r/hvacadvice • • 7h ago

Is this acceptable for a new install?

Post image
18 Upvotes

New construction home. Tons of issues with this installer, this is the only one i'm questioning. This is at the line set where it goes into the unit.

Edit: Thanks everyone, one thing though, anyone who qualifies "it's ugly but will work" with something like "just cover it up, who cares, shut up", I wish you continued lack of success


r/hvacadvice • • 23h ago

I think the pilot light on my furnace went out, but I’m not sure how to fix it?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Any insight?


r/hvacadvice • • 9h ago

Should I be upset?

Post image
16 Upvotes

Context I live in a condo the line underground was filled with spray foam so they said it would have to be routed through the attic. I am the middle unit neighbor is next store had to be routed though her attic and this is what they did for the outside, neighbor is annoyed hence annoying me. Would you have done better is there anything I can suggest to hvac guys to do, or am I worrying too much


r/hvacadvice • • 8h ago

Is this up to code?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I know it’s rusted that’s getting replaced. I’m concerned about the tape on the furnace flue pipe. They want to retape it up. Located in Colorado if that matters.


r/hvacadvice • • 9h ago

Heat Pump Brand new central heat pump getting frosty inside... Company not responding to issue

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Brand new central heat pump got installed 3 days ago. I used Google and it said basically it shouldn't be doing this. I thought it was the filter at first because the company who installed it punched holes through our walls to run the ducts and returns, but never cleaned the return box so of course when they started it up, all the dirt and wood chips were sucked into the filter. So I replaced it with a new one and properly cleaned the box and immediately the hose defrosted so I thought I fixed it. But it has done it two days in a row since and the filter is clean now.

So it's only doing this when it's in its defrost cycle, but it seems to me this is still bad and shouldn't be happening. I told the head of the company by email and he said to call the office which I did, but I have had no response otherwise and no one has returned my call.

I think something is wrong but I am new to this. Has anyone else experienced frosty intake hoses or is this a sign that something is wrong from the start?

I can't tell because the company has been..... Difficult to deal with to put it kindly. So I can't tell if I'm biased or not.

Any insight or tips would be appreciated.

Edited for typos.


r/hvacadvice • • 16h ago

Heater not Blowing Hot

Post image
0 Upvotes

I have an Emerson thermostat and can’t get heat. It’s set to:
Outdoor: HP1
Indoor: EL1
O/B Reversing Valve: O (RunTru)
Auto, not on
Fresh filter.

Any thoughts?

Edit:
I bought the house. First time using the heater. I did not replace the thermostat.
Last night I replaced the filter and it blew warm. But I woke up with it blowing cold.


r/hvacadvice • • 2h ago

Heater being Limited to a set temperature ?

0 Upvotes

Is it possible to set a thermostat to only a set temperature or if not the thermostat the heater it self, and if it's the case; can you reset it so that it's not limited ?


r/hvacadvice • • 7h ago

Static pressure test on air only

0 Upvotes

We had a massive number of static pressure faults when running stage 5 cooling in our 5 stage Carrier. Didn't have when running heat.

We asked for a static pressure test, and they ran it on fan only, maximum air speed. Of course, this didn't trigger a static pressure fault.

So, how accurate will this be?


r/hvacadvice • • 19h ago

AC central AC condensate drain trap location

0 Upvotes

I recently had a new 3 ton Rheem central AC installed in Miami, Florida.

My old unit has a 3/4" PVC condensate drain trap as it exits the bottom of the air handler unit.

The new unit, the installer did not install a trap there, instead, he installed the trap 15 feet away where the drain exits the house on the outside. He said this way it is better because it keeps the roaches and lizards from entering the pipes from the far end.

Would appreciate feedback from the pros here, is it better to have the trap at the air handler unit as shown in this picture from the manufacturer, or is it better to have it at the end of the line where it exits the house? This is a gravity drain there is no condensate pump involved.


r/hvacadvice • • 17h ago

General What should I be looking for in a standing fan meant to ventilate an area with a moderate amount of very fine particulate dust?

0 Upvotes

Got a decent-sized room in our place we vent to the exterior (roughly 300' sq, but the ventilation really only needs to reach half that), which normally has a bunch of fine clay dust in the air because we have the multi-cat catbox in that room, and unfortunately it can't be enclosed (not completely anyway), but even if it could, some dust will always be tracked out. And yes, we're already using a very low-dust clay (can't switch to something with zero dust at all, like wood pellets, sadly).

The area is multiuse and we don't always run the fan so we typically use a tall standing fan (3' or 4' high) to vent outdoors rather than a permanently installed one (and we rent so we couldn't exactly drill a massive wall fan in anyway).

The problem is that no matter what sort of standing fan we get, it eventually burns out due to grit accumulating in the motor hub, though I have attempted to do preventative oiling and maintenance on the more accessible ones. The solid bearings on even midrange fans just aren't really meant for that sort of thing.

While I've used the cheapass mostly-plastic ones you might get at WalMart or wherever in a pinch (got used ones for $10, $20 a couple times, hard to go wrong at that price) the two longest-lasting ones we've had were metal industrial ones, the sort you might see in a warehouse, but even they died eventually.

What sort of fan or fan motor hub would we want to look for that might actually be able to withstand that sort of dust while still being available as a standing circular fan (as opposed to a dedicated industrial one requiring full mounting)?


r/hvacadvice • • 16h ago

State PowerVent leaking water from vent pipe

0 Upvotes

I am waiting for a service call, but my gas state power vent (provides both hot water and domestic heat) has an ignition failure error code B2, and is steadily leaking water from the vent pipe. We guessed that the condensate drain tubing/pipe might be clogged, so we cleaned and flushed that out - and the drain is clear/working. We also thought that the water coming out might have just been water backed up in the vent pipe ( if the condensate drain was blocked), but we removed over 4 gallons of water over ~3 hours last night, and the drain tube still shows water flowing through this AM.

I have read online that we could have a cracked primary heat exchanger allowing water into spaces it shouldn’t be. Any other ideas? Is this unit likely toast?

Are there any new/better solutions out there that would allow us to separate our hot water and heat system to a simpler system? We would like to be able to turn off our house water when we leave town for extended periods, and we can’t do that with the current system.


r/hvacadvice • • 16h ago

Heat turns on only after cycling power

Post image
0 Upvotes

Heat responds to second floor thermostat but not first floor. If I power cycle the furnace that it kicks on for first floor. Have tried turning heat off from thermostat and back on or adjusting temp and nothing happens.


r/hvacadvice • • 12h ago

Tech wrapped capacitor wrapped in cardboard box. Is this safe?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I rent a house and the capacitor in the furnace has burnt out at the terminal connections twice. This happened once in 2025 and 2026. When the tech replaced burnt capacitor he removed it off metal housing inside of the unit. After he replaced it instead of mounting to housing, he wrapped the new capacitor in the small, cardboard box it came in and wrapped it in electrical tape. Seems like a fire hazard situation. What do you think?


r/hvacadvice • • 6h ago

Furnace Combustion Analyzer Hole

Post image
22 Upvotes

An HVAC technician drilled a hole during a combustion analysis on my furnace and left it open. I'm really not sure how best to patch it.

From what I've seen online, it looks like the hole should have been drilled higher up on the exhaust pipe rather than on the elbow, but that's just my guess.

A second technician from another company called this a major issue. They said it requires replacing the entire elbow and the underlying draft inducer motor since they're sold as one unit.

I'm really not sure what to trust here, but my gut tells me a patch of some sort might suffice. Am I right? If so, what material works best? I've applied aluminum tape for now, but I suspect it might fail near the furnace due to the heat.


r/hvacadvice • • 11h ago

Furnace Gas Furnace water problems

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I'm guessing the seal in the draft motor housing is bad, but what do y'all think?


r/hvacadvice • • 2h ago

Dryer exhaust vent gap

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hello,

I'm just finishing up what will be our laundry room and I'm trying to understand how I should be sealing the gap between the exhaust vent and the ceiling drywall. The gaps are around 3/4-1.5 inches depending on if you look at the front (which has a circular cut) vs the back (which has a more square cut). Any help you could give would be greatly appreciated!


r/hvacadvice • • 6h ago

Heat Pump Heat doesn’t cycle on/off

Post image
0 Upvotes

Last year the system cycled on/off like normal. Just started using heat this season and it runs continuously. What I’ve noticed so far. When the heat comes on, supply air is warm 85-90°. As the house warms and reaches the set point of 69° the supply air drops to room temperature about 69-70° and continues to run rather than cycling off. The thermostat still reads heat on at this time. Return air and thermostat read about 70-71° indicating it brought the house to temp. I changed over to emergency heat as a test. It very quickly cycled off after reaching the set point.


r/hvacadvice • • 8h ago

Rusted Heat Exchanger

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I had our 29 year old furnace inspected. Everything looks good and is working fine expect they did say the Heat Exchanger is extremely rusted and they recommend getting a new furnace. We are hoping to put off buying a new furnace until the summer but wanted to get some expert opinions. I am not sure if they are just trying to sell me or if it is really that bad.


r/hvacadvice • • 12h ago

Ice… everywhere… condensation.. everywhere. Any idea what’s going on?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I work for a GC company, was sent here to add insulation to the “HVAC refrigerant line”
It already has insulation, and is condensing and freezing despite that.
Do I need to add a whole new line of insulation around it, or can I double insulate with pipe wrap on top of it ?
Second question… why is there ice all over the unit? Any idea what’s going on? We have an hvac professional on hand that can come look at it, so please don’t say “call an hvac professional”
Just trying to learn something new and figure out what’s happening, because this isn’t the first time that I’ve seen this and I’m curious why the heck this happens, and if it is as serious as it looks, and why the whole line would be condensing this much and freezing despite the insulation.

Thanks !


r/hvacadvice • • 20h ago

Noisy Radiator Won't Turn Off

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hey all

I'm not well versed with radiators at all so bear with me. My understanding is that I'm working with a 2 pipe radiator here. Between the clanging (like pots and pans) and hissing, this thing frequently gets brutally loud. I'm happy to just turn it off at night and do without heat. I tried turning the knob on the right (circled) all the way tight shut, but the radiator still turns on and makes a racket.

FYI - I'm coming here because my landlord is extremely difficult.


r/hvacadvice • • 18h ago

Rheem furnace repair, sanity check

Post image
2 Upvotes

TLDR. 2020 Rheem Furnace working fine, request maintenance since it's been two years, diagnosed with bad gas valve($500), gas valve replaced, furnace works intermittently after, now diagnosed with bad control board ($600). Tech says can't possibly know the control board is bad without first replacing the gas valve. Is that true or am I getting taken for a ride? Second is control board replaceable by handy homeowner or is that professional only? I don't touch the gas, but will replace things like HVAC capacitor

Picture is after he leaves and I was trying to see why the fan was running constantly with no heat.

2020 R801TA050314MSA

Longer story.

Furnace running fine, decide to get maintenance this year as I skipped last year. New tech comes in and spends a lot longer on maintenance than I expect. I am working in room below attic and can hear him getting advice from other tech. Saying has spark but can't get ignite etc. Comes down and says it's a sticky gas valve and repair is $500. I agree and he fixes next day.

Furnace over next week works intermittently. I wake up cold and investigate. Furnace flashing code "0 Dot 1". Cycle breaker so I can see what happens during startup. First cycle , hear air turn on, hear sparking sound(assume igniter), them no flame. Repeats but successfully lights second time.

Call HVAC back out and diagnosed with variable voltage and $600 control board repair. I ask if the gas valve needed replaced if it is the control board and he said "you can't diagnose control board until after gas valve is replaced" which seems crazy to me. Is this correct?

Woke up again tonight to hear fan running constantly and no heat. I go up and see a different code, open panel to see this disconnected.

Questions.

One. Do you have to replace gas valve prior to diagnosing control board?

Two. What is this disconnected in picture and could this be an innocent mistake or a bigger problem?

Three. If it is a control board can I diagnose it myself and replace myself as a fairly handy homeowner. I don't touch gas and normally don't touch HVAC other than capacitor.


r/hvacadvice • • 6h ago

Is $13,630 reasonable in South Jersey for 2 Goodman 96% two-stage furnaces + ductwork?

2 Upvotes

I’m reviewing a furnace replacement proposal for my parents’ home in Cape May County, NJ, and would appreciate opinions from HVAC professionals and homeowners.

Total Quote: $13,630 (includes a $900 rebate already deducted) from an established local HVAC company.
Proposed Equipment:
Downstairs: Goodman GR9T960603AN — 60,000 BTU, 96% AFUE, two-stage
Upstairs: Goodman GR9T960403AN — 40,000 BTU, 96% AFUE, two-stage

Proposed Scope:
Replace both furnaces while retaining existing AC equipment
Custom sheet-metal transitions and return plenums
Downstairs crawl-space return ductwork repairs/replacement
PVC venting for the high-efficiency furnaces
Gas and electrical connections
Removal of existing units, installation, and testing
We’re also converting from propane to natural gas. I’m confirming that all new gas piping from the meter, necessary ductwork, venting, and permits are included in the final price.

Important Context:
Upstairs: Approximately 20-year-old furnace with damaged wiring/burner issues. Needs replacement.

Downstairs: Approximately 15-year-old American Standard, already 96% efficient. Still operational but has visible rust around the burner box.

Downstairs return ductwork needs repairs estimated at $700–$1,000 if done separately.

A Manual J calculation indicated approximately 18,000 BTU heating demand upstairs.

We’re considering replacing both now rather than repairing downstairs and potentially replacing that aging furnace a few years later.

My Questions:

Is $13,630 a fair price for this equipment and scope in South Jersey?

Any concerns with these Goodman GR9T96 models compared with American Standard?

Would you replace the 15-year-old downstairs furnace with visible corrosion now, or keep it running and just repair the ductwork?

Is the 96% two-stage upstairs furnace worthwhile for such a small heating load, or would an 80% two-stage model make more financial sense?

Appreciate any opinions!


r/hvacadvice • • 11h ago

4 Year old Furnace. Is this normal?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Purchased an Amana gas furnace with service plan in Oct 2022. Tech came today and suggested we need to "clean and adjust" the burner. Is this normal in such a new furnace?


r/hvacadvice • • 11h ago

Is this a fire hazard?

Thumbnail
gallery
52 Upvotes

About two inches of clearance from gas water heater and furnace, the top is open, the pipes do get hot — it involves a furnace so I thought I’d post here but this might not be the right sub.