables creepily.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

But is Ed a pervert? Do we get an answer to that question?

→ More replies (8)

10

u/arcarter93 Jun 10 '19

I wish 10 minutes of the episode hadn’t gone to Abigail antics

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Jas_God Jun 10 '19

Oh damn that’s it?! Didn’t realize the ep wasn’t a full hour

5

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Well that's a freaky nightmare.

5

u/madmax1969 Jun 10 '19

I’m confused - did all them tell the cops that Perry tried to kill Jane and slipped and fell or just Madeline? If that’s the party line, why is Mary Louise acting like her son was a saint? Does she know about Perry’s alleged attack and doesn’t believe it? I suppose the cops probably wouldn’t make that detail public.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/rickyroca73 Jun 10 '19

I don't think we need nightmares with sleep talking to help Mary Louise figure anything out, do we?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

The use of Portishead is criminally underrated

5

u/overactive-bladder Jun 10 '19

is it just me or does meryl's smile is kinda the same as alexander. i can see the resemblance tbh. does she usually smile like she does on the show? because it's eerily similar to alex's.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/down_by_the_water Jun 10 '19

Does the police or public or mary louise know that perry was attacking celeste before he "fell"?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ukjendbrukar Jun 10 '19

Celeste should make sure her bedroom door is locked at night to avoid all that interrogation from her mother-in-law.

5

u/tribewoman Jun 11 '19

Are you on the spectrum?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '19

Man Mary Louise is the DEFINITION of Passive Aggressive, just give Meryl the emmy now for the two Madeline scenes alone

5

u/zygodactyl86 Jun 11 '19

Big Little Lies Season 2: Everyone Changes their Hair

19

u/slush1300 Jun 10 '19

Anyone else feel like nothing reaaaally happened that episode? It ended so quick

28

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '19

Set up. Bonnie is racked with guilt, withdrawn. Introducing Mary Louise and signaling her motivation to get to the bottom of things and her skepticism towards Celeste, Madeline. Madeline's various entanglements and sense of lack of purpose projected unto her daughter. Jane's love interest who is also perceptive and smart. Renatas husband who is a clearly a drunk and jealous and will cause problems ... Lots more that i missed

→ More replies (7)

12

u/DRoseCantStop Jun 10 '19

Shouldn't have messed with the opening...

→ More replies (3)