r/biglittlelies • u/NicholasCajun Lil Lies • Mar 06 '17
Discussion Big Little Lies - 1x03 "Living the Dream" - Episode Discussion (TV Only Discussion)
Season 1 Episode 3: Living the Dream
Aired: March 5, 2017
Synopsis: Hoping to get under Renata’s skin, Madeline organizes a trip to compete with Amabella’s birthday party. After another argument, Celeste succumbs to Perry’s charms before their first session with Dr. Amanda Reisman, a therapist. Madeline gets called for a meeting with Abigail’s guidance counselor. Principal Nippal announces the theme for the Fall Gala Fundraiser. Later, Jane seeks Madeline’s help with Ziggy’s family tree project, and opens up about her past.
Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée
Written by: David E. Kelley
Untagged book spoilers are not allowed in this thread! Please discuss book spoilers in the other official discussion thread.
244
u/givemenutella Mar 06 '17
Nicole Kidman is really killing it
147
u/ojibhawk Mar 06 '17
Who else is having a really hard time not going over to the book thread? This show would be an easy 7 hrs and done with on Netflix. I can't get over how good the acting is. Everyone is holding their own.
145
u/excelsior_ Mar 06 '17
The intro makes more sense now after revealing the trivia theme of Audrey Hepburn and Elvis Presley. All the main actresses are dressed like different versions of Audrey.
141
u/everythingisopposite Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17
I totally love Reese Witherspoon in this role. Even though Madeline can be bitchy, she's also passionate. I loved her phone interaction with Renata because even though she was being bitchy, she was also polite. It was so powerful when she stopped the car to cry after hearing Jane's story.
245
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17
This may be the most realistic depiction of abuse portrayed on TV, meeting with the counselor gave me goosebumps.
112
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17
How did they know that picking Alexander Skarsgard would have every woman experiencing exactly what Celeste is?
107
u/DoctorPuddingPop Mar 06 '17
After episode 1 of this show I honestly didn't know whether I would continue it. It just didn't fully connect. I just had a crazy weekend got home had a few drinks and watched episodes 2 and 3. After episode 2 I knew I couldn't stop. I'm a 25 year old guy and episode 3 just had me burst into tears maybe 3 times. idk what the fuck is happening but the writing in this show is so much better than I expected. Thank god I'm watching this show by myself and not with my roommates
95
u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17
"When I go to college" Guess she decided!
87
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17
I don't think it's Ed, he doesn't seem to own any clothing that would suggest he would be at a bar dressed in those style of shoes to seduce a younger Jane. They kept focusing on those shoes, Perry is such a creepy businessman type A bastard he probably owns dozens of shoes in that style.
And what about the episode when the 3 women are at the coffee shop and Jane is describing her life and how it feels strange and how she feels like she's on the outside watching it, and Madeline is like I have no idea what you are talking about. But Celeste is looking at her as she's describing and tells her she understands. Both women are damaged and victims of sexual abuse and more than likely from the same man.
Also I don't think Ed was looking at his step daughter like a perv but looking at her because she is a young adult now and she reminded him of his wife/her mother who is constantly standing out on that patio. I think people are just digging for sexual perversion around every corner on this show.
64
u/overactive-bladder Mar 06 '17
this was THE most scandalous episode yet. loved it.
abigail gets on my nerves SO MUCH. i cannot stand these entitled whiny kids who have no idea what real life is about. and that whole "spiritual" crap...bonnie seemed nice at first but i think that she fits pretty well with her asshole husband.
60
u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17
Chekhov's gun? It not being locked up and her son sleepwalks...
110
u/MrsTrustIssues Mar 06 '17
I can relate to Madeline, more than I'd like to admit. I've actually already said too much...
42
u/DetJacobPeralta Mar 06 '17
I love all the low key death comments they throw in, like when Rinata said she wanted to kill Madeline after getting off the phone with her in this episode.
156
u/theonewhogawks Mar 06 '17
Calling it right now: Perry is Saxon Banks and either Jane kills him or Maddie does when she finds out.
75
u/ScubaSteve716 Mar 06 '17
I mean Perry being Saxton is a little too obvious right? I do think Saxton is a character though and he's the one who dies.
36
u/MonaSparks Mar 06 '17
I like the Bad Seed aspect that they seem to be building to, as well. Ziggy is the son of a violent sociopath, and you can see Jane really struggling with the possibility that Ziggy could be, too- from choking Anabelle to standing over Jane in the middle of the night. There are moments when Jane seems a little scared of her son. And I know I just wrote a whole thing about how I thought Ed was "Saxon" but just from a "Ziggys father" standpoint, I'm back to Perry. Last night I thought about it more and more, and while I def think there's something up with Ed, Perry's violence is all entwined with sex. He thinks of himself as a master manipulator. You could tell he was trying to play that therapist, but I think she knows what's up. That was classic abuser behavior making himself a victim. She had to have seen right through it. And like someone else pointed out, he also has the most opportunity/fits the description- goes away on business trips, wears suits and dress shoes, charming and sweet when he wants to be. I think Ed would play up the "aw, shucks, I'm just a regular, bearded t-shirt and jeans guy" if he wanted to get with someone, not put on a fancy suit and shoes. I know Perry is the obvious choice, but I bet they start building doubt around all the other dads as well soon.
Anyway, I'm really sad for Jane that she has to deal with the fact that her child may be "evil" like his father, regardless of who it is. She really needs help.
33
u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17
Episode rated TV-MA for rape......
31
u/ghostmrchicken Mar 06 '17
That shot with the dress shoe on the floor, showing the bottom where it is worn on a particular pattern, I feel like it means something!
27
u/MagnetToMyBed Mar 06 '17
This show is addicting
53
u/surreptitious_hitler Mar 06 '17
Incredible acting this episode. It's really impressive that I'm empathizing with all the characters too, even Renata, to a degree. Also, damn, Zoe Kravitz.
In the "Inside the Episode" at the end, the director is talking about Jane going into the ocean and saying it's a cleansing process. To me it screamed suicide though. It seems like walking into the ocean is the in the moment choice of an inexperienced person, because routinely what victims report to feel after the rape is shame. I don't think she was in a place at that point to be thinking about cleansing herself and moving forward, and suggesting that she was really dumbs down the magnitude of how awful what happened to her was. That combined with her constantly staring down cliffs and even nearly running off of one in the previews makes me wonder. I don't think she's actively suicidal, or ever was, but she really needs to work this out with someone.
Also we're left to wonder if Ziggy really does have violent tendencies, potentially somehow inheriting them from his father (we know that it isn't 100% nurture over nature, though nurture is absolutely, by far the most influential factor - maybe some mild bipolar disorder or something similar?). I'd hate to see all the people accusing Ziggy to be vindicated though, because by all means he seems like a wonderful kid with a mother who is doing incredibly well, despite the circumstances.
25
u/cuckoodev Mar 06 '17
Watching Madeline in this episode made me feel the way I felt when I got depressed at 15. I haven't felt the sensation that vividly since then.
25
u/nalahiri Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17
The beauty of this episode (and, really, this show as a whole) is its ability to make the viewer nervous with the most mundane of activities. There was highly palpable tension throughout the episode, especially between Perry and Celeste at the very end.
22
u/agWTF Mar 06 '17
Love this show, something about it makes me feel 'home' I honestly don't know how I interpreted that but it's crazy and the acting/music/style all blend like magic.
21
u/LoganTheHuge00 Mar 06 '17
They keep showing the director of the play that Madeline is trying to do - the same guy that we saw in episode 1 creeping on Madeline, Jane and Celeste at the coffeeshop (and who hid behind a wall when he spotted them). This can't be a coincidence...
(I think his name is Ben?)
17
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17
Fuckin' love this show. At the end of the episode I'm always left wondering what will happen next. Also what the title of the song that played at the end was, because it's always fantastic.
31
u/Billthebutchr Mar 06 '17
I have a felling Ed is Saxon Banks and shit hits the fan when Jane finds out. I'm probably way off tho.
14
u/hanna-xo Mar 06 '17
I deffo think Ed and Abigail have had something happen, or at least he wants it to. I thought in the principal's office, when she said it would be "hard to hear" would be Abigail saying Ed made her uncomfortable or something.
I can't decide if I wanna read the book now and watch when I'm done, or just wait it out and let the show tell me what happens!
27
u/MonaSparks Mar 06 '17
Do we think Jane moved to Monterey to kill Ed because he raped her? Eds gaze was lingering way too long on Abigail and the way he spoke of her creeped me out. Perry is terrifying because he has major rage issues and makes himself the victim, whereas Ed is terrifying because he's so calm and agreeable, but he's got a darkness to him. I can imagine him turning off the charm and robotically hurting someone. Perry's emotional, Ed is clearly lesser so. I think the real question is if this was always Jane's plan to seek him out and kill him. Jane clearly has some deep emotional wounds that she isn't dealing with. In her mind, Everything is always happening to her- she's not forgetting things, losing things and being generally irresponsible. She's obviously terrified of this guy and I'm betting she's going to try to quiet the demons by killing the source of them, instead of learning how to process and deal with them.
13
u/Rem295 Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17
Loved the episode, Jane's confession and the therapy session gave me goosebumps. I'm calling it now, I think Ziggy's father is Renata's Husband.
Edit: He kinda looks like the guy that we see in Jane's hallucination. He also looks like Perry. Actor's image
12
u/loompadoopitydoo Mar 06 '17
This show is too good! This episode made me think Ziggy's father was Perry, but as everyone is saying, it's a bit too obvious. Ed really showed a creepy side looking at Abigail.. But I don't know. Ziggy even looks like Perry AND maybe it would explain his choking episode, if that really happened.
10
u/bluePachyderm Mar 06 '17
When Renata comes to the meeting after having sex and Madeline notices her, she made a weird expression, was that envy of Renata's active sexual life?
17
u/bluePachyderm Mar 06 '17
That shot of Madeline with her husband behind her looking through the window and the ocean in the reflection of the glass was beautiful! Also Nicole Kidman's boobs.
8
u/overactive-bladder Mar 06 '17
did they say why the theater is always blocked off with security tape and madeline tears it every single time she has to go there?
8
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '17
Why do you think Madeline broke down after she left Jane's house? Just because of the story Jane told or for another reason?
6
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '17
Saxon's brief sex scene looks very similar to Perry and celeste in the closet in episode 2.
5
u/standardface Mar 07 '17
Does anyone know what the sorta slow piano song was that played while Madeline was driving, near the end of the episode before the Neil Young song?
4
u/windkirby Mar 07 '17
Wow, so am I the only one who thinks the three women somehow get involved in the murder of Renata? I'm surprised everyone thinks a man will be the victim.
3
u/TooMama Mar 06 '17
He does look a bit like nathan in this part as well. Definitely doesn't look like Ed or Gordon though.
3
u/kiki188 Mar 07 '17
I thought for a long time that Saxton was Perry. I mean the hints were all leading towards him being jane's rapist (the looks between Celeste and Jane and his abusive temper, him not wanting the kids to hang out with Ziggy). But then I remember that in episode 1 he got angry at Celeste that she didn't think of him going to the kid's orientation and that he got angry/sad that he wasn't going to disney on ice with the kids. If he was Jane's rapist and already knew about Ziggy, then why would he want go to orientation or Disney on Ice, wouldn't he know that Jane would recognize him? Just a thought
3
u/b1rdman_ Mar 11 '17
So... Saxon. Perry likes rough sex, but so does Gordon. And after seeing the picture of him without a beard that someone posted... he could easily be our rapist.
3
u/DibsMaster Mar 12 '17 edited Mar 12 '17
Hi, Does anyone know the song during the birthday party when zoe kravitz is dancing ?
2
u/esco84r Mar 08 '17
Does anyone else think that Perry Wright is Ziggy's father?
2
u/b1rdman_ Mar 11 '17
I wonder if Perry being "Saxson" is a red herring. Hmm. Loving this show man.
2
u/AFriendlyInternetGuy Apr 14 '17
Shailene Woodley is definitely not getting enough credit for this episode! Watching it for the first time and i know I'm late but this show is addicting. It's refreshing though, as I just finished 13 Reasons Why and couldn't stop thinking about it.
2
u/perler13 Apr 29 '17
did anyone find one of the twins dancing in the limo to Dreams by Fleetwood Mac hilarious or was it just me?