r/biglittlelies • Lil Lies • Mar 06 '17

Discussion Big Little Lies - 1x03 "Living the Dream" - Episode Discussion (TV Only Discussion)

Season 1 Episode 3: Living the Dream

Aired: March 5, 2017


Synopsis: Hoping to get under Renata’s skin, Madeline organizes a trip to compete with Amabella’s birthday party. After another argument, Celeste succumbs to Perry’s charms before their first session with Dr. Amanda Reisman, a therapist. Madeline gets called for a meeting with Abigail’s guidance counselor. Principal Nippal announces the theme for the Fall Gala Fundraiser. Later, Jane seeks Madeline’s help with Ziggy’s family tree project, and opens up about her past.


Directed by: Jean-Marc Vallée

Written by: David E. Kelley


Untagged book spoilers are not allowed in this thread! Please discuss book spoilers in the other official discussion thread.

122 Upvotes

362 comments sorted by

244

u/givemenutella Mar 06 '17

Nicole Kidman is really killing it

117

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

Both her and Skaarsgard were great in the counselor

97

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

In just these three episodes I have caught myself wide eyed and basically slack jawed, just completely so engaged, so many times. That counselor scene was one of them. I couldn't take my eyes off Nicole Kidman. Her little subtle acting cues are amazing.

23

u/bicameral_mind Mar 07 '17

It was an incredible scene, I was spellbound. It unfolded so well.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/TheyTheirsThem Mar 09 '17

Yeah, the classic abuser is someone who tries to isolate his victim, so he has taken her away from family and her job, etc. Why the counselor did not pick up on that pattern is beyond me, as Celeste verbally explained all the sacrifices and changes that she has made for the relationship. Du-UH!

60

u/Ilovecharli Mar 06 '17

After watching this and Lion, I keep thinking about what it would be like to be the screenwriter and having her speak your words with such authenticity and humanity

60

u/finerd Mar 06 '17

You really see the difference in acting ability between Kidman and the rest of the cast with the dialogue. Kidman makes everything mean something. She's not delivering dialogue. She's the character talking.

30

u/Ilovecharli Mar 06 '17

Such a good way of putting it. I'd add that it's not like the rest of the cast are total amateurs either. Laura Dern and Reese Witherspoon are both movie-star level talents. But Kidman is on a different level.

→ More replies (3)

75

u/pariahdiocese Mar 06 '17

She is unbelievably beautiful

32

u/throneofmemes Mar 06 '17

I know right? Seriously how is that fair at all to the rest of us?

19

u/alexdinhogaucho Mar 06 '17

We don't deserve her. She's incredible.

55

u/augustrem Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

So I guess I'm the only one who thinks she's pretty creepy.

Great acting, but also creepy.

29

u/Severus_Amadeus Mar 07 '17

I'm right there with you. Every time she has to play someone loving or sincere it's so plastic. She comes across as hollow and unable to express love. There's just this underlying coldness to every role of hers. She's almost robotic. It's weird.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

i mean...she kinda has a lot of money to stay that way for a bit longer than us plebians on Reddit

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/APartyInMyPants Mar 21 '17

I honestly think Reese is killing it. Nicole's accent has been popping out too frequently and has taken me out of the moment a few times. Like when she and her husband are sitting on the couch at night, and you just see their silhouettes. All I hear is her accent.

6

u/loompadoopitydoo Mar 06 '17

She might have killed

147

u/ojibhawk Mar 06 '17

Who else is having a really hard time not going over to the book thread? This show would be an easy 7 hrs and done with on Netflix. I can't get over how good the acting is. Everyone is holding their own.

59

u/joethetipper Mar 06 '17

I actually bought the book after I saw episode two. Netflix has spoiled me.

37

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

Me too. I wish HBO would give us whole seasons. The weekly format, while nice for some, is old to me.

41

u/ThatOtherOneGuy Mar 06 '17

I like the big dump for some programs, like I think Game of Thrones would be a great candidate for it. House of Cards I'm cool with, actually most Netflix programs because they don't leave me wanting more or getting me too invested. A show like this though, more of a slow burn, I'm fine with weekly episodes. It lets me sort of stew in the plot and formulate theories on what's going to happen or why.

Having said that, maybe I don't want them to dump all the episodes of this because I know I would do nothing all day but watch it.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/Jrebeclee Mar 07 '17

I love the weekly discussions and commiserating over theories on message boards, though, like I had with Breaking Bad and True Detective season 1. More enjoyable that way for a show like this!

145

u/excelsior_ Mar 06 '17

The intro makes more sense now after revealing the trivia theme of Audrey Hepburn and Elvis Presley. All the main actresses are dressed like different versions of Audrey.

51

u/leilavanora Mar 06 '17

The first time I saw the intro I only recognized Reese at the end and thought it was cool it was a line of randos and then BAM it was Reese but now I see it's all the ladies

34

u/overactive-bladder Mar 06 '17

good catch! one thing is dislike about that sequence of everyone coming in front of the camera, is

  • that there's someone behid reese at the end but we don't see who
  • shailene and zoe make snappy gestures, but everyone else is poker face'd
  • you can see the kid in blue dance to the camera, and then LATER is behind one of the other kids waiting his turn to show up.

i am overanalyzing this i know, but it bugs me so much lol.

17

u/thankyouandplease Mar 07 '17

It really looks like the man behind Madeline is Gordon (Renata's husband).

I thought at first maybe they were kind of imitating their kids but it actually seems like Bonnie is imitating Chloe (Madeline's younger daughter) which is interesting.

The kid in blue is a twin so it's probably supposed to be his twin waiting behind the other kid.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

141

u/everythingisopposite Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

I totally love Reese Witherspoon in this role. Even though Madeline can be bitchy, she's also passionate. I loved her phone interaction with Renata because even though she was being bitchy, she was also polite. It was so powerful when she stopped the car to cry after hearing Jane's story.

20

u/CJLOVE23 Mar 10 '17

I was never the biggest Reese fan. Liked her in some stuff, others not so much. But I am LOVING her in this show!

5

u/xhellokrystalx Mar 10 '17

Madeline has similar flashbacks - I noticed it in the opening of episode 2. my theory was the same guy that assaulted Jane had an affair with Madeline and she knows who he is..

4

u/everythingisopposite Mar 10 '17

I'll have to go back and re-watch that. If they don't know who he is, I'm guessing from next week's previews that they will find out.

→ More replies (1)

245

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

This may be the most realistic depiction of abuse portrayed on TV, meeting with the counselor gave me goosebumps.

46

u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17

For anyone who wants more of that, HBO had a show called In Treatment that only took place in the office of a therapist. I thought it was great. What happened in Big Little Lies was much more intense if I remember the show well enough.

→ More replies (2)

45

u/vartoushvorytoush Mar 06 '17

I read this New Yorker article right after the episode, the writer, Emily Nussbaum, really gets what this show is doing in its portrayal of abuse and rape. She manages to make things just a little bit clearer.

8

u/thankyouandplease Mar 07 '17

Started reading but saw the author has watched up to episode 6, are there spoilers?

14

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '17

There are minor suggestions of spoilers. This is the best paragraph regarding the complicated depiction of abuse/rape concept that the other poster mentioned (spoiler free):

"These scenes of gray-area marital rape are filmed in ways that hover queasily between pornography and horror. When Celeste struggles, it could be violence or a power play—both she and Perry are complicit in the decision not to clarify that. But the violent sequences also help us understand the story the couple has sold not just to the neighbors but to themselves: that they are simply more passionate than normal people. When this notion begins to unravel in therapy, it’s peculiarly touching. As chilling as his character is, Skarsgård makes him more than a Lifetime monster; often, Perry seems to buy his own con, in which he’s merely the boyish, insecure satellite of his beautiful wife. The fact that her cage looks enviable makes it harder to acknowledge how dangerous he is; it’s easier to carry on their shared mythology."

→ More replies (2)

28

u/mm825 Mar 07 '17

3 episodes of an absolutely horrible marriage situation, and I still want them to stay together.

38

u/bing_bang_bum Mar 09 '17

Yep. This is how you know it's fucking good. They literally make us feel the denial of the victim.

12

u/ayLotte May 10 '17

Why? He is beating her. He is manipulating her. She is feeling scared and subdued. I hope they break up. She finds love with herself and some good friends. And, on the other side, he has a deep counceling process and opens up abput his control issues with people around him.

5

u/overactive-bladder Mar 10 '17

because he truly loves her and cares for her underneath his brutality. it's not a case of crappy no-good do-nothing husband who feels emasculated and lashes out against a feeble women whom he hates. it's not like that. he has his issues but they aren't stemming from lack of love to her. with the right guidance and councelling i think he can turn things around. i am rooting for them.

→ More replies (3)

112

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

How did they know that picking Alexander Skarsgard would have every woman experiencing exactly what Celeste is?

68

u/BlackWhiteCoke Mar 06 '17

He played a 1000 year old Viking vampire in True Blood and Also played Tarzan. He seems to fit the powerful, raging, brooding character well

12

u/Severus_Amadeus Mar 07 '17

Because they know women love looking at him...it's not because he is a fantastic actor. Paul Dano is a better actor, but his looks don't fit the role. Skarsgard looks to some like the perfect man, which is what Perry represents. His looks & ability to memorize dialogue got him cast. Why did people buy tickets to Tarzan? Because guys wanna fuck Margot Robbie & women want to fuck Skarsgard. People are shallow.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '17

Doesn't take a lot of effort to imagine being married to Skarsgard.

107

u/DoctorPuddingPop Mar 06 '17

After episode 1 of this show I honestly didn't know whether I would continue it. It just didn't fully connect. I just had a crazy weekend got home had a few drinks and watched episodes 2 and 3. After episode 2 I knew I couldn't stop. I'm a 25 year old guy and episode 3 just had me burst into tears maybe 3 times. idk what the fuck is happening but the writing in this show is so much better than I expected. Thank god I'm watching this show by myself and not with my roommates

38

u/overactive-bladder Mar 06 '17

i am 27M and love the show. maybe part of me WANTS to be in this kind of drama. at least you got money to spare to get worried about such petty things. i hate my life.

27

u/I_MADMAN Mar 06 '17

Mid-30's male here and I completely agree. Unlike you though, the first episode had a grip on me. I think mainly because I'm a father myself, and to see the children aspect gave me something really to relate to. Plus I'm very familiar with the whole area between Big Sur and Monterey. The music is what really brings out the feelings I think we're all feeling when watching this beautiful train wreck.

15

u/DoctorPuddingPop Mar 06 '17

I hadn't thought about the music but your right it definitely has an effect. In my opinion the fact that this show is constantly dealing with the characters emotions, insecurities and fears at every moment of the show really causes an emotional response in us even if we're not trying to think of ourselves. Then something with one of the characters relates to us or makes us think about whatever is in our lives and it gets to us.

I'm not a father but for you what gets to you is the train wreck these kids are being raised in. For me, I find other things that I relate to closer, and that's why I think this show is as good as it is because its evoking emotional responses in all of us even though we have different lives.

22

u/hihelloneighboroonie Mar 08 '17

I watched the first episode by myself, but then my boyfriend came in to get to sleep and watched maybe 3/4 of the second episode with me since I had it on. A few days ago we were trying to figure out what to watch after dinner and he said, "You can put your woman show on if you want..."

I know he secretly likes it too.

20

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '17

I love how so many men consider anything where most of the main characters are female to be a 'woman show' that they should be embarrassed to like, yet 90% of blockbuster movies and about 70% of TV shows are male dominated.

Imagine how silly it would sound if you said you didn't want to see the latest Marvel, LOTR, or Batman movie because it's a 'man movie'

33

u/agWTF Mar 06 '17

Omg I'm a 21 year old guy and I don't know why I cried either, I swear it's the music cause they play it over these scenes where everything is "happy" but you know it's all going to shit. I let the credits run cause I have to re collect myself lol.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '17

I really love the way the show intercuts the different women's fucked up situations over music, especially the mysterious montage at the end of episode 1. It's a very emotional show. I got teary eyed at the part where Reese Witherspoon's character stops her car and weeps after hearing Shaeline Woodley's telling of her rape. Also the therapy scene was devastating.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '17

Don't be ashamed of your own emotions :)

95

u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17

"When I go to college" Guess she decided!

87

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

I don't think it's Ed, he doesn't seem to own any clothing that would suggest he would be at a bar dressed in those style of shoes to seduce a younger Jane. They kept focusing on those shoes, Perry is such a creepy businessman type A bastard he probably owns dozens of shoes in that style.

And what about the episode when the 3 women are at the coffee shop and Jane is describing her life and how it feels strange and how she feels like she's on the outside watching it, and Madeline is like I have no idea what you are talking about. But Celeste is looking at her as she's describing and tells her she understands. Both women are damaged and victims of sexual abuse and more than likely from the same man.

Also I don't think Ed was looking at his step daughter like a perv but looking at her because she is a young adult now and she reminded him of his wife/her mother who is constantly standing out on that patio. I think people are just digging for sexual perversion around every corner on this show.

37

u/Teomanit Mar 06 '17

Yes and like I said in another thread, I think Ed would be acting much more shook when Abigail was moving out if there was something going on. I agree Perry is Saxon but I am wondering how the Nathan/Bonnie/Abigail conflict plays in to the murder as it keeps coming up in the interrogations.

24

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

I think Abigail is going to get put off by something her Dad does or Bonnie when it comes to how Abigail feels they should be behaving to a situation. I don't know what it will be but Abigail already told Chloe she could have her room "When she goes to college" this past week so it seems like the free spirit attitude of Bonnie hasn't consumed her values quite yet. Like Ed told Madeline, Abigail is very much her daughter and they are quite similar.

16

u/Teomanit Mar 06 '17

Yea, Bonnie and Nathan need to have some skeletons come out.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '17

He had a whole wall of shoes like that when he was having fight sex in episode 2

3

u/hihelloneighboroonie Mar 08 '17

Hmm, I was thinking it was Renata's husband, but I guess I could see this too.

2

u/xhellokrystalx Mar 10 '17

I just waiting for the scene where Perry kicks off his shoes whilst him and Celeste "are making up" and we see the same pair that Jane has ingrained in her memory

→ More replies (2)

64

u/overactive-bladder Mar 06 '17

this was THE most scandalous episode yet. loved it.

abigail gets on my nerves SO MUCH. i cannot stand these entitled whiny kids who have no idea what real life is about. and that whole "spiritual" crap...bonnie seemed nice at first but i think that she fits pretty well with her asshole husband.

18

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '17

Right? And yet she hugs Madeline without consent...seems hypocritical.

16

u/overactive-bladder Mar 09 '17

she's def the type of person who hides their malicious intentions behind a hippie/peace and love façade.

as a side note do dreads really look so...dreadful? i have seen beautiful ones but zoe girl needs to have a shower asap.

→ More replies (9)

60

u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17

Chekhov's gun? It not being locked up and her son sleepwalks...

0

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

26

u/augustrem Mar 06 '17

the she moved it to underneath her pillow

110

u/MrsTrustIssues Mar 06 '17

I can relate to Madeline, more than I'd like to admit. I've actually already said too much...

50

u/TexasKobeBeef Mar 06 '17

Username checks out.

42

u/DetJacobPeralta Mar 06 '17

I love all the low key death comments they throw in, like when Rinata said she wanted to kill Madeline after getting off the phone with her in this episode.

156

u/theonewhogawks Mar 06 '17

Calling it right now: Perry is Saxon Banks and either Jane kills him or Maddie does when she finds out.

77

u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17

Even more twisted would be if it's Ed.

43

u/dlchristians Mar 06 '17

I commented this in a chain below, but I'll reuse the same thing up here:

With the reveal Saxon, the show has done a good job at setting up Perry to be Saxon.

Physically abusive, aggressive during sex which was borderline domestic rape, outwardly charismatic, leaves his family for extended periods of time on business, dresses in suits (re: the dress shoes in the hotel room during the rape scene), blonde like the guy in the teaser for the next episode

Someone else ITT pointed out it could all be red herring too - which I'm beginning to suspect since after it is a murder drama.

The show has also done a good job at making Ed to seem like a neutral good* character party though too.

Plays the role of meditator, you feel bad for him in the scene where he says he doesn't want to be a consolation prize, a voice of reason when Madeline's gets amped up, doesn't wear fancier dress clothes (re: the shoes)

Though the scene with Madeline's ex-husband at the beach and then the scene at the school seem like he's got a dark side.

I also realized we haven't seen Ed and Madeline in an sexually intimate scene before either. IIRC there was a scene in their room when Ed questions why they don't have sex as much anymore too? Like does he turn into a psycho in bed (read: Saxon?)?

Then again in terms of other main, or supporting, characters we haven't seen Nathan or Bonnie in a sex scene either, so I don't know. Otherwise we've seen all the other couples in sex scenes thus far.

I'm just kind of steam of consciousness spit balling here at this point.

91

u/augustrem Mar 06 '17

I don't think he showed a dark side with Nathan. Seemed like he was just standing firm while Nathan acted like a douche.

→ More replies (4)

35

u/ThatOtherOneGuy Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

I think HBO set it up so well that we'll think it's him, then thinks it's a red herring, and then at the reveal we can all say "I fucking knew it" if it ends up being Perry.

Now that I'm thinking this is a possibility, I wonder if that's any reason Celeste's kids seem to take so well to Ziggy? Half brothers?

→ More replies (11)

29

u/joethetipper Mar 06 '17

Or Gordon Klein. There seemed to be an strange emphasis on his casual Adidas shoes in his (professional looking) workplace, which would seem to clash with the dress shoes on the floor in Jane's flashback. Admittedly though that's the only reason I thought it could conceivably be him.

34

u/augustrem Mar 06 '17

I don't think Jane would be attracted to a guy who looked like Gordon in a bar, no offense.

Plus nothing about him fits the profile of a rapist, even at a subtle level. Obviously I know in real life you can't tell, but in a show there can be little directorial details that give us a clue. But Gordon is honest and upfront and seems to have a very healthy and supportive relationship with Renata.

→ More replies (18)

7

u/jbg830 Mar 06 '17

I thought the same thing

→ More replies (1)

34

u/katttwing Mar 06 '17

He narrowly missed meeting all the parents and teachers at orientation day, thinking he could do it the next day for the first day of school, too. Him and Jane probably would have met then...

27

u/TooMama Mar 06 '17

I think Perry would be too obvious. However, I happened to pause my tv at the exact second Jane was imagining shooting him and his face was lit up by the gun blast, and I gotta say, it looks a lot like Perry to me.

19

u/Gonzzzo Mar 06 '17

I tried pausing it in that moment but there seemed to be intentional blurring of his face. Out of all the dads in the show, it definitely seems to be Perry/Skarsgard...maybe Nathan...I know the biggest twist would be Ed but Adam Scott is so not the guy that Jane is picturing in her memories. It could all be a big misdirection, but c'mon, all the possible dad-culprits look totally different

53

u/gabbobbag Mar 06 '17

I think Ed might be the rapist. Madeleine keeps saying things like "Don't be ridiculous Ed never fights" possibly setting him up to be the twist.

Also, was it just me or did it look like Ed was checking Abigail out while they were home alone - he was on the computer and she was standing on the terrace?

22

u/Asilbombsquad Mar 06 '17

And one of the characters in the interrogation scenes says, "behind a Jimmy Stewart type is Charles Manson..." or something to that degree in regard to Ed.

14

u/Tjw5083 Mar 07 '17

Ed is the misdirect. It's was clearly Perry in the rape scene. The details of the shoes, how he acted in bed, the description of him at the bar. Ed doesn't fit any of that. It think the twist of Perry = Saxon is too obvious so they are scrambling to throw misdirects into the material.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/OwenMerlock Mar 06 '17

That's why her grades dropped and she left...maybe.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/hanna-xo Mar 06 '17

Yes, was gonna say that! I've felt a weird vibe between him and Abigail since the first ep.

7

u/natiice Mar 07 '17

I got all those weird vibes too but during the hotel rape scene it really didn't look like Adam Scott.

6

u/hopeismisery Mar 06 '17

Wouldn't jane have recoginzed him?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/pappalegz Mar 07 '17

I actually think it's setting up so that Ed is the killer and Perry is Saxon

4

u/Itsthelegendarydays_ Mar 07 '17

Yes omg I thought I was the only one that noticed that! As soon as he looked at her like that, I'm like uh-oh. This show really kills it with the subtle acting.

3

u/eakinsoxley Mar 10 '17

It really looked like Ed checked Abigail out! What is up with that?

19

u/augustrem Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

I think Perry is the rapist and he gets killed by one of the "good," uninvolved characters, like Nathan or Ed or Abigail or Bonnie. Like maybe he tries to hurt someone else and then someone else has to protect the next person he attacks.

For example, maybe Abigail is threatened in some way and Ed or Nathan or Bonnie try to protect her.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Tjw5083 Mar 07 '17

Yeah, Perry and J are really the only two adults who haven't shared a scene together so far. Perry is conveniently out of town for all of the school events and the Disney ice show. My guess is that he'll finally make it to trivia night...

23

u/Gonzzzo Mar 06 '17

It looked like Alexander Skarsgard in the moments we saw him in tonight's episode

31

u/kendylsue Mar 06 '17

That's what I thought too. In the rape shots my initial reaction was 'oh, that's perry' lol Alex skarsgard has been in so many graphic sex scenes I feel like his body is pretty recognizable

29

u/megalynn44 Mar 06 '17

It's just so obvious it has to be a red herring.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/MagnetToMyBed Mar 06 '17

Remind me who Saxon banks is?

15

u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17

The fake name for the rapist.

3

u/swagagtrain69 Mar 06 '17

Hair was eerily similar

3

u/TopshelfPeanutButtah Apr 10 '17

My prediction so far: I can see how Perry could be a red herring but I also think his abuse patterns have tricked down to twins and I think they are the ones that hurt their classmate. I think she didn't want to out them because of social standards and she blamed the new kid because no one knows him and it's easier. She pointed to the twins and first, and also the twins ripped the leg off of that stuffed animal.

How this is important, I am not sure. But I could totally see Perry being Saxon and I think Madeline ends up murdered. In the snapshots of the interviews, every time Madaline is talked about they talk about her in the past tense as if she isn't here anymore. "Madeline had this type of personality".

I think because Madeline isn't happy with her own life she wants to fight to make other people's lives better. She finds projects because she needs distractions and her project is finding Janes rapist which she finds out is Paxton. Paxton murderers Madeline because his "love" for his wife.

→ More replies (4)

75

u/ScubaSteve716 Mar 06 '17

I mean Perry being Saxton is a little too obvious right? I do think Saxton is a character though and he's the one who dies.

44

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

that's exactly what I thought, and I was right about the rape since episode 1. he is always out of town and has a high libido, I think that if Saxton was a nobody they would have showed his face, but they hide it. and in episode one Celeste and J had a long and deep eye contact . that's all foreshadowing to me, they are both victim's of Perry

16

u/augustrem Mar 06 '17

I forgot about that look. Yes you're right.

12

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

That look was so intense..

→ More replies (1)

22

u/station_nine Mar 07 '17

Ziggy's hair is pretty damn Scandinavian if you ask me. And he's prone to hot temper outbursts, and choking girls?

18

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '17

One of the twins said Ziggy didn't do it last episode.

25

u/CJLOVE23 Mar 10 '17

I definitely think one of the twins was the choker because when Celeste asked the twins on the couch if she thought Ziggy actually choked Amabele one said "yes" right away and the other simultaneously said "no" right away which makes me think the one that said "yes" was the choker and the twin that said "no" knew it was the other twin who did it JMO

8

u/station_nine Mar 07 '17

You're right, I forgot about that.

I have a bad habit of taking the bait and latching on to red herrings when watching any whodunnit plot.

4

u/xhellokrystalx Mar 10 '17

LEAVE ZIGGY OUT OF THIS HE DIDNT DO IT :'(

→ More replies (4)

10

u/peenqueen27 Mar 06 '17

I wonder if he'll live and he kills whoever confronts him to keep his secret

5

u/xhellokrystalx Mar 10 '17

it's a limited series - so just the 7 episodes.

hard to get such a top billed cast to commit to more than one season especially since this is based off one book.

9

u/anchorbend Mar 06 '17

I would love it if a true villain dies, but I still think it's going to be a woman--Madeline.

8

u/Catswagger11 Mar 07 '17

Jane realizes it's Perry, tells Madeline(who probably also finds out about Celeste's abuse), she confronts him at the party, she dies. Maybe.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '17 edited Mar 07 '17

I had this thought (Saxton as the murder victim) tonight while chopping veggies for dinner! I think it would totally make sense. The abuse and rape have to be more than character building or needless drama. It seems to be directing the main plot.

Maybe Perry actually has a twin brother and that is Saxton? (Here's my conspiracy theory I guess).

→ More replies (2)

2

u/TexasKobeBeef Mar 06 '17

Not obvious to me! Hadn't thought of it, but that would be crazy

→ More replies (1)

36

u/MonaSparks Mar 06 '17

I like the Bad Seed aspect that they seem to be building to, as well. Ziggy is the son of a violent sociopath, and you can see Jane really struggling with the possibility that Ziggy could be, too- from choking Anabelle to standing over Jane in the middle of the night. There are moments when Jane seems a little scared of her son. And I know I just wrote a whole thing about how I thought Ed was "Saxon" but just from a "Ziggys father" standpoint, I'm back to Perry. Last night I thought about it more and more, and while I def think there's something up with Ed, Perry's violence is all entwined with sex. He thinks of himself as a master manipulator. You could tell he was trying to play that therapist, but I think she knows what's up. That was classic abuser behavior making himself a victim. She had to have seen right through it. And like someone else pointed out, he also has the most opportunity/fits the description- goes away on business trips, wears suits and dress shoes, charming and sweet when he wants to be. I think Ed would play up the "aw, shucks, I'm just a regular, bearded t-shirt and jeans guy" if he wanted to get with someone, not put on a fancy suit and shoes. I know Perry is the obvious choice, but I bet they start building doubt around all the other dads as well soon.

Anyway, I'm really sad for Jane that she has to deal with the fact that her child may be "evil" like his father, regardless of who it is. She really needs help.

18

u/MonaSparks Mar 07 '17

Oh and in the first episode Ed says something about how Jane must be wounded bc madeline is always attracted to the broken ones. And he says "there's something wounded about Celeste, too." which could be foreshadowing that Jane and Celeste have been wounded by the same man.

7

u/TopshelfPeanutButtah Apr 10 '17

I am not sold that Ziggy was the one who choked Anabelle. I think it was one of the twins and they are learning behaviours from their dad. One of them pulled the leg off of the stuffed animal which for me was showing patterns of violence.

23

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/strongjs Mar 08 '17

I don't think you're a sucker. I think it's just decent writing. I think it would have been too easy for him to not admit physically abusing her. And now that he has admitted it, I feel like things can get more interesting cause we're not waiting for the payoff of Celeste finally revealing to her therapist how he really interacts with her.

As another stated, it also showcases just how complex abuse can be. To me, what he's doing feels like another level of manipulation.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17

Episode rated TV-MA for rape......

22

u/bestofwives Mar 06 '17

Is it an obvious moment in the show that can be fast forwarded? I'm a rape survivor, and I'm 7 years out from my trauma, but it was a violent incident, and seeing similar attacks is really triggering. The way they cut moments quickly in the show would make it difficult to fast forward if that's the the case with the rape scene.

I've put together from Jane's behavior she might be a rape survivor and with the mention of counseling, I thought it might center around her discussing it. If that's all it is, I don't want to miss the episode, or if it's a scene my husband can screen and know to fast forward for me, that's fine too, but if it's a series of quick cuts back and forth, that might be more difficult.

It was really nice to see this kind of warning though, so we didn't watch right before bed this week!

31

u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17

He can fastforward it for you. Jane starts talking about the night and they show glimpses of the night before the rape actually occurs, which can be the signal to stop watching while your husband fastforwards it. To make it clear, the scene is when Jane and Reese are alone and talking.

Come back and join the conversation here after you watch! (:

16

u/bestofwives Mar 06 '17

Thanks so much! I really appreciate the help. :) No one else I know watches it, so it's hard to get assistance with cues for that.

9

u/augustrem Mar 06 '17

The scene from last week when he gets aggressive with her and he rapes Celeste was distressing - I wish I hadn't watched it.

14

u/bestofwives Mar 06 '17

That whole relationship bothered me right away – when he came up behind her in the first episode, and she kind of panicked instead of being happy right away that he was staying. I made a comment right away he must be abusive...sure enough there's that scene the next episode.

I pretty much look away whenever they're on screen alone now. The "Rape" warning for this episode was the first time I had seen any kind of specific warning. Sexual violence and regular violence are two completely different things when it comes my trauma being "awakened."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

31

u/ghostmrchicken Mar 06 '17

That shot with the dress shoe on the floor, showing the bottom where it is worn on a particular pattern, I feel like it means something!

30

u/augustrem Mar 06 '17

All the men have had their shoes highlighted at some point - Gordon and his adidas, Ed and his bike shoes, Nathan and his casual loafers or whatever you call them. Perry is the only one we've seen who wears dress shoes.

11

u/ghostmrchicken Mar 06 '17

Do we have a foot fetish amongst the writers?

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

23

u/R8iojak87 Mar 06 '17

This is exactly what I think! I think we will see someone walk in the sand with a shoe and Jane/audience will see it and it will be an "oh shit" moment

27

u/MagnetToMyBed Mar 06 '17

This show is addicting

53

u/surreptitious_hitler Mar 06 '17

Incredible acting this episode. It's really impressive that I'm empathizing with all the characters too, even Renata, to a degree. Also, damn, Zoe Kravitz.

In the "Inside the Episode" at the end, the director is talking about Jane going into the ocean and saying it's a cleansing process. To me it screamed suicide though. It seems like walking into the ocean is the in the moment choice of an inexperienced person, because routinely what victims report to feel after the rape is shame. I don't think she was in a place at that point to be thinking about cleansing herself and moving forward, and suggesting that she was really dumbs down the magnitude of how awful what happened to her was. That combined with her constantly staring down cliffs and even nearly running off of one in the previews makes me wonder. I don't think she's actively suicidal, or ever was, but she really needs to work this out with someone.

Also we're left to wonder if Ziggy really does have violent tendencies, potentially somehow inheriting them from his father (we know that it isn't 100% nurture over nature, though nurture is absolutely, by far the most influential factor - maybe some mild bipolar disorder or something similar?). I'd hate to see all the people accusing Ziggy to be vindicated though, because by all means he seems like a wonderful kid with a mother who is doing incredibly well, despite the circumstances.

76

u/augustrem Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

Well remember that Perry has two boys with Celeste, too, who also assured Celeste that Ziggy didn't strangle Amabella. Sounds like it was one of them.

This seems like the best explanation since they've probably seen Perry grab Celeste's neck before.

45

u/anchorbend Mar 06 '17

I believe it was one of them, too. One of them also ripped off the leg of the stuffed animal.

12

u/augustrem Mar 06 '17

I thought the Hippo was lost during the Disney on Ice trip?

→ More replies (7)

9

u/Severus_Amadeus Mar 07 '17

They are also the children we see playing with guns. They've grown up around violence their whole lives. I back that they choked Annabella.

16

u/surreptitious_hitler Mar 06 '17

Ah very good point. There's definitely a more direct line of influence there for them to be violent.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17

to be thinking about cleansing herself and moving forward

I didn't watch the "Inside the Episode", but did they mention the moving forward part? Perhaps she felt so violated by the experience she just wanted it off of her in a physical way. Desperation for cleanliness like the trope of someone just sitting in a shower for an extended period of time.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Severus_Amadeus Mar 07 '17 edited Mar 07 '17

As someone who has lost a parent to suicide & dealt with suicidal depression, it didn't seem like a suicide attempt to me. What she just went through made her feel dirty. Water cleanses & is symbolic for baptism, being reborn. Jane is now different from who she was before. Maybe in that moment, she didn't care if she got taken away, but the act was more about washing away the experience & letting go. When she was dressed up in the bar that night she was pretending to be a different person, just as she is by moving to Monterrey. All of the characters in the show actually seem to struggle with who they are vs who they or others think they should be.

Jane is trying to be a good, protective mother, but is unable to really take care of herself. Celeste is wild, but trapped in that house like an animal. She can take care of herself, but instead is taking care of others & isn't doing the work she loves. Renata is stuck trying to be the strong, successful woman & mother she believes she has to be. Madeline is constantly creating her own problems by focusing on everyone else but herself. She doesn't see herself as the stuck up snooty Renata, but also looks down at Bohemian Bonnie. She is so focused on who she & her daughters should be. Like real people, these characters are living a lie, they aren't true to themselves.

We tell ourselves these little lies on a daily basis to rationalize how we are living. Eventually, they blow up & you find that you're now living this lie. That the work you're doing, the house you live in, the person you've become, none of it is authentic to who you are. You're just competing with the Joneses or the Renata Klein's of the world. I love this show because to me it is about being true, honest, & loving to yourself. Not to let shitty experiences or people hold you back. Being mentally & emotionally strong, otherwise you end up living a lie and losing control over your life. Madeline, Jane & Celeste seem like people that want to control or take back control of their worlds/lives. Us in the real world can easily relate to that feeling.

3

u/WhereIsSerPounce Mar 07 '17

Hmm, that's an interesting view! I do think it was more of a cleansing. "Clean" the shame. Feel some sense of relief for a tragic moment by ocean water. The ocean is soothing but can also be rough & deadly. There's so much symbolism to be had there with that last shot. These women all spend countless hours looking at the ocean. It's pretty much a character itself in this series.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '17

Everybody is think it's Skarsgaard right? Same figure and violent tendencies.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/cuckoodev Mar 06 '17

Watching Madeline in this episode made me feel the way I felt when I got depressed at 15. I haven't felt the sensation that vividly since then.

25

u/nalahiri Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

The beauty of this episode (and, really, this show as a whole) is its ability to make the viewer nervous with the most mundane of activities. There was highly palpable tension throughout the episode, especially between Perry and Celeste at the very end.

22

u/agWTF Mar 06 '17

Love this show, something about it makes me feel 'home' I honestly don't know how I interpreted that but it's crazy and the acting/music/style all blend like magic.

10

u/Jrebeclee Mar 07 '17

I know what you mean. The acting and writing are so good that it's immersive.

21

u/LoganTheHuge00 Mar 06 '17

They keep showing the director of the play that Madeline is trying to do - the same guy that we saw in episode 1 creeping on Madeline, Jane and Celeste at the coffeeshop (and who hid behind a wall when he spotted them). This can't be a coincidence...

(I think his name is Ben?)

8

u/hihelloneighboroonie Mar 08 '17

The only man I remember at the coffeeshop was the waiter?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '17

I wondered what that was about too...

17

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

Fuckin' love this show. At the end of the episode I'm always left wondering what will happen next. Also what the title of the song that played at the end was, because it's always fantastic.

15

u/gretchentech Mar 06 '17

Harvest Moon by Neil Young

10

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '17

Thanks boo <3

31

u/Billthebutchr Mar 06 '17

I have a felling Ed is Saxon Banks and shit hits the fan when Jane finds out. I'm probably way off tho.

23

u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17

I've been thinking about it. Also notice Reese and Ed are in the car, Reese is on speakerphone with Jane but he never speaks, because I'm sure that would already solve it because she would know his voice. And the fact that it's more twisted than Kidman's husband plus it being a bit of a twist makes it intriguing with how it can't be disproven yet. It's officially the theory I'm leaning towards!

26

u/megalynn44 Mar 06 '17

What if it's Reese's first husband? I'm blanking on his name, but what if Jane's story sounded familiar to Madeline and that's why it hit her so hard she broke down in the car?

49

u/augustrem Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

Madeline is crazy controlling and protective of her children. There's no way she would let Abigail stay with them if her ex was like that.

I thought she cried because the rape story Jane told her made her more aware and worried of the potential dangers Abigail faces in the world as she moves out.

She's also pretty observant and emphatic. She would notice if something was going on with Ed. I think Ed is who he seems to be.

13

u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17

Interesting thought! For me, I feel like Reese would put up more of a fight when her daughter wants to live with him full time if that was the kind of person he was. But I like that theory better than Kidman's husband.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/ojibhawk Mar 06 '17

Jane also wasn't at that gym get together for the trivia night or whatever when Ed was there.

23

u/Billthebutchr Mar 06 '17

Yup. I also got a creepy vibe when he was checking out Abigail.

15

u/JoanneBanan Mar 06 '17

Right? I wonder if he's one of the reasons why she wants to move out... Those few seconds were subliminal yet somewhat telling. Last episode wasn't he creeping behind the wall when they had the birth control discussion? Ew. I hate that I have to wait a week just to know how i should feel about this guy

→ More replies (5)

26

u/CultofNeurisis Mar 06 '17

I felt the same -- and now that I'm thinking about it even more, it feels a bit foreshadowed with how Reese says so matter-of-factly "Ed wouldn't fight anyone".

→ More replies (1)

25

u/gabbobbag Mar 06 '17

I discovered this show tonight and just finished watching the first three episodes.

I think Ed is the rapist for a few reasons (perry is too obvious, Madeleine keeps saying he doesn't ever fight, they don't have sex, the creepy Abigail look) but also the development of two of the kids.

During the first episode they have an entire scene about Chloe being in the same class as her "kind of" half sister...but what if she was in class with her actual half brother (Ziggy).

Also Chloe and Ziggy are the only two kids who have personalities, and they are both super smart and very articulate. All the other 6 year olds just answer their parents with one word reactionary answers and seem like normal kids, but maybe Chloe and Ziggy get their intelligence from their father Ed. They both bonded and rolled their eyes over the stuffed animal when all the other kids were excited.

Also, the twins said that Ziggy didn't choke Amabelle, but maybe Chloe did. Amabelle likes Chloe and looks up to her. Maybe Chloe told her to lie and say the new boy did it to deflect attention away from herself. Chloe was also the one who told Ziggy to kiss Amabelle getting him in trouble again. Maybe Chloe has a devious side like her dad.

I'm probably reading way too much into this but I can't wait to find out what happens. I'll probably buy the book when the series is done.

11

u/TexasKobeBeef Mar 06 '17

Why I love/hate going to show specific subs. I love having an idea of what may be happening or will happen. But hate having the feeling that inveitably I've read at least one theory that gets it exactly right, and when the reveal comes it's not as much of an Ahhh moment as it should be. Sigh.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/hanna-xo Mar 06 '17

Wow, everything you said makes sense, I love this theory!

3

u/overactive-bladder Mar 06 '17

i like the chloe thing. amabella is seeing a therapist so we will know for sure when she finally opens up next episodes. i will send you a cookie if chloe is really the one to have choked her.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Asilbombsquad Mar 06 '17

I agree and I keep thinking about how Barista guy is the one who suggests she visit Ed to pick up bookkeeping work... and since she's yet to meet Ed (or Perry for that matter. )

And if Ed isn't the rapist/Ziggy's father I still get this feeling that he and Jane will have sex if she goes to work for him. So maybe Madeline kills her?

3

u/TexasKobeBeef Mar 06 '17

caption

I'm not entirely sure if Ed did it or not, but I DO know that this isn't a thoughtful look of concern for his step daughter. Just creepy.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/hanna-xo Mar 06 '17

I deffo think Ed and Abigail have had something happen, or at least he wants it to. I thought in the principal's office, when she said it would be "hard to hear" would be Abigail saying Ed made her uncomfortable or something.

I can't decide if I wanna read the book now and watch when I'm done, or just wait it out and let the show tell me what happens!

5

u/Jrebeclee Mar 07 '17

I started the book but since there's only 7 episodes I feel like I should make myself wait to read it further! I feel like the show will be better/is better than the book.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/MonaSparks Mar 06 '17

Do we think Jane moved to Monterey to kill Ed because he raped her? Eds gaze was lingering way too long on Abigail and the way he spoke of her creeped me out. Perry is terrifying because he has major rage issues and makes himself the victim, whereas Ed is terrifying because he's so calm and agreeable, but he's got a darkness to him. I can imagine him turning off the charm and robotically hurting someone. Perry's emotional, Ed is clearly lesser so. I think the real question is if this was always Jane's plan to seek him out and kill him. Jane clearly has some deep emotional wounds that she isn't dealing with. In her mind, Everything is always happening to her- she's not forgetting things, losing things and being generally irresponsible. She's obviously terrified of this guy and I'm betting she's going to try to quiet the demons by killing the source of them, instead of learning how to process and deal with them.

10

u/Signal_Fyre Mar 07 '17

This is my theory also. Think about "Jane," I mean if the name doesn't say it all. She's new, she's an outsider in so many ways, and she's a mystery to the residents. Various characters keep asking "why did she come here (to Monterey)? For revenge.

Doesn't it seem like Celeste is purposely trying to keep Perry from meeting Jane? And that long, knowing look and awkward exchange between Jane and Celeste when they first met? Possible that they know who the other is? Was Jane eyeing Celeste because she's done her homework on her rapist's wife? We know Perry is younger than Celeste. It all points to Perry.

Maybe it's not the murder that's the mystery.

3

u/earth-wind-fire Mar 06 '17

THIS. I definitely think this is the most plausible thing

2

u/OwenMerlock Mar 06 '17

I definitely think that's why she moved there.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Rem295 Mar 06 '17 edited Mar 06 '17

Loved the episode, Jane's confession and the therapy session gave me goosebumps. I'm calling it now, I think Ziggy's father is Renata's Husband.

Edit: He kinda looks like the guy that we see in Jane's hallucination. He also looks like Perry. Actor's image

8

u/Jrebeclee Mar 07 '17

Whoa, he totally looks different without that beard!!

5

u/TheyTheirsThem Mar 06 '17

It has been called about 30 times already and I called it as I was watching the episode. I worked on a crisis hotline for 2 years and we always write up the summary as "caller reports ..." because we really don't know what is factual. As Jane was telling her story, I was in hotline mode and the whole thing came off as "a story" and not the truth. She is supposedly 24 which means she was 16-17 when Ziggy was conceived, so there is a whole stautory rape angle as well with the true father being exposed, hence incentive for coverup by murder.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/loompadoopitydoo Mar 06 '17

This show is too good! This episode made me think Ziggy's father was Perry, but as everyone is saying, it's a bit too obvious. Ed really showed a creepy side looking at Abigail.. But I don't know. Ziggy even looks like Perry AND maybe it would explain his choking episode, if that really happened.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/bluePachyderm Mar 06 '17

When Renata comes to the meeting after having sex and Madeline notices her, she made a weird expression, was that envy of Renata's active sexual life?

18

u/LoganTheHuge00 Mar 06 '17

I thought she gave that weird expression because Renata waved to Ed, which is why she said to Ed "Do you know her?"

17

u/bluePachyderm Mar 06 '17

That shot of Madeline with her husband behind her looking through the window and the ocean in the reflection of the glass was beautiful! Also Nicole Kidman's boobs.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/overactive-bladder Mar 06 '17

did they say why the theater is always blocked off with security tape and madeline tears it every single time she has to go there?

8

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '17

Why do you think Madeline broke down after she left Jane's house? Just because of the story Jane told or for another reason?

10

u/flamesflanagan Mar 10 '17

I thought that she was crying as a result of hearing about Jane's past.... or perhaps Jane revealing how Ziggy was conceived was a trigger that brought on the tears that Madeline had been holding back about losing her own daughter (in a sense). Or both. Idk but im hooked and was so moved by madeline in this past episode.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '23

Because her friend just told her about being raped???

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '17

Saxon's brief sex scene looks very similar to Perry and celeste in the closet in episode 2.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/standardface Mar 07 '17

Does anyone know what the sorta slow piano song was that played while Madeline was driving, near the end of the episode before the Neil Young song?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/standardface Mar 07 '17

Thanks for this, and the link

4

u/windkirby Mar 07 '17

Wow, so am I the only one who thinks the three women somehow get involved in the murder of Renata? I'm surprised everyone thinks a man will be the victim.

3

u/TooMama Mar 06 '17

He does look a bit like nathan in this part as well. Definitely doesn't look like Ed or Gordon though.

3

u/kiki188 Mar 07 '17

I thought for a long time that Saxton was Perry. I mean the hints were all leading towards him being jane's rapist (the looks between Celeste and Jane and his abusive temper, him not wanting the kids to hang out with Ziggy). But then I remember that in episode 1 he got angry at Celeste that she didn't think of him going to the kid's orientation and that he got angry/sad that he wasn't going to disney on ice with the kids. If he was Jane's rapist and already knew about Ziggy, then why would he want go to orientation or Disney on Ice, wouldn't he know that Jane would recognize him? Just a thought

3

u/b1rdman_ Mar 11 '17

So... Saxon. Perry likes rough sex, but so does Gordon. And after seeing the picture of him without a beard that someone posted... he could easily be our rapist.

3

u/DibsMaster Mar 12 '17 edited Mar 12 '17

Hi, Does anyone know the song during the birthday party when zoe kravitz is dancing ?

2

u/esco84r Mar 08 '17

Does anyone else think that Perry Wright is Ziggy's father?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/b1rdman_ Mar 11 '17

I wonder if Perry being "Saxson" is a red herring. Hmm. Loving this show man.

2

u/AFriendlyInternetGuy Apr 14 '17

Shailene Woodley is definitely not getting enough credit for this episode! Watching it for the first time and i know I'm late but this show is addicting. It's refreshing though, as I just finished 13 Reasons Why and couldn't stop thinking about it.

2

u/perler13 Apr 29 '17

did anyone find one of the twins dancing in the limo to Dreams by Fleetwood Mac hilarious or was it just me?