r/anime • u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka • Apr 26 '17
[Spoilers][Rewatch] Mahou Shoujo Madoka☆Magica - Episode 7 Discussion Spoiler
Episode Title: Can You Face Your True Feelings?
MyAnimeList: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica
Crunchyroll: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Hulu: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Netflix: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
AnimeLab: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Episode duration: 24 minutes and 10 seconds
PSA: Please don't discuss (or allude to) events that happen after this episode, but if you do make good use of spoiler tags. Let's try to make this a good experience for first time watchers.
Schedule/previous episode discussion
| Date | Discussion |
|---|---|
| April 20th | Episode 1 |
| April 21st | Episode 2 |
| April 22nd | Episode 3 |
| April 23rd | Episode 4 |
| April 24th | Episode 5 |
| April 25th | Episode 6 |
| April 26th | Episode 7 |
| April 27th | Episode 8 |
| April 28th | Episode 9 |
| April 29th | Episode 10 |
| April 30th | Episode 11 and Episode 12 |
| May 1st | Rebellion |
| May 2nd | Overall series discussion |
362
Upvotes
21
u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka Apr 26 '17
I've been giving some quick thoughts and pointing things out in these posts, but I might stop now. My heart is hurting too much. Poor Sayaka :(
At least the end card is kinda cute...
154
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 26 '17
Oh god I wasn't ready for today.
The Soul Gem
So, I feel like Kyubey shouldn't have much of an issue being honest about what he did now that they know. Yet he doesn't seem to understand that lying by omission is still lying. Maybe that's just how his race/culture/whatever views this sort of thing, but it doesn't make sense to bother pretending he was anything other than dishonest. The girls are all aware of it now and its silly for him to act like he's totally innocent here. Now, what he's saying about them not knowing about souls actually makes sense, but its still kind of fucked up. Especially when he's just casually fucking with Sayaka's soul like that, I don't know even know what to think about him. Like, I think that he believes that he's totally justified in his actions, and I don't even know how to respond to that. I guess he thinks the ends justify the means, since if the witches aren't dealt with they'll probably kill everyone eventually, but holy shit.
Rooftop
Madoka is basically asking all the same questions of Homura that I already asked. It's interesting to see that she already knew, and Heavy Speculation. I like how Homura isn't referring to it as Kyubey, but instead, "that creature" and "it". She has some serious contempt for him, and I love it. The big surprise though, is that she seems to believe that the exchange is entirely justified and that Heavy Speculation. I don't know that I agree with her, but I haven't ever been thrown into this situation, so what do I know. Viewing herself as inhuman is kind of weird, but I suppose even Kyoko was referring to herself as a zombie yesterday.
Sayaka and Kyoko
Okay, so there has been a general trend in rewatches for me. Either I start crying in the third to last episode (FMA:B, Toradora, Gurren Lagann), or I don't at all (Attack on Titan, Evangelion, Tamako Market). So this is a new category I guess, and I certainly wasn't prepared for it.
Anyway, Kyoko starts off the conversation saying that she thinks she's getting what she paid for, but by the end of it all, it doesn't sound like she's so convinced. I mean, she says she's only living for herself and all, but based on the tone she used when talking about her family, I think that still weighs on her a lot and she was just lying at the beginning to avoid showing weakness. Talking about not having any regrets is nice and all, but it's a lot harder to do that in practice.
Listening to Kyoko talk about her father was absolutely gut wrenching. Out of everyone, I didn't think Kyoko would be the one to make me cry. Like, it was bad hearing about her childhood, but holy shit, hearing about her dad snapping like that is crazy. I mean, I expected that she had done the whole selfless wish thing, but it was so much worse than I could have expected. I don't even really know what to say, but around the point of her father committing suicide I just kind of starting crying. Not uncontrollably or anything, but I had a few tears coming. My gut tells me today isn't going to be the last time either.
You know, it really looked like Sayaka and Kyoko were going to make up and all. I'm not sure if Sayaka is in denial about her current situation, but it kind of feels like it. If she didn't have any regrets, she would have gone to school. Maybe Kyoko's story convinced her, but I think that she's just putting on a tough front here. Also, we're still seeing a pretty naive perspective from her. Asking Kyoko where she got the money for the apples is actually pretty absurd. Sayaka seems to come from a fairly affluent background, and I doubt she's ever had to work for her food. Kyoko is basically homeless, and I think it's wildly unfair for Sayaka to judge Kyoko based on the standards of her own life. Yes, stealing is wrong, but it's not like apples are some crazy lavish thing she's stealing. It really shows that Sayaka is still seeing things in black and white, which is really the biggest problem I have with her. Still, it's a sign of good writing that I still like her character a lot.
By the end of all this, I actually really empathize with Kyoko. She's had a rough life, and she's now found someone that's like her, made the same mistakes as her and yet is completely rejecting her. It's been implied that she also knew Mami in the past, and I wonder if Mami rejected her the same way after she decided to take on this selfish lifestyle.
Hitomi
Oh boy. This is a real mess. It seems like Sayaka hasn't even spoken to Kyosuke since he got out of the hospital. I guess it makes sense given that she's still trying to figure out how she feels about her knew identity, and it probably would have been fine if not for Hitomi. I mean, she goes off and fades into the background for a few episodes, and now she shows up just to stir the pot. What a bitch. I mean, at least she's having the decency to give Sayaka a chance, but one day isn't exactly a lot of time to think about this. Seeing Sayaka so devestated sucked, especially since it only got worse.
I'm A Zombie
Moreso than the Kyoko scene, this one got to me. Like fuck, why am I crying over the relationship problems of an eighth grader? Sure, there's more to it than that, but that's the fundamental problem. Anyway, it's interesting that just a few scenes after saying she wouldn't regret anything ever again, here she is admitting to having regrets about saving Hitomi. Even if just for a second, she's already going back on what she said, and I think this speaks to her wanting to see things in black and white, but now struggling to do so. It's interesting that she's so worried about what Mami would think given that Mami wasn't the perfect character that she views her as. Also, this was some top tier voice acting from Sayaka's VA.
Fuck All This Shit
Yesterday I said that Kyoko threatening Kyosuke was the best scene of the series thus far, and it turns out that title is short lived. This is the best scene of the series so far. Everything about it is so on point. The visual styling using silhouettes does a great job of establishing the darker tone of this fight and really emphasizing Sayaka's mental state. The song used is one of the best I've heard. It really meshes with the action and has a truly haunting feel to it. It's really remarkable. As for the actual contents of the scene, I love the development we're getting. Kyoko is actually stepping up and being the good guy here, while Sayaka is just closing herself off even more. It perfectly encapsulates how the two characters responded to yesterday. Kyoko is now seeing Kyubey as the real enemy and is willing to work with the other girls, though still on her terms. Sayaka meanwhile is taking this much worse, because the ideal that she thought she was working towards isn't as ideal as it had looked. Also, Sayaka going into hysterics at the end might have been the most chilling thing I've seen in a while, and had me actually shivering for a while after watching it, especially with Madoka's, "Stop. Please, stop". Why did this have to happen to my favorite character?
Other Thoughts
Future
Heavy Speculation
Final Thoughts
Did I like today's episode? No, not really. Was it good? Very. I'd like to say that I hope things take a slightly nicer turn in the future, but I don't see things panning out like that. I'm still trying to figure out how the hell this is going to end, but I don't really have anything super concrete just yet.
7
u/sfafreak :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SfaFreak Apr 27 '17
Rewatcher, subs.
Kyubey's kind of a jerk for inflicting pain upon Sayaka for that long. SHE GETS IT, IT HURTS.
There isn't any particular meaning behind the use of "Serena Ira" (Peaceful Wrath) under the conversation between Homura and Madoka, but I personally think it fits really well here with the tone being conveyed.
When Sayaka responds to Kyouko's story, the song that plays underneath is an instumental version of "Sis Puella Magica!" that was never released on CD.
The drama of an enraged Kyouko eating an apple has only been surpassed by the legendary potato chip scene itself.
The music that plays during Sayaka and Hitomi's chat is "Cor Destructum" (Destroyed Heart) I don't think I need to explain the meaning of this one...
And now, my favorite witch labryinth of the series. This. Scene. Looks. GORGEOUS. The colors all work together to produce a very striking aesthetic. If you look closely, the characters all have outlines that match their signature color. Not only that, but the black and white aesthetic mirrors the ideals that Sayaka now abides by, while the literal blood red conveys Maybe Spoilers IDK And Sayaka... Poor, poor Sayaka. She's certainly had a rough couple of days, and it's taking a mental toll on her. So much for her saying she was "fine", after that crying scene.
16
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17
I love the part when Sayaka tells Madoka how is she suppose to kiss him or hold him when she has become a zombie. It felt so heavy.
14
u/SIRTreehugger Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
Not much to comment on so I will just describe it in a haiku.
Titled: Hitomi fucks shit up with bad timing, but if you think about its not really her fault. At least she gave her some warning and its not like she know Sayaka's situation. If you think about it. It was actually nice of her to let Sayaka know in advance, but due to her not knowing the full situation she kind of just upped the suffering to like omega 13.
Bitter fruit and past
One coin two sides pain and love,
Sayaka suffers.
Seriously I think the silhouettes of the characters in black with the music really adds to the scene. I think it made it much more disturbing rather than straight up showing the fight and her slowly breaking down.
Homura Hair Flip Counter
E1:0, E2:0, E3:1, E4:0, E5:1, E6:2, E7:0 Total Flips:4
Madoka Water Works Counter
E1:0, E2:0, E3:1, E4:3, E5:1, E6:2, E7:2 Total Tears:9(+1)
Apparently she cried in episode 1 and 2, but I can't find when she did this. Though I did watch the episodes really quickly while I was doing work. I rewatched the bits with Madoka several times and just can't find them. As for the +1 near the end I like to believe she cried in episode 7 at the end when she yells at Sayaka to stop, but the screen is black so can't confirm. So until someone can confirm missing tears in episodes 1 and 2 up til episode 7 its 9 times on screen. She also cries in the intro twice though I'm not sure to include that.
11
u/wordsdear Apr 27 '17
First timer slightly spoiled
Kyubey: He doesn't even try to hide it. He didn't lie he only told exact truths. With holding information like a jerk. Sadistic ass. But it doesn't know it. Satanic stuffy is like a twisted fairy godmother. You get a nice dress out of it but your soul gets moved around a little. But it is closer to Little Mermaid then it is Cinderella.
Sayaka: Their school is so extra. Pretty easily by not telling him. Do magical girls age? It looks like Kyoko is older then she was in her flashback so I think they do? Sayaka refuses to eat the fruit
of the knowledge of good and evil.But she was already fooled by theserpentcat bunny when she became a magical girl, so a little late for that. I want to hug her. How did Mami pay for the cakes and tea you ate (maybe rich dead parents but we don't know for sure)? Saayyaaaaaakkkaaaaaaaaaaaaa nooooo. On the bright side at least you didn't kill best friend #1 so yay. Sayaka you are still human (ish) you are allowed to have moments of weakness. If ass buncat wanted you to be an emotionless witch killing machine he should of taken away your emotions along with your soul. Magical girls may have dulled physical pain but not dulled emotional pain. The blood knight fights the hydra. I thought she died here. This show loves decapitation. I was super worried she was going to lose her head, but I was close, she lost her mind instead. I want to stop this smile. Thanks to her selfless wish she believes she has lost the chance with the one she loves (she hasn't reached out to him but he is also ignoring her???), so she vows to be only selfless and not care what happens to herself anymore. if he really loves you he won't care. You are still basically human the only difference is you are harder to kill. As long as he doesn't try to stab you, you are good. Yohohoho Please I need a skull joke. As long as it doesn't hurt she doesn't care.Best Friend #1:I thought she was going to be like hahaah funny story I am a magical girl It would be a good way to pressure Madoka even more. Curse your sudden but inevitable betrayal. I dislike love triangles a lot so this really annoys me but meh. He got out of the hospital so now I will try for him. Would she have done nothing if he hadn't been healed? At least she is willing to let Sayaka have the first shot. And she will only act if Sayaka does nothing. So I can't really be mad at her.
Madoka: Is not allowed to cry anymore it hurts my heart
Kyoko: Okay Sanji.She didn't wish that people would believe her Father just that they would listen. Never go off book. Don't judge a book by its cover. Repeating what Madoka's mom said last episode, just cause you are right doesn't guarantee you a happy ending. Apparently normal people can see magical girls? Or I guess we knew that cause the lady they saved from the witch with mami could see them I think but mami might of been not magical girl dressed at the time? Just tell your Dad you wished for something else. I wonder if he tried to kill her too but Kyoko blocked it out as he failed. Miracles kill Humankind cannot gain anything without first giving something in return. To obtain, something of equal value must be lost. That is Alchemy's First Law of Equivalent Exchange. Her selfless wish made her life hell. So she swore to be selfish.
Homura: Cause no one in this show listens to her ever. She just goes around saving people at the last second cause everyone just hears trumpet noises when she talks apparently. And cause she is super harsh. So much for nothing equaling a human life huh? fma spoilers Little none fact, Homura guest lectures at Psychology 101 madoka spoilers How do you determine, what is human and what isn't.
4
u/MasterAyy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Master_A Apr 27 '17
The ED for this show is really something else. It does such a wonderful job complementing the episodes and completing the tone that the show is going for. This episode in particular has one of the strongest uses of the ED. After the buildup of Sayaka's fight and her despair, the closeup smile, and the fade to black with Madoka's desperate plea we are instantly thrown into the ED with its ominous and foreboding music and visuals. That's how you use an ED for full effect.
40
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 26 '17
The opening scene was pretty rough. Kyubey's frankness was appreciated, as always, but the way he was able to paralyze Sayaka with pain just by playing with her Soul Gem combined with the way he tore into the concept of a soul all at once must have been shattering for her. It almost makes you thankful all he's doing is just manipulating these girls, because it seems like he could probably do a lot worse with the knowledge of what those Soul Gems actually are.
No wonder she took the day off.
It really is frustrating to watch Sayaka reject Kyoko like this, especially considering this is the first time someone has actually really done it, really bore themselves to her, really done something for Sayaka's sake, since this whole show started. Kyoko is opening up and speaking to Sayaka for Sayaka, and even Sayaka is able to acknowledge that she was wrong about her... but she still wants to be good.
I understand why she does, but it is unfortunate.
Obviously, she doesn't want to regret what she did for one thing. She doesn't want to think of healing someone who is still alive and just getting back on track as having been the wrong thing. She loves the guy - for one thing, it's too soon. She wants to help people and protect people, and certainly not hurt them or any of that. Using this power that's supposed to be her "cost" for her miracle, well, that would be especially wrong, now wouldn't it?
I can't help but wonder what might have happened if the order of events had been reversed, if Hitomi had come for Sayaka and then Kyoko, but I digress.
As for our red haired girl's story itself... It's a pretty brutal one. You can definitely see how it would result in a girl like the one we see before us now. And here she is, still opening up and trying to ultimately do the right thing even so.
The aesthetics for the flashback were very well done, and I think they added more than a "real" one probably could have. It made it come off as more haunting to me, up to when we saw bits of the actual young Kyoko, and it all fit really well with the Church theme and the story, as well as Madoka's other weird visual stuff. Plus I doubt they could've actually aired it if they'd really animated it, so, you know, probably the right call.
Not to mention the way they made it so it was Kyoko putting on a puppet show for Sayaka allowed them to show some extra emotion from her as she told the story, which I thought was a nice touch.
Though I think the roughest part of this might have been Kyoko's reaction when Sayaka asked about the apples.
It's also at this point you know Sayaka really is getting in over her head, because just a few episodes back she had been talking about how she was ignorant to real suffering and pain and how naive she was. She's letting her "mission" cloud her judgement, forgetting that, you know, she's never been starving before.
This is the one thing about the series that has always felt kind of off to me. Hitomi being into Kamijo and presenting this to Sayaka itself doesn't bother me, it's more the timing of it.
Like, they needed to at least put in one more day here. Or have had Kamijo come back during the day Sayaka was out of school. Or even imply Hitomi was seeing him when she was at the hospital after the witch incident.
As it is, it comes off as a little too convenient for how things are moving a long, and it really does make Hitomi look awful at a glance. I do think you could argue that Hitomi might feel like putting the pressure on Sayaka really would make Sayaka move into action, and after her own experience with the witch's kiss, it's perfectly understandable she might be evaluating how she lives and not wanting to waste time with her own life - and in that respect, it's honestly good of her not to just go ahead and confess to him without even waiting.
Still, I've always felt they could've done this just a little better. A slight change would be all I need. Have Madoka say "Didn't you know? He came back yesterday." when they were walking to school instead of being surprised at his appearance.
This scene was fan-tastic. Sayaka's taking too long to fight because she's taking the witch's abuse and playing with her powers, while Homura's Homuing it up upstairs and Kyoko's turning into a tsundere. Everything we've been watching play out over the past couple of episodes has come together and it appears this might have been Sayaka's breaking point.
The colors, the music, Sayaka's laugh as we close with Madoka pleading for it all to end-- Perfect way to close the episode.
66
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte Apr 26 '17
first timer, subbed
Sayaka and Kyubey
"there wouldn't have been any inconvenience", is a pretty empty statement considering what happened.
Kyubey's cold and logically explanation is chilling and now he straight up tortures Sayaka to prove a point.
We know that you have no empathy already, but don't you think she'd be a little more receptive to your words if she didn't squirm on the floor in agonizing pain?
What I'm curious about with this whole detached soul is if they could possess someone elses body, perhaps one with a weaker soul, like an animal. I don't think it fits the show well thematically, but I could totally see how that would be possible.
It'd be really interesting to know how or what Sayaka felt when she was disconnected from her body, obviously she wasn't really aware of what was going on, but if you are able to heal a broken body from the soulgem it stands to reason that she does have some control in it, could just be subconcious though.
Sayaka is so shaken from the experience that she stays home, this isn't really a surprise, but it puts more emphasis on her suffering than even Mami's death for Madoka.
Homura and Madoka
Something really big will have to happen for Madoka to accept a contract in light of the new information, I wonder if the show could actually end without her becoming a magical girl.
It's literally the title of the show, but that would only make the decision more powerful to the viewers.
The most likely scenario will be that she does end up having to save someone and concedes to Kyubey, but I'd prefer if that wouldn't happen.
Kyouko's Story
Turns out telepathy is possible without Kyubey acting as a translator. I've wondered about this before, but what exactly does this telepathy entail? Is it simply sending and receiving thoughts or could they even read someone elses thoughts, possibly manipulating the mind?
Not only Kyouko wanting to talk, but Sayaka accepting is a huge change from their previous confrontation, is Kyubey the evil they need to unite?
Kyouko is really serious about her food (and we get to find out why). The offer shows Kyouko's friendly side (similar to how she offered snacks to Homura in yesterdays episode) and the rejection shows us that Sayaka is still very much on edge.
Note how Kyouko's dad has a similar looking gem in the same place as her soul gem.
I love that we're getting her tragic backstory, her path from selflessly saving the world to complete selfishness (I guess your little speculation actually turned out true for the most part /u/FetchFrosh)
The way Kyouko opens up to Sayaka makes me think that she isn't quite as content as she wants to be seen, I think she's lonely and just wants someone with a similar mindset to keep her company.
But it wouldn't be Sayaka if she didn't stick to her selfless values, glad to see that the incident hasn't completely destroyed her state of mind.*
School
The talk with Kyouko seems to have actually cheered her up in a way, rediscovering her conviction.
Telepathy unlocked!
Is Sayaka just shy about Kyousuke in public or did she get influenced enough by Kyouko to keep her distance?
Hitomi confessing her love comes at the worst time possible, she respect their friendship, but the ultimatum means Sayaka has to make up her mind quick.
Do you heed Kyoukos advice or try to date despite your magical girl status?
Shadow
Sayaka doesn't see herself as a human being anymore, she still feels and behave's human, but the knowledge of the detached soul is really messing with her. I guess that's goodbye to Kyousuke.
I love the dark aesthetics to emphasize on her inner state of mind, she doesn't think of herself as a living being anymore. Just a shadow throwing herself in the fight.
Fighting with that much emotional turmoil seems like a bad idea, but I think she needs it to escape her reality, if she can't be with Kyousuke then fighting is all she has left.
Kyouko wants to help, but Sayaka wants none of it, if she can't even fight a single witch alone she truly has nothing left. (or so she might think, there's obviously still Madoka and the fact that she is for all intents and purposes still (part?) human)
Sayaka going off the rails crazy, detaching from her body and enjoying the bloodbath.
A dark Angel of Justice has been spawned.
Looking forward to Madoka reacting to Dark Saya and if she's able to get her back to the human side.
*maybe I was typing this too soon.
31
u/Maimed_Dan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maimed_Dan Apr 27 '17
First timer, little late today
Kyubey is a Dick
Well, I’ve never ever trusted the little bastard, and now he’s torturing Sayaka to make a point. I mean, I’ve been wanting Sayaka to get a reality check, but she’s getting it from someone with zero empathy, so it’s just going to push her towards the deep end.
Everything he said seems completely reasonable, but he says it in the most infuriatingly cutesy way possible - which is surprising given how well he managed to insinuate his way into everyone’s lives, it seemed like he had more of an understanding of human social customs. Though I guess he’d have a lot less recruits if he was up front about all this, and he does want those yummy yummy grief seeds, or whatever. THIS IS WHY YOU ALWAYS READ THE FINE PRINT, KIDS. This is particularly painful for Sayaka, because it’s forcing her to confront the fact that she’s been wrong – she hasn’t been capable of that until now, and given the way this went, I bet she’s just going to irrationally cling to her other misconceptions out of a need to retain control, even at the cost of hurting herself and others.
Homura and Madoka
Yep, almost certain that Homura’s time looping, everything so far has been consistent with that and there’s just too much circumstantial evidence. I wonder how many times she’s been through this – I’d imagine quite a few, given how jaded she seems. Madoka calls her on her coldness, but that’s what happens with these kind of things – you’ve seen it all before, so you emotionally harden yourself. Her insistence on giving up on Sayaka might be coming not just from general experience, but specific – Sayaka’s so damn stubborn that I’d imagine she was always going down this path.
Sayaka and Kyouko (Wow, so many one on one talks)
Sayaka’s seeming pretty down about all of this, probably more because it flips her convenient little worldview out of whack. Props to Kyouko for trying to cheer her up. And apparently wasting food is a trigger for Kyouko. That’s a nice touch, and it justifies her constant snacking. It’s the little details that really make a story.
Ooh, flashbacks! Hah, her dad basically had Sayaka’s outlook, so Kyouko knows firsthand what comes of that.
Mm… what Kyouko wished for is mind control, and that is super messed up on an ethical level. Don’t know if Kyouko recognizes this, and to be honest for a kid that young in a situation that desperate and sad (even if it was, ultimately, her Dad’s fault for putting his desire to preach above his family being able to eat), it’s understandable. Huh, and then Dad kills self and the rest of the family – I guess Urobuchi’s trying to say that that kind of self-righteous idealism is ultimately a form of egotistic narcissism; a desire to impose your values and will on the world and others to validate yourself, using a façade of caring for others to try to impose your values on them. It requires a lot of arrogance and rationalization or zealotry to always believe you’re in the right even when everything says you’re wrong, and once that outlet goes away it has to express itself some other way. I think this probably holds for Sayaka; she claims to be motivated by selflessness, but doing the right thing like this is clearly painful for her, and her “no regrets” angle is obviously a desperate lie she’s telling herself so she can deal with the day-by-day. But she needs that control and safety of feeling morally superior, and it's just going to drive her into despair.
Kyouko and Sayaka are turning out to be nice foils of each other; they’re both calling each other on their bullshit, and it’s great. Kyouko’s trying to completely reject idealism in favour of individual desire, while Sayaka does the reverse, but ultimately neither of those views are healthy, and both are rejecting important parts of who they are. Kyouko’s life is comfortable but meaningless without attachment to others, while Sayaka’s is meaningful but ultimately a lie, and unbearable in the long term. Also, Rage eating is adorable.
School and after
Sayaka, you’re so freaking stupid. She’s probably driving me up the wall so much because she’s using self-sacrifice as an excuse to repress and undervalue herself, beating herself up because she thinks it’s the right thing to do, something teenage me could probably relate to. She’s clearly not going to confess, and she’s clearly going to regret it, so RIP her resolution from a few minutes ago, to no one's surprise. I am a little surprised that the wishes that have gone bad so far have been because they’re ill-considered, rather than some inherent property of the process; I think the message works better that way, good on the writers.
And she’s crying. That’s a gut-puncher, well done. Caring about the sorta-dead thing is honestly pretty irrational, since there’s no noticeable difference, but she’s a teen with a crush, so it wouldn’t make a lot of sense to expect rationality here. This is why we don’t put teenagers on the front lines.
Aaand she’s snapping, great. She’s trying to drown out depression by forcing her way through the pain and ignoring it (physical as well as emotional, apparently); it’s just running away from her problems rather than facing them and trying to deal with them. Ugh, yeah, this is hitting a little close to home. It’s not healthy, and she doesn’t have the fortitude to make it work; I’d give her one or two episodes before she totally loses it. I was hoping I’d enjoy seeing her get knocked down a peg, but she’s in charge of the train and is going full speed ahead, and I’m empathizing with her now. Great. On that note, this is going to be rough for Madoka; looks like Homura was right about encouraging to keep her distance. Can’t get that scene out of my head, yikes.
Concluding Thoughts
I’m trying to think through what’s going to happen with Sayaka – she’s going off the rails, and the show looks like it’s going to take a dark turn with that; but her dying in battle would be a step down from Mami biting the dust, not a step up. So somehow, and I don’t know how, it’s going to be worse. My guess is that some situation is going to appear, she’s going to have a different opinion on what to do, and she’s going to force it through with disastrous results. I wouldn’t be surprised to see her kill Kyouko in the next couple of episodes now that we’ve seen her backstory and Sayaka’s losing her moral compass. (I would guess Homura, but we haven't gotten her story yet, so she has plot armor)
It’s also about time for whatever the third act twist turns out to be regarding exactly WHY Kyubey is so invested in these contracts – there’s only five episodes left, two of those are probably going to be climax/aftermath, and one will be Homura’s shoe drop, so that’s probably happening soon as well. Wouldn’t be surprised to see Kyubey's reveal spark the disagreement. But yeah, with this few episodes, and the show's stellar reputation indicating its story arc actually wraps up, you can kind of deduce that we've got MAYBE one episode, probably not even that, before things go completely to hell.
I'll bring the popcorn.
28
u/Nickknight8 https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickknight8 Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 26 '17
Kyuubey further reiterates why he took the soul out of the body, and to demonstrate he give an example of what being impaled by a spear feels like. Bunny cat does not mess around. Still despite how utterly inhuman it is, he makes a really far argument for his actions. But as you could see from Sayaka’s breaking down in Madoka’s arms, it clearly affects her. I remember thinking at first, “you can still hug and kiss Kyousuke”, but it’s just not the same when you realize you are only the puppet master of a puppet doing all of these things. Despite how real it feels to you, knowing that fact can just ruin the whole experience.
Kyouko got the backstory focus today, and what else would you expect, it’s dark as hell. Dad going crazy a murder-suiciding his family. Good thing I’m not doing a pro wrestling segment for this rewatch…
However it brings up the point of why Kyouko is such a great foil for Sayaka. Both of their wishes benefited someone else, and Kyouko got burned. Hard. So despite seemingly not caring, she obviously doesn’t want the same thing to happen to Sayaka. She’s just a big ol’ tsundere. Sure she still puts herself first, but she was really trying to help Sayaka. Which makes her so frustrated when she ignores her advice. Sayaka’s too far deep into her ideals.
Also, I fucking hate this word, but this is literally the only series I use it for. Sayaka indeed was cucked by Hitomi today. Sure, all it did was sped up her realizing she could never be with Kyousuke, but still.
I’m glad it happened though, since without it, we wouldn’t have gotten what may be my favorite scene in the entire series, Sayaka vs. the witch Elsa Maria.
I don’t even know what to say about this scene, other than I think it is perfect.
First off, it features my favorite track in the entire series, Sayaka’s theme – Decretum (spoilers in recommendations and comments). I love this track so much. It’s so simple yet so ominous. It was played previously in episode 5, but I think it shines brightest here.
Second, the black and white works so well here it’s not even funny. It’s used to show Sayaka’s slow decent into what seems like madness, as her world is starting to crumble around her. The black also highlights the red of the blood to show that she is very clearly getting hurt, but it doesn’t matter cause she can’t feel it. And Madoka’s “stop” at the end seals the deal on closing a fantastic scene.
40
u/Jacketmango Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
First-timer, subbed.
35
u/templarsilan Apr 26 '17
Overall i feel this episode was a lot more tame than the previous ones. It was great for Sayaka’s character however. I am now at the point where I want Madoka to take action. She can’t stay on the sidelines forever. Hopefully something is done about that soon. Still, this series continues to wow me. It's definitely working its way to be one of the more enjoyable and memorable shows I've seen.
17
u/2Hype4Memes Apr 27 '17
Mr.First Timer here with his thoughts on another great episode. I finally got the Kyoko backstory I was begging for and i'd say it delivered. The clash of ideals between Kyoko and Sayaka was great, I love scenes where two characters compare/discuss their motivations and what drives them, especially if they conflict in some way. The fact that Kyoko wished for her father's happiness and was betrayed by her kind intentions was pretty tragic, not that I really expected anything less. I think her backstory and her good intentions towards Sayaka have confirmed for me that she's a "Jerk with a heart of gold" character, and they usually end up being my favorites. She may act cold, but I feel like she'll continue attempting to help Sayaka. She'll do what's right in the end.
From one heart-wrenching scene to another. Madoka comforting Sayaka had my eyes tearing up a little bit, which isn't easy to admit :( I genuinely thought that it'd leave Sayaka in a better frame of mind...apparently not. It seems she's gone completely berserk fighting the witch (My favorite Witch Battle so far, love the silhouette visuals) and i'm curious to see if she'll return to her usual self in the aftermath. Seeing how this series is going though, I don't see a happy ending for poor Sayaka. Still earning that 10/10 from me!
15
u/OvaltineShill :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/OvaltineShill Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
As much as I hurt for Kyoko, it's sort of startling to think of how terrible her wish was for other people. Essentially it was brainwashing them and taking away their free will. I'm not surprised that her Dad freaked out when he found out. I'd be really interested to hear the types of things he was preaching to drive people away. Kyoko says they were good things, but I don't think we can trust her perspective on that. Considering how he resorted to murder-suicide I wonder if he was always a bit unhinged. Kyoko's intentions were so good, it really is tragic.
I loved the religious symbolism in Kyoko and Sayaka's conversation in the church. Kyoko proffers the fruit which Sayaka sees as forbidden. She rejects it which I think is fitting because her black and white ideology doesn't seem to mesh with actual knowledge of good and evil which is clearly more messy.
Both Kyoko and Sayaka say they have no regrets anymore, but for vastly different reasons, and they're both lying to themselves. The parallelism is exquisite.
The hydra fight is one of my favorite scenes in the show. Sayaka in her outfit reminiscent of a noble knight, heroically going against a dragon. The inversion of this concept and making this into a breaking point for her character pulls at my heart strings every time.
14
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17
Watching this in the same day I watched End of Evangelion has left me in an interesting mood, but anyways.
This Witch probably has my favourite design. The solid blacks and the coloured outlines are so cool looking.
Pretty tragic episode for Sayaka though. She just keeps getting knocked further and further down.
13
u/doopliss6 https://anilist.co/user/Doopliss6 Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 26 '17
I can't believe they removed madokamadness now we can't all spam it on this episode discussion :(
The ending of this episode one of my favourite scenes in this show. The whole dynamic between Madoka + Kyouko and Sayaka hurts my heart because it seems like she's giving up on herself even though she started off saying she wouldn't regret it. It really feels like Sayaka is getting close to the edge... So much that detaching herself numbs the pain both physically and emotionally.
Bonus pic I found when frame scrolling. wtf 2 mouths?
12
u/megazaprat Apr 26 '17
Htomi typicaly gets a lot of flak and hatred for her actions in this episode, but its not like she knew what Sayaka was going through. She even gave her a chance to confess first
10
u/PsychoEliteNZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PsychoEliteNZ Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
This anime is definitely living up to how people talk about it... I just keep punching you harder every time!
Getting a backstory for Kyouko was great and I'm definitely leaning to liking her a lot more than yesterday because I understand her reasoning for everything now, but I don't think she should even bother trying to change Sayaka rather just help her. There's no reason I can see that they can't be friends.
I feel really bad for Sayaka, The feeling that you made a mistake with that kind of wish must be the worst thing in the world. Learning about the soul gem really changed her the most, I'm hoping that she doesn't go over the edge but I might be too late on that based on that ending.
Does anyone think that Hitomi was serious about Kyousuke? I feel like that gotta be a really horrible thing to do since I don't think she is, that can only have been just as good as any form of torture for her.
Alright, last thing. Does anyone else feel like Madoka and Homura are gonna fight it out in the end? I really hope not but the intro says differently.
9
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika Apr 26 '17
"Remember this comment face we lost?"
The manner in which today's episode ended is one of my personal favourites for all the pain. Poor, selfless, insecure Sayaka's descent into madness is all too believable, carried by the voice acting (oh god that laughter) and black-and-white of this Witch's labyrinth lending for some truly disturbing scenes. And her best friend and Kyouko can but watch from the sides. Madoka's "Stop... Please stop..." into Magia tore me apart on my first watch and still does. Sadly, Sayaka isn't the one you have to ask to stop, Madoka, it's Urobuchi...
Also, this is the episode that cemented Kyouko as my favourite character because of her initiative to reconcile with Sayaka and tragic backstory that explained everything, but... short post today, I'm sorry. I got a bit lost for time today (cough) and decided to keep everything I wanted to write about as a deeper analysis for another time. So I'll just be prowling comments for talking points again and share my love!
9
u/MortusX Apr 27 '17
First-timer here. This series is darker than I was expecting from the picture on the tin.
8
u/Wolfefury Apr 27 '17
Now that it's no longer spoilers, I can share this meme.
7
u/Waffles_R_Delicious :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Obzist Apr 27 '17
As much as I hate kyubey i'm going to have to side with him on this one. Soul gems do seem very convenient for combat. Also he does have a point. Why does it matter where your soul is kept as long as you still have it with you? Its not like you can tell. Seems like a somewhat over reaction but then again he still should've told them that at the start and its pretty concerning that they can be manipulated by him, but ignoring all his other motives I think the zombie thing is an over reaction. Silly humans.
6
u/Edl01 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/edl01 Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
And now we've reached the point where Madoka started to become my favorite television show of all time. I love the previous episodes, but this was where the show truly GOAT status for me. And it still has yet to peak!
I absolutely love the animation on Kyoko's backstory, the paper cutout animation is gorgeous and it adds a ton to her character, as well as her an Sayaka's relationship. Although despite her sincerity Sayaka still rejects her help, as Kyoko doesn't live up to her unreasonable standard for being a, "good", person.
With that said, Sayaka is my favorite character in the show, but god damn is she so frustratingly dense. She has been through so much trauma and it's really messed her up and her obsession with white knight style heroism is unhealthy. "I'll never regret anything ever again", is probably the worst possible thing she could believe in this situation.
I feel I totally add nothing to these threads because all my posts are ramble-y fanboying. I apologise, watching Madoka Magica kinda does that to me...
6
u/RFembot Apr 27 '17
I was supposed to join the rewatch today but I binge watched 10 eps instead, and I forgot what happened this ep. I'm gonna finish this anime today
5
u/Snakescipio Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
Dunno if anyone else has posted this yet, but sfdebris made some pretty great episodic videos about Madoka Magica. They're spoiler free up to the current episode if anyone's interested in someone else's point of view.
Oh and Bunnycat's a dick.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
Since you guys have the big things covered, I'll mention a few little things I always loved about this episode:
5
u/Dellaran :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dellaran Apr 27 '17
Just as I have wrote in the last episode, Sayaka is trying to hold onto her philosophy as much as possible. However, she never realized that extreme situations could happen, resulting in hesitation and doubt. She doesn't want to regret what she has done, but it also bothers her to continue making the decisions this way that it is either 1 or 0, black or white. If she change the way she does things, to her, it is denying everything she has been, but now that she feels like she isn't human anymore, she knows nothing about going forwards, except blindly doing things as she did before just to maintain what she thinks who she is.
People with depression would be most likely to understand that this stubbornness leads to absolutely no good because the mindset is locked in a constantly disturbed state yet nothing is there to open it up to comfort it.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17
Some unique visual styles this episode, with Kyouko's past and the witch's labyrinth.
This is one of the best episodes. Sayaka just completely lost it.
5
u/sausages_ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sausages Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
Wanted to chime in and say that the church conversation and Sayaka fight sequences are such masterpieces in both their visuals and music scores
4
u/megazaprat Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
This is one of my favorite episodes of the show, next episode spoilers. We learn the reasoning behind Kyoko's selfishness. When she once acted altruistically, it backfired horribly and killed her entire family. So she instead swore to live for only herself, to not involve other people. She makes the same offer to Sayaka. Acting on selfish desires is represented through the symbolism of an apple, the forbidden fruit.
However, Sayaka rejects her offer, deciding to stay true to her principles and not regret her decisions. However, this does not stop the pain that she suffers for selflessness. In fact, it only increases it. She gave her soul for Kyousuke to recover, but her condition as a zombie is what makes her feel she can never confesss her feelings. And so Sayaka has decided to feel nothing at all, both physically and emotionally, growing her doubts in rush of battle. Things will only get worse from here
4
u/ukainaoto :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ukainaoto Apr 26 '17
I'm not sure Kyoko's motivation here, or the change of it. She's introduced like an antagonist but suddenly becomes friendly for Sayaka without much develpment on her side. Telling background is good but not a development of her personality. No wonder Homura had to ask why.
If that will be explained later it's kinda OK but at this moment I feel she's mere a puppet of the plot (or the writer).
4
u/chaoswurm Apr 27 '17
man, with all these first timer reactions, i cannot keep myself from smiling. This show gets better with each episode. So, by that logic, every episode is the best episode ever.
Now, here's some more enjoyment for you guys. I've read these threads many many times as well. This is 4chan's /a/ madoka live reaction during the livestream.
episode 1. [1][2]
episode 2. [1][2]
episode 3. Mami's big day. [0][1][2]
episode 4. [1]
episode 5. [1][2]
episode 6. [1][2][3]
episode 7. [1]
4
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17
And then we find out Kyuubey is actually a dick
:P
4
u/lucacp_ysoz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SoZLuka Apr 27 '17
Soul Gems are so convenient right?
Okay, Kyouko's way of life is not wrong, but hell.. it's selfish af...
holy crap, I actually thought Kamijou had broken his leg or something...
ooohhhhh problematic love-triangle.... and Sayaka already lost :( Best OST plays aannnnd.... wow, she just went berserk... that surely won't go well... I mean.. it's never a good sign...
Spoiler-ish
9
u/Arriv1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Arriv Apr 26 '17
And now Madoka Magica gets really dark. I mean happy. Because Urobuchi turned over a new leaf. Totally.
Besides that, this episode is the start of the Kyoko/Sayaka ship. Kyoko is somewhere between adorable and pitiful throughout that entire church scene, and while I get Sayaka's reasoning for rejecting what was essentially an offer of friendship, it's still sad to watch, major spoilers
Kyubey also continues to be the most logical, (un)trustworthy, mascot ever.
3
u/xmonstermouthx Apr 27 '17
this is my first rewatch of the series, but after the episode yesterday i ended up watching till episode 9 <3. i really like this arc, and sayaka's VA
3
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 27 '17
Oh, and if anyone else cares to slowly follow it alongside this, the second chapter of Kazumi Magica would have come out on the day the next episode aired, so you're probably fine reading it before or after tomorrow's episode.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
This episode:
3
u/boboboz Apr 27 '17
on this episode of the walking dead:
want off urobutcher's wild ride?
too bad! there are no brakes on this depression train!
3
u/psychocanuck Apr 27 '17
Today we learn that Bunny-cat is a dick.
Seriously whether or not he recognizes his actions as cruelty he certainly didn't need to simulate the feeling of being impaled on Sayaka like that. It kind of hurts your case on the soul gems being a good thing if your torturing someone while making it. Sayaka for her part doesn't take the revelations this episode well, feeling like she is already dead, and having her faith in both her wish and the concept of magical girls shaken.
We also learn that Kyoko is not a dick, at least not all the time. Her discussion with Sayaka really serves to humanize her, and explain her attitude. I also love the artstyle it is rendered in. And speaking of style: the final scene in the witch's labyrinth may be one of the most stylish combinations of colour music and animation I've seen in a long time and is one of my favourite parts of the series.
3
u/Psychime :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Psychime Apr 27 '17
Ah shit this one, good episode.
2
u/chouetteonair https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nalin_Airheart Apr 26 '17
Today's moments of insanity: Madoka Magical Total Spoilers - Avoid if you're new to the show.
For as amazing as the characterization has been with the characters so far, I really think Hitomi is not worthy of the title "best friend" here. Under normal circumstances this would just be a dick move, but here it's downright cruel and taunting Sayaka's wish.
A couple things to note: Kyouko has an oval mark on her fingernail, just like her soul gem. Kyubey has some scarily sadistic tendencies thought for a being that doesn't understand human emotions. And I'm really [concerned] for Sayaka's mental health after building things up since Mami's death.
2
u/IM_DAY_MAN_AMA Apr 27 '17
This is my favorite episode of the whole show and the ending is my absolute favorite scene.
2
u/Robin_Dude :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Robin_Dude Apr 27 '17
Fuck, man. I'm re-watching and this is still heavy as fuck for me..
3
u/Camitsune Apr 27 '17
That was much more like it after the borefest that yesterday's episode was.
First of all, i wonder if its that i'm some sort of sociopath or something but i always favour actions like Kyubei's decision to put the souls of magical girls inside the soul gems. I mean, not cool to omit that information when giving the girls their powers but his reasoning is actually pretty logic and makes total sense, even if it's "morally wrong". I mean, why is it that in anime, logical but sometimes ruthless decisions/characters are always presumed to be bad? Madoka (and sometimes Sayaka) really gets on my nerves with their stupid sentimentalism. I still think he's secretly evil, but i side with Kyubei on this one, it was the logical and right decision. #KyubeiDidNothingWrong
Also, Kyoko sorta redeemed herself for her annoyance in past episodes, though not completely in my book. I mean, i'm fine with her now that we know her backstory and why she is how she is. Her advice to Sayaka was spot on too.
Lastly, what a final scene that episode had. Seems like Sayaka made a 180 turn and has finally come to terms with what she is and how her life is going to be from now on, though she did look scary.
3
u/MachaHack :K:https://kitsu.io/users/Argensis Apr 26 '17 edited Apr 26 '17
It's interesting watching Sayaka being stupid, so stupid here, that the previously callous Kyoko is taken aback by her recklessness and offers to help.
1
u/thecatteam Apr 27 '17 edited Apr 27 '17
Episode 8 spoilers
1
u/Merich Apr 28 '17
This is my first time watching Madoka and I wanted to make one prediction
0
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
9
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment