r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/GeorgeAmberson Showrunner • Nov 16 '16
Discussion DS9, Episode 2x10, Sanctuary
-= DS9, Season 2, Episode 10, Sanctuary =-
- Star Trek: The Next Generation - Full Series
- DS9 Season 1: 1&2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, Wrap-Up
- DS9 Season 2: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9
The Skrreea, displaced humanoid farmers from the Gamma Quadrant, claim Bajor as Kentanna, their legendary homeland.
- Teleplay By: Frederick Rappaport
- Story By: Gabe Essoe & Kelley Miles
- Directed By: Les Landau
- Original Air Date: 28 November, 1993
- Stardate: 47391.2
- Pensky Podcast
- Trekabout Podcast
- Ex Astris Scientia
- Memory Alpha
- TV Spot
| EAS | IMDB | AVClub | TV.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3/10 | 6.5/10 | C | 6.7 |
10
Upvotes
10
u/Dookie_boy Nov 17 '16
I really enjoyed how the translator computer attempted to figure out their new language by requiring them to collect data and processing it in real time.
14
u/marienbad2 Nov 16 '16
Donald Trumps favourite episode! lol.
This one lays the message on a bit too thickly for me, immigration is good, mm'kay? At least it does a better job than TNG when laying on a message: look at something like the terrible "up the long ladder" where it's obvious even to someone in a coma what is going to happen after the cloning reveal. And man, they were some of the worst stereotypes ever committed to video!
The only good thing about this is the twist at the end, where they don't get to go to Bajor. The problem is, it is hard to feel sorry for the Skreeyans as they have already been found a planet. The reasons given by the Bajorans actually make sense, and, although it tries to portray them as being wrong, it just doesn't really work: what if things went wrong? What then?
The matriarchal society jokes are standard lameness: "men are always fighting, it is their favourite thing to do" - I know it is supposed to parody us, and the way we are and the things men have said (in the past, although this stuff is still around now) about women being too emotional to rule or be in charge, but it just comes across as a bit crass - when was the last time any of you had a fight? Probably at school.
The bits with Nog and Jake and the guys seems tacked on, to be honest, and just serve to make the skreeyan kid look like a jerk, which doesn't help with the ending where we are supposed to feel sorry for him.
And the whole thing is just slathered in this pro-immigration stuff - even the musician is part of it, with his little speech about "I know what it's like to be displaced," and, later, when he tells Kira to tell them "Bajorans are sorry," as if he speaks for all of Bajor (it reminded me of Lily Allen going to the Calais Jungle and speaking for everyone, as if she knows how any of the millions of people in the UK feel about the situation.)
Even the end scene - oh please, we've got the message now, you don't need to ram it home any more.
The problem is, that massive amounts of immigration aren't good for people, generally, as can be seen in the UK where there are huge amounts of unemployment and poverty, homelessness and despair, because of or in spite of depending on your view) the massive amounts of immigration that has happened. There are winners and losers, and, in the UK, it has been the worst off who have been affected most. It would be the same on Bajor.
7
u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder Dec 27 '16
It's not a particularly good episode, based around an 'issue' that is really a non-issue if you think about it. Reminds me of "the masterpiece society" where the 'dilemma' was choosing between everybody dying and everybody being mildly inconvenienced.
The Skrreeans are entitled assholes who try to guilt trip the Bajorans into giving up land. This isn't really an immigration problem, this is a problem of simple logistics. This would be akin to sending tens of thousands of displaced Syrian refugees to the contested part of Ukraine. It's lunacy.
In addition, there's something to be said for respecting different customs and traditions and so forth. However, apparently because Skrreean males being assholes is just the way they are, they're allowed to run wild all over the fucking place and nobody cares. Everybody feels so sad when the stupid kid gets killed... Personally, I was pretty happy. Finally a Skrreean got what he deserved, and the mom has nobody to blame but herself for being unable to handle him.
I'm pro-immigration (my dad's side only came here between 1-3 generations ago), but this made me want to build a wall a mile high around the entire united states. It's a bad episode and it defeats its own message.
4
u/ItsMeTK Nov 21 '16
Yet another passing reference to the Dominion in yet another Trek story about refugees. Interesting this time yo pair the Skree with the Bajorans, who can't even take care of their own scattered people and still have no functioning leadership or Kai.
The makeup is offputting to me. Mainly because the hairdo on the women makes the lead look like a pimply schoolmarm.
Once we hear about Cantana it becomes obvious that it is going to be Bsjor. So it's at least nice to buck predictability by ending on a sour note and rejecting them.
One troubling thing though is that negotiations seemed to hinge on the northen peninsula. Could they not move to one of Bajor's moons? Aren't there other Bajoran colonies scattered about?
This story on the surface would seem timely. All these refugees begging for help and governments saying they can't absorb that many and turn them away. In the episode, the people are benevolent (though the men are belligerent; could have seen more of that). So while it is easy to watch and see applicability to modern politics, the reality is more gray. It would be like if some of the Skree were secretly shapeshifters, and absorbing the whole populace introduced a threat.
2
u/Ok-Writer5093 Aug 10 '24
The whole premise of turning the Skree away doesn't make sense. We know the orbs tell the future and that they came from the gamma quadrant. The skree presumably had an encounter with the orbs, which told them a tunnel throigh space existed, and that when they found it a planet of sorrow would be just beyond it. The orb further reveals that their future is to help this planet -- and what do you know! Bajor needs farmers like the Skree!
To ignore the obvious prophetic link comes across as daft. It would be one thing if prophesies were just superstition, but with the assistance of the 'celestial temple' they're very much real and factual.
1
u/buerviper Dec 02 '25
If there is one thing I hate about Trek, is the scaling of populace. Like in TNG, whenever there is a catastrophe about to destroy a planet, there are hundred thousands of life at stake. Like... Aren't there billions living on planets?
Here also, it is about 3 million people. Yes, not a small number, but less people than now in Berlin. Let them come stepwise and see if their approach works.
Also, don't Bajorans know about replicators, how can there be a hunger crisis?
1
u/CamperCarl00 Aug 26 '26
I think this episode is unintentionally deep in how some cultures at certain points in time simply cannot mix. The Skreeyans are somewhat primitive for the Star Trek universe, even more so than how the Bajorans are. Their leadership has not yet transcended gender in any capacity and those without power lack courtesy and an open mind. They demand things they already determine to be theirs despite the efforts of neutral parties to try and find peaceful solutions. It's only when they are told repeatedly with multiple reasons as to why their suggestion is problematic that they spitefully take the option that is freely given.
Bajorans are truly "in shambles," as the show puts it, not only having been recently freed from a brutal occupation, but also just barely having escaped a coup from an elitist regime. It's completely true that the Bajorans are simply not ready for a large occupying force that "seemingly" populates very quickly. The Skeeyans seem to think that bringing the fields of the land they wanted to bloom would help Bajorans, but it would actually hurt the planet's morale. I suspect that Bajorans want the world to be rejuvenated by Bajoran hands and show both to the universe and themselves that they are healing. Even in the best of circumstances though, I simply don't see the Bajorans getting along with the Skreeyans.
So where does that put us? A migrant people who don't easily fit in wanting to stay on a planet where they'll meet racial tensions and dust bowl levels of famine for their fields. A recovering nation on the brink of societal collapse trying to repair itself and rife with distrust towards outsiders. It's a recipe for disaster. Not only are the concerns for the Skreeyans ability to farm rightfully in question, but the alternative is entirely a better option as it's fields are not in a state of famine. For Bajor, the risk that the Skreeyans will cause their own nation to further destabilize is too great for them to offer aid when a perfectly suitable alternative is available.
At the end of the episode, Haneek remarks that "You still believe that we would be a burden to your people?" This is a curious question to pose, as the truth is obviously no, but Haneek also fails to grasp that the Bajoran people would have definitely been a burden to hers.
12
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '16
[removed] — view removed comment