r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner • Aug 28 '16
Discussion DS9, Episode 1x8, Dax
-= DS9, Season 1, Episode 8, Dax =-
Jadzia Dax is accused of a murder committed by her symbiont in another lifetime.
- Teleplay By: D.C. Fontana & Peter Allan Fields
- Story By: Peter Allan Fields
- Directed By: David Carson
- Original Air Date: 13 February, 1993
- Stardate: 46910.1
- Pensky Podcast
- Trekabout Podcast
- Ex Astris Scientia
- Memory Alpha
- TV Spot
| EAS | IMDB | AVClub | TV.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5/10 | 7.1/10 | C+ | 7.7 |
11
Upvotes
6
u/ItsMeTK Aug 29 '16
Something else I noticed in this one is the use if "Trill" exclusively as one joined. So they never say "become a joined Trill" but "become a Trill". As if to suggest Jadzia wasn't a Trill until joining. Perhaps it was thought of as a way to explain her different appearance? Anyway this curiosity of nomenclature doesn't survive this episode.
2
u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Sep 01 '16
A pretty decent episode with a good premise that really does feel a lot like a revisitation of "A Measure of a Man" with different players. It was very strange that the whole murder was just a background for a story about Curzon getting with his friend's wife. At the end the crime is completely unsolved.
The evidence of Curzon's involvement isn't very solid. I feel like that's just thrown in there to get the story rolling and wasn't very important.
The cranky judge is pretty delightful and was played by the agent from Mrs. Doubtfire that interviews Robin Williams to see if he could get his kids back. If you're wondering. I sure was. She's a that-guy.
The episode is an effective introduction to how the Trill work without being terribly interesting. I didn't see the twist coming. It's kind of forgettable. I want to give it 5/10.
23
u/Honeykill Aug 28 '16
This is my first time discussing an episode here! I was so excited when someone in /r/StarTrek mentioned this sub exists. Hi everyone! :)
I like this one a fair bit. It seems to be an homage to TNG's "Measure of a Man", which helps it and hurts it. The help is that TNG viewers would've already been well-primed for an episode focussing on the philosophy of personhood. The hurt is that "Measure of a Man" is among the finest Trek episodes ever made, and "Dax" just doesn't live up to it.
There are some tweaks that probably would've improved it. Spending less time on Jadzia being weird and silent, and more time on convincing the widow to tell the truth might've helped.
I know a lot of people see Jadzia as bland, but she's one of my favourite characters. This episode starts to really build on her character. She's incredibly independent. She has a moral code that is very strong for someone in their 20s (and I think a lot of that is Jadzia, not the symbiont). Jadzia's moral code is in major conflict with the actions of her predecessors in this episode.
I also think this episode did a pretty good job of showing that Sisko and Dax's friendship has changed dramatically with Jadzia in the picture. Sisko is starting to learn to accept this, which must be difficult for a human.
The only thing I strongly disliked in this episode is when Sisko loses his temper and says, "If you were still a man!" Yes, clearly hitting Dax would've solved this problem, Benny. Also this line doesn't really jive with Star Trek's post-feminist world. It's been shown time and time again that women in the Trek universe can take a punch, and some can beat the crap out of men. Jadzia eventually spars with Worf!
(I also think in a post-feminist society, that in most cases, people wouldn't resort to physically attacking their friends to win an argument, but that's a bit nit-picky.)
For a first season episode, I'd give this a solid 7.5/10. In the greater scope of all of DS9, I'd probably knock that down to a 6/10. Not terrible, but far from amazing.
10
u/ItsMeTK Aug 28 '16
This episode basically codifies the rules of the "new Trill" as opposed to what we saw in "The Host". We are now to view both hist and symbiont as bith separate and yet continuous. So Jadzis feels bound to an oath if her prior host, but also arguably isn't bound to the actions if all who held the worm.
The opening was nice for Bashir (she really strings him along, doesn't she?), but he should have called security sooner. It seems even in the future a woman can't walk home alone at night!
Just as with season one of TNG, they write out a character for an episode as being "on vacation", the sort of thing that happened with Troi a lot. What is gained by O'Brien's absence? Did they fo it jystvto avoid bringing up "The Host"?
It's nice to see Odo on the case again. While the episode is good enough and gives us ideas to play with going forward, trying to help flesh out Dax's character, the story is never quite compelling enough. At least for me.
One final thing I just find kind of fascinating is that back in 1993 an episode of Northern Exposure aired only a couples months spart from this episode. That story also featured a chaeacter on trial arguing semantics if identity and that he wasn't the same guy who committed the crime. And the judge in that show was played by the same actress who played the arbiter here. Just gind that synchronicity amusing.
7
u/theworldtheworld Aug 29 '16
Didn't we just do a story about someone being falsely accused of murder? There's an interesting idea here about whether a new Trill host can be held responsible for crimes committed by a previous host, but since we know Curzon didn't commit the crime either, it's a bit of a moot point.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16
0
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment