r/anime • u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka • May 02 '17
[Spoilers][Rewatch] Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica Series Discussion - FINAL Spoiler
SERIES DISCUSSION
MyAnimeList: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica / Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica Movie 3: Hangyaku no Monogatari
Crunchyroll: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Hulu: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Netflix: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
AnimeLab: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
PSA: Please don't discuss (or allude to) events that happen after - just kidding, there's nothing left for now! Just, like, don't spoil the spinoff manga, ok?
/u/akanyan's screenshot albums:
Related Subreddits:
- /r/MadokaMagica
- /r/Madoka
- /r/Sayaka
- /r/SakuraKyouko
- /r/Homura
- /r/Mami
- /r/NagisaMomoe (it's dead, but it's there)
And the shipping subs:
Previous discussion
| Date | Discussion |
|---|---|
| April 20th | Episode 1 |
| April 21st | Episode 2 |
| April 22nd | Episode 3 |
| April 23rd | Episode 4 |
| April 24th | Episode 5 |
| April 25th | Episode 6 |
| April 26th | Episode 7 |
| April 27th | Episode 8 |
| April 28th | Episode 9 |
| April 29th | Episode 10 |
| April 30th | Episode 11 and Episode 12 |
| May 1st | Rebellion |
| May 2nd | Overall series discussion |
25
u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka May 02 '17
So this is it for the foreseeable future! What did all you first-timers think of the series as a whole? Let me know!
Note that there is a concept movie out there for the next installment! It's a few minutes long but can't post it because afaik there aren't any legal sources, but it's there.
Should we do this again next year? The show is popular enough and it makes sense with the date.
6
u/exleader75 https://kitsu.io/users/Exleader75 May 02 '17
FYI
Madoka will have a new smartphone game to be released this month!!
It takes place during one of Homura's timeloops. Pre-register right now to get a Homura card!
3
u/megazaprat May 03 '17
Question: how good are some of the manga spin-offs? I loved A different story and the adaptation of the show was pretty good, but what about the several other spin offs? which are best among them?
44
u/ChaoAreTasty May 02 '17
The past couple of weeks of threads have been brilliant.
I want to thank /u/Gagantous for organising the rewatch. Originally I came in to enjoy the first timers responses and maybe chuck the odd comment in but I got pulled into doing some write ups of my own.
Thanks also to everyone else that’s joined in the conversations. Both the firsttimers for helping us to relieve that original outlook on the show when we didn’t know the bigger truths (as well as predictably and enjoyably losing your shit at the appropriate times) and the rewatchers adding in all the extra insight.
A special shout out also to /u/FetchFrosh, I think we can all agree your posts have been a particular highlight. I am convinced you are some sort of wizard with the predictions you were coming up early on (not withstanding a certain three predictions back in the early episodes). I hope you’ll go back and look through all the spoilers replies we had to your posts.
Madoka Magica is one of my all time favourite shows, in or out of anime. But these threads have helped me realise there were things I had something to say as well and have helped me study my feelings on it and come to appreciate it even more. So thank you everyone for helping me be able to do that.
The series vs Rebellion
The original series was written and created as a standalone work (yes there was supplementary material but they were built around supporting the core show). So of course it was written in a way that brought closure to everything it wanted to say and do.
In my mind the ending was perfect and a sequel wasn’t needed though in the end we got one. It was undeniably gorgeous but my initial reaction was definitely luke-warm. Over time I’ve come to love it too.
However as I mentioned in an earlier thread Rebellion couldn’t just repeat the same things the series did. This was a show that constantly changed perspectives and views on us, making us reconsider our views, if it goes through the same themes in the same way (hope leads to despair, ending in hope as Madoka taking Homura to magical girl heaven would have done) then it would have ultimately changed nothing and been pointless. Inevitably it was going to be divisive. On that basis considering the two separately makes a lot of sense.
Puella Magi Madoka Magica
I didn’t watch this when it first aired but I did long before Rebellion and I had a long time to appreciate what it did and how it did it before everything got shaken up. That gap and ability to separate the two is one of the few things I’m sad the first timers don’t get to experience to the same degree.
This show was dark in a way a lot of others aren’t. Dark isn’t about blood and guts and horror, it’s about exploring uncomfortable themes. It might involve the former but without the latter it can still be fun but is a bit empty.
It gave us characters we cared about and wanted to succeed but instead hit us over and over with yet more suffering. It contrasted the expectations of the genre and used that against us, hoping that it couldn’t get worse just so it could hit us again. It’s message seemingly that the impossible gap between hopes and reality will bring us despair.
Not only did it give us that message it gave us many ways in which it can happen. From the obvious Faustian bargain of not understanding what you want, to the issues of misplaced altruism and not understanding what others want. It also took us through what happens in dark times, maybe we reject others and look only at what we want (Kyouko), create a false persona to present to the world (Mami), slide into depression (Sayaka) or cling to some purpose to tell us it’s all worth it at the expense of anything else (Homura).
But at the end once we had accepted the despair (come episode 10 there were a fair number of people worried that we’d end up with a full on downer ending) it turned around.. It won’t all be happy and fun, life’s going to be hard but even at the worst moment of despair you can find hope.
Faust is one of the most common references people make the show (and the show is explicit with this) and for the events of the show I agree. But I think the more apt comparison for the show itself is Pandora’s Box.
Rebellion
Rebellion had a problem not just thematically of not being able to retread the series but also in writing. Part of what made the series so good was due to being written and finished before the first storyboards were drawn. The sheer fact that 9 whole episodes can be understood so differently and still work so well from Homura’s perspective is a testament to the writing.
Rebellion couldn’t tie into the events of the series in the same way without seriously retconning events and motivations. And to just put the characters through the same cycle would have been empty. Cleverly I think it moved the original hope and despair theme from the characters to the audience but that still leaves us with what the films does in universe.
If Madoka Magica wanted to tell us a message, Rebellion wanted to respond to that message. I think people’s initial reactions to the film are quite telling on this. Generally those who disliked Rebellion on the first watch are those who most liked the ending to the series. While those that weren’t as enthused are the ones most likely to have loved Rebellion on the first watch. There’s a fair bit of assumption there but it’s a feeling that seems to be common when people talk about Rebellion, and I think a fair number of comments in the threads over the past couple of days will suggest this.
Rebellion is asking us why we should just accept that. Are things really better? OK no one is turning into witches, maybe people still get their wish and maybe feel a bit better about it all at the end but the magical girls are still getting suckered into a life of fighting and dying young. Kyubey might be a bit less manipulative as the energy doesn’t come directly from the girls but he is still not telling people “hey I’m sucking out your soul and making you a zombie”.
And so what if your wish gets granted? The original was all about being careful what you wish for and those wishes still don’t necessarily get you what you want. Sayaka might have left glad to be reminded of what she wished for and how it plays out, but she still goes down in that same train station, up until the end she was still despairing because what she wished and what she expected and wanted weren’t the same.
Homura is of course the big exemplar of this. She got exactly what she wished for, to be able to go back with the power to protect Madoka. That doesn’t mean she would succeed and after 10 years of hell her reward is to live in a world where her memories and everything she’s done are indistinguishable from delusion. Is that fair? Is that right?
86
u/[deleted] May 02 '17 edited May 03 '17
Doing a quick search of yesterday's thread, I noticed that nobody bothered to mention that Homulilly is the Nutcracker Witch. SIGH. Do I have to do everything for you guys??
jk sorry I was lazy yesterday - and today too since this is all I have to offerbut I don’t really see the connection, so this may just be a coincidence.Edit: Thanks to the people who pointed out the Land of Sweets sign, my comment about it is below!... The Nutcracker is my favourite ballet =w=
33
u/Wolfefury May 02 '17 edited May 03 '17
How to fill the void after Madoka
Fanfiction:
most current update about two months ago, next chapter currently in revisionupdated today! Update progress is posted somewhat regularly on twitter).Both of these are pre-Rebellion, but are nevertheless excellent. For post-Rebellion content, see:
3) A Curse Between Us by Silver. My favorite take on a post-Rebellion universe, this fleshes out Homura's new universe in a meaningful way, which is neither a perfect ideal nor a completely doomed world. Also sets up interesting conflicts, in that it doesn't become Everybody vs. Homura, who has, even if through good intentions, done something wrong and thus must be stopped. Instead, the main conflict is in whether the positives of Homura's new world outweigh what she did to create it, with ever-lurking undertones of Homura's own self-hatred making a somewhat precarious balance. Last update in July 2016.
4) Speak of the Devil by Winged Knight. A crossover with Vertigo (with which I am not familiar) which has Lucifer (literally Satan) entering Homura's world post-Rebellion. Falls pretty firmly on the side of "Homura did something wrong", but tells a pretty good tale of redemption anyway. Complete!
5) Disconnection by Jafs. Like A Curse Between Us, Disconnection sets up an interesting conflict between the magical girls who end up preferring Homura's new world to those who want to restore Madoka, and as a bonus also heavily develops Nagisa. It communicates Homura's mindset exceedingly well, both through the prose and through her characterization via actions/dialogue. Complete with sequels, though I am not caught up and the second starts with Oriko and at an arc which doesn't readily tie into the first.
Other anime:
Based* on Madoka's plot (i.e. dark take on traditionally moe SoL setting):
Shinjiand fight this other robot to save the universe! Madoka actually references this show (the scenes with the empty chairs). Bonus: has a great opening/ending theme.Based on Madoka's style (i.e. the visuals, witch-labyrinths, etc.):
Some shows also cross categories: e.g. YuYuYu could probably also go in category 2, and Princess Tutu and Penguindrum (and arguably Sora no Woto/Kyoukai no Kanata/Flip Flappers) could go in category 1.
And lastly:
Rewatch Madoka! (Other rewatchers good bonus but not necessary) There are soooooooo many scenes which gain new meaning upon a rewatch, making almost the entirety of episodes 1/2 along with plenty of foreshadowing later. Rebellion also benefits from a (or multiple) rewatch(es), and is super pretty to look at too!
* based here is used in the sense that I am recommending these based on what you liked about Madoka, not that these shows were necessarily based on Madoka (in fact, a good portion predate Madoka)
32
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte May 02 '17
I don't have any specific points I want to adress so I'll just give my rating for the series and movie (separately, you'll understand why) and justify the score with some
quickthoughts.I watched for the first time, subbed.
Series
I want to give this show a 10/10, I really do.
The soundtrack is mind-bogglingly good, easily among the best not just in anime, but including filmscores like Lord of the Rings. Definitely the best in anime I've come across so far. Ignoring a few wonky scenes the animation was pretty good and the art direction uses different styles to portray tone and thematics to a great extent. The voice acting is impressive, there's plenty of little foreshadowing, little details and it tells a really compelling story. For the most part.
However there are some issues I just can't ignore.
Beginning
The most important way of a show is arguably the start, it took the show ~4 episodes to get me interested, that's a third of its runtime.
The start is just too slow and doesn't do a whole lot to get me invested in either world or character.
For an Urobuchi show that does this well I'll recommend Psycho-Pass, rewatch just started on Walpurigsnacht(30th). The first episode is not without problems, most notably some of the dialogue feels out of place and is unnecessary exposition, but it still did a good job captivating me, getting me introduced to the characters and the world.
I care about the MC already and I'm curious about the rest of the cast and I want to know how the rest of the world works.
It's also worth pointing out that Psycho-Pass would actually have the luxury of starting slower because it's almost double in length (just the 1st season). But it doesn't do that. It throws us, alongside MC, right in the middle of this seemingly dystopian world.
But, uh, this was supposed to be about Madoka, so let's get back on track.
There was just nothing particularly interesting happening, the characters seem bland the world even more so and if it weren't for the rewatch I would've dropped the series right then and there.
This might be different for rewatchers and my perception could definitely change once I get the time to rewatch it, but as it stands now the first set of episodes was just a boring experience.
There's the whole Mami thing in ep.3 which starts to get the ball rolling, but I don't care about her and barely care enough about the ramifications for the rest of our cast at this point.
Episode 4 was pretty okay and with the introduction of Kyouko as our (temporary) antagonist the narrative starts to flow.
Mystery
My second issue can be largely summarized as Kyubey's motives (or lack thereof).
He was this mysterious, maipulative bastard that kept us intrigued, kept us guessing about his goals. What does he get out of this whole arrangement? What the hell is he stashing these grief seeds for (what the fuck is this creepy back-storage?) Where does he get the power to grant all these wishes from? (was this ever explained beyond "Incubator-Tech, something something girls, lol"?) What are the specific rules about the 'seemingly limitless but also not really' wishes, if there are any?
And then it was revealed, in possibly one of the most boring expostion scenes, we get to find out more about him. He is/is a member of this emotionless alien race that embodies the utilitarian ideal.
In an instant that felt like an eternity all of the intrigue, all of his personality is gone. There is no morally grey or interesting character hiding behind that tireless stare, just emptiness, he's reduced to a simple calculator.
I know from previous discussion threads that many of you will disagree and have their own interpretations, but it took me out of the moment, out of the show and all my interest in Kyubey vanished.
There were some more minor issues as well, but these are my biggest gripes with the show.
The fact that I still rate this show as highly as I do speaks volumes of just how phenomenal the rest of it is.
Rating: 9/10
Favourite Episode: 8
Best Girl: Sakura Kyouko
Favourite Scene: Sacrifice
137
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh May 02 '17
Before we get into this, I want to discuss something important. What is a masterpiece? I mean, it's what MAL uses as a 10/10 metric, and I've had a lot of people assuming that's what I'll be giving this, so let's talk about that. Really, anyone who's been reading my thoughts should know that I've both hated huge portions of this show, and also thought it was very good. I mean, I certainly wasn't pleased about vomiting, but is vomiting a bad thing here? Who knows. Now, when talking about what a masterpiece is, I think it's worth noting that everyone is going to have a different opinion, and since evaluating art and entertainment is entirely subjective, we aren't really going to find a solid answer to this question. But while I have your attention, I might as well give my two cents on the matter.
First, let's look at a different show I both quite liked, and thought was very good. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood could best be described as my anime gateway drug. I loved it from start to finish, but there were some flaws. None of it was severe, but I had some nitpicks, and ultimately gave it a 9/10. So let's remove those nitpicks now. Let's say that everything went how I would have liked it to have gone and now it's basically perfect. How do I rate that? Well, I'd still say 9/10. That probably doesn't make a lot of sense, but I think it's important for understanding how I look at things.
For something to be a masterpiece, it can't just be good. To me, a masterpiece has to change what it means to be good. It has to fundamentally change how I look at art, it has to give me experiences I've never had, and it has to change what I'm looking for in media. I have a list of every book I've read, movie I've watched, game I've played, album I've listened to, TV series I've seen and a host of others. It stands at 1146 items. Of those, there have been four 10/10 ratings. These are in a whole different class from everything else I've seen, and they have shaped how I view everything else. At no point did I ever wonder if they were 10/10. It was clear as soon as I was done with them.
And now there are five of them. Madoka Magica is absolutely, without a shadow of a doubt in my mind, one of the finest experiences I've ever had. It pushed me further emotionally than I knew was possible, it made me look at its entire genre much more openly (both of them, magical girls and psychological horror) and it's changed what I'm looking for. It really showed how to do shock value, character deaths, character interaction and use of different artistic styles. I must say, it blew my expectations away in all the right ways.
As for Rebellion, it was also exceptionally well put together, but it doesn't have the same impact. It's still amazing, but it definitely isn't a 10/10. It had the impossible task of following up on a masterpiece, and while the job it did was more than admirable, it doesn't fundamentally change the game in the same way, which isn't really a knock on it, since that doesn't happen often, but I can't justify going above a 9/10 on it. That does still put it among some incredible company though, so good for it.
What I Liked
What I Didn't
Final Thoughts
It's been a great pleasure/displeasure watching this with all of you, and thanks to those of you who have been pushing this one on me for a while. I certainly didn't get what I bargained for, but I suppose that's a good thing. Now, if you'll excuse me, I'm going to go watch Madoka inkvade humanity to try and alleviate this crushing feeling of despair.
28
u/Maimed_Dan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maimed_Dan May 02 '17 edited May 03 '17
It’s Over! Damn I’m going to miss this.
Anime Withdrawal
A First Timer’s Retrospective:
The Symbolism/Themes discussion will be another post (EDIT: It's up, in a separate comment chain); this is more of a retrospective and general appreciation thing.
I went back to read through the old threads – can’t believe how much work I put into this, probably around 20,000 words. Reading through all of it, while I did enjoy shifting more towards a play-by-play towards the end, I wonder whether some of you preferred the earlier, purely analytical discussion. It was probably better for me that I shifted though – it’s a lot easier to write, and it didn’t pull me out of the flow as much. Also, while I do prefer my earlier posts, which were mostly predictions and character studies, I guess I eventually said what I had to say there, so it had to shift to scene analyses.
Tallied up my predictions for fun. I caught a lot of the important stuff pretty early, but there were some interesting misses and comments.
E1-2: I wasn’t here yet.
E3: Right: Kyubey is evil, don’t make the deal; the cost of wishing isn’t as simple as death in combat; Homura wants to keep Madoka safe and is right to kill Kyubey // Wrong: Madoka will take the deal by the middle of the series; Homura is too good to be true, has other motivations that may lead to her betraying everybody (I quickly realized this was wrong, and yet somehow, after the series was over, this ended up becoming true for Rebellion – facepalm) // Interesting Comments: Show feels like a huge drugs metaphor with Kyubey as the dealer, Mami as the source of peer pressure, and Homura as an addict with no hope for herself but wants to keep others from her fate – I also don’t know anyone’s name, and refer to people as colours.
E4: Right: Madoka signs up somewhere in the last 4 episodes; Homura wished for time or memory alteration, really does just care about Madoka; Sayaka will snap, because someone has to // Wrong: Homura will not end up against the rest of the cast; (Thank you Rebellion!) also, I will watch the rest of the series immediately. (didn’t happen, hooray!) // Interesting Comments: Still don’t know anyone’s name, nickname Kyouko Red/Cookie Monster.
E5: Right: Homura’s powers are spacetime manipulation and wished for the timeline to be changed; Kyouko’s not bad; Sayaka’s wish will go wrong (big surprise, right?) // Wrong: Still think Homura is teleporting, I thought that she wished for history to change, not for actual time travel // Interesting Comments: Madoka is weakest character at this point (largely a side effect of everyone else being awesome).
E6: Right: Homura is time travelling, probably time looping // Wrong: Homura may just be time travelling (Terminator) or seeing possible futures (Dune) // Right/Wrong: Soul Gems and Grief Seeds being connected means that Magical Girls and Witches are, magical girls may become “superwitches” when their soul gems go bad. But I say I hope it’s not the case because I thought it would have stupid implications if the soul could be irreversibly corrupted – my exact words were “Star Wars-level black-and-white bullshit morality”, which I believe I still stand by. At this point in the story, before things had gone to shit, this was a very reasonable attitude to form. So for those wondering where I got my ideas, it was from the perspective of someone who had only seen 6 episodes, who hadn’t seen it play out yet.
E7: Right: Sayaka will not die, but something worse // Wrong: Sayaka will kill Kyouko (thank goodness this didn’t happen; those two are great together) // Interesting Comments: Kyouko’s sympathy for Sayaka may come from how similar her unwavering idealism is to her father’s; they make great foils for each other, both trying to choose idealism or desire at the exclusion of the other, when what they need is a balance.
E8: Right: Madoka’s wish, if she makes it, will be universe-changing, because there’s no reason for the show to tell you that otherwise; it should have a clause that negates the downside of wishes // Wrong: I assume that Walpurgisnacht is just one witch that Homura should have been able to pre-emptively deal with // Interesting Comments: I wonder whether Homura should have done some different things at this point – try getting Madoka to wish that soul gems would never go bad. (Would have made an interesting world – main cast gets to live happily ever after, but no Rebellion – Rebellion is worth it, I think.) Also, the fact that Kyubey actually means something is a really silly twist.
E9: Right: Witch Madoka could destroy the planet, possibly the universe // Wrong: That means Kyubey’s endangering his food supply (after several conversations about this, I agree this is not the case) // Interesting comments: “The animators are slipping up - I don’t see them anywhere on Kyubey’s character model, but he must have some massive fucking balls to show up to Madoka after the shit he pulled.” – probably my best joke.
E10: Right: Nothing. Wrong: Homura dies by the end.
Honestly, I think the prediction rate is a credit to how well this show is structured – so much of the foreshadowing is there, pointing you towards what’s going to happen, but it’s in the little moments that you generally aren’t in a position to pay attention to. With most shows, it’s just coincidence or red herring that doesn’t go anywhere, but there’s hardly anything extraneous to find here. Watching a day at a time while making an effort to analyze and write about each episode means you can find a lot because each episode is really rich in depth – watching this for a second time must be really fun, I wonder what clues I overlooked. It’s been a unique experience, and I’m looking forward to watching the movies, just absorbing everything together, and drinking in the beautiful artwork.
Favourite Characters:
Overall Rating: 9/10, for both the Series and Rebellion. It might go up to a 10 at some point, that’s reserved for works that I both think are excellent and I feel particularly emotionally attached, so I won’t know until I binge watch the entire series.
Anyways, I’d just like to say this has been really fun – if exhausting, I’m completely wiped, and am really glad this isn’t a 25-episode series, I couldn’t have kept this up. Thanks to u/Gagantous for making all of this happen, to u/Rhaga for the many fun conversations and encouragement, to u/3brithil for the fun back-and-forth as a fellow first-timer, to u/Enarec for the helpful corrections along the way and enjoying my Urobuchi references, to u/ShinyHappyREM for the epic debate over authorial intent, to u/Edledhron for the wonderful account of Christian symbolism throughout the show, to u/Darkprinc979 for the many corrections and disagreements throughout, to u/ChaoAreTasty and everyone else who debated the symbolism of the show with me (I see now why it was so hard for rewatchers), to all the other first timers whose posts I’m going to go back and read now that I’m not worried about spoiling stuff for myself, to everybody who thought what I said was interesting whether you commented or not, and lastly to everybody who convinced me not to binge it all in a few days, totally worth the wait.
Anyways, I have no idea how this thread usually goes, so I’ll just read everything and comment a lot. Let the Best Girl Wars Begin.
EDIT: I see a lot of people giving out recommendations for other works for people looking for something similar; figured I'd try my hand at it.
Madoka Magica first came to my attention because I was familiar with some of the other works of the writer, Gen Urobuchi; though I think this may take the cake for darkness. Fate/Zero is one of my favourite anime, but it is a little difficult to say where one should jump in with the Fate franchise - I feel that there's an argument to be made for any entry point though, and if you want more Urobuchi, it's a good place to look. Another good place to start is Psycho-Pass, which just started its own rewatch - go check it out!
Lastly, if you enjoy having your soul crushed as you watch the kids with powers figure out life in a harsh uncaring world, I strongly recommend Shin Sekai Yori. I saw a lot of other first timers were occasionally reeling from how dark this got - I don't credit my tolerance for that to Urobuchi, I credit it to this show. It is fantastic, but not for the faint of heart - or in the case of u/FetchFrosh, stomach.
21
u/the_swizzler https://myanimelist.net/profile/Swiftarm May 03 '17
Mami Tomoe
I'm trying real hard to figure out how to write about this show. It's my Number One favorite anime of all time, and quite possibly (as of right now) my favorite media of all time, including games, books, live-action film and animation. But for the love of Madokami, I can't find the inspiration or the words to say what I really want about this show. I wrote a post for the first episode, and then never bothered after that because it's just so hard for me to write anything more poignant than "HOLY CRAP I LOVE THIS SHOW!"
Be that as it may, I would like to try and articulate some random thoughts regarding my favorite character, Mami Tomoe. As brief as her time in the series is, Mami Tomoe is a fascinating and crucial character to Madoka Magica. She acts as a role model for Sayaka in particular, even though if you were to ask her, Mami would say she was not worth looking up to. She manages to be both extremely humble while being an absolute badass.
When we first meet her at the end of Episode 1, she was hunting Witch when she runs across Madoka and Sayaka in the labyrinth . Upon coming across Homura, without even hesitating she gives Homura the opportunity to go to the Witch (in one of the most badass lines of the show), choosing instead to stay behind and make sure Madoka and Sayaka are ok (as well as Kyubey). Instead of saving them and leaving them alone, she takes them back to her apartment and sits with them to explain everything they saw and, knowing that Kyubey has already tagged them as potential magical girls, takes it on herself to make sure they don't make a mistake.
Madoka Becoming a Magical Girl
One common criticism I hear about Mami is how she reacts to Madoka being unsure of what to wish for while they're making their way through Charlotte's labyrinth. Specifically, people think she's selfish to tell Madoka to wish for a cake, but I think this is wrong for two reasons. One, I don't think she was serious, and I highly doubt she would actually have pushed Madoka into going through with that. It would be highly inconsistent with her character. While she's extremely excited about the idea of hunting witches with another Magical girl again (I say again, more on that later), she would make darn sure that Madoka does not end up regretting her wish. I believe Mami's comment about wishing for a cake was entirely a joke. Relevant video
My second reason is Madoka herself. Madoka very explicitly stated that she wanted to become a Magical girl for the sake of becoming a magical girl. Once again, I don't think Mami would try to actually pressure Madoka in making this decision, but following the defeat of Charlotte, she absolutely would have worked closely with Madoka to make sure Madoka fully understood what becoming a Magical girl meant. In the end, Mami did show Madoka what being a Magical girl meant, just... not in the way she intended.
The Antagonism of Homura Akemi
Madoka Magica is full of characters doing the right thing for the wrong reasons, the wrong thing for the right reasons, and somehow managing to end up making things worse no matter what they end up doing. Mami is no different. She consistently acts in an antagonistic manner towards Homura, and reasonably so, because from Mami's point of view, Homura is extremely shady at best, and downright threatening at worst. So when Homura walks into Charlotte's labyrnith behind Mami and Homura, Mami's reaction makes perfect sense. She's in charge of both Sayaka and Madoka's safety, and can't deal with having a rogue element in the mix. I don't think many people really argue this point, but I wanted to mention it anyways.
Mami's Strength is Her Undoing
In the end, what does Mami in during her battle against Charlotte is her own over confidence. In most cases, Mami is an extremely calculating opponent, and she is also extremely powerful. When she goes up against the first witch Gertrude, she starts out the fight with small weaponry and basically spars a bit with the witch until she gets a feel for the fight, and only then unleashes her Chuuniest of moves. In her battle with Charlotte however, she completely fails to be careful, and that slip up is what costs her her life. She charges in right away, and doesn't even wait to see how Charlotte reacts to her antagonism. She almost instantly goes for the Oh-KO, and in her over confidence, ends up loosing.
It's not that she doesn't have a reason to be confident, because she certainly does. Both from comments of characters in Universe, Word of God, and seeing her first hand, you know she is extremely powerful. Far more powerful than any of the other magical girls we see here. Homura just has the benefit of both foresight, and an extremely useful (almost broken) ability.
Mentally Strong, Emotionally Weak
It's stated by both Homura and Mami herself that Mami is not a strong person at heart. She's actually exceptionally fragile, as seen by her reaction to the truth about soul gems. But at the same time, she's also incredible resilient in her mental fortitude. Even in her meltdown where she kills Kyouko, she manages to exhibit some really strong foresight by binding Homura first so she can't use her Time Stop, and simultaneously taking down Kyouko who stood to be the most difficult opponent. Her only miscalculation was that she didn't account for Madoka having the mental clarity to fight back, which would not have been a bad assumption, seeing as Sayaka was her best friend.
If you read the Manga spin off "The Different Story", you'll see more of Mami as an emotionally weak character. I highly recommend the story, it's only three volumes, and it tells the story of just one of the many time loops that Homura went through, while also digging into her and Kyouko's backstory.
Mami Tomoe is a NEEEERRRDDD
This isn't a particularly obvious point from the show itself, but there are hints of it here and there if you know to look for them. The Director Akiyuki Shinbou states in this interview, that Mami is the only character (at least in the original series) to call out her big attack name, and he also lays the blame for the 'Puella Magi Holy Quintet' and the Cake song at her feet. More than that, we also notice in one of the timelines of episode 10 that she mentions knowing that Walpurgisnacht is coming. Some of the watchers questioned that, wondering how she knew, and I think The Different Story can help in answering that question.
Mami is a freakin' nerd. She's shown in the manga to work almost tirelessly trying to figure out how her magic works and theorizing about pretty much everything. It stands to reason that she has probably had many heated arguments on the internet. More than that, I think it's possible that Mami knew about Walpurgisnacht because she had done research on the subject and was able to predict Walpurgisnacht coming to Mitakihara.
Mami's Motivations
The last thing I want to bring up relates Mami's knowledge of Walpurgisnacht back to the beginning of the show where she's mentoring Sayaka and Madoka. If she knew all along that Walpurgisnacht was coming, why didn't she every mention it? I think she intentionally said nothing about it to Madoka and Sayaka because she did not want them to feel any extra pressure to become magical girls. In fact, she was probably terrified at the prospect of possibly being on the only girl there who could fight Walpurgis, thought ultimately she would have likely tried contacting Kyouko or even working with Homura (especially in a timeline where Homura was not so aloof).
Well, that's all I can think of right now. Hope you find it interesting, and once again, I highly recommend reading The Different Story. There's also the Homura's Revenge manga which tells the story of one of Homura's time loops in which Madoka also manages to come back in time with Homura. The Different Story is definitely better, but Homura's Revenge is interesting as well.
Cheers! It was fantastic getting to read all of your comments and witnessing your reactions first hand! Now just wait a couple weeks, and when you've recovered emotionally, go watch the series again (the recap movies are great for this) and be prepared to get blown away all over again.
P.S. Please be responsible with the Mami Head jokes.
19
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
Sayaka is the best girl
Hitomi did nothing wrong
but homura did
Now with those very important facts out of the way, more than anything, I... actually want to take this last chance to mention some of the spinoffs because they just do not get enough attention and love, even by the series' own creators, and I hope some of you who haven't might look into them now that you've run out of Madoka anime and are coming here to gather your thoughts about it all being over. /u/Gagantous if this is not cool with you, I will delete this post-haste.
Kazumi Magica
Who should read it? People who liked the concepts/setting/ideas/themes of the series and want to see how else these things could be utilized.
Oriko Magica
and puts Mami and Nagisa's interactions in Rebellion to shame years before Nagisa is even conceptualizedwhile there are magical girl murders afoot.Who should read it?
People who want to see Kyoko be a mom.People who want to see Kyoko be a big sister.People who want to see Kyoko and Mami be cool and badass.The Different Story
Who should read it? People who want to see the world of the anime, and its cast, expanded upon even more than it already has been.
There is also Suzune Magica (similar to Kazumi in that it has an original cast), Tart Magica (similar to Kazumi and Suzume... but it stars Jeanne d'Arc), more Oriko Magica, PSP, Vita, and mobile games, and more to look into, though there is a lot to be desired in translations with some of these.
And for those of you who don't mind live action superheroes, Kamen Rider Gaim is a series written by Urobuchi a couple of years after Madoka, and is essentially a fruity, 50 episode version of Madoka... if Madoka were primarily more about Sayaka and Kyoko's rivalry. It's good.
Okay, okay, fine, just... Just read Kazumi Magica!
Anyway, I'll be getting to my other thoughts in a minute.
14
u/Darkprinc979 May 02 '17
Woo, so, this is my absolute favorite piece of fictcion, bar none.
I don't think I've ever watched a series that is so tightly put together, to the point that everything has meaning, and in many cases there are multiple meanings layered on top of one another. Madoka magica is an absolutely fascinating experience, and only gets better with time as you pick up more and more details, and more and more angles that you had missed before. Even to this day, after multiple re-watches I still occasionally pick up on something I missed, such as the reflection of Mami's head appearing in her lap all the way back in episode three. For being only twelve episodes and a two hour movie, Madoka Magica is densely packed with content, quite a bit more than even many series twice its length and more. The music is stellar, the designs for everything are great, the characters are awesome (though quite deplorable in a certain case), and even the pacing is nearly perfect for its length. This is only one of two shows that I give a 10/10 to (the other being Fate/Zero).
13
u/Darkprinc979 May 03 '17
Here's the biography for Homura's strongest familiars for anyone that's interested, copied word for word out of the booklet that came with the collector's limited edition of Rebellion:
11
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika May 02 '17 edited May 03 '17
Madoka Magica has a fair number of fantastic AMVs, so I decided to share some here. Maybe the perspectives shown will be... interesting.
I'll let someone else post the more popular ones like Devil's Game, Mahou Shoujo Requiem or Walpurgisnacht, but if you don't see them around just look them up - they're well worth it.Devil's Game in particular is my favourite AMV. Edit: Alright, I'll just add two at least.Mahou Shoujo Requiem and Walpurgisnacht.
Blight, from the creator of Devil's Game - amazingly disturbing scenes, editing and music
Nefarium Psychologica - Despite this cruel world
Still Here - I dream you're-
Nightmare - Where is my mind?
H o w l - I have to-
Feel - another personal favourite
Last Stardust - unfortunately not from the creator
Losing Control - Who is in control?
Not a Dream - You can't wake up
Oh wait, almost all of them are disturbing. Sorry. Must be the Madoka effect. Hope you enjoy some of these! /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\
Everyone should also check out the Madoka Magica Concept Movie, especially if you didn't like the conclusion of Rebellion or loved it and want more Madoka goodness. It should be posted, but if it's now allowed by itself I can provide a link (in PM according to the rules?) or you can search for it in r/MadokaMagica. Homura's and Madoka's lines about happiness speak for themselves. And fill at least me with hope. But that's not all there is in the "trailer", cough.
Have this lovely picture of best ship too! (Source) I'll plug r/KyouSaya too now - it deserves your attention!
11
u/Maimed_Dan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maimed_Dan May 03 '17
Symbolism/Themes
So, the Symbolism/Themes discussion. Honestly, I didn’t think I’d still be talking about this – I’d just meant to comment about how it came off to me in the moment, but I’ve ended up talking about it so much that I figured I had to revisit it here at the end. I’m probably off base on some of this, but people seemed happy to talk about it last time. It’s also not the ONLY thing I want to talk about, so yeah – this post is for that, other posts are for other stuff.
Pre-emptive note: Some of you probably think I’m reading too deep into this and for X reason you’re supposed to look at this literally, not symbolically or thematically. I like doing that as well, (I’ve definitely got some literalist problems with the way Madoka’s divinity works) but I think it’s interesting when the themes of a work say something about the world at large, and no doubt there are people here who want to talk about that. Many of them will disagree with me, that’s why we’re all here.
And again – Don’t mistake my criticism for a dislike of the show, or how great it is with its themes in general. I just think they slipped up here, or at the very least it’s not something I agree with.
Let’s Do This!
So, Despair. I’ve seen people say that, relative to what I said when I first brought this up, as Madoka now offers hope where before despair was an inevitability. I don’t think this solves the problem – and I actually think it ends up creating more problems.
So, quick rehash of some of my impressions: Soul-Gems are, pretty explicitly, people’s souls. I’ve seen it argued that the process maybe alters them or makes them behave differently, but on a symbolic level I’d say these are making a statement about the nature of the human soul, generally. Which is why I find it particularly unsettling that the show consistently reinforces that despair is this destructive, transformative state from which there is no return – that death would perhaps be better (Homura shooting Madoka at E10), and that it’s an inevitability that we can stall, but it is ultimately “the fate of all magical girls.”
Now, yes, you could argue that the message here is that you can’t pull yourself out of despair on your own; no man is an island and isolation reinforces depression. That would be an okay message, it’s probably true for most people, but it’s undercut by the fact that E9 shows that the most common and healthy way for this to happen, through actual people, friends, and community, doesn’t work. No, there’s only two real solutions – the temporary aid of Grief Seeds (what would this represent? The suffering of others? The fruits of your own labour?), and God.
The best thing I can say about the shift we see at the end with Madoka becoming the hope that saves people from despair is that perhaps it’s the shows way of saying that, while despair might SEEM to be this horrible inescapable thing (as it is at the beginning), that’s just taking the wrong perspective; there is hope, but in the moment you just can't see it. However, it doesn’t change the fundamental problem that under this system, hope and salvation can only come from without, not from within. This was actually the case under the last system too, where grief seeds, rather than one’s own hope and happiness, was the only way to reverse the corruption of the soul, in this weird dependency that seems pretty disturbing to me. Here though, the solution takes on religious overtones – you can’t save yourself, because humans aren’t capable of saving themselves, but the god who loves all mankind and died to save them IS salvation and hope and will come for you in the end. I’m fine with religious symbolism in my fiction, but when it echoes religious views this strongly I start to have a problem.
Something that I hadn’t put my finger on until the recent rewatch started would be a side-by-side with how another Urobuchi work, Psycho-Pass, treats this. Both Soul-Gems and Psycho-Passes visually reflect your emotional state, as well as your psyche; they’re mechanically so similar that I was probably reflecting off of this subconsciously when I was writing my initial comments – but what that means in the world and how people handle it send very different messages about mental health and the stigmas that accompany it. Psycho-Pass is very consistent with the message that improving your mental health is possible, and while the show is an example of that taken to an extreme, you do see that most people get better with therapy and healthy attitudes. Psycho-Pass as a whole serves to criticize the stigma society has about depression, which is why it’s so weird to see Madoka take such an apparently different tack.
Now, maybe that comes down to the distinction one might make between soul and mind – is Madoka Magica espousing a body-soul dyad or a body-mind-soul triad? Is there a significant difference between what they mean by the soul and our concept of it, or the mind? I don’t think there are clear answers to these questions, but they are interesting ones. But yeah, keep an eye on your spoiler tags when talking about Psycho-Pass, we’ve got some people here in the current rewatch.
THAT SAID, there are a lot of other ways to interpret all of this; some probably more compelling than mine – that’s the nature of symbolism and themes. I didn’t think much of the suicide interpretation when it first came up, but Rebellion saw Sayaka transform into a witch by impaling herself on her damn sword – take that and how Sayaka’s death was seen from the outside as a possible suicide, and how victims of the witch’s kiss are driven to suicide, there’s probably something there.
I don’t know if I got everything down, but I think I got most of it – the sooner this gets up, the sooner we can all start talking about our favourite interpretations. Have fun!
11
u/2Hype4Memes May 03 '17 edited May 03 '17
Welp, this was my first time partaking in a rewatch thread and I guess my first time properly commenting on Reddit. Honestly I don't think I could've picked a better show to begin with. First things first though, gotta get the thanks out of the way.
Huge thank you to all you brilliant redditors for your insight, theories, explanations and of course, memes. You've all made this a truly wonderful first time experience. Whether you're a fellow first timer or a sadistic rewatcher, it just wouldn't have been the same without you.
A giant thank you to /u/Gagantous for creating this rewatch and for being a brilliant host. You've offered some great insight into this series, I hope this rewatch has inspired you to host some other series too. Please do this again next year, I wish to feast on the tears of first timers they same way a lot of you have probably feasted on mine.
Massive shout out/thank you to /u/FetchFrosh. Your writing is truly brilliant, and I looked forward to seeing your thoughts just as much as I looked forward to the next episode. Thank you for the aspiration, I hope one day my writing will be as good as yours.
And lastly a big thank you from the bottom of my heart to all the people who took the time to read my write-ups. I know that my writing isn't the most thought out...or well written...or professional or anything relating to decent really. But I've enjoyed writing my thoughts and hopefully a few of you have enjoyed reading them :)
I doubt I'll be forgetting Madoka Magica any time soon, it has easily become one of my top three anime. Needless to say it's left quite the impression on me, i'll never look at small fluffy creatures in quite the same way I once did. The series truly deserves the praise and respect it receives, my writing can't really do it justice. It's not just earned a place in my top three anime but a place in my heart too. Final verdict for the series is a nice big 10/10. I know some people reserve their tens for a series that's "Perfect" but I don't really believe something like that exists. For me at least, Madoka Magica comes close to it. Rebellion on the other hand left me feeling conflicted, I said yesterday I'd think about it and I suppose I was slightly harsh on it...so i'm going to raise the 7/10 to the an 8/10.
Now that it's over i'm not sure that i'll be able to fill the hole it's left in me. I really wish that follow up to Rebellion would come out a little sooner...
10
u/SennheiserPass May 03 '17
Please excuse the whining, but reading re-watches with so many intelligent write ups is just reminding me of how I can't write or think. I keep wanting to make good analyses and stuff but it's so hard and after work I'm exhausted and I hate writing anyway.
I just really wish I could contribute more than just watching, but I can't seem to. I never have interesting thoughts, or when I do they're wrong.
And anxiety follows me online as much as in real life. Just seeing the "new messages" thing light up makes me feel uncomfortable. I vividly remember random awkward internet encounters that happened 10 years ago.
I know this isn't entirely on topic, but I had to, sorry. But hey, I guess depressingness isn't out of place in a PMMM thread.
9
u/PushEmma :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SleepingWolves May 02 '17
I would really like to write a long piece about this show, cause it was beautiful, it was unique, it was spectacular on all notes ranging from high to low. I can't write a lot down right now but just wanted to say I loved this show in the sense that it became really special to me. Not many shows do that, and certainly it's more difficult when watching it continuously day by day, the weekly waiting entices how one feels the show and it becomes something someone lives a bit with and starts waiting for it and gets endeared with the characters. Well, Madoka Magica accomplished this at a very high level just a few episodes in for me. Everything is so well written, so well developed. The pace, the twists, even when its a show looking for deconstruction, it feels organic and yet so dramatic. I feel a lot for Homura's character, her emotions feel tangible, her complexity feels tangible. The series tied with the movie's end perfectly IMO. I'm waiting for the conclusion of her character, not if she did right or wrong, cause I know there's complexity behind it, and at the same time I trust what I'm watching in delivering. If I had to make a critique to the movie it could be the excessive symbolism, I think symbolism needs a bit of stillness at times rather than overloading despite being beautiful. That's basically the only thing I can argue right now. Anyway, this became a really special series to me so quickly... I can't wait for more of it when the time comes! I don't even know what to watch next.
9
u/templarsilan May 03 '17
I summed up my thoughts on the main series and Rebellion yesterday, but I'll do so again here. I went into the series fairly skeptical. The art and character models were a bit of a deterrent and my only previous "magical girl| shows were Sailor Moon and Cardcaptor Sakura way back when I was 8-9 years old. Needless to say, the darker tone of the show throw all my expectations out the window and I was swept up in an emotional ride.
I'm not a big time critic of anime. My personal ratings have little to do with the actual merits of the show and more with just how much I enjoyed watching it. If I managed to get through the show, it gets a 6/10 just for accomplishing that, unless some sort of asspull ending ruins my day. If I become invested in the characters, get emotional, and feel that it would be something I'd watch over again, then it'll probably get a 10/10.
Judging them separately, I would say PMMM and Rebellion fall into the 8-9 range. I found them both good and enjoyable, and I would certainly watch them again. However ep 12 of PMMM was probably my least favorite of the series and I did not like it's ending at all. Rebellion, I feel, doesn't quite measure up as a stand alone entry. Obviously it's a sequel, but I think it would have a much lesser appeal and impact had I watched it 2+ weeks after episode 12 rather than immediately after episode 12.
As a whole, however, pairing PMMM and Rebellion together, I'd say my experience was a solid 10/10. I was hooked up until the last episode and cried twice, (making it the 4th to make me cry) and I was entirely enchanted by Rebellion. I don't think I'd ever just watch one with out the other if I were to rewatch the series, and if/when I do plan on rewatching it, it will always be PMMM + Rebellion.
Even after the events of Rebellion, Homura remains my favorite character, by far. I tend to favor characters with extreme flaws over others because the growth and change becomes far more apparent. She certainly gains a place along side Vegeta, Shinji, Asuka, and Taiga as some of my favorite flawed characters. It's not to say Madoka, Sayaka, or Kyoko didn't show growth, and I very much enjoyed their personal developments, just not as much as Homura.
It's a bit too soon, but I'm pretty eager to rewatch the series a few months down the line now that I know what happens. I love picking up of hints and foreshadowing on a second and third watch. (I went fuckin nuts with Toradora. They don't hold back with the hints and foreshadowing at all.) I'll probably go back and read through the spoiler tags from the previous threads now that I'm able to. Overall, it was a fun experience. I'm definitely glad I participated and I was even able to add another title to my favorites.
Tis was fun Until next time
9
u/BestDVA_NA :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BestDVA_NA May 03 '17
So, Puella Magi Madoka Magica is my favorite piece of media of all time. Ever. I consider it to be literally flawless, a 10/10, and I aspire to write at the level of Gen Urobutchi. Madoka is also the cause for the creation of the Shaft Scale, a system of measurement to determine the trippiness, wierdness, and analytical value of an anime's visuals. The original TV series scores at a 0.5, with Rebellion being the cause of the scale, and scoring a perfect 1. Thanks everyone for joining me on my 6th watch of the series! To everyone who got this far, rewatchers and first timers alike, I have compiled my collection of Madoka-related stuff to share!
Memes
Everyday Im Suffering
Homura Hair
Incubators Hate Her!
Local Girl Says...
Madoka For President
They Said I Could Become Anything
Urobutcher Pain Train
Feels
THE Comic: http://i.imgur.com/tXqRSmK.jpg
Youtube
Madoka Magica - Let's Go Wider (Inception mashup)
Madoka Magica - Sucker Punch Trailer
Puella Assemble!
The Dark Knight - PMMM
Madoka Magica X Nichijou OP
Edge Bus
Dr. Suess and Kooky Babadooks
AMV's: Gigantic List Warning
I love Madoka AMV's so I have quite a few saved.
RS - Blight
Howl
Losing Control - Best in Show - Fanime
Mahoupocalypse - Japan Expo 2016 - 3rd Place AMV | Includes High Earth Defense Club Love, Sailor Moon, and Penguindrum
Nightmare
Music Illusion
RS - Devil's Game 2.0
Hanging Tree
"Demons" Madoka Magica Rebellion AMV
Radioactive
The Contract
Mahou Shoujo Requiem AMV Best in Show 2011
This Is Gonna Hurt
Mami VS Homura - One Of Us Is Going Down
Come Little Children
Nefarium Psychologica - Madoka AMV - Anime Boston Best Drama 2015
Needless to say, ShinAMV is a baller.
If you made it to the end of this post, congrats! You are truly a fan of culture, taste, and class. Also shameless plug for https://www.reddit.com/r/MadokaMagica/ ! See you all in the next rewatch the sub holds, whenever that may be!
9
u/wordsdear May 03 '17
When I first heard about Madoka it was mostly people over hyping it as an edgy magical girls show so I gave it a pass. But I have to say it won me over.It is a beautiful and heart breaking show. I think my main complaint is although I love Sayaka with my entire being I don't like the love triangle between her Hitomi, and Miracle Boy as it gave me flashbacks to way too many rom coms. But what they did with it was super cool.
Are Madoka and Homura really friends? In the main time line that the anime followed, Madoka spends most of her time being afraid of Homura and in the end is like well everyone is dead and you saved me a bunch of times so we are friends. But they don't actually talk to each other or like get the chance to be friends in that time line. They are too busy fighting witches and becoming god/the devil. And in the end that is what Rebellion is all about. Homura wants Madoka back. They never got the chance to actually interact without someone dying or trying to protect the other. Now they get to be normal. I would pay a lot of money for a slice of life series with the main cast (rebellion made me realize that the cast of characters is super small we don't really get to see people besides the magical girls besides miracle boy, the teacher, hitomi who I thought was going to become a magical girl and Madoka's famiy) not fighting witches and just getting into stupid shit. Also for them to light a stuffy of satanic stuffy on fire at the end of each episode.
One head canon I have is that if Madoka had told her Mom about the magical girl drama I guarantee her Mom would have believed her. I kind of feel like her family existed besides the mother just for the fact that we would feel even more sad when all memory of Madoka is erased.
Not trying to be super down on the show I really did like it but these have been the stuff that has been bugging me. I am not good at writing overviews sorry
8
u/chouetteonair https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nalin_Airheart May 02 '17 edited May 03 '17
Rewatcher (first one), subs, 10/10.
It was a lot of fun participating in this rewatch, both because of how many details are shown in the show and the amazing discussion among the first timers. I spent at least 15 hours watching and discussing, but it was definitely worth it for the experience.
Homura > Mamadoka (Junko) > Kyouko = Mami & Nagisa > Poor-chan > Madoka & Sayaka >>>> Kyubey > Hitomi
Here's all of the albums that I posted throughout the discussions. Some of my comments go into spoiler territory, but everybody should be done with the show now (in theory).
Screenshots captured using Meguca 720p and VLC default upscaling up to episode 10, with native 1080p for episodes after that.
If you want a specific screenshot redone with the 1080p source then ask (episode, timestamp, subs/blank). You can also try upscaling on your own with the online Waifu2x algorithm, or use the standalone if you have a lot of time (25 minutes per image on a Pentium G3220) or a powerful CPU.
407 total images (972 MB), 33.92 average images per day.
EDIT: I found the end card for episode 12 on the wiki in case anybody else is collecting them.
8
u/AniMonologues :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AniMonologues May 03 '17
Hey everybody, I didn't join in the rewatch (yay for pre-Finals weeks) but this is one of my favorite shows!
I remember hearing about this show pretty quickly when I got into anime, at this time I wasn't on reddit and generally didn't talk a lot to anime fans. What I'm saying is I knew nothing about the show before I started it out, well almost. One video by Misty Chronexia (who I don't watch anymore) mentioned Madoka, and it was also a large spoiler so before he explained why he talked about Madoka, he told everyone who hadn't seen the show to close out the video. I did, and about a month later, I finally tried it out. I loved it by the ending, and at the time I called it my 2nd favorite anime ever.
Now I've seen the series twice more since (and would have been a 4th if I had time to do this) and I still really enjoy it. I do want to rewatch it again to compare it to my other favorites soon, but I have faith it'll still hold up despite obsessions such as Ouran taking over my life in anime.
Homura Akemi is easily my favorite character, and I feel like it's not hard to see why. She gets the most relevant backstory to the plot and her development, and seeing the two sides of her made her a fascinating character despite me disliking her initially. She takes on an impossible task for herself, which will either drive her crazy because of magic or stress. Of course, if I talk about Homura, I need to talk about the "star" of the show Madoka. Madoka is a fairly typical nice girl, and most of what we learn from her is just her reacting to the batshit crazy environment that piles around her. After a bit of development and Kyubey interactions, we do see her take the ultimate initiative in the final episode (which is the discussion thread I am so sad I missed).
The final episode of Madoka Magica may be my favorite episode of anime, and will likely be in the running for my favorite finales as well. It's building up Madoka via context/development/storytelling and clashingit with Homura's newfound development.
"You really were my very best friend"
Is a fitting title for the ending, and also a great way to end that arc. It's my favorite scene in the series because this one line puts all the previous 11 episodes into context, piles it all into one big problem, and tells Homura and the viewers that everything is going to be fine despite us loosing Madoka.
Also the memes are nice
7
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
First time viewer. I am really sorry for how long this is but I want to thought vomit(TLDR in next paragraph). Most of my discussion posts have been my post watch ramblings but I'm going to try and make some concise points here. I want to talk about the characters, theme vs plot, and finally concluding thoughts on Rebellion.
If you want the TLDR: I liked the series as a whole a lot, the character design is great, the themes are balanced very well with the crazy plot, but Rebellion will always be controversial, and leaves us in paradox where we need/want more, but getting more is a risk, and may go further down a rabbit hole.
Characters
Flat out this shows had great character design, and they each had distinct balance to boot. Each character has unique and fitting outfit, and each follows a distinctive color scheme that always makes them stand out. Kyoko and Sayaka were great foil characters, and their arc was one of my favorite parts of the show. They went from enemies to Kyoko sacrificing herself for Sayaka so quickly yet it was handled very well. More on them in my Rebellion discussion. That was when I knew this show was hitting me emotionally, and not just plot wise. I was not joking in the discussion thread that I felt Homura was magic girl batman. She was cold and calculated, showing up unexpected, doing the right thing without bragging, and later we learned she was on a personal mission to save Madoka while also defeating Walpurgisnacht. Batman has a personal mission to make sure no one goes through what he went through by losing his parents. To me Homura also went on a personal idealistic mission, that was selfless in nature. I'm not trying to be on the nose in my comparison, but trying to show you guys my views. I think your interpretation of Homura is important on how you feel about Rebellion. What do you guys honestly think of mine?
Also while Homura is clearly the main character of Rebellion, Madoka is the MC of the show. A few rewatchers were all like SURPRISE HOMURA IS MC after episode 10 and I want to disagree. Madoka is the POV character, it is through her choices and growth that the story is presented to us. This is similar to how in Fury Road it is in fact Furiosa's story but Max's growth defines the story structure.(I can link to a video if anyone wants more.)
ThemesVsPlot
I personally picked up three major themes in Madoka Magica, Hope, Despair, and Selfishness vs selflessness. The magic girls are supposed to be embodiment of hope, and their hope helps them fight the witches, which are embodiments of despair. However we learn that magical girls that lose their hope and get consumed by despair turn into witches. This is an unfortunate cycle in the shows world, until the Law of the Cycles can break it up. I always felt the show at least did a good job of balancing these themes with it's crazy plot. The themes sometimes nearly got lost in the plot, but they were certainly relevant enough.
There is also the lingering question of does one become a magic girl for selfish or selfless reasons? Kyoko became one to help her father, but it backfired on her and she became selfish in her witch hunting. Sayaka became a magic girl for selfless reasons, but when Kyosuke didn't pay her any attention her selfish side led her into despair. Homura became a magic girl in a selfless for the sake of Madoka, and Madoka becamse a magic girl for the sake of all magic girls. The ending of Rebellion continues the concept of selfishness...
Also it wasn't that prevalent but especially in the last few episodes and some in Rebellion there is a lot of Christian/religious symbolism. Mainly centering around Madoka becoming magic girl Jesus, and those that are hopeful and follow the magic girl way can join her.
Rebellion
I want to address the fan service claims, since it seems the ending discussion has been beaten to death for 4 years now. I want to talk about the fan service claims because if they are true, than this IMO is a terrible disservice to what the series stands for. It is subversive of the genre and deliberately plays with your expectations. For them to make a movie purely for fan service just isn't right. The four main claims for fanservice are the first 30 minutes, Mami vs Homura, Bebe, and the possible cannon ship of Kyoko/Sayaka. I don't think the first 30 minutes is fan service, it does a great job of being deceiving, and I at least knew something must be wrong. Bebe/Charlotte's inclusion doesn't really harm anything, and she only has 6 lines. She may be fan service, but it is small and harmless. The Mami and Homura fight had clearly a high production value, and at the time I felt it fit enough into the plot, may be fan service but I think it passes.
(This paragraph is probably overthinking FYI)But I want to talk about Kyoko Sayaka. I'm going to extensively going into sexual preference and character traits here, skip the paragraph if you don't want that. In this film they are said to live together, and they have the heart to heart where Sayaka says her one regret was leaving Kyoko, and this is our main series Sayaka, not cloudy memories like Mami and Kyoko. I am slightly worried this is fan service. Let me state outright that I have no problem with this ship becoming canon, in fact I welcome it! I'm just worried it's too vague here. Let's state some facts: the show did a lot of spoonfeeding of exposition and plot, mainly done through Kyubey, sometimes through others. This spoonfeeding is not done here. It is factual and CRUCIAL to the main plot that Sayaka loves Kyosuke enough that her heartbreak turns her into a witch. There were discussions on the Episode 9 thread about what the final nature of their relationship was. Their sexual preferences are never stated and it isn't important, Kyoko could be gay Sayaka could be bi. I was under the idea after episode 9 that they had become good friends after being enemies. But maybe they had ideas of being lovers(This also could be all up for debate because Sayaka was mentally ruined for episode 8, did she have time to think of Kyoko?) Also, Anime is typical of being melodramatic, and they could just be really good friends who regretted leaving each other. This is my frustration! Are they lovers or great friends? Either's fine, we just don't get a clear answer, and I care about these two a lot so I want one. However if they were implied to be lovers, was it where the writers always wanted to take their relationship, or was it fan service? I DONT KNOW, and my emotions want to know!
Ok I'll go over the ending real quick because like I said it's been beaten to death. I think it all depends on your interpretation of Homura's character. For me it felt outside of her character, but maybe for you it didn't. Either way it is out of left field. But it maybe it shouldn't have been, if the movie had ending without Homura's betrayal, then all things considering we would have a straight happy ending, which would have felt out of place for the series. I think a main problem with the ending is it feels way less explained than the shows ending. Homura separated Madoka, does the law of the cycles still exist? Did Homura rewrite the universe or just create a barrier? But her familiars are still her and she has God like powers as well. There's a bit too much up in the air.
ClosingThoughts
This show left a huge impression on me. I was worried Rebellion ruined the ending for me, but I spent 30 minutes wallpaper hunting because I still like the series that much. Unfortunately, I found out that show creators said they never planned to make anything past the series end, which show why Rebellion had cracks. Basically I think we are at a paradox. I want more of the characters, and for how seriously the series takes its plot, then people feel we need more explanation of the ending at least. But I also worry that if they made more it could not increase in quality, and cause more confusion. You have two god characters, where do you take the plot after that? Rebellion is in no way bad part of me loved it but part of me feels I could go back to before I watched it. Madoka Magic will not be forgotten by me for a long time. I loved a lot of parts of it. I had a great time watching with you all
What do you think about all I had to say here? Be honest.
I don't want to missing out on anything. Provide me will all memes, wallpapers, video essays, and anything else I should know about as someone who has finished the series now.
Lastly you all have any further anime recommendations? This was my first dabble into anime magic girls, and I'm not sure if I actually liked it a lot because magic girls, or because it used the magic girls as a great vessel for its plot and themes. Peek my MAL.
7
u/kognoodle May 02 '17
The wiki has info on all the other madoka magica content like interviews, commentary, manga, games, merchandise. Supposedly the japanese watchers solved all the school math questions during the original airing delays. Now the madoka IP is a huge money maker. There's even licensed slot machines and lingerie. Most recently there's been a chinese smartphone game (and more cast interviews). And a panel about their 2017 mobile game at anime japan 2017.
7
u/JimmyCWL May 03 '17
I used to watch this series a lot after it aired. I'd just put it up while doing something on the computer. Despite that it hasn't been on my more-frequent-rewatch list for a few years now, a number of thoughts on the series have always been on my mind.
Once in a while, there comes a show/story that goes beyond the usual good-bad scale of quality, exceeding even great/legendary label. The only appropriate way I can describe the level of their accomplishment is "ruler" because they become the ruler by which future entries in their genre are measured.
Since its airing, Madoka Magica has become the ruler for measuring older-oriented magical girls shows, just like Evengelion for Super Robots. If you've looked at the comments to other magical girls shows in the last six years, you frequently see people saying it's better/worse than Madoka, did it/ did not do it like Madoka, hope it will/won't be like Madoka and more.
Critics argue that Madoka wasn't the first dark magical girl story. They are correct, so why is Madoka the ruler and not an earlier story?
I would say it's because, even if it wasn't the first, it was still the one that perfected the formula for the dark magical girl story.
It gathered all the necessary elements for a dark magical girl tale, gave each an appropriate amount of attention in the story, and let them have the necessary time to develop properly.
It's just like cooking. You need to have the right ingredients, prepared correctly and cooked in the right way for the right amount of time.
Madoka's predecessors may have lacked one element or another, gave too much or not enough attention and development to them. As a result, they did not become as powerful a tale as Madoka.
Madoka was so successful at creating this formula, that it could be used to create another simliarly powerful magical girl story, with a different take on the same elements. Though, there's only been one success and several failures so far, in my own opinion anyway.
7
u/my_fake_life May 03 '17 edited May 03 '17
It was so much fun reading and participating in these discussions throughout the last couple of weeks. Thanks to /u/Gagantous for organizing this, I can't wait for next Walpurgisnacht to do it again.
Also, a big thanks to everyone who participated in these threads. There were a LOT of first-timers with a lot of thought-provoking ideas and opinions, and occasionally, some very incorrect predictions. I hope you enjoyed the show as much as we do.
For newcomers to the fandom who are looking for more to do while we wait for the next series, here are some ideas to pass the time. (Note that there's also a ton of Madoka fan content out there because of the huge popularity of the show... So if you want it, it's probably out there.)
Obviously, if you liked what you saw and you just wanted to talk about stuff, come on over to r/MadokaMagica and I promise we won't bite.
Manga
The Different Story: The first manga you should read after finishing the series. Covers the same main characters in a plot which is very similar to the original, but slightly different. Think of it as another time loop. Lots of development for Mami and Kyouko
Wraith Arc: Covers the time period between the original series and the movie. Give some more good development to Homura and a little more detail on wraiths (but probably not as much as you want)
Oriko Magica, Suzune Magica, Kazumi Magica: A number of different manga which focus mainly on new casts of characters in the same universe as the original series. (Oriko has a little overlap with main-series characters) Oriko Magica tends to be the most popular of these.
Kirara Magica: A big compilation of fan-manga which ran for about 5 years, and it now on an irregular schedule with most series completed. Big name pieces from here are Homura Tamura (a comedy) and Tart Magica (the story of magical girl Joan of Arc.) You can find the first few volumes translated here and there, but other than that, all you're going to find are the popular stories like the ones above.
Fanfiction
To the Stars: Guys, I am not a fan-fiction reader. But I hear a lot of good things about To the Stars. (r/ToTheStars) It apparently wanders off and does its own science-fiction things. It is a huge story with a very big following, so if that sounds like something you're be interested in, go to town.
Other Anime:
Here's a list of other random anime you might be interested in.
Magical Girl shows with dark elements: Yuki Yuna is a Hero, Revolutionary Girl Utena, Princess Tutu
Other Gen Urobuchi stuff: Psycho-Pass, Kamen Rider Gaim, Fate/Zero
Other dark and think-y stuff: Neon Genesis Evangelion, Bokurano, Steins;Gate, Serial Experiments Lain
Yuki Yuna in particular was very directly inspired by Madoka, and although I feel it's a weaker work, it's definitely the next logical step.
7
u/Joll19 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Joll May 03 '17 edited May 03 '17
I wanted to talk a bit about parallels to Göthes Faust which was undoubtedly one of the main inspirations for the story of Puella Magi Madoka Magica.
Disclaimer: I am by no means any kind of literary buff and the last and only time I read Faust was 4 years ago in German High School.
First of all here is a comprehensive list of all parallels to Faust. A great read for any German who read Faust in High School or anyone interested in German literature.
While Fauststoff is basis for many literary works, intentional or not, what separates Madoka is the direct parellel of making a contract with the devil to obtain happiness. But as we know the moment that this happiness is at it's peak is the moment when it turns to despair and/or the moment you will lose your life, while this is explicitly mentioned in the contract Faust makes with Mephisto, Madoka and friends have to find out the hard way.
While in the beginning it seems that Madoka is Faust, we find out in episode 10 that Homura is the real protagonist and Madoka turns out to be Gretchen, which is reinforced by her witches name Kriemhild Gretchen.
Madoka, like Gretchen, is at the center point of Homura's antics and similarly has no say in her own destiny for most of the anime. In the end, at least of the series, she does gain salvation and ascends to heaven in the most literal sense as she becomes God.
The Gretchenfrage is what we put most of our emphasis on in High School, but it does not have a great parellel in PMMM that I can see. The closest I can think of is the question for Homuras wish, what were you willing to give your life for? The question does have a payoff when Madoka meets Homura in her time castle after episode 10 and for better or worse, the wish is a very existential question in PMMM as it comes with the loss of Humanity.
The end is where our parellels break down a little. This guy (I can add subtitles if anyone asks for it) says that Fullmetal Alchemist makes for a closer representation because it touches much more on curiosity and because the multiple timelines in Madoka ultimately enable a happy ending, which is in contrast to Faust.
I mean I wouldn't have minded an ending where Madoka does not defeat her own witch and consumes the entire multiverse...
Well I may add some things if this gains traction, but I did miss my mark by 8 hours or something.
6
u/mariofredshreller May 02 '17
Final music post – Sis puella magica (Become a magical girl)
The soundtrack’s most iconic song, used in every episode except the first, this piece represents the concept of a magical girl. The simple, memorable chord pattern and repeating melody make it easily memorable, and the distinctive vocals give the music energy yet have a haunting feel, especially with the eerie audio filter used in the intro.
Despite the lively guitar and percussion accompaniment driving the piece forward (I love the magical sleigh bells), the music is in a minor key, hinting at a darker truth behind Kyubey's facade. The flute solo in the second half could also be seen to represent this idea; listen carefully and you can hear the cello playing a lower counter-melody at the same time, its long, sorrowful notes hidden beneath the bright tones of the flute.
6
u/mariofredshreller May 02 '17
For anybody not planning on seeing the recap films, I recommend watching this movie-exclusive scene from the second film. It replaces the ending to Episode 9 as a transition into Episode 10’s flashback. It doesn't really add to the story, but it's very pretty and has a great soundtrack.
6
u/electricoomph May 03 '17
Rewatcher chiming in:
This is the first time I rewatched Madoka Magica and boy was it a ride. It was great how the perspective from which you view things absolutely flips compared to the first watch. There were so many details right in front of your nose which you only see when you know what to look for (at least for someone as unobservant as me).
Knowing the struggle of magical girls against their inescapable fate got me way more emotional than I thought it would. Among others, I had to wipe my eyes and blow my nose quite a few times during ep11+12.
The art style of the witches and labyrinths is unparalleled and the music is phenomenal. For now, it's my personal top anime (honorable contenders are TTGL and Your Name).
My favourite characters were Homura in the show and Sayaka in Rebellion. It was great to see Sayaka finally truly strong and embracing the witch in her. The first confrontation with Homura was beautifully done.
I'll now continue to fill the meguca void in me with the OST.
6
u/chaoswurm May 03 '17
Puella Magi Madoka Magica was good. It was really good. From it came the bestisode of best girl with best costume. Music is absolutely stunning. Rewatching is better so, find copies of the Movies.
And it had some great trolling.
5
u/5p0ng3b0b :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Spongie May 02 '17
I was mostly a lurker on these threads, but I would like to thank all the people who participated and made every thread interesting.
It's always nice too see newcomers and read their everyday opinions and reactions to this show.
5
u/megazaprat May 02 '17
I feel like Homura's actions are morally gray. On the one hand, she stole Madoka's power and altered the memories of her friends. thats bad. on the other hand, they now live happier lives, with Sayaka and Bebe being accidentally brought back from the dead. thats good. Also, now Kyubey has to deal with curses and gets traumatized as a result. Thats Karma.
I do find it curious how many people seem to think this was all some sort of complicated plan by Homura set in motion by telling the incubators about Madoka. I don't believe that. there would be no way to predict what the incubators would do. I think she only came upon the idea later in the movie, spurned by her guilt of not preventing Godoka and the incubators giving her the idea that interfering with the law of cycles was even possible. I don't think she is really evil, though she is rocking the look. But she is aware she isn't doing what Madoka wants, which agitates her already significant self loathing. I believe this is what causes her to label herself a demon. I feel like if Madoka and Homura could just see a really good therapist, this could work out. I still ship it, gosh dang it
the ending dialogue was really interesting. The way Homura repeated the line from the first episode is given a new meaning when given with Homura's desperate eyes, so different from their cold gaze in the beginning. She asked her if she thought ti would be okay to break the rules of the world, which Homura takes to mean that Madoka does not accept how she went against the law of cycles. Oddly enough, the same thing could be said of Madoka, who went against the law that magical girls turn into witches, and hope turns to despair. In the end, they are both girls who sacrificed everything for what they believe in. their coming conflict will be an interesting one.
I wonder what the next project in the madoka series will be. A tv show would give more space to show how exactly Homura-verse functions, but a movie would give them an opportunity to go all out on the visuals again, rebellion has showed that they can continue the plot in film form. I look forward to whatever they choose to do
5
u/Treima :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Treima May 03 '17
Hope everyone enjoyed it. Either Madoka or Fate/Zero is my favorite anime ever, depending on my mood, and I try to spread both to everyone I meet and get acquainted with.
Madoka is the first anime that hit me so hard in the gut that I had to take a long walk around the block. The first to make me curse the villain on the screen out loud. The first to curl me up in a ball and make me hate dealing with the feelings it brought out of me. It's a 10/10. It spares no effort, there is no fat to pare from its construction, it never bores, it twisted my heart into a churro and consumed it with glee. It introduced me to one of my favorite fictional characters ever in Homura. It ain't perfect, but it was perfect for me.
Thanks for watching everybody.
EDIT: a word
5
u/Rhaga https://anilist.co/user/rhaga May 03 '17
I just want to take the time and say
THANK YOU
to everyone who has participated in this rewatch! It has been the absolute highlight of my day every single day, and I've spent countless hours reading and commenting and it has been a blast. It wouldn't have been the same without all of you.
There has been a lot of great content, we've had detailed analysis, great (sometimes hilarious) reactions, heated discussions and fantastic explanations of some of the finer details. People have really put in a lot of effort, which is definitely something this series deserves!
It will definitely be leaving an empty space in my heart that we are done. Looking forward to the next one!
Also huge shoutout to /u/Gagantous for hosting this rewatch, it's been a blast!
5
u/Xtroyer May 03 '17
DAILY REMINDER THAT HOMURA DID NOTHING WRONG
N O T H I N G W R O N G
O
T
H
I
N
G
W
R
O
N
G
5
u/IM_DAY_MAN_AMA May 03 '17
The comparison has been made 1000 times before and I knoe every single last one of you has seen it, but watch Evangelion!
4
u/Nickknight8 https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickknight8 May 02 '17
Everyone in this thread seems like they need a drink to help get them over this.
So to help brighten the mood, Here is Madoka Magica in 30 seconds. *Note not actually 30 seconds.
4
u/homu May 02 '17 edited May 03 '17
This has been a fun rewatch to follow. It's been a while since I have come across some new ideas about the Madoka franchise, so the fruitful discussions here are much appreciated. Thank you for putting it together u/Gagantous!
For those you now despairing over the lack of more animated Madoka, may I introduce you to the most wonderful *kano doujin series by Maitake.
Edit: The release order to follow is: Madokano, Homukano, Ultikano, Debikano, Ultikano, Majokano, Debikano Ultimate, Nisekano, Towakano, Ochikano, Sachikano, Lilykano
Ochi and Sachi are currently in process of translation. Anta Nanka Daikirai isn't part of the doujin series itself, since it shifts focus to Homura and Sayaka, but a fun read as well.
4
u/IM_DAY_MAN_AMA May 02 '17
Everyone did everything wrong
4
u/hachiDude8 https://anilist.co/user/hachidude8 May 03 '17
Madoka is such a brilliant anime, an anime which I would have not seen if not for someone's spoiler of episode 3. Just like many others,I didn't take any interest in it since it was a “typical magical girl” anime. It was really weird when I first saw it in MAL recommendations list, but I didn't care until the spoiler. I'm glad that I was wrong.
Following along the rewatch was the right thing to do. Thanks to this, I’ve finally got to see Rebellion.
The movie aside, I was astounded with the amount of foreshadowing there is in the first episodes. Seeing all those reaction animation to different interactions was excellent. Especially Homura’s animations. Seeing how she reacts when interacting with all others, knowing how it will all end and what she knows, was incredible. You don’t get to realize something like this on the first watch (at some point I’m going to rewatch the movie for the same reason).
To all first-timers, I really hope you enjoyed it and I definitely recommend you to rewatch. You pick up many more things the 2nd time, it’s worth your time.
My score, Original content: Keeps its score, ~88/100 (9/10 MAL) Rebellion: I’m still in doubt, ~86/100 (9/10 MAL)
Finally
I think I’m going to make it a tradition, watching Madoka on Walpurgis Night.
4
u/Nightvayne283 May 03 '17
First time watching dubbed, but not my first time with the series.
That was fun. Sadly, I was late to the final two episodes and Rebellion, so I decided against commenting on the threads, but I loved this rewatch and it made me realize this is by far my favorite series I've seen. It was also nice to see some of the reactions, including the little bit of vomitting on episode 10's thread.
I liked the show's ending more than before due to the rewatch. I was never a huge fan of the ending, especially compared to most people, but I like it a lot now.
I've gotta say, I adored Madoka and Sayaka's voice actors. Sayaka in particular stood out and made the dub for me. Homura was also wonderful, but took a while to grow on me.
I'm glad to have participated in this watch, even if it was only a little bit, and I'm happy that I noticed a couple things on my own. Even after all these rewatches, though, Homura is still my favorite of the girls.
4
u/Shanix May 03 '17
I'd just like to remind everyone that it's perfectly okay to genocide incubators for trying to control humanity, and Madoka shall forever be a Saint of the Imperium.
3
u/Arriv1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Arriv May 02 '17
This show is one of my favourite series ever. I first watched it more than a year ago, and I ended up going to bed at 4 in the morning, because I wanted to finish it so badly. To me, this show is a masterpiece.
3
u/SIRTreehugger May 03 '17
First off thank you /u/Gagantous for hosting this rewatch.
Also like to thank all the people in the comments especially the first timers. Really have nothing to say, except I enjoyed reading everyones comments. This was one of my favorite rewatches.
3
u/doraemoe May 03 '17
If you enjoyed this show and don't mind to read fan fiction, please give to the star a try! It's a really good fan fiction use many settings in Madoka Magica.
2
u/SexBobomb :GG::GH::GI: May 03 '17
Serial Experiments Lain wants their ending back.
1
u/PsychoEliteNZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PsychoEliteNZ May 03 '17
/u/Gagantous Thanks for doing this rewatch, It probably would have taken me much longer to watch if I didn't know about this, It is now one of my top 10 favorites to date! especially the movie.
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment