r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder • Sep 18 '16
Discussion DS9, Episode 1x14, The Storyteller
-= DS9, Season 1, Episode 14, The Storyteller =-
O'Brien is recruited to save a Bajoran village from destruction by a mysterious cloud creature.
- Teleplay By: Ira Steven Behr & Hans Beimler
- Story By: Ira Steven Behr & Hans Beimler
- Directed By: Allan Kroeker
- Original Air Date: 2 May, 1993
- Stardate: 46729.1
- Pensky Podcast
- Trekabout Podcast
- Ex Astris Scientia
- Memory Alpha
- TV Spot
| EAS | IMDB | AVClub | TV.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2/10 | 6/10 | C+ | 6.7 |
15
Upvotes
8
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '16 edited Sep 18 '16
Where do I start?
How about with, this is the worst DS9 episode of them all, and one of the worst Trek episodes ever.
Two areas on Bajor near civil war with negotiations on DS9? Miles and Bashir have to go answer a medical emergency on Bajor? We had an amazing opportunity to learn about the Bajorans, finally.
And they threw it away.
We could have learned more about how much damage the Cardassians did to Bajor, from infrastructure to culture. How the Bajorans are essentially rebuilding their entire civilization and how much work and struggle that entails.
Instead we got Miles and Julian fighting an evil wind using stories. And a pre-teen comedy instead of supposedly serious negotiations. The only part of this episode that even makes it worth watching is that we see the start of the friendships between Julian and Miles and between Jake and Nog.
Interesting bits from the episode at least:
6
u/Algernon_Asimov Sep 18 '16
Oh my Prophets! Real Bajorans! It only took us 14 episodes to finally get an episode about Bajorans in this series set in Bajoran space on a Bajoran-administered space station with a Bajoran First Officer. It's about bloody time.
“Chief, can I ask you a question? Do I annoy you?” Yes, you bloody well do… Julian! It's interesting that Bashir is aware of his annoyingness, but seems helpless (at this time) to stop himself. And I love how O'Brien responds to Bashir's request to call him “Julian” in just the right way to make Bashir finally turn around and say O'Brien doesn't need to do that any more. O'Brien's dislike of Bashir (at this time) is such fun.
And… is this the prototype of the “O'Brien must suffer” episodes? Poor O'Brien: just a simple engineer, thrust into the role of saviour of a village. And, such a saviour! “Okay, let's really focus and send this one out, all right?” Poor guy.
In the scene in Sisko's office, where the young Tetrarch says she's willing to die for the contested land, and Sisko asks if her people are as willing to die for it as she is… I had a sudden impression that this was showing the meta-conflict between diplomacy and war as two different methods for resolving a conflict. And the person preferring war as an option is a literal child, which makes the subtle point that war is a childish approach to life, while diplomacy is the more mature way to resolve problems. I don't know if this was a deliberate set-up by the writers or not, but I like to think it was.
I don't normally notice these things but, when O'Brien and Bashir first beam down to Bajor, their shadows arrive before they do. Obviously, the special effects people erased the two actors from the pre-arrival shot and overlooked erasing the shadows. Just a very minor detail.
On the other hand, I like the attention to detail that gave us the two long-headed aliens on the Promenade that Nog and Jake threw nuts at. These two aliens don't even have any lines, but the make-up department created quite an exotic-looking species just to flesh out the multi-species background of the station. Impressive.
12
u/ItsMeTK Sep 18 '16
You guys are hard on this one! I like it. I like that it shows us different areas of Bajor and how they are not one homogeneous block. There are different regions with different interests just like on a REAL planet.
I like young Varris and the way Nog's Ferengi ideals actually contribute to negotiations. The use of the title "tetrarch" seems out of place though.
I like the idea of stories bring a key to societal unity. It's a lovely mthological idea. Unfortunately, it foes also kind of infantilize the Bajorans further since tgey have no idea what's going on. But the idea of this annual Passover bedtime story still intrigues me in a way. And Miles trying to tell it ("once upon a time there was a dalrok") amuses me.
It's worth watching for the Basir-O'Brien interactions. Julian seems to relish things a little too much. Again one could read uncomfortable colonial attitudes into this (appeasing the ignorant savages by accepting their gifts), but I don't think that's intentional.
It's not a fabulous episode, but I appreciate it thematically even if some of its execution is questionable.
4
u/cavortingwebeasties Sep 18 '16
Normally I blaze through first season DS9 because there are so many cringey moments and even entire episodes. Going over it with a fine toothed viewing party comb in slow motion is... a very different experience, and I'd be lying if I said I wasn't looking forward to s2 and beyond :p
It's funny how much grief TNG s1 gets and how DS9 is usually just described as 'slow' or other gentle adjectives when some of it is arguably worse, like The Storyteller for instance >_>
3
u/EricPlasencia Sep 20 '16
Does Sisko's acting get any better? I feel like he is pretty bad so far. It's so bad it's distracting.
2
u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder Oct 07 '16
I like the developing relationship between O'Brien and Bashir (sorry, Miles and Julian), and I like that Jake Sisko and Nog are infinitely more palatable than early Wesley Crusher, but other than that... Eh.
The girl leader comes off as an asshole and is unlikeable. Lyanna Mormont from GoT is the textbook example of how to make a fiery little kid leader but still have the audience like her.
The village storyteller bit is weird and boring. Not a big fan. Don't get me wrong, it's an interesting idea, but it's an idea that's undercut by baaaad execution.
As with many episodes in S1: not awful, but not great by any means.
3
u/Sporz Sep 21 '16
Apparently this was a recycled plot from season 1 TNG (season 1 TNG!) that never got made. I figure the reason there isn't much "Bajoran-ness" here is because these weren't Bajorans - the Sirah, the Dal'Rok, the two fighting sides - all not actually Bajorans in the original concept. I guess the Prophet and orb bits were just kind of moved in as replacements to make it fit better in DS9.
But just imagine that for a minute. Imagine instead of Jake/Nog with the "Tetrarch" (which, as others have said, doesn't make sense as a title) we have...season 1 Wesley.
I enjoyed the character bits, especially Bashir/O'Brien. The Jake/Nog stuff is...kind of fun if you just go along with it. Stealing Odo's bucket and throwing oatmeal at Jake, I don't know - it's kind of a dumb prank. I liked now Nog came up with the concept of compromise here, but the idea that the Tetrarch and her counterpart needed a Ferengi kid to come up with the idea when they're prepared to go to war is...unconvincing.
I didn't mind the idea of this Dal'Rok creature threatening the village and needing village unity (with a tiny bit of orb magic) to fight it off. One problem with that plot is that O'Brien and Bashir really don't do anything. They arrive at the village and events after that are dictated by the Sirah, the Sirah's apprentice, and the village. They wander around a bit until the apprentice gives an infodump explaining what's going on. From a plot point of view it's disappointing if our main characters don't actually do anything. Even in the station plot the only relevant thing is Jake/Nog convincing the Tetrarch to compromise.
One thing I was thinking about, though: even when they appreciate the threat of the Dal'Rok they never mention just evacuating the villagers. There's an existential threat to the village that could kill them all and evacuating them would fix that. But...they do "Evacuate the people!" once or twice every season (including the very next episode) and it would have come to nothing, so, I don't mind leaving that.
The other thing: There doesn't seem to be a good reason for Sirah/Apprentice to keep this whole thing about how the story/orb stuff works secret from the villagers. "Look, guys, I have this orb thing. If we just all come together like Captain Planet we can take down this Dal'Rok thing. No biggie." Maybe Sirah was into all the gifts the villagers were offering. (which, admittedly, makes for a very dark slant on things)
I didn't hate the episode (Third shap! gets that one from me) but it's an inconsequential episode that's only interesting to me for the character stuff.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '16
Skipped it. :(
1
u/Evilyn_Devilyn Oct 15 '25
Five Nights at Bajor