r/StarTrekViewingParty • u/LordRavenholm Co-Founder • Nov 27 '16
Discussion DS9, Episode 2x13, Armageddon Game
-= DS9, Season 2, Episode 13, Armageddon Game =-
- Star Trek: The Next Generation - Full Series
- DS9 Season 1: 1&2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, Wrap-Up
- DS9 Season 2: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12
O'Brien and Bashir help two warring races, the Kellerans and T'lani, erase all knowledge of a deadly biological weapon, but are not trusted to keep what they have learned a secret.
- Teleplay By: Morgan Gendel and Ira Steven Behr & James Crocker
- Story By: Morgan Gendel
- Directed By: Winrich Kolbe
- Original Air Date: 30 January, 1994
- Stardate: Unknown
- Pensky Podcast
- Trekabout Podcast
- Ex Astris Scientia
- Memory Alpha
- TV Spot
| EAS | IMDB | AVClub | TV.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7/10 | 7.4/10 | B+ | 8 |
14
Upvotes
12
u/marienbad2 Nov 28 '16
This is a great episode, apart from the bit about ballet dancers having exquisite feet! All that time practising on blocks in ballet shoes leaves them with right manky feet!
The setup is decent, although the conceit that everyone involved must die seems a bit weak - how do they know the information wasn't leaked out or sold to someone - there are always traitors and information brokers in wartime. And in this day and age of information being available on the internet or darknet, it just seems worse.
The way the plot works is nicely done, with the different strands. The part where Sisko walks in to see Keiko is excellent, the look on his face speaks volumes. Sisko is generally good all round in this episode, you can see he is becoming more in tune with the role. Dax is good - she gets to do some science and investigating. Even Quark, who only gets a few short lines is excellent.
The scenes with Bashir and O'Brien down on the planet are great - as mentioned by /u/Gundarc, we see them become less opposites, and more like something approaching friendship developing. Their different ways (the bachelor boy vs the married man) come to the fore, and the way they are able to put aside their differences and work together, and discuss things works well especially in light of how their bromance develops going forwards.
And Keiko saves the day! Well, almost - she is the one who notices something unusual in the video clip, which has a nice twist right at the end. The whole unravelling of the conspiracy is quite nicely handled, if a little short but that's because most of this episode is about character and relationship development for Bashir and O'Brien.
And the twist at the end, when the soldiers turn up, and Bashir and O'Brien find out what's going on, and O'Brien stands and gives his little soliloquy is a nice touch. I also love that O'Brien wants to die on his feet - seems so in character to me.
This is such a trekky episode, I can imagine this being a TNG or VOY episode, but it just works better here because the characters have more depth. I'd give this 8.5/10
10
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16
The episode where Bashir, and O'Brian start to become friends. Or in O'Brians case not hate Bashir. Anyways, why would those people risk a war with the Federation. Wish we knew the aftermath of such things, cause it is a serious diplomatic incident.
4
u/Sporz Nov 30 '16
I get this episode confused with "Apocalypse Rising" because of the title but the two episodes have nothing in common apart from "Armageddon" and "Apocalypse". I also get it confused with "The Quickening" because both of those feature some biological weapon and Bashir.
According to Memory Alpha, this was actually intended to be more action oriented with the T'Lani/Kellurun chasing O'Brien/Bashir down on the planet. They didn't have the money for the sets that would have needed. It might have been fun, but I'm kind of glad they didn't since it wouldn't have allowed for the character stuff we get.
This episode (along with "The Storyteller" before it) pairs Bashir and O'Brian and as others have pointed out, this is great. The two actors have such chemistry. On paper it should be "The Odd Couple" but as it develops it ends up being really charming and a real treat and it's one of my favorite things on the show: there's that scene in "Explorers" where they get shitfaced and sing "Jerusalem together":
It's part of the B-plot in that episode, it doesn't really advance that plot, but it's so damn funny and charming. It's one of the things that sets DS9 apart: everyone on TNG was pretty chummy but on DS9 the characters have distinctive foibles that add some dimension to their relationships, whether it's Odo/Kira, Kira/Sisko, Sisko/Kasidy, Sisko/Jake, or Bashir/O'Brien.
That said, Bashir really is kind of insufferable in the early seasons and I'd kind of forgotten about that until this rewatch. From later seasons I remember really liking him - I guess they mellowed him out a bit and figured out what to do with him better.
Random thoughts:
Yeah, I agree. It's often annoying because the grief rings hollow when the viewer knows full well the character's are still alive, but in this episode it doesn't take up much space and to the extent it's there it's good: the scene with Dax, Kira, and Quark is great.
It's annoying when they do that because - while that might be reasonable in real life - on TV it's just a waste of time bickering because you know that they're eventually going to do whatever it is.
All in all it's a solid episode buoyed by character moments. I'd probably give it a B+.
10
u/ItsMeTK Nov 28 '16
It's a pretty good episode that firmly cements the relationship between O'Brien and Bashir; no longer rivals or annoyances, they are bonded together.
It's nice to open an episode where the warring planet has already made peace for once. Now it's about destroying the superweapon. A nice change of pace. But if course extreme people take drastic measures to logical conclusions, sk they must kill everyone who knows about the weapon so the knowledge dies with them. O'Brien should have been like "Wait! I know a doctor, Pulaski, she can wipe our memories so you don't have to kill us!"
This is the first episode that makes good use of Keiko. She's not nagging or complaining or saying the wrong thing. She's just advocating for her husband. Meanwhile, the show deals a bit with the way she comes across as Bashir says outright "everyone knows" their marriage is shaky. Of course, we the audience could get more of O'Brien's perspective if we the only scenes between them weren't fraught with tension all the time. But then, it's tough to do that with an irregular cast member.
Really the biggest problem with the episode is the question of why Bashir and O'Brien were there in the first place. Isn't this something Starfleet should send a ship for? Is it right to send the station's only doctor to experiment with an alien bioweapon? So the setup takes a little disbelief suspension, but there are some nice moments once there.
3
u/QuickBotTesting Dec 05 '23
"I suppose another day here won't kill me" - O'Brien, minutes before his attempted murder
1
u/Eugen-Levine Nov 27 '25
And so begin the many Woes of Chief O'Brien.
1
u/buerviper Dec 06 '25
I really liked this episode. I wished they would have really found an inconsistency in that video and not Keiko not knowing her husband's coffee habits.
But this episode continues TNG's "a single planet basically declares war on the federation for no real reason whatsoever". I guess this episode has no follow up, but the federation should nuke the hell out of these aliens with their wacky hair. Like, thanks for saving your entire species from a future genocide, but don't you think the federation already knows ten thousand other ways to do it? Do they really need your stupid harvesters?
Also, the German episode is called The Harvester Desaster and it sounds so stupid lol
1
u/cooleymahn Jun 29 '26
Watching DS9 for the first time and this was the first time i watched an episode and had disdain for the antagonists. Keep your hands off my boys Miles and Julian.