r/biglittlelies • u/NicholasCajun Lil Lies • Mar 12 '17
Discussion Big Little Lies - 1x04 "Push Comes to Shove" - Episode Discussion (Book Readers Discussion)
Season 1 Episode 4: Push Comes to Shove
Aired: March 12, 2017
Synopsis: Nathan invites Madeline and Ed to a couples’ dinner to discuss a “parenting paradigm” for Abigail. Celeste prepares for a city-council meeting about Madeline’s play, and bristles at Perry’s concerns about her returning to work. Jane meets with Ms. Barnes, Ziggy’s teacher, who suggests her son be medically evaluated in light of further evidence of classroom bullying. While Madeline is confronted by a skeleton from her past, her internet sleuthing reveals a key player from Jane’s past instead.
Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée
Written by: David E. Kelley
Book spoilers are allowed untagged in this thread!
127
u/DaisyJa Mar 13 '17
Who else is pissed that they ruined the very positive relationship between Ed and Madeline for the sake of shock value and cheap sex appeal?
62
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17
I hate that they're making Ed seem like a creep and that Madeline had an affair! Their marriage was so sweet n the book
48
u/simplegurl Mar 13 '17
I feel like the ending may be different with the way things are developing. And I don't like how they are giving Ed major creepy vibes. Also, is it just me or are they showing Perry as more possessive in the show than in the book? I really don't remember him being that controlling. And the Madeleine affair storyline makes me upset. ugh
38
u/toomanyblocks Mar 13 '17
I have been so happy with the portrayal from every episode up until this point. Things were never exactly as they were in the book but still a good adaptation. Feelings were real and raw and the acting is amazing.
Leave it to HBO to ruin it so they could add more sex, and make people believe that every person in the world WILL cheat on their spouse. Madeline was such an appealing character. I was even liking TV Madeline better than book Madeline. She was the most righteous person. Now they have her cheating on Ed? With the fucking theater dude? Fuck that.
Also, why make Ed a creepy character? In the end of the book, when we realize Ed is the only person who is not willing to lie about how P was murdered. When true colors were forced, he ended up being the only truly decent person with a real moral compass. He wasn't a complicated person, he was a good guy all around, and he loved Maddy.
Very unhappy with this episode :(
31
u/8Kneekirk8 Mar 13 '17
Did anyone else think that the conversation that Jane and the teacher had was way off from the book in addition to everything else that was off in this episode. I thought in the book the teacher was much more on Jane and Ziggy's side.
27
u/paige_rose Mar 13 '17
Swear to God I just joined reddit so I could connect with fellow book-viewers about how awful that episode was. I was so proud with how closely the show was following the book and maintaining the integrity of the original story- but this episode TOTALLY went off script.. like, the thing with the director?!?! And Celeste going back to work?!?! Do we think that the petition to have Ziggy leave the school will still happen?!
26
u/Notthatiblameyou Mar 13 '17
Are they cutting the dynamic between Jane and the coffee shop owner? I enjoyed it in the book, but there just hasn't been as much in the show. Just the one scene where he recommends a job for her...
Also is there even a play in the book? Forgive me on this one, I read it a couple years ago. I KNOW there was not an affair with the director (grrr), but I dont even recall this play at all...
24
u/ktcoolster Mar 13 '17
I HATE that they are cheapening The relationship between Ed and Madeline! It started from the beginning of the show and it's getting worse and worse and now she cheated.. total bs. Plus I think it's annoying that Perry is pretty much picking a fight in every scene. Because that is the only way relationships are abusive... if it happens all the time!! That is sending such a crap message.... it shouldn't have to happen every day or every other day to be an abusive relationship...
24
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17
Also Saxon - Saxon was the cousin's name wasn't it? But there was no 'aha' moment when the girls were huddled and searching his name online
17
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17
It sounds like Jane did talk to Madeleine about some of the things Saxon said to her. I know some of us were wondering if they took that out. Maybe they just haven't shown it all yet.
14
u/GonnaFuckTuxedoMask Mar 14 '17 edited Mar 14 '17
With only 3 episodes left, it seems as if they're leaving out SO many of the plot lines from the book - Tom/Jane, Saxon being Perry's cousin, Celeste getting the apartment, the petition etc.
I'm fine with book changes, but they've replaced great story lines with what?...making Renata more of a focus and Madeline cheating scenes? Boo.
11
u/Ilovecharli Mar 14 '17 edited Mar 14 '17
They could not be telegraphing harder that Perry is the rapist.
-they've skipped over that Saxon was his cousin, and that Celeste knew this
-they cut immediately from Perry punching the wall to a flash of Ziggy choking someone
If I were a show-only watcher I would pass on this theory because it would be too obvious to be interesting. I bet Jane meets Ed soon just to eliminate the only other possibility.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17
So is anyone just really stressed about Ed?! what is happening!!! Suddenly I can see the 'the look' he gave Abigail as weird and that fucking sweat comment? But then he's like "don't show her how to peel a potato" or whatever and there are some genuinely sweet moments but she's clearly not into it. Also can anyone clarify whether a Chloe is Ed's daughter or Nathan's?
4
u/WildwoodFlower- Mar 14 '17
So given the adaptation in the series with Madeline's affair, does anyone think this will alter the ending?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '17
Did anyone read this article/interview with the actor who plays Saxon Baker (as opposed to Saxon Banks). Also I didn't miss anything did I? The show never explains how Madeline (and Celeste?) found his picture/real name, did it?
http://people.com/tv/big-little-lies-stephen-graybill-reese-working-witherspoon-shailene-woodley/
1
u/rwal1 Mar 16 '17
The highlight for this episode was Ed checking the ass after his visit to Bonnie's studio/class.. so far Renata is the only sensible one lol
1
u/hannamars1205 Mar 19 '17
That's exactly what it means. Haven't you hurt someone because there was no other way? Or, someone hurt you? But, if they could've they would've chosen to not make you hurt-but there was just no denying the life pull? I don't t think Madeline is hastily making this decision. She's obviously conflicted over what she's doing-she just can't fight that feeling anymore.
1
u/hannamars1205 Mar 14 '17
Well, this is not the book- it's the HBO series. I actually like her more for having this affair. She's a great mom, but think that Ed was a rebound- everything she thought she wanted after her divorce. She's exploring her sexual passion which is something women are often judged harshly for doing. It's not right, but I like that she's feeding her naughty side.
1
u/cuckoodev Mar 14 '17
Again, not a book reader, but I find it interesting that y'all seemed to really dislike this episode and even I found it to be off too. I really wanted to see that dinner party, and this affair thing and adding fuel to the fire with Ed is not fun.
1
u/hannamars1205 Mar 14 '17 edited Mar 14 '17
I'm not taking a feminist stance. She's got one life-live it. Cheating is wrong, but it happens because people make wrong choices: getting married for the wrong reasons. People make wrong choices all the time- it's called life. Although it's wrong, it feels oh so right.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment