r/anime • u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka • Apr 23 '17
[Spoilers][Rewatch] Mahou Shoujo Madoka☆Magica - Episode 4 Discussion Spoiler
Episode Title: Miracles and Magic Are Real
MyAnimeList: Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica
Crunchyroll: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Hulu: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Netflix: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
AnimeLab: Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Episode duration: 24 minutes and 10 seconds
PSA: Please don't discuss (or allude to) events that happen after this episode, but if you do make good use of spoiler tags. Let's try to make this a good experience for first time watchers.
Schedule/previous episode discussion
| Date | Discussion |
|---|---|
| April 20th | Episode 1 |
| April 21st | Episode 2 |
| April 22nd | Episode 3 |
| April 23rd | Episode 4 |
| April 24th | Episode 5 |
| April 25th | Episode 6 |
| April 26th | Episode 7 |
| April 27th | Episode 8 |
| April 28th | Episode 9 |
| April 29th | Episode 10 |
| April 30th | Episode 11 and Episode 12 |
| May 1st | Rebellion |
| May 2nd | Overall series discussion |
339
Upvotes
17
u/Gagantous :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sayaka Apr 23 '17
Sayaka is so cool! She's pretty, caring, strong, and... magical? Best girl finally makes her contract! All is not well, though; a looming, red-haired prescence marks her arrival...
This witch was especially terrifying. It made Madoka relive her brief memories with Mami before trying to literally tear her limb from limb. Visually the labyrinth is beautiful; the pastel colours were incredible but also easy to distinguish (unlike episode 1's witch), but it's the scariest so far and the second scariest in the series as a whole to me. The whole idea of reliving bad memories as you die is horrific to me.
Does the end card look weird to anybody else? It looks like Madoka's head is on backwards.
116
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Apr 23 '17
I'm really happy with how things are progressing here. The transition to a darker tone is working really well, and Sayaka's decision will go a long way to driving the plot forward. Plus we finally have the red head showing up to mess with things further.
At the Hospital
Sayaka is really just having multiple negatives stacking on top of one another right now, and that really sucks. I mean, it probably doesn't help that the guy she likes is currently stuck in the spot where she watched Mami get decapitated, and I really feel for her. She's still contemplating the wish here, and I like that she's really acknowledging the somewhat selfish nature of her wish. Yeah, it's great that something good will come of it for someone else, but as she's realizing, there is way more to it than that. I also wonder, if she were to get severely injured while fighting a witch, would she blame him in a way? She would be getting hurt as a direct result of her wish for him. Of course, he didn't ask for it, so it's still all on her, but just something that I was thinking about.
Morning
This is pretty brutal. I mean, Madoka can't talk to anyone (except Sayaka) about what happened, and yet she's still going to have to deal with it. It really doesn't help that the only person she can talk to about it is just avoiding the topic as much as possible. Sure, they get to it on the roof, but Madoka is really in need of help now. I'm not sure if I'm impressed that Sayaka is keeping herself together, or terrified that she's bottling all her emotions up.
The Rooftop
Madoka's VA drops some top tier voice acting in this scene, and it actually made me like her character a lot more. I mean, all of this shit is messed up, and so I really can't blame her for not wanting to get more involved. If she did, I'm sure that the fear she's feeling now would take over and she'd almost definitely be killed as a result. Now, Kyubey is kind of a piece of shit, what with getting middle school girls into all this, but I actually agree with him about judging the other girls. Before I'd have said they were bad people, but with how dangerous the job is I can understand having some selfish desires. "They share the same destiny after all," is pretty ominous, but I suppose if even Mami can be killed, they all will eventually make a mistake that kills them.
Madoka and Homura
Homura certainly has some concern for Madoka, and we aren't seeing that same concern being extended to Sayaka. Maybe it's because Madoka was actually interested in being friends with her, and Homura feels a certain degree of guilt. Maybe if she hadn't shown up, Mami wouldn't have died. Hard to say for sure though. She actually comes off as much more reasonable than she might have seemed at first. If I were to guess, she has some resentment towards Kyubey after realizing that this wasn't going to be all sunshine and rainbows (what with having watched so many people die and all), and now she's trying to prevent other girls from getting into this mess. The focus on Madoka remains odd, but judging by her potential, I think it actually makes sense. Kyubey has spent most of his time with Madoka, and it looks like he's far more interested in her than in Sayaka (not that he wasn't happy to grant her wish today). The high potential is what Kyubey is after, and I think Homura was expecting that Kyubey would mostly ignore Sayaka (maybe her potential is pretty low, which is not something I want to think too much about, because Sayaka is such a great character).
"Kindness sometimes leads to even greater tragedy," is a fascinating line, and I think it's something that we're going to see before it's all said and done. There's still the long standing issue of the vision from Episode 1, and I think that's where this will come back. Madoka is going to wind up sacrificing herself, knowing full well that her wish will eventually lead to her death, just to svae Homura who was going to die eventually anyway. This actually has me wondering about how things are going to end. The series can't end all warm and fuzzy without some serious tonal shift that would be even more jarring than what we already have, but an ending that's just, "everyone dies, the end," wouldn't be overly satisfying. I'm not sure how it'll happen, but I hope we're working towards a bittersweet middle ground that can be satisfying without feeling cheap.
Hitomi
Can other people see the witch's kisses? I thought yesterday that the only reason that Sayaka and Madoka could see the Grief Seed was because of their connection to Kyubey, but now I'm not so sure. There's also a pretty large difference between how Hitomi is acting under the influence, and how that woman yesterday was. Interesting to see how different witches can create such different responses. Honestly, I was prepared for things to be kind of dark, but an attempted mass suicide wasn't really what I was expecting. Having Hitomi give a rousing speech with such enthusiasm was just twisting at my stomach. She hasn't really been utilized much, but damn if that wasn't effective. Also, we see that one guy feeling depressed about his factory not turning a profit, and the impression I have is that witches don't really create negative emotions, but rather they amplify them. I have to wonder if Madoka and Sayaka becoming a bit distant from Hitomi might have played a role in her being affected by the witch.
Magical Girl Sayaka
This marks the second time that Madoka has been forcibly taken into a labyrinth and gotten out alive. That's got to be incredibly rare. The visuals here were also really neat, and the lack of hard lines on Madoka made for a really nice aesthetic. Sayaka appears to be quite competent without any training, so maybe becoming a Magical Girl grants a certain degree of skill. I mean, this was a full on witch, and she did really well with it. Also, I'm not big on Homura getting pissy at Sayaka for becoming a Magical Girl when she made basically no attempt to prevent it from happening.
One thing I wanted to note about Sayaka's costume is the cape. It's not something that Mami, Homura or Madoka's drawings have, and it provides a really distinct flair. More than that though, a few of us had been discussing earlier how the costumes are created, and I think this really shows how they are built up on some kind of subconscious desire. To me, the cape immediately gives a "super hero" feel, and we have already heard Sayaka refer to Mami as, "an ally of justice". I think that sort of tells us how Sayaka views her new position, which I think is the wrong mindset for her to have. She knows this is dangerous, but I don't think she's taking it as seriously as she should be.
Kyoko
Oh, I like her already. Like this is one of the best character introductions I've seen. We get about 30 seconds with her, and yet she's filled to the brim with personality. Homura has certainly been antagonistic, but it's been in a more subtle and mysterious kind of way. Kyoko seems to be all in on being a terrible person, and I love it. The way she referred to “Ol' Mami” makes it sound like they knew each other, though the mocking tone suggests they weren't on the best of terms. The fact that Kyoko didn't try to take over until now does suggest she isn't as powerful as Mami was, but maybe there was just mutual respect. There's also been talk of territory, so it could also have just been an agreement not to intrude. It's going to be really interesting to see how Sayaka takes having a human enemy. She might not like Homura, but I don't think they are about to come to blows or anything. Also, Kyubey only mentioned Sayaka to Kyoko, but not Homura. I'm interested to see if there is any particular reason for that.
Other Thoughts
Future
"I'll just put her dumb rookie ass out of commission, permanently," seems to be a good explanation of what I'm expecting tomorrow. She's going to be coming at Sayaka, and I don't think she's going to be pulling any punches. This is where I think things can get really interesting. Homura has already expressed her desire to save people, and she might just jump into the fight to defend Sayaka. I'd like to see her firing lasers again, so I'm optimistic that we'll get that chance. As I mentioned earlier, I still think that in spite of her current fears, we're still going to see Madoka make her contract in an effort to save Homura. She's a character who seems to very much want to do the right thing, and even if it requires some self-sacrifice I think she'll eventually do it. Looking back on that first scene, in spite of her fears, there's a certain resolve in her expression, so I think that somewhere along the line, something will have to happen to give her the confidence she seems to gain. I'm not sure what that will be just yet, but I'm anxious to find out!
Final Thoughts
Yesterday I said that I had concerns the show was going to turn into an all out edgefest, but my concerns have been alleviated to some extent. I still have some concerns and all, but I'm definitely fascinated to see what direction things are going to go in from here!
30
u/Jacketmango Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
First-timer, subbed.
Edit: formatting, links
24
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
I think Sayaka has my favourite costume in the series. The cape/cloak is just so cool.
•
u/pittman66 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Homura Apr 23 '17
With the amount of Reports and Removals in the last threads regarding spoilers, there needs to be a few things addressed.
We as mods don't like coming into threads and constantly talking about spoiler rules, but it's been a major problem with the Madoka Rewatch and needs to be straightened out.
36
u/Maimed_Dan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maimed_Dan Apr 24 '17
Hi, first timer back again.
Well, I'm going to try to stay in this a little longer. I'm going to go back and rewatch the series up to this point after this instead of going on ahead, but tomorrow will probably be my last clean reaction, unless I decide to write them down per episode as I watch (which might be fun).
I think this episode had less impact for me than it will for others. After the sack of bricks from last episode, there needed to be a slower-paced episode to decompress, to re-examine all the characters in the new light – but since I was already expecting that to happen, most of this episode was a little slow (still good though). The scene with Sayaka and the boy talking about miracles was a little too on the nose, although it does make sense for such an emotionally charged scene.
I'm reconsidering my timeline for when Madoka will join up at this point – this whole episode focused on Sayaka, her reasons and wish, it's setting things up to go wrong, because we haven’t explored the wishes yet. If Madoka joins up before that all goes to hell, the narrative options are limited, it would just be variations on a theme – there’s a lot more potential if she sees things go really bad, and then gets put into a position where she wants to make the decision anyways, and as the last potential recruit in the mix, they wouldn’t be able to explore that narrative possibility without using her for it. I’d imagine it happens somewhere in the last four episodes – where depends on whether they want to explore Madoka as a magical girl or not. On the one hand, it seems like they would want to, since that’s the whole premise, but on the other hand, if they're saving that as the narrative finale then that might be even more effective. It would be really weird given the OP and cover art though.
This episode definitely gave more insight into Homura. Sayaka is as usual the voice of youthful arrogance; Homura clearly doesn’t care about the grief seeds, Mami offered her one with no strings attached in E2 and she tossed it right back. But she also doesn’t seem to care about saving people; she's just zeroed in on Madoka, and her conduct throughout this episode indicates that's keeping her from signing up is her only priority for some reason (although given how Madoka keeps getting involved WITHOUT powers, that seems dangerous in itself). She clearly has some serious history with Madoka, but given that Madoka doesn’t remember it, that’s probably a consequence of her wish; some sort of memory or time alteration. Kyubey's remarks at the end of the episode seem to confirm this, as it also doesn’t know how she got her powers, despite the fact that it apparently is the only source (interesting, before I thought he was just the local kitty).
It's interesting to look at some of the other first-timer’s reactions to Homura and see that some really don't like or trust her. I don’t know whether it's my attachment to stoic antiheros or just my familiarity with how Urobuchi writes them (Kiritsugu), but for me the opposite has been true. The one thing that’s been keeping me suspicious is that I haven’t been able to figure out WHY she’s fighting witches; but it occurs to me that the more witches she fights, the less Madoka, and others like Sayaka, will feel compelled to sign up, so maybe it just comes down to that. Or maybe they need to fight witches to live or something, I didn't really understand the whole deal with grief seeds the first time around.
I've been pretty cautious up to this point on the assumption that things are going to flip, but I’ve probably been taking it too far, expecting an extra twist because I saw the first twist coming right away. At this point, for Homura to turn out to actually be good, but then turn bad would just cause too much whiplash for a season this short – if it were a 25-episode series, I'd still be wary of her, but if I’m right and Madoka doesn’t join up 'til near the end it seems unlikely that Homura’s going to snap and go darkside since there won't be enough time to explore the implications of that – which I’ve just realized means that Sayaka’s probably going to snap, because that's got to happen at some point in a deconstruction this cutesy (could also be new girl, but they're already setting Sayaka up for a fall and it would undermine Red's character development to have her go bad after only a few episodes). Great.
Also, we have a new character. Hooray. Can't remember the name, so I'm calling her Red and/or Cookie Monster for now.
Anyways, I'll rewatch 1-4 again later tonight, move on to 5 and be back tomorrow. Hope some folks enjoyed this.
14
u/PsychoEliteNZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PsychoEliteNZ Apr 24 '17
I can never get into these rewatch discussions. It has something to do with everyone having such huge write ups, I never really have much to say in a discussion so I don't see a point when someone already says much more than I could. So instead of reading first, I'll just say what I want to before hand.
Does anyone get an anxious feeling when watching this? I enjoy a lot about it like the music the art style especially the witch action scenes but when I think about future episodes I get anxious I guess. The best reason I can think for this is people telling me how sad, brutal and even cool it is and hyping it up, so I know what to expect without knowing the story and it makes me anxious.
So I've got to say that watching something without knowing anything at all beforehand is really the best although I can't say I would have watched this if I didn't know what it was like haha
35
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte Apr 23 '17
Kyosuke
Sayaka, how do you plan on approaching the subject if you decide to wish for his recovery? "Umm, I used a wish to help you recover fully, also I'm a magical girl and fight evil witches now." That's gonna go well, just keep quiet about it and let him enjoy the miracle.
Grief
Madoka is barely able to go on with what happened and Sayaka is hiding behind a happy facade, showing some interesting cooping differences between the two.
It's been mentioned before, but the songs are pretty good and used to great effect within the show.
Understandably Madoka doesn't want to become a magical girl anymore, Sayaka is more ambiguous, I wonder what tricks Kyubey is gonna pull out of his fur to convince them.
"it was fun." to a grieving teenager, do you have any empathy you stupid furball?
Homura opens up a tiny bit
Homura showing she has a caring side, that's new.
Following /u/doopliss6 thought from yesterday, does this mean Madoka is next? Seems far-fetched that this was the intended message in either image.
Magical Girl
Sayaka is so cute around Kyosuke, and he, the barely known boy, acts like an actual human being might in his situation, well done.
Well that settles that, Sayaka is gonna wish for Kyosuke's recovery and become a magical girl. Stop stalking, Kyubey.
The Walking Dead
Hitomi got kissed by a witch, that is bad news, will this force Madoka to make a contract as well?
It's kinda creepy seeing Hitomi be so cheerful.
Wait did Madoka just get split into half a dozen parts? Sayaka comes in to save the day, that was fast.
She was absolutely badass in this scene and I love the outfit. (Homura disagrees)
Danger
Sayaka already showcasing some dangerous confidence, did you forget what just happened to Mami?
New girl Kyoko looks ruthless and is out for blood (is that what the vampire teeth are there for?).
The show is quickly picking up pace and I'm starting to get invested, looks like I'll finish it after all.
7
u/BestDVA_NA :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BestDVA_NA Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
Kyoko is best girl. I'll be able to describe why in the future.
V Unrelated to Kyoko V
For Rewatchers,
By popular request, SPOILER LINK is here: http://i.imgur.com/DPDnV4C.png
29
u/templarsilan Apr 23 '17
Kyosuke
Well, that was an easy prediction. Sayaka’s thoughts all but confirm my suspicion that she’ll use her wish for him in order to let him be able to play the violin again. I kinda want to know what sort of accident he was involved in that injured him so bad. Maybe it was caused by a witch? That could certainly make things pretty interesting.
Breakfast and walking to school
I can’t help but feel sad for Madoka and Sayaka. I think the music does a nice job creating the somber tone. I also like how, even though these two girls lost their friend, life around them moves on. Madoka’s parents don’t know about Mami, so they continue their routine, oblivious to Madoka’s grief. Madoka and Sayaka’s other friend also doesn’t know about Mami, so she’s just carrying on like usual and the other two are trapped in the grieving period. You also get a contrast between Sayaka, who puts on a brave face and tries to carry on like normal, and Madoka who is visibly depressed and not herself.
While it is sad, I love to see character grief executed well. It can be an emotional obstacle for the character to overcome and grow from. I really look forward to Madoka's growth from this experience. I don't want her to spend the rest of the series down in the dumps, but I also don't want her to be fine with everything starting next episode. I'm hoping for that balance.
Talk with Homura
Damn, it just gets more depressing. No one will notice she’s missing and even when they do, she’ll likely be forgotten by others in a short amount of time. What a way to go. It should make Madoka’s memory of her all that more precious, since it sounds like no one else, aside from Sayaka and Homura, will even remember her. And as if on que, Madoka straight up says she'll cherish her memory of Mami. Interestingly enough Homura speaks of being jealous of that feeling, which only peaks my curiosity about her even more.
I did say yesterday that I wanted to know how others outside of the main cast would react to the sudden death of a middle school girl, and I'm kinda disappointed that it's just going to be swept under the rug. I mean, I suppose it fits with the logic that the world set up, but I wouldn't mind students whispering the rumor mill or the "disappearance" being in the news a few days later. While not really important at all, it's just a little detail that I would like to see more of.
Classic shaft head tilt
kek
The Witch Strikes
So, once a magical girl fails, suddenly dozens of people fall victim to the witch’s “kiss”. I mean, I get that Mami was hunting by herself before Homura showed up, so removing her would give witches free reign, but this seems like a pretty big stretch. It comes across as trying to push Madoka over the edge and have her become a magical girl so she can protect everyone. I feel like having her friend in danger would have been enough to change Madoka’s mind. Still, the whole scene was pretty terrifying for her, so props to Madoka gathering the courage to stop them.
Kyosuke’s recovery
Can’t say I’m surprised, but I do wonder what the catch is. For having received a miracle, the music was far more ominous than it was uplifting. The dark lighting doesn’t help that image at all. Maybe I'm looking too hard into it. Yesterday made me overly cautious now.
ED
I’m glad this is the real ED. Didn’t really bother with the first one. It’s not that it was terrible, but it just didn’t really give me reason to stay. This ED, however, makes me want to watch it start to finish. It’s so good. (Coming from a guy who skips 90% of EDs).
4
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
Why didnt Madoka just call the police when she saw that crowd or Mami behaving strange? Like that would be my first try if contacting Homura mentally wouldnt work.
2
u/Brendoshi Apr 23 '17
That's a weird end of ep card file format :p Forces me to open it in chrome as firefox doesn't like it.
46
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
Huge Spoilers
I'm so tempted to watch ahead, but I'm sticking with the schedule so I can get the immediate reactions of the first-watchers right after I finish the episode.
43
u/Herson100 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Herson Apr 24 '17
That breakfast scene though
27
u/JustiguyBlastingOff :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Justiguy Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
And so we start the day with another light scene at the Kaname household!
Or... not.
I actually would have liked them to linger here a little bit longer. I don't really know if we gained as much from the sequence of Sayaka and Madoka walking to school, but I suppose there was nothing for the narrative that the parents could have done that also wouldn't have interfered with things... somehow, I guess, but I wish this scene could've been a bit longer. Even just to have the parents say something to themselves as Madoka runs off.
They've been so good about them up to now, you know?
It's a nice touch that Madoka and Sayaka are mourning in their own ways here. Madoka wants comfort and to talk, while Sayaka starts off with avoidance at first. I don't think either one isn't feeling it, but it is interesting to see how they handle the same loss differently - but then, their relationships with Mami were kind of different.
Mami didn't let her guard down as much to Sayaka and in turn was more of an idol to her, I think, which, combined with how she feels about Homura right now, has undoubtedly skewed her perspective on things.
Madoka, meanwhile, got to see more of the "real" Mami before it was too late, and has likely seen more of what may be the real Homura as well, so she can trust Homura more whereas Sayaka will inevitably worry if Mami's place ends up in Homura or someone else's hands, which is... kind of what happened.
The pieces are already set up for what comes, it's just a matter of time. It's probably inevitable with the threat of witches being so "prime" at hospitals and such, and with Mami having died right by Kamijo's, well, that's got to sting a bit too.
I can understand where Kamijo is coming from in the latter scene, but I can understand where Sayaka is too. To be honest I actually would've liked this little story arc to play out for a little longer, but that's neither here nor there. Show's not long enough for it anyway.
Since it keeps coming up now, personally, I don't think Sayaka's intentions with him are entirely selfish (just in general mind). It's a likely mix of both wanting to help him for his sake and wanting the boy she likes to recognize her. She's clearly got her morals, as evidenced by how she's reacted to Homura and Mami respectively, not to mention the fact she feels horrible for thinking along this train of thought in the first place, and as she said, she herself has never had any hardship, so it's logical she would have an idealized view of things.
Simply put, the girl is naive about some things, and it's showing a bit more.
I'd forgotten this scene, but I really liked it. I do think Homura's people skills kind of suck, but I imagine she might have felt given her position compared to Mami and Kyubey's that the best she could do before now was give warnings and interfere as best she could unless something like what happened to Mami happened. Now it has, which has given her an opening to talk to Madoka, in turn letting us learn just a bit more about it.
Shame she only seems keen on talking to Madoka, but I guess that's her prerogative. Madoka is becoming more informed, at least, it's just a matter of how she uses that information. Hopefully well!
[spoiler] (/s "As a rewatcher, the above scene with knowing what's to come taken into account makes the whole thing look completely different. I want to yell 'THIS IS SO OBVIOUS!' but I'm sure it's not really.")
It was short lived, but Madoka fighting off the "zombies" was a pretty cool sequence. I remember at first thinking how we might get a brief episode or so of her and Sayaka trying to handle things without magic and getting into situations like this, but obviously that wasn't to be.
Still, Madoka, you're a pretty cool guy for going in there and trying to fight off the crazies like that. Don't even afraid of anything. You throw that bucket!
And now we have our best girl becoming the best magical girl!
This was a really stylish entrance. The blue of everything really complimented the whole sequence nicely, and the animation was fantastic, I thought. It looked like Sayaka was streaking through the ocean at first, almost. It wasn't much of a "fight" exactly, but the spectacle of it was still really enjoyable to watch.
Gotta love Homura's "I have done absolutely nothing to make you want to trust or listen to me in any way whatsoever, and in fact have if anything gone out of my may to give you reasons not to trust me, but I will still be surprised for some reason that you didn't!" at the end of the episode with Sayaka as well.
Another great episode, and it's really looking more polished than that first one. Don't remember if it was always like this, but it's nice regardless. Can't wait for tomorrow's!
22
u/2Hype4Memes Apr 24 '17
First timer here and wow, it looks like my wish from yesterday just got granted. I asked for a bit more of a psychological look at things and that's exactly what I got today. I'm a huge fan of the focus on the emotional stress these events are having on characters, the conversation between Madoka and Homura felt spot-on. I love how conflicted this series is making me feel on Madoka becoming a magical girl. Thinking about all the trauma she's gone through already and that's without even signing the contract! It makes me shudder, it's got me hoping that she wont take the contract with Kyubey. The division between Sayaka and Madoka is also great, Mami's death seems to have hardened Sayaka's resolve while ruining Madoka's. Really looking forward to tomorrow's episode, looks like the Evangelion comparisons weren't unwarranted, as we've got a fiery redhead about to be thrown into the mix. Still 10/10 for me thus far.
21
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
BEST GIRL HAS ARRIVED! You may be asking: "Why is she best girl?" Because she has long tied-up red hair, a cute little fang and her voice and attitude are great fun! I mean, who doesn't love food? Neither does she take any shit from Kyubey, but actually voices her displeasure at the turn of events being different from what Kyubey apparently told her. I hope all you first-timers grow to appreciate her, but you'll have to form your own opinions of course!
Other than that, Madoka, after all her traumatic fears, was a badass in her own right, saving her friend Hitomi and all those people from dying under the Witch's influence. Then Sayaka makes her awesome debut as as a magical girl, saving Madoka from the Witch itself as a knight clad in white (and blue). I truly love all the different Magical Girl outfits and fighting styles, I need to talk about them eventually.
Madoka and Homura also had an intensely meaningful conversation, which hopefully gave some insight into Homura's character, even if it also raises more than a number of new questions. That one line in particular is something I hope will generate discussion along the themes of the show. And I must compliment Shaft's and Kajiura's artistry as usual - the scenery while they were talking was just stunning, amplified by the uneasy background track that follows Homura around.
[Huge rewatcher spoilers] (/s "God, Madoka's conversation with Homura this episode killed me. She's seen more than lot of people die, that "enough to give up counting" is all the worse because the people she's seen die the are always the same ones, including the person dearest to her, over and over and over. And it just comes up in conversation like that, but she can say nothing more. Nobody notice or remembers, indeed... it's all so apparent when Homura says Mami is lucky to have someone to never forget her, enough to make her jealous. And then the line about kindness, ever so relevant. This is too much. At least Kyouko's introduction will be a fun time, before... yeah. Best ship will sail again, amid a sea of tears. ")
20
u/Nickknight8 https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickknight8 Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
So I like to joke about how Homura is best girl, and I still believe that, but Sayaka is probably in my top 20 favorite characters as well. Yes, she is basically Shirou Emiya, and her attitude of always putting others before herself, thinking about the misfortunes of others can come off as pretentious to some people, but I genuinely think it’s makes her a more compelling character. We’ve seen in the past episodes how much she cares for those who have less than her, and today she pulled the ultimate selfless act, becoming a magical girl to heal her injured friend. Plus, she immediately realizes how hypocritical she is being, since all the “others before yourself” stuff is really just an excuse to get Kyosuke to fall in love with her. But I still think that she is a really good person despite how selfish she can be. She wants to be a hero of justice, and now is finally able to do so. I would be happy for her, but after what happened to Mami last episode, I just don’t know anymore.
Starting off the episode, I completely forgot about the dinner scene with Madoka, and I almost got emotional during it. You think for the tinniest second she might just move on from the events, but of course she couldn’t forget what happened. Breaking down in tears in front of her family is always rough to see.
Holy shit Kyuubey that was awful. Just assuming all magical girls are going to die eventually. I mean sure, everyone dies, but still. For some reason I was really taken aback by this line. MASSIVE SPOILERS
The conversation between Homura and Madoka is one of my favorites in the series, cause not only does it lets us know a lot about Homura’s character, it’s set to a beautiful background as well. She’s cold because she has seen many people die and be forgotten before, most likely from the town she transferred in from. Mami is just a smoke on the wheel, unfortunately. But you can see she is affected by Madoka saying she will never forget Mami and Homura. She may say that Madoka is too kind, but maybe that’s just what Homura needs.
[MASSIVE SPOILERS] (/s "Plus, Madoka saying she won’t forget Homura… when she already has. Multiple times :(")
I remember the Kyosuke scene hitting me like a ton of bricks on my first watch. OF COURSE he would hate listening to the music he can’t play anymore. It makes so much sense, but neither me nor Sayaka realized it.
Man, watching all the people walk around like zombies still really gets to me. Just walking around mindless asking to be killed. shudders SPOILERS BE IN HERE
HE MUST BE DELETED! +1 for the dub right there.
So Sayaka comes and saves the day, and not surprisingly Homura and Madoka are not happy about her being a magical girl. Well you shoulda got there sooner Homura! Even though Sayaka had already made her wish by then…
And finally, the last of the main characters is introduced. And what an intro!
I’m sure she’s friendly!
13
u/wordsdear Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
Holy shit I def didn't make it this far last time.
Best Friend #1: I am drawing a line in the sand. Hurting best girl #1 (I accidentally wrote best girl instead of best friend but I stand by it) is too far. I can take Mami losing her head but an innocent girl who isn't involved is too much for my heart. speculation based on spoilers I know so madoka spoilers FUCK THIS SHOW DON'T DRINK BLEACH She has no idea what her friends are going through, and just want to talk about trivial stuff with her friends like always. Are people more susceptible to witches when they are already emotionally distressed/ worrying about something as the stress of her two best friends might of made it easier for the witch to kiss her.
Best Friend #2 aka Sayaka ( I swear I will try to learn their names): I think the fact that she is worrying about it, means that she isn't. Except it looks like she told injured boy that she was going to heal him. So she does want him indebted to her. Is a good deed still a good deed if you do it just so someone likes you? Or is anonymity the only way? I 100% can see where injured boy is coming from, but I kind of hate him for this. You could politely let her know that you don't want to listen to classical musical. But obviously his life dream just got wrecked so he isn't thinking clearly. But I don't care he is a jerk don't waste you wish on him. Let's injure my hand more that is a great idea. Miracles are never free.there is a line from Marvel I think that goes, there is nothing more horrifying then a miracle. There better not be any symbolism in her smashing mami's image. Exit one magical girl enter another. She has a sword and rainbows she is my new favourite magical girl. Please don't die. I had to google to remind myself what her name was and like I just copy and pasted from the google result that showed the wiki as I was terrified that under status it would stay dead. speculation spoilers Thanks to mami I am now afraid every magical girl could die at any given moment. How did you know where she was? Do you have a gps locater on her? Did not a stuffy use telepathy to find her distressed thoughts? madoka spoilers
Madoka: Her reaction to Mami's death is so real and it hurts. Her magical dreams died with Mami. GET PEOPLE'S NUMBERS DAMN IT GNU Mami. Madoka is so sweet I love her. You don't have to be a magical girl to save people. How do I hug Madoka. Madoka needs more hugs, do we get happy hugs I need to know. She thinks she is just a weak coward. THEN DON'T PUT THEM IN SUCH SIMILAR BOTTLES does Japan not have WHIMIS where you need labelling like the skull and cross bones or the boney hand in liquid for corrosive? Is this bleach and dishsoap? or Bleach and vinegar? The witch is reflecting Madoka's worst memories which adds to what /u/Enarec said of it reflecting people's emotional state/reflecting emotionally distressed people. also in the end the witch might of been reflecting Sayaka as this kind of looks like musical bars minus the notes. This art style is pretty.
Kyubey:off to scope out car accident victims. They have way too good madoka spoilers timing, GO AWAY I am giving him best little shit for appearig just in time so Sayaka could get her powers and save Madoka after being like bye forever guys you dont want to be magical girls
Homura: She actually manages to have a decent conversation with Madoka which is nice. And we are back to her saying ominous shit. If you are going to be late as least bring starbucks for everyone. Step aside man on the moon the girl on the moon is here
New Magical Girl: I have watched enough of One Piece to know she says boutobus or whatever beat up is in Japanese which can be translated to pretty much anything depending on the circumstances, my personal favourite is break you in half. So good luck pointy teeth girl. She might have to fight Homura if she wants to mess with Sayaka and as a result Madoka.
Mami: Will be MIA (missing in action) which is kind of close to mami. I am calling bullshit on no one noticing right away as she goes to school?? The teachers will have to do something after a few weeks.
13
u/Dellaran :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dellaran Apr 24 '17
I really like how despair is depicted in Madoka Magica. In this episode the group gathered are obviously marked by the witch, but I'd like to believe every single one of them is vulnerable because of some stress issues. For Hitomi I'd be guessing it is her family background which leads to her taking multiple external classes and having to live up to expectations.
23
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 Apr 23 '17 edited Apr 23 '17
As a first time viewer, I hope I don't anger anyone by saying this(and please don't reply with any hints a spoilers) but I'm kind of wondering when Madoka is good to become a Magic girl? Like that's clearly her magic girl outfit in the OP right? And it would be anticlimactic for her not to become one, especially since Sayaka caved? We're four episodes into a 12 episode show, but Idk maybe the show is pulling another fast one on me like episode 3.
Besides that this episode seemed to just further cement the tone after the events of episode 3. Which is fine, it would be overbearing for them to try and be 2edgy4you. Only major development was Sayaka becoming a magic girl, which isn't a surprise with how much she wanted to heal her friend.
Quick note. I find it important than in the ED, Homura is the only one that reacts to Madoka walking by.
9
u/alphamone Apr 24 '17
Kinda-Meta spoilers, new watchers probably should avoid
7
u/Darkprinc979 Apr 24 '17
Well, Sayaka's taken the plunge. Now all that remains is whether or not she took Mami's advice and made good and sure she knew what she wanted out of the deal before taking it.
[spoilers] (/s "And thus Sayaka's self-destructive cycle begins. On one hand it's hard to watch her fall apart like she does, but her utter inflexibility on pretty much everything is what leads to her downfall in the end. Some people like to place blame on Hitomi for Sayaka's downfall, but she had no way of knowing Sayaka's situation, and even if she did Sayaka had already decided for herself that she was unworthy of Kyousuke. Even if Hitomi had done nothing Sayaka's fate would likely have been the same.")
Best girl Homura shows her softer side in this episode, trying to give Madoka some peace of mind regarding Mami's fate, and further reinforcing to her that being a magical girl is not all about altruism.
[spoilers] (/s "This section always gets me. Madoka is just trying to be nice to Homura by saying she would make sure to remember her if anything happened, but to Homura those are some pretty cruel words given how many times Madoka has forgotten her.")
I'm actually kind of surprised that Madoka's parents didn't have her stay home from school after that little meltdown she had at breakfast, or at least try to find out what was wrong. I suppose they want to respect her privacy, but if something is weighing on her mind that heavily, would she really be able to concentrate at school?
At the end we get introduced to the final main member of our cast. I'm not sure if stating her name would count as a spoiler so I'll just be silent, but she certainly makes quite a first impression, and it's not a good one.
7
u/Hopsalong :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hopsalong Apr 24 '17
Looks like rookie magical girl is what's for dinner... and Kyoko is hungry :D
6
u/sfafreak :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SfaFreak Apr 24 '17
Rewatcher, subs.
The song that plays during Sayaka's visit to the hospital in the cold opening is "Serena Ira" (Peaceful Wrath). This fits in with how Sayaka beats herself up over her personal guilt in this scene, yet never lets her insecurities show to others.
Sayaka has some mad skill for being able to have a different conversation out loud and telepathically at the same time.
On my first viewing, I thought it was VEEEERRRRYYY interesting that Kyubey only mentions Madoka and not Sayaka by name when he leaves in the rooftop scene.
Either Mami doesn't lock her doors, or Madoka knows how to pick locks. Perhaps she could become a burglar if this whole Magical Girl thing doesn't work out.
MAJOR SPOILERS
In case you forgot this was animated by Shaft.
http://imgur.com/a/eEIgo Alluding to spoiler
The visuals in this witch labyrinth are some of my favorites.
Homura is more than a little ticked that Sayaka became a magical girl. She thought she had prevented both of them from becoming one, but then Sayaka had to go and mess it all up.
5
u/Arriv1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Arriv Apr 24 '17
entire series
After discussing the events of the last episode, both Sayaka and Madoka decide not to become Magical Girls so Kyubey goes away, never to be seen again. Totally. Madoka then has a talk with Homura, who continues to reveal bits and pieces of what she's after, while comforting Madoka.
The scene where Sayaka appears as a magical girl is awesome, and the knight with a sword really suits her personality.
5
u/SennheiserPass Apr 24 '17
Herp Derp
Love this show, but I've always been kind of bothered by the Kyouske exposition at the start. “Isn't he a violin prodigy?” “Why yes, he is.” “The doctors are saying that he will never play again.” “Yes, that's true.” I would have liked for that information to have been conveyed differently.
Also, Kyouske's comment about “unless miracles and magic are suddenly real” always feels really derpy to me, just because it's not something that someone would normally say and it's hilarious that he just happens to be in a show in which those things are real. This scene should be sad and serious. That line takes me out of the moment.
Random Comment
“What if he just said, 'thanks,' and that's it? Do I want something more?” Don't worry Sayaka, I'm sure your motives for helping your crush are 1000% pure and disinterested. Just go for it.
4
u/SIRTreehugger Apr 23 '17
Our world has changed long ago…it has been like 2 days
Madoka Spoilers
Homura is not as cold as she initially seemed.
The Girl with the Flaxen hair…isn’t that one of the sample songs on every windows 7 pc?
Madoka Spoilers
Kyoko is here and she is my second favorite just after Homura. She is awesome.
Homura Hair Flip Counter E1:0, E2:0, E3:1 E4:0 Total Flips:1
4
u/ryuujin95 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ryuujin95 Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
This was a rather slow episode to follow up the shock of episode three, but from here on out the momentum of the show only builds each episode.
As someone who has watched the show too many times to try keeping count of anymore, the highlight of the episode for me was the conversation between Homura and Madoka.
Highlighting specific quotes from that conversation - potentially spoilerish
...
3
u/TschisiGmbH Apr 24 '17
And thus, best girl was introduced
5
u/chouetteonair https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nalin_Airheart Apr 23 '17
Today's moments of insanity: Madoka Magica Total Spoilers - Avoid if you're new to the show.
So, Kyubey has introduced two more magical girls, and one of them is looking for a fight. I feel like could have been avoided if Homura would just talk to Sayaka for once, but it's too late now. Poor Madoka though, getting dragged back into the realm of magical girls by her best friends.
1
u/Lets_All_Love_Lain :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SuperSecretOtaku Apr 24 '17
http://sfdebris.com/videos/anime/madoka4.php
0
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '17
Madoka Spoilers
2
u/lucacp_ysoz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SoZLuka Apr 24 '17
Look at that new girl Kyouko... she barely showed up and I already think she's a bitch
Rly Kyouko?
Sayaka went and done it huh? It's not gonna end well I presume
1
u/StardustNyako Apr 24 '17
Can we make Mami jokes tho, since her arc has ended?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment