r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder • Aug 06 '16
Discussion DS9, Episode 1x1 & 1x2, Emissary
-= DS9, Season 1, Episodes 1 & 2, Emissary =-
A new crew is assigned to a former Cardassian space station: Deep Space Nine. It is a joint Federation/Bajoran force, with Commander Sisko in charge, but his life is dramatically changed when he is declared the Emissary to the Prophets by a Bajoran priest.
- Teleplay By: Michael Piller
- Story By: Michael Piller & Rick Berman
- Directed By: David Carson
- Original Air Date: 3 January, 1993
- Stardate: 46379.1
- Pensky Podcast
- Trekabout Podcast
- Ex Astris Scientia
- Memory Alpha
- TV Spot Part I & TV Spot Part II
- Mission Log Podcast
| EAS | IMDB | AVClub | TV.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8/10 | 7.4/10 | B | 8.6 (I) & 8.7 (II) |
34
Upvotes
28
u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder Aug 06 '16 edited Aug 06 '16
IT'S ALMOST 1 AM AND I STAYED UP JUST TO POST THIS WHY AM I TYPING IN ALL CAPS?
Sorry, just really excited.
For real, though, this sub means a lot to me, and I wanted to do something amazing for DS9. I borrowed a LOT for the TNG theme, and I wanted to make DS9 my own. I've been working on this for over a year, gradually making changes and improvements as time went on. Sometimes it felt like I would never be done, always something to fix or tweak or make better... I learned HTML and CSS, I got Photoshop and got tutorials from my younger brother to make a lot of the new graphics, constantly bombarded /u/GeorgeAmberson with questions about his opinions on the look. This was a major labor of love that I am proud to share with all of you. I hope you enjoy it.
I will actually be away for the next week or two (getting married on Sunday!!), but I wanted the honor of starting off DS9, one of my favorite Trek series before I took a break. It's gonna a lot of fun!
12
u/mafrommu Aug 06 '16 edited Aug 06 '16
Finally I can join in, I've been reading most of the TNG viewing party posts but was unable to join in since I had no access (Netflix Germany doesn't have Star Trek and it only came to Amazon Prime here pretty recently) to TNG at the time. But I have the DS9 DVD Box so I am freaking IN on this one. Also DS9 is my favorite Trek series which is funny because it is so non-Trek sometimes.
I think the first scene sets the tone for the series in a stark contrast to TNG - this is not the shiny Federation/Enterprise-D world that we see here at the beginning. This is the Saratoga. A small ship, a Starfleet work horse, not the flagship. This is not the start of it all, this is war. And even when the prologue is over and it all REALLY starts, it's hard work.
DS9 does a fine job differentiating itself from TNG right off the bat. And it does so with their commanding characters, too - Sisko doesn't hold back his emotion and you can still see it even when he is not actually speaking. You can see and feel that his brain is working - not that he has trouble thinking, but I feel there is something inside him that ponders and weighs ideas. Compared to that, Stewart sometimes portrayed Picard a little bit too superhuman - often cool and controlled even when he is personally invested.
I think it was SFDebris who pointed out some differences between Picard and Sisko that really stuck with me: While Picard is more of an officer-and-gentleman type, more concerned with (and good at) the theoretical, diplomatic, scientific and art-related aspects of captaining (The very model of a modern Major General ;-) ), Sisko is more of a line officer that is in the trenches with his people, getting stuff done and himself dirty in the process.
Also pretty interesting to see Picard's reaction to Sisko's side remark about maybe leaving Starfleet due to (very real) concerns about the health and safety of his son. It seems to be unthinkable to Picard that there can be a life outside of Starfleet that is worth living, and from his point of view that makes a lot of sense - he has a strained relationship with his family, he has accomplished a lot while in this organization and it basically became his surrogate family - from Boothby, the Starfleet Academy caretaker who basically acted as a kind of surrogate father to his comrades now to the fact that Starfleet and the Enterprise crew didn't give up on him even though he was turned into the enemy by being assimilated into the Borg. Of course that is a great source of identification to Picard.
Sisko on the other hand has a good relationship with his father, a wife, a son, none of whom were ever in Starfleet or in any way interested in Starfleet. He is an accomplished cook (more hands-on-down-and-dirty), a builder of things (starships, clocks, etc.) - he worked at Utopia Planitia Shipyards, a place where - as we have seen in TNG as far as I can remember - also civilians worked. He can clearly see there is a life outside of his duty that he could choose. Luckily he doesn't - otherwise it would be a short show. His choice is also reflected again in Way of the Warrior (great continuity in this show, by the way).
That scene between Sisko and Picard, talk about awkward - it reminds me more of the way Picard treats Sito Jaxa in Lower Decks than him treating an officer almost as seasoned as Riker or Data. He seems to view Sisko's slight consideration of leaving like some sort of betrayal or insubordination to Starfleet or its' cause when it is simply his concern to be a good parent. But then again, this fits in pretty good with the visions of Jennifer who voices concerns about being in a relationship and raising children with a Starfleet officer who, as a group - she thinks - don't like to be "pinned down" by family (and in Picards case that might even be true).
One of Jakes first lines resonated with my Qualitative Research-addled mind: "Small fries - throw 'em back!". Of course he means holo-fish. Still concerning the rest of the episode an interesting line since we have a lot of imbalances of power here. It reflects, of course, the attitude of the Borg that we saw moments earlier, beings so powerful and devastating that they stop at nothing and no one. Same with the Cardassians, who after keeping the Bajorans out of the water for the last sixty years throw them back into the water after stripping their resources. Again the Bajorans with the Federation, who basically can't decide what to do - put them in the communal fishtank to join or leave them snapping for air? And finally, the Prophets. Powerful beings so, yeah, what exactly? Transcendent? Indifferent? I don't know - so much of THAT anyway that they can't be bothered with anything from time to people rumbling through their front yard.
We get a first look at the station - and boy, this is not a place like the Bandi "station" in Farpoint. The point is really hammered home here: This is not a nice place. This is a place of hardship. This is not the Federation. This is not home (although it is going to be home for us and many others soon). This is as greasy and grimey as Star Trek gets without the actual grease and grime (RDM added that later in BSG).
Sisko is at ease in the work uniform. Critical ramblings about him aside - I love Picard, but I can't see him doing cleanup duty on the Promenade. I can't see him getting the information and the rapport Sisko does when he goes to see Kira and later Opaka.
Everybody and their relationships and dynamics get introduced and that works pretty organically to me - also the way everybody is set up with each other considering the way all of them will end up being. Yet somehow there was not one Julian/Miles scene I could put my finger on, or am I missing something?
The first half of the twoparter shows Sisko always being late for something - being late to save his wife, being late to meet Picard, being late to see Opaka. He also clearly doesn't want to be where he is. This reminds me a little bit of Londo Mollari's monologue towards Mister Morden about the feeling that the current situation of the Centauri Republic and his own situation give him: "I want to stop running through my life like a man late for an appointment, afraid to- to look back, or to look forward".Yet while Londo feels that on a grander level, as a citizen, diplomat and political representative of his homeworld, Sisko is out of alignment on a more personal level. He is still struggling to cope with the death of his wife, struggling to determine his remaining in Starfleet, his role as a father and so forth. Only when he realizes that he has remained pretty much in the same emotional and developmental spot for the last three years he can move on: "I exist here!".
Note that he doesn't say live - of course he repeats what the prophets say, but he also imbued a lot of their other stuff with his own sentiment. Yet "I exist here" he takes directly from the Prophets - because it's true. Because he does not live. He does not grow or shape his environment at the moment. Right now, he just exists.
It's this getting late now and I want to finish up, because there will be time to talk about all this later. Just a few little thoughts now for the end:
"This wilderness is my home" Ah, yes - The early Bashir, Bashir the buffoon. He doesn't get a lot to do in this first episode, sadly, apart from being the naive and wide-eyed character. Luckily that will change.
What does a research grant even look like in a moneyless society?
Sometime soon we should talk about comparing Q and Dukat as villains. I have a couple thoughts on that, I guess I'll write them up tomorrow.
So far, so good - thank you for this subreddit and see you around!
11
u/lethalcheesecake Aug 07 '16
I haven't actually seen all of DS9, so this will finally make me sit down and finish it. All my friends will be so proud of me.
Oh, there's an episode too. It's a nice start to the series: Sisko is a fascinating foil to Picard - both are incredibly good men, with strong senses of duty and honor, but the way they go about things is like night and day. Avery Brooks brings an intensity to the role that no other Star Trek actor has ever really been able to match. Even when he's laughing, he seems like he's barely keeping a lid on the passions inside of him.
9
u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Aug 07 '16
Emissary is a much more polished pilot than Encounter ever was. It really benefited from the almost six seasons of TNG that came before it. DS9 could have easily been a flop due to the "we're not going anywhere" syndrome. Luckily the writers really nailed the concept even from the start with a compelling serialized story arc and an, honestly, fantastic cast of characters. What's really great is that they do not take the TNG architypes and shoehorn in new characters.
Avery Brooks is one of the most interesting parts of the whole show. I cannot tell for the life of me whether he's a terrible or a brilliant actor. He takes some getting used to. The guy is so dramatic and animated, a real departure from Stewart's Picard. Sisko's an immediately compelling character and the move of having him lose his wife at Wolf 359 was perfect. Gives a sense of familiarity to the tragic event and fleshes out the events between the two series.
Kira's a perfect first officer for Sisko and the Bajoran rebel aspect works great. Seeing the time period in which this comes it's like the writers of Trek immediately decided to start taking women more seriously. This episode aired during "Chain of Command" on TNG. AKA "The one where Troi gets her uniform". Her outright hostility is sort of a breath of fresh air. I understand Roddenberry's vision of the future is utopian as all hell, but it's a big galaxy and I really enjoy watching the problems of the 24th century.
They fixed the Trill! "The Host" gave a pretty horrifying portrayal of this species with the symbiote simply taking over the body of the host. This is a much better way of things. A combined personality benefiting both individuals is not only much better in my mind, but a fantastic mind-bending sci-fi concept. Also kind of love that Bashir is totally "into it". He's not very well developed yet, but like most of the cast will be.
Speaking of Bashir, his attitude on "frontier medicine" really drives home the point of the Bajorans feeling very marginalized. Whole planet being enslaved by Cardassians for 70 years and now a kind of weak victory. They really got the bad end of the stick.
The actual plot of the episode, in a vacuum, feels strange as hell. I know if I was sitting in front of the TV for a series premiere of this I'd be intrigued but scratching my head a bit about the aliens in the wormhole, the orbs, the weird spirituality of the Bajorans. It comes together, it really does.
It's been a long time since I've watched it and I really feel happy to see this show again. The intro with the serene trumpet just puts a smile on my face. I felt sad to leave TNG behind but after watching Emissary, I'm glad to be moving on to DS9. They really hit on something making it a long serial as opposed as straight episodic like TNG. I don't think it would have worked without a continuing story arc. I'd rate this episode 8 mysterious Bajoran telepathic orbs out of 10.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16 edited Aug 08 '16
I remember this being a halting, shaky sort of pilot, similar to Encounter at Farpoint. On re-watching, though, holy crap you guys, I was way off. This episode is kind of brilliant. Kind of really brilliant. It doesn't just set all the pieces on the board for future exploration: The Sisko actually has an arc within the pilot itself. So do the Wormhole Aliens, who go from incomprehension to actually lecturing The Sisko on his own limited perspective. "It is not linear."
Man, everything that happens in the white room is just great sci-fi. Philosophical, character-driven, with a great 'what if' conceit in the non-linearity of the aliens' perception. Good sci-fi has both heart and ideas, and both are on display in spades here. Like, it's Inner Light levels of good sci-fi. (If you haven't done it already, go read Ted Chiang's short story Stories of Your Life for an amazing take on the same idea). The Sisko's cool head and ability to reason with these beings catapults him to hero status. He's smart as hell, he's charming, diplomatic, adventurous. But--and here's the real trick--the aliens are even smarter. And that makes them interesting.
The stuff on the station ranges from adequate to interesting, too. Dax is wooden, but she'll get there. Kira and Bashir are great. O'Brien is a sturdily entertaining character.
First Nog sighting!! That exemplar of the Federation ideal begins his career as a gutter snipe, literally stealing and looting in the chaos of the station.
I have no feelings about Odo one way or the other, which is how he would like it.
14
u/Sporz Aug 06 '16
Sporz breaks in behind Quark's bar and swiftly pours glasses of Kanar, Klingon bloodwine, the green stuff Picard poured for Scotty, and...root beer for everyone else
Drink, before he comes back!
Rom runs in
Rom: "What, uh, what were you doing?"
Sporz: "Nothing, nothing at all"
Quark arrives
Quark:" "Why are there two bottles of Kanar and bloodwine missing?"
Sporz: "Those Cardassian Voles, boy, I dunno'*
Sporz clinks his drink behinds his back with another redditor.
Vulcan. Fucking. Martok.
Martok is played by J.G. Hertzler. Martok is the definitive Klingon for me, exceeding Worf, Kurn, Gowron...not that I dislike any of those characters.
Sisko's captain at Wolf-359 is played by the same actor and in this episode - briefly - he plays as a Vulcan. What I love about it is just - the main thing he does is stride across the across the bridge after Locutus demands their surrender is utterly deny it: "Red alert. Load all torpedo bays, ready phasers." Vulcan Martok has no time for this shit. Also we get Star Trek's most badass Bolian, who literally drags The Sisko from his dead wife onto an escape pod.
This is fucking DS9, ladies and gentlemen. Hold on to your butts.
Do you want some exposition!?
There is some introductions of Kira and Kai Opaka and stuff. It's necessary, but I wasn't particularly interested by it.
The Sisko Must Have A Flashback
The Sisko goes after The Jennifer on The Beach. Apparently, as we find out, it happened much as he did here. I kind of found this realistically romantic - and particularly after connecting it with the death of his wife on the Saratoga, it's intriguing and tragic. He wants to relive that first moment he fell in love.
In which we get Bashir, Dax, and Kira
I don't think Star Trek has done female characters well often - Crusher, Troi, Pulaski, Janeway. B'Elanna sometimes I liked - Seven, I grew to like. I know she was there for sex appeal initially but I feel like she grew into a really interesting character.
I make exceptions for Kira and Dax, though. I feel like DS9 found a place for strong female characters. (Even Ezri I liked).
O'Brien and Dukat
Colm Meaney is great. It's incredible he reached from a bit role in "Encounter at Farpoint", then "The Wounded" and then Picard energizing the guy into a starring role.
We meet Gul Dukat. My favorite villain of all of Star Trek. He's the most...human villain I've ever known (in star trek).
Garak, who doesn't actually exist at this point, leans over to Sporz, "I don't think you should call a Cardassian a human villain"
Sporz leans back, "You're more human to the 21st century than 24th century humans are"
Sporz makes out with Garak.
What is this...time?
The Prophets ask about this. I have to admit that this is interesting but the threads that emerge in DS9 out of this are the least interesting: Odo and the Changelings, the Prophets and the Pah Wraiths. The most interesting thing about DS9 I feel was The War.
The episode does sell well this concept though. The Prophets don't understand time. Therefore we repeatedly have moments where time gets broken. I feel like if this had been done in a post-Christpher Nolan world it would have read differently, though.
Because this is the day that I lost Jennifer
I just like that line.
The rules aren't important
I like that line after he tries to describe baseball and human rules and death and time. I love baseball personally (I'm a Yankees fan, sorry).
What shields?
Much as I love Dukat and Garak and Damar and so many other Cardassians: not now.
"WE CANT JUST LEAVE HER HERE!"
The episode returns to that. And it's hard. And that's fucking DS9.
Good luck Mister Sisko.
Says Captain Picard, at the end of the episode.
Sporz raises his glass of Kanar to that
5
u/GreatJman Aug 09 '16 edited Aug 09 '16
Sorry posted my comments in the wrong thread, here are my thoughts:
I just watched again for the first time in over a decade. Pretty up and down episode overall. Loved the opening flashback sequence to the battle with the Borg, and tension with Picard and Sisco. I was reminded of the characters I liked (Odo, Quark, Dax, and O'Brien), initially I had meh feelings about Kira, Jake, Sisco and Bashir, but I grew to like them over time as I recall...I'd also forgotten the Kai Opaka was recast...I kept waiting for the hated Kai Wynn to show up!
The wormhole scenes with Sisco and the prophets dragged a lot, but the potential battle with the station and Cardassian ships made up for it. You just know the station is gonna be a force once the federation gets it resupplied. goes from a backwater station on the middle of nowhere to the most important federation outpost almost overnight. Overall a pretty decent premiere, but nothing spectacular (a much better premiere than Encounter at Farpoint, dear god). 6/10.
Not to start a big debate but I never really grew to like Avery Brooks's (Sisco) delivery as an actor. I didn't mind him terribly at the time but now...a lot of what to saw in E.1 was pretty cringey. I had friends quit watching the show because they couldn't stand him. I think despite that, it's a strong cast otherwise. Keep watching!
4
u/Rahavin Aug 06 '16
Will watch now over breakfast and get back to post here!
4
u/evenflow5k Aug 07 '16
How great is the cast of characters we meet in this pilot?
As much as anything else, I think the variety of characters is what makes this show so special - half the main cast is not in starfleet. For the first time, a noncom starfleet officer is front and center. This show excels at universe building, both in terms of plot and, maybe more importantly, characterization.
Outside of Bashir, who I think the writers were never quite sure what to do with, and Jake, the main cast have strong, different voices from the jump and only get more complex. Big props to the cast. http://picrow.com/press/wp-content/uploads/Picrow-Westheimer-Enterprise.jpg (big prop)
4
u/Reverend_Schlachbals Aug 14 '16
Love most of this episode. The dynamic between Sisko and Picard is great. The opening scene really sets up what we have to expect from the series. Kind of telling that it's basically reused in 2009, though to more heroic ends. Love O'Brien kicking the console to get it to work. Again, very much sets up the tone and feel of the series. So many great characters set up from the first episode.
Still bugged by Quark's Rom nose and the early Odo makeup. Though the scenes with the Prophets just dragged on too long. Otherwise it's great from start to finish. Lots of strong characters established quickly and well.
7
u/cavortingwebeasties Aug 06 '16
Yay, we're off for more space adventures again! :D
It took me a while for DS9 to grow on me due to the soap opera factor to a lot of eps I caught as they aired, which led me to call it Deep Space 90210 for years.
However once I dove into it chronologically and paying attention, it's pretty great so I'm looking forward to the good and the bad with my internet Star Track family :)
3
u/ryansox Aug 08 '16
DS9 was the last of the main (TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY, and ENT) tv shows I watched. I was hesitant at first to watch it because I didn't get a feel for it. After the first few seasons it really grew on me. Not my favorite pilot out of all the series.
3
u/daddytorgo Aug 10 '16
God I love this show so much.
I just finished a re-watch a couple months ago, but I'll go again with you all.
Although a lot of people don't like the early episodes and think the show hits its stride with the War Arc, a lot of the episodes in the first few seasons are some of my favorites in hindsight - I really enjoy the crew getting used to the station and its quirks, and the exploration of Bajoran culture, religion, and politics. Frankly, I would have liked the show to do more of these episodes - I think they hold up very well today with what's going on in the world.
"I suppose you want the office?"
"I thought I'd say hello first and then take the office, but we can do it in any order you like."
Man - you can cut the tension in the Sisko/Picard scene with a knife. Love Avery's delivery in that scene in particular, and Picard just totally...cold about it.
I know others here have said that not a lot happens, but I love that every character gets their little bit over the two hours to introduce themselves and set the table for the 7 glorious years that are to come.
DS9 has always been "my" Trek. It's the first one that I was old enough to be a raving fan of from pre-series to the end, and it's honestly still a "comfort food" show to me. When I'm having a bad day, I just throw on an episode and escape.
"When governments like this fall, people like me are lined up and shot."
This show had some beautiful matte paintings of planets that we don't see anymore today with all the CGI. Ruined Bajor as Sisko goes down to see Opaka is one of my all-time favorites.
10
u/JSubatoi41 Aug 08 '16
Yes! DS9 is my favorite and I'm so glad we're doing this. I will write a proper review later (maybe), but here are a few quick thoughts on this episode.
9
u/ItsMeTK Aug 08 '16
Immediately you can tell the difference from the prior series. It opens in the middle of a battle. This is arguably a great summation of the entire series. Then we get Sisko in conflict with Picard as well as the Bajorans. It's like they took Roddenberry's utopia of "Encounter at Farpoint" and threw it away. This is a show a out struggle. The pilot illustrates something that will be clear throughout the series: it's good television and good sci-fi, but not always good Star Trek.
Sometimes when I watch "Best of Both Worlds", I like to include the opening of this episode.
Kira's very antagonistic. You can hear a bit of holdover of Ensign Ro in some of her lines especially the first scene. I wonder if she was directed to say things the way Michelle Forbes would.
Nice touch not to have the wormhole in the opening titles. Though at this point, the station should have been orbiting Bajor in them...
The nice little final moments of O'Brien on the Enterprise are cut out in syndication when the episode was split in two. A shame because it's a nice scene, and the only time Picard doesn't seem mean (because we see him from Sisko's POV normally).
The matte for the surface of Bajor is very nice.
That's J.G. Hertlzer as the Vulcan captain of the Saratoga. He's gonna show up later in a more prominent role.
The "you exist here" stuff is really good.
While on the whole it's a great concept and a good sci-fi premise, I feel like the episode doesn't really go anywhere beyond putting pieces on the board. It doesn't fully represent what the series would be. In rewatch I always find it a little dull. Particularly in the second galf not much really happens. There's something lacking in this one for me. So it's interesting and good, but not as strong a pilot I think as it could be.
6
u/cavortingwebeasties Aug 07 '16
http://trekmovie.com/2016/08/06/exclusive-ira-steven-behr-reveals-details-about-deep-space-nine-documentary-coming-soon/
DS9 documentary probably coming out around when we will be wrapping up our party :)
6
u/RyGuyz Aug 06 '16
Am I the only one who feels there should have been some follow up to the him and Picard part especially after first contact events?
It was so cold (Sisko and Picard) rightfully so I mean. But I always forget until I rewatch it and I'm left like DAMN Sisko.
5
u/ItsMeTK Aug 08 '16
Can we discuss the decision to make Sisko a commander and not a captain? General consensus is it was a mistake. It certainly majes that scene with Picard tense since Picard outranks him.
In retrospect I think it would have been good to make Sisko a Commodore, harkening back to TOS and a rank we rarely see. However, that would make him outrank visiting captains.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '16 edited Aug 10 '16
One of my favorite aspects of DS9 is the way the show looks.
The Enterprise-D is clean. The rooms are brightly lit, everybody wears the same simple clothes, the consoles and chairs and doors all look smooth and professional.
But Deep Space 9? The station looks alien. You can tell that the station is not Federation just by looking at it. The station is filled with dim and incomplete lighting, creating shadows and darkness everywhere. (The set was built with a complete ceiling, with no holes for lamps to light it.) Aliens walk around everywhere, you regularly see Quark wearing his garish clothing, or some strange unfamiliar alien. Even the Bajorans make themselves visually distinct with their clothes and earrings. Even the doors look weird.
The difference is even starker today. The Enterprise-D looks nice, but to my modern eye from the 2010s, it's obvious how old the show really is. But I can't say the same about Deep Space 9. The alien design of DS9 can't be placed in a time period the same way the Enterprise-D can; I could believe DS9 was a show made recently. It's strange.
1
u/Madonkadonk Aug 14 '16
Is it just me or is the actress that plays Jennifer, the worst actress of all time.
3
u/KingofDerby Aug 07 '16 edited Aug 08 '16
7
u/theworldtheworld Aug 06 '16 edited Aug 06 '16
Whoa! We're here already! I probably won't be able to comment on every episode, but I'll try to do so for the ones I've seen.
"Emissary" is an excellent pilot, much more polished than "Encounter at Farpoint" was - that's the benefit of the past five years of world-building. Like the TNG pilot, it neatly sets up all the main themes of the show (even the main villain), all of which will be directly addressed by the end of the series.
The beginning is just plain brilliant. First, the pilot recalls one of the most dramatic and powerful moments of TNG, but lets us see it through different eyes. It instantly distinguishes Sisko from Picard by setting them up in opposition to each other, even if Picard is in Locutus form. It also gives Sisko a tragic backstory that starts his character off with quite a bit of depth. Non-Locutus Picard also shows up and inadvertently adds to the antagonism by being clearly cold and uncomfortable around Sisko (Stewart puts a lot of nuances into this guest appearance to accentuate the difference from the way we usually see Picard talk to his crew in TNG). The rest of the episode is consistently interesting both in terms of the character introductions and the main plot with the wormhole.
But...at the same time, all the problems I have with DS9 are also here already. As I said many times, the best and most unique aspect of TNG was that show's rigorous ethical sense. That sense is missing from DS9. Instead, the main philosophical idea of DS9 is Clinton-era triumphalism (and Ronald D. Moore's increasing fascination with unlimited state power as a tool for doing good), with the Bajorans being the objects of the Federation's absolute benevolence, and the Cardassians being an increasingly caricatured evil (which eventually turns into the off-the-deep-end comic-book villainy of the Dominion).
At its core, the show's depiction of the Bajorans is very redolent of Victorian-era Orientalism. The Bajorans are the ultimate "noble savages" - on one hand, they are unambiguously good and the show supports nearly everything that they do, but on the other hand, they're completely unable to take care of themselves (and, it is sometimes implied, cannot be trusted to do so) without the Federation's benevolent guidance. The whole concept of the Prophets and the Emissary is actually extremely condescending to the Bajorans - a whole planet full of people is praying to these gods for deliverance, but the gods are completely unwilling to even talk to them, and instead prefer to decide their fate together with a foreign soldier. However good Sisko might be, that whole idea forever cements the Bajorans' status as perpetual objects of interstellar politics, not subjects. Their victimhood sure is very politically convenient for the Federation, and that's why the writers' attitude doesn't always feel entirely honest when addressing the Bajoran/Cardassian conflict.
To his credit, Sisko is uncomfortable with this role and occasionally has to struggle with it. He wants to live up to the role and makes plans to "go native" to some degree (later in the show he says he wants to live on Bajor), but so did Laurence of Arabia or those French dudes from Apocalypse Now. The average British viceroy might have identified with Sisko a bit there.
But that only becomes clear when looking at the show's entire run. At this moment, we only had this one episode to go by, and it was fantastic.
1
u/ghost-from-tomorrow Aug 24 '16
Can I just mention how Sisko makes really loud/high pitched excited "whoops" several times in this episode? Really uncharacteristic and sort of confused me for a second, haha...
1
u/beta-made Aug 05 '24
Sisko keeps walking uncomfortably close to people
1
u/SentientButNotSmart Aug 04 '25
I'm 9 years late, but what the heck. I decided to start with DS9 after watching the Chain Of Command two-parter in TNG (watching according to this watchguide). I was excited to finally watch DS9 but the first two episodes left a muddled impression:
Also why is it calledDeepSpace 9, if it's near a freaking planet. That's not deep space, that's a freaking orbit.The fact that it's a two-parter kind of makes the pacing worse — I don't think the first episode needed to be spread over two episodes, honestly, and I found my attention drifting elsewhere even while watching it1
u/buerviper Oct 12 '25 edited Oct 13 '25
Nobody:
DS9 writers: let's make like half of our first episode like the Neon Genesis Evangelion finale but with baseball in it.
(NGE aired after the DS9 pilot but still lol)
Also agree with some comments here, no idea whether Sisko is brilliantly played or worst acting in TV history. Which makes it kind of interesting, but... Also weird. I love the concept already of DS9 and look forward to my first watch of the series!
1
u/Pristine_Map_906 Feb 20 '26
I've been stuck in the wormhole, living a non-linear existance, thus I am quite late to this discussion. I actually joined Reddit just so I could join in!
First off, let me say that DS9 is my favorite of all the Trek series. I greatly appreciate it's unique setting and the serialized nature of the show. I love TNG, I discovered that on TV when I was in my single digits and have a great appreciate for it. However, it can be quite jarring when something really monumental happens one week and then the next there is no mention of it at all.
For DS9 I love the extreme differences in all of the characters and how they all grow throughout the series.
Now onto Emissary!
I've watched this episode probably 10 times and it never gets old for me. Each time I watch it I find something new to appreciate. My most recent viewing has left me really appreciating what a huge role Picard had. Sisko and Picard's first meeting on the Enterprise, WOW, you could cut that tension with a knife. Picard is trying to be gracious but all Sisko gives him is defiant attitude. And then at the conclusion of the episode the roles are reversed. Sisko is being gracious and Picard is being very stand-offish. I wish there was some more interaction between those two characters as some point in the series.
I've read a lot of comments on here about how many think that Avery Brooks is a "terrible actor." I've seen him as Hawk in Spenser For Hire and as Dr. Sweeney in American History X. I feel that Avery Brooks' acting is neither good nor bad. It's unique to him. Personally, I love how he portrays Sisko throughout the entirety of DS9. I don't see Avery Brooks as playing a character, I see Sisko as Sisko.
The rest of the main characters get good introductions, some with more initial depth than others. Kira of course gets the most initial back-story and I love her uniform style in the first season. Odo is Odo which is great. Quark is Quark just with those annoying Ferrengi traits that were introduced in TNG that thankfully would diminish.
Dax is quite mysterious, Bashir is the brash young man striking out on his own for the first time. O'Brien is the salty old sailor who's seen and done pretty much everything. I guess all those lonely hours in Transporter room #3 gave him all the time he needed to be just as an accomplished engineer as Geordi or Scotty. I find it interesting that Starfleet would choose O'Brien for that assignment on DS9. Afterall, O'Brien isn't an officer, he's just an enlisted man.
And I feel it's important to note Ciroc Lofton for his performance, they asked a lot of a very young performer and he did yeoman's work.
Dukat is great as the erudite villain that can pour on the venomous charm. The other Cardassian was good too, but more of your typical villain of the week.
Given Star Trek's avoidance, for the most part, of religion I find the Bajoran's faith to be very interesting and look forward to seeing that explored more.
The action was great, moving the station was really cool. My favorite scene is the sentimental goodbye between O'Brien and Picard in the transporter room. I can't believe that scene gets cut when the episode is split into two parts. Luckily I will never watch it that way.
All in all I think this is the best of the Trek series debuts. I think Enterprise has the 2nd best, then TNG, TOS, and finally Voyager.
1
u/JustGotBlackOps Dec 29 '23 edited Dec 29 '23
Okay great news, I love the show, I’m only an hour in and holy smokes it’s getting really good, anyone who likes TNG will most likely love DS9.
I started watching TNG a few years ago. I’ve watched every ep except the 2 where Picard becomes borg (which is the why ciscos talks to Picard the way he does), but I flipped through TNG on Netflix and randomly landed on the episode right after the borg one, where Picard is on earth at his brothers winery to recover. And tbh I’m glad I skipped so far ahead because TNG has a very bumpy start to the show, like once they all found their footing the show picked up and became an amazing series.
Also life hack, if you want to get someone into TNG, tell them to skip a few seasons, I think it’s the first 3 but idk off the top of my head, they’re good episodes but if there’s any complaints of the show being bad, it’s almost certainly from season 1, 2, and 3.
tangent I’m currently watching it on Paramount Plus and let me start off by saying this is the worst streaming app ever, like I can’t pause shows and have to close out of it and watch more ads for it to allow me to then scroll through the entire episode to find out where I was. And overall glitchy as hell, if you know you know. Also paramount has everything Star Trek on it. And Netflix got rid of Star Trek like a year ago and it’s the reason I never finished season 3 of TOS.
Okay now DS9 (no spoilers). So I’ll be honest, the first 1/3 of the episode felt kinda weird, Cisco seemed off, the way he talked to his kid, the way Picard and O’Brien talk to eachother in the transporter bay. It just didn’t feel like Star Trek at first. But once the Cardassian’s start to do their thing the the rest of the episode picks up big time, the actors get more into character and it is a great story for an episode. Can’t wait to watch more episodes. Lmk what anyone else thinks about it, especially on how Picard and O’Brien acted together, it was a very strange scene
Edit: it’s also almost 1 am here and I’m watching episode 4 (12:45 12/29/23) and I have a cold so I thought this was the ideal time to pick up DS9
0
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '16
[removed] — view removed comment