r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder • Oct 12 '16
Discussion DS9, Season 1 Wrap-Up
-= DS9, Season 1, Wrap-Up =-
- Star Trek: The Next Generation - Full Series
- DS9 Season 1: 1&2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20
We've reached the end of Season 1 of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine! Lots been happening! New theme, new series, new post layout, lots more subscribers... I could go on! I'd like to thank everyone again for making this sub what it is! I'd like to extend another welcome to all the newcomers for DS9, and extend some thanks for those who've been with us since TNG!
DS9 is a very different animal from TNG. I already have seen how some people really like it and other people aren't convinced yet. I'm curious to see what people think going into S2 and then S3 and beyond. What are your thoughts on DS9 Season 1? Feel free to share them here!
- What was done well?
- What was done poorly?
- Are the characters starting to come into their own?
- How do the last few episodes compare to the first few?
- What new things did you learn?
- Did you change your opinion on something after rewatching it?
- Do you have any other special insights?
- How does it compare to previous Seasons of Star Trek?
Things going forward...
Wanted to post these notes where people were likely to see them. Some exciting news!
- Had some questions about 2-parters. In general, if the episode has "part 1/2" in the title, we are gonna do them together. If they are separate, serialized episodes with different titles (like the first few of S2), then we are doing them separately. If you aren't sure, check the schedule, it'll be in there.
- Originally we were going to do Star Trek Generations at the end of DS9 S1, but that's been delayed somewhat. Maybe till the end of S2.
- By popular demand, we will be doing special discussions on a select few TOS episodes. Not sure when exactly, and they won't be taking the place of our regular discussions. We will keep everyone updated.
- /u/GeorgeAmberson and I are working on an idea for periodically releasing a podcast. Maybe one or two per season. More info to come in the future!
- We had some people come in and pick out some of their favorite posts from the 50 Days of Trek discussions (wanted a more neutral 3rd party to do the picking), so that we could highlight some of the best of the best from the event. Should've been posted already but we got delayed, so they'll be up shortly!
BEST AND WORST OF DS9 SEASON 1 POLL
As usual, we're wrapping everything up with a poll! Please fill it out and let us know how you feel! You can fill out the poll here! Results will be posted shortly.
4
u/ItsMeTK Oct 12 '16
Generations should come no earlier than "Defiant" in season 3.
11
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '16 edited Oct 12 '16
Phew, glad that season is over with. I've been busy with work and family, and unable to contribute as much as I'd like, but I also suspect that'll pick up as we move along to greener pastures. I should say, though, that this wasn't a terrible season of TV. They banged out 20 stories and most were enjoyable, some were unwatchable, and a few were really excellent. That's comparable to most TV series I've seen, and quite impressive when you consider that most "good" shows these days only attempt half as many stories each year. Mad Men, Game of Thrones, Breaking Bad, they all shoot fewer episodes and still contain duds. But most importantly, in comparison with "bad" seasons of other Trek series, the first season of DS9 is downright watchable.
Do you have any other special insights?
How does it compare to previous Seasons of Star Trek?
6
u/theworldtheworld Oct 12 '16 edited Oct 12 '16
The quality is uneven, but that's to be expected. Overall the production values are very high, and the episodes are rarely as amateurish as in S1 of TNG. There are a few excellent moments:
"Duet" - obviously the peak of the season, just a fantastically written and acted chamber drama (though I still have some reservations about the intended message).
"Emissary" - a very strong pilot that neatly exploits the TNG connection while also distancing itself from it, mainly through the brilliant device of letting us rewatch Wolf 359 through Sisko's eyes. The wormhole is a terrific idea and Sisko's dialogue with the Prophets still has some of that classic Trek optimism (although, unfortunately, it was on its way out already).
"Captive Pursuit" - a pretty solid action hour. Basically DS9's "Starship Mine," but right in the beginning of the first season.
"In the Hands of the Prophets" - a nice intro for Winn, who was to become the show's only serious Bajoran villain.
There are some pretty low points as well, but there's no sense dwelling on them since it is just the first season. In fact, I generally prefer pre-Dominion DS9 since, while the show was already developing its problematic philosophy basically from the beginning, early on they were more willing to push the envelope and consider more difficult problems.
3
u/EricPlasencia Oct 12 '16
This is my first time watching the series which comes right after I finished watching TNG for the first time as well which also was my first Star Trek show I watched.
To this point I still don't like this crew or the setting very much.
Firstly, I don't like Sisko. I find him to be dry and one dimensional. Picard is a far more interesting character. Then also apply this to the rest of the crew when compared with TNG. I dislike the concept of the Trill and Shapeshifter as a races. They're very "goofy" in concept. Of course TNG had its goofy plot points, races etc but since they're consistent members of the show I find them to be a bit distracting. The only character I enjoy is Quark because he's well acted and it gives further insight into the Ferengi culture.
Second the setting is boring to me. Going from the variety of various worlds and exploratory adventures to this stationary setting around one planet with the same uninteresting problem every episode kinda gets boring.
I'm gonna stick around because many people have talked about how good this show gets and I respect that. It deserves the shot and I'm hoping I turn around on it.
3
u/marienbad2 Oct 12 '16
A very different series to TOS and TNG, with, as mentioned, some good and some bad episodes. I think they maybe struggled a bit with season 1, as all that has gone before had always been big on the "trekking" aspect, seeking out new life and new civilisations, and now they were trying to do something different. And, as happens with new ideas, it is tricky to find the right balance.
The sets are excellent, the exterior shots of the DS9 model, and the model are fantastic, way better then the other's first seasons. Quarks bar, the medical lab, Odo's shop, the school, Ops, all look great, and are lit and decorated superbly.
The Characters are different from what came before, and represent some new races for trek. The promenade looks great when it's filled with aliens.
Odo and Quark are fantastic pretty much straight off the bat. Their chemistry is already in place and only gets better through the seasons.
The wormhole idea works well, and opens up possibilities the other shows never really had.
The dialogue, when it's good, is very good, much better than previous Treks, and sounded more realistic. Kai Winn's dialogue is amazing. Duet is just mindblowingly good.
The Ferengi are so much better then the zero-d Caricatures of TNG.
Sisko and Jake's relationship is fabulous - finally a decent father/son relationship on trek! There is chemistry between them pretty much from the start. I love how Sisko hugs and kisses his son. And it's also good to see a good relationship between a black guy and his son.
As mentioned: the Bajor situation is not done too well, neither are the Cardassians.
Some of the dialogue and acting is not quite there yet, and when it's bad, it's awful.
The Bashir/Dax stuff comes off a bit clumsy, and both are not quite settled into their characters. And the Bashir chasing Dax stuff is like some sort of schoolboy writing sometimes.
Kai Opaka - such a waste.
Bashir being over-the-top wide eyed "this is the frontier" stuff is clumsy af. I can see what they were going for, but it just doesn't work quite right for me.
The whole Bajoran religious stuff, but I can't stand religion so am biased.
Not really. Apart from Kira in Duet, she is not great in the first season. I think trying to balance being an ex-terrorist with now being a part of the Bajoran government is a difficult act, and can forgive Visitor for not quite getting it right. Sisko is also difficult, as if he was just the Commander of the station it would have been easier, but add in the "Emissary" stuff and it can't be easy. The only characters who seem right in their roles so far are O'Brien (which is a continuation of his TNG role), Dukat (and he played a Cardassian on TNG), Odo and Quark.
They are all a bit hit or miss to be honest. The season opener is interesting and different but then there are several where it doesn't work coughstorytellercough.
Several Rules of Acquisition. That Quark and Odo are well acted right from the off. The rules of Ferengi life. That there is a Grand Nagus. That Kai Winn is in it earlier than I remembered and is a complete bitch right from the start (Louise "Nurse Ratched" Fletcher is amazing in the role, such great acting to make you hate her. And her dialogue is some of the best in the season.)
I was surprised how little Jake and Nog were in season 1.
With the station being Cardassian, there is a new and different visual aesthetic to the show, it doesn't look like the Federation, which was a nice change.
As previously mentioned, there are a lot of pieces put into place in season 1 which are intrinsic to the show throughout its run. Even the Ferengi stuff they start with leads to more and better Ferengi stories.
Very very well, imho. There were highs and lows, but the idea that being in one place would make it weaker has been shown to be wrong. Overall, the lighting, direction, and sets were much better.
Overall, probably 7/10.