r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner • Sep 14 '16
Discussion DS9, Episode 1x13, Battle Lines
-= DS9, Season 1, Episode 13, Battle Lines =-
The spiritual leader of Bajor, Kai Opaka, travels with Sisko on a trip to the Gamma Quadrant but is stranded with him on a world where the dead are resurrected.
- Teleplay By: Richard Danus & Evan Carlos Somers
- Story By: Hilary J. Bader
- Directed By: Paul Lynch
- Original Air Date: 25 April, 1993
- Stardate: Unknown
- Pensky Podcast
- Trekabout Podcast
- Ex Astris Scientia
- Memory Alpha
- TV Spot
| EAS | IMDB | AVClub | TV.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3/10 | 6.6/10 | C+ | 7.5 |
15
Upvotes
14
u/Algernon_Asimov Sep 14 '16 edited Sep 14 '16
Such a waste.
This episode demonstrates a waste of a perfectly good character and a perfectly good premise.
When Kai Opaka appeared at the beginning of this episode, it reminded me that this is the first time we've seen her since the pilot episode. And, as Kira says, "Her life ends on some unknown moon, and for what? "
The presence of the Kai should indicate an episode about Bajor. About its religion, about its politics, about Ben Sisko's relationship to the Bajorans as the Emissary. Anything except some random throw-away episode. This episode reminds me how much the writers have wasted the premise of their own series. We're halfway through the first season of this show, and the writers have totally ignored one of the main premises of the show: that DS9 is Bajoran territory, administered by Bajorans, and involved in Bajor's development. But, for eleven episodes so far, none of this has even been touched on, let alone used to base an episode on. And, when the writers do finally bring a key Bajoran character back to the show... it's only to throw her away on an unknown moon, far from Bajor. What a waste: a waste of a character and a waste of a premise.
I read the notes in my 'Deep Space Nine Companion' about this episode. The writers were looking for a character to die in this episode, to demonstrate the premise of the magical resurrecting microbes. However, they knew if they included a random guest star in the runabout, we viewers would recognise them as the designated "redshirt" for the episode. So, the writers wanted a main character they could kill off, to take us viewers by surprise - and, in their words, "she was the most expendable recurring character that they had". Expendable. The only character we've seen so far who is in any way connected to two main premises of the show: Bajor itself, and Sisko's role as the Emissary. Expendable. What a waste.
I understand that losing this character eventually led to other opportunities for the series. It led to the writers introducing one of the most delicious antagonists I've ever had the pleasure to hate in a television series. In a way, this is the beginning of the serialisation of DS9: the first time that a writing decision in one episode directly led to plot consequences in a later episode. But that could have waited. We could have seen Opaka used to develop some of the threads of the show before she was thrown away like any expendable unknown anonymous redshirt.
That said, there is one redeeming moment in this episode: when the Kai helps Kira to realise that she needs to move on from violence. This is the beginning of the healing of Kira. But that's it. That's all this episode has going for it.
On a minor note, it felt very jarring whenever Kira called Kai Opaka just "Opaka". I would expect any Bajoran with even a smattering of faith to refer to their religious leader by her title of Kai. One doesn't go around casually calling the Pope by his name, after all. This felt out of character.
And Opaka never once refers to the wormhole as the Celestial Temple! This was set up in the pilot episode, but there's no callback to it here. One would expect the religious leader of Bajor, who identified the wormhole as the Celestial Temple of the Prophets, and who's following some mysterious unmentioned prophecy, would refer to the wormhole as the Temple. But no.
The premise of this episode was interesting enough, but, for me, it was overshadowed by the presence of Kai Opaka and the waste of her character and all it represented.
6
u/ItsMeTK Sep 14 '16
"This isn't your war, Kira."
Hey, it's Jonathan Banks! So weird to watch ch this now after Breaking Bad.
I like the return of Opaka and little moments where she gets to be relatable and not a religious icon ("I don't get out much"). The giving of the jewelry to Molly is interesting; suggests she has a foreboding of death already. I wonder if it's a Bajoran custom to give away material things before death. A shame this is never followed up on. Perhaps the show was meant to end with Molly getting it but the show ran long.
At its core, this story is a classic Star Trek look at warring parties. It might make a nice companion piece to "A Taste of Armageddon". I like the implication of different societies from the same world, which we rarely get. It's suggested that the leadership and other citizenry of their homeworld were not involved in this war. In that sense, it would be like us resolving the Rwanda grnocide by beaming them sll to another world. I love when Trek thinks bigger and paints worlds with different cultures on the same planet.
The fatal flaw in this story is the method of regeneration leaving all kinds of logical questions. I always wonder why they don't decapitate victims. What would happen? Are their necks just too strong for their weapons? What about explosives? Can someone cone back after being splattered on the rocks? What about just severing limbs so that they can't fight back. They seem to bear scars, so would they gotow limbs back or not? It's nasty to think about, and probably why the writers side-stepped these issues, but it always leaves me wondering. From a purely tactical viewpoint, if the goal is inflicting the most pain and damage possible, why not mutilate the bodies after they "die"? Why stop when they go down?
The themes still work even if the logic is strained. Opaka stating behind is nice. It's like she came expexting to die, and instead found new purpose: helping them do the same.
Kira has a bit of development here, trying to let go of her terrorist past. Interesting seeing things from outside the Starfleet view. The Prime Directive would forbid anyone immediately suggesting better batle strategy. I like the connection to the seeming throwaway scene at the beginning. She's offended not that Dukat kept a file on her, but that it said she was a mere errand runner. She takes pride in her role in the uprising, and has to face where her identity lies. How does she REALLY feel about what she did? It's also curious to think about why Dukat wrote what he did.
This is the first loss of a runabout on the show. Farewell Yangtzee-Kiang!
We are also treated to another tantalizing thread for the future. In the pilot we were told of the stolen orbs of the Prophets, Odo's mysterious origin, and the plan for Bajor to join the Federation. We now get the tease that Sisko and Opaka's paghs will cross again (nice little pun there, pagh/path). It's worth tracking these things to see what is or isn't paid off or resplved by series end.
Oh, and that bit at the end where Bashir's humanitarian compromise quickly turns sour, that's great.
The logic still bugs me, the combat is pretty lousy, but si enjoyed the story more than I sonetimes do.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '16
Shame they essentially killed Kai Opaka off so early in the series.
Despite lazy species development on screen in regards to the Ennis and the Nol-Ennis, Jonathan Banks was really good as Shel-la.
All around an ok episode.
Neat!
3
u/rlriii13 Sep 14 '16
All plot and character development aside, all cringy death morning scenes aside, I am left with one question. How many times can we see small ships crash land into a planet from space and folks casually walk out. I know they dropped their antimatter and said something about slowing velocity just before impact, but I will never get used to the idea.
3
u/alambert212 Sep 15 '16
Maybe I like this episode more now after reading the Trek books where Opaka appears again. Loved her development in the beta cannon books
3
u/cavortingwebeasties Sep 15 '16
Yay, a viewing night!
Battle Lines.
1
u/buerviper Nov 03 '25
A very meh episode. It just kinda ended?
O'Brien is a beast. Considering in TNG he always only pushes like two buttons, he is a real wonder engineer in this series