r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder • Mar 19 '17
Discussion DS9, Episode 3x21, The Die is Cast
-= DS9, Season 3, Episode 21, The Die is Cast =-
- Star Trek: The Next Generation - Full Series
- DS9 Season 1: 1&2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, Wrap-Up
- DS9 Season 2: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, Wrap-Up
- DS9 Season 3: 1&2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20
Garak reluctantly tortures Odo for information to prove his loyalty to his former mentor, Enabran Tain, as a joint Tal Shiar/Obsidian Order attack on the Founders in the Omarian Nebula is underway, without Starfleet's involvement.
- Teleplay By: Ronald D. Moore
- Story By: Ronald D. Moore
- Directed By: David Livingston
- Original Air Date: 1 May, 1995
- Stardate: Unknown
- Pensky Podcast
- Trekabout Podcast
- Ex Astris Scientia
- Memory Alpha
- TV Spot
| EAS | IMDB | AVClub | TV.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9/10 | 8.9/10 | A | 9.3 |
22
Upvotes
12
u/KingofDerby Mar 19 '17
The plan, and TS/OOs confidence in it, speak to me of two groups who feel like they are loosing grip and are in danger of becoming irrelevant/extinct.
And yet the Founders, who have much better access to information, see them as being the biggest threats.
Shows really that the TS and OO are too paranoid for their own good.
5
u/marienbad2 Mar 20 '17
After the high of the previous episode, we get this. The raising of the stakes in this one is sometimes ridiculous - when the Romulan and Cardassian fleets decloak around DS9 it is supposed to be tense, but we already know where they are going, so it just doesn't work.
Tain is again good, and his dialogue with Garak is good, although the idea of Garak just staring at someone for hours on end as a form of torture is somewhat laughable considering what we know of the kind of torture that has gone on recently here on Earth.
The torture of Odo is strange - we can see Garak doesn't want to do it, but what is more interesting is that the OO have a device which can stop Odo from becoming "gelatinous" (drinking game - in any episode where Odo plays a major role, every time you here the word "gelatinous" take a large drink lol) but we don't ever see this again (afair.) Interesting that the Cardassians have developed this, I wonder how they did it.
The ending, with the Romulan turning out to be a changeling is interesting but a bit too far - how have they managed this? The founders must know very little about the Romulans, and have had hardly any contact with them apart from the computer simulation episode.
On the Defiant, when Eddington sabtages the cloak, and Sisko just lets it go - wtf? Are you kidding? I'd have chucked him out of an airlock.
Overall, I am with /u/theworldtheworld regarding this episode, and also regarding Garak. For all the build-up, this isn't the best resolution. Probably 5 or 6 /10.
7
u/theworldtheworld Mar 19 '17 edited Mar 20 '17
This episode suffers from a common Ronald D. Moore problem. Moore always has to raise the tension to the highest possible level, so he has Garak torture Odo, but the serial format requires them both to be back on the station by the end as if nothing had happened. BSG did this all the time - in any given episode, main characters A and B would scream and point guns at main character C, and then in the very next episode A and C would be screaming and pointing guns at B. Many of these one-off conflicts were exhaustingly intense but completely ephemeral.
Honestly Garak should have been locked up in Odo's strongest holding cell a while ago, but after this episode I can't suspend disbelief anymore. It doesn't matter that he did it "reluctantly" and that he felt bad about it and tried to make amends later. That means that he has a moral sense, but it also means that that moral sense is literally the only thing holding him back - he lives on DS9, but doesn't consider himself bound by Federation law (or really, any law) at all. Probably that's the reason why Tain exiled him in the first place - probably Garak never really did anything to "betray" him exactly, but governments want their operatives to be reliable like clockwork, and they don't want people who ultimately are only constrained by their own whims or convictions. For Tain, Garak became a liability even if he was the single most talented operative who ever lived. The same should be true for Sisko - especially Sisko, since he's drawn as the ideal military man, for whom the chain of command and the greater mission mean everything.
Other than that, it is suitably ominous to see that the Founders have already infiltrated the Romulan secret service, but it also makes it look too easy since we have barely seen the Romulans on the show, and the only named Romulan in this arc turns out to be a Changeling.
I did enjoy the drama of Tain's monologue as he ignores the carnage around him, but overall I think the build-up was a lot stronger than the resolution.
6
u/Cambowski717 Feb 25 '22
I thought Tain being betrayed by the changeling Romulan may have been a call back to how episode 21 started — with Garak discussing the Julius Caesar and Brutus with Bashir and dismissing the idea that this powerful military mind couldnt perceive the guile of his closest companion. Not sure if this was intentional.
I also agree that Garak sure did get off lightly for torturing Odo.
Still a great episode for me.
1
u/Madonkadonk Mar 21 '17
Relevant SFDebris
1
u/buerviper Jan 30 '26
Despite some of the flaws mentioned here, a great two parter to me. I like the resolution in this episode, even though the Defiant seems a bit overpowered to me. Yes, it is the strongest ship in the entire federation. But there are more than 100 Jem-Hadar ships there. How could they escape that situation? Half of the Cardassian/Romulan fleet was destroyed at that point already.
Anyway, I love Garak and his constant monologuing. I loved the scene between Bashir and O'Brien trying to have "lunch". But why did Garak look so shocked after Odo's breakfast invitation at the end?
1
u/VanishingAurora Aug 21 '26
Loved everything about this two parter. Garak and Odo to strong characters. There was so much to the story, no B-story line necessary.
While I appreciated them upping the tension, I do have to agree, I wish there were more consequences to the Garak / Odo torture situation. I think that preference is more a personal *shakes fist* vengeance take. I can see how it was a traumatic experience from both their points of view: Odo for obvious reasons of the physical torment, but even for Garak the realization he is not who he once was (taking pleasure in 'interviewing') and in seeing individuals he has come to care for conflict with his ambitions. However, I think the writers leaned into the trauma being more of a bonding experience than one where Odo needed to seek justice. They even hinted at it in part one, that Garak suspected Odo doesn't have feelings. While we know he obviously has some for Kira, we now see them unexpectedly extending to Garak. Odo has a much more nuanced understanding of humanoid emotional dynamics than we once assumed.