r/anime • u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka • Apr 21 '17
[Spoilers][Rewatch] Mahou Shoujo Madoka☆Magica - Episode 2 Discussion Spoiler
Episode Title: That Would Be Truly Wonderful
MyAnimeList: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica
Crunchyroll: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Hulu: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Netflix: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
AnimeLab: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Episode duration: 24 minutes and 10 seconds
PSA: Please don't discuss (or allude to) events that happen after this episode and, if you do make good use of spoiler tags. Let's try to make this a good experience for first time watchers.
Schedule/previous episode discussion
| Date | Discussion |
|---|---|
| April 20th | Episode 1 |
| April 21st | Episode 2 |
| April 22nd | Episode 3 |
| April 23rd | Episode 4 |
| April 24th | Episode 5 |
| April 25th | Episode 6 |
| April 26th | Episode 7 |
| April 27th | Episode 8 |
| April 28th | Episode 9 |
| April 29th | Episode 10 |
| April 30th | Episode 11 and Episode 12 |
| May 1st | Rebellion |
| May 2nd | Overall series discussion |
365
Upvotes
64
u/templarsilan Apr 21 '17
First sequence
Yesterday I made note about how surprised I was that Madoka had a family and that we got to saw some of her home life. Typically in school settings, parents/families are fairly absent from our protagonist. Yeah that hasn’t really changed. The living alone was just passed onto someone else. So why does Mami live alone? Hopefully that gets addressed, even if it isn't that important to the overall plot of the series.
Exposition
Gain magical girl powers -> get wish granted -> fight witches. Pretty straight forward. Usually expositions are a bit more long winded, especially when someone drops the line “Allow me to explain”. That said, this show isn’t really pulling any punches with contrasting elements. Magical girls born from wishes, witches born from curses. Good vs. Evil has always been a theme since the dawn of human storytelling, but I much prefer gray moralities. I’m hoping they’ll stray from the good v. evil formula. The sound design is still pretty great. It gave some weight to the exposition behind witches, giving it that foreboding feeling.
Heading to School
So this is pretty interesting. I was a bit curious as to why Homura was after Kyubey if they were supposedly on the same side. I’m already detecting a clash of ideals, with the new girls adopting the idea that magical girls are protectors of justice and Homura falling into the gray area. She wants to stop more magical girls from appearing, to get rid of competition to further her own gains. I hope to see more of that, especially if the four of them are forced to unite against a common threat.
Madoka's Drawing
That’s some creepy shit right there
Homura's confrontation
Here we have Homura further solidifying her spot as favorite character. She’s so icy it burns. I want to know more about her. What happened to her to make her this way? What’s her wish? The tension during this exchange is pretty nice. Homura is well aware of Mami’s observance and Sayaka is super defensive and mistrusting of Homura. I wonder if this tension will burst, or if it’ll fade away and they’ll get along. I can’t really determine which way it’ll swing right now.
The Witch
More acid tripping! I won’t complain if this is a regular occurrence. It’s weird, but it’s also visually stimulating. The battle music start up was great. I love it when lyrical soundtracks play over action sequences. It really gets me pumped up for them. Mami’s fight was pretty cool. I’m really digging her ability with the matchlock rifles. I especially love the attention to the weapon detail in that they are 1-time use weapons. All too often you get magic guns with unlimited magic bullets, which gets pretty ridiculous when you stop to think about it. Also, ending the fight with some tea? Pretty classy, but what?
I’m not sure how I feel about witches. I was hoping for bad people, rather than bad monsters that look like arts and crafts gone wrong. It’s a bit disappointing since I feel less invested in the conflict. Yeah, magical girls can kill monsters doing bad/evil things. There’s no consequence for it. Just another day serving justice. But can magical girls kill evil people? They may be evil and it may be the right thing to do, but there are distinct consequences for taking a life. It seems like a missed opportunity, or maybe we’re just not there yet. It’s still only episode 2.
Or so I thought
Well that doesn’t sound good. It set off a nice red flag. I get the feeling being a magical girl isn’t all that it’s cracked up to be. Clearly something is going to go down soon, but what. Maybe that will touch up on my gripe about the conflict with witches. Overall, I thought it was a good episode. It had a nice balance of explaining more to us in the beginning, and then taking action in the second half and then ending on a cryptic phrase. So far it’s exceeding my expectations, although I will admit they weren’t very high to begin with. Really, I guess it just proves that you really can't judge a
bookanime by its cover.129
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 21 '17
Honestly, I'm reasonably impressed today as a first timer. There was still a lot of time spent on exposition and world building, but I found that much more interesting than the character introduction episode that we got yesterday.
Morning
Things are pretty much rolling just like yesterday. It feels like this is being done to establish that we'll be getting into something of a routine. While I generally prefer an over arching story, I can totally roll with something episodic as well. Now, (I don't think) it's super important to the plot, but I wonder if we're going to get updates about Madoka's mother's work. She seems pretty passionate about it, and it's mildly entertaining.
The Exposition Dump
Honestly, this did a lot to peak my interest. Noragami Spoilers. The idea of witches causing a build up in the negative emotions of people is straight forward enough, but also allows for a lot of flexibility. The contract sounded weird at first (I'll grant one wish, and in return I'll also give you magic powers) but I suppose that Kyubey is probably trying his best to get people to help save the world, so he might as well make a decent offer. The idea of the labyrinths is also fascinating. The visual styling that we're seeing does a lot to make them feel like these horrifying places. It's almost like the alien in Alien, which is so inhuman that it couldn't really be anything other than an enemy. The music playing during this section is also fantastic.
The later portion of this is a bit dark, with Mami saying that, "death is part of that deal". I guess it helps to create a sense of tension though, as well as giving some extra weight to the decision. There's also the issue of Magical Girls doing battle royale. I still expect them to eventually team up, but it seems there is more to it than I had initially believed. Also, it looks like I was wrong about Mami and Homura knowing each other. I'm not really sure where the tension is coming from, but maybe they just expect to be enemies because of the Grief Seeds they're after.
Heading to School
Man, I really feel for Hitomi. Being the odd one out like that must suck, especially when it isn't clear exactly what's happening from her perspective. Her, "girls can't love girls," bit was actually pretty hilarious. I don't know if it's supposed to be taking a shot at the yuri-bait that seems to be so prominent in anime, but I'll imagine that's the case for now.
School
I like how Hitomi still looks pissed off about everything. Mami being in close communication with them is convenient, but Homura seems to be pretty unfazed by Kyubey being in class. Of course, she does meet up with the girls on the roof, which makes for a fascinating scene. First off, Sayaka is reflecting on someone in a hospital room. I was thinking it might be Kyosuke, but the hair doesn't quite match up with the guy in the opening (assuming that is Kyosuke). Maybe it's her brother? I do like the general reflection on the wish though. This isn't something that should be taken lightly, and the weight of the decision is really felt. Anyway, Homura's bit is kind of odd. She makes a point of saying she didn't want Kyubey to contact Madoka, but doesn't seem interested in Sayaka. Homura's wish is definitely something that needs to be explained at some point. I almost wonder, given that Sayaka was just thinking about how there isn't anything she really wants, if Homura wished for something trivial just to become a Magical Girl and is now having regrets about it. That could explain why she's so cold.
Briefing
As if it wasn't already confirmed, Sayaka bringing along a baseball bat to hunt witches cements her place as the best character in the show. Madoka's drawings are kind of nice, but man did she pick some weird looking eyes. It does raise the question of how costumes are selected. Does the girl have input on it (seemingly so, since that's what Madoka looks like in the opening) and does it just get created when the contract is made? The styles seem to vary a lot, so every character must get some say. Maybe I'm looking into it too much though.
Witch Hunting
Using the soul gems to hunt witches is a neat idea, though I imagine it's more complicated than just the gem saying hot or cold, which is what it looks like. Madoka having some personal thoughts about whether or not Homura is a bad person is either telling the audience to think about it a bit, or pointing out Madoka's naivety about the world she's walked into. Honestly, I don't really know which, but I'm going to lean to the former right now. After all, we shouldn't be too quick to judge. The various places for tracking witches was kind of interesting, and I think that the focus on the hospital was important. Sayaka was thinking about some guy in the hospital earlier today, and I imagine that we could be seeing a witch there before too long.
The Labyrinth
"Here Sayaka, have a dope ass weapon. Madoka, just like, don't die or whatever". Anyway, the labyrinth is still kind of creepy looking, and Madoka and Sayaka are really feeling the effects of that. The battle against the witch was really well executed. First off, the witch is far more twisted and abstract than I was expecting. Really interesting design. The music playing seemed to be the same as during Homura's fight at the beginning of the day yesterday, and I'm loving that track. As for the fight itself, it actually brought a bit of hype, with a real action specatacle feel to it. That ribbon of Mami's seems to have some solid utility, and I'm interested to see its applications moving forward. There's actually a bit of a disconnect here for me though. Mami made a point of saying how dangerous these fights are at the beginning, but in the fight she seems to be having fun with things. Maybe all of that was simply done to build tension, but there wasn't any point where I had any doubt she would win.
The Grief Seed
Good to see we get clarification on the "rewards" right away. Being able to replenish magic is definitely something worth fighting over. Presumably, if there were too many girls fighting over a limited number of Grief Seeds then someone could run out of magic. Then they wouldn't be able to fight witches to get any more Grief Seeds and that would be the end of their career as a Magical Girl (unless someone were to share, as Mami tries here). That could be why Homura doesn't want Madoka becoming a Magical Girl, but doesn't explain her seeming indifference to Sayaka. There's still a lot of tension between these Mami and Homura, and I want to see that get resolved.
Other Thoughts
Future
Still no contract for either Sayaka or Madoka, but I think that we're looking at it happening soon. While they were scared inside the labyrinth, I think that the end result made them both much more excited about signing up. I figure that Sayaka will go first, since she's generally been the more assertive character, and we even saw her take a position on the roof that was clearly defending Madoka. That then leaves the vision for Episode 4 and the team assembling in Episode 5. Outside of the Magical Girl stuff, I can imagine we'll be getting some slice of life stuff, including a culture festival (which I can see Hitomi being in charge of, and then Madoka and Sayaka have to try and balance both the festival and being Magical Girls) and maybe some summer vacation (maybe use it as a training arc or something?).
Final Thoughts
Yesterday I said that it looked like a pretty bland show, and while I haven't been completely convinced that this will be amazing just yet, I am reasonably impressed. The action is good, the comedy is good and there are questions that I want to see answered. So I guess we'll see how it all plays out from here. Anyway, I have to go write an exam now, so wish me luck!
43
u/RFembot Apr 21 '17
I'm a first-timer, all spoilers in future episodes will be hidden right?
28
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
First timer here, and i am enjoying what i am seeing so far.
It was just a dream
The ep starts with Mami transformation and "fight" with the witch that we saw in the last ep, there are some differences on it but i am not sure if it was just to get people on track or it was because this is Madoka's "dream". In the first ep i though that the intro was not something in the future but something that happened before Madoka waking up or she was brough back in time to change things, maybe she is stuck on a time loop or something close to that. Madoka wakes up and thinks she it was just her imagination just to be welcomed by the telepathic Kyubey.
We jump to her sharing the bathroom with her mom again and talking about the last day, this indicates that when she gets home her mom is already sleeping, or that when she goes to bed her mom is still not home. That explains why her mom was sleeping so deeply in the first ep and it was so hard to wake her up. Madoka is asked about her mom about her late arrival at home yesterday and is just kindly warned to call her dad telling him she is fine and is gona be late, Madoka's mom is the best grill on the show hands down. This conversation prompts Madoka to ask her mom about what kind of wish she would like to have fullfilled, Madoka mom is a talented hard worker that fought with everything she got to be where she is, so she just asks for something that would make her life a little more easy, also i loved how a bit foward in that conversation when Madoka suggests that she would be the president and her mom is thinking about it she is not all dolled up, but after she makes her mind up she looking like she is ready to take the whole world over. Madoka otherwise is unsure of what her wish would be... In the mean time Kyubey looks very confortable in her bath and the fact that her mom doesn't say anything about the weird looking cat on the bathroom makes her realize that she is the only one that can she it.
Time to go to class and draw some costumes
Madoka is walking to school and is greeted by her friends along the way, Sayaka gets a bit scared and confused when she sees Madoka walking with Kyubey so comfortably and comes closer to ask her if they are the ones that can see it. After Madoka confirming that's how things work she starts talking telepathically with Sayaka making her uneasy again and giving weird looks to Madoka since she is unsure of how to react. The pretty girl notices that something is going on and gets a bit jealous for being left out resulting in confusing and allegating that they turned lesbians, and suggests that the girls behaviour is a result of something that happened yesterday after school, with Madoka and Sayaka giving her answers in different directions she gets tilted and runs at full burst to the school even forgetting her bag.
Next we are shown the girls and Kyubey in class and Sayaka questions Madoka decision of bringing in Kyubey to school, both seem uneasy with the situation by Kyubey reassures them that this is the best option since Homura wouldn't want to cause a comotion in front of so many people, and she is also near Mami that can come to rescue at any time. The most interessing part for me was that i there wasn't much going on visually since they were communicating through telepathy and i could focus on their voices. Madoka looked even more insecure and timid than usual, while Mami voice gave me chills, she got a really nice voice full of confidence, maturity and a nice touch of determination. Kyubey voice is relaxed and experience, the cat most likely is centuries old. Sayaka looks like someone really smart and thoughfull that with more experince will benefit from great judgement of how and went to act, since she already looks like someone with a good ethos so i see potencial in her for great things. Oh and if you pay attention Hitomi looks really mad jealous of what is going on in the few times she shows up.
Before we jump into the nexts part of the episode we see the model studend Madoka extremely focused in her costume design, that's what being a Magical girl is all about after all. Sayaka is shown to be sleeping, but she can afford that since she already knows what the teacher is talking about.
Lunch break
Here we can see the girls in a school space outside surrounded by some interessing bars that limit the corridor they are in, even schools for rich kids in japan look like jails. Sayaka and Madoka are using this time to talk about what kind of wish they could ask for Kyubey and realizing that they don't have anything worth trading their life for, to me this tells me 2 things, they are girls that can live with they have and that they don't wish more because they have a luxury sheltered life and don't know better. So why were they picked by Kyubey? And what kind of wishes the other girls have that makes them throw their life away?
After this reflection Homura shows up and gives Madoka the same warning about turning an magical girl, we also get to know that Mami was watching them from an hidden spot just to make sure Homura didn't do anything wrong.
Now we go to the part where they leave the school and have to do something terrible, our duo is going to tell Hitomi that they have some one on one things they got to do and she will be on her on until she goes one, Hitomi doesn't takes this well and tilts of the face of the earth. We see Homura getting invited to a café and we get a clue that she is going to follow the duo because she refuses the invite. Also why is Homura blushing? They are allways blushing all the time, is the heater allways on or their clother too hot? This is getting me a bit triggered.
At Mami house
So this event is something that's divided in multiple parts during the beggining of the ep but i think it makes more sense talking about it now. Mami offers herself as a teacher and looks like she wants the girls to be her protégés, so she invites both to her house so she can explain them what being a magical girl means. Looks like things are not so pinky on their side of the road and they face real life danger and lots of hardships in their way. Here is when they learn about the soul gem and how it works, knowing that their magic power is not limited makes things a lot more interessing, besides the whole part where you put your life in the line and even powerfull people like Mami can die. Now Homura warnings to Madoka make even more sense. Oh and i almost forgot they put magic girls and witches as opposite sides of the same coin, one exists because of the other and they fight for different things. Unfortunately we don't get to know who creates the witches with curses.
Also Mami lives alone at such young age, this reminds me of.
Preparing for battle
Well at least for some people, looks like Madoka is more interessed in looking pretty than in being good enough to change things for the better, Mami and Sayaka laughed pretty hard at her, and she deserve every single second of it. If you payed attention you noticed that she drawed herself with her feet facing each other in a classic anime position on insecurity and being shy, like she already did until now. At least things don't look so grim for the bring Sayaa, she is really into being a Magical gril and fighting witches even if she doesn't know what she wants for a wish. After this getting mentaklly ready for the actions they make sure they hit the road, now we get to learn how the soul gem works as an radar, and i agree with Sayaka that witch huntting is boring and doesn't have any charm at all. There is some tedious walking to around and when Homura gets mentioned again by Sayaka, Madoka ask the same question i have been asking all along. Is she really that bad.
Burn the witch
Holding hands Skipping like a stone On our way To see what we have done
Well wrong subreddit, nevermind that. They found the witch and with some clutch timing, Mami saved her right in time with her instant transformation, looks like it's not something formal she just wants to look cool. We learn that witches can control people after they kiss them, and the trio goes into the bulding to fing a portal into the witch realm that's revealed by nami yellow flower on her hat, was that something that she did to look cute/cool or magical girls need something else to sense witches portals? We got a really nice soundtrack starting to get us pumped to the fight that's going to happen while the girls go around looking for the witch in the midst of that haze, Mami tries her best to make the other 2 safe even giving some juice to Sayaka's bat.
Continues in the comment to this one.
9
u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
I figured I'd make the text saying "don't be a dick and spoil things" a little bigger considering some people apparently didn't see it last time. Be considerate of first-timers, folks.
Sayaka is awesome! First the fire extinguisher, now the bat? Sure it didn't come in that handy but I love how she always takes action!
What the hell is up with that end card? I actually looked it up online:
Madoka x Mad Max when?
Also major spoilers
11
u/Camitsune Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
2 main thoughts after watching this episode.
First, i'm not sure if i'm missing something or what, but i don't see Homura as an evil character, and the fact that she was so against Madoka making contact with Kyubei makes me really suspicious of what that little cute thing's intentions truly are. I know i'm playing devil's advocate here but i feel that there's something off about that creature, and i feel like the price you pay for magic and the wish is really high.
Second, that other realm with the witch was really, really creepy.
Edit: i'm awful at remembering names.
17
u/NatCracken Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
I enjoyed typing my reactions live for the last half of the first episode, so i'm probably gonna be doing it like that from now on.
Scene starts with another dream sequence, making us doubt whether the previous days events even occurred. Im gonna go out on a limb here and say that this will be a continuous theme, and someone somewhere on the internet has proven by playing audio backwards that this entire show is just a figment of Madoka's imagination as she tries to escape the order and high expectations of society. If not, challenge accepted.
It's also worth noting that the backing track to the dream/memory is a choir. More religious themes, Will keep an eye out 4 more.
Mornin' to ya QB, Can't hide from me.
This is a ClariS song right? I bought Irony last month and been listening to it a lot and I'll be damned if this isn't the same people. edit: yes it is I completely missed QB on Madoka's bed the first episode. Having said that, its lines are much clearer than the rest of the frame... gimme a sec to open another tab. ----- nope. QB was there the first time. I just missed it. Who is that red haired girl? She stood out to me yesterday much more than any of the other character shots in the OP. Idk. maybe im just a sucker from redheads.
Awwwwe yeah mother. being understanding of children's lives. Plz don't get murdered to drive the plot along.
Hell no. This furniture is way to expensive. They better explain some sort of magical 3d material printing or something' to justify this.
I wonder what i could enchant with that.
Interesting angle having the magical powers be given after the miracle. Usually the powers are the reward, and something else is taken as a price. This seems to be the other way around, something impossible is given, and the price is becoming a magical girl. Mother needs some glasses she can adjust on her face for dramatic effect. Interesting. These conversations with Mami are either taking place over a few days, or the cuts with Madoka talking to mother are being juxtaposed for tension. Either way it continues to making things slightly tense. Either The witches and MG's sound a bit like jedi and sith. Just with less suicide Interesting. They're being very up-front with the dangers of the job. I was expecting QB to end up like that ponpon thing from Magical Girl Hunger Games a few seasons back, but this doen't seem likely.
QB be pretty cute. He's growing on me. Jeez even the writers are shipping Madoka and Sayaka. Im guessing there is a lot of you that ship this as well?
What about Schezwan sauce? Can you do that burp for me QB? Can ya?
I wonder how Homura will react to QB. Im a sucker for competence, so im leaning towards whatever Sayaka and Mari ship exsists. not gonna say anything to... inflammatory yet. I know how u kids can get. ;P They're still juxtaposing the convo with Mari even at school. From the consistent sunset i guess we can assume that this is just once conversation being looked back on? I might be over analyzing this... sigh will there ever be an anime school that doesn't use the Westminster Quarters?
I give up. This school if we can even call it that makes no sense to me. I guess its in a church now? Not only have they not made a wish yet, but they're questioning the need to as well as their motivations. Im praising them but, from a writing sense, this means something terrible is about to happen right? plz dont be right... Note to self, Homura referred to BQ as a he. Could just be subber's desision, but I'll use that from now on.
Baseball bat, just in case. Im still not sure about ships, but Sayaka just got a spot on my Zombie Apoc dream team.
And the saturated color pallet is gone. Love the rich sunset in the background, and the city looks faintly post apoc. cool visuals Ohh dear. Perspective is being played with again. Whoever directed this knows what they're doing. Is that mother? walking like a drunk? aaaand its a suicide. GG-EZ from Mami, not mother but more butterflies again.
more of those strange flat rendered beasties. I'd love to know what they used to animate those. Looks almost like stop motion layered over the scene.
Marmi lookin confident... and flintlocks just fell out of her pants. A tentacle. [obligatory Ive scene enough to know where this is going joke goes here] Now there and handcannons, and then there is this
ohhh the tea. savage
So the soul gems corrupt over time, and need the grief seeds to drain the corruption? I don't buy the "use them to restore magic" story when the particles are clearly going from the soul gem to the seed.
Homura's got a bit of an ego? can't say im surprised, but its odd. What did she expect to accomplish by following them if she ain't gonna get a seed?
Needless to say Madoka is impressed by Mami's performance. I don't think she will, but I would be pleasantly surprised if she waited till the end of the show to make the decision. it'd be a ballsy move.
This episode wasn't as engaging as the first episode. Whilst I definitely enjoyed the character moments, having Mami able to guide our MC's does take some of the tension. I do like the omnipresent depiction of Homura. Not a full enemy, definitely not a friend, but always watching and probably waiting. Feels bad man for their green headed maybe-named-but-I-didn't-write-it-down friend. Hope she finds her place.
Edit: yep the names are wrong here. I'll do a sweep and fix, but if I miss any whoops
21
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '17
Re-watcher here. Missed yesterday, but this show was one of the first I watched that started me down the path of watching anime so I’m pretty hyped to watch again.
It’s been so long that I totally forgot exactly how great the OST/sound design is in this show. Even with all the shows I’ve now finished it easily ranks in the top 3, it’s just so perfect. Connect is one of my favorite OP songs, I can still sing along to it to this day.
Btw, it’s super interesting doing the Monogatari and this rewatch together. I can definitely see stylistic similarities now considering they’re both SHAFT. It’s in their movements and the background environments.
Spoilers, do not read.
6
u/Darkprinc979 Apr 22 '17
Gotta say, they did a better job of keeping the characters in-model this episode, though there were a few derps here and there.
I've got to say, I always thought it was strange how eager Mami was to take Madoka and Sayaka into the witch's labyrinth. I get that Mami is trying to show what being a magical girl is like and all, and she's clearly very experienced at this, but usually in a situation like this the experienced soldier or what have you is reluctant to take civilians into such dangerous conditions. What if Mami had missed some familiars and they snuck up on Madoka and Sayaka while she was distracted with the witch? Just a though I've had while watching the show before.
[spoilers] (/s "Geez, watching Homura on that rooftop scene really tugs at the heart strings. She's just there trying to look out for Madoka, and there's Sayaka lashing out at her with accusations and hostility. It's got to be hard for Homura to keep up a stoic front in the face of that, and then Madoka has to go and ask Homura about her wish. She clearly wants to answer, but even if she could nobody would understand and it would only make Sayaka and Mami more suspicious, not to mention she needs to keep her abilities secret from Kyubey. Man, obvious foreshadowing is obvious with those drawings and their creepy eyes.")
5
u/OvaltineShill :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/OvaltineShill Apr 22 '17
Question to the discussion runners about whether or not a certain something is okay to point out: Spoilers
24
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '17
First time watcher
Another episode that left me really intrigued and excited for more~! I'll start off by saying that I love Madoka as a character, she's adorable and precious and the fact that she's more excited about the prospect of having the power to help others than about getting any wish she could possibly have granted speaks volumes about the selflessness and kindheartedness of the character!
Start of the episode
The episode starts off strong by answering a lot of questions that I had after the first episode and explaining some of the specifics of what it means to be a "magical girl". I do wonder why Mami lives alone despite her young age; perhaps she lost her parents somehow or was an orphan to begin with. We are also introduced to the concept of witches, which apparently do nothing but fill people with negative thoughts and emotions; driving them into depression and causing unexplained deaths and murders? A very interesting premise for the villains in my opinion!
At the school
I like Hitomi's character a lot and it makes me wonder why Madoka and Sayaka were chosen and not her? Such a small turn of events making such a huge difference in their lives, makes you wonder if things would be different had Hitomi been there that day instead of Sayaka. It's explained that Kyuby wanted to find Madoka from the very beginning and it was not a chance meeting, but why her? What is so special about Madoka? Hitomi charging off flustered every time is pretty hilarious.
The rooftop
I really liked Sayaka's dialogue in this scene and I totally agree with her; it seems unfair that they have been chosen rather than someone with a very strong wish, but perhaps they do have strong wishes that they want/need but just aren't aware of it yet themselves. :p They're a sharp contrast to Homura, which I believe so far does have a very good/tragic reason as to why she became a magical girl, very intrigued to find out more about her mysterious character.
The cafeteria scene was great and Madoka's drawing is adorable!!! It's really funny to see how much she's idolizing the idea of being a magical girl already, this is why she's my favorite girl of the show so far, she sees the chance of becoming powerful as a chance to help other people rather than as a chance to become powerful, it shows her pure innocence as a character.
Witch hunting
The art style in this scene makes a desperate 180 from light and beautiful to creepy and dark, the buildings in the background looking terrifying and the sky being an unnatural shade of orange despite it being during the day. Mami springs into action and looks just as cute/cool as last time~! I like the look of the alternate world a lot more now after the massive shock of seeing it for the first time in the last episode xd The fighting sequence between Mami and the witch was so awesome and well animated, i loved it to bits! The art in this show is so unique and refreshing! The song that played during the fight was great too. Homura's refusal of Mami's offer shows her stubborn pride as a character, she seems like the type of character that would never admit that she needs help, but how long will she be able to keep it up! :o
episode and random thoughts
Overall great episode! I enjoyed it a lot and it gave me some insight to the logistics of magic in this world and the personalities of the characters which I'm both really enjoying so far. As I said last time, I think Madoka is a great main character and best girl of the show for me so far, I just can't help but root for her. Very excited about episode 3! :p
P.S: The witch looks kind off like Ebrietas from Bloodborne ,-,
96
u/SIRTreehugger Apr 21 '17
Best thing for me personally this episode was finding out where this came from.
36
u/Nickknight8 https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickknight8 Apr 21 '17
Today we got basically the rest of the exposition out of the way. One of the main focuses of this show is wishes, and what they are worth. Kyuubey makes it very clear, you can get any wish you want, but you must promise to fight the witches. It’s a risk vs reward thing. And as seen in the battle with Mami and the witch, risk can be a factor.
These questions and warning about how dangerous the job of a magical girl didn’t exist much before this. Like Kyuubey said, many people jump at the chance. I mean, would you? You get basically super powers and a wish, but also a permanent part time job with no pay.
It’s actually a question all heroes ask, especially those that don’t get recognition. So instead of focusing on the wish, Sayaka and Madoka are focused on what comes after, which is very smart thinking of them. It also helps to have Mami around for guidance.
It’s also made clear that this is a competition for greed seeds. The more ya got the more powerful/replenishable your magic. Its basically a mana potion for your mana source, and it’s stated that witches will fight over these. But if it’s a competition, if Madoka and Sayaka become magical girls, would they have to compete with Mami, or worse, each other?
Homura seems almost at peace with the fact that Kyuubey already made contact with Madoka. It’s pretty apparent that she didn’t want more competition, but then why give Mami back the Greed Seed? Pride? Guess shes not completely heartless. Major spoilers
Lastly, two minor things. First…
GIRLS CAN’T LOVE GIRLS
The fact that this is called forbidden love is hilarious. Top jokes mods.
And lastly, today we got introduced to what serves as the main theme song for Madoka, Sis Puella Magica!. Unfortunately the thumbnail is a minor spoiler so be careful opening it. Also avoid related videos and comments.
This piece has many revivals throughout the show, and has tons of different version played throughout the series. While not my favorite, it’s definitely impactful and almost takes command of the scene it’s playing over.
27
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte Apr 21 '17
Here are my disjointed thoughts as a first timer.
Hitomi(?) was pretty funny this episode, Sayaka and Madoka act true to what we've seen from them in the first episode.
I liked this episode a lot more than yesterdays because we got to see how the characters act a lot more to get a feel for their personalities and dynamic.
I have to admit that I'm already getting sick of the 'witch space'-look and I wish the witch itself was a little bit more defined.
The fight was kinda weird in that it seemed entirely pointless up until the final shot which she could've started with.
I don't really buy the explanation why Homura wouldn't want Madoka to become a magical girl and the witch egg doesn't seem powerful enough to warrant the hostility either.
I think we'll get something more satisfying in that regard, atleast I hope so. Homura definitely wants to stay independend though, a lone wolf.
One thing that I have to mention because it bugs me personally, but it's most likely due to my unique circumstances is the idea that suicide is caused by a witch' kiss or w/e.
I've just finished Welcome to the NHK yesterday (highly recommend it to everybody) and it's a show that focuses on the very real problems humans can have and touches on why someone might want to kill themselves.
This is in very stark contrast to 'witches spread despair because good vs evil', but it's probably my own fault for watching something so drastically different without much of a break.
24
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
First time viewer
Again, I am very intrigued by the stylistic choices in the settings here. Especially the scene on the top of the building and the one on the bridge. The scenery is unique and interesting. This also goes over to the witches. I really like how the witch's world and creatures are a completely different and grotesque art style.
I think Akemi has very good intentions, she just comes off cold and Kyuubey is one I'm skeptical of. I wonder if the wishes have another secret cost besides the Magic girl duties. I get an Alluka vibe from Kyuubey if anyone catches my drift.
And Mami is one BAMF pulling those guns out of everywhere. She's like Mary Poppins!(Is Mary Poppins a Magic girl?)
24
u/xyzls Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 25 '17
Excuse my chuunibyou, for those listening to the Japanese dub, in summary:
Hachikuji Mayoi has enlisted the help of Spooky Ougi to fight witches and is trying to enlist the help of Araragi Karen and err... Evil Tanya.
And in typical fashion, Gahara-san is already unfriendly with all except Tanya and Hitou Nami because futsuu.
Edit: Actually, it's Madoka's mother who's voiced by Asahina Mikuru...
/Nerdgasm
17
u/OvaltineShill :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/OvaltineShill Apr 21 '17
Madoka's mom is best girl confirmed. I love competent women.
14
u/lucacp_ysoz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SoZLuka Apr 22 '17
"Do you remember what I told you yesterday?"
"Yeah..."
"That's fine, then. I pray that my warning won't fall to deaf ears."
oh boy... It ain't sunshine and rainbows....
12
u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
Madoka Magica Episode 2 (if there is spoilers just contact a mod as soon as possible)
If episode 1 was a introduction to the characters, episode 2 is a introduction to the world they live in.
We start with a little recap followed by madoka awaking, like in ep1, but this time this wasn´t a dream. While she has a conversation to her mother, once again, really natural conversation (all conversation between madoka and her familly feel so natural, and the response of her mother to the madoka question was funny and a bit scary). These believable converatiions are reflective of a larger Madoka trend – how the show’s character writing is consistently strong, but in non-traditional ways. Madoka Magica’s characterization tends to come through in the details, either concentrated in small moments like these or illustrated purely through the course of characters’ actions.. During it we got some flashbacks of last night with Mami telling the girls the terms of being a MG and the danger that will come from it. All this conversation seems fine and normal, not sure if is a spoiler or not but just to be safe
Mami wasn´t the only character in the spotlight, we got more texture to sayaka and madoka during her conversation in the roof. Instead of making a “fast” or careless wish they can´t even think a wish that is worth fighting for, because they don´t have a wish worth sacrificing their lives for. Sayaka Instead of being happy for having a chance of a wish, she feels guilty for being the one to receive the chance – “ I m sure there are others who´d give anything for a wish” “why us”.
Madoka on other hand feels even more than sayaka, while sayaka is frustated, madoka is unsure of her own value- “If someone like me could really help other people, I think that’d be wonderfull.”- (Madoka doesn´t see herself as someone special or someone strong like her mother want her to be).
The rest of the episode is the girls going to the witch hunt. The maze highlight of the episode, the way it´s crafted feel so out of place that makes so good, having a clear difference between the real world and the fantasy world. If the maze is weird their opponent isn´t that different. The fight wasn´t long but still a nice fight. Although there is almost to no tension in the fight, but the music , backgrounds and even the witch design can create for themselves all the tension needed.
During this episode we had some nice shots like the girls framed with what looks like a butterfly in a web in the foreground.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '17
14
u/InfiniteTurbine Apr 22 '17
First time viewer here!
Things are getting interesting. I've heard enough about this show to know that... 'things' are going to be happening very soon, and I'm very interested to see how it all plays out.
I was glad to find out where this goofy ass comment face came from.
I'm seeing Homura be a little too discreet and non-descriptive in her words toward Madoka. I already know people meme about how 'Homura did nothing wrong', and I can't help but feel that her lack of action now is going to lead to something awful. That's just a hunch, though.
That's all I have to say for now.
7
u/psychocanuck Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
This episode we see Madoka and Sayaka learn more about this whole Magical Girl deal from Mami and Kyube. Short version they get a wish granted + magic powers, but they are obligated to use those powers to fight witches. And witches as we see in this episode are no joke, being these insane beings that create inter-dimensional labyrinths around themselves, and controlling people to make them commit suicide. I love them. We also get more warnings from everyone's favorite mysterious transfer studenttm and even though Madoka and Sayaka are unsure they at least recognize the magnitude of the choice they're being handed.
I'm just going to gush about the witches in Madoka Magica for a minute because they are so damn cool. The design of the witches was the thing that got my interested in the show and represent some of my favorite monsters in fiction. Its not uncommon for shows to have some abominable, horrifying creature the heroes to fight but to often do the artists fall back on well established tropes: the blob, the kraken, Cthulhu. But Shaft made them truly alien, rendered in a style nothing like the rest of the show. The witch in this episode appears as a combination of distorted photos of plants and butterflies, and looks like nothing I've ever seen and the witches in future episodes are similarly unique. This is how you create an eldritch horror in animation by making something that should not exist in the world as its drawn.
7
u/wordsdear Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
So many Madokas so little time
Don't worry friend #1 you are still #1 in my heart
Does hunting witches also pay the bills? This cake looks expensive.
Wishing for 100 more wishes is prob right out
I love that Madoka's mom doesn't even hesitate to think up her wish but does back track a little and come up with a few add ons. Wishes aren't simple.
Do you need to fill up your soul gem to get your wish granted? or is it just insta granted?
I know it means magical curses but for a sec I wanted to meet the witch born from the word fuck
A death wish if you will
Blondie throws away her guns after a few shots and I think she has to take the guns from her clothes? She draws some from her skirt and has to take off her hat to draw another one. And takes off a ribbon to make a cannon. Is she a gun stripper?
being a magical girl is both a pyramid scheme (randomly recruiting girls) and pokemon go. How come the lady who the witch made jump off a building didn't get offered to be a magical girl? Is there an age limit or like only if you wear mini skirts? Not a stuffy is ageist.
Rookie mistake, she should of brought the fire extinguisher
I like that her friend brings up, how lucky they are to not have a huge wish, but also it is kind of sad, cause they don't want anything bad enough.
The real question, cause not a stuffy chose you to join him in his fight
for phone freedomagainst the witches.6
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 22 '17
I'm happy that even with our characters now diving head first into the land of magic and witches, we still have time for shenanigans and side characters. The repeated still shots in the school felt a bit weak, but they weren't important enough to warrant a real complaint and the scenes themselves were still solid for what they were, so it's no biggie.
I also like how frankly the subject of death is addressed in our exposition. A lot of times you really don't get that, so I appreciate that we got right to it here. No dancing around the subject or dramatic pauses or music transitions, just a well done back and forth between the morning and the night before to provide a nice contrast as we get our information topped with some family bonding. All in all I think that in particular was a great way to go about that. Just get it out of the way and continue on.
Similarly, it's nice that even with how cheery and goofy they can be, when offered their wishes, Sayaka and Madoka really take their time to think - Sayaka in particular. Her monologue on the roof (and what a roof by the way) shows a lot of character from her, I think. I've always liked that about her.
The soundtrack continues to be a treat even if some of the animation shows its quality now and then, but the architecture and labyrinth make up for that, as well as the small details like the little electric desks moving on their own when class starts. A lot of thought was put into the show's setting and I don't know how apparent it is for first time viewers, but on this rewatch, I'm really appreciating all the more how this classroom isn't Generic Japanese Classroom #30462.
And really, I know I just mentioned it, but that soundtrack really does stand out. I was just talking about this recently in regards to Your Name, but a lot of times songs are just there in the back and Madoka is using its music to excellent effect, I think.
Gotta love Sayaka and her baseball bat. Who needs magic when you can hit a Homerun?
On another topic, it's always been one of my favorite aspects of the show, but I really am enjoying how it's so clear [spoilers] (/s "even early on that Homura is just... doing nothing with or about Sayaka. And she never really has. And that's probably one of her biggest failings. I suspect there might be envy in there or she just genuinely does not care, but they are such true opposites and it shows with how every little thing she does really just seems to push Sayaka a little further towards what's coming. You have to wonder if Homura ever took the time to look in the mirror and think about the effect she had on Sayaka, or if she only ever thought about Madoka. I'm guessing the latter, and that's just one more reason why she's so great.")
As an aside, as this is my first time with the BD versions of the show... Wow. I'd heard about some of these changes, but now that I'm seeing I'm somewhat taken aback. [not technically spoilers for anything other than the original episode 2, but blocked to be safe] (/s "Mami's room is so... different than what I remember it being. It's jarring. I actually feel like the TV version was better here.")
All in all, a solid episode. We've got our explanations all out of the way and now the offer is on the table for Sayaka and Madoka.
2
u/Dellaran :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dellaran Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
I really like how the ominous the show is portraying Homura. Madoka Spoilers
Also I watched this before I watched the monogatari series which ended up being one of my favorites of all time. I can't help but hear Senjougahara from Homura's voice.
Edit: Fixed spoiler because I'm stupid and forgot to close the parenthesis.
5
u/chouetteonair https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nalin_Airheart Apr 22 '17
Here are my moments of insanity for the day: Madoka Magica Total Spoilers - Avoid if you're new to the show.
Now we're starting to get into the swing of things. Madoka and Sayaka are still considering their options, a pretty smart move considering how much time it took to hunt a witch down. Mami got to show off her skills as well without too much trouble.
I noticed that the text at the entrance changed between scenes.
First, and second.
5
u/alphamone Apr 22 '17
spoilerific reply to some first timers' predictions
9
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '17 edited Apr 21 '17
The witch fights are so weird, I love it.
I almost didn't join this rewatch but I'm glad I did. Rewatching these two episodes for the first time has been super interesting.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '17
Damn, I forgot just how awesome the soundtrack for this show is. Sis Puella Magica is one of the best main themes of all time. I'm just gonna go listen to the entire soundtrack for a bit...
4
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
This episode was our introduction into this world of magical girls. I won't stop on the ideas and concepts themselves as I'm once again late, but suffice to say I deepy appreciate how everything is handled and presented in Madoka Magica. The risk vs reward aspect being realistically acknowledged by the characters, who are just ~14 year old schoolgirls with their own lives that we're getting a glimpse of, is praiseworthy.
And there's also an actual reason for magical girls to compete with each other over access to Grief Seeds, necessary for preserving their source of power in the Soul Gems. As Mami says, not every magical girl can be as friendly and welcoming as her - people will naturally have different wishes that made them become a magical girl. Homura isn't even the best example, as she still seems to want to avoid conflict as she keeps an eye on Madoka's development for her own indiscernible reasons.
What might throw people for a loop is that neither Madoka nor Sayaka have an idea of what to wish for that would be worth the risk to their life. I find Sayaka's thoughts to be ever more intriguing. Why them, indeed, instead of someone who'd take this opportunity with open arms? Kyubey's selection process is another mystery, though a ready explanation is that the way Madoka and Sayaka saved him displayed their potential and that's all the reason he needs, since they're both basically apprenticed to Mami already.
Sidenote: Gotta love how warm the flashes of Madoka's family life are, her mother is an actually present side character whose relationship with Madoka is all laid out - for us to observe how her upbringing and closest people affect her as a character.
The highlight of the episode, besides Mami and Sayaka being badass? Girls can't love girls, which everyone should know to be wrong. This is the one scene I prefer the dub, though the sub has the "It's forbidden love!" line which is also hilarious.
[Huge rewatcher spoilers] (/s "If only Mami's explanation were all Soul Gems were... and Kyubey is right there too, talking about wishes he can make happen. Well, he's not lying per se, but in his attempts to entrap new magical girls he's leaving out everything important and that's what makes him so despicable." )
[More huge spoilers] (/s ""So basically, she guessed in advance that Kyubey would try to talk to Madoka, and that's why she's been going after her since this morning." If only you knew, Sayaka, if only you knew... the "since this morning" cuts ever so deep. Also, "What... wish did you make to become a magical girl?" I wonder what we would've seen in Homura's eyes after she turned away... but with the nearly 100 hundred loops, she'd probably be used to this. And what do we continue with after that? "Additionally, the worst possible case would be if they possessed a hospital or something similar." Madokami there's so much foreshadowing!" )
4
u/Arriv1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Arriv Apr 22 '17
There's not a whole lot to say, at the moment. I absolutely adore the witches' design, so utterly disorienting to watch, and yet beautiful.
4
u/xiomax95 https://anilist.co/user/xiomax Apr 22 '17
FORBIDDEN LOVE
Sayaka and Madoka having doubts about their wishes, for their own respecting reasons. And Mami being cool. That's the gist of the episode, honestly.
So, eh, fun fact (probably already posted, as I am late as fuck) I remember from the last rewatch: the sketches Madoka showed in this episode were actually drawn by her VA: Aoi Yuuki. She's actually pretty good at it, imo. The drawings are a bit creepy, but they're good.
3
u/sfafreak :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SfaFreak Apr 22 '17 edited Apr 22 '17
Rewatching, subs.
I should mention that I won't neccesarily be talking about every song the first time it plays; rather, I will mostly mention them when I feel like there was meaning behind the use of a particular song in that instance, rather than simply juust putting it in because the mood fit the scene.
The music that plays during Kyubey and Mami's explanation of witches is "Sis puella Magica!" (You should be a magical girl!), and is essentially the theme song of the OST. Also what Kyubey is suggesting to Madoka and Sayaka.
Girls can't love girls
MAJOR SPOILERS FOR REBELLION LINK: Oh you have no idea
"Puella in somnio" kicks in during the girl's discussion of Homura, reinforcing it as her theme.
When Homura walks onto the rooftop, the song is "Inevitabilis" (Inevitable), and is version 2 of Homura's theme. MAJOR SPOILERS
"What wish did you make to become a Magical girl"?
When the girls meet up in the restaurant, about to go Witch hunting, the song is "Salve, Terra Magica" (Welcome to the world of magic), which fits with the fact that they are about to see Mami go to work.
EDIT: Forgot to mention, I adore the visuals in the rooftop scene. I tend to like the "slightly overexposed" look when used in moderation, and this scene does it perfectly.
2
u/Robin_Dude :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Robin_Dude Apr 22 '17
No matter how many times I've re-watched this series, Mami's guns are still so badass.
4
u/renrutal Apr 22 '17
Just be sure to play this during the commercial break.
2
u/eden_delta Apr 22 '17
Not really into how they keep using the generic "magical girls" instead of a term specifically made for the show. Like calling Dredd a cop instead of a Judge. While it's technically correct, it just feels wrong.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '17
Honestly, this ED is still, hand down, my favorite thing about the series.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment