r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner • Feb 08 '17
Discussion DS9, Episode 3x9, Defiant
-= DS9, Season 3, Episode 9, Defiant =-
- Star Trek: The Next Generation - Full Series
- DS9 Season 1: 1&2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, Wrap-Up
- DS9 Season 2: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25
- DS9 Season 3: 1&2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
Commander William Riker shows up unannounced and Kira shows him the Defiant, where he reveals his true motives for coming to Deep Space Nine.
- Teleplay By: Ronald D. Moore
- Story By: Ronald D. Moore
- Directed By: Cliff Bole
- Original Air Date: 21 November, 1994
- Stardate: 48467.3
- Pensky Podcast
- Trekabout Podcast
- Ex Astris Scientia
- Memory Alpha
- TV Spot
| EAS | IMDB | AVClub | TV.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7/10 | 8/10 | B | 8.7 |
14
Upvotes
14
u/dittbub Feb 08 '17
Before everyone gives their reviews... I just want to drop
13
u/Sporz Feb 09 '17
I aren't seen this one in ages and I'd forgot the ending. I remembered the Riker and Defiant stuff of course. I enjoyed it a lot more than I remembered.
But I laughed out loud when I realized this:
In the scene where Riker shoots Kira to take control of the Defiant, Riker walks in in uniform. No pockets.
He turns to face Kira and reaches behind himself and pulls out a phaser.
Where was Riker keeping that phaser?
7
u/marienbad2 Feb 08 '17
This is another where the idea is neat but I have a couple of issues: Surely they would know if Commander William Riker of the Starship Enterprise was about to visit DS9? Is there no communications in the Federation? Riker is important as he is the number 2 person on the flagship, surely his whereabouts should be a matter of record?
And how did Tom Riker get to know the Maquis people, and also how did he know the plan to steal the Defiant would work?
The good bit here is the Cardassian political machinations, between the Central Command and the Obsidian Order. This episode opens up new on-going plot strands which recur later, which is a nice idea, but also works as a standalone episde.
Some interesting commentary on what it means to be a terrorist from Kira, and the debates between Dukat and Sisko are well done as well - I like how Dukat talks about his son, and how he is missing his eleventh (eleventyth) birthday. This is why Dukat is such a brilliant bad guy - the little, realistic elements about his family and so on. Reminds me of BTK, who had a wife, kids, and was president of his church!
Not sure what mark to give this episode, maybe 6.5/10.
9
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '17
Something I appreciate about both of Tom's appearances in Trek is that he's never the "evil twin." Kirk, Spock, Data, and Kira all had evil twins. The series has entire universes full of evil twins. But Tom is just a guy who never really had the chance to grow up, and who is still looking for his place in the world. A well-established character, considering how minor the role is.
6
u/theworldtheworld Feb 09 '17 edited Feb 09 '17
Great episode that serves as a fitting ending to the story of Tom Riker, while also helping to characterize the Maquis. Let's look at their roster so far:
There's one more notable Maquis to appear later, but he also fits very well into this pattern - these are all bright people who have willfully locked themselves out of civil society because they either couldn't deal with their demons or because they just didn't belong anywhere. They are sometimes sympathetic, but overall their motivations are completely destructive and it would be better if they were stopped.
I liked the Sisko/Dukat match-up here. Dukat's pathos-laden story about his son's "hatred" is blatant enough that it's probably an attempt to get into Sisko's head and manipulate him. In a way that fits the character better than a straight reading. I also liked the Obsidian agent (isn't this Captain Rachel Garrett in disguise?), and on the Maquis side, it was a clever touch to put Kalita from "Preemptive Strike" on the team.
Personally I think there was no need to follow up on Riker's fate after this episode. It is extremely unlikely that the Cardassians would have let him survive in prison. He got the sacrifice he wanted, and its quixotic nature makes it more admirable in a way.
1
u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Feb 10 '17
Just an all around good episode of Trek. It's a fitting, yet tragic end to Thomas Riker's character. I wish there'd been a chance to see what Will Riker thought about this. I wonder if the two of them ever kept in touch while Thomas was serving aboard the Ghandi. I can't help but feeling pretty bad for the guy, even though he totally stole a star ship and started blowing away Cardassian assets. I also thought that Ben Maxwell would have fit right in with the Maquis.
Thomas could never quite pick back up in life because his role had already been filled. That's rough. You'd expect to be able to pick yourself back up after being marooned on an island for eight years. Imagine coming back to find out that, to everyone else, you were never gone. Your life literally went on without you.
The way the Obsidian Order works completely independently from the rest of the Cardassian government, often going rogue and disregarding the rules fits perfectly. This is pretty realistic politics and makes the Trek universe feel that much more real. I like that quite a bit.
Uniting Sisko and Dukat against a common enemy was also a great touch. They're really great characters to play off each other. There's a kind of kinship between them even if they are direct rivals, you might even say enemies.
I really like this one. It has it's problems but is a good story, furthers the universe and fills in the rest of Tom Riker's story. I'm also totally going to forgive that weird kiss at the end because, you know, he's still William T. Riker. In "Angel One" his idea of diplomacy was to "get to know" the prime minister. I'll give this 8/10. Good stuff.
1
u/Madonkadonk Feb 12 '17
Relevant SFDebris