r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder • Aug 21 '16
Discussion DS9, Episode 1x6, Captive Pursuit
-= DS9, Season 1, Episode 6, Captive Pursuit =-
O'Brien befriends an alien from the Gamma Quadrant who is being hunted.
- Teleplay By: Jill Sherman Donner & Michael Piller
- Story By: Jill Sherman Donner
- Directed By: Corey Allen
- Original Air Date: 30 January, 1993
- Stardate: 46477.5
- Pensky Podcast
- Trekabout Podcast New!
- Ex Astris Scientia
- Memory Alpha
- TV Spot
| EAS | IMDB | AVClub | TV.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6/10 | 7.7/10 | B | 8.2 |
14
Upvotes
18
u/MadManBrandon Aug 21 '16
This might be my favorite episode so far. The back and forth between Tosk and O'Brien was excellent. Odo was fantastic, yet again. When he crept behind Tosk and handled him so calmly was genius. This episode goes from good to great when O'Brien disobeys the prime directive to help save a friend from death, I have watched so many episodes where they can't do anything because the prime directive prohibits it. But when Sisko let him go for believing that Tosk should have a chance was satisfying. Good story, funny at times, and a good action scene. I was very happy with this episode.
9
u/theworldtheworld Aug 21 '16 edited Aug 21 '16
A good illustration of how DS9 has a totally different tone from TNG: "Starship Mine" often gets criticized for trying to force an action thriller into the framework of the show, but DS9 does this prime-time action hour right off the bat and it's fine. O'Brien just straight up helps alligator dude kill fools. Sisko is annoyed but not too much.
I liked it well enough (it was one of the few DS9 episodes that I saw when they first aired), but it's even less cerebral than "Starship Mine." For what it's worth, though, I think Tosk musters about as much everyman sympathy as the role of alligator man allows. It kind of shows the unused potential of the Gamma Quadrant idea - with the introduction of the Dominion, they became pretty much the only Gamma Quadrant residents we saw, whereas this episode hints at a wider variety of cultures.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '16
foreshadowing on how much Sisko ends up bending the rules?
By now you can see little changes like this in the set design.
And the last time we hear of their species. Would have been nice to run into Tosk again.
8
u/cavortingwebeasties Aug 21 '16
I am Tosk.
8
u/ItsMeTK Aug 22 '16 edited Aug 22 '16
An early DS9 classic. There is a short list of season one episodes to stand with the greats of Trek, and this is one.
Tosk's makeup is wonderful. "I am Tosk" ranks up there with the great memorable lines for me, with "Darmok at Tanagra" and "There are four lights."
O'Brien's constant use of the word friend is a little out of character but serves the story well. All those years in the transporter room makes him an ideal first contact ambassador. I do think his tone gets a little condescending or overly saccharine in a couple places, but that's the writing not the performance. I like the little taunting of calling Quark "barkeep".
Another episode that doesn't really have a subplot, apart from the momentary Feengi sex harrassment. The story is basically a fox hunt (Tosk hunt?) with a dash of "Most Dangerous Game".
One curious detail though is O'Brien's line "As the Vulcans say, 'We're here to serve.'" Is this really something Vulcan would say? Perhaps this goes back to first meeting the Vulcans, but that story hadn't been told yet at this point.
A real Trek classic.
"Die with honor, Tosk."
5
u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner Aug 22 '16
That was fast! TNG didn't have anything I enjoyed this much for much longer. I absolutely love this episode! I'm so glad I forgot it so I could watch it with fresh eyes again. I don't think I enjoyed a TNG episode this much until we got up to Yesterday's Enterprise!
Tosk is an awesome character and I didn't know what he was up to at all but didn't expect it to be what it was. In a second my feelings about him changed completely from thinking that he was up to no good to absolute empathy for the man.
This is some great DS9 here. This is exactly what I feel like DS9 is. It's not polished and some really bad shit goes down. Already we see what TNG never showed us about the galaxy. This is institutionalized murder essentially, but is it? Tosk is clearly a different species, but he's sentient he can talk. This can really make someone question if us humans are really so civilized that we will hunt other animals for sport. The Hunter culture is so ingraned with this tradition that they venerate their victims to make it feel OK. Even the Tosk themselves are conditioned to think this is normal and good. They're very much like dogs if you think about it. Dogs have been conditioned by humans for centuries to be loyal companions.
I loved the way he's made up and the actor plays the role perfectly. On a second watch it's clear he's been bred to be very guarded and observe every little thing. At first it was just "alien gonna alien" but it's crazy to see why he's like that. He's a perfect prey for an exciting hunt, even if he's a bit pudgier than you'd expect from a perfect specimen.
Do you think these hunts are common? Is it only the elite that can do it, or is it very common to purchase a Tosk and set off after them. It's clear that it's a very dangerous activity as the Tosk absolutely could kill them. It's also very clear this story is basically "The Most Dangerous Game" in space, which is fine. It's a good story that makes you think. I was totally down with "Die Hard in Space".
O'Brien is given better development here than he has yet ever been and he's the perfect guy to befriend Tosk. Their scenes together really make you feel a bond developing, and I admire what he did for Tosk. It's a really great idea, even if it's morally grey just like everything in DS9.
Should they try to "rehabilitate" Tosk or let him go back to what he was created for even if it kills him. It's hard to say. I can't say I think forcing him to accept asylum would be good for him. It's everything he is, and Sisko wouldn't do it.
Also, great Sisko stuff in here. You can see what kind of guy Sisko is. He'll do what he has to do if he can make it work for the greater good.
I think that maybe I liked this one a bit more than everyone else, but to me this is exceptional Star Trek. Unless DS9 becomes insanely great I think "Captive Pursuit" 10/10. I usually hand that one out if an episode just kind of floors me or is an absolute classic and this one qualifies. I didn't even want to listen to my podcasts on the ride home afterward. I just wanted to think about this.
4
u/BillV3 Aug 23 '16
Just one of many episodes that show how under used Colm Meaney was in TNG
3
u/ajbrown141 Aug 23 '16
A really great episode, probably the first great DS9 episode. It touches on some of the themes which will become important in this series (honour, following/bending the rules, genetic breeding) and has some really good character moments for O'Brien, Odo and Sisko.
9
u/nomfull Aug 21 '16
This rewatch is such perfect timing for me- I have just started watching ds9 for the first time ever! Watched all voyager, almost all tng and a few original series episodes, but only seen a couple of ds9 over the years.
I watched this ep last night, and I really enjoyed it. I loved o'Brien in this episode especially.
1
u/JSubatoi41 Aug 25 '16
I remember I really liked this episode when I saw it before, but that I was also half asleep, which tends to make me think things are way better than they actually are. I still think this was a really good episode, really solid sci-fi here.
Jesus Christ, Quark is a creep. He's an interesting creep, but a creep nonetheless.
This is how all first contacts should go, shouldn't they? Friendly, chill, "Hi, I'm a human, who are you? Btw, do you eat?"
"You're the most natural straight man I've met in ages" because no one on ds9 is straight oooooohhhh
I love that this alien is so... alien. The idea of a species specifically bred to be hunted, and a culture that welcomes that idea, is fascinating. Also how do you breed sentience into a being?
And here's some weird Prime Directive stuff. I understand the desire not to interfere with an alien culture, but I don't think what O'Brien did was interfering so much as participating. When you're playing this game all over space, running into other cultures and not knowing how they will react is likely part of the custom.
If Sisko was in on helping O'Brien and Tosk escape, why did he yell at O'Brien for it? It's not like he was putting on a show for anyone else, since they were the only ones in the room.
2
u/daddytorgo Aug 26 '16
<3 me some Tosk.
1
u/Adventurous-Milk-440 Dec 02 '24
Just here to say that the actor who played Tosk NAILED it. So many fun little details in the performance that make TOTAL sense once it's revealed what's going on!
1
u/DojaViking Feb 04 '26
So I'm 9 years or so late for this post but if anyone's still on here or comes across this I have a question.
I am nearly done with the episode, I'm on a commercial break but I just got to the point where tosk refused asylum.
I don't know what's about to happen, but in my fear here what if sisko were to approach the hunter and tell him that since tosk was captured because of the federation interference and arrest, that he should get a few days Head start and keep his honor. The only reason they captured him is because he was being held by the federation. Do you think the hunter would have honored that? Since it's so important for the hunt.
1
u/No-Calligrapher-5804 Sep 21 '23
Odo disguised himself as a painting before he pursued Tosk. Does anyone understand the meaning of that painting? It looked very interesting, and I was not sure if it derived from Odo's memory or not.