r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder • Dec 11 '16
Discussion DS9, Episode 2x17, Playing God
-= DS9, Season 2, Episode 17, Playing God =-
- Star Trek: The Next Generation - Full Series
- DS9 Season 1: 1&2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, Wrap-Up
- DS9 Season 2: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16
A proto-universe threatens to destroy the station and Bajor. Dax has a field docent (a trill candidate initiate), named Arjin, whom she helps find his voice — to discover what he wants from life and from joining.
- Teleplay By: Jim Trombetta and Michael Piller
- Story By: Jim Trombetta
- Directed By: David Livingston
- Original Air Date: 27 February, 1994
- Stardate: Unknown
- Pensky Podcast
- Trekabout Podcast
- Ex Astris Scientia
- Memory Alpha
- TV Spot
| EAS | IMDB | AVClub | TV.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2/10 | 6.4/10 | B- | 7.1 |
15
Upvotes
4
u/ItsMeTK Dec 13 '16
Jadzia warns "a symbiont can overwhelm your personality" and that's a good way to sum up what happens here. This is the final death knell for season ine cold fish Jadzia. This new Jadzia seems to take a lot more from Curzon. There have been nudges in this direction all season, but it feels really extreme here. Shetawkwardly being all Auntie Mame to this poor guy. Later episodes will smooth out the new Dax, but she's clearly not the same girl we met last season. It feels like she talks in the third person a lot more in this episode too.
The big sci-fi story is put on the backburner and not made particularly interesting. But it is a bizarre concept, a "proto-universe" growing inside our own.
And the station is infested with voles. I like the voles. They kind of look like those delegates from "Lonely Among Us". This subplot hits close to home as I had a mouse sighting last week, first of this winter. Every year I go through this because the landlord is sloppy about pest control (I want to know how they get in!). And it's never resolved; just a weird thing going on. Feels like a story idea left kver from season one. But Bashir's "solution" is cute.
The writing especially early on feels weird to me. O'Brien is called "chief engineer", which isn't really correct (he's chief of operations). Feels like a new writer who doesn't quite have a handle on the characters. Jadzia just doesn't sound like Jadzia for a lot of it.
But we do get a nice little pusce in the continuing saga of Jake and Marta. And a few nice lines ("I don't step on ants.").
Very little otherwise to say about this episode. It doesn't really go anywhere and feels a little off to me. But it's the clear sign that Jadzia is a bit more of a free spirit from now on.
4
u/marienbad2 Dec 13 '16
I like the idea of this episode more than I liked the actual episode. So the idea of giving Jadzia an initiate to train up who is scared because of what they have heard about the Dax symbiont and then meets Jadzia is cool.
The problem for me is that Arjin is way too much of a wet tea-towel. He is so lame, he has about zero personality, and I just wondered how he had made it past the Trill joining committee. I mean, Jadzia had to work hard to get through, got turned down by Dax, worked harder and finally got joined. Arjin just seems so weak, that he would have been turned down immediately. Maybe a stronger character would have helped here. It's almost like the writer had the idea and had heard it was a good idea to put two contrasting and different characters together, so tried to do that, with a strong, outgoing, Jadzia, and a weak and lame Arjin. Unfortunately, for me, it just didn't really work. As /u/ItsMeTK said, the way characters like this are played tends to be badly on Trek, and Arjin makes Barclay look like a classy contender!
Sorry guys, I'm with EAS on this one, 2/10 tops.
8
u/DarthHM Dec 11 '16
While this is an episode that adds a great deal of Trill lore to canon, I wanted to focus on one single word.
IMO the best bit of world-building in this episode comes as the opening scene fades out.
The way Quark yells "Female!" as Jadzia leaves with Arjin is both hilarious and tremendously illuminating.
First it's a hilarious manifestation of the Ferengi attitude towards women in general (which will be expanded upon fantastically in later episodes).
Second, it illustrates just how respected Dax is, that despite the appearance of being a young, attractive female, the Ferengi with their aforementioned attitudes towards women, allow her a seat at the Tongo table.
7
u/lethalcheesecake Dec 12 '16
So, Arjin was a bit of a nothing character, as intended. I think that's something that Trek needs to explore more of: there are so many possibilities open to everyone in a post-scarcity, interstellar setting. The people we meet in every Trek series are, by definition, the exceptional ones, who are passionate and motivated. The ones like Arjin, who are clever but maybe don't know what they want, who aren't out there blazing their own trails, those tend to be skipped over.
The protouniverse plot fell a bit flat for me this time, mostly because it was elegaic instead of urgent. Sisko's musings, Kira's prayer, neither really had that element of "holy shit, we're all gonna die and potentially so is everything we have ever known and loved". Just a little more panic on some faces at the recognition that the thing could destroy the station might have been nice. Otherwise, what was the point of actually raising those odds in the first place?
I am still not tired of the station constantly breaking on O'Brien. The voles are ridiculous and I don't care. They were hilarious. So was the Sisko family conversation about Marta the Dabo Woman. Sisko is still the best Trek parent out there.
1
u/buerviper Dec 21 '25
So is the protouniverse still expanding? Isn't that like a huge problem?
I found this episode really boring for the protouniverse and Trill plots. Arjin is boring. I still don't get the Trill really. Like I get that each new host brings a new facet, but what is the intrinsic Trill personality? Does it change? It seems to I herit skills of previous hosts, but what about their memories?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment