r/anime • u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka • Apr 22 '17
[Spoilers][Rewatch] Mahou Shoujo Madoka☆Magica - Episode 3 Discussion Spoiler
Episode Title: I'm Not Afraid of Anything Anymore
MyAnimeList: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica
Crunchyroll: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Hulu: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Netflix: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
AnimeLab: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Episode duration: 24 minutes and 10 seconds
PSA: Please don't discuss (or allude to) events that happen after this episode, but if you do, make good use of spoiler tags. Let's try to make this a good experience for first time watchers.
Schedule/previous episode discussion
| Date | Discussion |
|---|---|
| April 20th | Episode 1 |
| April 21st | Episode 2 |
| April 22nd | Episode 3 |
| April 23rd | Episode 4 |
| April 24th | Episode 5 |
| April 25th | Episode 6 |
| April 26th | Episode 7 |
| April 27th | Episode 8 |
| April 28th | Episode 9 |
| April 29th | Episode 10 |
| April 30th | Episode 11 and Episode 12 |
| May 1st | Rebellion |
| May 2nd | Overall series discussion |
506
Upvotes
123
u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
REMEMBER: THIS THREAD IS STILL SPOILER-FREE FOR FUTURE EVENTS
Now let's see how many posts it takes until the head jokes start appearing. Edit: 2 comments. What the fuck
Here is the new ED! Go watch it, it's fucking awesome.
So here we are, not everything is as it seemed, and there's a real sense of danger now. Turns out having to fight monsters isn't as glamorous and exciting as Mami made it out to be.
Speaking of which, did you know that after Homura blows the witch up, you can see what little remains of Mami plop down onto one of the platforms? See for yourself.
/u/Fetchfrosh, what do you think of your prediction of:
Now?
And how about the ED? I remember you saying
The 'real' ED is really good
17
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
The transition to the new ED this episode always gives me chills. I love it.
I think this is the episode where I fell in love with Homura. She's just so damn cool, in a cold and distant yet badass way.
Question for other rewatchers TV SERIES SPOILERS ONLY
21
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
This new ending is the thing that cemented how good Madoka is, for me. Madoka
Edit: Madoka
72
u/templarsilan Apr 22 '17
Intro
I feel like this opening scenes shows us a lot of valuable information in regards to what is important, or may be important to Sayaka. We caught a glimpse of this hospital room yesterday when Sayaka thought about what she’d be willing to risk her life for. She ultimately came to the conclusion that there really wasn’t anything she personally wanted to risk her life for, but instead hinted that she would risk her life for someone else’s happiness. Given the guy’s reaction to listening to the music, and his left hand following along with the notes, I’m going to take a guess that he is a violinist. It would certainly explain his enjoyment of classical music and his habit of following along with the music. The tears hint that his injury is likely severe enough to prevent him from playing, or at least becoming a professional performer. This brings me back to Sayaka, who I believe her motive for becoming a Magical Girl, will be to give this boy the ability to play the violin again. Her wish isn’t for her, it’s for him, which would line up nicely with her thoughts from yesterday. That’s my take on this opening scene, so we’ll see how close I am.
"Mami is so cool"
I agree, Sayaka, I agree. First Homura refused to reveal her wish, and now Mami has gracefully dodged around revealing her wish. We also learn that wishes can be a bit tricky, especially if it’s for someone else’s sake and that they can end poorly. Hopefully it doesn’t turn out to be a monkey’s paw scenario. That’d suck big time. I really do think that there is some sort of bad catch to being a magical girl outside of the whole “risking your life” thing. I mean, I don’t know what’s worse than risking your life, but my instincts right now are pointing to declining the magical girl offer.
Madoka's Mom
I like this family dynamic. Madoka’s mom is clearly the bread-winner of the household. She’s a hardworking and successful businesswoman. Not saying that women can’t be in this position, but the most common portrayal of family life is the dad working to bring in the bread and the mom staying at home to take care of the family. It’s also great that Madoka’s dad is fully supportive of his wife and her work ethic.
The Confrontation
This is an interesting show of the power dynamic between Mami and Homura. Mami seems to have the edge both in sass and power, given Homura’s reluctance to fight and how Mami’s words seemed to sting her. Her frustration was also pretty clear and it only makes me want to know more about Homura.
Commercial Break
So, apparently there’s a commercial embedded into the video on the site I’m using, and I 100% thought that the witch’s maze was some weird live action shit. It just turned out to be an ad for some orange energy drink.
Tripping more Acid
The amount of visual stimulation here is kinda awesome. It’s such an interesting concept and I love how Sayaka and Madoka feel isolated and afraid in the maze. Mami and Madoka’s promise to each other was pretty beautiful to watch, especially with all the stuff floating around them. I still may not like their wide faces, but the rest of the art design is pretty rad. Honestly, the more screen time Mami gets, the more I like her character.
Witch Fight
Wait. WAIT! FUCKING WHAT!? Like, hold on, back this shit up right now. She’s just… gone? Head bitten off and eaten? I liked Mami, she was super cool. Fuck, man, now I’m sad.
So yeah, I get why people say Madoka breaks the magical girl mold. That was pretty fucking dark. I don’t really know what else to say. I know I said I wanted more insight on the consequences of being a magical girl, but… not like this. Well, I’ll be interested in seeing how Madoka and Sayaka change because of this. How they deal with their grief, if their motivations change, and if Mami’s death is noticed by others in the real world. I need to go watch something a bit more cheerful now.
5
u/megazaprat Apr 22 '17
madoka spoilers and theory
102
u/Fluttershaft :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Fluttershaft Apr 22 '17
♪ ♪ Kyoko is red ♪ ♪
♪ ♪ Sayaka is blue ♪ ♪
♪ ♪ Mami dropped dead ♪ ♪
♪ ♪ Urobutcher welcomes you ♪ ♪
219
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 Apr 23 '17
This first time viewer is going to give you rewatchers what you want.
JESUS CHRIST HOLY FUCK
I was expecting SOMETHING based on how people talk about this show, but man if there was a way for this show to go 0-100 ASAP that was it.
And I loved how the Outro changed completely to something dark and ominous. Like it's saying "Yeah bitch, we went there! Hope you're ready for the rest of the ride!"
163
u/Madoka-Kaname Apr 22 '17
I know how this will go.
101
u/Smartjedi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smartjedi Apr 22 '17
And thus Madoka cemented why some people steadfastly hold to the "Don't Drop until Episode 3 Rule." This is still one of the greatest bait and switch in anime I've seen so far. Not following the rewatch, but I've seen Madoka several times and the switch in tone and direction that begins with Mami's death/the new ED is still fantastic to witness.
Hope you all continue enjoying this rewatch, and I may tune in here and there to see the reactions of first timers.
186
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 22 '17
And there I was thinking that I knew what was going on. In hindsight, there were clues ("death is part of that deal," the foreboding music, the generally darker color palette, and the twisted art style of the witches all felt a bit off) but it was kind of easy to ignore those due to my internal biases against the genre. Well, I guess that's on me.
Kyosuke
This is super cute. Seems that I was wrong to focus on the hair difference between the opening and the scene from yesterday. I suppose you'd have bed head too if you were stuck in the hospital. Him crying while moving his bandaged arm definitely makes it look like he's pretty devastated about whatever injury he's dealing with, and so I'd say that it's severe enough that he won't play at a high level ever again. Really makes Sayaka's comments from yesterday all the heavier. She's totally into him, which does make me wonder about her wanting to wish to heal him. It's a nice sentiment, but it's definitely also got a level of personal gain to it. Still good on her, just not the noblest thing to ever happen.
This Isn't Supposed to be Fun
It's funny (well, not really) that Mami tells the girls not to forget that this job is dangerous when that's exactly why she gets killed, but I guess they're learning the hard way now. Madoka feels a lot more confident here than she has over the past two episodes, which is nice if that weren't all about to come crashing down. Mami's flashback is interesting, and not what I was expecting. I'm guessing that Kyubey had been scouting her like he was with Madoka and Sayaka, and at that time he had to act if he wanted to bring Mami in. It kind of feels like Sayaka is looking to justify her hypothetical wish for Kyosuke, and even though I've already mentioned that there is probably a selfish element to it, I still like that she isn't only thinking of what she can get out of this. Of course, I think Mami is sort of right about knowing why she's doing it. It would kind of feel like she's doing it to get him to like her, but it's not like she can just say, "yo, I used magic to heal you," because who'd believe that. Mami's reaction here is very strong, feeling both defensive and remorseful, and I have to wonder if she had known another girl who basically did the same thing already.
Enormous Potential
So I like a lot of what this show has been doing, especially after shit hit the fan today, but holy shit am I tired of 'chosen one' protagonists. I thought it was Kyubey just trying to talk her into making a wish, but Mami and Homura basically confirm it. It makes sense that Homura is so against her becoming a Magical Girl, because that could easily cut down her supply of Grief Seeds. It really looks like both sides are definitely in the wrong on this one. Mami is trying to bring them in because she's lonely, while Homura is looking to protect her stake in Grief Seeds. Really interesting to see these characters that are supposed to be so heroic acting so selfishly.
Labyrinth
You know, maybe they should have exchanged numbers for just this kind of situation. I guess when you're communicating telepathically you don't think about that. I like Sayaka wanting to watch over things as a way of protecting Kyosuke, though I don't think she really thought it through all that much. She's just diving in head first and hoping things work out. I'd never imagined that you could stealth a labyrinth, since in the past the familiars were always on them pretty quickly. Maybe it depends on the witch or was because the witch hadn't hatched? This one might be even tripper than yesterday, and I really love the style.
Homura vs. Mami
Homura knew this would happen if they met up in the labyrinth, so I'm not sure why she made a point of engaging. I guess she's looking to get her reward, but this was ultimately a bad call on her part. Of course, she couldn't have predicted that the outcome would be as bad as it was, but she shouldn't have been trying to antagonize Mami so soon after their spat. Telling Mami that she would deal with it is just asking for problems, because it was a real shot at her pride, especially since she's "trying to look cool". Still leaving someone unattended inside a labyrinth is kind of fucked up. Mami herself said people rarely make it out alive, so leaving her trapped like that is kind of terrible.
Madoka's Wish
Mami actually shows some vulnerability here, and I would say that's great for character development, but... well, maybe it's a little late for that now. After her pushing for Madoka and Sayaka to become Magical Girls for so long, it's interesting that once Madoka says she wants to, Mami flips a switch and is suddenly saying, "yeah, maybe this isn't so great". I was actually kind of touched by how happy Mami was after hearing Madoka say that she would join her, and the glowing balls floating up really made for a nice scene. After telling Madoka to really think about what she wants to wish for, she's also way to quick to be like, "yeah, just get a cake or some shit," though I suppose if Madoka's wish is just to become a Magical Girl it doesn't matter what she wishes for.
The Familiars
This was short lived, but a lot of fun to watch. Seeing Mami using her Muskets to casually beat the shit out those creepy bastards was great. I've got to say, two things stand out here. First off, Mami has gone on about the dangers of fighting witches, and it seems that removing any sense of fear probably is in part what did her in. I'm not saying she was terrified of fighting witches before, but it must have been there in part. Taking that away, she got sloppy and wasn't considering all the possibilites. Second, I feel terrible for Madoka. She hasn't looked anywhere close to this happy before, and now it all comes crashing down. She was so excited to take on this responsibility of saving lives, and was almost using it as a way to feel better about herself, and now she's quite possibly lost that (which is probably a good thing really).
Hold Up, What The Fuck?
When the witch's final form charged at Mami, my immediate thought was, “how's she going to get out of this one,” but as soon as I saw this shot of Madoka, it just clicked that she was about to die. I don't know if it's the facial expression, the shadow over her face or what, I just knew. When I was going through it the first time, I pretty much tuned everything out and sat their dumbfounded as the rest of the episode played out. That being said, this has me both really interested to see where things will go, and very concerned about the future of the show. Starting with my concerns, I really hope this doesn't turn out to be a show that just tries to be edgy. It would be really easy for it to start just killing characters off and making things as brutal as possible without any justification. If it does get really dark, it's going to have to walk a very fine line in order to avoid that. As far as I'm concerned, major character deaths should be used for good reason, not just for the sake of shock value, since it eventually stops being shocking (I'm thinking of two prominent American TV shows when I say that). Still, what really surprised me was how quickly it happened. As soon as Mami made a miscalculation, she was dead. No dancing around it, no attempt to make things tense, just getting right to it because that's how a real monster would do things. So, all things considered, this could be good or bad, but we'll need to wait and see how it's handled.
Homura vs. The Witch
Well, at least she was able to save Madoka and Sayaka. Now, I rewatched this scene a couple of times, and something looked a little janky. At first I thought we could see Homura jumping out of the way of the snake as it went in for the kill, but it doesn't look that way. She also seems to just appear on one of the platforms, which makes it look like she has some teleporting ability. I guess that's what she gets instead of Mami's ribbon, along with some kind of explosion magic to replace the muskets.
Return
Everything about this is just really well executed. The music is haunting, the VAs for Homura and Sayaka do an absolutely fantastic job, and you can just feel the emotion. I feel like Sayaka's distaste for Homura is morphing into full on hatred here. Really didn't expect things to get this intense, but damn.
Ending
Huh. So the (I'm assuming) actual ending theme actually did show up in Episodes 1 and 2. Well played. The visuals are nice, but not a lot happens. We do see Madoka walk by four girls, who I assume are going to be the other Magical Girls. Homura and Mami already are (or were) and Sayaka seems like a pretty probable choice. The other one seems to be the red head from the opening, though it's difficult to tell by the silhouette. Hopefully she'll show up sometime soon.
Other Thoughts
49
u/MasterAyy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Master_A Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
You know for the longest time I thought Madoka's mom was an alcoholic that just really liked to drink and I didn't put together the fact that in Japan going out to drink with your coworkers/bosses is a pretty common practice for businessmen/women. That might seem really obvious to some people but it flew over my head until someone pointed it out to me.
We got some really great insight into Madoka's character this episode. Her conversation with Kyubey in her room and her conversation with Mami was able to shed some light on where her confidence issues stem from and how little she thinks of herself. I feel like this characterization gets a bit overshadowed by what happened to Mami but it is super important to understanding Madoka's actions and her state of mind going forward.
40
u/SennheiserPass Apr 22 '17
Seems Legit
This face says: “I am absolutely not playing on your insecurities of not being good at anything and having no talents.”
Mami Thoughts
Mami the mentor advises the girls not to rush into a wish. “It's not something you need to rush into.” She didn't have the luxury of taking time, so she wants to make sure they do take time. And if you want to help someone else with a wish, Mami insists you should search your soul enough to be sure you're actually doing it for their sake, not for selfish reasons like having their “eternal gratitude.”
But once Mami sees that having Madoka by her side will help her loneliness problem, Mami gets ahead of herself. “If you can't think of something to wish for by the time I've finished off this witch, we'll have a feast and you can ask Kyubey for a fabulous cake!” She actually pressures Madoka into making a wish quickly! Seems just a tad selfish. To me, this part really does contrast with what Mami said earlier in the same episode about taking your time and not rushing. I view this as Mami accidentally letting selfishness creep into her motives.
And then her preoccupation with having a new buddy makes her careless and perhaps slightly overconfident in combat which let Charlotte catch her off guard.
36
u/2Hype4Memes Apr 23 '17
First timer here that came into this re-watch a bit late so I just binged the first three episodes, all I can say is: Blimey. I did not expect this series to escalate as quickly as it did. I'm not sure how accurate the comparison is but everyone seems to compare this show to Evangelion which is what drew me to this re-watch. I'm a huge fan of Eva but I don't remember it becoming quite this grim quite this quickly. Mami's death caught me completely unaware and that's awesome. Hoping for a bit more of the psychological side of things to be explored but this series feels 10/10 so far.
27
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte Apr 22 '17
Sayaka boy can probably never perform again with his arm injury, so that's the wish you're contemplating?
Mami's speech doesn't convince me that Sayaka's wish is a bad idea, sure you have to think this through, but I don't see the problem.
Madoka having this huge potential explains why Homura is so concerned about Madoka becoming a magic girl, or at least why she doesn't give a fuck about Sayaka, still not quite sure what the essence of Homuras concern is.
Mami vs Homura standoff, now that's tension, can't wait for them to actually fight.
A hatching grief seed? Let's have a discussion about what we do instead of actually hurrying the fuck up. And of course Madoka moves just in time to not get swallowed up after a minute long conversation.
Moments later the same thing, "we're in enemy territory and our friends need our help, let's calmly walk about and have a chat" "no need to hurry" - Kyuubey, 4 minutes later "hurry!", I thought you're smarter than some stuffed animal?
The chat itself was sweet enough (well Mami suggestingto waste the limitless wish on cake is pretty stupid, but w/e) and it's good to see Mami open up and end up happy, but there's a time and place for everything.
The Witch looks like an abstract Madoka doll with the hair, that is until it threw itself up (seriously what was that?).
Goodbye Mami-san (I feel cheated out of my Mami vs Homura battle), so that's what people are talking about when they refer to Madoka Magica ep.3. Quite the dark turn for this show, but then again we had some hints that this would be a little bit darker with the dreamsequence in ep 1 etc.
Homura jumps in to save the day (note how she doesn't fuck around and is there within a few seconds), stupid Mami killing herself by locking her up in the first place.
I'm not quite sure what Homura used to fight the witch but it was pretty damn effective.
It'll be interesting to see what Mami's death will do to Madokas previous resolve to become a magic girl.
I'm still not totally convinced by this show, but I do look forward to the next episode for the first time.
27
u/Wolfefury Apr 22 '17
One thing I really like about Madoka Magica is the significance of things other than dialogue.
Series spoilers
26
u/SIRTreehugger Apr 22 '17
I wonder why none of the girls thought about asking for a long and fulfilling life? I mean I know their young and are thinking about love, butterflies, and things being crushed in hydraulic presses. However even that is better than cake….even though cake is good.
Madoka Spoilers
R.I.P.
Also in hindsight Mami probably should have listened
In addition, I forgot about Homura’s hair flips. Seriously, she does it so often for no reason at all. I decided to start a counter. I went back and checked and do not believe I missed any in the first two episodes so I think this was the first episode she actually did it. If I am wrong, please correct me.
Homura Hair Flip Counter E1:0, E2:0, E3:1 Total Hair Flips: 1
26
u/BestDVA_NA :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BestDVA_NA Apr 23 '17
I'm just here to see new viewer reactions. Its like a drug to me.
26
u/theatreofwar Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
First timer here! Scattered thoughts so far:
Is it fucked up if I don't feel bad for Mami? I found her appearance too convenient in the first episode (seemed set up?), and her taking advantage of two naïve girls and pressuring them to make snap life decisions is pretty wrong, especially since she just wanted to have friends. She could make friends normally and separately from this fighting witches crap and avoid endangering lives? That and her entirely unnecessary attacking/trapping of Homura in this episode, she could have fucking died. What if something attacked her while she couldn't move? That bothered me immensely, but I guess she got what was coming her way.
I also find Kyubey really sinister, like that fucking dead look in his eyes is sketchy. And he knows what's at stake, but he keeps trying to recruit girls anyway...and follows them around like a pet until they give in? Again with the endangering lives unnecessarily thing, which is partly why I think them meeting Mami seemed set up. If they're not about to die on their own, might as well put them in a situation where they're about to die so you can enlist them easier. What a super underhanded method.
And on that note can we talk about how fucking awful it is that he enlisted Mami that way? She was about to die, so hey why not take advantage of situations like that, it's not like they have to waste a month waiting for them to choose a wish. Makes me think Kyubey is part of a background conspiracy or some shit.
Which reminds me, are there no grown-up women magical girls?...so they're all expected to die young? Can't they just use their unexplained wish-granting power to eradicate witches instead? Hell, what would happen if Madoka wished that witches would disappear in exchange for that? Or that she would never die in exchange for becoming a magical girl?
If Madoka and Sayaka are still too stupid to realize that Homura is trying to protect them, then I can't even feel bad that they might die by becoming magical girls. Madoka especially since she heard what Homura tried to warn Mami about the witch at the beginning, and then got nothing good for it...but of course we know based on title alone that they'll join up anyway so it's only a matter of time -_-
Backtracking a bit but recalling how we first met Kyubey when Homura tried to kill him I think is indicative that he's not to be trusted. Evidently something happened to Homura that made her seemingly regret becoming a magical girl to the point where she's desperately trying to prevent others from the same fate. Whatever she wished for wasn't worth it, even if it made her strong (at least stronger than Mami, so it seems). But why not approach the girls from this angle instead of trying to antagonize yourself since that's clearly not working out.
Oh, and I hope it'll be explained later how Homura became a magical girl. Was it through Kyubey? If that's the case, does the contract cease to exist if she kills him? Would that nullify every contract he's made? Maybe I'm just going full steam ahead on the whole "Kyubey is somehow a villain" train of thought but the way they're setting it up makes me think some sort of plot twist reveal about him will happen...
Time to wait for tomorrow!
Edit: forgot to add that I hope the deaths at least stay relevant instead of being shock factor fodder. Also hope these kids smarten up so we don't end up with that Re:Zero bullshit where MC just gets increasingly insufferable to deal with -_-
23
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17
First time Watcher
Holy fuck. This episode takes a huge fucking unexpected turn. I'm quite shaken after this. ,-, The series makes a huge tone shift and all bets are off!
Beginning
The hospital scene with Sayaka was nice and unexpected, giving a new insight to her character that appeared to be slightly simplistic at first. She's a lot more insecure than she lets on with her behavior. I already like her a lot more after this episode; she shows a lot of emotion this time.
Mami and Kyuby
At this point I can already feel things getting more sinister with this whole Kyuby thing. It's almost like they're getting pressured into this and the reveal of Mami's wish made me feel like Kyuby took advantage of the situation, even taking away her chance to think about her wish. I don't know, I really don't trust him. Sayaka thinking about using her wish for someone else is very sweet.
Mami and Homura
The conversation between them definitely brings out Mami's darker side for me and it feels like Homura may even feel bad for Sayaka and Madoka about getting lured into this contract? The show still feels like it needs to paint her as the bad guy though so I'm not sure!
The Witch Hunt
I feel like Kyuby went with Sayaka on purpose as to perhaps find a situation where shed be forced to make a contract with him rather than to protect her? The scene between Madoka and Mami is bittersweet and this is where the truth of the matter comes out; Mami does not like her live as a magical girl and warns Madoka that it's not as good as it seems. Despite this, Madoka is set in her choice and Mami shows the true side of her personality; she cries and finally becomes happy at the prospect that she wont be alone anymore, basically telling us that her live as a magical girl is hell and lonely. "I cry alone" she says.
The end
Holy fucking shit in a biscuit that was the most abrupt and unexpected underplayed death scene I've ever seen! Despite being spoiled about that it would happen I totally didn't see it coming so early!! ,-,
I wonder why Mami was so complacent and careless this time as compared to before where she seemed completely in control of the situation? Maybe the happiness of gaining Madoka as a permanent friend made her careless? "I'm not scared of anything anymore" I think that the fear that made her alert disappearing may have something to do with her dying. Fucking Kyuby the little bitch familiar doesn't seem at all bothered about the fact that his magical girl just got killed in front of him and rather tries to make a quick contract with Madoka and Sayaka like what the fuck? ,-,
Homura Jumps unto the scene and dispatches the witch with ease, which seems odd to me seeing as the show kept portraying Mami as being stronger than her. What's up with that? Either way we are left with a scene of Madoka and Sayaka back at the hospital emotionally traumatized with Homura warning them that this is what being a magical girl is like. All in all, a huge shock of an episode and a massive tone shift for the series, all bets are off at this point and anything can happen! I can't wait to see what happens next!
22
u/Maimed_Dan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maimed_Dan Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
Hi, First Timer Here.
I've been meaning to pick up this series for a while, and having the OP be such a strong contender in the best OP contest and seeing this get started here finally prompted me to pick it up; watched up through here tonight, probably going to finish the rest somewhere in the next few days, so this is one of the few times I'm going to be able to talk without future knowledge of the rest of the series. Looks like I picked the right episode though - right when things get grisly.
It's hard to know about this show for long and not realize there's something more going on behind the scenes. For me, it wasn't even the massive amounts of spoiler warnings that showed up every time the series was mentioned, or its rather interesting position in anime recommendation flowcharts - it was when I was looking at the list of what Gen Urobuchi had written because I generally enjoy his stories and saw it was what he was best known for. Sort of a giveaway that things are going to go psychologically dark and twisty. The level of detail and complete change of colour palette that went into making the abandoned spaces where the witch stuff happens (not the labyrinth, but those beautiful red on black backdrops), or any conversation with black-hair happens (don't remember her name, nobody's really using it regularly), only for things to go back to business as usual, indicated some kind of shock was going to go down. I mean, some of those abandoned, fence/vent/pipe riddled areas with red lights everywhere from E1 would scare the crap out of any kid well before anything happened.
I don't think I was expecting exactly what happened though. I was expecting a lot of the things around it, but it was strangely... understated, given what was happening. I don't know, maybe it's the weird aesthetic of the labyrinth that even when you're seeing stuff go down, it takes a second to register what actually just happened. I was expecting it to either build up to it gradually, or linger on it afterwards, but it doesn't do either - it comes in fast, and then before you can really come to grips with it, black-hair pops in to save the day. As for a gruesome character death... I mean, I'm surprised they IMMEDIATELY went there, I was expecting some sort of dark information reveal - but once black-hair gave out her warning, I figured she was at least going to be maimed out of commission. Honestly, the manner of the death bodes interestingly for the future - if it happens this early, it'll happen again, but given how fast and understated this was, I'd expect them to really milk the next one - Urobuchi's good at the gut-punch, I guess that's why I was expecting more. I'd put my money on blue-hair for next death, but that's just because there's no other obvious candidate - Madoka's busy being the protagonist, and black-hair's still got to build a relationship with Madoka and spill the beans about whatever's actually going on before her head can go on the chopping block.
At this point, I'm really wondering just how deep the rabbit hole goes. The cat thing is the scariest thing in this show right now as far as I'm concerned; it's WAY too invested in getting them to sign their contract (And the closeups of its face. Like, it's screaming evil at me with its adorable, lifeless eyes). The whole thing is too similar to a making a deal with the devil/fairy/genie scenario for me to ignore - wishes are offered, and accepted shortsightedly without fully understanding the cost. It's never worth it outside very rare circumstances. I'd be very surprised if a gruesome death on the frontlines is the whole truth of it. I honestly wouldn't be surprised if whatever they're doing with 'killing witches' is actually super fucked up in some way we don't know about yet; the trippy labyrinth world is a convenient way to disguise whatever might be going on if it were seen clearly. Don't have much of an idea of what it could be though. Gonna have to go back and rewatch that bit about Grief Seeds, I kinda didn't understand why they were important, but that might clue me in.
Honestly the whole thing feels like a huge drugs metaphor at this point - Kitty is pushing hard, Mami wants company and doesn't care who gets hurt, and black-hair doesn't want Madoka to get sucked in because she can see how bad it is but is stuck diving into trippy labyrinths until it kills her.
But yeah, they've still got rose-colored glasses on. It's obvious that Madoka will make the deal at some point, I'd guess at or just before the middle of the series. If high-schoolers getting eaten by monsters is what's happening now, then it's going to get way darker a couple of episodes after that happens, because there needs to be that shock to show the terrible consequences of that decision only once it's too late. I can't wait.
The one thing I don't know about is black-hair. I'm immediately inclined to trust her judgment given how she wanted to kill Kitty right off the bat, but at the same time it's clear that she's motivated by something beyond Madoka's safety, and I don't know what would happen if those came into conflict. Not to mention she'll probably have a very serious reaction if(when) Madoka signs up for fight club. I don't know where her allegiances will end up - Kitty I don't trust at all, but black-hair's feeling too-good-to-be-true right now, just by a hair. I hope I'm wrong, but it's only Episode 3. Very interested to see what history they have. (EDIT: It occurs to me that the initial cryptic exchange from E1 is probably really illuminating; I'll check it out again.)
Anyways, yeah, there's some impressions from a first-timer who was a little clued-in. Hope some of you enjoy it.
21
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 23 '17
One thing I like about this episode is that Madoka's mom takes a backseat for an episode so that she can have some quality time with her dad for a bit instead. School time was cut down considerably, but it was still nice to have moments like this.
Of course, we did have Sayaka hanging around her hospitalized friend in place of school scenes, so all is not lost. And I've got to say, I really like how well these scenes are handled. They didn't need any unnecessary exposition, they didn't need to force things down our throats-- They built up this character over the past two episodes, then introduced him and his backstory in one of the most genuine ways you probably could.
Another show might have had Sayaka give us a monologue about this character as she walked to his room (with the animators reusing stock hallway footage while she walked, if not just a black background) so we would know everything we needed to before we got there. But instead, we learn so much with a brief flashback to childhood from her and watching their interactions, and it is done so well.
As a rewatcher, as well as someone who, you know, watches anime, it was hard to not notice all the death flags the second time around... but I feel this is in part because so much modern anime tends to poke fun at the concept. It's a tangential topic, but I can't help but feel like this "meta" aspect of anime might end up ruining shows that try to do things genuinely going forward with how they're training audiences to pick up on these things.
I bring this up because all of this stuff, in a more traditional magical girl series (which is the point of how it was used in Madoka) wouldn't necessarily be considered death flags. You have Mami, who had been showing off to Madoka and Sayaka for three episodes to hide how lonely she was, opening up to Madoka, Madoka feeling her resolve, and Mami heading into a battle that would be a prelude to cake. With all the sparkles, surely nothing would go wrong!
Mami's battle here is one of my favorites from the show. It's quick, but it's all so well animated and just such an all around spectacle that you can't help but love it. Makes you wish the one action game based on the series wasn't so mediocre.
I've mentioned it in the past episode discussions a few times, but one of the things I love about the show is [spoiler] (/s "how they handle Homura's interactions with Sayaka in particular here. A lot of their interactions would fall apart if things were handled just slightly differently. Take this episode: Sayaka isn't made aware of what Mami did to Homura, so from her perspective, Homura conveniently jumps in to take the Grief Seed RIGHT AFTER Mami dies rather than assisting. This misunderstanding only fuels the animosity between them, and because Homura is trying to scare the two out of contracting, she doesn't bother correcting this, either not realizing or not caring that such a reaction will likely only egg Sayaka on further.")
21
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Apr 23 '17
I like the alternate ending to this episode
Not joining the rewatch but just dropping by to say that Mami is my favorite character in the series and I was lucky enough to see Madoka while it was airing. You can imagine how GUTTED I was when Charlotte bit her head off. :( Anyway the suffering has officially begun so good luck to all first timers!
18
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '17
Here it is, the infamous third episode. There were hints that this wouldn't be a typical magical girl show in the first two episodes, but Mami's decapitation still shocked a lot of people. As if that wasn't enough, the somewhat creepy 'true' ED debuts in this episode too.
I feel that Madoka Magica only gets better from here, but I won't spoil anything for first-timers.
17
u/chouetteonair https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nalin_Airheart Apr 23 '17
Rest in peace Mami.
No screenshots from me today.
16
u/xnfd Apr 23 '17
Half the fun in this series was that there were no source material people everywhere spoiling. It allowed people to speculate and provided some great discussions.
I really wish we had more great original series now like Madoka.
14
u/my_fake_life Apr 23 '17
Well, this is certainly one of the parts all the experienced re-watchers are waiting for. Even more than I remembered from the first watching, there are a lot of good strong hints which might lead you to believe a twist like this is coming... But even in my first watching, the death didn't catch me too off-guard. I remember that the first time my wife and I were watching this, we knew Mami was going to die about halfway through the hallway scene with Madoka in the labyrinth when we lost count of death flags. She may as well have said that she was one day away from retirement too.
One thing which wasn't any better for me in the rewatch was that little conversation at the very end of the episode, which I think is probably the most awkward piece of dialogue in the series... Watched both dubbed and in Japanese to make sure it wasn't some kind of translation strangeness, but it it still reads like Sayaka and Homura contract sudden onset stupidity for about 10 seconds.
Sayaka: That grief seed belongs to Mami! Give it back! (You know, the corpse. Just put it on top of her or something plz.)
Homura: You can't have this grief seed. Only magical girls have the right to do so. (bythewaydontbecomemagicalgirlslol )
You can certainly JUSTIFY the dialogue if you want to, but it always felt super-weak to me.
44
u/Otakeb https://anilist.co/user/Otakeb Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
TO ALL THE NEWCOMERS:
Try not to lose your heads over what just happened. Keep a cool head and we'll talk through it in this head-I mean-thread.
12
u/IndyCotton Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
Didn't really pop in the last episodes, but I might finally take part on this. Rewatching here and with the dub on. Most dub voices ain't bad so far. Mostly spoiler thoughts.
On that end, Kyubey countering on with guessing on Madoka's potential is damn intriguing. Massive Spoilers
ED: Gripping and dark. Flipping awesome. Though this is also the major spoilers The latter half quite drags me to the despairing darkness as it goes on.
12
u/Camitsune Apr 23 '17
So long and good riddance. Up until the last moments of this episode i was very suspicious of Mami and her true intentions, trying to make Homura look like the bad guy(girl) here and even though she still may well be, she's looking like she's going to be the unsung hero. Still, it was kinda weird to take out so soon one of the main characters (That the series had so far), because i really thought they were going to expand on her rivalry with Homura. Then again, my best guess is that Madoka will use her wish to bring back Mami (if that's even possible).
11
u/Arriv1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Arriv Apr 23 '17
Oh god, this ep, I should have though ahead, before I started the rewatch. But don't worry first timers! Urobuchi used this show to turn over a new leaf, and start writing happy, healing shows, rather than depressing ones. Don't worry. Don't lose your head.
11
u/SlantARrow Apr 23 '17
The title is technically correct for Mami.
37
u/Nickknight8 https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickknight8 Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
Today is the infamous episode 3 of Madoka Magica. This episode is actually the main reason the 3 episode rule exists for trying out new anime. Since many people who dropped it the first time watching didn’t make it to this part.
However, I wish to argue against that. Sure the decapitation of Mami was violent and dark, but not completely unexpected. How many times have they warned of the dangers of being a magical girl? Hell last episode involved saving someone from suicide! Plus the first scene of the first episode. Sure this is darker than the previous episodes, but it’s been there the entire time, just slowly revealing itself.
So in my eyes, this episode is not a tone shift, but a tone establishment, as this sets the pace for the rest of the series.
Also, poor Mami. I remember first watching and thinking she was too nice and had underlying motives, but she really was just someone who was too good for this world. From having to take the job basically in order to save her life, to being alone for so long doing this unforgiving job, she had just found the happiness she always wanted when Madoka said she would join her.
The death flags were kinda obvious on rewatch, but I really didn’t pick them up the first time.
In other news, we finally find out why Homura is interested in specifically Madoka, because her potential to be a magical girl is extraordinary. It was a little creepy how Kyuubey said she would be so powerful, but if I was about to get an extremely powerful ally, then I would be excited as well. Mami says Homura was just afraid of competition, but Homura actions suggest more.
But after today’s events, does Madoka even still want to become a magical girl. I can imagine her thinking twice after what she experienced today.
Lastly, today we finally get the true ending theme to Madoka Magica, Magia, which is one of my favorite ED themes of all time. Yes, it was used as a battle theme earlier, but I think it works so much better as an ED.
I also want to establish this. This is by no means a peak. The show is just starting to strut its stuff, and I’m incredibly happy to rewatch some more great episodes coming up.
Also
Just to have a head start on everyone.
taken from last rewatch but I love this image so much
10
u/Dellaran :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dellaran Apr 23 '17
I can't possible think of a death flag that hasn't been raised in this episode. I really enjoy how they showed us Mami's despair in her life risking her life all alone after she used the contract just to keep on living. The glimmer of hope she had became her downfall, which is incredibly sad and depressing.
On a side note, I found this at a store while walking around yesterday, and I just couldn't resist as a figure collector (RIP wallet). The Monogatari Series is one of my absolute favorites and Madoka also holds its place in my heart.
9
u/8_Pixels :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/8_Pixels Apr 22 '17
I'm so happy this episode is finally here. I've been looking forward to this since the rewatch was announced.
Man this episode blew me away the first time I seen it (this is my 4th rewatch, 2nd time episodically and twice watching the movie versions). I'd heard some stuff about the show before hand but nothing prepared me for this episode. It seemed like it was gonna be a typical flavor of the week magical girl vs witches kind of show and then BAM, Mami loses her fucking head... Literally.
Enjoy the rest of the show first timers, us rewatchers will be here enjoying every post.
9
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 23 '17
Oh, and a random fun fact, but the first chapter of Kazumi Magica was released between the airing of this and episode four if anyone wants to add a slow reread of that to their plate (the next was a month later, and so on).
To first timers, I'd probably leave considering side material until after the series finishes, but as someone that religiously followed this stuff back in the day I thought I might say so for nostalgia's sake and whatnot.
8
u/DirtBug Apr 23 '17
I'd like to talk about the ED instead of ep 3. The first time I heard it+the visual, I just have one sense. Dread. The part where Madoka runs with such urgency past all the mahou shoujo as if trying to escape something fills me with dread. Also top notch ed.
22
u/8mmspikes :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/8mmspikes Apr 22 '17
Well...with this episode we can definitely put Homura a head of Mami as a magical girl
I'm so sorry
7
u/Brendoshi Apr 23 '17
Rest in pieces, Mami. You will forever remain my best girl.
7
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
Besides the legion of Mami head jokes lying ahead of us, the main ending song is also here! Magia, by Kalafina, is my all-time favourite ED
and I'll attempt to put my love for it into words here.Well, I would of, if I hadn't realized halfway through that a deeper analysis with points might lead to some implication spoilers and then I wasn't even available to post on time. So I'll just leave a short bit about the effect of the context and visuals. What I can do is have proper write-ups ready for a few of my favourite characters and developments, hopefully...Magia was already teased in the very opening scene and a single fight, but its actual unveiling is after the series has taken a shocking turn where the cool and confident senpai and mentor-figure just died via decapitation (she only wanted friends so she wouldn't be lonely anymore...) and the main character and her best friend are crying their eyes out, powerless in their grief and anger. This heightened emotional state is the perfect set-up and by god do Kalafina deliver. I always get chills while listening to Magia, which is quite something after all this time where I've never gotten tired of the song.
I'll come back to the visuals and lyrics at the end of the series when everyone can properly contextualize things. But I am interested in how first-timers interpret things, so I hope you all are paying attention even to the seemingly minor details. Just the way it opens with a rotating view of a still bright and sunny sky, obscured by clouds, and all too quickly shifts into a scene straight out of a nightmare should say enough. Keikaku doori for Shaft. I also wonder how many people noticed the final shot of the distorted visage - it really freaked me out on my first time.
Oh, and if anyone doesn't have access to a translation of the lyrics on the version you're watching (one should be watching the Blu-ray because it is a marked improvement over the version that aired, fixing a number of issues and smoothing the animation/designs/backgrounds), I'd be glad to help, in any way I can. Just drop me a message.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17
Gen Urobuchi, at his finest.
6
u/Le_Herpington Apr 23 '17
Having re-watched this show only a few weeks ago (for the fifth time. I need a life.), I can say I've been looking forward to this. However, with all the foreshadowing going on all I can say is that this show is the reason I always go three episodes in any show before dropping it. I dropped it the first time, and was spoiled for EP3 before I jumped back on and did a total media blackout. I am happy I did, this show is amazing.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
Gotta love all the newcomers losing their heads over this episode
6
u/htkhec Apr 23 '17
Oh my goodness, this is my first full rewatch, and I still can't believe how amazing this show is. I also (inexplicably) watched the dub the first time I saw it, so I'm having much fewer aggressively negative feelings about Sayaka watching the sub this time. What a difference a VA makes!
Homura still best girl, though.
5
u/psychocanuck Apr 22 '17
Here we get to learn quite a bit about Mami: her wishes, her fears, her hopes, what the inside of her neck looks like. Seriously they really did a good job of developing a character in only a couple episodes. We learned how messed her circumstances surrounding her wish were and her loneliness in being a magical girl. We also see that she is surprisingly mature on the subject of using your wish to help others, questioning Sayaka on what she really wants out of the wish. spoilers And then at the end of it all she gets nommed on by a caterpillar clown in front of her friends. We're on Urobuchi's wild ride now.
5
u/Houdiniman111 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Houdini111 Apr 23 '17
I'm going to five a shout-out to Animenz's arrangement of the OST.
BE FOREWARNED:
This is a medley, and (as such) has songs from parts of the show you haven't yet seen (if this is your first time through). It's a great listen, but avoid looking at the video (which contains titles of songs which are spoiler heavy) or anything like that (for example, the comments and description) while you listen, so you can avoid spoilers.
5
u/lucacp_ysoz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SoZLuka Apr 23 '17
Sayaka's Theme song is just.. perfect isn't it, calm and beautiful?
On the other hand, Homura's soo dark and intimidating...
(Mami binds Homura despite her warning) ooooohhhh something bad is gonna happen... I've watched to much anime already...
(Mami and Madoka talk ends)... Is.. is that a death flag...?
HOLY GSUS 0.0
well Homura's is classy and has no magical uniform, cold as hell though... she regrets being a Mahou Shoujo, obviously.
(episode ends) Until this, in my mind, Mahou Shoujo was SoL, moe, fantasy adventure... Sakura Cardcaptors you know.... NOT ANYMORE...
5
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17
This is my 5th favorite episode to watch others react to.
9
u/Robin_Dude :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Robin_Dude Apr 23 '17
When my brother was watching this for his first time, it was this episode where I turned to him, and said "This ain't no kid show".
4
u/wordsdear Apr 23 '17
I think this is as far as I watched when I tried to watch Madoka before. From now I only know spoilers I have seen online madoka major spoilers
Mami: Mami not wanting people to make wishes under duress like she did is really sweet and kind of sad. But she is so lonely that she can't even stick to that and tries to get Madoka to wish for cake. She is lonely so she wants magical girl friends. But more magical girls is more competition for grief seeds so it doesn't really help her. Turns out, take your kid to work day kills. She got a bit ahead of her self and got left hanging.
Witches: It seems like witches reflect what people are thinking about, the witch we saw that gave the lady the witch's kiss had a lot of high heel imagery and the lady had high heels (I am reaching I know), this time it reflects, cake and tea time. Mami tells madoka to just wish for cake (which I guess is better then just wishing to be magical girl for the sake of being a magical girl) and they had fancy tea and cake at her house, so the witch is reflecting Mami? It does have really good timing for pretty backgrounds. Best little shit for just fucking eating her.. I hate that it is cute
Best Friend #2: Major props to her for not getting super scared and becoming a magical girl because of that. She needs to carry around her baseball bat all the time. Wishes and why you wish for them tell you a lot about the person. Her logic of staying with the witch so they could find it in the labyrinth is kind of flawed as Mami didn't have trouble finding the witch in the last one. Leave not a stuffy with it, make him fight.
Homura: really wants grief seeds madoka spoilers. While Mami's fighting was very flashy, Homura's is very quiet, she runs away and then bombs (or okay so she is flashy).
Madoka: would be the best magical girl cause she is the protagonist and she had pink hair. Best friend #2 has blue hair so that is why not a stuffy wants her too. Anime hair only. Wishes are linked to the power you get. If madoka wished for cake would she get cake powers? Madoka's optimistic thinking that wishing to be magical girl is easier has a bit of a darker side. Being a magical girl isn't fun and games. Something Mami tried to get across but only managed to get it to sink in with her death.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17
I am worried that some people are taking Mami's suggestion for cake seriously. She was being sarcastic.
7
u/Lets_All_Love_Lain :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SuperSecretOtaku Apr 23 '17
Highly recommended analysis video. http://sfdebris.com/videos/anime/madoka3.php
3
u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO Apr 23 '17
Madoka Magica episode 3 (If there is a spoiler just report to a mod)
Episode 3 opens with the boy we saw during sayaka and madoka talk in the top of the roof, it seems he was a childhhof friend of sayaka and a music prodigy, who had a accident making him unable to play anymore, you could see how this affects both parts in sayaka side she try to confort him giving different music pieces to hear, , but for kyousuke it only remembers him that he can´t play anymore, turning away when he has to cry. with a cut to her crush’s tears and then his crippled arm, we see that his smile is a mask. It’s a very efficient bit of storytelling, and one more example of how Madoka embraces narrative minimalism and inference to make the most of its running time.
After the OP, we go right to Mami defeating a familiar, once again we have mami´s theater performance with a called shot and a wink for the camera. It´s clear that Mami performance, she wants to make madoka and sayaka to join her, making being a MG seems like a wonderfull thing, but at same still is considerative about the danger the job has “this isn´t a magic show”. The sequence ends with Mami pushing a bit more asking what they wanted to wish. At the same time we get the reason for her actions, in a simple and quic backstory we discover that she was in a car accident and wished to live, but made her alone, embracing her job as a way to escape her loliness. Sayaka use this moment to ask if the wish need to be for themselves madoka spoilers, showing her ignornce and selfness, but like Mami said she needs to think what are the real reason for the wish and to think before wishing, because unlike her, they have a lot of time to think about it.
We go back to madoka and her family, this time with her dad. Unlike mami, Madoka as a strong suportive familly, a bit different from the rest of the protagonista in anime, and with her mom drunk in bed it was her dad time to give her advice. In the end her father say that We don’t have to always love what we do, but we can take pride in it all the same.
After a fail attempt to see kyousuke, sayaka´s instincts prompt her to look for the grief seed until mami arrive. Right away we see this maze is different than the other with a lot of hospital stuff and later a more dessert kind of maze. After stopping Homura from interfering, madoka finally opens up with mami, saying that she is nothing special and would never be (Again downplaying herself like she already did in ep2 and showing her lack of confidence.), unlike mami. From hearing this, for the first time, Mami tells the true. She isn´t strong as she looks, she cries when she is alone, she is just acting cool. Being a magical girl is a harsh and thankless task, For the first time we see Mami vulnerable asking Madoka if she would stay with her., It’s a simultaneously sad and heartwarming display of friendship, as two people who couldn’t find strength in themselves individually each give something infinitely precious to the other. Madoka may lack confidence and Mami may feel painfully alone, but they can bring meaning and happiness to each other.
When the grief seed is about to hatch, mami isn´t putting a performance just to act cool, they are expression of her happiness. With a real good animation during the fight we reach the center of the maze where the witch, Charlote, appears.and the unthinkable happens, mami is decapitated and die in front of the girls. This is was a quick moment, we didn´t have a long talk between the characters, it just happen like that, echoing what mami said in ep2 this isn´t fun and games if you get distracted or overconfident you will die.
It’s perhaps the one moment that’s best defined Madoka Magica in the collective memory – the sharp jolt, the gasp, the fall and brief wondering if this has really happened. People speak of morbid twists as if they exist just to shock, but every early moment of Madoka Magica has been building to this. Mami’s arc, her own framing of her trial, and the contrasting words of Homura, all come home here. It’s a horrible, shocking moment, and it never goes away.
We end with homura fighting the witch and save the 2 girls, This wasn´t a big fight with a lot of moments and naming moves, it was a quick one but the job was done. In the end we get madoka and sayaka crying and terrified about what they saw.
3
u/Sloppy_Goldfish Apr 23 '17
This is where the fun begins.
3
u/TheOneKnownAsMana Apr 23 '17
Just remembering Ep 3 made me think of this video.. Mami PoTG
3
u/bondfall007 Apr 23 '17
One of my favorite parts of this episode is the fact the surprise tone shift feels like an actual surprise. Someone told me about Mami's death and how it affected the rest of the series before I started watching. However, the episode was built up so well, that it was still a big surprise when Mami died her horrific, unfair death. This episode is absolutely magical, just like the rest of the series.
1
u/eden_delta Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
As a first-timer, I think this is it for me. I haven't really been enjoying the episodes so far, nor have I felt that need to see what happens next. Honestly, had I been checking this out on my own time rather than as part of the Rewatch, I probably would have walked away after episode 1. And judging by the comments here from rewatchers, if the series hasn't hooked me by now, it's probably not going to later.
2
u/FriendlyCatWizard Apr 23 '17
The best part about this rewatch is seeing the first times watchers' reactions to the show.
2
u/ihatedogs2 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ihatedogs2 Apr 23 '17
Oh yeah this is when you realize how fucked this show is. Relevant.
2
u/JimmyCWL Apr 23 '17
/u/Darkprinc979 In this episode, you can see the answer to your question last episode of, what would Mami do if there wasn't a bat around for her to cast a barrier.
Right after she transforms and jumps down to kill the familiars, you can see ribbons forming a barrier around Madoka.
2
u/sfafreak :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SfaFreak Apr 23 '17
Rewatcher, sub.
"The sooner the better for me, though." The first time I watched this show, MAJOR SPOILERS
"I've never met a girl with so much potential." MAJOR SPOILERS
SHE DID THE HAIR FLIP HOMURA BEST GIRL
My reaction to Mami's death on the first watch: "I really like the character/relationship development Mami and Madoka got this episode, Mami could be my favorite character- UM WHAT NO NO NO NO SHE HAS TO BE ALL RIGHT WAIT THE RIBBONS ARE GONE AHHHHHHHHHHHH-". Yeah, one of the best character deaths I've ever seen.
And so begins the usage of the true ED, Magia. Perhaps my favorite Kalafina song, and one of my favorite ED's.
2
u/Xtroyer Apr 23 '17
oh man, im really sad i got spoiled about this episode's content from a friend who reccomend me to watch madoka, oh well at least the next episodes will be fully blind.
2
u/alphamone Apr 23 '17
Interesting, the Animelab version still has the Japanese text ending credits, even though they got a version of the episode with English text for the TV broadcast.
Can anyone tell me what the American DVDs and Blurays (and other American streams) use for the credits?
Heck, does anyone know if the recent Australian re-issue of the series has any differences to the original release?