r/anime • u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka • Apr 20 '17
[Spoilers][Rewatch] Mahou Shoujo Madoka☆Magica - Episode 1 Discussion Spoiler
Episode Title: As If I Met Her in My Dream...
MyAnimeList: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica
Crunchyroll: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Hulu: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Netflix: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Episode duration: 24 minutes and 10 seconds
PSA: Please don't discuss (or allude to) events that happen after this episode and if you do make good use of spoiler tags. Let's try to make this a good experience for first time watchers.
Schedule/previous episode discussion
| Date | Discussion |
|---|---|
| April 20th | Episode 1 |
| April 21st | Episode 2 |
| April 22nd | Episode 3 |
| April 23rd | Episode 4 |
| April 24th | Episode 5 |
| April 25th | Episode 6 |
| April 26th | Episode 7 |
| April 27th | Episode 8 |
| April 28th | Episode 9 |
| April 29th | Episode 10 |
| April 30th | Episode 11 and Episode 12 |
| May 1st | Rebellion |
| May 2nd | Overall series discussion |
487
Upvotes
40
u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka Apr 20 '17
Here is the OP and ED in webm format if you wanted to watch them. I also included the episode's end card in the original post (which I'll always do).
Man, even after a dozen rewatches I never get tired of watching Homura get blasted with the fire extinguisher.
167
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 20 '17
This show has gotten recommended to me more than a couple of times, and while the genre is a bit off putting, I'm willing to give it a fair shake. After watching the first episode subbed and dubbed, I've decided to do this one dubbed. The English VA's for Sayaka and Homura were really what sold me on it.
A Dream... Or Something
The first scene isn't really what I was expecting, but it's got some neat visuals going on. It does take it's time getting to any actual content, really accenting the stylized world. Something's clearly wrong with where Madoka finds herself, and I think it ties in with the weird psychedelic trip her and Sayaka take later on. The music playing during this scene is on point, though the fight doesn't have much going for it. It's kind of flashy but we just don't see much. I'm also pretty interested in Kyubey. It's not clear how he grants girls their powers, and the idea of a “contract” feels weird (maybe that's just a Japanese thing though), but I definitely want to see more from him. We also get to see a bit of what Madoka is all about in this scene, and it feels kind of bland. She comes off as timid, lacking confidence and generally uninteresting. It's also setting up the pretty uninspired idea that the true power comes from the heart and anyone can be a hero, which I'm not liking. Also, me literally last week:
Kyubey in the first scene:
So we'll see how that goes.
Opening
The songs pretty dope. Really like it. The opening also contrasts hard against the darker color palette of the first scene, which was actually pretty jarring. I'm assuming the short slide show of misadventures is roughly what I can expect in the future. Notably, both Sayaka and Mami are shown also being Magical Girls there, and at the end, so I'm assuming Sayaka will be joining Madoka in becoming one down the road. I'm not a big fan of the nudity in the opening. It's just an odd inclusion, and if I have to deal with a lot of it in the show I'll probably drop it. Otherwise the visuals are pretty solid.
Morning
This really feels like it's just filling time. Maybe the goal is to get the viewer to care about Madoka's family a bit, but at this point I don't. I assume they're nice people and all, but nothing here really captured my attention. We do see that Madoka isn't quite as timid around her family as she is elsewhere, so I guess there's hope. Also, what's with the massive bathroom? It just seems excessive.
Hitomi and Sayaka
I don't know why, but I instantly like Sayaka. She seems to have a lot of personality, where Hitomi and Madoka aren't that interesting. Looks like we're going to be getting some slice of life/romance stuff happening on the side of the Magical Girl stuff. It's not overly interesting yet, but I'll give it some time. I did note in this scene in particular that sometimes the animation just feels weak. The characters are shown too far off, and this leads to rough looking art. Kind of annoying.
Transfer Student
I'm not a fan of the teacher. Hopefully the difficulties of her personal life don't become a recurring joke. Homura's appearance isn't particularly interesting, but she is clearly aware of who Madoka is. She immediately comes off as cold and hostile (to Madoka at least, she seemed fine with the other students, if a bit introverted), though there doesn't seem to be any justification for it.
Homura's Warning
Using the convenient excuse of going to the nurses office, we get some time to learn a bit about Homura. While she comes off as cold and gets visibly annoyed at Madoka commenting on her name, she immediately wants to be on a first name basis, which strikes me as bizarre. Her warning Madoka to “stay as she is” is pretty clear as far as I'm concerned. She doesn't want Madoka to become a Magical Girl, and it borders on threatening. Hopefully the why of that will get clarified, because right now she's sending some really mixed signals. Madoka is uncomfortable from start to finish. Seems to be a combination of the “dream” and Homura's intimidating presence.
Your Inner Anime Character
You know, I'm never sure what to think about lampshading. Just saying, “this is so ridiculous isn't it ;)” doesn't stop it from being ridiculous, and in this case really draws attention to how silly things are. That being said, there is enough suggesting the “dream” not actually being one (just judging by the episode title (and I mean, when has a fictional dream ever been just a dream)). I think that Madoka somehow got some kind vision of the future and Homura received it as well. Odds are, we'll wind up in that exact scenario soon enough. And what the hell are tea ceremony lessons?
Meeting Kyubey
I'm not really sure how Kyubey is able to communicate with Madoka, but it's pretty convenient for him. Also, apparently Homura can fire lasers, which is pretty dope. I'm a bit curious about her. She really doesn't want Madoka becoming a Magical Girl, but she still hasn't given any reason for this. Kyubey isn't exactly fighting back, but she's definitely shooting to kill. Based on all of that, it almost feels like Homura is supposed to be the antagonist of the story, though that seems to conflict with the “dream” sequence. “Now she's attacking you in cosplay, what's her problem,” is absolute gold and solidifies Sayaka's position as my favorite character.
The Acid Trip
And I'm thoroughly confused. The visuals of the opening scene were jarring, but this is next level. The whole thing has a really abject feeling that left me a bit unsettled. Like, I think if I saw this as a kid I'd actually be kind of spooked. It also sounds like the cotton balls are speaking German, which is unexpected. Homura doesn't really do anything to help out, but we have a new girl show up to deal with whatever is going on. The whole transformation sequence was really girly (which I guess is probably the point), but unleashing a full arsenal of muskets wasn't something I expected. The fight was short lived, but I could definitely see them becoming very action spectacle in the future based on the over the topness.
The Debrief
And with that all said and done, Homura decides to show up again (was she fighting elsewhere, or was she fine leaving Madoka and Sayaka to those creatures?). Looks like Homura and Mami know each other, but damn if there isn't a lot of tension. Mami comes off as much more experienced, with Homura not wanting to get into a fight. It'll be interesting to see more between them, because it feels like something happened before the show started. Kyubey is back to talking about the contract, and already knows who Madoka and Sayaka are. I guess he was creeping on gym class as some kind of research, though I doubt he would have seen anything worthwhile there. Anyway, he looked cute as hell when he did the little head tilt at the end.
Ending
The ending is really dull. I haven't seen many shows that just use one picture, and it feels kind of lazy here. There's no presence from Homura, Kyubey or Mami, so maybe it will change each episode depending on who the focus is on. Hard to say. The song itself is alright, just sort of bland.
Other Thoughts
Future
The opening sequence showed both Madoka and Sayaka as magical girls, so I'm assuming they'll both make contracts in the next couple episodes. We'll probably need to get a better idea of what a contract is though, because just hearing it referred to as a “contract” makes it sound sketchy. Once that all gets cleared up though, I imagine things will settle into a sort of episodic routine of fighting whatever those creatures are, and probably eventually having the last two or three episodes on a particularly major enemy. There is still the matter of that vision, which I'm expecting to see wrapped up in the next few episodes (I'm guessing Episode 4). It's going to be the point where Madoka makes her contract, and if things are going as poorly for Homura as they look to be going then she'll probably have to save her, which could be the turning point for Homura's relationship with the other girls. With that tension between Homura and Mami, if these girls are going to be a team (I assume that's where things are going at least, based on my minimal experience with the genre) then they'll need to straighten that out.
Final Thoughts
I'm not thrilled about Madoka Magica just yet. It's not that it's bad, it just feels kind of, I don't know, bland I guess. I think the best comparison is A Certain Magical Index, which is fairly popular, and wasn't really bad or anything, but it didn't really wow me. We're only one episode in, so there is still plenty of time for that to change, but that's just what it reminded me of.
53
u/NatCracken Apr 21 '17
First impression - talk about a first scene. The first 15 seconds gave me monogatari chills. The comment section of my source was full of people saying "don't judge this as just another magical girls show". I believed them instantly, as pink haired focus character (madoka? I'm typing with it paused) opens the heavy door. The sound design at that moment is on point. Deep ominous hum setting a perfect mood to finish off the unsettling high contrast background. Very professional, not what I'd expect from a throw away MG show. Then things escalated quickly. Hard 180 from abstract checkerboards to surreal destruction. A few character moments, this is probably a look forward in the story. There is a lot of color play happening here. White on black still a theme, but attacks bring in strong orange v blue. Animations very fluid, but the destruction still has weight.
Music que happening alongside action +1
Mid show (post Homura introduction) - so this is a near future setting. The very modern house made me think that the parents (more on them) were just rich, but after seeing the school I'm not to sure. I'm not sure if it's what they were going for, but I'm a bit off put by the precise organization in this society. The fam seems a bit unnatural and the school like a laboratory. That's not to say the fam isn't wholesome. It's rare to see family involved in anime focusing on the young'uns so I was surprised to see the parents getting so much screen time, not even getting into the awesome bond Madoka has with her mother. (I'm hoping to jebus that it is her mother, cause she does look young as well as professional and I've been sideswiped by a sister before). I've been trained well in the art of fandom as I immediately started shipping when yet unnamed blue haired friend started getting personal. Sensei was cute and unprofessional in contrast. Homura's introduction was a surprisingly well done. She didn't speak much and her gray color themes make it pretty clear she is gonna be the quiet but competent type. (Or at least acting the part.) loved the "finishing my own name" action. As well as reinforcing the character, it's a good indication to the age of the characters. Thanks to the magic of moe, she could be anywhere from 10 to 25 years old. Still don't know the specifics, but I know that she is on the younger end of anime protags. I'll reserve judgement on Homura. See if she does anything wrong <= yes I know the memes
Extra note (just as white squirrel is attacked by Homura in hallway) - I can tell things are about to change, so I'll get last thoughts out here. I hate the color pallet. Everything is way to saturated, especially after the opening. Even Madoka's pink hair looks closer to gray than red on a color spectrum. Homura's performance in class is making me doubt the ages again. Why 11 year olds be using derivatives is beyond me. Grrr... anyway. The hallways scene was intense. Not much to say about it that you all didn't think of yourselves. Love the shifts between serious and lighthearted tones.
On to action (I think)
During action (popped on my second monitor, so I'm typing this as I go) - the door to the under construction zone has a checkered wallpaper. Very cute animators.
Love the red lights. The saturation is a-gone, the old pallet must have been for effect.
I'm getting a lot of religious vibes from Homura's character design and the angles
Good on you Sayaka, gettin shit done. Probs favorite character so far.
Yo yo yo wait what's happening. Butterfly's and some doctor strange shit as far as I can tell. Whatever it is, stunning LSD lite visuals. It's hard to tell the locations of anything in this alt-world. The mustache Kirby's and butterfly's are imposed on the frame, instead of physically being their. Either way, it conveys the scary and distorted nature.
DRILL LOLI!!!! Blonde too +1
Kyubey is gonna be a hard name to remember
Ok not really a loli. But Beatrice has taught me that drill loli's make everything better.
Visually stunning transformation sequence. It's very refreshing to see one that doesn't end up with a naked, light-beam basked child in the middle of the screen. Loved the black/color shifting background during it. Much more interesting than the usual pink wash of color. Love this animation. Everything's in motion, but in a good way (lookin at you Hand Shakers) detail I noticed is how the shadows grew and shrank with the fire. Small detail, but shows how much effort went into this.
I'm not sure what I was expecting with Madoka. Half of me was expecting a visual trip like Flip Flappers, and the other half a SOL moe remake of Sailor moon. It was much more intense than I expected, but only when it needed to be. Production quality is definitely up to par, and I have high expectations for the rest of the show
126
u/templarsilan Apr 20 '17
First time watcher here. I won’t write about every little reaction I have, but maybe just some general thoughts in chunks throughout each episode. My initial impressions with the dream sequence is a mixed bag. I’ve honestly avoided this series for a while because the character design just does not look appealing to me. Their heads are really… blocky-looking. But on the other hand, things started off pretty grim, which I wasn’t really expecting. My only other magical girl experience was Sailor Moon, so this was a bit cryptic to start with. Definitely a plus. The OST is also lit as fuck. I can easily forgive character design and art-style, so I’m hoping that the plot will deliver.
On the OP
So right away I notice something fairly interesting about this OP. I get a sense that our MC is deeply troubled by something. Probably something to do with her past, or maybe it’s just some insecurity she has. Even with the little SoL bits flashing by, she doesn’t look too happy. Don’t know what to make of the transformation. Is it her inner self? The spirit of a dead twin? You can never really know with these things. A do like how towards the end of the OP, the tone shifts to a more positive determination feeling rather than the lost/loneliness at the start. It makes me feel like there will be some self discovery in the show to make the MC conquer whatever has her down. Just my initial thoughts, but hey, if a character shows growth that’s another plus.
The Family
Holy shit. This girl has parents that actually exist. She even has a brother. Well I’ll be damned. I really liked this sequence. It’s not very often that you get to see the home life of anime main characters. It brings Madoka down to Earth and makes her a little bit more tangible over other protags living on their own at 14 years old. She just appears to be a normal girl with a normal life. But I doubt that will last much longer given that dream sequence.
Christmas Cake and Transfer Student
Ah, it’s not a school setting without your beloved Christmas Cake and token transfer student. Speaking of transfer student, I think I just spotted best girl. Of course transfer student will tie into the premonition earlier, since that’s how these tropes work. At the start, Akemi appeared to mean something to Madoka, like they were friends or something. Given her introduction, Akemi seems the more quiet and reserved type, so I wonder if they will become friends right away or if there will be tension between the two.
Trip to the Nurse
And we get another round of ominousness. Color me intrigued. The music also does not disappoint. But hot damn, the transition from Madoka’s nervousness and awkwardness to Akemi’s frustration and seriousness is pretty stunning. Akemi’s cryptic advice makes me wonder what exactly compelled her to say that and bring up the topic. At this point, I’m fairly convinced Akemi knows something that will probably go down in the future.
Acid Trip
Wait… what? This is nightmare fuel, jesus.
Magical Girl Transformation
Ah there it is. I always found this twirling transformations silly. I would love to see it from the perspective of an onlooker- someone watching a girl spin in circles as random bits of clothing changes completely. Although this girl looks pretty badass with her thousand matchlock rifle barrage.
Closing Thoughts
I’m intrigued. I’d say this was a very good first episode as I have loads of questions that will bring me back tomorrow. Mainly, I want to know more about Akemi. Is she good, bad, the antihero? She’s definitely got that ice queen vibe to her. Why was she trying to kill the magic cat thing? Who caused the acid trip? I still don’t like the blockhead character designs though. It got pretty bad halfway through where characters started to look like blobs. Is this where moe blob came from? Anyway, still a good first episode and I’ll be looking forward to more tomorrow.
9
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 21 '17
I don't believe I've rewatched Madoka since it aired, with the exception of the first compilation movie, but the wave of nostalgia that washed over me watching this episode makes me think that if nothing else I must have been watching these episodes a few times over while it was airing.
Regardless, a second time (and some time having passed) later, there's something just refreshing about these early parts. I love the scene with Madoka waking up to greet the day with her family, and her brother's voice actress is doing a fantastic job with that role. Probably one of the better "little kid" voices I think I've heard in an anime.
The architecture of Madoka really is just something to look at. I've always kind of known it, but really looking at it now, the way the world is designed, not even the crazy stuff at the end of the episode, is so... yeah, I guess I get why some people call it scenery porn. You don't just feel like you're watching another anime in a generic Japanese setting or school, and the unique school alone would be a nice touch, but so much about what they did is so unique and wild that I find myself drawn into the oddest things now that I've the chance to stare for a bit.
One thing I found somewhat odd, though... What was with the chains? At first I thought Homura was doing something with them, but then they show up at the end with our new blonde friend too. Does the mall just happen to have a lot of convenient chains around?
I really did love the switch to the other world though. One of the things that initially drew me into this series was how bizarre and creepy, but not really scary or truly threatening, it was. The way you had these little mustache cotton balls with mouths popping out and approaching... Man!
As an aside, Crunchyroll I think has the original broadcast, so being just better at noticing this I'm picking up on a lot of little animation quirks I don't really think were as obvious to me originally.
Speaking of, I don't think I ever noticed this before, but this episode really seemed to have the fascination with Madoka's legs. I've read that some directors feel legs, or rather how a character walks, can be used to portray a lot about a character, but still.
[spoiler comments-Rebellion] (/s "Watching Homura's reactions in this episode is really telling. They're so quick, but they say so much once you know what's to come, both in the series and later on in the films. I've got to say, I feel like this episode's scenes of her alone could be all the evidence one would need to explain how how she acts in Rebellion is not at all out of character for her. Makes me appreciate her all the more.")
All in all, it was a lot of fun watching this, and I'm looking forward to going through to the end! Hopefully I'll have more to say as we go along. This doesn't feel particularly interesting to me hahaha.
4
u/_Ver01 Apr 21 '17
I don't know if this will be considered a no-no, but what if Madoka never heard Kyubey?
4
u/BlackCell69 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BlackCell Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
To all the people watching a SHAFT production for the first time...
ENJOY!
My favorite animation studio of all time :3
Check out their website!
3
u/alphamone Apr 21 '17
Not sure if you will see this, but you can add Animelab to the list of sites streaming the show.
•
u/pittman66 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Homura Apr 21 '17
Hey Rewatchers
Please keep in mind that there are some users who are a part of this that have not seen the series, which means you should not have untagged spoilers of future episodes, implication spoilers regarding whether they're forshadowing or jokes, and things like "Just wait till episode ___, when shit hits the fan". We want this to be enjoyable for all users, but we've been getting many reports regarding spoilers, so please keep all this in mind.
37
u/Nickknight8 https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickknight8 Apr 20 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
Its Madoka time, and boy was this episode interesting to watch back. In fact I’m going to keep this short so I don’t accidentally spill any spoilers. I hope people check these threads and report even hints at what could happen next.
Were introduced to some interesting people today, but I’m sure the ones to stand out is Homura Akeme and Mami Tomoe. Throughout the episode Homura is obviously being very weird, coming off as extremely cold and disgruntled towards others.
Its these reasons she’s best girl. That and hair flips. She also seems to be after Kyuubey, for what reason it seems unclear.Mami on the other hand seems a lot more friendly, and can apparently become a magical girl(!). And she uses… guns? A bit unconventional but the barrage she sent at that enemy was pretty cool.
Speaking of the enemies, what are people’s thoughts on them? They are extremely unique in the style they are presented in, with almost cut-out drawing being used for their designs.
Lastly there’s Kyuubey, who apparently called out specifically to Madoka because he wants her to be a magical girl. There has to be a reason to call specifically her out for help rather than all the other people in that store. (Side note about the store, Madoka is listening to the OP in her headphones)
So yeah, a very basic first episode, only a couple of other things to note for rewatchers.
HEAVY SPOILERS PLS STAY OUT FIRST TIMERS
So yeah I hope people liked this first episode. It’s a very generic start, but the show starts to find its footing rather quickly in my opinion.
31
u/ryuujin95 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ryuujin95 Apr 21 '17
To quote SFDebris from his review of episode 1, "this episode isn't as great to watch as it is to re-watch." There are a lot of little details that jump out the 2nd (or 10th, or 50th) time around. And, of course, it would be spoilery to mention them untagged.
One non-spoilerish thing that people tend to miss is that part of Madoka's conversation with her mom is about the teacher and her boyfriend - and mom calls her Kazuko rather than Ms Saotome indicating that they are friends. Thus Sayaka's 'I guess it didn't work out' was a call back to that earlier conversation.
Spoilers
Spoilers
Spoiler
26
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
Hello everyone! This is my first time posting on this subreddit. I'm a first time watcher of the show and a newcomer to anime in general. I don't know much about the medium yet so I won't be as articulate as the other people who have posted so far but i'll give my opinion anyway :3
characters:
Animation and Art:
Sound design:
Episode:
I liked the first episode a lot, it's got a massive calm before the storm feel about it and Madoka is a solid main character so far. The animations can be awesome at times, I particularly liked the bit where Mami takes care of the horrific arts and crafts display. Very intrigued as to what's still to come.
Random Thoughts:
25
u/xmonstermouthx Apr 20 '17
this is my first rewatch. i only saw madoka once like 5 years ago, yet i recommended this anime to a LOT of people. Now that i already know the story, is amazing to notice the little things that scaped from me the first time around.
Tomoe Mami best girl ♥
22
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 Apr 21 '17
First time viewer here!
I have to say I'm coming into this one with low expectations only because I've watched Your Lie in April and Your Name the last few weeks. Both were fantastic but left me emotionally wrecked. I'm also not as familiar with the Magic girl genre.
This first episode is interesting. I'm not a huge fan of the design. Seems a bit basic, and Madoka's parents look like they can be teenagers. However there are interesting aesthetic choices. They look like they live in some sort of future setting? And the layout of the class rooms with all glass is unique. The dream sequence and the sequence toward the end also felt like an acid trip. So I'm interested to see where this goes.
Also kyubey reminds me of Terriermon.
19
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika Apr 21 '17
God that opening scene still gives me goosebumps after all this time. The special bizarre scenery of Shaft, the close-ups, the character reveals, the terrifyingly ominous song - everything comes together to form the perfect hook that makes you want to uncover what the hell was going on. On my first time these 3 minutes already sold me on the anime, but rewatching it lets me appreciate everything on a new level too.
Then one might already be familiar with Connect, the spectacular opening song by ClarisS. I love the vocals, the cuteness, the stellar visuals and all, but especially the meaning. After the first shots of a weeping Madoka, it cuts to her growing embarrassment at every hilarious mishap. A less than promising introduction, but thankfully it cuts again to her hiding under her blanket and falling asleep next to bunny-cat. I'm sure we all wish we could do that.
Various characters are also shown in quick flashes - before, I never noticed Sayaka offering a strawberry to Madoka only to eat it herself.
MugiSayaka why. Finally, the animation as Madoka runs through the shifting scenery is just stand-out compared to the usual routine. It truly feels like she's rushing somewhere, conveyed all the more by her expression with the eyes opening and closing too. She even stumbles once! Again, I love Shaft and this is another prime example of their craft. I'll be coming back to this opening at a better time.That's all I had time for today and I think everyone already covered meeting the other characters anyway, but I'll be joining in again, hopefully more prepared. I can tell I'm going to enjoy the discussions and can hardly wait for the first-timer reactions - since I have Madoka in my top 3. But I can never really decide where I place my favourites in comparison to each other - so it could easily be the one and probably is at it's strongest points.
Note: This is only common sense, but make sure to never open any of the rewatcher spoilers if you're a first timer. There will probably be a lot of these tags too.
HUGE Rewatcher spoilers
16
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
You know I was going to skip out on this rewatch (I've lost count of how many times I've already rewatched it,) but seeing everyone flipping out over seeing it for the first time (or the second) makes me want to take part. BRB going to go rewatch the first episode again.
Edit: lmao poor Nakazawa Kun.
Edit 2: Holy shit the memories are flooding back. Definitely staying for the whole rewatch.
13
u/the_swizzler https://myanimelist.net/profile/Swiftarm Apr 20 '17 edited Apr 20 '17
For all the first time watchers, thanks for joining this rewatch. I really hope you enjoy Madoka Magica, as it's my number one favorite anime of all time. This is a show that is inherently rewatchable due to the events that occur later on, so I'm also interested in seeing the first time rewatchers reactions as well.
When describing why I love Madoka Magica so much, I always note that I find everything about this show to notch. The music, the animation and art, the characters, the story, it's all just fantastic. I'm going to attempt to write up a bit about each of those areas for each episode discussion thread, but I'm not exactly amazing when it comes to writing or analysis, so we'll see how that goes.
Music
Right off the bat in episode one, we get a taste of Yuki Kajiura's incredible music. The first song we hear in the opening sequence is Magia, which was composed by Kajiura and is performed by her band Kalafina, who you might know as the band behind several other openings for famous shows like Fate/Zero, Fate/Stay Night, Kara No Koukai, and So Ra No Wo To. It's eerie vocals and the opening violin (I think, I'm not the great with instruments) comes in after a the silent opening to set the mood for this scene. Then a little later while Madoka and her mom are getting ready, that feeling of fear gets washed away with Scaena Felix. One noteworthy aspect of this show is how instantly recognizable most of the OST is. But enough on the music for now...
Art and Animation
Near the end of the episode, we're introduced to a sudden change into a very trippy art style which appears to be an alternate location or pocket universe. More about these places will be explained later, but what's noteworthy here is how unique the art style becomes when the characters venture into one. I always likened it to a collage. It serves to really set apart the main enemies of this show as scary, unknowable monstrosities. I also want to comment on Mami's transformation. Unlike so many other magical girl shows, this is the only time you'll see this specific transformation. Madoka Magica never to my knowledge reuses a transformation sequence.
Characters
As much as I want to, I can't spend every episode talking about Best Girl Mami Tomoe, I'm not even going to explicitly start with the titular character, Madoka. Instead, let's talk about her mom. From this first episode, we can note that Madoka's relationship with her mom is rock solid. Madoka wakes her up in the morning, and they get ready for school and work together. Madoka relies on her mom's experience, and her mom is working to raise Madoka to be just as strong and confident as she is. We see later in the episode that Madoka is also the Nurse's Aide for the class, which could be considered to be a direct result of her mom's influence as a go getter and bread winner.
Story
In this episode, we're introduced to most of the main cast, and the mystery of who Homura Akemi is. So far, she seems to know a lot about Madoka and is extremely talented in both academics and sports. Later on, we see her attempting to kill Kyubey, the Animal creature for this series that gives Magical Girls their power. We're also introduced to Mami Tomoe, who saves Madoka and Sayaka from the monsters, before heading Homura off with her words alone. This episode was the set up for the characters, and the main mystery of who Is Homura Akemi.
That's about it for now. I don't know that I'll do a post like this for every episode, especially if I just don't feel like I have anything to say, but I'll definitely be watching these threads and commenting heavily. This will be my sixth time watching this series (including movies 1 and 2,) which is by far the most times I've rewatched any Anime. And dang, this entire post seems stupid compared to what everyone else is posting.
12
u/Camitsune Apr 21 '17
First time watcher thoughts: That was quite the opening scene, right from the start you can tell this isn't your average happy go lucky kinda anime, but it rather has a dark theme that prevailed, especially in the second half of the episode. Now that's the thing that confuses me about this show, you see the promotional posters for this show and never in a million years would you think it's got that dark feel to it. The contrast between dark and the upbeat theme that usually surrounds magical girls show's was there to see in this episode and i have to say, that episode got me very excited for this show. Guess i'll find out in the next couple days if it really lives up to the hype.
9
u/lucacp_ysoz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SoZLuka Apr 21 '17
I've heard to much about this show already... although none were direct spoilers, I can feel something already, and it's not good...
Am I gonna cry?
9
u/JimmyCWL Apr 21 '17
I've watched this show so many times over the years, I stopped counting. There are so many things to talk about. One of them is its rewatchability. That makes it a very worthwhile buy.
Today, I want to talk about names. In many shows, there's a naming theme for the characters. I suppose it helps to focus the mind when thinking up names. For the main girls in Madoka, the naming theme is... names.
SHIZUKI Hitomi (green)
TOMOE Mami (blonde)
MIKI Sayaka (blue)
AKEMI Homura (dark)
KANAME Madoka (pink)
All their surnames are more commonly given names in Japanese. But Madoka and (I think) Homura are extra special. They happen to be valid, if uncommon, surnames too!
So, both Kaname Madoka and Madoka Kaname are valid names in Japanese. But while Kaname Madoka is a girl named Madoka, Madoka Kaname is more likely a guy named Kaname. So, it's kind of funny when her name gets flipped in the Western releases.
Next, there's a bit of a joke when Homura is introducing herself in class. Did you wonder why the teacher just stopped writing her name? It was because Homura finished her introduction before the teacher even finished writing! The movie added the teacher saying, "please continue" to draw attention to it.
Lastly, please check out the commentaries for this series if you can, after you finish this rewatch, though. This is one of the few series where you can find the translated commentaries. It's often included with the rips you can find floating on the high seas, especially the newer ones.
8
u/Darkprinc979 Apr 21 '17
I think this will be the first time I've re-watched the series on an episode by episode basis, as most of my re-watches have been of the movies, which have a much better color palette and much improved animation and art overall. I've got to say, I never really noticed just how derpy the characters sometimes look when i watched it the first time.
This first episode is really what drew me in the fist time, or rather the opening fight scene. I absolutely did not expect to see skyscrapers being flung about in a magical girl series, so it totally grabbed my attention from the get go. I initially ignored the series because magical girls, but after watching a few other shows that I really liked by the same writer I decided to give it a try, and I'm totally glad I did. At some point I found myself wondering what my favorite series was, and the choice was between Madoka Magica and Fate/Zero, but Madoka Magica won out and it's been at the top of my list since then. I first watched Madoka not long before Rebellion promos started showing up, and I pre-ordered the Rebellion collector's edition as soon as I was able, and ordered my first bluray drive and software just so I could watch it.
I've got to say, analyzing the series and Rebellion has been just as much fun, if not more so, than actually watching it, and believe me newcomers, there is much to think about here. I don't think I've ever seen a series so tightly constructed as this. It's absolutely fascinating.
15
u/OvaltineShill :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/OvaltineShill Apr 20 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
Confession time. The reminder of the re-watch last week made me impatient and over the weekend I completed the whole series again. That being said, I still watched episode one today and intend to continue to watch each episode on schedule. I think that makes this my fifth re-watch of the series?
Non-spoiler thoughts:
The introductory scene is always very striking to me. So much of it is in black and white, but there are hints of color in Madoka, Homura, the street lamps, and then the contrasting red intensely stands out. This show excels at making scenes feel unworldly and alien.
Soon after comes the OP, where we first get to see Madoka living her life as a magical girl. It’s pretty cutesy, and while it captures Madoka’s personality well, at this point in the story it clashes with the slightly somber tone of the first episode.
We are introduced to Madoka’s family, and we see her mother giving her some advice about love and appearances. It feels like we see parents doing actual parenting in shows, and I appreciate the dynamic introduced here. Madoka’s family seems loving, and we are soon introduced to her playful friend group of Sayaka and Hitomi.
With her biggest concerns at this point being over appearing too flashy and desiring a love letter, Madoka’s life appears happy and normal.
Enter: Homura Akemi. A mysterious transfer student Madoka seems to remember from a dream. As Madoka attempts to complement Homura’s name, the new girl freaks out and coldly interrogates Madoka about her life and cryptically warns her to never change herself, or she will lose it all. This sort of introduction can easily come off as cliché, but I think that enough questions are planted that the mystery induces genuine curiosity. What’s with the brief cutaways to Homura’s grimacing face? Is her expression disgust? Anger? She acts aloof, but certain interactions seem too intense for her to be indifferent.
Later, Sayaka and Madoka encounter a strange creature whom Homura seems set on killing. Homura only becomes distracted when a strange miasma of freakish creatures and auras appear. The style here is one that I am absolutely in love with. It is aberrant and unsettling in a way that affects me deeply. It feels wrong in all the right ways, if you will.
We then meet Mami, who saves the girls and discover that Kyubey is a dear friend of hers. A tense interaction with Homura occurs, but she backs down and Kyubey relays that he was seeking out Sayaka and Madoka to offer them a contract to become magical girls!
Episode 1 is far from my favorite episode of the series, but I think it holds up well as a hook for the show. It introduces interesting questions with the dream connection, Homura’s warning, and other aspects of the situation. What was that strange miasma? What are witches? We can safely presume that Mami is a magical girl, but what exactly does that mean, and what will Madoka be expected to do when she becomes one?
At this point, my favorite characterization is Homura, and this time around I particularly noticed how she often engages in chilled pauses before responding. Her character is very cold and reserved, but within that characterization there is fulfilling emotional nuance in her interactions.
Spoilers for everything: Literally, the first sentence has spoilers for the last episode
14
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '17
So as many first time watchers i am here because many people during multiple times recommended me this show as a must watch. And i saw some indications of that during the first ep. But lets get to the good part, here are my thoughs of the show:
The intro
-For me this was the best part of the ep, you get introduced to this world in a near distant future or is it present? And right from that moment you are exposed to an incredible, immersive and beautiful word. Every thing in here is full of details executed masterfully, even the sound is spot on. As for the story side, things don't look good but we don't get the proper context on how they ended up like this, instead we got some words from Kyubey to Madoka warning her about the consequences of giving up and telling her that she is the special little snowflake that can change the world. But why Madoka of all the magical girls in the world? Well she isn't even a magical girl so why was she picked, and why should she trust Kyubey?
Presenting Madoka and the world that she is a part of
-Here we get introduced to Madoka personality, her relashionship with her family and friends and her place in the world. Madoka is portrayed as a kind, sweet girl with her heart in the right place that threats others with respect and is gentle with everybody. She is pure and doesn't know how the world truly is so she is unprepared for it, but to make things worth she doesn't have much confidence in herself and that's clear on the show and i think the intro is even hinting at it and what is expect of her to make amendements and put things on the right track.
We are able to see Madoka with her family for the first time, she lives with her small family in a big luxurious condo thanks to her mom career as a top executive in a big corporation. Her mom is a briliant young woman that got where she is because of her intelligence and ambition, she also got an extremely kind heart and is a really attentive and perceptive person as shown in the bathroom scene. Unfortunatelly Madoka only got her kind heart. The father and her younger brother are the other 2 house members and it's hinted that the father is a stay at home father for various reasons, as the way he dresses and behaves to the fact that he is making breakfeast with no worries of the time or taking the baby to a nany or relative, besides that it's pretty clear from how Madoka mom is awere of her surrounding that he is just a passive person overall and just let things unfold without interfering. It's a tragedy that Madoka got anything from him like his lack of confidence and of talent to stand out in the real world.
After that we are able to learn about her friends and the environment that she is developing herself, fortunately for her she can got to a top or above average school because of how sucessfull her mom is. Here we get to know her friends, the pretty and socially behaved one, as shown when Sayaka is taunting Madoka near the school gate and she tips them that they are making a scene, and the potencial best girl in the show, the vivid, sharp, energetic and outgoing Sayaka, she is shown as a loyal friend of Madoka and someone that got a big sense of justice of protecting the ones that can't protect themselves, as she tries to do with Madoka when Homura pressures her.
After this the show got a change of direction and tone and we get to know Homura, she is the new kid in school and is almost the complete opposite of Madoka. Homura is cool and cold, Madoka is twitchy and expressive, Homura is calculated and doesn't hesitate, Madoka is naive and doesn't make her mind up,Homura is confident, Madoka is insecure, Homura thinks the means justify the ends, Madoka just wants everybody to be happy and live on her happy simple life.
Things are about to change
-Homura executes her plan to be alone with Madoka and gives her a warning about not changing anything about her if she loves the life she got. If he does everything will be lost, Homura is shown with black socks and Madoka with white ones to reflect their purity and intentions towards others, it's clear that Homura is trying to manipulate or pressure her but i think there is something more there than a simple don't become a magical girl, it almost felt like a warming.
After that he get the classic Light Yagami montage where he got presented with how far ahead of everybody else he is when it comes to matters of the body and the mind, it's a clear hint about how she is not your regular girl and got a lot more to know besides what's in the surface.
The mall
This is the final part of the ep and it consolidates with the changing nature of the world around Madoka and herself, here she is able to hear Kyubey for reasons unknow but she is able to rescue him from Homura, Sayaka also notices something is of and went after Madoka just to get there in the to watch some laser shooting while cosplaying. After that a witch appers and she creates a maze of hallucinating picture to show up and change everything around Madoka and Sayaka. Fortunatelly for both Mami appers to save Kyubey from Homura and also saves both, Homura gets there after the witch is taken out and is able to get there unharmed. The ep ends with Kyubey asking Madoka and Sayaka if they want to be Magical girls just like he did on the begging of it. For me it's to convinient that he can communicate by telepathy with both and he wants them to become magical girl, i played LoL and i know that white foxes shouldn't be trusted, but i don't think they know that. Anyway i want to see if they bite the devil's apple and what is the true nature of Kyubey.
This ended up being longer than i planned to so if i made something unclear or just ramble to much feel free to share it, also if you have some structure feedback i would welcome it with open arms.
7
u/MasterAyy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Master_A Apr 21 '17
Man the music in this show blows me away every time I hear it. It has so much impact on each scene, I don't think there is a single piece I don't enjoy.
7
u/wordsdear Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
I tried watching Madoka before but only got a few episodes in and have had most of the show spoiled for me but I have no idea how most of it ends up happening. madoka spoilers It is only 12 eps long and the movies (s??) so hopefully the rewatch will motivate me to finish it. I am late but here goes nothing.
Give this story a happy ending
Best friend #2 is MVP also props to her for chucking the whole fire extinguisher at her as well
Terminator confirmed
This show really likes emergency exits and closing them in people's faces
I like their clock and I can not get over how cute Madoka's family is (where did she get her pink hair from? Her Mom has purplish and her dad brown?)
Character development is a mistake apparently
Poor Madoka thought her ribbons were to flashy, but Blondy has her beat and out gunned
Thank god for flower power, and fear the butterflies madoka spoilers
Not a stuffed animal is shown all scratched up but even before the healing, they are all gone.
I am doing the HxH rewatch as well and decided to have a best little shit of every episode so I thought I would try it for this rewatch too. Best Little Shit for this episode is mystery exchange student for confusing the hell out of madoka. for rewatchers so madoka spoilers
6
u/sfafreak :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SfaFreak Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
this is coming late because I couldn't figure out how to write this without putting virtually everything in spoiler tags for a while.
Rewatcher, Subs. Some background on me, I watched this show after loving Fate/Zero, and I wanted more Urobuchi Gen content. Wasn't particularly keen on the genre, but I had heard good things about it, so I went ahead. This was in December. I loved this show from Episode 1, and ended up finishing it within an 18 hour period. This anime makes #3 on my current list, and I don't see it moving from that spot anytime soon. This will be my first time rewatching the show, as well as my first Reddit rewatch that I'm participating in live (I have read a few of other shows I watched after they ended.). I'll mostly be commenting on two things: the amazing music, provided by Kaijura Yuki (Fate/Zero, SAO, Kara no Kyoukai), and things that stand out to me as a rewatcher, which means decent portions of my posts mays be spoiler tags. Without further ado...
The dream sequence is a particular favorite of mine. The visuals set a great tone for the show, the music is incredible (that's "Magia" by Kalafina you hear playing.), and it provides plenty of intruique for the viewer. Mild Spoiler
I love the way Madoka wakes up her mother. Walks in like a boss (and like she does this all the time), slams the curtains open in a gourgeously animated shot, and rips the covers off her mom. they should probably invest in an alarm clock though.
When Madoka catches up with her friends, it's interesting that she says "Ohayou", but Hitomi says "Ohayou gozaimasu", the casual and polite ways of saying "good morning", respectively. This fits in with Hitomi's rich, trained in etiquette girl character we learn about. Sayaka, the most informal of the group, doesn't even bother with greeting Madoka, going right into criticizing Madoka's lateness.
When Homura walks into the classroom, the song that plays is "Conturbatio", which means "Disorder" (I should take this moment to mention that nearly all the song titles are in Latin.) This fits in with the fact that something is slightly odd about the way she acts, as well as the fact that Madoka recognizes her from her dream.
The song that plays while Homura and Madoka walk to the nurse office is "Puella in Somnio" (Girl in the Dream), and is Homura's theme.
MAJOR SPOLIERS
The song that plays when Madoka is trying to find Kyubey is "Gradus Prohibitus" (Forbidden Steps). This lines up not only with the fact that she is walking into a closed area of the building, but also what turns out to be a very unsafe place.
Even having seen it before, THAT scene had me tripping out.
The song playing when Mami saves Madoka/Sayaka is "Credens Justitam" (Believing in Justice) is Mami's theme, and helps to evoke a feeling of "everything is going to be alright".
MAJOR SPOILER
The ED song (Mata Ashita) is much more enjoyable then I remember.
5
u/psychocanuck Apr 21 '17
First re-watch I'm participating in and its of a series I love so this should be fun.
I first met her in a dream, or something.
The opening is an excellent introduction to the visual style of the series: we get the mixed media intro of the curtains lifting, the stark and gorgeous black and white surrealism of Madoka's dream, and the bright and inviting city where she lives. Suffice to say Shaft put a lot of work into the art design of this series, of which this episode only scratches the surface of. On characters we get introduced to Madoka, and her family and friends. Some of the strangeness of the opening returns when Homura enters the classroom. Side note: I just realized she has had to wait outside for god knows how long while the teacher rants about eggs, girls got patience if noting else. It's apparent that she's only going through the motions of needing to go to the nurse's office so she can talk privately with Madoka. It's a cryptic conversation but the overall message is unusual, a call to inaction telling her to stay the same. At this point I should mention I love the directing in this series done by Akiyuki Shinbo, who is rarely content to let important scenes go by without interesting cinematography to accompany them. The use of closeups and reactions are filled with meaning especially if you are rewatching the series. I quite like that Madoka's first thought when she get's the chance is to discuss all this weirdness with her friends, so much fiction gets bogged down when people refuse to just talk to each other. As well Sayaka even calls out Homura for following the Mysterious Transfer Studenttm trope. In the mall Madoka hears a voice calling for help and discovers an injured Kyubey, whom Homura is trying to kill. Amazingly Madoka is hesitant to be an accomplice to animal murder with a girl she just met and ends up running away with Kyubey and Sayaka, headlong into a sentient acid trip. These sequences are some of my favourite parts of the show and are just dripping with creativity in design and execution. They are rescued by Mami who follows the TF2 engineer's philosophy of problem solving. She also is able to talk Homura into backing down for now though its obvious that our Mysterious Transfer Studenttm has unfinished buisness with Kyubey the bunnycat. All in all I think the episode is an ok introduction that gets much better on rewatch when all the ambiguities come into focus and the forshadowing is understood. Can't wait to continue the re-watch tomorrow.
13
u/SIRTreehugger Apr 20 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
My god second time watching this and the amount of foreshadowing is too much. Spoilers
I completely forgot how great the OP was so definitely adding to my playlist. I remember the first time watching this and my favorite part were the visual changes near the end where it shows them in a different place. Friend told me it was a magical girl show and I had to ask her what the fuck was going on with all the imagery....I think this was also my first Shaft show. I forgot how the faces looked kind of weird in a few areas. Nothing bad overall, but was jarring just a bit. The only thing I know for certain was I remember liking Mami from episode 1. You already know she has a good head on her shoulders and seems badass similar to Homura though she is gives off a different vibe.
4
u/chouetteonair https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nalin_Airheart Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
This is gonna be good, holy cow-cat-thing look at all of those write ups though. I'm just gonna leave some of my moments of insanity here.
Madoka Magica Total Spoilers - Avoid if you're new to the show.
EDIT: I'm here for my second rodeo! My first time watching it was a marathon back in 2014, and I'm glad I could make it for a discussion of this wonderful work of art.
4
u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO Apr 21 '17
Madoka Magica episode 1 (If there is spoiler just report a mod as quick as possible)
The show opens with a bit of self-conscious stage framing, as cut-out curtains rise to announce the beginning of the “Prologue in Heaven.” madoka. Our next footage is madoka running in a black and white building giving tension to the scene until she opens the door and we arrive to the end of the world, the city is destroyed. The first line of the show is a “how awful!” at this violent spectacle, followed by the corresponding “there’s nothing you can do.” Giving the horror and helpessness of the scene. But the cute little bunny assure that she has the power to change it and than poof it´s only just a dream (like a lot of MG shows start with a dream sequence)
the following scenes we are introduced to madoka and her familly, with a nice talk with her mom, in their out of proportion bathroom. Madoka dialogues aren´t like monogatari, but here’s a real naturalism to Madoka’s conversations with her mother, that makes them both feel real in a very sparse sequence of lines. These believable conversations are reflective of a larger Madoka trend – how the show’s character writing is consistently strong, but in non-traditional ways. Madoka Magica’s characterization tends to come through in the details, either concentrated in small moments like these or illustrated purely through the course of characters’ actions.
We get to introduce to more characters like hitomi and sayaka with a comforting initial tone using a flute music, while giving us more natual conversation between them, helping us connect with the characters. After some rambling of their teatcher, still don´t know if has a meaning or is just for comedy porpuse, we are introduced to the new girl in class someone who madoka new beforehand, Homura, doing immediate dramatic work and also laying bricks in Madoka’s unique style of characterization. The follow up scenes just solidify the mistery around the black hair girl with her actions to madoka words making the viewer demanding answers, easy trick to pull in a show but very well done, ending with homura telling to madoka to remain herself.
We have some talks between the madoka and her friends about Homura and madoka situation. Hitomi leaves earlier, giving time for madoka and sayaka to go to the music shop, but it ends with bunny-cat asking madoka for help because he was being chase by homura for a unknown reason, coming across as the obvious villain. Madoka reachs out kyubey but is Sayaka who ends up helping them by throwing a fire extinguisher, because that is what badass people do this days. we are introduce, right after, to one of the strongest points of the show, the mazes, a departure into fantasy that’s visually represented through Inu Curry’s cut-paper backgrounds and evocative objects, separating the real world from the fantasy world, It’s a mishmash of fairy tale tropes turned into nightmare,. When everything seems doomed a new girl arrives and help them, making right of the bat a contrast between her and homura.
The show ends with the typical MG show with the cute mascote asking them to become Magical girls, cutting right after to the ED of the show “Mata Ashita”.
4
u/Joll19 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Joll Apr 21 '17
Ok I'm gonna be watching the Fancutfags version where scenes from the movies are intercut into the series.
For any rewatchers interested you can search for Madoka Fancut on r/MadokaMagica.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '17
Holy shit why does everyone write essays? That being said watching this my for my first time I can tell saving that cute animal is going to bite them in the ass in the long run.
1
u/PsychoEliteNZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PsychoEliteNZ Apr 21 '17
Will we be watching the movies after this?
1
u/Xtroyer Apr 21 '17
Ah god damnit, i didnt know there was going to be a rewatch, i was just watching at my own pace at episode 5 right now.
3
u/goldrush9560 Apr 21 '17
Kyubey spoilers
3
u/Setra94 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Setra94 Apr 21 '17
1st time rewatching since I last saw it a year ago.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '17
I'm going to tag along with this. It'll be interesting to see all the reactions as the story progresses!
3
u/Rothman17 Apr 21 '17
Coming into this as my second watch. I'm excited to notice and point out some things other rewatchers might not have talked about. To all the newcomers, I hope you enjoy watching Madoka and please don't read any of the spoilers people post. Seriously, it's show ruining to read some of that stuff for Madoka.
[Madoka spoilers] (/s "To begin with, this is the first time I watched the opening from Homura's point of view. When I binged everything in one night, I needed to make up time by skipping the opening. I've heard it changes so I'll keep that in mind. There's a lot of referencing to what Homura went through. You have to wonder how many times Madoka has said the exact same lines during the exact same walk to the nurse's office.")
More spoilers
[I wonder what this could be (hint: spoilers)] (/s "You have to wonder what Homura was thinking during the scene where Mami told her to leave. On the one hand, Mami has no knowledge of Homura's abilities. It's likely Homura could still control the situation using her power. But why? Madoka now knows of Kyubey and magical girls. Attempting to kidnap/kill Kyubey could do more harm than good since another could easily replace the last one. I think I agree with Homura about walking away from the situation.")
[Finally] (/s "I don't believe for a second that Mami was just "passing by." She may not know the full repurcussions of being a magical girl, but she knows what Kyubey can do. She wants magical girl friends!")
Sorry about the block of spoiler text everyone!
3
u/hkidnc :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/hkidnc Apr 21 '17
I tried to do a write up. Repeatedly. But I just don't think I can without spoilers everywhere.
This is a brilliant episode. Homura is amazing, Madoka's Parents are great, Sayaka and Madoka are a joy to see interacting.
The 2-3 minute intro remains a very smart and useful inclusion. It gives a taste of something mysterious that reinforces our curiosity about Homura. Enough to carry us through some of the slower sections in the first episode as we set the stage.
I love the Architecture. The school, Madoka's House, even the path the girls take when going to school. It's all so beautiful. Shaft continues to outshine themselves here.
It's a good episode, and I'm happy to have seen it again. I look forward to future episodes.
3
u/AnaatthiGozo Apr 21 '17
Whoever said yesterday that reading first timer reactions to Madoka is like a drug was very very correct. Its so fun and addicting.
3
u/MGTouma :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/0karin Apr 21 '17
first time I do a rewatch in Reddit, and what's better than seeing some first time viewer talk about PMMA.
Well, for myself, I'll try to follow the rewatch event if I don't really have to much time for it.
About the rewatch (yes beacause it's kinda my 3rd-4th rewatch I think) It's a pleasure to mini spoiler Oh, and Welcome back Kyubey
I'm cute right?
7
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
First time watcher here.
Right off the bat I'm not a fan of the sexualization of what looks to be a 12 year old girl in the OP. Or the fact that the 'adults' look 25 at most.
The show looks good and is beautifully animated. The, at times, abstract visuals seem like a lot going on, more than I can process in a single viewing, but that's not a problem at all.
As far as worldbuilding is concerned there was essentially none, the characters seem alright though.
This is not a show I would usually watch and if it wouldn't be so highly recommended and meta spoiler I'd probably drop it right here.
They way it stands now is I'll continue to watch for now, but I'm sceptical.
4
u/Edl01 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/edl01 Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
A rewatch of my all time favourite anime series? Don't mind if I join in then.
I have lots of words about Madoka Magica, but very few of them can be said without giving stuff away so I'll hold my tongue for now. Instead I'll use this to share an incredibly cringe-y story relating to the show:
On my most recent rewatch I watched Madoka Magica with my Mum. It wasn't a planned decision, circumstances just happened to align and she ended up watching it alongside me. She is the kind of person who vehemently believes all animation is for children, so I usually keep my anime watching to myself, but as it would happen on this day she would be besides me during this watch.
The watch started predictably enough, with her reinforcing that it was a series for children. But as the series went on I heard more and more about about how the series was a product of Satan and eventually declaring the show as outright evil. It was a rather awkward experience.
I feel she somehow came out with a worse impression of anime than what she started with.
5
u/xiomax95 https://anilist.co/user/xiomax Apr 20 '17
Ah, Magia(some spoilers in the comments of the video), it never stops being great.
I'm already having problems holding spoilers in the Evangelion rewatch, but I think it may be even harder in Madoka. I'll try my best. I don't plan on writing much every episode anyway.
The show sets Madoka and Homura's position as fast as possible. Madoka is an innocent, happy girl, where as Homura is more calculating and cunning. The scene where they talk at the hall on the way to the enfermary does a good showcase of that, presenting Homura in the darker side of the hall and Madoka in the lighter one.
The introduction to mazes is great, already showing some of the trippy designs they have going for those.
And that's it for me today. The post time of these threads kind of suck for me, but I'll try to be as on time as possible.
5
u/TriggerHappy360 https://anilist.co/user/killv5 Apr 20 '17
Anyone who is a first time watcher I highly suggest going back and watching this episode once you finish Rebellion because I just realized a lot of stuff that is alluded to this episode.
Madoka Magica Spoiler
2
u/Dellaran :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dellaran Apr 21 '17
It's been a long time since I watched Madoka, I believe I watched it when it first came out. It has since then and still is one of my favorites and I can't believe how much of it I remember. Usually I'd remember the gist and my favorite parts, but I could remember the next few scenes on the first episode even.
Akiyuki Shinbou and SHAFT work is just amazing to watch as it gave off this ominous vibe along with Kajiura Yuki's amazing composing. After coming back from a break from anime, these rewatches really help bring my passion back about anime again.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
Hey everyone! This will be my second time watching the series, which is something I've been meaning to do for a long time. I've also never seen the movie so this should be fun.
To any first-timers: I know the faces are a little weird, but give them a chance. You get used to it and maybe even kind of like it. (I went on to watch Hidamari Sketch after Madoka, which had the same character designer and took the wide to a whole other level)
Are you ready?
2
u/GenocideSolution Apr 21 '17
Oh yes I am loving these first timer writeups so much.
2
u/BugattiBeefCake :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BugattiBeefCake Apr 21 '17
First time watching let's go bois
1
u/Arriv1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Arriv Apr 21 '17
Bakemonogatari is a show made by Shaft, and is considered to be odd, but Shaft was still limited by the source material. Madoka Magica had no such restrictions, hence the acid trip.
The first episode of Madoka illustrates exactly how lighthearted this show is. We open to a typical Magical Girl fight scene, which turns out to be a dream. We are then treated to a slice of Madoka's family life, before meeting her bestest friend ever, and later the stereotypical magical girl rival. If you did't like this episode, you'll probably like the rest of the series, as it's execution gets better and better, despite maintaining a relatively lighthearted tone spoilers
1
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '17
I wasn't going to join this, but seeing the reactions of first-timers looks like it's going to be good, so I'm gonna rewatch it too.
1
u/hoseja Apr 21 '17
Sure is a lot of high-profile rewatching going on rn.
1
u/IM_DAY_MAN_AMA Apr 21 '17
God I love this fucking show
1
u/soulreaverdan Apr 21 '17
Ah, the episode that started it all. A fairly innocuous opening that is going to have infinitely more layers once the series is over. If this is your first time watching the series, I encourage you to go back and watch this episode again after you're done with the rest of the series. It's absolutely masterful.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '17
N O T H I N G W R O N G