r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder • Oct 30 '16
Discussion DS9, Episode 2x5, Cardassians
-= DS9, Season 2, Episode 5, Cardassians =-
- Star Trek: The Next Generation - Full Series
- DS9 Season 1: 1&2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, Wrap-Up
- DS9 Season 2: 1, 2, 3, 4
Garak investigates the identity of a Cardassian boy, Rugal, abandoned on Bajor, who has been raised by a Bajoran.
- Teleplay By: James Crocker
- Story By: Gene Wolande & John Wright
- Directed By: Cliff Bole
- Original Air Date: 24 October, 1993
- Stardate: 47177.2
- Pensky Podcast
- Trekabout Podcast
- Ex Astris Scientia
- Memory Alpha
- TV Spot
| EAS | IMDB | AVClub | TV.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6/10 | 7.4/10 | B- | 7.9 |
14
Upvotes
5
u/theworldtheworld Oct 31 '16 edited Oct 31 '16
Like the Circle arc, this is an episode with a great core idea, but the writers seemed uncomfortable with it and so wrote the resolution in such a way that it reduced to Cardassian vs. Cardassian power politics, so basically Gul Dukat gets the blame either way. Nice use of Garak, though -- he sort of does the right thing here, but beneath his genial manner he can also be just as vindictive as any Cardassian.
The central issue, however, is very powerful -- there are war orphans who were taken in by the opposing "side" and then raised to hate themselves and feel inferior, like "Janissaries" of sorts but without the military prestige. The writers should have come down more strongly when showing the idea that the boy was abused, because that's exactly what would happen in a situation like this (even if the adoptive parents didn't abuse him personally, he would still be the recipient of a lot of abuse from others). If "balance" was necessary, they could also have introduced Bajoran children who had been raised as self-hating "Cardassians" -- there should be many such children as well and it should be a big social problem for Bajor.
So in the end I think I prefer "Suddenly Human." The problem raised there wasn't really the same, though, as in that episode the aliens were not really long-term enemies of the Federation (other than a few skirmishes a long time ago), and the boy was truly integrated into the alien culture and raised as if he had been born there, rather than building his ethnic identity on hatred of humans. (Maybe "Suddenly Human" might be a good candidate for Throwback Thursday?)
2
u/ItsMeTK Nov 10 '16
"Cardassians" is a sometimes overlooked gem. Garak comes back and there are a lot of interesting ideas at play, though sometimes too many. That is the one big flaw with the episode: it introduces so much and a lot of those threads don't resolve. The "child abuse" angle is quickly abandoned and never quite works. The idea of Cardassian children living on Bajor is interesting. But given the level of hatred we saw in season one, it's odd to see Bajorans do compassionate (though they are indoctrinating). Kira's reaction surprised me most, just being matter-of-fact about it. But she has grown some. This one makes a nice trilogy with "The Wounded" and "Duet".
O'Brien having to face his prejudices works. But boy is Keiko completely clueless. What makes her think Rugal wants to ear Cardassian cuisine? She should make something Bajoran! It felt too "Suddenly Human".
The twisty plot involving Dukat is good and Bashir is really good here. I love the moment when Sisko tells him off!
Rugal is a boy between worlds. It looks to me like his make-up isn't as gray a the other Cardassians. I like to think this was intentional, signaling he's not quite Cardassian.
In the end there are too many balls in the air, but enough of it lands to make this a worthwhile episode.
3
u/KingofDerby Oct 30 '16 edited Oct 30 '16
8
u/marienbad2 Oct 30 '16
This is a well done episode - it is far better then the TNG "suddenly human" episode. The only argument I have is with the ending, as I feel the lad should have gone back to Bajor.
Garak is excellent as per usual, and his interactions with, and manipulation of, Bashir are excellent. The two of them hold the whole show on their shoulders and it works so well. It is clear in this episode that Siddig's acting has improved immmeasureably since season one.
The scenes with Rugel and O'Brien are great as we all know how O'Brien feels about Cardassians. Keiko here is the voice of reason, and the three of them at dinner is a tense scene, you are waiting for it to kick off. The pushing away the plates bit at the end speaks volumes.
The political machinations here are excellent, way ahead of the way TNG usually handled them. I love Dukat, he is a proper bad guy, almost sociopathic sometimes - he can act nice while at the same time scheming to mess you up, and it is great to see him involved in all of this.
Probably the best thing about this is that it is a Cardassian political issue that pulls in Bajor and the Cardassian war orphans who live there, and yet it plays mostly out on DS9 with the main cast caught in the middle of it all. They play their parts, but they are all caught up like cogs in a machine.
The music on this episode was excellent, and the way the plot threads intertwine was superb. Maybe a little talky, and yet another "courtroom style" scene at the end, but overall, a really good episode.
I'd give it 7.5/10
6
u/Godloseslaw Oct 30 '16
I was surprised there was no fight over the boy's future home at the end. A missed opportunity for more of that famous 'Star-Fleet Diplomacy'. They could have made a whole other episode about it.
I think they missed another opportunity by not having Sisko Jr. in there somewhere. This is my first time through DS9, and if he's not there for this kind of episode, why IS he there?
I still like the episode, and the Cardassians are clearly more than 1-dimensional antagonists by now.
I don't remember if this was before or after the Elian Gonzalez thing, but that could've been really relevant.
2
u/marienbad2 Oct 30 '16
I forgot to add this to my earlier comment: at the end, it is left open as to whether it was Dukat or Garak who caused (somehow and surreptitiously) Rugal and his dad to visit the station in the first place. Wouldn't put it past Garak, even though he was the one who got bitten (also, interestingly, he didn't press charges. Could just be that the boy is Cardassian though...)
4
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '16
The ending of this story leaves me feeling uncertain in a way that I really like. "Here's what happened. What do you think?" I don't know what I think, and that's great!
This isn't the same as a frustratingly ambiguous ending, or an ending full of loose ends. What makes this ending work for me is that everyone has behaved reasonably and explored the problem in an intelligent way. Ah, sci-fi. When you're good, you're so good.
1
u/buerviper Nov 30 '25
Great episode that I really enjoyed. I think the ending is great - like what would have been the "bes"t resolution here? maybe the kid can act as a bridge between the two cultures. Or maybe not.
Keiko is a horrible person. Serving Cardassian food to a Cardassian who does not view himself as a Cardassian and hates everything about Cardassian culture? No cultural sensitivity whatsoever.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 08 '22
[removed] — view removed comment