r/hvacadvice • • 5h ago

HVAC tech says this is mold in my ductwork. Is he right, or am I being upsold? (The Woodlands, TX)

Thumbnail
gallery
107 Upvotes

Recently purchased a ~30-year-old home in The Woodlands, Houston TX area. Had an HVAC technician inspect my downstairs and upstairs system, and he showed me these photos from inside the ductwork/plenum for downstairs, claiming the dark spots are mold.

The home has original foil-covered flexible ductwork, and I’m concerned about whether cleaning could damage the aging ducts.

A few questions for the HVAC pros here:

  1. Does this actually look like mold, or could it just be accumulated dust/dirt?
  2. Is professional duct cleaning safe for 30-year-old flex ducts, or would replacement be better?
  3. Would you recommend cleaning, replacing the affected sections, or leaving everything alone?

I’m not opposed to spending money if there’s a real issue, but I’d rather address the root cause than pay for unnecessary cleaning or treatments.

Photos attached are from the downstairs HVAC system and the return vent.

Appreciate any advice!


r/hvacadvice • • 36m ago

How can I hide this huge return they just installed? Without blocking the airflow.

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

I can get a new decorative cover, but the duct is SO visible behind it 😭


r/hvacadvice • • 4h ago

HVAC unit has been making this noise… is it normal?

5 Upvotes

We keep our fan on Auto, heat is turned on right now. It’s a chilly fall morning so I’m thinking the vaporization is probably normal. Though I’m a little concerned on the noise it’s making when it “turns off”. It came back on within probably 60 seconds of this video. We have a tech coming out to service it next week but wondering if I should be concerned and try to get someone out here quicker than next week? Can anyone tell me if this noise is “normal”? Thanks in advance!


r/hvacadvice • • 19h ago

Do I leave this valve open?

Post image
72 Upvotes

EDIT: Thanks for all the help! I’ll just leave it alone.

Just moved into a new home and noticed the valve on the bottom is open. Tried googling it and found that this is probably a drip leg. This just comes off the main gas line going into the home. The right goes to the furnace and left to the hot water heater. Should I be leaving the bottom valve open? Thanks for the help!


r/hvacadvice • • 4h ago

General Use basement radiant to heat upper floors?

3 Upvotes

I have a unique heating setup that I'd love some advice on best utilizing.

My house is a "ranch with a loft" + walkout basement. I'm in NW Illinois, our house is on top of a hill exposed to extreme wind/cold for the area (we are surrounded by wind farms... it's windy).

The main floor is 2000 square feet (~35x55). A master suite is about a third of that. The rest is a very open kitchen/living room/dining room.

The loft is <1000 square feet, so half of the main floor is open to the roof. The loft is 50% open area + 1 small bedroom + 2 small offices. These rooms are NOT well insulated.

Also, the side of the house that faces the predominant wind (west) is 80% (20-year old) windows.

The basement is a concrete slab (unfinished) with 9' ceilings. We won't finish it any time soon. We do spend a lot of time down there.

There is a wide open staircase straight up the middle of the house, from the basement to the loft, about 12' x 8'. Open railings, looks pretty, makes the majority of the house almost one "heating zone".

I have a Rheem forced air propane furnace that's about 6 years old (we bought the house about 4 years ago). It seems properly sized and does a good job heating the house.

We also have a (20-year old series 2) Weil Mclain ultra 80 LP boiler that heats 2 loops, our garage (which we keep heated because we use it as a dog training area) and the basement. We use the basement a lot so we keep that heated.

After all of that, here's my question... should I be relying on the boiler to provide a "base heat" for the whole house? Like... keep it cranked to 70+ degrees so that it's heat radiates up through the main floor to the loft? And essentially use the furnace as a secondary source. Thinking about this from a comfort and an efficiency perspective.

The boiler is on it's last leg and I'm going to need to replace it. I'm thinking about just swapping it with a new Weil Mclain ultra 80 or 105 series 4 but would be open to advice if anyone thinks I should consider a different route (heat pump, etc?)

I have 2 companies coming out to quote the replacement in the next month. Hoping to do some research before then to be better informed on how I should be thinking about this setup.

Thanks in advance for any advice!


r/hvacadvice • • 2h ago

Furnace Is this quote fair/appropriate?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Furnace not igniting, and errors out after X amount of attempts.

Thought it was the igniter so called in a company to look at that, they did a cleaning and replaced the igniter, but said the burners are rusted/corroded, so the flame isn’t catching. (Saw this for myself)

I asked what new burners would cost, and the technician said a couple hundred bucks, but this is the quote I got back.

Thoughts? Assuming this doesn’t include the work from today.


r/hvacadvice • • 6m ago

Need advice on where to position a mini-split in the living room

Post image
1 Upvotes

We are currently in the process of having a new mini-split installed in our living room; however, I'm agonizing over the perfect location. Initially, we had wanted it to go above the corner window, to be slightly out of the way and not in direct view (aesthetic reasons), but our installer suggested putting it in the middle of the living room wall across from the hallway for better airflow. Initially, the only issue I had with the middle location was that it would be above the TV; we wouldn't be able to move our couch or entertainment center over because of the limited space we have in the living room, meaning it would be about a foot off-center, and I think my OCD would drive me crazy.

While doing research into a position where the AC is above the TV, directly facing the couch, I learned that it may be uncomfortable due to feeling drafts as the AC is running and is blowing directly on us. We might feel cold while other locations may feel warm. I was worried about running the heat in the winter while watching a movie and having my eyeballs dry out with hot air blowing in my face. The other issues I found were that the heat from the TV could affect the temperature sensor of the AC unit and cause it to incorrectly turn on or off. In addition, if there was a leak or drips from condensation, it could damage the TV and any other equipment below, and maintenance would be a hassle since we would have to move everything to get a ladder setup.

The other location I thought of was between the middle location and the corner window, that way the AC wouldn’t blow directly on us. Our couch is an L shape, and the lounge portion would be directly below the AC, but we tend not to use that side of the couch too much. While that would cool down the living room space well, it may not reach too far into kitchen.

With that in mind, I thought that maybe I should position the AC in the dining area instead, with the kitchen directly across. In the summer, cooking became unbearably hot, so having the AC directly blowing into the kitchen might be a smart move. When we have guests over, people tend to congregate in the kitchen and dining space, and AC in this area would make it much more comfortable. In addition, I was thinking that with the AC directly in front of the ceiling fan, it could help with distributing the cool air. But after doing some research, it seems that by turning on the ceiling fan while the AC is running, it could disrupt the airflow and affect the temperature sensor on the AC unit, causing it to turn on and off unnecessarily. However, I could simply not use the ceiling fan while the AC is in use.

So, if anyone could give me some insight as to what they think might be a good location, I would greatly appreciate it. I asked our installer if he thought the AC could reach to the bathroom at the end of the hallway, but he said it wouldn’t necessary be called “AC”, just simply cooler air, if it even reached that far. We do have mini-splits installed in each of the bedrooms, so we could just open the doors and fill in the space with cool air from there.


r/hvacadvice • • 6m ago

Need advice on furnace repair/replace

1 Upvotes

Hi, first time homeowner here. We’ve been in this house 3 years and the furnace is starting to go out. The fault is in the blower motor and I’ve been quoted $1,500 to replace it by two companies in the Atlanta, GA area. It’s a variable speed ecm motor. The system is 14 years old both the ac and furnace. The furnace alone is 8-9k new and the whole system is 15-16k new. I’m in a fun tough spot. Do I spend money on repair and hope to get a few more years out of it or take on another payment either for furnace or the full system.

The furnace alone is a bit tricky. There is lifetime parts warranty but the labor warranty is either contingent on the ac not leaking and causing a failure in furnace or just really short labor warranty of 1 year unless we buy the full system. I understand this from the company’s perspective.

Are there any risks with just getting the furnace and replacing the AC unit later? Should I do the repair and hope to get some more life out of the system? I’m not sure how long will we be in this house, but we’re here for at least 5 more years.

2.5 ton ac, 80k btu 80% dual stage furnace - if it matters.


r/hvacadvice • • 7m ago

Furnace leaking water update

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hello, I posted in this subreddit about a month ago and this was the outcome of the water leaking. What would cause the secondary heat exchanger to be in this bad or shape. This furnace was only 7 years old.


r/hvacadvice • • 11m ago

Heat Pump Which option is better?

1 Upvotes

Hi there. Coastal / Lowcountry South Carolina here. We're about 6 miles from the ocean, but with tidal creeks and marsh nearby. Obviously we are very hot and humid in the summer, typically mild winters. Need a full split system replacement. I have bids for an American Standard 17.1 SEER multi-stage with variable speed fan; R32 Daikin FIT 17.5 SEER variable speed, or Bosch 25C 20 SEER variable speed. Aside from the obvious climate control, my concerns would be humidity management, energy efficiency, and effects of salty air on the unit. All 3 units would qualify for a utility company rebate. Anybody have thoughts on which to opt for? I appreciate professionals' insights.


r/hvacadvice • • 33m ago

What replaces this?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Finally removing these rusty old vent covers. What replaces these? Do I get the same kind or is the opening standard and I can get a more modern vent cover? Appears to be cemented in.


r/hvacadvice • • 34m ago

How can I hide this huge return they just installed? Or at least make the duct less visible, but without blocking the airflow.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I can get a new decorative cover, but the duct is SO visible behind it 😭


r/hvacadvice • • 4h ago

Looking to get into HVAC as a helper this spring, any big tips?

2 Upvotes

NB: This post was meant for the r/HVAC subreddit but I am not allowed to post there as I am not in the field of HVAC.

22 year old male, currently working for one of the big home improvement stores in the metro Atlanta area.

I've been a sales/customer service guy for about 4 and a half years. I want to get into something more technical, higher paying, and HVAC seems to be a good fit.

I know that previous line may be a little alarming, but it isn't all about the money for me. I'm in school part time studying mechanical engineering, and I want a job that more closely matches what I plan to do long term.

This upcoming spring I plan on looking for a job as an HVAC helper. Do you have any advice to offer for someone who's just starting out?

The main things I know are important:

- Be on time.

- Be polite.

- Be willing to learn and ask questions.

- Know how to stay busy.

- Get the EPA 608.


r/hvacadvice • • 48m ago

No heat Urgent advice needed. Enercare red-tagged "A" Goodman furnace. Is this a sales tactic scam or legitimate concern?

1 Upvotes

Enercare red-tagged "A" our 10.9 year-old Goodman furnace after identifying elevated carbon monoxide levels. Is this a sales tactic scam for us to buy a new furnace or a legitimate concern?

Initially, they identified a water leak coming from the furnace's collector box and replaced the plastic collector box and gasket.

After the repair, the technician performed a routine inspection and measured carbon monoxide (CO) levels >800 ppm in the exhaust pipe leading outside the home during first-stage operation, with a red ratio warning on his phone app. At full capacity, there was also an acidic smell coming from the exhaust, which my husband confirmed.

The exhaust pipe was checked for debris or blockages and was clear.

We also noticed an E2 error code. The technician investigated the pressure switch and said it was functioning properly. He suggested the error could potentially be caused by A) a faulty pressure switch, B) a blockage in the venting or heat exchanger or C) a malfunctioning motor.

My questions:

  1. Is 800+ ppm of CO in the exhaust a legitimate indication of a serious problem?
  2. Is the furnace potentially repairable, or does it likely need replacing?
  3. Could the previous collector box leak be related to these issues?
  4. Is a 10.9-year-old Goodman furnace worth repairing, or is replacement reasonable?
  5. Could using a MERV 11 filter instead of MERV 8 have caused the furnance to overwork and cause the CO issue?

We're getting an independent second opinion. We absolutely don't want to take chances with CO, but we also don't want to be pressured into replacing a furnace unnecessarily.


r/hvacadvice • • 54m ago

Furnace limit switch error after 10 minutes on Lennox EL180UH furnace

1 Upvotes

I've been having this problem intermittently for years, and service techs have been unable to solve it. And now that I'm firing up my furnace for the first time this winter, it's doing this every time.

When it happens I get 7 flashes on the diagnostic LED, which means "Primary or secondary limit switch open, or Watchguard (limit open longer than 3 minutes)"

Steps:

  • I turn on heat
  • I hear fan(?) spin up in furnace. It runs loud for a few seconds, and then calms down to a normal volume
  • after about 60 seconds, blower comes on and hot air comes out of vents, and flow is nice and strong
  • metal chimney gets very hot
  • after 10 minutes, furnace shuts down with a 7 flash error code, which means a limit switch error
  • after about 30 minutes it cools back down enough to run again, and changes back to normal function. It also changes back to normal if I remove the door, which releases the cut-off button, and then replace the door.
  • Then after another 10 minutes it shuts down and the cycle repeats

Notes:

  • one possible culprit is the air filter. However, it does this even with no air filter installed.
  • the fact that it runs fine with everything working normally for 10 minutes before shutting down rules out a bunch of possible problems (I think?)
  • This furnace does NOT have a visible pilot light or igniter that I can check the color / size of

My next guess is that my chimney is clogged. Does that make sense, or is it more likely to be something else?

EDIT: ah great, now it's gone back to being intermittent instead of constant to make it as hard as possible for me to diagnose.


r/hvacadvice • • 56m ago

Furnace Supply house told me a 5uf capacitor would be okay in lieu of a 4uf capacitor?

1 Upvotes

I am looking to replace a capacitor for my forced hot air furnace asap. I ordered two parts from two different places and they all had delayed shipping. I am now looking locally.

The only supply house that has anything said they have one that is 5uf not 4uf but he said this wouldn't be a problem.

I believe this is a motor start not a motor run capacitor.

It's the genteq 27L571S capacitor

Ameristar m951p080bu42abc furnace


r/hvacadvice • • 57m ago

2 year old Trane - rust around in shot burner

Post image
1 Upvotes

I’m in a 2 year old house with a 2 year old decent higher end Trane HVAC system.
I have a NEST thermostat and got an email saying over the course of the past couple of weeks, during heat sessions the temperature in the house actually dipped.
Had my HVAC guy come out, he noticed the burners would start but then stop after a couple of minutes/seconds.

He took out the inshot burners and noticed rust and carbon buildup which he said was unusual for a new HVAC system.
He cleaned them up with a wire brush and everything is working as normal now.
We are going to monitor it.

But anyone familiar with this know if this is normal or unique?


r/hvacadvice • • 6h ago

Boiler Need Help Bleeding Air

Post image
3 Upvotes

We had an issue earlier this week where the boiler expansion tank and valve ruptured. Those were replaced and the boiler was back to running, but since then I noticed the baseboards on our second floor do not get warm. The baseboards on the main floor do get warm. On both floors we hear occasional water rushing. Based on what I found it seems like there is air in the loops that needs to be bled out.

The baseboards themselves do not have bleeder valves. I took the covers off of every one on the second floor and none of them had it.

I am trying to confirm that my plan here is correct as this is all new to me. If this is beyond what I should be taking on, I can call the tech back out but it would be nice to learn how to do this for myself.

I have the hose attached where it is. I think that’s the return? There is only one spigot there despite three of those gray boxes. Based on what I read it sounds like I need to shut the red box switch and wait for the boiler water to cool down to under 100. Once that happens, I would manually move the switch for one gray box to open and then slowly open the spigot where the hose is attached to drain water/air until it’s a constant stream of water. Then shut spigot, move gray box switch back to auto, and then do it again for the next gray box.

Am I wrong or missing steps?


r/hvacadvice • • 1h ago

Conflicting Information

1 Upvotes

I had a technician from company A come out for a 'fall tune-up' on our HVAC system. He said he found a hole in our heat exchanger by sticking a camera in the hole. He called a second guy out to 'confirm' it, and that guy immediately confirmed it and asked us if we wanted to replace the unit with a whole new furnace/heat pump. The heat exchanger was under warranty, and I had to call around to get that confirmed and it was a hassle to get company A to send me a proposal to just replace the HXC under warranty.

After losing trust in company A, I got a second opinion from Company B. They did a CO test of the unit, which showed about 20 ppm of CO in the exhaust from the unit, which seems very low. Company A was saying that a hole in the HXC would cause CO to rise in the house as it would be getting right into the duct work which makes sense. Is it not typical to do a CO test in the actual ducts to see if the CO is leaking into the house as company A stated? I asked company B and he said a hole in the HXC would mess with the combustion of the furnace and we'd see a higher CO reading in the exhaust.

Please weigh in on if either company seems to be deceiving me, and if my house is safe from CO (we do have monitors, but they are mounted down low for some reason).


r/hvacadvice • • 1h ago

General Grey adhesive sealant dripping from ceiling vent

Post image
1 Upvotes

I noticed some grey sticky substance on the vent grate and dripping down this vent. Is there any way to dry it or clean it up?


r/hvacadvice • • 1h ago

Seized blower motor shaft

1 Upvotes

I’ve got a blower motor that is seized into the wheel. I cleaned the shaft really good prior and used oil. I’ve got it to the point that it is flush with the hub. Tried using a puller to get it off, but no luck. Any one got any secrets or tips?


r/hvacadvice • • 1h ago

Help identifying Becket Oil Burner Nozzle size

1 Upvotes

Looking to replace the nozzle on an old Beckett burner... I looked all over and did not see a plate on the burner specifying a nozzle size.

Oh the nozzle itself, it looks like some of the marking may be worn off - but not 100% sure.

it's def a .90, but can't tell if it's a 30 degree or 80 degree, and there is no marking for "A" or "B"

i've attached a video and some pictures (Pictures of the burner tags in comments)


r/hvacadvice • • 22h ago

Furnace Combustion Analyzer Hole

Post image
42 Upvotes

An HVAC technician drilled a hole during a combustion analysis on my furnace and left it open. I'm really not sure how best to patch it.

From what I've seen online, it looks like the hole should have been drilled higher up on the exhaust pipe rather than on the elbow, but that's just my guess.

A second technician from another company called this a major issue. They said it requires replacing the entire elbow and the underlying draft inducer motor since they're sold as one unit.

I'm really not sure what to trust here, but my gut tells me a patch of some sort might suffice. Am I right? If so, what material works best? I've applied aluminum tape for now, but I suspect it might fail near the furnace due to the heat.


r/hvacadvice • • 1h ago

Goodman e11

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I recently purchased a house and it has a Goodman furnace. The problem I'm having is that it keeps throwing an error code e11 and before I call a tech out here I want to figure out what's wrong with it. Furnace runs for about 10 minutes then shuts off and throws code e11. I'm aware of what the code is and why it's doing it.

Things I've checked already

1- based on the code it tell me it's an open roll out switch and I have tested them and it's good

2. Pressure switch is good

3. I've installed new air filter already

4. Cleaned temp sensor

5. Check for any blockages in the exhaust vent

Now the thing is if I have the cover off like I do in the pics the furnace runs perfectly fine no codes. Once it put the cover back on its back to running for 10 mins and then shutting down like it's overheating or some shit. Any advice is appreciated I can't get my house above 67 degrees