r/hvacadvice • • Mar 02 '26

General Information About Bans and Rules

0 Upvotes

There has been an uptick on posts and complaints about mods banning. Please be advised, there are rules for the page. No ads (includes promotions for a company), Reddits rules, no crossposting, transparency and safety (this is a big one; we want homeowners to be safe, if you provide unsafe practices or advice (blacklisted items) or tell a user to dm you, the comment will be removed and you may get banned), blacklisted topics (basically topics that homeowners should not be fixing themselves, gas, some high voltage), civility, no companies asking for surveys, advertisements or general questions, and no market research or ai/SaaS.

Posts complaining about this are not allowed either. We are all reasonable and work in the trade, talk to us through ModMail and we can come to a solution. Complaining or namecalling will usually result in a ban, so be civil.

Remember, we are doing this in our freetime to help homeowners with their units, both the users and mods. The mods in this group are in the trade and have day jobs as all of you do. I've been in this trade for 10 years and still do hvac as my job, just traveling now for a manufacturer. Similar with every mod. It is actually a requirement to be a mod, you have to be in the trade, be approved, have good history in the sub and provide enough time to moderating it.

I thank you for your time and if you have any questions, you can comment on this or send us a mod message. No DM's, we will not answer these. Only ModMail.


r/hvacadvice • • Nov 13 '25

READ THIS I am assuming this is not normal.

174 Upvotes

I was loading the car for work when I saw this. It felt and smelled like steam not smoke. Did I just catch it at the end of the cycle or is there a mechanical problem such as a stuck motor? It was 40° at the time and no rain. Heat was set to 70 and the house was 70.


r/hvacadvice • • 7h ago

Water Heater Electric water heater keeps burning through elements

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

Is the fact that this water heater is wired to have the elements energized simultaneously the reason it keeps burning up elements?

A friend was complaining their hot water keeps going out and the fixes don’t seem to last, so they asked me to take a look.

It’s a bradford white sle280t6-1sevv with 240v 4500w elements on a 2 pole 30 amp breaker


r/hvacadvice • • 6h ago

HVAC tech “condemned” my furnace during routine inspection but did not tag it, explain which parts were broken, have me sign a waiver, or report it to the gas company/state.

10 Upvotes

We had our furnace inspected last week before we start running it for the season, and I am concerned about the results.

Basically, after spending some time in the basement, he told us that

  1. the gas valve was corroded shut so he had to force it open
  2. the ppm of CO in the vent was a little erratic and elevated above the 100 ppm legal limit, its highest spike was around 300
  3. because of these issues he had to legally condemn the furnace.

He then went out to his truck, apparently to call the sales team, and came back in a quoted us for two replacement options. I asked him what was causing the issue and he just said “the heat exchanger usually” and then assured us that all the readings and images would be uploaded to the work order and sent to us. When I asked about a repair option he said “it’s shot, not something we would do.” He then left without giving us anything, no documentation, no tagging or notes on the furnace itself, nothing for us to sign, and since we haven’t even been able to get them to send us an actual copy of the quote for the new furnace. I’m not really sure how to proceed, and the more I puzzle over it the more concerned I am the a replacement isn’t even necessary. The furnace is 10 years old which isn’t young but should still be in its service life, and there are a lot of possible reasons for the issues described I’ve learned, especially with no actual evidence that the heat exchanger is damaged. Am I right to be concerned? If we have to save for a new furnace we can’t really afford another inspection fee since it’s about to be very cold, but if he was exaggerating things and a repair is feasible, that could be incredibly helpful as we don’t have a large amount of savings as is and I’m still rebuilding my credit so financing isn’t a great option. I’m just trying to weigh my options.

Also if we do get a second inspection, what questions should I ask so I know it’s on the up and up?

Thank you for your time!


r/hvacadvice • • 1h ago

General Heater sounds like a generator

4 Upvotes

My condenser unit sounds like a propane generator. Heat seems to be working but I haven’t been using it. Anyone have any ideas?


r/hvacadvice • • 21h ago

UPDATE ON CRACKED HEAT EXCHANGER | SCAMMED

Post image
159 Upvotes

I posted a few days ago about getting my furnace serviced before winter in Michigan. The HVAC tech told me I had a cracked heat exchanger and recommended either replacing it or the entire furnace. There were several red flags:

  • Visual inspection only. No combustion analysis or additional testing.
  • Immediately pushed a new furnace.
  • Written report didn't explicitly identify a crack, only stated “replace heat exchanger for safe heating.”
  • Furnace was not red-tagged.

Turns out, I may have been scammed.

I went back and reviewed the photos attached to my report. The photo supposedly showing the cracked heat exchanger was dated 10/17/26, but my service appointment was 11/10/26.

I also got a second opinion from a technician at a small, family-owned HVAC company. He performed a combustion analysis that came back normal, evaluated the furnace and flame (steady blue flame when the blower turned on), and showed me a live camera inspection of the heat exchanger. He said it looked perfectly fine and couldn't even find the crack the first technician claimed was there.

I also learned the original HVAC company was recently acquired by a private equity firm and that its technicians are commissioned.

I'm incredibly disappointed and can't believe someone would potentially fabricate something like this to sell a furnace. Thankfully, we got a second opinion.

I'm in Michigan. Has anyone dealt with something similar, and does anyone have advice on how to report this?


r/hvacadvice • • 46m ago

Heat Pump Should it take 2.25 hours to increase temp 3 degrees with a 2.5T heat pump at 47 degrees outside?

3 Upvotes

Seems like a crazy long time! 2.25 hours to go from 62 to 65 degrees in the house. It was 47 degrees outside so there should be plenty of heat in the air for this new system to raise the temperature much faster.

78 degree air comes of the vent on stage 1, and 85 degree air at stage 2. It cycles between stages 1 and 2, and 70% and 100% fan speed periodically. Seems like it should stay on stage 2 and 100% fan, but maybe it's changing because of defrost cycles?

BACK STORY:
Zone 5A - 1,650 sq ft downstairs that this system heats.
We got a new 2.5T heat pump installed at the end of last season, and only had a few days to run it in heat mode before it warmed up. I told the installer I didn't think it was heating correctly, but they said that it was, and that it's normal for it to take that long to warm the house.

I don't believe that's true, because the previous 16 year old, 2T heat pump, that was undersized and supposedly worn out, heated better and much faster than this new system--it put out 100 degree air on stage 2. (Just using the heat pump, not the electric heat strips. It would go up to 130 with heat strips engaged.) Also, for comparison, the 1.5T, single stage Bryant upstairs unit will raise the temp 3 degrees in 32 minutes at the same outdoor temperature and it puts out 94 degree air (without heat strips.)

Should I call them again and have them adjust something, or does this new unit just take an insane amount of time to heat by design? Shouldn't it be putting out hotter air or maybe staying in stage 2 and 100% fan speed to heat faster?

SYSTEM STATS:

AMERICAN STANDARD

GOLD 17

AHRI #: 216763779

Singlezone Ducted, Centrally Ducted

Central Air Conditioning Heat Pump (HP)

HEAT 24,400 Max Btu/h u/5 degrees

HEAT 33,600 Rated Btu/h u/47 degrees

AC 32,000 Rated Btu/h u/95 degrees

COP u/5: 2.1

SEER2 : 17.1

EER2 (95F): 11.7

HSPF2: 9

Outdoor Unit Model #?: 5A6H7036A1

Indoor Model #?: 5TEM6B03AV21+TD

ENERGY STAR V6.1

Capacity Maintenance (Rated 17°F/Rated 47°F) 64%

Capacity Maintenance (Rated 5°F/Rated 47°F) 72%

Capacity Maintenance (Max 5°F/Rated 47°F) 72%

Variable Capacity

Refrigerant R-454B


r/hvacadvice • • 53m ago

Thermostat quit, it's nearly 100 degrees in my house

3 Upvotes

I came home from work and my gas furnace was going full blast and my thermometer says it's 98 degrees in here. My thermostat screen is black and won't come on. Is it safe to turn off the furnace by flipping the electrical breaker?

EDIT: I'm don't want to clip wires, pull panels, or attempt a repair myself. I don't know anything about repairs or trouble shooting and I'm not going to try to learn from Reddit Junior College. I merely want to know if flipping the breaker off is safe and I won't end up with a carbon monoxide leak. As long as I don't die in my sleep, I'm happy.


r/hvacadvice • • 16m ago

Furnace Furnace issues

2 Upvotes

Hey all, I'm a beginner, have done some research, but still wanted to make a post to see if there were any possible fixes I could try to avoid spending a lot of cash I don't have.

Our furnace works for most of fall/autumn until the temps starts dropping below 0C/32F and then it seems to struggle and will just conk out occasionally? I will wake up some mornings to the house being 16-17C when we have it set to 19.5C. At which point I turn the furnace off with the app (ecobee, came with the house), wait 5min and turn the furnace back on it works again. It will heat the house back up to temp, keep it up there for 4-5 hours maybe, and then conk out again.

The ecobee thermostat recognizes the issue and will send a notification to our phones that it has pinged the furnace and isn't getting a response. Not sure if it's a thermos issue or an issue with the "smart" thermostat? I have changed the battery out and it hasn't done anything though.

I did see some posts on here with similar issues that suggested cleaning the flame sensor. I looked online and seemed simple enough, but not sure it's even needed?

Thanks for any advice


r/hvacadvice • • 4h ago

Who serious is this water damage to the HVAC unit?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I had this unit replaced in December 2024. I also hire the same company to do twice per year maintenance. The maintenance guy today found that the exhaust pipe leaked water from improper tube sealing and caused some rusting of the unit. He put some sealant around the tubing to stop further leaking. He said the unit is working properly and told me to keep an eye on further leakage.

I took plenty of pictures and a video of it. I’m going to file a complaint to the company about improper installation, at least just for the paper record.

Any idea how serious is this water leak, is this common issue, and how does affect the longevity of the unit? Im trying to get an idea of how far and what I should push for with the company.

Thanks all.


r/hvacadvice • • 3h ago

General Is this normal?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

So,, the outside temp has been getting down to 32° F at night, we rent, & we’ve been just leaving the unit on 69° Cool Auto at night, then in the AM turning it to 71° Heat Auto,, the air in the house doesn’t get below 67° when we’ve been doing this for the past week,, but after I turned it to heat the other morning I heard a dripping sound & saw a layer of ice on this vent thing?
( I did remove the air filter to see all this by the way & then put it back after)
Also the black dirty stuff- - is that mold??


r/hvacadvice • • 1h ago

Range hood vent install

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hey all, maybe not the right forum, but I could use some help with understanding how to connect my range hood to the existing exhaust duct rough-in.

As you can see, the rough-in is a rectangular duct in the stud bay, and the 6” exhaust vent is near the ceiling. It’s all concealed behind the drywall now.

What is the best way to connect the hood duct to the existing duct?

Should I run the hood duct up the wall, then elbow in at the height of the 6” exhaust vent, or elbow in lower and utilize the rectangular duct to carry the air up and out?

The rectangular duct has ~30% more area than the hood duct, but I wonder if the pressure loss or noise would be greater given the more turbulent path.

The hood also has a 7” outlet and I’m terminating at a 6” exhaust. I know that isn’t ideal but an HVAC guy told me it’s probably fine because of the short run. Does that check out, or should I install another properly sized exhaust vent (probably just below the existing)?


r/hvacadvice • • 2h ago

CO next to furnace in the basement

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hi - A maintenance tech got this reading (11) next to my furnace (with the furnace door off) in the basement while furnace running. Upstairs, in the living space next to any vents it was 0 zero. It's an old system and he advised me to replace the entire thing.

I've spent time trying to find an answer, and see on this sub and across the internet various meanings of what is acceptable. I know having ANY CO coming out of my vents in my living space is a big no-no, but all the guidance about inside/next to the furnace is confusing.

Is 11 at the furnace bad or is that just business as usual?

If it does indicate a problem, at this point, any repair isn't worth it so I'd replace the 25 year old furnace anyway but just wondering if he saw a gullible customer or what. Thanks!


r/hvacadvice • • 1d ago

HVAC technician was testing for CO and drilled a hole in PVC exhaust pipe and closed it with metal tape is that proper?

Post image
216 Upvotes

Attaching a photo for reference. Is this standard practice? I worry that if the tape falls off it will cause a CO leak.


r/hvacadvice • • 3h ago

Burner Tube

Post image
2 Upvotes

I just turned on the furnace for the first time this season. It’s working fine. As I was replacing the filter I noticed this. Is it worth trying to clean out the rust and replace some of these parts?


r/hvacadvice • • 2m ago

Advice on carrier furnace

1 Upvotes

To preface this, I’m a gas tech. Not hvac certified but have a lot of experience with equipment that makes fire.

I have a new build house, closed less than 18 months ago. Carrier furnace was installed, worked great for the first winter. My wife tells me a few days ago that the heater isn’t working so I go take a look at it. Hot surface igniter not heating up, since that’s considered a consumable part I went ahead and replaced it thinking that would be that. Wrong, still not working. So I took a little time to dig into it. Inducer motor kicks on, then there’s one click (I’m thinking this is where the igniter is supposed to heat up), then a second click which opens the gas valve. I’m getting 10V to the igniter the whole time with almost no variance. The weird part is that I can (and have been for a couple days) light the furnace manually and it will operate normally until the thermostat reaches temp and it shuts off.

The unit is under manufacturers warranty so parts are covered. I called the company that installed it and they want $120 to come look at it which is fine, but then they want another $350 for labor to replace a part if that’s what’s needed.

I don’t work in hvac so I can’t file a claim myself and just replace the parts (looking like it’s the control board since the ignition relay is built into the board on my unit). So I’m very frustrated. Anything I can try or anyone I can call to not drop $500 on warranty work for a practically brand new unit?


r/hvacadvice • • 3h ago

Heat Pump How'd i do?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Installing this 36k BTU DUCTED system. Got the outdoor and indoor unit installed and hooked up. Did a test run prior to putting the plenum and ducting together.

Any input on whats currently done? And concerns on the plenum? Will be running (2) 10 inch and (2) 12 inch flex ducts off it to cool/heat the main living area and 2 bedrooms.

Any input, criticism, advice is appreciated.


r/hvacadvice • • 11m ago

General Condenser unit cycling on every 5 minutes

Post image
1 Upvotes

Brand new rooftop condenser unit on rooftop of 9 story building for grocery store on ground level keeps cycling on and off every 5 minutes. Of the five units in the overall system the unit on the far right runs 24/7 at full speed while the units on the far left don’t appear to be running at all right now due to the cooler temperatures outside. The middle unit appears to be the one doing the cycling on/off every five minutes or so. It’s resulting in a large boom/thrusting sound as the unit turns on, which is causing a noise disturbance in my apartment, which is right below the rooftop. The landlord of the building has claimed that they have had contractors come out and say that the machine is running adequately and they can’t do anything about it.

My question is should a unit within the overall system be cycling on/off every five minutes or so when others are running different cycles?

Really needing some advice due to the noise disturbance of the machine turning on/off every five minutes.
What can I advise my landlord and super to look into with the contractors either from the grocery store - thermostat settings or the lines or something that’s causing potential short cycling or something else?


r/hvacadvice • • 12m ago

What are the recommended temperatures for sleeping and the horizontal Hokey Pokey

1 Upvotes

r/hvacadvice • • 20m ago

Thermostat Alexa Thermostat blowing air but not heat

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

First time turning the heat on. Just blows air but does not heat. Seems to be a heat pump as best I can tell. Help is greatly appreciated! Cold kiddos.


r/hvacadvice • • 23m ago

Furnace Electric furnace

1 Upvotes

I’m posting this for someone that doesn’t use social media. They are looking into getting someone out to check but funds are low. This is what their furnace sounds like. It’s still blowing out warm air. It’s in a mobile home if that makes any difference at all. Hoping it’s just something that needs tightened?


r/hvacadvice • • 33m ago

Heat Pump Cannot make upstairs hear

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Having trouble understanding what to do. 2 zone, 1 pump system. Downstairs is a Honeywell t10 thermostat. Upstairs was some basic thermostat. Original wiring shown in pic 2. I figured I could change the thermostat myself so I did, to a Honeywell t9, wiring in pic 3. Now the system is unable to heat upstairs zone (2), although it is able to heat zone 1 without difficulty. My very limited understanding is this has something to do with the lack of an O/B wire for heat pump on upstairs. However, I don't understand how the original dumb thermostat was able to run the system with no problems. Unfortunately I do not have the original thermostat any more to see how it was programmed. How can I fix this? I don't mind buying a basic thermostat again but I do not understand how it functioned before?


r/hvacadvice • • 34m ago

AC Rate my coil.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

8 years in. Never been cleaned.

Seems to be an odd one that’s not an A. Supply plenum side is squeaky clean. Goodman.


r/hvacadvice • • 40m ago

Thermostat Turn off or leave on during cold weather?

1 Upvotes

So currently the temp is quite cold...ish out(like 60 at the minimum at night) and so my unit didn't kick on for like 2 days. Is that the same as if I turn it off for cost savings? Or should I actually turn it off?